Professional Documents
Culture Documents
13
I see such sentences all the time and I'd like to learn more about their
grammatical structure (e.g. how they are described in grammatical terms), their
meaning and how to use them in different contexts.
Community♦
1
asked Nov 5 '11 at 16:38
Tarik
2,2971818 gold badges4343 silver badges5050 bronze badges
That sounds like a word for word translation of a foreign expression, such as the Italian "essere
d'aiuto", rather than something a native would say (e.g., "if I can help you") – badp Nov 5 '11 at 17:00
3
You might find iit simpler if you parse of help as the syntactic unit - which could be replaced by helpful,
useful, etc. - rather than seizing on the fact that of help can in principle be completely omitted (which is
grammatically quite a significant change, in that help thereby becomes a verb rather than a
noun). – FumbleFingers Nov 5 '11 at 17:06
2
My impression is that "be of" can only go with a limited number of nouns. Googling, I find "be of use", "be
of service", "be of aid", "be of help", "be of benefit", "be of interest", "be of age", "be of influence", "be of
value", "be of account", "be of danger", "be of relevance". But to choose an arbitrary noun, I don't think
"be of security" would be used by native English speakers. – Peter Shor Nov 5 '11 at 17:07
1
I agree with Fumble and Peter. To be of help is just an idiomatic phrase, in modern
English. – Cerberus_Reinstate_Monica Nov 5 '11 at 17:59
add a comment
2 Answers
Active OldestVotes
25
As far as I can tell, there are only a limited number of nouns that work with "be
of". I would classify them as idioms. I am listing the most common ones I can
think of, where commonness is judged by Google Ngrams. I have grouped them
into sets of near synonyms. There are
be of use,
be of help,
be of aid,
be of service,
be of assistance;
these idioms mean that something/someone can be used, can help, can aid, can
serve, or can assist. There are also
be of relevance,
be of importance,
which mean that something is relevant to/important for the current subject of
discussion. Also,
be of value,
be of benefit;
these mean that something is valuable, usually with respect to the current
subject of discussion. Also
be of interest,
which means that something is interesting.
be of age,
which means that someone has reached adulthood.
If you are learning English, it should be fairly easy to figure out what one of
these constructions means. But I would suggest that if you use this construction,
you should treat it like an idiom, and memorize the specific phrase(s) you want
to use. Many nouns describing attributes, like "security" or "tact", cannot be
used with "be of". (Google books gives a few instances for "be of security"; it
seems to have been used occasionally in the 19th century, but it sounds very
strange today.)
RESOLVED
Mustafa
" The ordinary people were of Saxon blood, but the nobles were all French" When I check the similar
examples on the internet, I came to the conclusion that it has the almost same meaning as "to have".
However, when I see "Can I be of any help?", I got confused a bit. I appreciate it if you can elaborate
the meaning and usage of this phrase. Thanks in advance
0 2
Answers • 2
Jordan Stubblefield
Jun 12, 2019
Best Answer
Be of: possess intrinsically; give rise to. Basically, it IS or HAS or GENERATES whatever it is "of".
Examples: ‘this work is of great interest and value’ (it's interesting and valuable) ‘The story was of
particular interest to me as a New Zealander living in Australia.’ (it's interesting) ‘Listen and make the
other person feel that what he or she is saying is of interest to you.’ (is interesting) ‘The school has a
number of buildings listed as being of historic interest.’ (the history is interesting) ‘Warrington
council has recognised the building as being of historical interest.’ (the history is interesting) ‘Why
people read what they read and watch what they watch has recently been of interest to me.’ (it's
interesting) ‘The software will be of interest to schools and museums, as well as town planners.’ ‘The
rise in the rate of suicide amongst young people is of constant concern to our agency.’ ‘They were
getting historic items that they felt were of too great an importance to sell on and should be on
public display.’ ‘Sgt Brown added the cars involved were of little value with only one new vehicle
being seized over the past six months.’ ‘Many of the calls were of a difficult nature from distressed
families with moving reports of missing people.’
Read comments
Cole
Jun 12, 2019
Edited
The construction "be of + noun" is virtually the same as "be + adjective" except it sounds more
formal. You can think of it as to be of a certain class or of a certain type. The book is of interest = The
book is interesting. (The book is typified/classified as interesting) Can I be of any help? = Can I be
helpful? (Can I be classified as helpful) *note that this is a set phrase. Nobody would ever say "Can I
be helpful?" in this context The ordinary people were of Saxon blood = The ordinary people were
Saxon (They were classified as Saxon)
NET Bible
So for me, it is a minor matter that I am judged by you or by any human court. In fact, I do not
even judge myself.
Douay-Rheims Bible
But to me it is a very small thing to be judged by you, or by man's day; but neither do I judge my
own self.