Professional Documents
Culture Documents
How to Cite:
Perdana, Petrolis Nusa. Improvement of The Accounting
Listing Database System in Management Information System
for Accounting and Finance of State Property (SIMAK BMN)
BLU UNJ about Constelation Amortization of Integrated
Asset. Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14(2), 127-142.
https://doi.org/10.21009/wahana.014.2.2
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
128
Petrolis Nusa Perdana/ Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14 (2) 2019, 127-142
the status of the usual Work Unit to the full status Management Systems and Adequacy of Human
Public Service Agency (BLU) Decisions are Resources, Accounting Policy Draft, Manual
made as follows: Recording, Remuneration and Rates.
1. Establish Jakarta State University to Based on this, the researcher wants to conduct
become the full status of the Public Service research on how the influence of PSAK number
Agency at the Ministry of National 13 and PSAK number 19 policies regarding fixed
Education. assets and intangible assets in terms of the fair
2. Financial management flexibility is given value basis is done at the earliest every 3 years
to Jakarta State University in accordance and the longest every 5 years where the assets to
with Government Regulation Number 23 of be valued only have a useful life below the time
2005 concerning Financial Management of of the valuation. This study will be entitled
Public Service Agencies and "Constellation Amortization of Management of
Implementation Regulations. Intangible Assets in Accounting Records in
3. The Public Service Agency of the State SIMAK BMN Public Service Agency of the State
University of Jakarta is obliged to prepare University of Jakarta as a Follow-Up to BPK-RI
an accounting system no later than 2 (two) Findings".
years after the Jakarta State University is Intangible Assets
determined to be a Public Service Agency. According to paragraph 8 of PSAK
The form of the Public Service Agency's (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards)
Financial Management status (PK-BLU) which Number 19 in (Revised 2010) regarding
has been dressed by Jakarta State University intangible assets that adopt the basis of IFRS
since 2009 has consequences in the field of (International Financial Reporting Standards),
financial management, namely the obligation to intangible assets are defined as non-monetary
have an Accounting System. The Objectives of assets identified without physical form. There are
this researched is to train the financial reporting three fundamental characteristics to be able to
operators of BLU UNJ for making better ho to determine whether the expenditure of resources
access and to archives the documents of and the creation of liabilities carried out by the
Management Information System for Accounting entity in the acquisition, development,
of Finance State Property (SIMAK BMN) UNJ. maintenance or improvement of intangible
PK-BLU Accounting System includes; Financial resources can be categorized as intangible assets.
Accounting System, Fixed Asset Accounting The three fundamental characteristics are:
System and Cost Accounting System, and must 1. Identification;
be equipped with Accounting Systems and 2. Control;
procedures, Account code standards and 3. Economic future benefits.
Ratification of Account Codes by the Ministry of Examples of intangible resources are
Finance, Monitoring and Evaluation of science and technology, the design and
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
129
Petrolis Nusa Perdana/ Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14 (2) 2019, 127-142
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
130
Petrolis Nusa Perdana/ Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14 (2) 2019, 127-142
The assessment is done at the earliest every 3 intracomptable report and financial statements as
years and at the latest every 5 years. if the goods still exist and are still used by BLU
This is where information dispute occurs UNJ.
for auditors and readers of the BLU financial RESEARCH ROADMAP FLOW
statements, especially the UNJ leaders. Nature or The following is the research roadmap
the context of intangible assets that are the flow for this study:
findings of the CPC are the average assets - Inventory of BPK Findings Regarding BMN UNJ
assets such as: —> Reconciliation with the BMN UNJ
1. Intangible assets in the form of physical, Intracomptable Report —> Comparison with
such as compact disks (which contain SAK UNJ Accounting Report —> Results of
computer software), legal documentation Reconciliation and Comparison Serve —> Test
(which contains licenses or patents), or with Assertion - Audit Management Assertion,
films in the event that the intangible namely:
elements are more significant 1. Occurrence
2. Rights arising from licensing agreements 2. Completeness
for matters such as films, videotapes, stage 3. Valuation
works, manuscripts, patents, and 4. Right & Obligation
copyrights. 5. Disclosure —> Recommend to BLU UNJ
The average of these assets has a useful LITERATURE REVIEW
life of under 5 years. While the independent A. Conceptual Description
assessment by appraisal - in this case the UNJ is The Public Service Agency's own
carried out by the Office of the State Wealth accounting system according to the Minister of
Assessment and Auction - carried out every 5 Finance Regulation Number 76 / PMK.05 / 2008
years, where this is selected to reduce the costs to is a series of procedures both manual and
be paid for the valuation services. The point is computerized starting from the process of
rather than paying every 3 years, it is cheaper to collecting data, recording, summarizing to
pay every 5 years. reporting financial positions and financial
The operator SIMAK BMN BLU UNJ operations. Public Service Agency at least
also implements an internal assessment not to develops three accounting systems which are sub
conduct amortization (depreciation operation of systems of the BLU accounting system, namely:
the utility value of an intangible item or asset that
has a limited useful life so that the value will be 1) Financial Accounting System, which is
exhausted after the useful life is completed) in an accounting system that produces basic
intangible assets every year. Thus, when the financial statements for general purpose. The
intangible assets have expired and are no longer purpose of the financial statements is:
used, they are still recorded in the SIMAK BMN
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
131
Petrolis Nusa Perdana/Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14 (2) 2019, 127-142
A. Accountability; accountable for the man- stakeholders, namely those who are related and
agement of resources and the implementa- have interests with BLU. Whereas the financial
tion of policies entrusted to the BLU in statements in accordance with SAP are used for
achieving periodically set goals. the purpose of consolidating BLU financial
B. Management; help users to evaluate the im- statements with the financial statements of state
plementation of a BLU activity in the re- ministries / institutions.
porting period so as to facilitate the func- 2) Fixed Asset Accounting System, which is
tions of planning, management and control the Accounting System that produces reports on
over all revenues, expenses, assets, liabili- fixed assets for the purpose of asset manage-
ties, and equity of the BLU for the benefit ment. This system presents information about
of stakeholders. the type, quantity, value, transfer, and condition
C. Transparency; provide open and honest of fixed assets owned by BLU or not BLU but is
financial information to the public based on in the management of BLU. The development
the consideration that the community has of the Fixed Asset Accounting System is fully
the right to know openly and handed over to the relevant BLU. However,
comprehensively the accountability of the BLU can use a system established by the Minis-
BLU in managing the resources entrusted ter of Finance such as the State Property Ac-
to it and its compliance with the laws and counting System (SABMN).
regulations. 3) Cost Accounting System, which is an Ac-
The Financial Accounting System counting System that produces information
produces basic financial statements in the form of about cost of goods manufactured, unit costs per
Budget Realization Reports / Operational unit of service, and evaluation of variants. Cost
Reports, Balance Sheets, Cash Flow Reports, and Accounting Systems are useful in planning and
Notes to Financial Statements in accordance with controlling, making decisions, and calculating
Financial Accounting Standards (SAK) service rates.
established by the Indonesian accounting The BLU Financial Accounting System
profession association / specific industry component consists of integrated sub-systems to
accounting standards and Government produce financial reports and other reports that
Accounting Standards (SAP). The financial are useful for those in need. The Accounting
statements in accordance with SAK are used for System components include:
the purpose of reporting to general users of the 1) Accounting Policy; which includes the
BLU financial statements in this case choice of principles, fundamentals, con-
ventions, regulations and procedures used
by BLU in the preparation and presenta-
tion of financial statements.
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
132
Petrolis Nusa Perdana/Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14 (2) 2019, 127-142
Consideration and / or selection of account- nomic reality, and not just the aspects of its
ing policies need to be adjusted to the con- formality. If the substance of a transaction
ditions of the BLU. The most appropriate or other event is inconsistent / different
policy choice targets will describe the from the aspect of its formality, then this
BLU's financial condition appropriately. must be clearly stated in the CaLK.
Considerations for the selection of the ap- c. Materiality; Although ideally all infor-
plication of accounting policies and prepa- mation is included, BLU financial reports
ration of financial statements by manage- are only required to contain information that
ment include: meets the materiality criteria. Information is
a. Fair Presentation Financial Statements pre- seen as material if negligence to include or
sent fairly Activity Report / LRA, Balance error in recording such information can af-
Sheet, Cash Flow Statement, and Notes to fect the user's economic decisions taken on
Financial Statements. Healthy considera- the basis of financial statements.
tion factors for financial report compilers 2) Accounting Sub—System;
are needed when facing uncertainty about The accounting sub-system is part of the ac-
certain events and circumstances. Such un- counting system. For example, the sub ac-
certainty is recognized by revealing the na- counting system for cash receipts and cash
ture and level by using sound considera- disbursement sub-systems is part of the fi-
tions in the preparation of financial state- nancial accounting system.
ments. Healthy considerations contain an 3) Accounting procedures; Procedures used
element of caution when making estimates to analyze, record, classify, and summarize
in conditions of uncertainty, so that assets information to be presented in financial
or income are not stated too high and liabil- statements; also refers to the accounting cy-
ities or costs are not stated too low. The use cle (accounting cycle).
of sound judgment does not allow the for- 4) Standard Account Chart (BAS); BAS is a
mation of hidden reserves or excessive al- list of estimates of ledgers that are set and
lowances, and deliberately sets lower assets systematically compiled by the BLU leader-
or income or records 5 obligations or high- ship to facilitate planning, budgeting, budg-
er costs so that the financial statements be- et execution, and accounting and financial
come neutral and unreliable. reporting. For the purpose of BLU financial
b. Substance Over Form statement consolidation with financial state-
Information is intended to present fairly the ments of state ministries / institutions used
transactions and other events that should be BAS which has been determined by the
presented, then the transaction or other Minister of Finance.
events need to be recorded and presented in
accordance with the substance and eco-
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
133
Petrolis Nusa Perdana/ Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14 (2) 2019, 127-142
Purpose of Financial Statements The pur- a) Budget Realization Report / Operational Re-
pose of financial statements is to provide infor- port;
mation about financial positions, financial opera- b) Balance Sheet.
tions, BLU cash flows that are useful for users of The BLU accounting system processes all
financial statements in making and BLU revenues and expenditures, both from busi-
evaluating economic decisions. ness revenues from services, grants, state budget
Financial statements are prepared for gen- revenues, and other business revenues. So that the
eral purposes, namely meeting the needs of most financial statements produced by the accounting
users. However, financial statements do not pro- system cover all financial transactions at BLU.
vide all the information that financial report users BLU financial transactions originating from busi-
may need in making economic decisions. In or- ness revenues from services, grants, state budget
der to achieve these objectives, the BLU finan- revenues, and other business revenues must be re-
cial report presents information about: ported in the Budget Realization Reports of state /
1) Assets; institutional ministries and the Government.
2) Obligations; Therefore the transaction must be authorized by
3) Equity; the KPPN with the SPM mechanism and Ratifica-
4) Income and Costs; and tion SP2D every quarter.
5) Cash Flow. Thus the implementation of SAI in BLU
In the case of the Consolidation of the can be carried out cumulatively every quarter.
BLU Financial Statements in the State Ministry / Balance sheet items consist of assets, liabilities
Institution Financial Reports, the BLU prepares and equity also consolidated into the balance
financial reports based on Financial Accounting sheets of state ministries / institution. For this pur-
Standards (SAK). BLU is a state ministry / insti- pose, it is necessary to reclassify the balance sheet
tution, therefore BLU financial reports are con- items in accordance with SAP by using BAS as
solidated with the financial statements of state determined by the Minister of Finance. In order to
ministries / institutions. Consolidation of finan- prepare financial statements for consolidation pur-
cial statements can be done if the same account- poses, the BLU accounting system must also pro-
ing principles are used. BLU uses SAK while fi- duce electronic data (in the form of General Ledg-
nancial statements of state ministries / institu- er / Computer Data Archives) by using the Eche-
tions use SAP, therefore BLU develops an ac- lon I or Ministry of Education Accounting System
counting sub-system that is able to produce fi- application.
nancial reports to meet those needs. The compo- For Recognition and measurement, SAK us-
nents of the BLU Financial Report that are con- es an accrual basis in the recognition of assets, lia-
solidated into the financial statements of state bilities, equity, income, and costs, revenue is rec-
ministries / institutions include: ognized when received or the right to collect aris-
es in connection with the existence
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
134
Petrolis Nusa Perdana/Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14 (2) 2019, 127-142
of goods / services delivered to the community. The consolidated financial statements consist of a
Whereas costs are recognized if a decrease in fu- balance sheet, a budget realization report. The Ja-
ture economic benefits relating to a decrease in karta State University Financial Accounting Sys-
assets or an increase in liabilities has occurred tem is made so that a series of procedures for the
and can be measured reliably. This means that use and management of state money can be pro-
the recognition of costs occurs simultaneously cessed into accounting information prepared in
with the recognition of an increase in liabilities the form of Accountability full Financial State-
or a decrease in assets, for example, accruals of ments; Management (implementation of the func-
employee rights or depreciation of fixed assets. tions of planning, management and control over
SAP uses an accrual basis in recognizing assets, all revenues, expenses, assets, liabilities, and eq-
liabilities, and equity as well as the cash base in uity of the BLU for the benefit of stakeholders);
recognizing revenue and expenditure. Revenues and Transparency;
are recognized when cash is received in the ac- B. Relevant BLU Accounting Policy Guide-
count of the State General Cash. Expenditures lines
are recognized at the time of expenditure from The absence of the BLU Accounting Policy
the State General Cash account and are account- Guidelines in the specific education sector has
ed for. Revenue (excluding income transferred made various accounting entities in the education
from the state budget) and BLU expenditure are sector propose their respective draft proposals as
recognized if the income and expenditure are re- the mandatory of their institutions from the re-
ported with the SPM mechanism and SP2D. Ap- spective BLU KMK institutions.
proval of said income and expenditure. However, from so many drafts on this
The formula for income adjustment and matter, the draft from Sriwijaya University was
accrual-based spending to be cash-based is as fol- felt to be quite adequate and the draft was made
lows: into its institutional Chancellor Regulation, so it
A. Cash Based Income = BLU income + in- was quite reliable to be used as a patron and ref-
come received in advance - income that erence.
remains to be received C. Theoretical Framework
B. Cash Based Expenditures = BLU Costs - According to Mahsun (2010) good govern-
Fees paid in cash include Depreciation + ance must have good performance accountability.
debt fees paid + prepaid expenses Accountability in the public sector consists of:
While in terms of disclosure or disclosure 1) Performance Accountability
of financial statement disclosures in accordance In a narrow sense, accountability can be
with SAP must follow the requirements in ac- understood as a form of accountability that refers
cordance with PP No. 24 of 2005. BLU LK con- to who the organization (or individual worker) is
solidation into state ministry / institution LK is responsible for and for which organization
conducted regularly every semester and yearly. (individual worker) is responsible?
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
135
Petrolis Nusa Perdana/Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14 (2) 2019, 127-142
In a broad sense, accountability can be under- but also accountable to the general public, non-
stood as the obligation of the holder of the trust governmental organizations, mass media, and
(agent) to give responsibility, present, report, and many other stakeholders.
disclose all activities and activities which are his Thus, the application of accountability, in
responsibility to the principal (trustee) who has addition to dealing with the use of sound and le-
the right and authority to hold that responsibility. gal administrative policies, must also be able to
The meaning of accountability is a core philo- increase public confidence in the form of formal
sophical concept in public sector management. accountability that has been established. Public
In the context of government organizations, accountability consists of two kinds, namely (1)
there is often the term public accountability vertical accountability and (2) horizontal ac-
which means the provision of information and countability. Vertical accountability is accounta-
disclosure of the activities and financial perfor- bility for the management of funds to higher au-
mance of the government to those parties who thorities, for example the accountability of work
are interested in the report. The government, both units to local governments, regional accountabil-
central and regional, must be able to be the sub- ity to the central government, and the central
ject of information giving in order to fulfill pub- government to the MPR. Horizontal accountabil-
lic rights. Accountability relates primarily to the ity is accountability to the wider community.
mechanisms of supervision, reporting, and ac- 2) Accountability with Responsibility
countability to higher authorities in a formal The term accountability and responsibility
chain of command. In the era of decentralization is often defined in the same way as accountabil-
and regional autonomy, public managers are ex- ity. In order to understand the concept of ac-
pected to be able to transform from a role of pas- countability, a clear and deep analysis is needed
sive obedience to being an active participant in so that it does not overlap with the notion of re-
the preparation of accountability standards in ac- sponsibility. This concept of accountability is ex-
cordance with the wishes and expectations of the plained very simply by various references. In
public. Therefore, the meaning of accountability Australian literature according to Donaldson et
is broader than just a formal process and channel all (1991), the concept of accountability is often
for reporting to higher authorities. Accountability understood in two senses, (1) relating to virtually
must refer to a broad spectrum with performance interchangeable, and (2) related to closely related
standards that rely on public expectations so that (there are interrelationships that closed). Mean-
it can be used to assess performance, responsive- while, responsibility has a number of connota-
ness, and also morality of public trust bearers. tions including freedom to act, obligation to
This conception of accountability in a broad praise and blame, and good behavior that is part
sense makes us aware that government officials of one's responsibility.
are not only responsible to higher authorities in So accountability and responsibility are in-
the institutional command chain, terconnected as part of a comprehensive system.
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
136
Petrolis Nusa Perdana/Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14 (2) 2019, 127-142
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
137
Petrolis Nusa Perdana/Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14 (2) 2019, 127-142
Based on the above problems, then briefly, b. The practice module was obtained from re-
problem solving can be seen in the diagram be- source persons regarding cost management
low: materials used in this training to help for
Agencies and Managers of State Property
at Jakarta State University in the method of
recording in financial statements so that
competitive advantage is achieved.
3. Development Phase
The community service implementation
team seeks to develop this training both in terms
of training materials, modules, and questions and
answers in a form relevant to aspects of the re-
cording of intangible asset models in the devel-
opment of computer-based recording programs.
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
138
Petrolis Nusa Perdana/Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14 (2) 2019, 127-142
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
139
Petrolis Nusa Perdana/Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14 (2) 2019, 127-142
This training emphasizes the success of partici- constellation of good intangible asset manage-
pants in absorbing material specifically aimed at ment in depth to the Financial Statement Manag-
managers of Accounting Systems. Institutions ers is by giving a paper presentation and present-
and managers of state property of the Public Ser- ing the use of a computer system in the form of
vice Agency of the State University of Jakarta SIPPAS (Information System for Reporting In-
can display and present the quantity and quality ventory and Assets of State Property), as well as
of goods of intangible assets in monetary value discussions to be able to produce feedback on
that are state property. at the Public Service this Computer Application System.
Agency of the State University of Jakarta. The following is the screen shot of the SIP-
The training material is delivered in the PAS BMN Computer Application provided with
form of practical direction that can support their training:
ability to improve expertise in developing data-
bases and be able to have high performance pow-
er in the presentation of accounting reports. The
approach is carried out by conducting training
and direct examples with managers of BLU UNJ
financial reports, as well as lectures and discus-
sions on Understanding of Intangible Asset Re- With this media and training with the appli-
porting which is part of State Property (BMN). cation system above, thoroughly discussed about
the examples of intangible asset management in
Theoretical Analysis the BLU UNJ. The discussion of direct commu-
This training cannot be achieved if there is nication media is presented as the second and
no support from the managers of the BLU UNJ concluding material in this community service
Financial Report. There is a tendency to view session. In this second session, there are more
training materials only as mere rhetoric, for this tips and tricks for speeding up data retrieval and
strategy is needed. The method used is to ap- classification of intangible assets. The presenta-
proach the participants as people who are directly tion of the material was carried out complete
related to the problem. with the latest practice and case examples so as
In trying to understand the training material, the to be able to produce an understanding with en-
team chose the method of giving the material fol- thusiasm and happy feelings that resulted in an
lowed by practice sessions, questions and an- increase in the quality of financial reporting of
swers, sharing, discussion sessions by partici- BLU UNJ.
pants. Evaluation of activities
Knowledge of material introduction to the In the process of implementing community
accounting database system concept in SIMAK service, we received positive appreciation from
BMN BLU UNJ about the amortization the Managers of BLU UNJ Financial Reports.
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
140
Petrolis Nusa Perdana/Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14 (2) 2019, 127-142
The enthusiasm of the participants was very high the theme of improving the accounting record da-
in responding to the provision of material as evi- tabase system at SIMAK BMN BLU UNJ on the
denced by the emergence of various questions amortization constellation of intangible asset
that varied around the topic of this intangible as- management needs to be redesigned from up-
set, which caused the holding time to be a little stream to downstream reporting.
longer than scheduled. Tips and tricks that are In the future this activity needs to be de-
practiced indeed become its own strength in the veloped in other themes, not only limited to in-
discussion of the constellation of recording intan- tangible assets, but also with other accounts,
gible assets in order to improve the quality of where the ultimate goal is to improve the quality
BLU UNJ financial statements in general. of the financial statements of UNJ BLU.
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
141
Petrolis Nusa Perdana/Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Akuntansi, 14 (2) 2019, 127-142
G.T Sav. Four Stage DEA Efficiency Evauation : Sutedjo. 2009. Persepsi Stakeholders Terhadap
Financial eforms in Public University Transparansi Dan Akuntabilitas Pengel-
Funding. International Journal of Econom- olaan Keuangan Sekolah (Studi Kasus di
ics and Finance : Vol 5, No 1: 2013. Sekolah Menengah Pertama Standar Na-
G.T Sav. Managing Public Higher Education Re- sional Kabupaten Kendal).Tesis, Program
structuring : Understanding College and Studi Magister Akuntansi Universitas
University Cost Structure. Diponegoro, Semarang.
Iskandarini. 2004. Analisis Pemacahan Masalah
dan Pengambilan Keputusan. USU.
Mahsun. 2005. Metode Penelitian Bahasa. Jakar-
ta: PT Raja Grafindo Persada.
Mardiasmo. 2006. Pewujudan Transparansi dan
Akuntabilitas Publik Melalui Akuntansi
Sektor Publik: Suatu Sarana Good Gov-
ernance. Jurnal Akuntansi Pemerintahan
Vol. 2, No. 1, Mei 2006.
Mardiasmo. 2002. Akuntansi Sektor Publik. Pen-
erbit Andi Jogjakarta.
Mitsopoulos, Michael and Theodoe Pelagidis.
2008. Comparing the administrative and
Financial Autonomy og Higher Education
Institution in 7 EU Countries. Interec-
onomics, September/October 2008.
Peraturan Pemerintah No 4 Tahun 2014 Tentang
Penyelenggaraan Pendidikan Tinggi dan
Pengelolaan Perguruan Tinggi.
Pernyataan Standar Akuntansi Keuangan. 2009.
Ikatan Akuntan Indonesia.
Suryana, 2010. Metode Penelitian, Model Praka-
tis Penelitian Kuantitaif dan Kualitatif. Bu-
ku ajar perkuliahan, Universitas Pendidi-
kan Indonesia, Bandung.
ISSN
2302-1810 (online)
DOI: doi.org/10.21009/wahana-akuntansi/14.2.02
142