Ar

ticl e
l
Hll
HHHl
ll
HIr
TJH

Numer
icali
nves
tigat
ionorwar
headdes
ignwi
thHE

Hi
saat
suKat
o★,
Jin8
houYone
da*.andMi
chi
noi Ta
r ki
2nk
n*

Ac onvent
ionalwar headc ommonlyempl oy8Casel
oadedllihe
g xplosives(HE).Thec asi
ng
(
Shellandli
ner)ofthewar he adisacc
eleratedandtr
ans f
ormedbydet o nat
ionenergyo faHE
i
ntofragments,whic
hdes t
royat ar
geteffect
ivel
y.Wes houldsel
ecttheHEanddes igno ft
he
c
asingtodestroythet ar
getmos teL
TT
ecti
vely.Toimprov
et heperforma nceofthewar head,We
s
houldconsi
dernoto nlythei mpr
ovemento ftheHEandt heShel
l,butalB Oi
nterac
tionbetween
HEandt hec asl
ng･Gene rll
a yi tmayrequlreal ongtimeandhi hC
g ostinthedevelopmentof
8ne wWar head･I tiSne cessaryt Oreducethet imeandt hec os
t,whi c
har emainlyo ri
inat
g ed
fromthee xpeime
r ntlv
a eif
r i
cationSinthedeve l
opment,R∝e ntl
yadv ancementi
nt hec o
mputer
technol
og ya ndappe ranc
a eo fnume ri
calanAly8i880f
twaresenabl edonet or e
duceLi
meandc ost
forwarhe adde si
gnS i
gm
if i
c antl
y .Wet ie
r dtoc omparethee xpe ime
r nt
ldat
a aw
iththec al
cul
ated
result
sobt ine
a dbyus ingt hehydr ocodeAUTODYN f orwar headde sig
ns .Thepreci
8 i
onofthe
nume ic
r alva luesrequire
df orc omputer8imu18tionshasimpr o ve
dt heaccuracyoft
hec al
cul
ated
re8ult
8f orawar head.Numer ic almethodsf orsimulatingdi ffere
ntt ypesofwar headsare
proposedi nt hi
spape r
.

1
.Intr
oducti
on ef
fici
encyofHEwasi nestimable.Ho wever.
atthe
Awar headg enerall
yc on白iBt
80 fac asingandA presenttime,w
it has pr
e adofhigh-perf
ormanc e
HE. I tisc las sifi
edi ntot hr eemaj ort ypes; personalconlput
erSandapr ogreSSin80ftware,
fr
agme nt･
,HJ iAT( Hih Expl
g osi
veAnt i･Tank) ･and e8ti
mationoft
hei nt
eract
ionbe t
we e
nt heShel
land
EFP( Ex plosi
ve l
yFo rme dPe netrater)
-war head.A HEandI .
hesimulati
ono fadet.
OnAtionintheHE
warhe adr equlreSthemo stsuitableHES inces i
之e havebe c
o mepos s
ible.Ac curacyoftheS imu
lation
andS tructureO ft hewar headar erestri
c t
edbya result
sal s
ohasi nc reasedtoapr ac
tical
lyu8Able
carriersuc hasmi ssi
leandpr oj
ectile. I tiS level.I tbecamepo88i blet oShort en t
he
necessaryt Ode t
e r
i net
m heo pti
malc asingandHE develo
pme ntpe io
r dandt ore
duc ethede v
e l
opment
int hedevel opments tageoft hewar headby cost.l
nt hispaper,
t hecase8tudie80rthecomputer
repetitionof8S er i
esofpr oces sdesi gn,t ri
al simulati
onf orwa rheaddes i
gni nNI PPONKOKI
produc ti
on,Andt esti
ng.Tht l
Sgr eatdealort ime Co.wi l
lbei ntr
oduc ed.
Andc os tShouldbes penti nthi sprocess .Int he
pastperf
ormancepredi
cti
onofthewar headhas 2.Then
umeri
calanal
ysi
sme
thod
beencarr
iedoutbytheempir
icalmethods
.Thus APC( PENTIUM I II:1GHz ,memo ry:512MB)
thepredict
edresul
tswereinsuff
ici
entandt he wasusedbyus l
ngt hefoll
owlng8 0ft
war eS.
2.1KHTpr ogram vcr.4.4
Received:Ma y17,2 002 2.1.1Ca一culation ofdeton ation vel ocity.
Accepted: Novembe r26,2
0 0
2 energy. and C-J ( Chapman-Jouguet)
'
R&Dd ivis
ion,NipponKo kiCo.,Ltd.
.211Dobu,
NA g
A an
S k, Nishigou-mura,Nishis
hirak8Wa･gun, pressurei nl oadeddensi tyofaHE
Fukus hima9 61･
8686,JAPAN AsforaHE,dens ityanddet onationvel oci
ty
でEL+81 ･248-
22-
3802
FAX+81 ･248･
22-
4252 wouldbechangedwi t
ht hemat eri
all ots,the
e･mailHnkt oh@nipp o
n-koki.
co.
jp composi
tionratio,andt hel oadingc onditi
ons.

Ka
yi)
kuGa
kka
ish
i.Vo
l.6
3,No
.5,2
002 -223-
Genell
r
a y,
ar equi
redp e
rfo
r mancew
il lber
e al
iz
e d,
i
ftheloadingcondit
ionsaredeterminedtoSatisf
y
anece88ar
yd ensit
yund erthecond it
ionthatthe
mate
ia
r llotsandthecompo si
ti
ona retheS
ame .I f
theactualmeas uredval ues0ft hedetonation
v
elocit
yforthee xpeime
r ntalHEwe rewi t
hin3 %
o
fthet heor
et i
calv aluesca l
culat
edb yus i
ngKHT
(
Ki
c
o
har
nside
a･
re
Hi
dt
ki
o8
t8･
at
TanAka)pr
iS
fyade 8ig
o
nl
gr
ev
e
am,t
ll)
･Ho
heHEi
wever
S
,i
f
b re
L d▲T ニ k J e
oi
nY l
oty=L/ ▲

Fi
g.1Ex
per
ime
ntal8
et･
u T
dea
lingwithac it
r icalpro ble
m, t
hei nit
ialdataof
t
heKHTpr ogram 与 houldbeC orr
e ct
e dsot he
c
omp lュ
tedval
uet oa greewit htheexpeime
r ntval
ue .

2
.1.2CaLc
ulationvr
itht
heJWLE.0.S.
I
nor
dertousetheJ
WLE.0.
ら.(
Jone
s-Wil
kinS
l
L ee
e quationofState)appl
iedtoaHEi nAUTODYN
(Hydr ocode)2),itisne ce88
8ryt Ode t
eri net
m he
parame te
rO ft hisequat i
on州 ･U8 uall
y,these
parame ter80fJWI JE.0.S.havetob edeteri ne
m d
bye xpe ri
JnentS.Ho weverinthisC alc
ulati
on,it
couldbede te
r minednume ri
cal
lyfromt heAbove･ 3.
2N Fig.
2EFPwa r
head.p.
me nti
o nedKHTpr ogramf orthepr eser
vationof 3.
2.1G
u
meo
r
mi
ec
t
arlc
icm
aJo
c
du
el
alo
ti
ft
ons
costne ceSBar
yf orthee xperi
me nts
. Ag e
ome t
icmo
r deli$Showni
h
nF
ey r
i
a
gr
.head
toSavethec omput ertimeandthe 3.1 norder
2.2AU TODYN( H
y drocode) t
wo -
dimensi
onala xiS
ymme t
icmo
r det otalc08t
,a
2.2.1Si mL
Jtatio nb yAU T ODYN-2 D Euleia
r nproc e8
80 rf
ortheHEandl wasused.A
n
Simulation80fAwar he adb yAUTODYNhas pro
ce880rf
ort heS he
lland aLag rangl
an
beenperf
orme dbyi nputti
ngAS etOfdataa Bf
oll
owS;
(1
)g eometicmo
r de lofthewar head:( 2)physi
cal
propert
ies0ft heJWLE. 0. S.f
o rHEandSho ck
Hug o
niotJ己.
0.S. oraS
f hellandl iner:(3)physi
cal
propert
ies0f8 treng t
hmo de l
sf o
rt heS truct
ural
mateia
r l8:(4
)bo n da
u ryandi niti
alco nditi
ons.

3.E xa mpl eo fa nE F Pwar head

3.1E xp erimentalc on figuration
Thepe r f
o r
manc eco nfirma t
ory･testequlpme nt
oftheEFPwar headi SS howni nFi g.1.TheEFP
warhe ad( linerdiame ter: 9
0mm)S howni nFig .2
explode sbyane lect
r icde t
onat or.Thel ineri s 3 Fi
g. 3Geo metr
li
n
cem
ro
wde
er
e
l.appli
ed.
accel
era t
e da ndde or
f me db yt heene r
gyoftheHE. .
2P.
B
2P
Xh y
sical-propertymo deloft heH E
Then, thepr ot
ecti
onpl ater emo v
e dthefmg me nts NIPPONK
(PJ
3OE S･
ⅩN 201
)ma deforane xperi
me nti
n
andonl yanEFPc anpas st hroug
h i t
.Ame an 5wasusedfol
rtC
ho
e.
bW
o8
o8
stu
es
re
Cd
hf
ao
rr
gt
eh
,eH
andET
.P
et
rB
yXN
lfo
r-

EFPv e l
oc it
ywa sme a8u redbyus i
ngt hef
oiltargets
andthes hapeo fforme dEFPhdbe ent a
ke na s
photogr aphswit hanaS hX･ raye quipment.
 T
abl
e1awlpar
ame
ter
s0re
Xpl
oSi
veS(
thes
trengt
hmo
deli
8appl
iedf
orHydr
omo
del
)
Explo8i
ve 8name PBXNS-
201 PBXN- 5 TET
Combinatio
n BaSemat eri
al HMX 90% HMX 95 % T RYL
component Binde retc. HTPB 10% ⅤⅠ
TONA 5 ETRYL 99%
De n8it
y( g/
cm3 ) % GRAPHI TE1 %
Det
onationv el
oci
t y( 1.
705 1.88 I .
73
C-JEnergy /UnitVol.(km
J//
8)'
mm ) 9.
38
84
10
Ⅹ6
1 881 6 7910
C-
JPr e88
ure(TPa) 3. 0一3 9.6L
Ix10'3 8.
2 0xlO.3

JWLpar Amete 095Ⅹ10●2 3.53x10'2 2.

85x1 0'2
r a(
8A( TPPaa
)) 2.
86
1.
2
1Ⅹ
00
10'2 3.
417
.756 5.
87 x10●t
Rl 5XlO`2 I.
07 xlO'2

R2 51.
4
50
50
1 5.810 4.40
W 2.
934Ⅹ10●
ー 3.1
2.
l5
x00
l
O-1 2.1,20

3.
2.3Physi
cal
-pr
oper
tymo
deloft
he 75
x10'l
Twocasingmateri
818Wereused:(1
)Stc
easi
ng ThedetonatingSi
mul ati
ono
arhf
et
a
hd
eHEi 8
theshell
.and(2)TantAlum f
ortheline elf
or inFig.4
.Thedef or
ml ngS i
mulationor Shown
E.0.
S.wasappl i
edfortheShockHug oni
r
o
.T
tahe andanou theEFP
t
heS t
rengthmodelwasAppl
iedf
ortheSt nb nd
ei s t
lineorn88 hX･ rayphotogr
aphsare
ho
Wh
wni
en
nFti
hge
.5S
.imulat i
on re
experimentalvaluesWereCsO
ump
lt88r
8e
nd t
he
G
3.
u2
i.
n
4B
8n.oundaryand i niti
alcondi ti er
g- def
ormationofEFP,thepat
h,length,addt
n,t
he
Abo undaryconditi
onw88appliedf
orto
hn
esEuler
J vel
oci
tyagree
dwellwit
htheSi
mulate
dv he
Lagrangeinterac
tion.A8theini
ti
mede t
onatio
nmodel ★wa白us e
d
ti.
alc
onditi
on,the 4
.Ex
ampl
eoft
hewar
hea
dcontr
o alues
.
*(Detonati
ont i
meo feAChHEc el
l)=(thedist
ance n8ti
ony
ravef
orm wi
th anex
plo
ls
li
vn
egdeto-
r
romt hei
nit
ialdet
onati
ngpo
i AHEATwar headuti
liz
esatechni
quetoco
lens
/
(det
onati
onveloc
ityoft
heHEntt
) oea
chHEc
ell
) th
3.ewavef
3ResuJor
m or
tsoftHEb
heEye i
t
FPyh
lerAw aveS
h ape
nr
tr
ol
mu
lti･
pointdeonat
t or
.I norde
rtom8XiiZ
m ethi
Or

Fi
g. c
4Calul
ate
dre
sul
tsf
orde
tonat
iono s

OF
JSht
er 1
5 J

l f
Vt
o
h(
e
CE
ax
H
tp
.
)
.
E)
:
1
:1
9
.9
52
4
0m
E
EL/
/
sS

Fi
g.5 Si
mul
aF
L
ti
S
onof
30
t〝
heE
S FP(
5
u5
p1
1
pe
S
techni que,wehavet Oknow t hedef ormat ion pl
usexperi
ment
).There
for
e,ates
twar
headwhich
eff
ici
enc yo falinerandt hepe r
formanc eoft heme tal usi
nganexplosi
velenswasmadeforobtai
ning
jet
. ne
ce888r
ydatafors
imulat
ion.
Awaves hape ri 8us uallymadeo fani nac ti
ve
mat eri
a l.Fr agme nte ff
e ctmayde creases inc ethe 4.1Ex perimentalc onfigL
Jration
mas s0ft heHEbe comes1 e88erWi thi nc reas i
ng Thec onvent ionalwarhead t ypewi thout
themas s0ft hewave8 hape r.Awaves hape ri S explosivelensi sS howni nFi g.6.Twot ypes0r
structural l
ys impl ebutamul ti-
pointde t onat i
on warhe adsCOnt r
Ollingorde to
nat i
onwav eE
brmwit h
deic
v ehasC OmPl icateds hapeandl argeS ize.The ane xplosi
vel ensar eShowni nFig.7.Ani on･gap
controlte chnologyo fadet onationwave formi san probewasal soS ett OOtherst es
twar headi nthe
eff
e ct
iv emeansi nor dert ous etheener g yo fHE samemanne raSS howni nFi g.6.
effectively.Howe verdevel opmentoraHEAT
war headempl oyingawave畠 haperc os tsmuc h 4.2Nur
Tl
ericalmeth
od
compa redt oac onve ntionalHARTwar headbe caus e 4.2.1Geometri
cmodeloft
hewar
hea
d
ofs t
uc
r turalc ompl e xity.I rthes imulat iono ran Thege ometri
cmodelsofthreewarhe
ad8are
accumt ee xplo8ive 8pe rf
o rmanc ec anbeus edi n showni nFig.8.1nordertousethemodelofa
thede8 ignSt ageOtawar head,i twi llbe come two･dimen8i
onalaxIS
ymmet ry
,theL8grangl
an
reductio no fde velopmentc os t
s( t
rialpr oduc ti
on proc
e 8
80rW88usedtosavet
hecompute
rtimeand

Fi
g.6Conve
nti
onalwar
he ype(
adt 1 rnol
Ypeo en
 T
abl
e2JWLpa
rame
ter
s0fe
xpl
oSi
ve8(
thes
tre
ngt
hmo
deli
88ppl
iedf
orVom
i e
sesmo
del
)

EXpl
OSi
veSnAme PBXNS-
211 PBXN.
5 HB

C
co
om
mp
bi
o
nna
et
i
no
tn BB
aS
iema
nde rt
e
ei
r
tc
.AI RT
HDPXB91 9% HMX 95% A
T
Rle
N
DT
Xt
(X
3
2
:
.-
9
3
41
%
0%
De nsit
y( g/
cm3) 1. % ⅤⅠ
TONA 5 %
De
tonat i
onv el
oci
ty( m/8) 650 1.
88 1 .
80
C.JEner gy/UnitⅥ}1.(
kJ/ mmり 8.78
5158
Ⅹ4
10' 881 6 6849
C-JPr esS
ure(TPA) 2.831 Ⅹ 3 9.64xlO●n 4.
00Ⅹ1 0●3
JWLpa ramet 10'2 3.53xlO''
Z 1.70Ⅹ10■2
erSA(
B(TPPa
a)
) 2.61
0.0
8Ⅹ
27
10●2 3.
JI
17
.55
7Ⅹ6
10■ 2. 254
Rl 5. 2 1.
587 Ⅹ102
R2 1.4
52
50
4 5
1.810 6. 623
W 2.88Ⅹ10'l 2.
3.15
x0
10
0'1 2.1
2.
35
Ⅹ87
1
0ーl

T
abl
e31
ゝpi
calpar
ame
ter
s0ft
heL
ee-
TAr
Verm

maint
ainthe8
8tiS
raC
tOr
yreso
lut
iona8S
tr o
del
Thetarge
tpointwasSett
OtheSamepouc
sit
ures
. T

4
t
h.
e2.
i
o2P
n･
gh
ay
psp
i
cr
o
ablp
e.rop t
iona8
PBX(PBXNS- 211)er
td
maymo deloftheH E
NIPPONKOKICo .wasuSe
easAnexpeimenti
r n
5wasusedfortheboost
erdfortheHE.PBXN･
theexpl
osi
velenS
･ C
harge.andHBX･
3for
expl
osiv
esareSho TheJWLparameter
80rt
hese

4.
2.3D
eton
ati
onc
wni
on
nT
di
a
tb
io
l
eno
2･ft
h

e eTn
L ･ar
vv
ee
rrm
moo
dd
ee
lw
lasde
) scibe
r d eH
E(Le
e-
growthmodelofexplosi
veiniti fo ri
gni
tionand
ofcal
cuhtiont
oapplythemo del
Ati
on･Ther e
sults
ofheterogene
ouse xpl
osive o ns hocki
niti
ati
on
comp･ B were compared sswi
ucthSP
ha pub
BX･9404,

e we
xper
it
mho
eut
nh
g
alt
dt
he
ata榊the
･L
ee -Tarvermo l i
shed
appl
iedforexplo
s i de
lcoul
dbe
theHEmadei n o nandt hedetonationmodelor
t｡useitf
orth o urcompany ･Acc
o r
dingl
ywet r
ied
parameterseSi
mulationofthewar
head.Typi
cal
summari
Z:
edinT
0ft
ab
hl
e 3.ee-
eL Tarvermodelar e 4.
2.4Ph
ysi
calpr
oper
tymo
dcloft
hec
asi
ngs
 Fi
g.9Cal
clat
u edr

p
RES
SUF
7亡く
TPa) es
ult
sforde
tonat
iono
fthr
eewar
heads
. q
Tr
ge
●t
t
R
H 4
c
d

1
8.0 璽1
2 or
璽 璽 些 璽T
T ge
lt
tB
R 6
8o5
7
8

- ･p,
( uC) Ty
peo
fnol
ens 盲;
"
p
ES
eu
f
B主h
onl
enst
ypeTy
peo
fl
.
0 on 1
8.0

Fi
g.l
lSl
m peo
fde
tonat
ionw
Fi
ga
.v
1ef
0Pro
rn
et
ss
ureC
urveOnt
het
argetpo
int
.gl
engt
hlens
ot
herhandwet
hinkt
hatt
he8
imul
ati
onofan lti
sv eryI
mpor t
antthatawar headde8igner'
s
explos i
onSi tuationc anexpr e88thedet onation ideac ouldbeexami nedbyus ingnumer i
cal
Situationwel lal thought het endenc yfort he simuht i
onquic
kly.Wewi llac
cumuht erequired
de t
onationvel oci
tyi nthec entralpartiBquicker datafortheseSimu18t
ion8furt
herfrom nowon.
th nt hati nc i
rcumf erencepartsint hewar head Accur
acyOrAWarheadSimu
lat
ionwo
ldbemuc
u h
Promt hec ompar iso nofthe8 i
mul at
edr eS
ult8w
it h impro
vedinnearfutur
e.
thoseo bt ainedex pe iment
r all
y.Wec onsiderthat
thev elo
c itydiff
e r
e ncebetwe e
rLtheSimulati
onand Refer
ences
thee xperimentwe recausedbyt heAccuracyOfthe 1
)K. Tanaka,De tonat
ionProperti
eso fCondens
e d
e eTar
L ･ ve rmo delingo fHEbas edont hesmaller Explosi
veSComput edU8 i
Jl
gt heK
ihar 8･Hiki
ta･
8CAlete8 Lre s
ults. TanakaEquat iono fStat
e,Nat ionalChem
ic al
Laboratoryforlndu8try(19
83 )
.
6.Con
clusi
ons 2
)Century Dynami cs lnc.,AUTODYN
A8f orthi 卓Simu
lat i
on,wehaveaf i
nalgoalt o (I
nterac ti
veNon･ LinezL
rDynami cAnaly8i8
calculatetheml esscostl
y,more白 i
mpl y.andwi h
t Soft
wAr e)U8er8MAnualRe is
v ion3.0(1997)
.
higher叩e e d.Sinceame shwasC OOrdinatedmor e 3
)M.KAt ayama.
K.TanAka,AndT.
Ai2
i
aWa.Proc
.
coarselythant hernanualcurr
ent l
yint roducedto AnnualSymposi
um onShoc kWave,Tbkyo
referencen,t hecalcul
ationoftheEFPwar head (1
992)
.
tookt wohour sforonecaseandt hec al
c ulat
ionof 4)M.Kat AyAmAAndK Tanaka, a.JapanExpl os.
thewarheadwit
htheexpl
osi
vel
enst
ookhal
fan Soc..62,25 7･26
8( 2001).
houri
nonec as
e. 5)Shir°Kubot a,Hi dekiSimada,KikuoMat 8ui.
Genem l ly,since a calculat i
on ti
me is YukioKat o,Kat suhikoTakah88hi ,MaS at
ake
propo
rtionaltothenumberofme sh.Thenumber YoBhida,Zhi ･
yueLi u,andShigeul
r toh.Kayaku
ormeshi 8prOpO
rti
ona
ltot
hec al
culati
ona
ccur
acy
. Gakkt l
i8hi.Vol.62,No.2(2001
).
Thust henumberofme shS houldbedetermi
ned 6)E.L Le eandC.M.Tar ve
r,Phy8 .FluidO,23,
b
yt r
ade･of
rofe
ffe
ctstoexpense8. 2362( 1980).
Si
nceitispossi
bletover i
fythepe rf
ormance 7
)Centur yDynamicsInc.
,Explosivel
nit
i8ti
on
r
equiredfor8designbyc oarseS eLupli
kethis U8eBManual(
r ee
L -Taz
I
VerIgnit
ion& Growth)
s
imulati
on.webel
ievethati
ti8pO88 i
blet
ousethe Rev
i8ion4.
1(199
9).
S
imulati
onforthewarheaddes i
gn.

K8
yOk
uG8
kka
ish
i.Vo
L63
･No
･5･2
002 -229-