Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Differentiation
Compiled by:
Kimberly (Hilton) Hawkins
South Dakota ‘06
Table of Contents
According to students’…
Content
Content consists of ideas, concepts, descriptive information, facts,
rules and principles that are presented to the learner.
Additional suggestions:
• When possible, students should be encouraged to move through
content areas at their own pace. If they master a particular unit,
they need to be provided with more advanced learning activities,
not more of the same activity. Thematic, broad-based and
integrated content, rather than single-subject areas in isolation
best serve their learning characteristics. In addition, such
concept-based instruction expands opportunities to generalize
and to integrate and apply ideas.
• Middle and secondary schools are generally organized to meet
student needs within content areas. Providing an interdisciplinary
approach is another way of modifying curriculum. Jacobs and
Borland (1986) found that high ability learners benefit greatly
from curriculum experiences that cross or go beyond traditional
content areas, particularly when they are encouraged to acquire
an integrated understanding of knowledge and the structure of
the disciplines.
Process
Process is the presentation of content, including the learning activities
for students, the questions that are asked, as well as the teaching
methods and thinking skills that are used.
Product
Products are the outcomes of instruction that consolidate learning and
communicate ideas.
Teachers can differentiate content, process, and/or product for students (Tomlinson,
1999). Differentiation of content refers to a change in the material being learned by a
student. For example, if the classroom objective is for all students to re-tell a story some
students may learn to re-state the beginning, middle, and end, while others may learn to
incorporate character’s points of view into the re-telling. Differentiation of process refers
to the way in which a student accesses material. One student may explore a learning
center, while another student collects information from the web. Differentiation of
product refers to the way in which a student shows what he or she has learned. For
example, to demonstrate understanding of a non-fiction article, some students may
create a graphic organizer, while others discuss the main concepts in a small group.
How Is it Implemented?
Implementation looks different for each student and each assignment. Before beginning
instruction, teachers should do three things:
1. Use diagnostic assessments to determine student readiness. These
assessments can be formal or informal. Teachers can give pre-tests, question
students about their background knowledge, or use KWL charts (charts that ask
students to identify what they already Know, what they Want to know, and what
they have Learned about a topic).
2. Determine student interest. This can be done by using interest inventories and/or
including students in the planning process. Teachers can ask students to tell
them what specific interests they have in a particular topic, and then teachers
can try to incorporate these interests into their lessons.
3. Identify student learning styles and environmental preferences. Learning styles
can be measured using learning style inventories. Teachers can also get
information about student learning styles by asking students how they learn best
and by observing student activities. Identifying environmental preferences
includes determining whether students work best in large or small groups and
what environmental factors might contribute to or inhibit student learning. For
example, a student might need to be free from distraction or have extra lighting
while he or she works.
The table in this document provides descriptions of eight differentiation strategies, ways
in which the strategies are primarily used to differentiate instruction, and guidelines for
their use. Teachers should select differentiation strategies based on the curriculum
taught and the needs of students in their classrooms.
Differentiation
Primary Use Description of Strategy Things to Consider
Strategy
Assignments and products are • Focus task on a key
designed to instruct and assess concept
students on essential skills that • Use a variety of
are provided at different levels of resource materials at
complexity, abstractness, and different levels of
open-endedness. The curricular complexity and
content and objective(s) are the associated with
Tiered same, but the process and/or different learning
Assignments Readiness product are varied according to modalities
and Products the student’s level of readiness. • Adjust task by
complexity,
For example, students with abstractness, number
moderate understanding about a of steps,
topic are asked to write an concreteness, and
article. Students with a more independence to
advanced understanding are ensure challenge and
asked to prepare a debate. not frustration
Compacting is the process of • Thoroughly pre-
eliminating teaching or student assess the learner’s
practice due to previous mastery knowledge and
of learning objectives. document findings
Compacting Readiness Compacting involves a three • Explain the process
step process: and its benefits to the
(1) assess the student to student
determine his/her level of • Create written plans
Differentiation
Primary Use Description of Strategy Things to Consider
Strategy
knowledge on the and timelines for study
material to be studied • Allow student choice
and determine what in enrichment or
he/she still needs to accelerated study
master
(2) create plans for what the
student needs to know,
and excuse the student
from studying what
he/she already knows
(3) create plans for freed-up
time to be spent in
enriched or accelerated
study
∗
More information about grouping strategies can be found in Strategies to Improve Access to the General Education
Curriculum. Available at http://www.k8accesscenter.org/training_resources/curricular_materials.asp
Strategy Focus Definition Example
are placed based on interest reports, based on the book
and/or learning profile. Groups topic.
can either be assigned by the
teacher or chosen by the
students. Students can be
assigned purposefully to a
group or assigned randomly.
This strategy allows students
to work with a wide variety of
peers and keeps them from
being labeled as advanced or
struggling.
Learning contracts begin with A student indicates that he
an agreement between the or she wants to research a
teacher and the student. The particular author. With
teacher specifies the support from the teacher,
necessary skills expected to the student determines
be learned by the student and how the research will be
the required components of conducted and how the
the assignment, while the information will be
Learning Readiness
student identifies methods for presented to the class. For
Contracts Learning Profile
completing the tasks. This example, the student might
strategy (1) allows students to decide to write a paper and
work at an appropriate pace; present a poster to the
(2) can target learning styles; class. The learning contract
and (3) helps students work indicates the dates by
independently, learn planning which each step of the
skills, and eliminate project will be completed.
unnecessary skill practice.
After students read Romeo
Choice boards are organizers and Juliet, they are given a
that contain a variety of choice board that contains
activities. Students can a list of possible activities
choose one or several for each of the following
Readiness activities to complete as they learning styles: visual,
Choice Boards Interest learn a skill or develop a auditory, kinesthetic, and
Learning Profile product. Choice boards can be tactile. Students must
organized so that students are complete two activities
required to choose options from the board and must
that focus on several different choose these activities
skills. from two different learning
styles.
∗
More information about grouping strategies can be found in Strategies to Improve Access to the General Education
Curriculum. Available at http://www.k8accesscenter.org/training_resources/curricular_materials.asp
Strategy Focus Definition Example
skills. magazine letters to create
poems, using a word
processor, or dictating a
poem into a tape recorder
and transcribing it. Students
must complete two activities
from the board and must
choose these activities from
two different learning styles.
∗
More information about grouping strategies can be found in Strategies to Improve Access to the General Education
Curriculum. Available at http://www.k8accesscenter.org/training_resources/curricular_materials.asp
Strategy Focus Definition Example
work at an appropriate pace; data and conducting
(2) can target learning styles; research about football.
and (3) helps students work The student decides to
independently, learn planning create a PowerPoint
skills, and eliminate presentation to present his
unnecessary skill practice. or her findings to the class.
∗
More information about grouping strategies can be found in Strategies to Improve Access to the General Education
Curriculum. Available at http://www.k8accesscenter.org/training_resources/curricular_materials.asp
Strategy Focus Definition Example
skills. video with demonstrations
centered around density.
The activities are based on
the following learning
styles: visual, auditory,
kinesthetic, and tactile.
Students must complete
two activities from the board
and must choose these
activities from two different
learning styles.
References
Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. http://www.ascd.org
Hall, T., Strangman, N., & Meyer, A. (2003). Differentiated instruction and implications
for UDL implementation. National Center on Accessing the General Curriculum.
Retrieved July 9, 2004 from:
http://www.k8accesscenter.org/training_resources/udl/diffinstruction.asp
Interests
Interests
Reading, writing, running, teaching,
cooking, spending time with family
Interests: _________________________________________________
Friends: ___________________________________________________
Modality Preference Survey
Directions:
For each item, circle “A” if you agree with the statement describes you most of the time.
Circle “D” if you disagree that the statement describes you most of the time.
4. I like classrooms with lots of posters and pictures around the room. A D
22. I prefer talking on the phone rather than writing a letter to someone. A D
23. I would rather participate in athletic events than watch them. A D
27. I like being outdoors and doing things like biking, camping, A D
swimming, hiking etc.
28. I remember best what was done rather than talked about. A D
29. When faced with a problem, I often select the solution involving A D
the greatest activity.
SCORING
Total number of “A” responses
VISUAL SCORE
(Items 1-11)
=
Total number of “A” responses
AUDITORY SCORE
(Items 12-22)
=
Total number of “A” responses
KINESTHETIC SCORE
(Items 23-33)
=
NOTE:
• It is important to keep in mind that sensory preferences are usually only evident during prolonged
and complex learning tasks.
Sternberg’s Triarchic Theory
of Intelligences Survey
Directions:
Mark each sentence “T” (true) if you like to do the activity.
Mark each sentence “F” (false) if you do not like to do the activity.
SCORING
Transfer your answers from the survey to the key.
The column with the most “T” responses is your dominant intelligence.
Bodily-Kinesthetic Learners...
• Use the body effectively (like a dancer or a surgeon)
• Have keen sense of body awareness
• Like movement, making things, touching
• Communicate well through body language
• Learn best by touching, moving, interacting with space,
processing knowledge through bodily sensations
• Can be taught through physical activity, hands-on learning,
acting out, role playing
Interpersonal Learners...
• Understand and interact with others
• Have many friends, empathy for others, street smarts
• Learn best by sharing, comparing, relating, cooperating,
interviewing
• Can be taught through group activities, seminars, dialogues
Intrapersonal Learners...
• Understand own interests and goals
• Tend to shy away from others
• Are in tune with their inner feelings (have wisdom, intuition
and motivation, as well as a strong will, confidence and
opinions)
• Learn best by working alone, individualized projects, self
paced instruction, having own space
• Can be taught through independent study and introspection
Logical-Mathematical Learners...
• Think conceptually, abstractly, and are able to see and
explore patterns and relationships
• Like to experiment, solve puzzles, ask cosmic questions
• Learn best by categorizing, classifying, working with
abstract patterns/relationships
• Can be taught through logic games, investigations, mysteries
• Need to learn and form concepts before they can deal with
details
Possible Vocations: accountant, bookkeeper, statistician, trades
person, computer programmer, scientist, engineer, inventor,
designer
Musical Learners...
• Show sensitivity to rhythm and sound
• Love music (also sensitive to sounds in their environments)
• May study better with music in the background
• Learn best by rhythm, melody, music
• Can be taught by turning lessons into lyrics, speaking
rhythmically, and tapping out time
Naturalistic Learners...
• Like to physically experience nature, do observations
• Are good at exploring natural phenomenon, seeing
connections, seeing patterns, reflective thinking
• learn best by doing observations, recording events in nature,
working in pairs, doing long term projects
Verbal-Linguistic Learners...
• Use words effectively
• Have highly developed auditory skills and often think in
words
• Like reading, playing word games, making up poetry or
stories
• Learn best by saying, hearing, and seeing words
• Can be taught by encouraging them to say and see words,
read books together
Visual-Spatial Learners...
• Think in terms of physical space (as do architects)
• Very aware of their environments
• Like to draw, do jigsaw puzzles, read maps, daydream
• Learn best by visualizing, dreaming, using the mind’s eye,
working with colors/pictures
• Can be taught through drawings, verbal and physical imagery
touching, moving,
BODILY/ Eager to solve problems
move around, interacting with space,
physically. Often doesn’t physical activities,
KINESTHETIC touch and talk, processing knowledge
read directions but just crafts
use body language through bodily
LEARNER starts on a project
sensations
understanding
Likes group work and
INTER- people, leading others,
working cooperatively to have lots of sharing, comparing,
organizing,
PERSONAL solve problems, has an friends, talk to relating, cooperating,
communicating,
interest in their people, join groups interviewing
LEARNER manipulating,
community.
mediating conflicts
Verbal/Linguistic
3. I really like to listen to the radio.
☺
4.
I really like to do word searches or crossword
puzzles. ☺
5. I really like language arts and social studies.
☺
6. I really like to do experiments.
☺
☺
Mathematical/Logical
7. I really like math.
Visual/Spatial
18. I hardly ever get lost or mixed up.
☺
19.
I can pretend I am in the sky looking down on
my house and know where everything is. ☺
20.
I am good at drawing or making things with
clay. ☺
21. I am good at sports.
☺
22. I really like to dance.
☺
Bodily/Kinesthetic
23. I like to be outside a lot.
☺
24. I am good at learning new sports or dances.
☺
25.
I can figure out how something works or how
to fix something that is broken by myself. ☺
26. I feel sad when others are feeling sad.
☺
I feel happy when I am with others that are
☺
Interpersonal
27.
feeling happy.
28.
I like playing games with a group of people
better than just one other person. ☺
29. I have more than three really good friends.
☺
30
.
I really like being in the middle of a crowd.
☺
31
.
I like to spend time alone to think by myself.
☺
32
.
I think a lot about the future and what I want to
do when I grow up. ☺
Intrapersonal
33
.
I know right away when I am feeling “stressed
out” and I spend time alone to feel better. ☺
34
.
I keep a diary or journal to write down my
feelings. ☺
35
.
Most of the time, I'd rather stay home than go
out somewhere with a lot of people. ☺
SCORING:
When four or more smiling faces in each section are colored in, it is a good indication
that that student utilizes that learning style with ease.
the posters. Not liking one area doesn’t make you NOT
Smarts
Last week, the students participated in a lesson about what it means to be smart.
At the beginning of the lesson, I asked them to think about whether or not they thought
that they were smart. We then completed the attached paper together. The students
were asked to check things that they liked. I then collected the papers and talked to
them about all the different kinds of smarts they could have. I also explained that
being smart in one area, doesn’t mean you are not smart in others. I took the
information on this sheet to create the bulletin board in the hallway. If a student
highlighted a lot of preferences in one box, it means that they are smart in that area.
Being smart in one area means that they prefer doing those types of activities. The
eight different types of smarts are:
When things start to “not go your way” and you are tired and worn
down, what might your responses be?
say “I’m sorry” over-control “it’s not my fault” withdraw
make mistakes become critical manipulate don’t talk
feel badly take charge act out indecisive
When you’ve had a bad day and you become frustrated, how might you
respond?
become physical
over please perfectionism disengage
be irresponsible
cry verbally attack delay
demand
feel depressed overwork daydream
attention
TOTAL SCORE
Harmony
Production Connection Status Quo
“Winnie the
“Rabbit” “Tigger” “Eeyore”
Pooh”
Personal Objectives/Personality Components
Teacher and student personalities are a critical element in the classroom dynamic. The Array Model (Knaupp, 1995)
identifies four personality components; however, one or two components(s) tend to greatly influence the way a person sees
the world and responds to it. A person whose primary personal objective is Production is organized, logical and thinking-
oriented. A person whose primary personal objective is Connection is enthusiastic, spontaneous and action-oriented. A
person whose primary personal objective is Status Quo is insightful, reflective and observant. Figure 3.1 presents the Array
Model descriptors and offers specific cooperative and reluctant behaviors for each personal objective.