KALPATARU POWER TRANSMISSION LIMITED

Tender Opening Result - KPTL/BD-TD-T5

KPTL INTL Divn Tx: 1646
Mumbai, India Date: 08.05.2017

EEP, Ethiopia
Lot 4: Semera-Afdera 230kV Single Circuit Transmission Line ICB No:EEP/PMO/03/2017
Tender opening results for tender opened on 08.05.2017
Sr. No Party Quoted Prc Discount Discounted Prc % Position
Eqv USD Eqv USD Per Km
USD 16,133,183 USD - USD 16,133,183
1 Power Construction Co. Ltd. EUR - EUR - EUR - USD 17,948,703 USD 91,950 100.00% L-1
ETB 41,666,194 ETB - ETB 41,666,194
USD 12,111,387 USD - USD 12,111,387
2 Transrail EUR - EUR - EUR - USD 18,251,569 USD 93,502 101.69% L-2
ETB 140,917,167 ETB - ETB 140,917,167
USD 27,256,557 USD 9,485,280 USD 17,771,277
3 Al Sharif Group # EUR - EUR - EUR - USD 18,677,939 USD 95,686 104.06% L-3
ETB 236,453,332 ETB 215,645,440 ETB 20,807,892
USD 13,663,905 USD - USD 13,663,905
4 KPTL EUR - EUR - EUR - USD 19,129,690 USD 98,000 106.58% L-4
ETB 125,439,775 ETB - ETB 125,439,775
USD 12,042,230 USD - USD 12,042,230
5 TATA ** EUR - EUR - EUR - USD 19,539,871 USD 100,102 108.87% L-5
ETB 172,070,877 ETB - ETB 172,070,877
USD 17,995,264 USD 3,208,556 USD 14,786,708
6 L&T * EUR - EUR - EUR - USD 21,121,695 USD 108,205 117.68% L-6
ETB 194,213,111 ETB 48,825,176 ETB 145,387,935
USD 13,515,894 USD - USD 13,515,894
7 KEC EUR - EUR - EUR - USD 22,221,305 USD 113,839 123.80% L-7
ETB 199,789,192 ETB - ETB 199,789,192
USD 19,206,257 USD - USD 19,206,257
8 Gedi-ZTT-Sinotec JV EUR - EUR - EUR - USD 22,968,810 USD 117,668 127.97% L-8
ETB 86,350,594 ETB - ETB 86,350,594
USD 21,623,429 USD - USD 21,623,429
9 Etern-Hei-CCCE Construction EUR - EUR - EUR - USD 25,868,170 USD 132,521 144.12% L-9
ETB 97,416,823 ETB - ETB 97,416,823

Page 1 of 2
KPTL INTL Divn Tx: 1646
Mumbai, India Date: 08.05.2017

EEP, Ethiopia
Lot 4: Semera-Afdera 230kV Single Circuit Transmission Line ICB No:EEP/PMO/03/2017
Tender opening results for tender opened on 08.05.2017
Sr. No Party Quoted Prc Discount Discounted Prc % Position
Eqv USD Eqv USD Per Km
USD 22,389,659 USD 1,567,276 USD 20,822,383
10 Xian Electric EUR - EUR - EUR - USD 26,266,485 USD 134,562 146.34% L - 10
ETB 134,346,397 ETB 9,404,248 ETB 124,942,149
USD 24,918,781 USD 1,121,345 USD 23,797,436
11 NCC EUR - EUR - EUR - USD 26,895,666 USD 137,785 149.85% L - 11
ETB 74,454,847 ETB 3,350,468 ETB 71,104,379

Exchange Rates (As per Final Tender's P&P)

1 USD = 1.09 EUR
1 USD = 22.95 ETB
1 USD = 64.25 INR
* L&T Discount not clear Offered / Read out - "14% on FOB, 30% for USD & 30% for test, erection & Commissioning". Discount in above table calculated
based on our price breakup i.e. 17.83% on FC & 25.14% on LC
** TATA submitted only Swift message for BG
# Al Sharif have not submitted BG
## KPTL - USD 840,000 conditional discount for award of both Lots - Lot 3 & Lot 4

1 Scope Mekele-Dallol and Semera Afdera Power supply for Industrial Development and Access Scale-up Project
Lot 4: Procurement of Plant, Design, Supply and Installation of Semera - Afdera 230kV Single Circuit Transmission Line - 195.4 Kms
2 Consultant -
3 Funding African Development Bank
4 Price Variation No PV. Firm Price
5 Tender Validity 180 Days after bid submission date
6 Project Completion 18 months from the Effective date.
7 Taxes & Duties Customs, import duties, excluded on foreign supplies. (import ). VAT applicable on Erection and local supplies
8 Tower Design New Tower Design
9 Tower Tonnage 3791 MT
10 LME Aluminum considered USD 1948 / MT
11 Aluminum Tonnage 612 MT
12 Other / Remarks 195.2 KM

Page 2 of 2