Rubric for Seminars grading Date: ____ _____________, 2020

Assessment parameters Teacher: Chem. Eng. Eng., Dr. Amadeus Castro

Students: _____________________________________________________________________________________

Speech: ________________________

Criteria OMG! (5,0) So good (4,1) Better next time (2,6) WTF! (1,0)
Files just in Team send files Team send files the Team send the files Team don’t send the
time 1 day before or night before activity. about 1 hour before the files after starting the
earlier. activity. activity.

Team Every student take Not all the students 1 or 2 students take part Only 1 student rules
organization part in the speech and take part in the in the speech. the speech.
catch the class speech.
attention.
Auditorium Speech is performed Speech is performed Speech is focused on the Speech is focused on
management over all the partially over all the teacher/whiteboard the whiteboard.
auditorium. classroom audience.
Scientific & All the questions Al the questions about Some questions are No questions are
engineering about the topic are the topic are solved solved. solved.
knowledge solved with both with fluency or
fluency and accuracy. accuracy.
Time The speech is The speech is The speech is developed The speech cannot be
management developed around in developed about the around in 1/2 part of the concluded with
2/3 part of the maximum time. maximum time or need satisfaction in the
maximum time. to be stopped when assigned time.
almost conclude.
Coherence The topic assigned is The topic assigned is The topic assigned is The topic assigned is
with asked totally coherent with totally coherent with partially coherent with not coherent with the
topic the speech, include the speech, include 1 the speech, although speech.
several examples. example. including examples.
Speech aides Attractive design, Interesting design, Design from templates. Design no interesting.
Design animations, legible legible font Font size/images are Font /images aren’t
font size/images, very size/images, uses partially legible, uses legible, text exceed to
visual. images and text. more text than images. images.
Use of Whole document Only images or topic Only sources are cited. No references.
references contain cites and sources are cited.
references.
Interest in Along others Along others speeches Along others speeches Along others
others topics speeches the whole the team majority the team majority speeches the team
(optative, team remains quite, remains quite, pay discuss but no make majority discuss
professor pay attention, take attention and make coherent questions without paying
criteria) notes, and make questions about about the concept under attention to their
questions about concepts or examples. study (or are absent). classmates on
concepts or examples. conference (or are
absent).
Comments:

Important notice: This rubric bring all the grades inly to people that attend to the activity. For people absent the
final grade covers only the items “Files just in time” and “References”. Absences affect the item “Interest in others
topics” lowering the team ranking.