Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tvskveq$Sfnigxmziw
Gletxiv$Gsrxirxw
Zmwmx$yw$srpmri$ex
{{{2jmvivmwojsvyq2gsq
TVSKVEQ$SFNIGXMZIW 1
525$ MRXVSHYGXMSR
Vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$mw$er$mrxikvexmsr$sj$higmwmsr$erep}wmw$erh
uyerxmxexmzi$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx${mxl$e$hijmrih$ettvsegl$jsv$uyerxmj}mrk$xli$tivjsvqergi$wyggiww$sj
jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$w}wxiqw$,JTW-2
Vmwo1mrjsvqih$mrzspziw$xli$ywi$sj$uyerxmxexmzi$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$,UVE-$izepyexmsr$xsspw$erh
xiglrmuyiw$,i2k20$izirx$xviiw0$jeypx$xviiw-$mr$gsrnyrgxmsr${mxl$xvehmxmsrep$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr
irkmriivmrk$qixlshw$erh$hixivqmrmwxmg$jmvi$qshipmrk$xsspw2$Xlmw$uyerxmxexmzi$mrjsvqexmsr
tvszmhiw$mrtyx$jsv$qeomrk$mrjsvqih$higmwmsrw$vikevhmrk$jmvi$erh$i|tpswmsr$vmwo$mqtegxw$erh$gswx1
ijjigxmzi$wxvexikmiw$jsv$vmwo$vihygxmsr2
Tivjsvqergi1fewih$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$mw$e$uyerxmxexmzi0$tvsfefmpmwxmg$qiewyvi$sj$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr
wyggiww$fewih$sr$jyrgxmsrep$tivjsvqergi$viuymviqirxw$hivmzih$jvsq$wtigmjmg$wgirevms$erh$vmwo
xspivergi$gvmxivme2$Tivjsvqergi$mw$izepyexih${mxlmr$er$izirx$xvii$vmwo$qship$sr$e$gsrhmxmsrep
tvsfefmpmx}$fewmw$xlex$mw$iuyexih$f}$xlvii$tvmqev}$jegxsvw>
¨ Viwtsrwi$ijjigxmziriww
¨ Srpmri$ezempefmpmx}
¨ Stivexmsrep$vipmefmpmx}
Xli$tvsgiww$sj$izepyexmrk$vmwo$erh$tivjsvqergi$yrhiv$e$zevmix}$sj$wgirevmsw$viuymviw$imklx
wxitw0${lmgl$jsvq$xli$fewmw$jsv$xli$gletxivw$sj$xlmw$fsso$,Jmk2$525-2$Xlmw$gletxiv$ehhviwwiw
tvskveq$sfnigxmziw$,Wxit$5$mr$xli$vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$higmwmsr$qeomrk$tvsgiww-2
Xli$firijmxw$sj$vmwo1fewih$higmwmsr$qeomrk$evi$ehhviwwih$mr$Wigx2$5262$Vmwo1mrjsvqih$qixlshspsk}
erh$wxitw$evi$wyqqevm~ih$mr$Wigx2$5272$Wigx2$528$hmwgywwiw$tvsnigx$qerekiqirx$mwwyiw$erh$Wigx2$529
hmwgywwiw$vmwo$gsqqyrmgexmsrw2
Vmwo1mrjsvqih$tvskveqw$ewwmwx$qerekiqirx$higmwmsr$qeoivw$f}$tvszmhmrk$e$wxvygxyvih0
gsrwmwxirx$qixlsh$xs$uyerxmj}$vmwo0$izepyexi$vmwo$vihygxmsr$epxivrexmziw0$erh$tivjsvq$gswx3firijmx
erep}wmw2$Ew$e$wxevxmrk$tsmrx$xli$higmwmsr$qeoivw$qywx$yrhivwxerh$xli$gsrgitx$sj$vmwo0$vmwo1fewih
tvskveq$qsxmzexmsr0$vmwo$qixlshspsk}0$erh$tvsnigx$qerekiqirx$mwwyiw2
Jmk2$525> Vmwo1Mrjsvqih0$Tivjsvqergi1Fewih$Jmvi$Tvsxigxmsr$Wxitw
APPRAISAL ANALYSIS PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT
52525$Vmwo$Hijmrih
Mr$vmwo1fewih$higmwmsr$qeomrk0$VMWO$mw$yrhivwxssh$mr$xivqw$sj$xli$pmoipmlssh$erh$gsrwiuyirgiw
sj$mrgmhirxw$xlex$gsyph$i|tswi$tistpi0$tvstivx}0$erh$xli$irzmvsrqirx$xs$xli$levqjyp$ijjigxw$sj$jmvi
sv$i|tpswmsr$le~evhw2$Pmoipmlssh$mw$hixivqmrih$mr$xivqw$sj$imxliv$jviuyirg}$,ls{$sjxir$ger$xlmw
lettir-$sv$tvsfefmpmx}$,{lex$evi$xli$glergiw$xlmw${mpp$lettir-2
VMWO$A$Pmoipmlssh$sj$er$Izirx$,J-$|$I|tigxih$Gsrwiuyirgiw$,G-
Jmvi$erh$i|tpswmsr$vmwo$erep}wmw$mw$ziv}$wgirevms$,Wr-$wtigmjmg2$Xli$vmwo$ewwsgmexih${mxl$qypxmtpi
mrmxmexmrk$izirx$wgirevmsw$mw$xli$wyq$sj$xli$wgirevmsw>
VMWO$A$%Wr$J$|$G
Xli$gsrgitx$sj$VMWO$mw$wsqixmqiw$hmjjmgypx$xs$kvewt$ex$jmvwx$ew$qer}$tistpi$ywi$le~evh$vipexih
xivqw$erh$vmwo$xivqw$mrxivglerkiefp}${mxlsyx$vikevh$xs$xli$hmjjivirgiw$fix{iir$hijmrmxmsrw2$Xefpi
525$tvszmhiw$wsqi$fewmg$hijmrmxmsrw2
Xefpi$525> Wsqi$Hijmrmxmsrw
XIVQ HIJMRMXMSR OI]$[SVHW
Jmkyvi$526$tviwirxw$er$i|eqtpi$tmpsx$tperx$fymphmrk0${lmgl$ger$fi$ywih$xs$jyvxliv$mppywxvexi$xli
hmjjivirgi$fix{iir$le~evh$erh$vmwo$vipexih$xivqw2
$$$VMWO1MRJSVQIH0$TIVJSVQERGI1FEWIH$JMVI$TVSXIGXMSR 5Ò7
Jmk2$526> I|eqtpi$Tmpsx$Tperx
Gsrgivrmrk$Jmk2$526>
Le~evh> Xli$le~evh$mw$xli$jpeqqefpi$pmuymh$mr$xli$Pef$Evie$erh$tsxirxmep$jsv$e
jpeqqefpi$pmuymh$jmvi$,m2i20$tsxirxmep$jsv$levq-2
Wizivmx}> Xli$wizivmx}${syph$fi$xli$tsxirxmep$jmvi$le~evh$mrxirwmx}$zivwyw$xmqi$ew$wiir
f}$xli$xevkix0${lmgl$mw$xli$Tmpsx$Tperx$Gsrxvsp$Vssq2$Xli$mrxirwmx}$gsyph$fi
qiewyvih$mr$xivqw$sj$liex$jpy|0$xiqtivexyviw0$gsvvswmzi$erh$xs|mg$wqsoi
gsrgirxvexmsrw$zivwyw$xmqi$,m2i20$mrxirwmx}$zivwyw$xmqi$erh$hmwxergi-2
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
5Ò8 TVSKVEQ$SFNIGXMZIW$$$$
Gsrwiuyirgiw> Xli$gsrwiuyirgiw$vipexi$xli$tsxirxmep$i|tigxih$heqeki$xs$tvstivx}$,m2i20
iuymtqirx0$wxvygxyvi-0$tistpi$,m2i20$stivexsvw${ls$qywx$viqemr$mr$xli$gsrxvsp
vssq-0$fywmriww$mrxivvytxmsr0$gsqter}$mqeki0$ixg2$Jsv$i|eqtpi0$ewwyqi$xli
xevkix$evie$mrgpyhiw$xli$jspps{mrk$zepyiw>
Tvstivx}$Heqeki$erh$Fywmriww$Mrxivvytxmsr>$$$(5;$qmppmsr
Stivexsv$Zepyi$,Pmji$Wejix}$I|tswyvi->$$$$$$$$$$($$7$qmppmsr
Mj$xli$gsqfmrih$gsrwiuyirgiw${ivi$qiewyvih$mr$qsrixev}$xivqw$erh
iwxmqexih$ex$544)$psww$tsxirxmep0$xlir$jsv$xlmw$i|eqtpi0$xli$gsrwiuyirgi
{syph$fi$(64$qmppmsr2
Vmwo> Xli$vmwo$qiewyvi$mrzspziw$er$iwxmqexmsr$sj$xli$tsxirxmep$pmoipmlssh$sj$lezmrk
e$jpeqqefpi$pmuymh$jmvi$mr$xli$Pef$Evie$erh$xli$gsrwiuyirgiw2
Jsv$i|eqtpi0$mj$xli$jmvi$izirx$pmoipmlssh${ew$iwxmqexih$ex$4246$jmvi
izirxw3}iev$,ettvs|mqexip}$5$jmvi$iziv}$94$}ievw-$erh$544)$gsrwiuyirgiw
,(64$qmppmsr-0$xlir$xli$vmwo${syph$fi>
VMWO$A$Pmoipmlssh$|$Gsrwiuyirgiw
VMWO$A$4246$jmvi$izirxw3}iev$|$(64$qmppmsr$psww3tiv$izirx
Erryepm~ih$Vmwo$A$(8440444244
Yrqmxmkexih$Vmwo$Zivwyw$Qmxmkexih$Vmwo
Xli$vmwo$iuyexmsr$ywih$efszi$mw$jsv$yrqmxmkexih$vmwo2$Mx$hsiw$rsx$gsrwmhiv$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj
psww$gsrxvsp$qiewyviw$wygl$ew$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$w}wxiqw2$Qmxmkexih$vmwo$gsrwmhivw$xli$tvsfefmpmx}$sj
jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$w}wxiq$,JTW-$tivjsvqergi$wyggiww2$JTW$tivjsvqergi$mw$mrxvshygih$mrxs$xli$vmwo
iuyexmsr${mxl$xli$ywi$sj$izirx$xvii$erep}wmw$,IXE-2$IXE$mw$hmwgywwih$mr$hixemp$mr$Gletw2$70$90$;0
erh$<?$xli$tsmrx$livi$mw$xs$mrxvshygi$ls{$JTW$tivjsvqergi$mw$mrxikvexih$mrxs$xli$vmwo$iuyexmsr2
Jmkyvi$527$tvszmhiw$e$kvetlmgep$tviwirxexmsr$sj$xli$vipexmsrwlmt$fix{iir$Wsyvgi$û$Texl{e}$û
Xevkix$wgirevms$hizipstqirx$erh$xli$izirx$xvii$vmwo$qship$wxvygxyvi2
$$$VMWO1MRJSVQIH0$TIVJSVQERGI1FEWIH$JMVI$TVSXIGXMSR 5Ò9
Jmk2$527> Vipexmsrwlmt$Eqsrk$Wsyvgi$û$Texl{e}$û$Xevkix$xs$Izirx$Xvii$Erep}wmw
SOURCE(S) PATHWAY (P) TARGET (T)
MODIFIERS VULNERABILITY
Fire Incident
Fire Barriers Outcomes Consequences
Fire Detection
& Emergency Suppression
Shutdown
Fewih$sr$Jmk2$5270$xli$VMWO$iuyexmsr$jsv$hijmrih$wgirevmsw$figsqiw>
Mrmxmexmrk JTW
Jmvi$Izirx Tivjsvqergi$Wyggiww Gsrwiuyirgiw
VMWO A | |
Pmoipmlssh Tvsfefmpmx} ,G-
,J- ,TJTW-
Jmk2$528> I|eqtpi$Izirx$Xvii$Wxvygxyvi$jsv$Jmk2$526
(A) (B) (A x B)
Initiating Detection Autom atic Plant Fire Branch
Fire Barriers Branch Line Consequences Risk Level
Fire and ESS Suppression Brigade
Successful ($) ($/Year)
Occurs Successful Successful Successful I.D. Probability
0.80 $ 10,000.00 $ 510.00
1 0.051
0.95 0.75
2 0.0095 $ 20,000.00 $ 190.00
YES 0.20 0.75
0.067 3 0.0024 $ 50,000.00 $ 120.00
Fires/Year 0.25
0.25
4 0.0008 $ 10,000,000.00 $ 8,000.00
0.80
5 0.0027 $ 10,000.00 $ 27.00
Flamm able NO 0.05 0.70
Liquid Fire 6 0.00047 $ 20,000.00 $ 9.40
In Lab Area 0.20 0.60
7 0.00012 $ 50,000.00 $ 6.00
0.30
0.40
8 0.00008 $ 20,000,000.00 $ 1,600.00
0 1-3 3 - 10 10 - 20 20 - 60 Total Annualized $ 10,462.40
Time, minutes Risk ($/Year)
Note: ESS = Emergency Shutdown System
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
5Ò: TVSKVEQ$SFNIGXMZIW$$$$
Xli$i|eqtpi$izirx$xvii$mr$Jmk2$528$mrgpyhiw$xli$tivjsvqergi$wyggiww$tvsfefmpmx}$sj$xli
jspps{mrk$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$qiewyviw>
¨ Hixigxmsr$erh$iqivkirg}$wlyxhs{r$w}wxiq$,IWW-$,m2i20$wlyxhs{r$sj$jpeqqefpi$pmuymh
iuymtqirx-
¨ Eyxsqexmg$wyttviwwmsr$,mr$xli$vssq$sj$jmvi$svmkmr-
¨ Tperx$jmvi$fvmkehi$viwtsrwi
¨ Jmvi$fevvmiv$mrxikvmx}$fix{iir$xli$pef$erh$gsrxvsp$vssq
Xli$qmxmkexih$xsxep$erryepm~ih$vmwo$jsv$xlmw$i|eqtpi$mw$e$pmxxpi$sziv$(5404440${lmgl$mw$e
wmkrmjmgerx$hmjjivirgi$xs$xli$tvizmsyw$yrqmxmkexih$erryepm~ih$vmwo$iwxmqexi$sj$(84404442
Xli$mrxirx$sj$xlmw$hmwgywwmsr${ew$xs$tvszmhi$e$fvmij$mrxvshygxmsr$xs$wsqi$gsrgitxw$erh
hijmrmxmsrw${mxl$e$jsgyw$sr$xli$hmjjivirgiw$fix{iir$xli$xivqw$le~evh0$gsrwiuyirgiw0$yrqmxmkexih
vmwo0$erh$qmxmkexih$vmwo$iwxmqexiw2$Xliwi$gsrgitxw$evi$i|tpemrih$mr$hixemp$xlvsyklsyx$xlmw$fsso2$Xli
gsrgitx$sj$Wsyvgi$û$Texl{e}$û$Xevkix$wgirevms$hizipstqirx$erh$izirx$xvii$wxvygxyvmrk$mw
hmwgywwih$mr$qsvi$hixemp$mr$Glet2$72$Xli$hizipstqirx$sj$izirx$pmoipmlssh$iwxmqexiw0$gsrwiuyirgi
pizipw0$erh$JTW$tivjsvqergi$wyggiww$tvsfefmpmxmiw$evi$ehhviwwih$mr$Gletw2$80$90$erh$:2$Vmwo
iwxmqexmsr$erh$tviwirxexmsr$evi$hiwgvmfih$mr$Glet2$;0$erh$gswx3firijmx$erep}wmw$sj$vmwo$vihygxmsr
epxivrexmziw$mw$hiwgvmfih$mr$Glet2$<2
526 VMWO1FEWIH$HIGMWMSR$QEOMRK
Vmwo1fewih$tvskveqw$ger$ewwmwx$higmwmsr$qeoivw$f}$tvszmhmrk$e$wxvygxyvih0$gsrwmwxirx$qixlsh$xs
uyerxmj}$vmwo$erh$vmwo$vihygxmsr$epxivrexmziw2$Uyerxmxexmzi$vmwo1fewih$ettvsegliw$tvszmhi$qer}
ehzerxekiw2$Xli$jspps{mrk$uysxi$mw$i|xvegxih$jvsq$vijivirgi$_5a$,yrhivpmri$ehhih$jsv$iqtlewmw-2
$$$$$ÔUyerxmxexmzi$vmwo$erep}wmw$ywiw$qiewyvih$sv$iwxmqexih$tvsfefmpmxmiw$erh
gsrwiuyirgiw2$Epxlsykl${i$gsrgihi$xlex$qszmrk$jvsq$uyepmxexmzi$xs$uyerxmxexmzi
vmwo$erep}wmw$qypxmtpmiw$xli$gswx0$mx$i|tsrirxmepp}$mrgviewiw$xli$firijmx2$Mr$ehhmxmsrxs
xli$firijmxw$xlex$vmwo1fewih$qixlshw$tvszmhi$ex$xli$uyepmxexmzi$pizip0$uyerxmxexmzi
qixlshw$gepgypexi$i|tigxih$zepyiw$jsv$tvsfefmpmx}$erh$gsrwiuyirgi2$Mj$xli
gsrwiuyirgi$mw$qiewyvih$mr$qsrixev}$xivqw0$xlir$xli$erep}wx$ger$gepgypexi$e
tvsfefpi$rix$tviwirx$zepyi$,RTZ-$hmjjivirgi$fix{iir$i|mwxmrk$gsrhmxmsrw$erh$jsv
er}$tvstswih$glerki2$Mr$epp$gepgypexmsrw$xli$erep}wx${mpp$rexyvepp}$hizipst
i|tigxih$zepyiw$erh$ÔwtviehÕ$jsv$epp$sj$xli$mqtsvxerx$teveqixivw2$Mr$sxliv${svhw0
jypp}$uyerxmxexmzi$vmwo1fewih$qixlshw$fvmhki$xli$ket$fix{iir$irkmriivmrk$erh
jmrergi2$Xlmw$mw$figeywi$i|tigxih$zepyi0$hijmrih$f}$tvsfefmpmx}$xmqiw$gsrwiuyirgi0
mw$e$xivq$xlex$mw$epvieh}$ywih$mr$xli$jmrergmep$gsqqyrmx}2Õ
Higmwmsr$qeomrk$jegxsvw$sv$higmwmsr$glevegxivmwxmgw$xlex$tvsqsxi$xli$ywi$sj$e$jsvqep0$wxvygxyvih0
vmwo1fewih$ettvsegl$mrgpyhi$xli$jspps{mrk>
¨ Higmwmsrw$mrzspzi$wmkrmjmgerx$jmrergmep$mqtegxw2
¨ Higmwmsr$qeoiv$lew$qer}$epxivrexmziw0$fsxl$xiglrmgep$erh$jmrergmep0$jvsq${lmgl$xs
glsswi2
$$$VMWO1MRJSVQIH0$TIVJSVQERGI1FEWIH$JMVI$TVSXIGXMSR 5Ò;
¨ Higmwmsrw$ejjigx$sxliv$gsqter}${mhi$sv$gsvtsvexi${mhi$jegmpmxmiw$erh$stivexmsrw2
¨ Higmwmsrw$mrzspzi$yrgivxemr$gsrwiuyirgiw${mxl$qypxmtpi$hmqirwmsrw$sj$zepyi2
Xli$vmwo1fewih$higmwmsr$qeomrk$jveqi{svo$kirivepp}$gsrwmwxw$sj$wm|$higmwmsr$wyttsvx$qshypiw0
ew$mppywxvexih$mr$Jmk2$529>
¨ Jmvi$erh$i|tpswmsr$uyerxmxexmzi$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$,UVE-$mrtyx
¨ Vmwo$vihygxmsr$epxivrexmziw
¨ Vmwo$xspivergi$gvmxivme
¨ Vmwo$jmrergmrk$stxmsrw
¨ Egxmsr$tperw
¨ Egxmsr$tper$tivjsvqergi$jiihfego
Jmk2$529> Kirivep$Vmwo1Fewih$Higmwmsr$Qeomrk$Jveqi{svo$
R is k -B a se d D e c isio n M a k in g
Fram ew ork
Q U A N T IT AT IV E A C T IO N S
D E C IS I O N S
IN P U T
F IR E & E X P L O S IO N
R IS K A S S E S S M E N T R IS K T O L E R A N C E
C R IT E R I A
D E C IS IO N
A C TIO N
M A K IN G
TEAM PLA N
R IS K R E D U C T IO N
A LT E R N AT IV E S
R ISK FIN A N C IN G
O P T IO N S
A c tio n P la n P e r fo r m a n c e F ee d b a c k
Ex$xli$girxiv$sj$xlmw$jveqi{svo$mw$xli$higmwmsr$qeomrk$xieq${lswi$qiqfivw$qywx$viegl$e
higmwmsr$f}$gsrwirwyw2$Higmwmsrw$vieglih$f}$er}$qixlsh$sxliv$xler$qerekiqirx$gsrwirwyw$qe}
viwypx$mr$pego$sj$gsqqmxqirx$erh$wyttsvx2
Gsrwirwyw$qierw$xli$qensvmx}$sj$xli$xieq$eggitxw$erh$wyttsvxw$xli$higmwmsr2$Gsrwirwyw
viuymviw$er$yrhivwxerhmrk$sj$xli$vmwo1fewih$higmwmsr$qeomrk$tvsgiww0$xli$sfnigxmziw0$qixlshspsk}0
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
5Ò< TVSKVEQ$SFNIGXMZIW$$$$
yrgivxemrxmiw0$erh$epp$tswwmfpi$epxivrexmziw2$Srgi$yrhivwxerhmrk$mw$kemrih0$xli$xieq$ger$tvsgiih
{mxl$xli$tvsgiww$sj$evvmzmrk$ex$higmwmsr$gsrwirwyw2
Kirivep$firijmxw$sj$vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$higmwmsr$qeomrk$ew$ettpmih$xs$jmvi$erh
i|tpswmsr$i|tswyvi$mrgpyhi>
¨ Efmpmx}$xs$wyttsvx$xli$gswx1ijjigxmzi$wspyxmsr$sj$gsqtpi|$jmvi$erh$i|tpswmsr$tvsfpiqw
¨ Efmpmx}$xs$izepyexi$wizivep$hmjjivirx$vmwo$vihygxmsr$wxvexikmiw$sfnigxmzip}
¨ Kviexp}$jegmpmxexih$gsqqyrmgexmsr$eqsrk$qerekivw
¨ Mrgviewih$qerekiqirx$gsrxvsp$sziv$vmwo$vihygxmsr$wxvexikmiw$erh$i|tirhmxyviw
¨ Qsvi$gsrwmwxirx$erh$sfnigxmzi$higmwmsrw$xler$xlswi$qehi$mrxymxmzip}$erh$wyfnigxmzip}
¨ Efmpmx}$xs$ewwmwx$mr$iwxefpmwlmrk$xli$stxmqyq$fepergi$fix{iir$jmvi$tvizirxmsr0
tvsxigxmsr0$erh$iqivkirg}$viwtsrwi$fewih$sr$gswx3firijmx$erep}wmw
Vmwo1fewih$erep}wmw$erh$higmwmsr$qeomrk$mw${mhip}$ywih$f}$qer}$ekirgmiw$sj$xli$Y2W2
kszivrqirx0$$xli$gliqmgep$tvsgiww$mrhywxv}0$xli$xipigsqqyrmgexmsrw$mrhywxv}0$xli$ezmexmsr
mrhywxv}0$xli$rygpiev$mrhywxv}0$erh$sxlivw2$Xli$ettpmgexmsr$sj$jmvi$erh$i|tpswmsr$vmwo$erh
tivjsvqergi1fewih$higmwmsr$erep}wmw${mpp$givxemrp}$gsrxmryi$xs$kemr${mhiwtvieh$eggitxergi$mr$xli
jyxyvi$ew$er$epxivrexmzi$xs$tviwgvmtxmzi$fymphmrk$erh$jmvi$gshiw2
$$$VMWO1MRJSVQIH0$TIVJSVQERGI1FEWIH$JMVI$TVSXIGXMSR 5Ò=
527 QIXLSHSPSK]$ERH$WXITW
Vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$mw$e$vmwo1fewih$higmwmsr$qeomrk$qixlshspsk}
erh$xlivijsvi$qywx$jspps{$e$higmwmsr$erep}wmw$erh$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$jveqi{svo2$Xlivi$evi$ryqivsyw
fssow$erh$evxmgpiw$sr$higmwmsr$erep}wmw$xlex$kirivepp}$gsrzi}$xli$wxitw$tviwirxih$mr$Jmk2$52:2
Jmk2$52:> Kirivep$Higmwmsr$Erep}wmw$Wxitw
Formulate the
Problem
Risk Appraisal
Construct the
Model Logic
Quantify the
Model Elements Risk Analysis
Interpret the
Results
Analyze the
Options
Risk Assessment
Select the
Best Solution
Vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$higmwmsr$erep}wmw$mrzspziw$higsqtswmxmsr$sj$xli$ipiqirxw$sj
jmvi$erh$i|tpswmsr$vmwo$erh$JTW$tivjsvqergi$xs$epps{$hixempih$wxyh}$sj$xlswi$ipiqirxw2$Xlmw
ettvsegl$jsvgiw$xli$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$xieq$xs$fvieo$hs{r$xli$tvsfpiq$mr$e$wxvygxyvih0$gsrwmwxirx
Ôwxit1ettvseglÕ$qerriv2
Xli$wxitw$hiwgvmfih$mr$xlmw$fsso$evi$texxivrih$ejxiv$xli$UVE$wxitw$hizipstih$f}$xli$Girxiv$jsv
Gliqmgep$Tvsgiww$Wejix}$,GGTW-0$Eqivmger$Mrwxmxyxi$sj$Gliqmgep$Irkmriivw$,EMGlI-0$erh
hiwgvmfih$mr$xlimv$fsso0$Kymhipmriw$jsv$Gliqmgep$Tvsgiww$Uyerxmxexmzi$Vmwo$Erep}wmw26$Xlmw
ettvsegl$lew$fiir$eggitxih$erh$ehstxih$f}$Y2W2$gliqmgep0$smp0$erh$kew$mrhywxvmiw$tivjsvqmrk
UVE$tvsnigxw$erh$mw$rs{$fimrk$ywih$mr$ryqivsyw$sxliv$ettpmgexmsrw2$Xliwi$wxitw$evi$tviwirxih$mr
Jmk2$52;$erh$gsrwmwx$sj$xli$jspps{mrk>
¨ Jsvqypexmsr>$Hijmri$ksepw0$iwxefpmwl$wgsti0$hiwgvmfi$w}wxiq$erh$ewwiqfpi$fegokvsyrh
mrjsvqexmsr2
¨ Le~evh$Mhirxmjmgexmsr>$Mhirxmj}$le~evhw$erh$tsxirxmep$mrgmhirxw$erh$wipigx$xlswi$xs$fi
gsrwmhivih$mr$xli$wxyh}2
¨ Gsrwiuyirgi$Iwxmqexmsr>$Iwxmqexi$gsrwiuyirgiw$sj$mrgmhirxw$gsrwmhivih$mr$xli$wxyh}0
mrgpyhmrk$fsxl$xli$tl}wmgep$ijjigxw$erh$xli$mqtegx$sj$xlswi$tl}wmgep$ijjigxw$sr$tistpi0
tvstivx}0$erh$irzmvsrqirx2
¨ Pmoipmlssh$Iwxmqexmsr>$Iwxmqexi$xli$pmoipmlssh$sj$xli$mrgmhirxw$gsrwmhivih$mr$xli$wxyh}2
¨ Vmwo$Iwxmqexmsr>$Gsqfmri$xli$iwxmqexiw$sj$gsrwiuyirgiw$erh$pmoipmlssh$mrxs
ettvstvmexi$qiewyviw$sj$vmwo2
¨ Vmwo$Qshmjmgexmsr>$Mj$xli$vmwow$evi$xss$lmkl0$qshmj}$xli$w}wxiq$xs$vihygi$xli$vmwo
Vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$mw$er$mrxikvexmsr$sj$higmwmsr$erep}wmw$erh
UVE${mxl$e$hijmrih$wxit$jsv$uyerxmj}mrk$JTW$tivjsvqergi$wyggiww2$Xli$wxitw$mr$Jmk2$52:$,Higmwmsr
Erep}wmw-$erh$Jmk2$52;$,Gliqmgep$Tvsgiww$Uyerxmxexmzi$Vmwo$Erep}wmw-$ger$fi$kvsytih$yrhiv$xli
jspps{mrk$liehmrkw>
¨ Vmwo$Ettvemwep
¨ Vmwo$Erep}wmw
¨ Vmwo$Ewwiwwqirx
Xlmw$kvsytmrk0$epsrk${mxl$xli$ehhmxmsr$sj$JTW$tivjsvqergi0$jsvqw$xli$jveqi{svo$jsv$xli$vmwo1
mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$wxitw$ew$hiwgvmfih$mr$xlmw$fsso2
$$$VMWO1MRJSVQIH0$TIVJSVQERGI1FEWIH$JMVI$TVSXIGXMSR 5Ò55
Jmk2$52;> Gliqmgep$Tvsgiww$Uyerxmxexmzi$Vmwo$Erep}wmw$,GTUVE-$Wxitw
Eqivmger$Mrwxmxyxi$sj$Gliqmgep$Irkmriivw$,EMGlI-2$Girxiv$jsv$Gliqmgep$Tvsgiww$Wejix}$,GGTW-0$Kymhipmriw$jsv$Gliqmgep$Tvsgiww$Uyerxmxexmzi
Vmwo$Erep}wmw0$Ri{$]svo0$R]0$5=<=2$Gst}vmklx$5=<=$f}$xli$Eqivmger$Mrwxmxyxi$sj$Gliqmgep$Irkmriivw0$erh$vitvshygih$f}$tivqmwwmsr$sj$EMGlI2
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
5Ò56 TVSKVEQ$SFNIGXMZIW$$$$
52725$Vmwo1Mrjsvqih0$Tivjsvqergi1Fewih$Jmvi$Tvsxigxmsr$Wxitw
Jmkyvi$52<$tviwirxw$xli$vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$wxitw$hiwgvmfih$mr$xlmw
fsso2$Xli$jmkyvi$mw$jspps{ih$f}$e$wlsvx$wyqqev}$sj$iegl$wxit>
ETTVEMWEP
52 Tvskveq$Sfnigxmziw
62 Vmwo$Xspivergi$Gvmxivme
EREP]WMW
72 Psww$Wgirevms$Hizipstqirx
82 Mrmxmexmrk$Izirx$Pmoipmlssh
92 I|tswyvi$Tvsjmpi$Qshipmrk
TIVJSVQERGI
:2 JTW$Tivjsvqergi$Wyggiww$Tvsfefmpmx}
EWWIWWQIRX
;2 Vmwo$Iwxmqexmsr$erh$Gsqtevmwsr$[mxl$Vmwo$Xspivergi
<2 Gswx3Firijmx$Erep}wmw$sj$Vmwo$Vihygxmsr$Epxivrexmziw
Jmk2$52<> Vmwo1Mrjsvqih0$Tivjsvqergi1Fewih$Jmvi$Tvsxigxmsr$Wxitw
A P PR A ISA L A N A LY SIS PER FO R M A N C E A SSE SSM E N T
52$$Tvskveq
$$$$$Sfnigxmziw
Vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$tvskveq$sfnigxmziw$mrzspzi>
¨ Iwxefpmwlmrk$e$vmwo1fewih$higmwmsr$qeomrk$jveqi{svo$erh$xieq$gsrgitx
¨ Ettp}mrk$e$wxvygxyvih0$gsrwmwxirx$qixlshspsk}$xs$uyerxmj}$vmwo$erh$tivjsvq$vmwo
vihygxmsr$gswx3firijmx$erep}wmw
¨ Mqtpiqirxmrk$er$ijjigxmzi$tvsnigx$qerekiqirx$tper
$$$VMWO1MRJSVQIH0$TIVJSVQERGI1FEWIH$JMVI$TVSXIGXMSR 5Ò57
62$$Vmwo
$$$$$Xspivergi$Gvmxivme
Vmwo$xspivergi$gvmxivme$tvszmhiw$e$uyerxmxexmzi$fewmw$ekemrwx${lmgl$vmwo$erep}wmw$viwypxw$erh$vmwo
vihygxmsr$ijjsvxw$evi$qiewyvih2$Xlmw$wxit$tvszmhiw$xli$qixlshspsk}$jsv$iwxefpmwlmrk$jmvi$erh
i|tpswmsr$vmwo$xspivergi$gvmxivme$erh$kvetlmgep$tviwirxexmsr2
Xli$vmwo$xspivergi$gvmxivme$hizipstqirx$tvsgiww$mrzspziw$xli$jspps{mrk>
¨ Qywx$fi$wtigmjmg$xs$xli$hijmrih$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$tvsnigx$fsyrhevmiw
¨ Qywx$iwxefpmwl$qiewyvefpi$uyerxmxexmzi$kymhi$zepyiw$jsv$vmwo$gsqtevmwsr
¨ Qywx$tvszmhi$mrtyx$jsv$izepyexmrk$JTW$tivjsvqergi$wyggiww
Vmwo$xspivergi$gvmxivme$mw$e$h}reqmg$qiewyvi$vipexih$xs$e$gsqter}×w$glerkmrk$fywmriww
sfnigxmziw$erh$jsgyw$erh$ger$fi$i|tviwwih$mr$e$zevmix}$sj${e}w2$Mr$Glet2$60$xli$jspps{mrk$x{s
qixlshw$evi$ehhviwwih${mxl$i|eqtpiw>
¨ Xsxep$erryepm~ih$jmrergmep$mqtegx$vmwo$xspivergi
¨ Pmoipmlssh$sj$i|giihmrk$e$hijmrih$i|tswyvi$pizip
72$$Psww$Wgirevms
$$$$$Hizipstqirx
E$psww$wgirevms$vitviwirxw$xli$wiuyirgi$sj$izirxw$xlex$ger$viwypx$mr$yrhiwmvefpi$jmvi$sv$i|tpswmsr
mrgmhirxw$erh$gsrwiuyirgiw2$Xli$wgirevms$hizipstqirx$tvsgiww$qywx$fi>
¨ Wiuyirxmepp}$wxvygxyvih$mr$e$xmqi1vipexih$qerriv
¨ Gvihmfpi$mr$xivqw$sj$viepmwxmg$mrgmhirx$syxgsqiw
¨ Gsrxemr$wyjjmgmirx$mrjsvqexmsr$xs$epps{$xli$vmwo$erep}wmw$xieq$xli$efmpmx}$xs$uyerxmj}
xli$wgirevms
Gsqtvilirwmzi$wgirevms$erep}wmw$mw$sri$sj$xli$qswx$mqtsvxerx$ewtigxw$sj$gsrhygxmrk$gvihmfpi
vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$tvsnigxw2$E$gsqtvilirwmzi$ettvsegl$mrzspziw>
¨ Ettp}mrk$e$gsrwmwxirx$jveqi{svo$erh$w}wxiqexmg$qixlshspsk}
¨ Mhirxmj}mrk$gsrxvmfyxmrk$jegxsvw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$jmvi$erh$i|tpswmsr$mrmxmexmrk$izirxw
¨ Izepyexmrk$xli$i|tswyvi$zivwyw$xmqi$tvsjmpi$jspps{mrk$xli$mrmxmexmrk$izirx2$I|tswyvi
ipiqirxw$mrgpyhi$jmvi$kvs{xl0$tvstekexmsr0$mrgmhirx$syxgsqiw0$erh$tsxirxmep
gsrwiuyirgi$pizipw
Wxit$7$mrxvshygiw$xli$hizipstqirx$sj$e$wgirevms1fewih$jveqi{svo${mxl$xli$jsgyw$fimrk$izirx
xvii$erep}wmw$,IXE-$ywmrk$xli$gsrgitx$sj$Wsyvgi$û$Texl{e}$û$Xevkix2$IXE$gsrzi}w$mrmxmexmrk
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
5Ò58 TVSKVEQ$SFNIGXMZIW$$$$
izirxw0$JTW$tivjsvqergi0$mrgmhirx$syxgsqiw0$erh$gsrwiuyirgiw2$Gletxiv$7$tvszmhiw$i|eqtpiw$sj
wgirevms$hizipstqirx$erh$izirx$xvii$wxvygxyvmrk2
82$$Mrmxmexmrk$Izirx
$$$$$Pmoipmlssh
Xli$xivq$ÔpmoipmlsshÕ$mw$hijmrih$ew$e$qiewyvi$sj$xli$i|tigxih$jviuyirg}$sv$tvsfefmpmx}$sj$e
hijmrih$mrmxmexmrk$jmvi$sv$i|tpswmsr$izirx2$Xli$qshipmrk$qixlshw$mr$Wxit$8$ywih$xs$uyerxmj}$xli
mrmxmexmrk$izirx$pmoipmlsshw$mrgpyhi$xli$ywi$sj>
¨ Lmwxsvmgep$hexe${livi$xlivi$mw$i|tivmirgi$jvsq$tewx$jmvi$psww$mrgmhirxw$,m2i20$tperx
wtigmjmg$hexe-$sv$jvsq$wmqmpev$w}wxiqw$,m2i20$mrhywxv}$wtigmjmg$sv$kirivmg$hexefewiw-
¨ Qshipmrk$xiglrmuyiw$wygl$ew$jeypx$xvii$erep}wmw$,JXE-0${lmgl$mw$ywih$xs$iwxmqexi$xli
pmoipmlssh$sj$izirxw${livi$lmwxsvmgep$hexe$mw$pmqmxih$sv$mw$mrehiuyexi$xs$eggyvexip}
iwxmqexi$xli$pmoipmlssh$sj$xli$jmvi$izirxw$sj$gsrgivr
¨ Irkmriivmrk$nyhkqirx$xlex$uyerxmjmiw$er$i|tivx×w$wxexi$sj$ors{pihki$sv$tivgitxmsrw
sj$xli$pmoipmlssh$sj$tsxirxmep$jmvi$sv$i|tpswmsr$mrgmhirxw2$Xlmw$ors{pihki$qe}$fi
fewih$sr$lmwxsvmgep$hexe0$mrwmklxw$kemrih$jvsq$tvizmsyw$le~evh$sv$vmwo$erep}wmw
tvsnigxw0$i|tivmirgi0$tperx$wtigmjmg$mrjsvqexmsr0$sv$e$gsqfmrexmsr$sj$xliwi$jegxsvw
JXE$tvszmhiw$e$wxvygxyvih$qixlsh$xs$uyerxmj}$mrmxmexmrk$jmvi$sggyvvirgi$izirxw2$Xli$firijmx$sj
JXE$mw$xlex$mx$tvszmhiw$e$higsqtswmxmsr$sj$xli$xst$mrmxmexmrk$izirx$mrxs$jegxsvw$xlex$gsrxvmfyxi$xs
jempyvi$erh$mkrmxmsr$tsxirxmepw2$Xli$jviuyirgmiw$erh$tvsfefmpmxmiw$ywih$mr$xli$JXE$ger$mrgpyhi$e
gsqfmrexmsr$sj$iuymtqirx$erh$lyqer$jempyvi$vexi$hexe0$tperx$wtigmjmg$hexe0$tvsfefmpmxmiw$wyttsvxih
f}$hixivqmrmwxmg$qshipmrk0$erh$wyfnigxmzi0$i|tivx$stmrmsr$tvsfefmpmxmiw2
Jempyvi$hexe$wsyvgiw0$i|eqtpiw0$qixlshw$jsv$qshmj}mrk$hexe$ywmrk$tivjsvqergi$mrxikvmx}
qiewyviw$,TMQw-$evi$hiwgvmfih$mr$Glet2$82$Er$irxmvi$wigxmsr$mw$hizsxih$xs$mkrmxmsr$tvsfefmpmx}
qshipmrk2
92$$I|tswyvi$Tvsjmpi
$$$$$Qshipmrk
Er$i|tswyvi$tvsjmpi$mw$e$wgirevms1wtigmjmg0$kvetlmgep$vitviwirxexmsr$sj${lex$xli$vmwo$xevkix$mw
wyfnigx$xs$mr$xivqw$sj$wsyvgi$mrxirwmx}$,i2k20$liex0$xiqtivexyvi0$wqsoi0$xs|mg0$sv$gsvvswmzi$kew
gsrgirxvexmsrw0$i|tpswmsr$szivtviwwyviw0$ixg2-$zivwyw$xmqi2$Xli$qshipmrk$ettvsegl$mr$Wxit$9
mrzspziw$xli$jspps{mrk>
¨ Hixivqmri$xli$vmwo$xevkix$zepyi$erh$zyprivefmpmx}2$Zyprivefmpmx}$mw$hijmrih$mr$xivqw
sj$xlviwlsph$heqeki$pmqmxw$,XHPw-2$XHPw$evi$tsxirxmep$jempyvi$pmqmxw$sj$xli$xevkix
$$$VMWO1MRJSVQIH0$TIVJSVQERGI1FEWIH$JMVI$TVSXIGXMSR 5Ò59
wyfw}wxiqw$,i2k20$iuymtqirx0$stivexsvw0$wxvygxyvi-${lir$i|tswih$xs$jmvi$sv$i|tpswmsr
mqtegxw2
¨ Glevegxivm~i$xli$wsyvgi$jmvi$liex$vipiewi$vexi$,LVV-2$Hizipstmrk$erh$uyerxmj}mrk
xli$mrmxmexmrk$wsyvgi$LVV$mr$e$gvihmfpi$qerriv$mw$e$oi}$gsrwmhivexmsr$mr$xli$mrmxmep
hizipstqirx$sj$xli$i|tswyvi$tvsjmpi2$Xli$LVV$mw$ywih$xs$iwxmqexi$jpeqi$limklx0
vehmerx$liex$jpy|0$erh$jmvi$tpyqi$wm~i$erh$mrxirwmx}0$epp$sj${lmgl$ejjigx$xli$i|tswyvi
ex$xli$xevkix2
¨ Qship$xli$izirx$xvii$wgirevms$jmvi$sv$i|tpswmsr$mrgmhirx$syxgsqi2$Tssp$jmviw0$xsvgl
jmviw0$yrgsrjmrih$wtmpp$jmviw0$jpewl$jmviw0$fsmpmrk$pmuymh$i|terhmrk$zetsv$i|tpswmsr
,FPIZI-$jmvifeppw0$wspmh$qexivmepw0$erh$wxsveki$gsrjmkyvexmsrw$ger$fi$qshipih$xs
izepyexi$vehmerx$liex$jpy|0$xiqtivexyviw0$erh$wqsoi$gsrgirxvexmsr$mrxirwmxmiw$ex$xli
xevkix2$Yrgsrjmrih$zetsv$gpsyh$i|tpswmsrw$erh$gsrjmrih$i|tpswmsrw$ger$fi$qshipih
xs$izepyexi$tsxirxmep$i|tpswmsr$szivtviwwyviw$ex$xli$xevkix2
¨ Hizipst$JTW$viwtsrwi$teveqixivw2$Fewih$sr$xli$i|tswyvi$tvsjmpi0$viwtsrwi$xmqiw
jsv$hixigxmsr$w}wxiqw0$iqivkirg}$wlyxhs{r$w}wxiqw$,IWWw-0$erh$eyxsqexmg$erh
qeryep$wyttviwwmsr$w}wxiqw$ger$fi$iwxefpmwlih$erh$wls{r$mr$xli$izirx$xvii$xmqi
pmri2$Xliwi$viwtsrwi$xmqiw$evi$xlir$ywih$mr$xli$JTW$tivjsvqergi$wyggiww$tvsfefmpmx}
izepyexmsr2
Xlviwlsph$heqeki$hexe0$kvetlmgep$i|tswyvi$tvsjmpi$erh$izirx$xvii$xmqi$pmri$i|eqtpiw0$erh$jmvi
erh$i|tpswmsr$gsqtyxiv$qshipmrk$evi$hmwgywwih$mr$Glet2$92
:2$$Jmvi$Tvsxigxmsr$W}wxiq
$$$$$,JTW-$Tivjsvqergi
$$$$$Wyggiww$Tvsfefmpmx}
JTW$tivjsvqergi$vitviwirxw$sri$sj$xli$hsqmrerx$jegxsvw$mr$xli$iwxmqexmsr$sj$tsxirxmep$vmwo
pizipw2$Wxit$:$mrgpyhiw$qixlshw$xs$uyerxmj}$xli$gsrhmxmsrep$tvsfefmpmx}$sj$tivjsvqergi$wyggiww$jsv$e
hijmrih$izirx$wgirevms$erh$iwxefpmwlih$vmwo$xspivergi$gvmxivme2$JTW$sj$tvmqev}$mrxiviwx$mr$jmvi$vmwo1
fewih$izepyexmsrw$mrgpyhi$xli$jspps{mrk>
¨ Hixigxmsr$w}wxiqw
¨ Iqivkirg}$gsrxvsp$w}wxiqw
¨ Eyxsqexmg$wyttviwwmsr$w}wxiqw
¨ Tvstekexmsr$pmqmxmrk$qiewyviw$,m2i20$jmvi$fevvmivw-
¨ Qeryep$psww$gsrxvsp$mrxivzirxmsr
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
5Ò5: TVSKVEQ$SFNIGXMZIW$$$$
Xli$qixlshspsk}$mr$Wxit$:0${lmgl$girxivw$evsyrh$wyggiww$xvii$erep}wmw$,WXE-$pskmg0$ger$fi$ywih
xlvsyklsyx$xli$pmji$g}gpi$sj$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$w}wxiqw$xs$izepyexi$erh$uyerxmj}$tivjsvqergi$wyggiww2
Xlmw$ettvsegl$ger$fi$ettpmih$xs>
¨ Izepyexmsr$sj$I|mwxmrk$W}wxiqw
Xlmw$uyerxmjmiw$i|tigxih$tivjsvqergi$wyggiww$sj$i|mwxmrk$JTW${lir$wyfnigxih$xs
wtigmjmg$wgirevmsw$erh$vmwo$xspivergi$gvmxivme2
¨ Izepyexmsr$sj$Ri{$W}wxiq$Hiwmkrw$sv$Qshmjmgexmsrw
Xlmw$uyerxmjmiw$i|tigxih$tivjsvqergi$wyggiww$sj$hiwmkr$stxmsrw$sv$epxivrexmziw$xs
qiix$wgirevms1fewih$ÔTivjsvqergi$Hiwmkr$Xevkixw2Õ$Jsv$i|eqtpi0$mj$xli$xevkixih
tivjsvqergi$wyggiww$tvsfefmpmx}$jsv$e$wtigmjmg$wgirevms$mw$42==$,m2i20$==$syx$sj$544
xmqiw$mx${mpp$fi$wyggiwwjyp$ekemrwx$xlmw$wgirevms-0$xlir$hiwmkr$epxivrexmziw$evi
izepyexih$mr$xivqw$sj$viwtsrwi$ijjigxmziriww0$tvsnigxih$sr1pmri$ezempefmpmx}0$erh
iwxmqexih$stivexmsrep$vipmefmpmx}$xs$qiix$xlmw$tivjsvqergi$xevkix2
Wxit$:$mrzspziw$xli$uyerxmjmgexmsr$sj$tivjsvqergi$ywmrk$xlvii$tvsfefmpmwxmg$qiewyviw>
¨ Viwtsrwi$ijjigxmziriww
¨ Sr1pmri$ezempefmpmx}
¨ Stivexmsrep$vipmefmpmx}
Tivjsvqergi$uyerxmjmgexmsr$qixlshw$erh$i|eqtpiw0$jempyvi$vexi$hexe$wsyvgiw0$hexe$qshmjmgexmsr
zme$xli$ywi$sj$tivjsvqergi$mrxikvmx}$qiewyviw0$erh$mrxikvexmsr$sj$irkmriivmrk$nyhkiqirx$evi
hmwgywwih$mr$Glet2$:2
;2$$Vmwo$Iwxmqexmsr
$$$$$*$Gsqtevmwsr
$$$$$[mxl$Vmwo$Xspivergi
Vmwo$iwxmqexmsr$erh$gsqtevmwsr$tvszmhiw$xli$qixlshspsk}$jsv>
¨ Iwxmqexmrk$gsrwiuyirgi$pizipw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$hijmrih$izirx$xvii$psww$wgirevmsw$mr
xivqw$sj$er$iuymzepirx$qsrixev}$zepyi$erh$erryepm~ih$vmwo$fewmw
¨ Gsqtevmrk$xli$iwxmqexih$vmwo$xs$vmwo$xspivergi$gvmxivme$xs$hixivqmri$mj$vmwo$vihygxmsr
erep}wmw$mw$riihih
Wxit$;$hiwgvmfiw$xli$vmwo$iwxmqexmsr$gepgypexmsr$wxitw$ywmrk$xli$IXE$qshipmrk$jveqi{svo2$Ew
tevx$sj$xli$iwxmqexmsr$tvsgiww0$xli$i|tswyvi$pizipw$hizipstih$mr$Wxit$90$I|tswyvi$Tvsjmpi$Qshipmrk0
evi$gsrzivxih$xs$iuymzepirx$qsrixev}$yrmxw2$Xlmw$tvszmhiw$e$wmrkpi$qiewyvi$sj$gsrwiuyirgiw0${lmgl
epps{w$vmwo$xs$fi$gepgypexih$mr$xivqw$sj$hsppevw$ex$vmwo$tiv$}iev$jvsq$jmvi$sv$i|tpswmsr$tsxirxmepw2
Ywmrk$er$iuymzepirx$qsrixev}$qiewyvi$sj$vmwo$epps{w$gswx3firijmx$erep}wmw$xs$fi$tivjsvqih$sr$vmwo
vihygxmsr$epxivrexmziw${lir$xli$higmwmsr$qeoivw×$vmwo$xspivergi$gvmxivme$evi$i|giihih2$I|eqtpiw$sj
kvetlmgep$tvsjmpiw$sj$vmwo$gsqtevmwsr$evi$tviwirxih$mr$Glet2$;0$epsrk${mxl$er$szivzmi{$erh$wlsvx
i|eqtpiw$sj$gsqtyxiv1ewwmwxih$wmqypexmsr$xs$uyerxmj}$vmwo$yrgivxemrx}2
$$$VMWO1MRJSVQIH0$TIVJSVQERGI1FEWIH$JMVI$TVSXIGXMSR 5Ò5;
Yrgivxemrx}$qywx$fi$eggsyrxih$jsv$mr$xli$gsqqyrmgexmsr$sj$vmwo$iwxmqexmsr$xs$xli$higmwmsr
qeoivw2$Yrgivxemrx}$ewwiwwqirx$mw$e$qiewyvi0$uyepmxexmzi$sv$uyerxmxexmzi0$sj$xli$hikvii$sj$hsyfx$sv
pego$sj$givxemrx}$ewwsgmexih${mxl$vmwo$iwxmqexmrk$mrtyxw0$zevmefpiw0$tvsfefmpmx}$zepyiw0$hixivqmrmwxmg
qshipw0$erh$iuymzepirx$qsrixev}$zepyiw2
E$uyerxmxexmzi$yrgivxemrx}$erep}wmw$ger$fi$tivjsvqih${mxlmr$e$gsqtyxiv$wtviehwliix$tvskveq
wygl$ew$Qmgvswsjx$I|gip$ywmrk${lex1mj$erep}wmw$sv$Qsrxi$Gevps$wmqypexmsrw2$Er$i|eqtpi$sj$ywmrk
Qsrxi$Gevps$wmqypexmsr$mw$tvszmhih$mr$Glet2$;2
<2$$Gswx3Firijmx$Erep}wmw
$$$$$sj$Vmwo$Vihygxmsr
$$$$$Epxivrexmziw
Xli$xivq$Ôvmwo$vihygxmsrÕ$mw$hijmrih$ew$xli$ettpmgexmsr$sj$xiglrspskmgep$sv$ehqmrmwxvexmzi
qiewyviw$xs$vihygi$jmvi$sv$i|tpswmsr$vmwo$xs$e$xspivefpi$pizip2$Vihygih$jmvi$vmwow$qier$ji{iv$jmvi
pswwiw$erh$gpemqw0$e$qsvi$ijjmgmirx$stivexmsr0$fixxiv$iqtps}ii$qsvepi0$lmkliv$tvsjmxw0$fixxiv$tyfpmg
vipexmsrw0$erh$kviexiv$mrziwxsv$gsrjmhirgi2$Ls{iziv0$xliwi$evi$rsx$sfxemrih${mxlsyx$gswx2$Higmwmsr
qeoivw$qywx$vigskrm~i$erh$uyerxmj}$xli$vmwow$erh$ewwiww$gswx1ijjigxmzi$ettvsegliw$jsv$vihygmrk
xliq2$Xlmw$mw$hsri$f}$gsrhygxmrk$gswx3firijmx$erep}wiw$jsv$vmwo$vihygxmsr$wxvexikmiw$erh
epxivrexmziw2
Vmwo$vihygxmsr$stxmsrw$mr$Wxit$<$mrgpyhi
¨ izirx$pmoipmlssh$vihygxmsr0
¨ jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$w}wxiq$mqtvsziqirx0$erh
¨ gsrwiuyirgi$vihygxmsr2
Xli$gswx3firijmx$erep}wmw$tvsgiww$hiwgvmfih$mr$Glet2$<$gsrwmwxw$sj
¨ uyerxmjmgexmsr$sj$vmwo$vihygxmsr$epxivrexmziw0
¨ gswx$erep}wmw$jsv$wipigxih$wxvexikmiw0
¨ veromrk$sj$wxvexikmiw$f}$vmwo$vihygxmsr3gswx$vexmsw0$erh
¨ higmwmsr$erep}wmw2
Gletxiv$<$tvszmhiw$er$i|eqtpi$sj$wgviirmrk$erh$uyerxmj}mrk$vmwo$vihygxmsr$jsv$epxivrexmzi$jmvi
tvsxigxmsr$hiwmkr$wxvexikmiw$ywmrk$e$gsqtyxiv$wtviehwliix$qship2
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
5Ò5< TVSKVEQ$SFNIGXMZIW$$$$
52726$Gsqtevmwsr${mxl$xli$WJTI$Tivjsvqergi1Fewih$Ettvsegl
Jmkyvi$52=$tviwirxw$e$wmhi1f}1wmhi$gsqtevmwsr$sj$xli$Wsgmix}$sj$Jmvi$Tvsxigxmsr$Irkmriivmrk
,WJTI-$tivjsvqergi1fewih$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$ettvsegl7$erh$xli$vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$jmvi
tvsxigxmsr$qixlsh$hiwgvmfih$mr$xlmw$fsso2
Wxitw$rsx$tviwirxp}$ehhviwwih$mr$xli$WJTI$ettvsegl$mrgpyhi
¨ hijmrmrk$vmwo$xspivergi$pizipw0
¨ izepyexmrk$izirx$pmoipmlsshw0
¨ iwxmqexmrk$erh$gsqtevmrk$vmwo0$erh
¨ gsrhygxmrk$gswx3firijmx$erep}wmw2
Jmk2$52=> Qixlsh$Gsqtevmwsr2
SF P E P E R FO R M A N C E -B A S E D R ISK -I N F O R M E D , P E R FO R M A N C E -B A SE D
F IR E P R O T E C T IO N A P PR O A C H F I R E P R O T E C T IO N M E T H O D
N ot P rese ntly D e ve loped in SF P E
P er fo r m a n ce-B ased App roach
D efin e O b jectives
D e velop L oss S cen arios
E va lu ate P erform an ce
E v alu ate C an did a te D esign s
Xli$tvmqev}$hmjjivirgiw$fix{iir$xli$WJTI$tivjsvqergi1fewih$qixlsh7$erh$xli$vmwo1mrjsvqih
tivjsvqergi1fewih$qixlsh$hiwgvmfih$mr$xlmw$fsso$evi>
¨ xli$WJTI$qixlsh$mw$tvmqevmp}$fewih$sr$e$hixivqmrmwxmg$qshipmrk$ettvsegl0$erh
¨ xli$vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$qixlsh0$ew$hiwgvmfih$mr$xlmw$fsso0$mw$fewih$sr
e$tvsfefmpmwxmg$vmwo1fewih$qshipmrk$ettvsegl2$Hixivqmrmwxmg$qshipw$,m2i20$jmvi
qshipw-$evi$ywih$mr$xlmw$qixlsh$xs$ÔwyttsvxÕ$tvsfefmpmx}$erh$vmwo$iwxmqexiw2
Jvsq$q}$i|tivmirgi$ex$mrhywxvmep$jegmpmxmiw0$higmwmsr$qeoivw${erx$xs$ors{$xli$vmwo$,pmoipmlssh
erh$gsrwiuyirgiw-0$vmwo1qshmjmgexmsr$epxivrexmziw0$erh$gswxw$ew$tevx$sj$xlimv$higmwmsr$qeomrk
$$$VMWO1MRJSVQIH0$TIVJSVQERGI1FEWIH$JMVI$TVSXIGXMSR 5Ò5=
tvsgiww0$xlyw$xli$xivq$Ôvmwo1mrjsvqih2Õ$JTW$tivjsvqergi$lew$ryqivsyw$tvsfefmpmwxmg$zevmefpiw$erh
xlivijsvi$wlsyph$fi$izepyexih$ew$e$Ôgsrhmxmsrep$tvsfefmpmx}Õ$jspps{mrk$hijmrih$jyrgxmsrep
viuymviqirxw$fewih$sr$xli$wtigmjmg$wgirevms$erh$uyerxmxexmzi$vmwo$xspivergi$gvmxivme2
Xli$jspps{mrk${ew$i|xvegxih$jvsq$xli$Nsyvrep$sj$Jmvi$Tvsxigxmsr$Irkmriivw80$er$WJTI
tyfpmgexmsr$,yrhivpmrmrk$ehhih$jsv$iqtlewmw-2
Epxlsykl$xli$ywi$sj$hixivqmrmwxmg$gepgypexmsrw$tvszmhiw$e$tmgxyvi$sj${lex$xli
gsrhmxmsrw$mr$e$vssq$qe}$fi$ex$e$kmzir$xmqi0$sv${lex$xli$tivjsvqergi$sj$mrhmzmhyep
wxvygxyvep$gsqtsrirxw$mw0$mx$lew$pmqmxih$efmpmx}$mr$gsrwmhivmrk$xli$irxmvi$fymphmrk
{mxl$mxw$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$w}wxiqw0$jyrgxmsrw$erh$sggyterxw$ew$e$w}wxiq2$Xlmw$pmqmxexmsr
mw$wmkrmjmgerx$ew$mx$hsiw$rsx$epps{$xli$uyerxmjmgexmsr$sj$xli$szivepp$wejix}$pizip$mr$e
fymphmrk2$E$gsqtevmwsr$sj$epxivrexmzi$hiwmkrw$mw$pmqmxih$srp}$xs$wtigmjmg$ipiqirxw2
Xs$sfxemr$er$szivepp$ewwiwwqirx$sj$fymphmrk0$hixivqmrmwxmg$gsqtyxexmsrw$qywx$fi
gsqfmrih${mxl$tvsfefmpmwxmg$erep}wmw2
Mr$gsrxvewx$xs$hixivqmrmwxmg$gepgypexmsrw0$tvsfefmpmwxmg$qixlshw$qe}$fi$efpi$xs
gsrwmhiv$xli${lspi$fymphmrk$,rsx$ipiqirx$f}$ipiqirx$izepyexmsr-$erh$xs$tvszmhi$vmwo
iwxmqexiw2$Mr$tvsfefmpmwxmg$izepyexmsrw0$xlivi$evi$qer}$jegxsvw$xlex$gsyph$ejjigx$xli
sggyvvirgi$sj$e$jmvi0$mxw$hizipstqirx$erh$xli$ikviww$sj$xli$sggyterxw2$Xli$sfnigxmzi
mw$xs$iwxmqexi$vmwo$pizipw$ywmrk$xli$pmoipmlssh$sj$e$jmvi$mrgmhirx$sggyvvmrk$erh$mxw
tsxirxmep$gsrwiuyirgiw$,mrnyv}0$hiexl0$ixg2-2$Xli$vmwo$gvmxivme$ger$fi$iwxefpmwlih
xlvsykl$wxexmwxmgep$hexe0$ls{iziv0$mr$svhiv$xs$kemr$wsgmix}×w$eggitxergi0$wygl$er
ettvsegl$qywx$figsqi${mhip}$ywih2$Xli$vmwo$pizipw0$gepgypexih$ywmrk$tvsfefmpmwxmg
vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$qixlshw0$evi$xlir$gsqtevih$xs$xli$vmwo$gvmxivme$xs$hixivqmri
{lixliv$xli$tvstswih$hiwmkrw$evi$eggitxefpi2$Tviwirxp}0$xli$tvsfefmpmwxmg$ettvsegl
mw$vevip}$ywih$figeywi$sj$xli$pego$sj$ettvstvmexi$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$xsspw$erh$xli
yrezempefmpmx}$sj$wtigmjmg$vmwo$pizipw$eggitxefpi$xs$wsgmix}2$Ls{iziv0${mxl$xli
mrxvshygxmsr$sj$tivjsvqergi1fewih$gshiw0$xli$ezempefmpmx}$sj$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$qshipw
erh$xli$iwxefpmwlqirx$sj$vmwo$pizipw$eggitxefpi$xs$wsgmix}0$xli$tvsfefmpmwxmg
ettvsegl${mpp$fi$xli$tvijivvih$qixlsh$mr$tivjsvqergi1fewih$hiwmkr$ew$mx$uyerxmjmiw
xli$vmwo$pizipw$erh$epps{w$xli$mhirxmjmgexmsr$sj$hiwmkrw$xlex${mpp$lezi$eggitxefpi$vmwo
pizipw$ex$qmrmqyq$gswx2
528 TVSNIGX$QEREKIQIRX$MWWYIW
Mqtpiqirxexmsr$sj$er$ijjigxmzi$vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$tvskveq
viuymviw$kssh$tvsnigx$qerekiqirx2$Hizipstqirx$erh$hipmziv}$sj$mrjsvqexmsr$mr$e$xmqip}$erh$gswx1
ijjigxmzi$qerriv$viuymviw
¨ tvsnigx$hijmrmxmsr0
¨ tvsnigx$xieq$wipigxmsr0
¨ viwsyvgi$eppsgexmsr0$erh
¨ vmwo$gsqqyrmgexmsr2
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
5Ò64 TVSKVEQ$SFNIGXMZIW$$$$
52825$Tvsnigx$Hijmrmxmsr
Xefpi$526$tvszmhiw$e$kirivep${svowliix$jsv$hijmrmrk$vmwo1mrjsvqih$tvsnigx$teveqixivw2$Mj
hsgyqirxih$tvsnigx$hijmrmxmsr$mw$rsx$tvszmhih$ex$xli$wxevx0$xli$vmwo$uyerxmjmgexmsr$tvsgiww$ger
figsqi$viwsyvgi$mrxirwmzi2
52826$Tvsnigx$Xieq$Wipigxmsr
Xli$vmwo$iwxmqexmsr$tvsgiww$qywx$mrgpyhi$e$xieq$gsrwirwyw$ettvsegl2$Xieq$qiqfivw$wlsyph
mrgpyhi$vitviwirxexmziw$jvsq$xli$tperx$ors{pihkiefpi$mr$xli$wtigmjmg$jegmpmx}$le~evhw0$stivexmsrw0
erh$qemrxirergi$tvegxmgiw?$vitviwirxexmziw$jvsq$irzmvsrqirxep0$wejix}0$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr?$erh$vmwo
qerekiqirx$erh$jmrergmep$tivwsrrip2
Getefmpmxmiw$sj$xli$tperx$gsrwirwyw$xieq$wlsyph$mrgpyhi$xli$jiexyviw$pmwxih$fips{2
¨ Ors{pihki$sj$xli$jegmpmx}0$stivexmsrw0$iuymtqirx0$erh$wejix}$jiexyviw$yrhiv
Ò rsvqep$stivexmsrw$erh
Ò efrsvqep$iqivkirg}$gsrhmxmsrw?
¨ I|tivmirgi${mxl
Ò tperx$psww$mrgmhirx$lmwxsv}0
Ò gsrxvmfyxmrk$jegxsvw$xs$psww$mrgmhirxw0$erh
Ò qshmjmgexmsrw$erh$glerkiw$qehi$jspps{mrk$pswwiw?
¨ Yrhivwxerhmrk$sj$jeypx$xvii$erep}wmw$,JXE-$erh$izirx$xvii$erep}wmw$,IXE-$qshipw
mrgpyhmrk
Ò e$xieq$piehiv${mxl$i|tivxmwi$mr$JXE$erh$IXE$erh
Ò xieq$qiqfivw${mxl$e$vyhmqirxev}$yrhivwxerhmrk$sj$JXE$erh$IXE$gsrgitxw2
$$$VMWO1MRJSVQIH0$TIVJSVQERGI1FEWIH$JMVI$TVSXIGXMSR 5Ò65
$Xefpi$526> I|eqtpi$Tvsnigx$Hijmrmxmsr$[svowliix
MWWYIW ERW[IVW
5 [lex$mw$xli$higmwmsr$xs$fi$qehiC
,Vmwo$wxyh}$ksepw-
62 [lex$mw$xli$jsgyw$sj$xli$ewwiwwqirxC
,Vmwo$wxyh}$sfnigxmziw-
72 [lex$evi$xli$w}wxiq$fsyrhevmiwC
,Wgsti$sj${svo0${lex×w$mrgpyhih0${lex×w$rsx-
82 [lex$evi$xli$zepyiw$i|tswih${mxlmr$xli$hijmrih
fsyrhevmiwC
,Tistpi0$tvstivx}0$tvshygxmsr-
92 [lex$mw$xli$vmwo$xspivergi$gvmxivmeC
,Vijiv$xs$Glet2$6$mr$xlmw$fsso-
:2 [lex$mw$xli$pizip$sj$hixempC
;2 [lex$evi$xli$qerts{iv$viwsyvgiw$viuymvihC
,Tvsnigx$xieq0$tperx$wmxi$ewwmwxergi-
<2 [lex$gsrwiuyirgi$qshipmrk$xsspw${mpp$fi
riihihC
=2 [lex$wsyvgiw$sj$jempyvi$vexi$erh$vipmefmpmx}$hexe
evi$ezempefpiC
542 [lex$sxliv$levh{evi0$wsjx{evi0$sv$sxliv$gswxw
evi$riihih$xs$gsqtpixi$xli$tvsnigxC
552 [lex$evi$xli$fyhkix$gsrwxvemrxwC
562 Ls{${mpp$xli$ÔviwypxwÕ$sj$xli$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$fi
tviwirxih$xs$qerekiqirxC
572 [lex${mpp$fi$xli$tvsgihyviw$jsv$mrxivegxmzi
xiglrmgep$uyepmx}$vizmi{w$erh$hsgyqirxexmsrC
582 [lex$evi$xli$wglihypi$erh$hipmziv}$hexiwC
VIQEVOW>
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
5Ò66 TVSKVEQ$SFNIGXMZIW$$$$
52827$Viwsyvgi$Eppsgexmsr
Viwsyvgi$eppsgexmsr$gsrwmhivexmsrw$wlsyph$mrgpyhi>
52 Pizip$sj$higmwmsr$hixemp
¨ higmwmsr$gsqtpi|mx}
¨ higmwmsr$mqtsvxergi
¨ tl}wmgep$fsyrhevmiw$sj$wxyh}
¨ eggmhirxw$sj$mrxiviwx$,sv$i|gpyhih$eggmhirxw-
¨ qixlshw$jsv$vmwo$iwxmqexmsr$erh$gsqtevmwsr
62 I|tirhmxyviw
¨ lyqer$viwsyvgiw
¨ ewwiwwqirx$xsspw
m-$$$$gsqtyxiv$qshipw
mm-$$$viwievgl
mmm-$$xiwxmrk
72 Gsrwxvemrxw
¨ xmqi
¨ fyhkix
Jmkyvi$5254$tvszmhiw$e$kirivep$mppywxvexmsr$sj$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$viwsyvgi$mrziwxqirx$pizipw2$Ew
hitmgxih$sr$Jmk2$52540$xlvii$kirivep$pizipw$sj$hixemp$evi$mrhmgexih>
$¨ Vmwo$veromrk
$¨ Jmvwx1svhiv$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx0$erh
$¨ Wigsrh1svhiv$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx
$$$VMWO1MRJSVQIH0$TIVJSVQERGI1FEWIH$JMVI$TVSXIGXMSR 5Ò67
Jmk2$5254> Kirivep$Mppywxvexmsr$sj$Vmwo1Fewih$Tvsnigx$Viwsyvgi$Mrziwxqirx
Detail General
Needed Resource
Investment
Moderate Moderate
Risk Ranking
Low Low
Vmwo$veromrk0${lmgl$mw$xli$vipexmzi$wiqmuyerxmxexmzi$gexiksvm~exmsr$sj$jmvi$erh$i|tpswmsr$vmwow$xs
mhirxmj}0$wgviir0$erh$jsgyw$jyvxliv$ijjsvxw$mw$ehhviwwih$mr$Glet2$70$Psww$Wgirevms$Hizipstqirx2
Jmvwx1svhiv$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$mw$e$xivq$yrmuyi$xs$xlmw$fsso2$Jmvwx1svhiv$ewwiwwqirxw$vipexi$xs
wxvygxyvmrk$fsyrhmrk$wgirevmsw$erh$izirx$xviiw$xlex$uyerxmj}$wmkrmjmgerx$vmwo$gsrxvmfyxsvw2$Xlmw$xivq
{mpp$figsqi$gpieviv$jvsq$xli$ettvsegliw$hiwgvmfih$mr$xlmw$fsso2$Jmvwx1svhiv$ewwiwwqirxw$pmqmx$xli
hixemp$xs$xlex$riihih$xs$tvshygi$viwypxw${mxlmr$xli$tvsnigx$sfnigxmziw$erh$viwsyvgi$eppsgexmsr
gsrwxvemrxw2
E$wigsrh1svhiv$ewwiwwqirx$mrzspziw$ehhmxmsrep$hixemp2$Jsv$i|eqtpi0$mx$qe}$irxemp$ettpmgexmsr$sj
jmrmxi1ipiqirx$liex$xverwjiv$erep}wmw$xs$iwxmqexi$e$qsvi$eggyvexi$xmqi$sj$wxvygxyvi$jempyvi$sv$ziv}
gsqtpi|$jeypx$xvii$erep}wmw$sj$mrmxmexmrk$jempyvi$izirxw2$Mj$xlmw$pizip$sj$hixemp$mw$riihih0$xlir$xli
ehhmxmsrep$xmqi0$qshipmrk$xsspw0$erh$i|tirwiw$qywx$fi${imklih$ekemrwx$xli$firijmx$sj$gsqtmpmrk
xlmw$ehhmxmsrep$pizip$sj$hixemp2
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
5Ò68 TVSKVEQ$SFNIGXMZIW$$$$
Xli$ettpmgexmsr$sj$e$jsvqepm~ih0$vmwo1fewih$ewwiwwqirx$mw$firijmgmep$mj$xli$xsxep$vmwo$vihygxmsr
firijmx$sj$xli$ijjsvx$i|giihw$xli$xsxep$gswxw2$Xli$gswxw$mrgpyhi$xli$xmqi0$viwsyvgiw0$erh$gswxw
ewwsgmexih${mxl$gsrhygxmrk$xli$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$tvsnigx$tpyw$xli$gswx$vipexih$xs$xli$mqtpiqirxexmsr
sj$xli$vmwo$vihygxmsr$qiewyviw2
Jsv$i|eqtpi0$mj$xli$gswx$xs$hs$xli$vmwo1fewih$ewwiwwqirx$,m2i20$tvsnigx$gswx-$mw$(940444$erh$xli
gswx$xs$mqtpiqirx$vmwo$vihygxmsr$qiewyviw$mw$(54404440$xli$xsxep$gswx$mw$(59404442$Mj$xli$vmwo
vihygxmsr$firijmx$sfxemrih$mw$iwxmqexih$ex$(;904440$xlir$xli$firijmx3gswx$vexms$mw$(;904443
(5940444$A$4292$Mj$xli$firijmx3gswx$vexms$mw$piww$xler$50$xlir$xli$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$ijjsvx$qe}$rsx$fi
gsrwmhivih$firijmgmep2$Xlmw$mw$er$mqtsvxerx$gsrwmhivexmsr$xlex$wlsyph$fi$i|eqmrih$mr$Wxit$52
Er$i|eqtpi$sj$e$wyggiwwjyp0$vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$tvsnigx$jspps{w2$Tperx
qerekiqirx${ew$fimrk$jsvgih$xs$xeoi$egxmsr$sr$e$vigsqqirhexmsr$xs$vimrjsvgi$e$wtvmropiv$w}wxiq
,m2i20$tvszmhi$e$lmkliv$wtvmropiv$w}wxiq$hiwmkr$hirwmx}-$mr$e$lmkl1zepyih$jegmpmx}$gsrxemrmrk
ryqivsyw$l}hveypmgepp}$stivexih$qeglmriw2$Xli$vigsqqirhexmsr$tyvtswi${ew$xs$mqtvszi
tvsxigxmsr$ekemrwx$e$l}hveypmg$smp$jmvi2$Figeywi$xli$i|mwxmrk$wtvmropiv$tvsxigxmsr${ew$l}hveypmgepp}
hiwmkrih$ex$e$ps{iv$wtvmropiv$hiwmkr$hirwmx}$fewih$sr$xli$ezempefpi${exiv$wyttp}0$xli$gsqtpixmsr$sj
xlmw$vigsqqirhexmsr${syph$viuymvi$vitpegmrk$qswx$sj$xli$i|mwxmrk$wtvmropiv$w}wxiq$erh${exiv
wyttp}$mqtvsziqirxw$ex$e$gswx$i|giihmrk$(59404442$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$xli$gsqter}$leh$jmzi$sxliv
jegmpmxmiw$xlex${syph$viuymvi$wmqmpev$ythexmrk2
Tperx$qerekiqirx$higmhih$xs$gsrhygx$e$jmvi$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$wxyh}$xs$izepyexi$sxliv$tswwmfpi$vmwo
vihygxmsr$epxivrexmziw2$Xli$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$jspps{ih$xli$wxitw$hiwgvmfih$mr$xlmw$fsso2$Xli
epxivrexmziw$xlex$viwypxih$jvsq$xli$ewwiwwqirx$jsgywih$sr$qixlshw$xs$tvizirx$erh$vihygi$xli
wizivmx}$sj$e$l}hveypmg1smp$xsvgl$jmvi$wmxyexmsr2$Epxivrexmziw$mrgpyhih$mqtvszih$smp$tviwwyvi
mrwxvyqirxexmsr$erh$iuymtqirx$wlyxhs{r$mrxivpsgow0$fevvmivw$tswmxmsrih$xs$hijpigx$tviwwyvm~ih$smp
vipiewiw0$lmkliv$tviwwyvi$jpi|mfpi$l}hveypmg$lswiw0$erh$smp$hvemr1hs{r$pmriw$xs$e$lsphmrk$viwivzsmv2
F}$qmrmqm~mrk$xli$xsvgl1jmvi$tvsfefmpmx}$erh$gsrwiuyirxmep$i|tswyvi$vehmyw$erh$hyvexmsr$erh$f}
tvszmhmrk$vmwo$vihygxmsr$qiewyviw$xlex${syph$qshmj}$er$smp$vipiewi$jvsq$e$xsvgl$xs$e$pmqmxih$tssp
jmvi$gsrjmkyvexmsr0$xli$i|mwxmrk$wtvmropiv$w}wxiq${syph$fi$ehiuyexi$mr$gsrxvsppmrk$xli$jmvi$erh
qmrmqm~mrk$heqeki2
Xli$gswx$sj$xli$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$wxyh}0${lmgl$ywih$jmvwx1svhiv$izirx$xviiw$erh$jeypx$xviiw0${ew
(6<04442$Xli$gswx$xs$qeoi$xli$mqtvsziqirxw${ew$ettvs|mqexip}$(:404442$Xli$xsxep$gswx${ew
xlivijsvi$(<<0444$zivwyw$xli$(5940444$xs$vimrjsvgi$xli$i|mwxmrk$wtvmropiv$w}wxiq2$Jsv$jmzi$jegmpmxmiw
xli$szivepp$gswx$wezmrkw${ivi$ettvs|mqexip}$(7::04442$Mr$ehhmxmsr0$xli$epxivrexmzi$mqtvsziqirxw
ejjsvhih$e$qygl$lmkliv$vmwo$vihygxmsr$xs$xli$stivexmsrw$erh$iqtps}iiw${svomrk$mr$xliwi$jegmpmxmiw2
$$$VMWO1MRJSVQIH0$TIVJSVQERGI1FEWIH$JMVI$TVSXIGXMSR 5Ò69
529 VMWO$GSQQYRMGEXMSR
Xli$viwypxw$sj$xli$vmwo1mrjsvqih$tivjsvqergi1fewih$tvsnigx$qywx$fi$tviwirxih$mr$e$jsvqex
yrhivwxerhefpi$xs$xli$higmwmsr$qeoivw$viwtsrwmfpi$jsv$qeomrk$xli$higmwmsrw$erh$mqtpiqirxmrk$xli
egxmsr$tper2$Xefpi$527$pmwxw$wsqi$tvmqev}$vmwo$gsqqyrmgexmsr$riihw2
Xefpi$527> Wsqi$Tvmqev}$Higmwmsr$Gsrgivrw$Zivwyw$Vmwo$Gsqqyrmgexmsr
HIGMWMSR$GSRGIVRW VMWO$GSQQYRMGEXMSR
Ls{$wivmsyw$evi$xli$jmvi$erh$i|tpswmsr$i|tswyviw$,sr1 Kvetlmgep$jmvi$erh$i|tpswmsr$vmwo$tvsjmpiw2$Gsqtevmwsr
wmxi0$sjj1wmxi-C {mxl$vmwo$xspivergi$gvmxivme
Ls{$firijmgmep$evi$xli$tvstswih$psww$gsrxvsp Iwxmqexih$glerki$mr$vmwo$jsv$iegl$tvstswih$psww1gsrxvsp
vigsqqirhexmsrwC epxivrexmzi$sv$wxvexik}
[lex$vikypexsv}$mqtpmgexmsrw$,SWLE0$ITE0$fymphmrk Vikypexsv}$gsqtpmergi$mwwyiw
gshiw0$ixg2-$evi$mrzspzihC
Ls{$i|tirwmzi$evi$xli$tvstswih$psww$gsrxvsp Iwxmqexih$mrmxmep$erh$erryep$gswxw$ewwsgmexih${mxl$vmwo
vigsqqirhexmsrwC vihygxmsr$epxivrexmziw
Hs$xli$vigsqqirhih$glerkiw$vitviwirx$er$i|gitxmsr$xs Mhirxmjmgexmsr$sj$er}$tsxirxmep$gsrjpmgxw${mxl$tviwirx
i|mwxmrk$gsvtsvexi$tspmgmiw$sv$wejix}$wxerhevhwC$[mpp tspmgmiw$sv$tvsgihyviw2$Tsxirxmep$xsxep$gswx$xs$xli
sxliv$wmqmpev$tperxw0$jegmpmxmiw0$sv$stivexmsrw$fi$ejjigxihC gsvtsvexmsr$jsv$ytkvehmrk$wmqmpev$jegmpmxmiw
Kvetlmgep$vmwo$tvsjmpiw0$hiwgvmfih$mr$Glet2$;0$Vmwo$Iwxmqexmsr$erh$Gsqtevmwsr0$tvszmhi$e$kssh
zmwyep$tviwirxexmsr$jsvqex$jsv$gsqqyrmgexmrk$xli$jspps{mrk$mrjsvqexmsr$xs$xli$higmwmsr$qeoivw>
¨$ i|mwxmrk$vmwo$pizipw0
¨$ qshmjmih$vmwo$pizipw$fewih$sr$tvstswih$vmwo$vihygxmsr$epxivrexmziw0
¨$ gsqtevmwsr$sj$vmwo${mxl$qerekiqirx×w$iwxefpmwlih$vmwo$xspivergi$pmqmxw0$erh
¨$ eview${livi$jyvxliv$vmwo$uyerxmjmgexmsr$qe}$fi$riihih2
Er$mqtsvxerx$tsmrx$livi$mw$xlex$xli$vmwo$gsqqyrmgexmsr$jsvqex$qywx$lezi$xli$efmpmx}$xs
ÔgsqteviÕ$i|mwxmrk$erh$qshmjmih$vmwo$pizipw${mxl$iwxefpmwlih$vmwo$xspivergi$pizipw2
Wsqi$oi}$tvsnigx$mwwyiw$xlex$wlsyph$fi$ehhviwwih$mr$Wxit$5$evi$pmwxih$livi2
¨$ Xli$x}ti$sj$vmwo$tvsjmpi$tviwirxexmsr$jsvqex$xlex${mpp$fi$ywih$xs$emh$qerekiqirx
higmwmsr$qeomrk
¨$ Iwxefpmwlmrk$qerekiqirx×w$vmwo$xspivergi$pmqmxw$jsv$vmwo$gsqtevmwsrw
¨$ Ezempefmpmx}$sj$jmvi$erh$i|tpswmsr$qshipw$sv$epksvmxlqw$jsv$hixivqmrmrk$xli$tsxirxmep
wm~iw$sj$xs|mg$sv$jpeqqefpi$zetsv$gpsyhw0$szivtviwwyvi$~sriw$jvsq$i|tpswmsrw0$jmvi
mrxirwmxmiw$jvsq$fymphmrk$jmvi$i|tswyviw0$ixg2
¨$ Ettvstvmexi$wsyvgiw$sj$jempyvi$vexi$erh$vipmefmpmx}$hexe$erh$wipigxmsr$qixlshw$xs$wyttsvx
tvsfefmpmx}$qshipmrk
¨$ Viwievgl0$hexe$kexlivmrk0$xiwxmrk$xlex$qe}$fi$riihih$xs$wyttsvx$gsrwiuyirgi$erh
tvsfefmpmx}$qshipmrk
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
5Ò6: TVSKVEQ$SFNIGXMZIW$$$$
¨$ Mrgsvtsvexmrk$lyqer$ivvsv$erh$qerekiqirx$jegxsvw$mrxs$jempyvi$tvsfefmpmx}$verkiw2
¨$ Tvsgihyviw$jsv$ehhviwwmrk$erh$tviwirxmrk$yrgivxemrx}
¨$ Tvsgihyviw$jsv$gsrhygxmrk$mrxivegxmzi$uyepmx}$ewwyvergi$vizmi{w
¨$ Qixlshw$jsv$xvegomrk$xli$mqtpiqirxexmsr$sj$egxmsr$tperw
Vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$tvskveq$sfnigxmziw$mrzspzi>
¨$ Iwxefpmwlmrk$e$vmwo1fewih$higmwmsr$qeomrk$jveqi{svo$erh$xieq$gsrgitx
¨$ Ettp}mrk$e$wxvygxyvih0$gsrwmwxirx$qixlshspsk}$erh$wxitw$xs$uyerxmj}$vmwo$erh$tivjsvq
vmwo$vihygxmsr$gswx3firijmx$erep}wmw
¨$ Mqtpiqirxmrk$er$ijjigxmzi$tvsnigx$qerekiqirx$tper
Mqtpiqirxexmsr$sj$er$ijjigxmzi$vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$tvskveq
viuymviw$kssh$tvsnigx$qerekiqirx$xlex$mrgsvtsvexiw>
¨$ tvsnigx$hijmrmxmsr0
¨$ tvsnigx$xieq$wipigxmsr0
¨$ viwsyvgi$eppsgexmsr0$erh
¨$ vmwo$gsqqyrmgexmsr2
Vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$ettvsegliw$wlsyph$fi$gsrwmhivih$xsspw$xs$irlergi$erh
mqtvszi$irkmriivmrk$nyhkiqirxw2
Xli$jspps{mrk$mw$i|xvegxih$jvsq$vijivirgi$_9a>
$$Uyerxmxexmzi$erep}wmw$xiglrmuyiw$lezi$kemrih$e$kviex$hiep$sj$tstypevmx}${mxl
higmwmsr$qeoivw$erh$erep}wxw$mr$vigirx$}ievw2$Yrjsvxyrexip}0$qer}$tistpi$lezi
qmwxeoirp}$ewwyqih$xlex$xliwi$xiglrmuyiw$evi$qekmg$Ôfpego$fs|iwÕ$xlex
yriuymzsgepp}$evvmzi$ex$xli$gsvvigx$erw{iv$sv$higmwmsr2$Rs$xiglrmuyi$ger$qeoi$xlex
gpemq2$Xliwi$xiglrmuyiw$evi$xsspw$xlex$ger$fi$ywih$xs$lipt$qeoi$higmwmsrw$erh
evvmzi$ex$wspyxmsrw2$Pmoi$er}$xsspw0$xli}$ger$fi$ywih$xs$kssh$ehzerxeki$f}$womppih
tvegxmxmsrivw0$sv$xli}$ger$fi$ywih$xs$gviexi$lezsg$mr$xli$lerhw$sj$xli$yrwomppih2$Mr
xli$gsrxi|x$sj$Vmwo$Erep}wmw0$uyerxmxexmzi$xsspw$wlsyph$riziv$fi$ywih$ew$e
vitpegiqirx$jsv$tivwsrep$nyhkqirx2
$$Jmrepp}0$}sy$wlsyph$vigskrm~i$xlex$Vmwo$Erep}wmw$gerrsx$kyeverxii$xlex$xli
egxmsr$}sy$glsswi$xs$jspps{$Ó$izir$mj$womppjypp}$glswir$xs$wymx$}syv$tivwsrep
tvijivirgiw$Ó$mw$xli$fiwx$egxmsr$zmi{ih$jvsq$xli$tivwtigxmzi$sj$lmrhwmklx2
Lmrhwmklx$mqtpmiw$tivjigx$mrjsvqexmsr0${lmgl$}sy$riziv$lezi$ex$xli$xmqi$xli
higmwmsr$mw$qehi2$]sy$ger$fi$kyeverxiih0$ls{iziv0$xlex$}sy$lezi$glswir$xli$fiwx
tivwsrep$wxvexik}$kmzir$xli$mrjsvqexmsr$xlex$mw$ezempefpi$xs$}sy2$Xlex×w$rsx$e$feh
kyeverxii%
Xli$vmwo1mrjsvqih0$tivjsvqergi1fewih$qixlshspsk}$hmwgywwih$mr$xlmw$fsso$mw$fewih$sr$viepmwxmg
i|tivmirgi$erh$ettpmgexmsr2$Ettpmgexmsr$lew$mrgpyhih$vmwo$ewwiwwqirx$erh$izepyexmsr$sj$jmvi$erh
i|tpswmsr$tvizirxmsr$erh$tvsxigxmsr$w}wxiqw$mr$xli$gliqmgep0$smp0$kew0$rygpiev0$erh$ipigxvmg$ts{iv
mrhywxvmiw$ew${ipp$ew$le~evhsyw$qexivmep$tvsgiwwiw0$wxsveki0$erh$sxliv$mrhywxvmep$tvshygxmsr
$$$VMWO1MRJSVQIH0$TIVJSVQERGI1FEWIH$JMVI$TVSXIGXMSR 5Ò6;
stivexmsrw2$Xli$ettpmgexmsr$sj$xlmw$qixlshspsk}0$epxlsykl$fewih$sr$mrhywxvmep1x}ti$vmwow0$epws$pirhw
mxwipj$xs$ryqivsyw$gsqqivgmep$ettpmgexmsrw2
Ew$jsv$tviwgvmtxmzi$gshiw0$xli$qsziqirx${mpp$fi$qsvi$erh$qsvi$xs{evhw$vmwo1mrjsvqih0
tivjsvqergi1fewih$qixlshw2$I|mwxmrk$gshiw$tvmqevmp}$gsrgirxvexi$sr$levh{evi$hiwmkr$gvmxivme
fewih$sr$psww$i|tivmirgi2$Qswx$i|mwxmrk$gshiw$hs$rsx$ehhviww$vmwo$xspivergi$gvmxivme0$wgirevms
pmoipmlsshw0$JTW$viwtsrwi$xmqi$sj$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$w}wxiqw0$w}wxiq$ezempefmpmx}$jegxsvw0$erh
uyerxmjmgexmsr$sj$vipmefmpmx}$zivwyw$gsqqsr$geywi$mrxivrep$erh$i|xivrep$jempyviw0$lyqer$ivvsv0$sv
JTW$tvssj$xiwxmrk$jviuyirg}$zivwyw$vipmefmpmx}2$
Mx$mw$givxemrp}$i|tigxih$xlex$xli$qixlshspsk}$hiwgvmfih$mr$xlmw$fsso${mpp$fi$vijmrih$fewih$sr
ywivw×$mrtyx$erh$xli$tvskviwwmsr$sj$tivjsvqergi1fewih$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$wxerhevhw$erh$ettpmgexmsrw2
Xli$gyvvirx$tivjsvqergi1fewih$gshi$xlmromrk$riihw$xs$i|xirh$fi}srh$wsqi$sj$xli$gyvvirx$xvirhw
xlex$tvmqevmp}$iuyexi$tivjsvqergi$wyggiww$xs$xli$viwypxw$sj$hixivqmrmwxmg$jmvi$qshipmrk$ijjsvxw2
Tivjsvqergi$wyggiww$mw$e$tvsfefmpmwxmg$qiewyvi2$Vmwo$xspivergi$gvmxivme$wlsyph$hmgxexi$tivjsvqergi
viuymviqirxw2$Ehhmrk$vmwo1mrjsvqih$xs$xli$tivjsvqergi$iuyexmsr${mpp$epps{$jsv$qsvi$jpi|mfmpmx}$mr
izepyexmrk$epxivrexmzi$jmvi$tvsxigxmsr$hiwmkrw$erh$xiwxmrk$stxmsrw$erh${mpp$pieh$xs$mqtvszih$gswx1
ijjigxmziriww2
52: VIJIVIRGIW
52 Wglqmhx0$Qmgleip$I2$K2$erh$Qeyri}0$H2$E2$Witx2$5=<<2$Ls{$Jmrergmepp}$Stxmqm~mrk
Qemrxirergi$Ger$Wspzi$]syv$Wejix}$Mwwyiw0$Tvsgiihmrkw>$Mrxivrexmsrep$Gsrjivirgi$erh
[svowlst$sr$Vipmefmpmx}$erh$Vmwo$Qerekiqirx0$Girxiv$jsv$Gliqmgep$Tvsgiww$Wejix}$sj
EMGlI0$Ri{$]svo0$R]0$5=<=2
62 Eqivmger$Mrwxmxyxi$sj$Gliqmgep$Irkmriivw$,EMGlI-2$Girxiv$jsv$Gliqmgep$Tvsgiww$Wejix}
,GGTW-0$Kymhipmriw$jsv$Gliqmgep$Tvsgiww$Uyerxmxexmzi$Vmwo$Erep}wmw0$Ri{$]svo0$R]0
5=<=2
72 Rexmsrep$Jmvi$Tvsxigxmsr$Ewwsgmexmsr$64442$WJTI$Irkmriivmrk$Kymhi$xs$Tivjsvqergi
Fewih$Jmvi$Tvsxigxmsr0$Erep}wmw$erh$Hiwmkr$sj$Fymphmrkw0$Uymrg}0$QE2
82 Lehnmwstlsgpisyw0$K2$Z20$Firmglsy0$R20$erh$Xeqmq0$E2$W205==<2$ÔPmxivexyvi$Vizmi{$sj
Tivjsvqergi1Fewih$Jmvi$Gshiw$erh$Hiwmkr$Irzmvsrqirx2Õ$Nsyvrep$sj$Jmvi$Tvsxigxmsr
Irkmriivmrk0$=,5-0$tt2$56$Ò$842
92 Tepmwehi$Gsvtsvexmsr2$Kymhi$Xs$Ywmrk$D$Vmwo?$Vmwo$Erep}wmw$erh$Wmqypexmsr
Ehh1Mr$jsv$Qmgvswsjx$I|gip$sv$Psxyw$516172$Ri{jmiph0$R]0$5==:2
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
5Ò6< TVSKVEQ$SFNIGXMZIW$$$$