Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Example:
To understand this better, imagine a conflict at school. There is a fight in the
schoolyard, two ninth-graders are beating up Tom. Those who watch the fight are
at different stages of moral development. Let's see what they do and how they
justify their behavior
At stage one, we make moral judgments based on obedience and
punishment. Finn's sense of good or bad is directly linked to whether
he gets punished or not. Finn sees what is happening to his friend and
wants to help, but he doesn't because he is afraid the teacher may
punish him if he gets caught fighting. He asks himself, how can I avoid
punishment?
At the conventional level, Betty responds to peer pressure and the teacher
follows the rules. Their morality is centered around what society regards as right, this
level, the fairness of rules is seldom questioned, it is common to think like this during
adolescence and adulthood
At the post-conventional level, Jesse knows that things are complicated because
individuals may disobey rules inconsistent with their own morality. The headmaster
follows a universal ethical idea at complete disconnect with what society thinks or the
rules say. To him, everything is solved through compassion. The right behavior in his
opinion is therefore never a means to an end, but always an end in itself. Not every
person reaches this level
The American psychologist Lawrence Kohlberg based his work on Piaget's theory of cognitive
development
04:41
In order to confirm his theory of stages of moral development
04:45
Kohlberg interviewed boys between the ages of 10 and 16
04:49
He analyzed how they would justify their decision when confronted with different hypothetical moral
dilemmas
04:55
We will now present to you the most famous moral dilemma Kohlberg presented to his students
05:00
Let's see what you would do
05:03
The Heinz dilemma: A woman was on her deathbed
05:07
There was only one drug that the doctors thought might save her
05:10
The druggist that made that particular medicine sold it for ten times the price of the production costs
05:16
The sick woman's husband, Heinz, was poor and could not afford to buy the drug
05:21
not even with the financial help of his friends
05:24
Heinz then asked the pharmacist to sell it to him for half the price
05:27
But he refused
05:30
To save the life of his wife, Heinz broke into the man's laboratory and stole the medicine
05:38
Now tell us:
05:39
Should Heinz have stolen the drug?
05:42
Would it change anything if Heinz didn't love his wife?
05:45
What if the person dying was not his wife but a stranger?
05:49
Should the police arrest the druggist for murder if the wife had died?
05:53
Please write your answers and their justifications in the comments below
06:11
If you like this video and the way we explain the subject subscribe to our channel
06:16
We try to explain complex subjects in simple language and cartoons to support students all around the
world in their learning
06:23
If you want to support us, you can go to www.patreon.com/sprouts and donate
06:29
Just $1 from many fans makes a big difference