You are on page 1of 11

The Katipunan and the Revolution: The Revolt of the Masses: The Story of

Memoirs of a General Bonifacio and the Katipunan


By: Santiago V. Alvarez (1992) By: Teodoro A. Agoncillo (2002)
Author’s Background
Santiago V. Alvarez Teodoro A. Agoncillo
Born: July 25, 1872 in Imus, Cavite Born: November 9 1912 in Lemery, Batangas
Died: October 30, 1930 in San Pablo City Died: January 14, 1985

Santiago V. Alvarez was a revolutionary He was a prominent 20th-century Filipino


general and a founder and honorary president historian. He and his contemporary Renato
of the first directorate of the Nacionalista Constantino were among the first Filipino
Party. He was known as "Kidlat ng Apoy" historians renowned for promoting a distinctly
(Lightning of Fire) because of his inflamed nationalist point of view of Filipino. He was
bravery and dedication as commander of also an essayist and a poet.
Cavite's famous battles particularly that in
Dalahican where the victory was crucial for the Agoncillo's "History of the Filipino People"
revolutionary cause, since it prevented the was first published in (1960). To date, it
Spanish send reinforcements across the remains a popular standard textbook in many
isthmus from Cavite to reconquer the province, Filipino universities, as are many of
the main Philippine bastion. For this reason, he Agoncillo's other works.
was rejoiced in the present-day Cavite City as
the “Hero” of the Battle of Dalahican.

Prior to the outbreak of the revolution, Some of his other well-known works include
Santiago was already a delegado general of the Revolt of the Masses (1956), Malolos: the
provincial council of the Katipunan in Cavite. Crisis of the Republic (1960), the Fateful Years
He became captain general and later, (1965), and History of the Filipino People
commander-in-chief, of the Magdiwang forces (1960) which are all still being used as
and valiantly fought the Spaniards from 1896 textbooks in many schools. For this
outstanding works as a historian, he was
conferred as a National Scientist in (1985).
to 1897. With his father, Mariano Álvarez, and
cousin, General Pascual Álvarez, they liberated
Agoncillo obtained a bachelor's degree in
Noveleta from the Spaniards on
philosophy from the University of the
August 31, 1896.
Philippines in (1934) and a master's degree in
the arts from the same university the following
In 1902 he was appointed Chairman of the
year.
Commission of the peace, an organization
created by U.S. authorities to promote the
He became linguistic assistant at the Institute
material reconstruction of the country and the
of National Language and as an instructor at
reconciliation between the two countries. In
the Far Eastern University and the Manuel L.
this same line created in 1912 the Association
Quezon University and a faculty member of
Makabuhay.
U.P., chairing the Department of History from
1963 to 1969, until his retirement in 1977.
When was the account written?
According to Journal of Southeast Asian
Studies, the Original Tagalog text of General The Revolt of the Masses: The Story of
Alvarez’s memoirs was published in 36 Bonifacio and the Katipunan was written in
installments, from July 24, 1927 to April 15, 1947 as the authorʼs winning entry in a
1928, in the Tagalog weekly, Sampaguita. national Bonifacio biography contest held in
1948. Another focus of inquiry is the
The translation of “Ang Katipunan at publication of the manuscript in 1956 by the
Paghihimagsikan” by Paula Caroline Malay in College of Liberal Arts of the University of the
English was published in Quezon City, Ateneo Philippines.
de Manila University Press on 1992.
Mention of Dates
 March 25, 1897 - A convention was held in  Middle of Decemeber 1896 - Bonifacio with
Tejeros in order to settle the dispute between his wife and two brothers, Ciriaco and
the two councils, The Magdalo and The Procopio, left Cavite because Bonifacio
Magdiwang group, and to decide on what accept the request of Mariano Alvarez his
type of government should be installed. uncle-in-law.
 March 27, 1897 - Those elected at the  January 2,1897 - Bonifacio wrote from San
Tejeros convention secretly gathered in the Francisco de Malabon to Mariano Alvarez.
Tanza parish house. They knelt before a Written in that letter was "President Mainam:
crucifix and solemnly took their office Don't fail to come this very moment for I
despite the Supremo, Andres Bonifacio’s want to talk to you privately about what
claim of the votings as null and void. happened to me in Magdalo and so that you
might explain their organization to me."

 January 1897 - The feast of San Francisco


de Malabon and is when the rebels enjoyed
the fiesta and relaxed.

 March 22,1897 - General Emilio


Aguinaldo's Birthday. Also it is when the
battle raged between the Spaniards and the
Magdalo soldiers and the assembly convened
the Tejeros.
Mention of Place
 Tejeros - The place where the assembly took  Cavite - The Tejeros Convention was the
place. meeting held on March 22, 1897 between the
Magdiwang and Magdalo factions.
 San Francisco de Malabon - The place  Mountains of Montalban & Mariquina - A
where the election for the new government delegate was sent in the mountains to look
took place. for the Supremo to apprise to him of the
urgent necessity of mediating of the widening
 Tanza (Santa Cruz de Malabon) - (parish rift between the two popular councils.
house of the Catholic Church) many attested
seeing Messrs. Mariano Trias. Daniel Tirona,  Noveleta - The place where Esteban San
Emiliano R. de Dios, Santiago Rillo and Juan invited Bonifacio to attend the
others, and that they were conferring with the demonstration of the Magdiwang rebels.
priest, Fr. Cenon Villafranca. The former
summer resort of the friars that witnessed the
first important election held under the
auspices of the Katipunan government  Estate house of Tejeros - The place where
the leaders of the Magdiwang planned to
Towns under the sovereign power of each hold another convention.
faction:
 Kin Batangas and other towns (Magdalo)  Town of Kawit, Bakood, and Imus – The
 Nasugbu, Tuwi and Look, in the same place where the Spanish army seriously
province (Magdiwang) threatened it for battle.

 Mountains of Montalban and Mariquina -  Barrio between the towns of Imus and
The search for Supremo, to apprise him of Dasmarinas - General Emillio Aguinaldo
the urgent necessity of mediating of the lead the Magdalo Soldiers to face the
widening rift between the two popular Spaniards.
councils.
 Santa Cruz de Malabon - The place where
 Zapote - Emilio Aguinaldo, Candido Tirona a bridge is connected to San Francisco de
and Edilberto Evangelista were on hand to Malabon and is the place where the former
meet the Supremo and and his entourage summer resort of the friars, that witnessed the
first important election held under the
 Imus (house of Juan Castaneda) - auspices of the Katipunan government.
Bonifacio was brought by the rebel leaders  San Juan del Monte/Laguna - The place
where he was visited by Baldomero where they were going to attack the
Aguinaldo, Daniel Tirona, Vicente Spaniards.
Fernandez and others. Bonifacio ordered the
arrest of Fernandez.
Key Personalities
 Emiliano de Dios - Elected as Secretary of  Andres Bonifacio - Supreme Head of the
War Katipunan
 Daniel Tirona - He went against the result of  Artemio Ricarte - Magdalo's military
the votings when Andres Bonifacio was commander brigadier-general
elected as Secretary of the Interior  Mariano Alvarez - Magdiwang's chosen
 Ariston Villanueva - Previous Secretary of President
war  Gen. Emilio Aguinaldo - Leading the
 Apoy - Previous Captain General Magdalo Soldiers, faced the Spaniards in
- He was insulted by Antonio Salitran
Montenegro’s remark about the  Candido Tirona - Magdiwang's minister of
revolution and made an order to arrest war
him  Edilberto Evangelista - Magdalo's elected
 Anotonio Montenegro - He was arrested by Lieutenant General
General Apoy because he compared the  Baldomero Aguinaldo - Made the proposal
revolution to a pack of bandits or of wild, to establish a revolutionary government
mindless animals if they did not agree on the  Daniel Tirona - Magdalo man
kind of revolutionary government they were  Esteban San Juan - Invited Bonifacio to
to have attend the demonstration of the Magdiwang
 Trining & Josephine - Pleaded with Apoy rebels in Noveleta
not to arrest Montenegro but to let him stay  Ariston Villanueva - Magdiwang's Minister
at the estate house of War who stood up and said that if new
 Jacinto Lumbreras - Previous Chairman of government was to be established, Andres
the Katipunan Bonifacio who had organized and planned
 Fr. Cenon Villanueva - Officated the oath the entire revolutionary movement, must of
taken by the newly elected officers right occupy presidency without any election
 Severino de las Alas and Daniel Tirona-  Santiago Alvarez - Magdalo's commander in
Witness of the oath taking chief
 Pascual Alvarez - Magdalo's executive
secretary
 Luciano San Miguel - Magdiwang
representative
 Mariano Trias - Magdalo's minister of grace
and justice
 Severino de las Alas - Magdiwang
representative
 Santos Nocon - Magdiwang representative
 Cayetano Topacio - Magdiwang's minister
of finance
 Antonio Montenegro - Magdiwang
representative
 Jacinto Lumbrera - Acting president of
magdiwang in the meeting
Sequencing of Events
In the Philippine Revolution of 1896, there was The Katipunan of Cavite, divided into two
a conflict that emerged between Andres factions, the Magdiwang and the Magdalo, and
Bonifacio, the supremo of the Katipunan, the each factions exercised sovereign power over a
secret society that launched the uprising number of towns. Leaders of each council
against Spain in August 1896, and Emilio never got together to elect their leader; they
Aguinaldo, a leader of the Filipino forces in proceeded independently their elected leader.
Cavite province who replaced Bonifacio as Both factions attempted to make their uniform
head of the revolutionary movement in March to recognized their council, however the plan
1897. did not go beyond the paper stage due to lack
of budget.
In hopes of uniting the conflicting factions and When Cavite led by its two factions,
establishing a new government of the successfully rose in their revolt, disputes arises
Katipunan, Andres Bonifacio and Emilio between the leaders of rival factions for their
Aguinaldo agreed to hold the Tejeros desire to control the other faction. But neither
Convention. The assembly at Tejeros took both sides would bow nor allow the other
place on March 25, 1897, which was initially faction to rule the other faction, and this led to
presided by Secretary Jacinto Lumbreras of the rebel's defeat at the hands of Polavieja and the
Magdiwng Council. Spaniards. The Magdiwang men initiated to
invite Andres Bonifacio to visit Cavite and
Secretary Jacinto Lumbreras announced the intervene in the conflict of the two factions. A
main topic of discussion, which was how to delegate was sent to look and inform him, but
bolster the defenses in the areas under he refuses to heed the request.
Magdiwang control. Severino de las Alas
interrupted and announced that the major Periodic exchanges of communication between
issues should be tackled first such as what kind Bonifacio and Magdiwang chieftains led to
of government should we have and how should accepting the third invitation written to
we establish it. Secretary Lumbreras Bonifacio. Bonifacio left for Cavite in the
emphasized that the Katipunan now holds middle of December 1896. A
authority over the island that has a government misunderstanding arose between Magdalo
of law and a definite program. Severino de las leaders and Bonifacio at the preliminary
Alas disagreed otherwise. meeting, that they regarded Bonifacio's
behavior and "acted as if he were a king". After
A disorder ensued between General Apoy and the meeting, Bonifacio met Fernandez, who
Antonio Montenegro, which disrupted the was his comrade in the battle of San Juan,
assembly. Antiono Montenegro said the they promised to help him, but didn't carried out his
who were in the Revolution would be no better promise had led to their defeat, ordered his
than a pack of bandits or of wild, mindless arrest. But Magdalo chieftains, whom
animals. Hurt by the words of Montenegro, Fernandez had run for shelter, refused to give
General Apoy emphasized that they are true him up and Bonifacio concluded that he had
revolutionaries fighting for the freedom of the little influence in Magdalo area.
native land and they are not bandits who rob
others of their property and wealth. General Bonifacio was invited to attend an event in
Apoy then ordered the arrest of Antonio Noveleta. A parade took place and Emilio
Montenegro. Aguinaldo, a Magdiwang, observed the parade,
while having a plan to nominate Edilberto
When order was restored, Andres Bonifacio Evangelista, with the intention of his faction to
presumed the chairman of the assembly, for he propose an establishment of a revolutionary
is the Father of the Katipunan and the government. Bonifacio knowing the plan of
Revolution. Secretary Lumbreras thought Aguinaldo was hurt for the presidency must be
Bonifacio to be the rightful chairman because given to him for he is the founder of
the as the leader of the Katipunans, he was Katipunan. After, an assembly was opened
responsible for the spread of the revolutionary with Bonifacio as chairman. And both factions
movement throughout the Philippines. have different sides that never come to
understanding. Magdalo proposes to have a
An election took place for the following government with the Katipunan for it was no
positions: President, Vice President, Minister longer necessary, and Magdiwang opposes the
of Finance, Minister of Welfare and Justice, proposal. At the end the assembly was
and Captain General. The Supremo Bonifacio adjourned, but as tension between the
emphasized that all decisions discussed and Magdiwang and Magdalo continues to rise.
approved in the meetings should be respected
and all should abide by the wished of the The leaders held another convention at the
majority, no matter what his station in life or estate-house in Tejeros. This was during
his educational attainment. The Magdiwang Aguinaldo’s birthday March 22,1987 and when
secretary of the treasury warned Bonifacio that he was facing the Spaniards in Salitran. The
the ballots were tampered and some were convention was mostly attended by
already filled out, however, Bonifacio ignored Magdiwang soldiers. The convention was
this and proceeded with the election. opened by Jacinto Lumbreras, however
Severino de las Alas took the floor and wanted
In the voting for the presidency position in the to discuss on what kind of government should
revolutionary government, Emilio Aguinaldo be set up. Andres Bonifacio explaining that the
prevailed over Andres Bonifacio. The next K in the Katipunan flag already identified the
most important posts went to members of the type of government but de las Alas was not
Magdiwang: Mariano Trias was elected Vice satisfied. The tension was heated up as Antonio
President, Artemio Ricarte, and Emiliano Montenegro insulted the Katipunan which was
Riego de Dios was elected Secretary of War. not taken lightly by Santiago Alvarez.
Andres Bonifacio was elected to a position, the Lumbreras then proceeded to gave the seat to
Secretary of the Interior. After that, an Andres Bonifacio in spearheading the
argument broke out between Bonifacio and convention.
Daniel Tirona, where the later insisted that the
position of Secretary of the Interior should be An election was held where whoever elected
entrusted to a lawyer and elect Jose del Rosario was to be recognized and respected regardless
instead. Bonifacio adjourned the meeting, of social status and education. Emilio
announcing that all matters approved in the Aguinaldo was elected President, Mariano
meeting are null and void. Trias as Vice President, Ricarte as Captain
General, Emilio R. de Dios as director of war
Baldomero Aguinaldo, the Magdalo president, and Andres Bonifacio as Director of Interior.
convinced the Magdiwang leaders to The position of Bonifacio was opposed by
reconvene the disrupted meeting at the same Daniel Tirona, which offended the Supremo,
friar estate house in Tejeros the following day that led him to call the assembly off and all that
to continue and revalidate the proceeding of was discussed as null.
the election; however, the Magdalo members
did not came. It was rumored that a meeting Bonifacio believed that that he should have
had taken place at the Tanza parish house and been given the presidency but was not due to
Bonifacio’s decision regarding the election the dirty work of the Magdalo men. In his letter
being null and void were not respected. At the to Mariano Alvarez he also said that he would
gathering in the Tanza parish house, those not recognize the chiefs elected during the
elected at the Tejeros Convention took their Imus Convention and should not be recognized
oaths office, which was officiated by Fr. Cenon by the people either.
Villafranca. Unknown to the Magdiwang
Council, the Magdalo posted troops to guard
the Tarzan parish house and not to admit any
unwanted Magdiwang partisans.
Differences between the two accounts
Date of the Tejeros Convention:
Revolutionary leader, Santiago Alvarez stated According to historian Teodoro Agoncillo, the
that the Tejeros Convention occurred on Tejeros Convention occurred on
March 25, 1897. March 22, 1897, which was Aguinaldo’s
birthday.
Details of the Events: Agoncillo’s Seeds of Discontent was
Alvarez’s account of the events that transpired comprehensive since it has many details and
during the Tejeros Convention was short and facts; giving the full particulars of the events.
brief but clear; expressing what needs to be
conveyed without unnecessary words. This account started with the The Katipunan of
Cavite, which was divided into two factions,
This account started with the assembly at the Magdiwang and the Magdalo. The disputes
Tejeros that convened on March 25, 1897. between the two factions lead the need to unite
Alvarez’s missed to account the events that the conflicting factions and establish a new
lead to the assembly. government of the Katipunan.
Events after the Tejeros Convention:
In Alvarez’s account, he did not mention that In Agoncillo’s account, he did not mention that
Andres Bonifacio wrote a letter to his uncle-in- the Magdalo President Baldomero Aguinalo
law, Mariano Alvarez venting his anger which intended to continue the disrupted assembly,
was triggered by Daniel Tirona and in his letter however the Magdalo members did not show
he reiterated his nullification of all that had up on the agreed place. Rather, the Magdalo
been agreed upon. members secretly gathered in Tanza to take
their oaths of office.

Own analysis of the differences between the two accounts


Alvarez’s account was not detailed enough to The group thinks that it was unfair for
really understand about what happened even Bonifacio to die when he wrote the letter to his
before and even after of that event. It only uncle in law.
briefly explained the situation unlike the 2nd
reading that is much more detailed of the Agoncillo’s account was very detailed and
occurrences. everything was described on how the election
became a null and later on was dismissed.
Alvarez’s account focuses more on the election
that occurred and how the officers opposed to The significant events that happened in
Bonifacio’s decision of declaring it as null and Agoncillo’s account were more on the conflicts
void. they encountered and what the outcome of the
election was.

You might also like