Professional Documents
Culture Documents
J. O. A r u m a l a I & E. G. A k p o k o d j e 2
1Department of Civil Engineering and 2 Department of Geology, University of
Port Harcourt, P.M.B. 5323, Port Harcourt, Nigeria
barho Zhl
,/
Omoku
Okehi
Aba
'art Harcourt
Junction
I0 0 20 40krn
I I I I I I
FIG. 1. Location map of the Niger Delta and the roads studied.
(Allen 1965; Short & Stauble 1967; Akpokodje 1979, Ministry of Works General Specifications (Roads and
1986a, b). The Niger Delta has a tropical rain forest Bridges, Vol. II) which were adopted from TRRL
climate with distinct wet (April-October) and dry Road Note 31 (1971), without much modification.
(November-March) seasons. The annual rainfall Although the exact design specifications of the
ranges from 2000 mm inland to over 4000 mm at the different roads vary according to the category, they
coast and approximately 85% of the annual rainfall fall within the following general groups:
occurs in the wet season (Table 2). The Niger Delta
constitutes an extensive deltaic plain with numerous (i) Subgrade; compacted to 95 to 100% B.S.
marshes and backswamps that occupy as much as 50% compaction with soaked CBR of 5 to 11%.
of the entire region. These areas are usually (ii) 50 to 120 mm sub-base, compacted to 100% West
submerged during the wet season where flood waters African Standard compaction.
range from 0.5 to 4 m deep. (iii) 50 to 150 mm base of either coarse grained soils
compacted to 100% West African Standard
Compaction with a soaked CBR of at least 30%
Design features and pavement conditions or a cement stabilized soil (5 to 7% cement
content).
The standard practice of pavement design in the Niger (iv) 30 to 90 mm double bituminous surface dressing
Delta follows the guidelines of the Nigerian Federal of rolled asphalt.
d=
~
0.~,~. ~ ~'0 ~ I=I I=I~
- ~
,q
0
== = ,,.9,o ".~.~ ~ ~ ~,
~ 0 0 "*"
o~ =
~'~
.~ ,~
9,..e,
~ ~.~.~
a~g 2: o
s ~ ~ o ~.~ r ~ ~
~~ o 0 0
o-"0 0 o "~-'
<~ ~
<
9~ "~ ' o ~a
8g 8~
a= "~ = ~ ,._.
. ,,,.,,
L.
,~ ~ ~ .~
.5
~F-I i 1
I
L .
i i
p_ i
'Z
I
o
,< o
J00d /~JBA t t ,,
<,~o JO0 d "'!
-- ::'~- a,!.on b ap9' X'X xlx'xlx!x x x
o ,v,~ 8 ~ poo~ ^,~^' '
'z:
i i
/
~ ~ - ' ~A ~ ~,,,0~>
cr c3 ~UON, q
-J pBAD d
-- g JOAOOIBAOJ~' q~.l~ paAoduFI t xx
Z- ~ Je'AOO1lOS q . p ~ poAodUCl" ' i
g .,~' JBAOOuo!,~olaBe^qJ,,~ paAodun'~. l ' '
,
' y=
E
__:~ ~$ o o o g~ awa>x>,i , c~ c,4 c,4 i ~ i r'4
~
~ o~~ S~ L ~ o\ ~' -d~ . A ._ , ,
~d ~m ?,,"1 > L ,
. ~_ o. 7 ~ ro ~ < auoN i ,
8
4
~,.~ o o o ~ ~ z w~>x>' 1
s''~u~ > =~,5 ~ ,.~ ' A ~0~ ' z~> ' ' I e"
~ ,~ ,:,,o g _ ~0^~s. , ] , 0
2
g
"0
o ~o . ~ ~ > .~215215 , >"
~D
g
-- -- ~
~ 0
e~ ~ ~ > auoN X X ]
wag < I ~ , 4 ' r ~ f
t |
&
o~j __, ~,, g ,%>: i ' d=
0
o •215215215215215215
,8
0 ,
~g o ~ o o -~ 'wu~gel>x>u~wo~ r ' 1
~-~ - ___' ~ A, o~_, u~u~0~>
> 8
~ oJ ~o ~ ~ ~: OU0N |
o
,- o o IZI S S D I 9 0 H S ~ / V
oo~
o~ o ~ ~ o ~ ~. ussm3 o~svv <
-~o _ _4 ~ A ~3~ [ssmOOHSVV
6< - ~ ~o ~; aU0N
w ~-~ i t -
E3
~O__-- t.~ ~ i.~ tat'~ -.4"-.4r'-4" .-.4r -4rt0"1
,_,~ o .~~176. ' s - s o . oo'oooo'o
03
_ ~ ~ oO ,.D ...r
a: ~ _ - -
2_2_ ~
0 ~
'i , i
* i
<~ ~- ~ _ .
0 F-
Year of Surface
com- Distance deform- Surfacing Failed Shoulder Drainage
Road pletion (km ) Cracking ation defects areas conditions conditions
East-West Road
Patani-Kaiama 1983 18 Slight Severe Slight Severe 3 1
Kaiama-Ahoada 1981 40 Slight Moderate Slight Moderate 1 4
Ahoada-Imo River 1981 115 Moderate Moderate Moderate Moderate 1 4
Mbiama-Yenegoa 1978 28 Slight Severe Slight Severe 1 4
Kolo Junction-Ogbia 1983 45 Moderate Severe Moderate Severe 1 4
Ahoada-Ebocha 1978 82 Slight Moderate Moderate Moderate 1 4
Ahoada-Degema 1977 48 Moderate Moderate Slight Severe 1 4
Taba Junction-Bori-Kono 1977 25 Slight Slight Slight Slight 1 4
PH-Igwuruta-Okehi 1978 100 Moderate Moderate Slight Severe 1 4
PH-Aba expressway 1980 50 Moderate Moderate Slight Moderate 1 4
PH-Owerri 1980 100 Moderate Moderate Slight Severe 1 4
1 See text for description of categories of severity and density.
FIG. 3. Completely broken down section of the East-West FIG. 6. High shoulder drop off along the East-West
highway between Patani and Kaiama. highway.
Soil properties
A summary of the geotechnical properties of soil
materials taken from under the failed sections of the
various roads and the borrow pits is given in Table 4.
The East-West highway was divided into three
segments since it crosses different geomorphic,
geologic and drainage/hydrogeologic units. The
particle size distributions of most of the soils are
characterized by an excess of fine materials (<74/~m),
FIG, 5. Failed shoulder of the Patani-Kaiama road. ranging from 17 to 94%. About 95% of the soils from
Quarterly Journal of Engineering Geology, London, 1987, Vol. 20
SOIL P R O P E R T I E S A N D P A V E M E N T P E R F O R M A N C E 293
~ ~ 9 ~ T ~ ~ ,, ,, ,,
~ ~ , ~~ ~
I I I I I I
9,..,~
~
~J
b
b
[-
~ / I I I I I II II II
~,.~~.~-.~-~o ~ ~ ~
6"~ ~"
.~ ~ -~' ~
~ < 2 ~~ O ~ ~0
z~ ~,~< ~
the failed road section of the riverine areas (seasonally specifications for base course materials shows that
flooded fresh and salt water mangrove swamps) most of the soils do not satisfy the Nigerian standard
contain more than 40% fines. Although soils from the because: (1) they have excess fines (i.e. fines >15%),
permanently dry lands contain less than 40% fines, (2) the plasticity values of the cohesive soils are higher
they still lack adequate amounts of the coarse fraction than the specified values (i.e. WL ~<30; PI<~ 12) and
(56 to 93% passed through a 425 ~m sieve). The silt (3) the CBR (both soaked and unsoaked) are much
fractions of the soils from the riverine areas are high lower than the minimum acceptable value (80%). If
(37 to 60%), in contrast to the very small amounts all the Nigerian specifications have to be met, then
(<10%) in soils from the permanently dry lands. none of the Niger Delta soils should be used for base
Generally, the soils are of low to medium plasticity course construction. This would mean hauling suitable
although the liquid limit of some samples may be as materials from distances of 80 to 200 km. Under these
high as 65%. Those soils that are predominantly made conditions, it would be more economical to improve
up of the fine sand and silt fractions are usually the properties of these substandard materials by
nonplastic. The majority of soil samples fall above the stabilization and to use new design and construction
'A' line on the Casagrande plasticity chart and the rest methods that take into account the soil properties and
either fall on or slightly below the line. Thus, although the physical environmental conditions.
the soils are mainly inorganic clays, some inorganic With regard to the construction of embankments
silts and dual classification soils (silt/clay) also occur. and general filling, more than 80% of the sandy soil of
The relatively low plasticity of the soils in view of the the permanently dry areas meets the Nigerian
high percentage of fines (up to 94%) is an indication specifications (fines ~<35%, soaked CBR~>5%)
of the absence of significant amounts of very active whereas the upper layers of most soils from the
clay minerals such as montmorillonite. This view is riverine areas do not satisfy these specifications.
reinforced by the low percentage of linear shrinkage. However, the sands/sandy lithologies that usually
The ranges of the achievable laboratory maximum occur at depth constitute acceptable fill materials.
dry densities and optimum moisture contents with The general poor performance of roads in the Niger
standard Proctor compaction effort are 1523 to Delta can be attributed principally to the substandard
2060 kg/m 3 and 10 to 26%, respectively; the values for paving properties of the soil materials. Other
modified AASHO compaction effort are 1644 to contributory factors include poor compaction and
2142 kg/m 3 and 8 to 23%, respectively. As would be drainage, lack of paved, waterproof shoulders and a
expected, soils with large amounts of fines (e.g. high water table. Severe pavement cracking, surface
Patani-Kaiama, Kaiama-Ahoada, Mbiama-Yenegoa deformations and failures that occur in the Patani-
and Kolo Junction-Ogbia) gave lower dry densities Kaiama, Mbiama-Yenegoa and Kolo Junction-Ogbia
and higher optimum moisture contents. The results of roads are due to the very fine grained (>70% fines)
the modified AASHO compaction show that the use silty clays/clays used.
of heavier and more powerful compaction plants will Although most of the sandy loam/sandy clay soils in
increase the dry densities achievable in the field. the permanently dry areas fall below the standards
Both the unsoaked and soaked (4 days) CBR values specified for conventional base materials, the majority
are low (2 to 67%). The soaked values of the very of the roads built with them or with their cement
silty/clayey soils are in most cases 60% or more lower stabilized mixtures showed a high degree of perfor-
than their unsoaked values. This means that the mance and durability provided the construction was
strength or bearing capacity of the subgrade, sub-base properly performed with good shoulders and drain-
or base course built with such materials will be age. This clearly shows that durable roads can be built
reduced by more than half of its strength (at the time in the Niger Delta with the so-called substandard soil
of construction) if allowed to absorb additional water. materials once the design and construction methods
take into account the poor geotechnical properties of
the soils and the environmemal conditions.
Suitability of the soils for base course
construction Proposed pavement design
The specifications for mechanically stable base course In designing flexible road pavements for the Niger
materials stipulate: (1) a certain particle size Delta, it is important to consider the following factors
distribution to ensure high dry density when which greatly influence their performance: (i) amount
compacted and (2) certain amounts of fines and levels of traffic, (ii) soil properties and sub-surface
of plasticity which ensure preservation of both wet occurrence of highly compressible organic clays and
and dry strength. In addition, 80% unsoaked CBR is peat and (iii) drainage, seasonal flooding and depth to
specified for light traffic roads. A comparison of the water table.
soil properties of the Niger Delta with the Nigerian Three categories of roads exist in the Niger Delta,
Estimated thickness
Percentage Plas- (ram)
passing Plastic ticity 150 to 450 450 to 1000
0.074mm limit index Soaked commercial commercial
Subgrade material sieve (%) (%) CBR traffic traffic
Sandy loam/sandy clay 17-40 33-45 10-19 8-18 300 350
Silty clay/clay 60-94 38-65 15-35 2-5 600 700
they are: (i) expressways, over 1500 commercial sub-b;:~se should be a 1:1 mix (by weight) of the silty
vehicles per day (e.g. Port Harcourt-Aba express- clay/day and either the underlying uniformly graded
way); (ii) trunk roads, 450 to 1500 commercial sand or dredged river channel sands. The base course
vehicles per day (e.g. East-West highway, Port can be made up of the same soil materials as the
Harcourt-Owerri road); (iii) all other public roads, sub-base, but stabilized with varying proportions of
150 to 450 commercial vehicles per day. Only the last cement (e.g. sandy loam/sandy clay with 4% cement
two categories will be considered because it is very and 1:1 mix of silty clay/clay and sand with 6%
unlikely that expressways of any length will be built in cement). The soil/cement mixture must be compacted
the region in the immediate future. The annual to at least 100% B.S. and should also possess a
growth rates o f commercial traffic are not expected to maximum 7 day compressive strength of 1720 kN/m 2
exceed 6% and a 10 year design life will be assumed (~250 psi). The minimum thickness of the bituminous
for all roads. surface dressing should be 50mm. The suggested
Two major groups of natural subgrade materials thicknesses of the different pavement layers are given
occur in the region: (a) sandy loams/sandy clays found in Fig. 8.
in the permanently dry land and (b) silty clays/clays The use of a cement stabilized mixture of local in
which occur in the seasonally flooded fresh/salt water situ soil and uniformly graded sand has been
swamps and meander belt. The geotechnical pro- successful in the recent construction of a 2.5 km dual
perties (ranges) of these two groups of soils relevant carriageway access road to the National Fertilizer
to pavement design are given in Table 5. Using the Company Ltd (NAFCON), Onne, near Port Har-
standard CBR design procedure (Road Note 29, court. A similar construction method was used for the
1970; Road Note 31, 1971) which combines subgrade 10 year old Western Avenue dual carriageway in
CBR and a cumulative number of standard axles, the Lagos.
minimum total thicknesses of the pavements over the It is suggested that shoulders should be constructed
two types of subgrade materials range from 300 to with the same materials and specifications as the
700 mm for a daily traffic of 150 to 1500 commercial sub-base and paved with a 10 to 25 mm single coat of
vehicles. The in situ subgrade material should be surface bituminous dressing. The soil/cement base
compacted to 100% B.S. and embankments built with course is impermeable and therefore does not need
the same material to bring the finished road level to at separate drainage. However, the slope (3 to 5%), the
least i m above the envisaged maximum water level. cross falls and the size (1 to 2 m) of the side ditches
Where highly compressible organic clays or peat occur must be adequate to facilitate the high runoff of the
on or near the surface, they must be excavated. equitorial rain forest region. Where shoulders are
As mentioned earlier, no standard conventional unpaved, they must be densely grassed to prevent
base course materials with the required gradings, erosion. Good drainage is essential since all road
plasticity and a minimum unsoaked CBR of 80% failures occur during the rainy season.
occur naturally in the Niger Delta. The use of cement
stabilized base course with adequate sub-base is
suggested in preference to the expensive haulage of Conclusion
acceptable base materials from distances exceeding
80 km. In the permanently dry lands, the sub-base can The following conclusions can be drawn from the
be constructed with the in situ soil, compacted to at present study.
least 95% modified A A S H O and with a minimum
soaked CBR of 8%. In the case of the seasonally (1) The very poor pavement performance of roads
flooded swamps, similar compaction and CBR in the seasonally flooded areas is primarily caused by
specifications are suggested but the composition of the the use of highly substandard soil materials. Other
B
A Z/lll//.,~5 0 m,f "/////.~
I I I i t / I i
"/////A.-lo~/,~ i i / / i / / /
/ / / / / / / / i
/ / / / / / / / / I , I 550 I m Zm r
,/ ,
! / / / / / /
/ / /300 mm / / / / / / / / /
/ / / / / / / /
/ / / / / / / /
/ / i / / I / / z/////,d5 o mm ~//////,d
9 i.
"//////AS O mm~//I/I/~ I I / i l l / i1
/ I / / I I l l l
:i i ! z //50ram// / 9 / , ,~v~.,'llllll,, t / / /
...-.. '. 3 0 0 m m :- .... 9..: 350mm ...:.:i. I I I I / I / / /
..... / / / t / / / /
-9-:. C .B .R. . B. - 2. 4. ,:
! ( c a r e- 24 ::~::
..........-... 9 ...r ..~.
...... -..- ..... ..: .......
::.: :.: 150 m m :i:):.:::. :.......: . . . . . . .
...... :
9 .. ..... .... . 9 ..., .-.........: ..
I:!::ICBR 8 - 24 !'7::
,..- .;~,., ..... : . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . : . . . .
-:~:CBR 8 - 24)i~:.)
-; : : ~ . . : : : . , . . , . . . . . , . , . ~ . . . : ; ; : /
7///////, "////////,
Subgrade Subgrade 5ubgrade Subgrade
CBR 2 - 5 CBR 2 - 5 CBR 8 - I O CBR 8 - 18
Bituminous surfacing
Cement stabilized base
Compacted sub-bose
important contributary factors include poor design, a AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR TESTING MATERIALS 1979. Annual
high water table and failure to adhere to design Book of American Society for Testing and Materials
specifications. Standards.
(2) None of the in situ soils of the Niger Delta BRITISH STANDARDS INSTITUTE 1975. Methods of Testing
meets the standard specifications of acceptable base Soils for Civil Engineering Purposes. British Standard
1924.
course materials; they therefore require cement CARMICHEAL, R. F. 1982. The role of visual conditions
stabilization. surveys in pavement management systems. Report
(3) A pavement design (using the local soil RI-Y2, Presented to the Rhode Island Department of
materials) that would ensure good performance in any Transportation, Providence, R.I.
part of the Niger Delta should consist of a cement --, SEEDS, S. B., HUDSON, W. R. & ZANIEWSKI, J. P.
stabilized base course, well compacted sub-base and 1981. Pavement performance model development.
subgrade and good drainage. Report for the Federal Highway and Water Administra-
tion, Washington, D.C.
CHANG, G. J., PHANG, G. W. A. & WRONG, G. A. 1975.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT. This study was funded by the Senate Manual for condition rating of flexible pavements'
Research grant of the University of Port Harcourt, Port distress manifestatiom. Ontario Ministry of Transport
Harcourt. and Communications.
ROAD NOTE 29 1970. A guide to the structural design of
pavements for new roads, 3rd edn. Road Transport and
References Research Laboratory, Department of the Environment,
Her Majesty's Service Organization, London.
AKPOKODJE, E. G. 1979. The importance of engineering ROAD NOTE 31 1971. A Guide to the structural design of
geological mapping in the development of the Niger bitumen-surfaced road~ in tropical and subtropical
Delta Basin. Bulletin of the International Association of countries, 3rd edn. Transport and Road Research
Engineering Geology, 19, 101-8. Laboratory. Department of the Environment, Her
~ 1 9 8 6 . A method of reducing the cement content of two Majesty's Service Organization, London.
stabilized Niger Delta soils. Quarterly Journal of SHAHIN, M. Y. & KOHN, S. D. 1979. Development of a
Engineering Geology, London, 19, 359-63. pavement condition rating procedure for roads, streets
1987. The engineering-geological characteristics and and parking lots, Vol. 1. Technical Report M-268,
classification of the major superficial soils of the Niger Construction Engineering Research Laboratory, United
Delta. Engineering Geology (in press). States Army Corps of Engineers.
ALLEN, J. R. 1965. Coastal geomorphology of eastern SHORT, K. C. & STAUBLE, A. J. 1967. Outline of the geology
Nigeria Beach Ridge Barrier Islands and vegetated tidal of the Niger Delta. American Association of Petroleum
flats. Geologie en Mijnbouw, 44, 1, 1-21. Geologist Bulletin, 51, 761-79.