Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Criticism and dissent are one of the foundations of democracy, hence, public officials must
tolerate, nay, welcome criticisms. According to Amartya Sen (1999), democracy is universal and has
three values to it: intrinsic value, instrumental value, and constructive value. The first value of
democracy is intrinsic value which means that it has value in and of itself. Humanity, and the universe
for that matter, is better off with it than without it. But for the purpose of this essay, the second and the
third values will be given emphasis. Democracy has instrumental value because it has a utilitarian
function. The leaders of a nation are incentivized to be responsible and accountable to the people
because citizens can count on their leaders to listen to their demands. It is in this symbiotic relationship
we find that when leaders fail to heed to the calls of their citizens, the breakdown of the system
becomes possible. When leaders dismiss criticisms or cause the arrest of critics, we begin to see such
leaders turn their back from responsibility and accountability to the people. The constructive value of
democracy, the third value according to Amartya Sen, is the ability of the people to conceive and
articulate their needs through criticisms and dissent. When people are allowed to freely voice out what
is perceived to be lacking in the provision of public goods, the people and the state can work on to
improve it. In the Philippine context, the people are calling out the lack of transparency and the
government’s failure to deliver its social services. The right of the people to participate in the public
dialogue must be protected at all times. On the side of public officials, they should welcome criticisms as
that imposes a code of conduct and ethical standards for Filipino public officials. In Section 2 of Republic
Act 6713 (1989), it declares that, “Public officials and employees shall at all times be accountable to the
people and shall discharge their duties with utmost responsibility”. The law further implores Filipino
public officials to uphold democratic virtues at all times. The will and the freedom of the people are
supreme.
References
Sen, A. (1999). Democracy as a Universal Value. Journal of Democracy. 10(3). 3-17. Retrieved August 8,
%20number%20follows%20the,(2011).
Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees. Republic Act No. 6713.
https://lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra1989/ra_6713_1989.html#:~:text=Public%20officials
%20and%20employees%20shall,public%20interest%20over%20personal%20interest.