Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/272498366
CITATIONS READS
0 4,505
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Nikhil Gakkhar on 06 April 2015.
Abstract-The supply of freshwater is a key element for the society. Ground water and rainfall are not always sufficiently
available in India, so alternative sources to provide fresh water are gaining imporlance these days. India being a tropical
country has solar radiation of 4-7 kW /hr for 300 sunny days which can be utilized to provide alterative source for distillation
technologies. In the couple of decades, the traditional solar desalination processes such as Reverse osmosis (RO), Multi stage
flash (MSF), Multi effect distillation (MED) and Electro-dialysis (ED) have been evolved to a wider extent. This paper reviews
various active and passive solar distillation/desalination research activities that have been developed in India. Though solar
desalination technologies have not been commercialized yet in India, with current ongoing research they have huge potential
for future. Thisresearch paper tries to investigate the current trends and future scope of solar distillation technologies in Indian
context.
INTRODUCTION
The provision of fresh water is becoming an increasingly important issue in many areas of the world. In arid
areas potable water is very scarce and the establishment of a human habitat in these areas strongly depends on
how such water can be made available as it is very much essential for life. Water is one of the most abundant
resources on earth, covering three fourths of the planet's surface. About 97% of the earth's water is saline water
in the oceans and 3% (about 36 millionkm3of volume) is fresh water contained at the poles (in the form of ice),
ground water, lakes and rivers, which supply most of human and animal needs. Nearly, 70% of this 3% fresh
water is in the form of glaciers, snow cover, ice and permafrost. Thirty percent of all fresh water is available
deep underground. lakes and rivers together contain a little more than 0.25% of all fresh water; lakes contain
most of it. The sustainable use of this freshwater is main concern for human beings and animals.
India's rapidly rising population, growing economy and changing lifestyles account for continues increase in
demand for fresh water. Thisleads to scarcity of fresh water and decrease in water table in many parts of India.
This problem is mainly due to irrational use of this precious resource by human beings. Many parts of India faces
a huge water scarcity because of unplanned mechanism and pollution created by manmade activities. According
-
to the annual report on Ground Water Year Book India (201 2) by the Ministry of Wat.er Resources, the state of
Rajasthan faces maximum depth of ground water level among other states [1]. The lowest depth to water level
recorded in th~ state of Rajasthan during November 2012 is 113.53m below ground level in Bikaner district.
In many areas of Gujarat and Rajasthan, people are facing freshwater problems but fortunately these areas II
are getting more amount of solar energy, which can be used to provide sustainable, technology for fresh water t
supply. Certain regions of Haryana and Maharashtra have ground saline water in spite of high rain fall.
}
The sustainable solution to provide fresh water supply for.human needs can be the utilization from 97% of the
,
available saline water. In this context many conventional and non conventional techniques have been developed I
for water purification. Among these, solar assisted water 'purification techniques are promising among others.
India, being a tropical country, is blessed with plenty of sunshine. The average daily solar radiation varies
I
between 4 and 7 kWh per square meter for different part of the country [2]. There are on an average 250-300 I
clear sunny days a ye"r through which it receives about 5000 trillion kWh of solar energy in a year. The highest
\
annual global radiation is received in Rajasthan and northern Gujarat. Thus solar energy technology for water f
purification can prove to be sustainable solution for this issue. I
j
WATER PURIFICATIONFROM SOLAR ENERGY
The solar energy assisted water purification depends on the nature of Total Dissolved Solids (TDS)in the water
content. TDS level of more than 35000 ppm is referred as saline water, while less th~n 10000 ppm as brackish
water. Permissible limit of TDS in fresh water is just 500 ppm. Desalination techniques, which are used for
from
a conventional fossil-fuel source like coal or from a renewable energy source like solar, biomass etc. with the
systems like MEF evaporators, solar stills etc. Solar Photovoltaic panels can be used to provide electricity for the
ROsystems,electrolysis etc.
Useof solar energy for distillation can be categorized into direct collection systems where solar energy is
usedto produce distillate directly in the solar collector, and indirect collection systems, where two sub-systems are
employed,one for solar energy collection and other for distillation. The solar still, which is widely used process
for solardistillation,works on direct collection principle. Butsolar stills require large area for the process and the
efficiencyof these systems are quite low [3]. The use of concentrating solar energy for distillation can prove to
be a suitable solution to the existing challenges [4].
Solar
SOlar Distillation Desalination
Direct Indirect
Multi Effect
Passive Electro-dialysis Distillation
Thermal Vapor
Compressor
Memberane
Distillation
Concentrating Solar Power (CSP) uses direct sunlight and mirrors to boil water instead of a fossil fuel as a heat
sourcefor producing' steam and drive conventional steam turbines in case of power generation. At present, there
are four main CSPsystems which can be categorized by the way they focus the sun'srays and the technology used
to receivethe sun'senergy. These systems are classified by their focus geometry as either line-focus concentrators
(Parabolic Trough Collectors (PTC)and linear Fresnel collectors) or as point-focus concentrators (central receiver
systems, parabolic dishes and Scheffler systems). CSP has several advantages by having higher efficiencies,
lower investment costs, an inherent thermal storage capacity that enables steam generation during cloud cover
or after sunset and a better .hybrid operation capability with other fuels to meet base-load demand at night [5].
Desalination process has been used for hundreds of years to produce fresh water by the sailors during sea voyage.
The literature review showed wide range of researches on desalination technologies all over the world, but a very
few on distillationprocess in Indian context using CSP.A detailed review work on solar stillcoupled withactive
solar distillation system was done by Sampathkum<;lret al. [6]. The authors stated that the concentrator assisted
regenerative solar stillhad muchhigher thermal efficiencythan the flat plate collector assisted regenerative still
at all water depths and they inferred that there was less thermal loss in the concentrator compared to the flat
plate collector panel. They concluded that the direct stream generation parabolic trough is a promising technology
for solar assisted seawater desalination. Tiwari and Tiwari [7] had done an experimental performance analysis
and thermal modelling of single slope passive solar still for different inclination of condensing covers mainly 15°,
30° and 45°. Each experiment was conducted for about 24 h for New Delhi climatic conditions. They observed
that the 15° inclination of condensing cover gave maximum annual yield and distillation efficiency. Dwivedi and
Tiwari [8] had done energy and exergy analyses of single and double slope passive solar stills on the basis of
annual experimental data for water depth of 0.01,0.02 and 0.03 m.
Tripathi and Tiwari [9] extending work done by Tiwari and Tiwari [7] by conducting experiment to study the
effect of water depth on internal heat and mass transfer for active solar distillation systems. They conducted
experiments for 24 hours during winter months for different water depths in the basin (0.05, 0.1 and 0.15 m)
for passive as well as active solar distillation systems. They studied the effect of different water depths in the
basin on the heat and mass transfer coefficients and observed that more yield was obtained during the off shine
hours as compared to daytime for higher water depths in solar still (0.10 m and 0.1 5 m) due to storage effect.
Later, Tiwari et a/. [10] studied the performance of an active solar distillation system and evaluated theoretical
yield from the active solar stills integrated with flat plate collector, concentrating collector and evacuated tube
collector (with and without heat pipe). In the month of December 2005, for hourly basis they evaluated fresh
water output, exergy efficiency, and overall thermal efficiency of active solar stills for 0.05 m water depth for
the climatic conditions of New Delhi. They found that the active solar still integrated with evacuated tube collector
with heat pipe has the maximum yield of 4.24 kg/m2'day.
. Tiwari et a/. [11] studied thermal.analysis of solar distillation to optimize the inclination of glass cover for
maximum yield. Further, the effect of inclination on the internal heat and mass transfer relations, the water and
glass cover temperature had. been studied. They observed that the yield increases with increase of inclinationin
winter and" vice-versa in summer and there was a significant reduction in evaporative heat transfer co-efficient
with increase of inclination in summer and winter. Bhagwan and Tiwari [12] published a paper in which the
effect of climate and design parameters on active solar desalination unit was studied. Based on steady state
conditions an analytical expression for hourly yield had been derived for a typical day of Delhi climatic cqndition.
They compared results with single effect active solar distillation unit and found significant improvement in the
performance for minimumflow rate of water in upper basin.
Tiwari & Sinha [13] carried out the 'analysis of an active regenerative solar still on the basis of energy
balances for its different components. They derived analytical expressions for w.ater and glass temperatures,
daily yield and thermal efficiency as a function of climatic as well as design parameters. They observed that
passive regenerative solar still has better thermal efficiency than that of active regenerative solar stills and
thermal efficiency also increases with increase in the water flow velocity.
Kumar and Bai [14] performed an. experiment on a basin type solar still (0.5 m2)with improved condensation
. technique using tap water, seawater and industry effluent as raw water source. They observed that the
I Area = 1m x 1m Maximum
I Bestoption
2009 Velmurugan, Solar still coupled Still angle: 10° productivity of for industrial [24]
Madurai with solar pond Dimensionof Solar 80% is achieved
Pond: 0.9xO.3xO.3 m3 applications
I during this.
Energy Desalination
Year Author Source Capacity Remarks
Details Technology Reference I
Further research work on solar still as discussed in references [1 6-1 9] is summarized along with other
researchworks as presented in Table 1. Besides solar still prominent research work on solar desalination using
CSPtechnology,over the world, is tabulated in Table 2. It is important to mention here that a very little research
hasbeenfound related to solar desalination based on non solar still technology specially in Indian context.
Asdiscussedin previous section, desalination technologies can be classified according to nature of technology used.
TheMSFis most common technique of distillation. MSF is currently the workhouse of the desalination technology
with a marketshare of around 60 % of the total world production capacity. Another desalination technique
suchas MED is also very popular. Membrane processes such as RO are currently fast growing desalination
techniquein world. The RO system depends on the properties of semi-permeable membranes, which, when used
to separatewater from a salt solution, allow freshwater to pass into the brine compartment under the influence of
osmoticpressure. If a pressure in excess of this value is applied to the salty solution, freshwater will pass from into
thewatercompartment. Theoretically, the only energy requirement is to pump the feedwater at a pressure above
osmoticpressure.The first country to use desalination on a large scale for municipal drinking water production
wasKuwait,in the Middle East [36] when the first industrial desalination plant opened in in 1960 [37]. In India
alsothe two major desalination plants in Tamil Nadu (Minjur and Nemmeli) are based on RO processes.
Minjur Seawater Desalination Plant
TheMinjur Desalination Plant is a reverse osmosis, water desalination plant at Kattupalli village, Chennai, India.
Locatedon the coast of the Bay of Bengal it provides fresh water to the city of Chennai. Built on a 60-acre site, it
isthe largest desalination plant in India with a capacity of 96000 m3/ day. The Minjur desalination plant consists
of 8600 seawater RO membranes, 248 pressure vessels, 23 pressure exchangers, five high-pressure pumps and
16 pressurefilter vessels which are electrically automated and controlled. The final water product from the RO
systemundergoes the post-treatment process and produces 100 mid of desalinated water from 273 million litres
of seawater.
TheNemmeliDesalination Plant is second desalination plant in India based on a reverse osmosis, and locateed
onthe coast of the Bay of Bengal to provide water supply to the city of Chennai. It is located about 35 km south
of the Chennai city. Built at a cost of f 5333.8 million, the plant is has a capacity to treat 100 million liters of
seawatera day (MLD).
, ,
Many other countries have begun to utilize desalination for drinking water production, but no other region of
theworld has implemented desalination on as large a scale as the M,iddle East [38]. Many researchers discussed
the desalination p~ocesswith RO [37,~9] for drinking water production, but a few researchers have done work
on groundwater distillation. The household RO units for groundwater distillation causes 75 to 85 percent of the
water rejection in northern part of India viz. Rajasthan. The commercial disadvantage of RO is its high power
and maintenance cost also the system is highly sensitive to membrane fouling [40]. The desalination with using
RO processhave been dealt ,by many researchers with the use of solar technologies [41-44]majority of the
experimental investigations focused on solar coupled thermally driven conventional desalination technologies
suchas Multi-Stage Flash (MSF.
FUTURESCOPE
In past few years, development of various desalination technologies in India is really apprecia~le. Chennai has
two desalination plants based on RO process. RO process may be a reliable technique to supply fresh water, but
it is far from being the most sustainable solution because of high rejection rate. Alternative,s such as use of solar
energycan be a better solution as it is sustainable in nature. India, being a tropical country, is blessed with plenty
of sunshine.The average daily solar radiation varies between 4 and 7 kWh per square meter for different part
of the country. There are on an average 300 clear sunny days a year. Thus,it receives about 5000 trillion kWh of
Solar Distillation Technologies in India: Past, Present and Future. 85
.
~ ICORE2014
solar energy in a year. The highest annual global radiation is received in Rajasthan and northern Gujarat which
promises huge potential for solar desalination plant in these areas.
Another option can be Solar thermal energy coupled with MEDtechnology as such systems are more flexible,
less expensive and give better performance than MSF system [43]. RO system driven by solar photovoltaic works
for small standalone applications [45].
Over the past few decades lot of developments took place for seawater desalination processes. The various
areas of improvements may be the technical and economical aspects of various desalination processes; hybrid
systems such as MSF-RO, MED-RO and PV driven RO systems for desalination; material selection for plant
construction like flash chamber, membrane modules etc.; prevention and control of scale and corrosion in pipelines;
and environmental aspects of brine discharge.
CONCLUSION
Solar energy can be used to provide sustainable solution for fresh water supply. As per the liferature, the use of
solar energy in desalination process is one of the best applications of renewable energy all over the world. This
paper reviewed the development of various desalination technologies from simple passive solar still to various
active solar desalination technologies, in Indian context. Most of the work 'on water distillation and desalination
has been done using solar still. System modification to improved efficiency and output are proposed by many
researchers. The desalination using MSF technology, either standalone or integrated with power plant system are
attempted by few researchers for Indian conditions. There are two desalination plants in Chennai namely Minjur
and Nemmeli which are based on Reverse Osmosis (RO) process.
The desalination using solar energy has huge potential in coming future. Various areas of India such as
Rajasthan and Gujarat where there is plenty of solar radiation can be used for the Solar Desalination. Based
upon review and discussion it is important to pay attention to the environment, mainly to produce fresh and clean
water without causing harm to the environment.
REFERENCES
1. Ground Water Year Book- India 2011-12. Central Ground Water Board, Ministryof Water Resources2012.
2. Soni MS, Gakkhar N. Techno-economicparametric assessment of solar power in India: A survey. Renewableand
SustainalJle Energy Reviews 2014;40:326-34. .
3. AI-Kharabsheh S, Yogil\Goswami D. Analysis of an innovative water desalination system using low-grade solar
heat. Desalination 2003; 156:323-32.
4. LiC. Innovative Desalination Systems Using Low-grade Heat. University of South Florida, 2012.
5. . Ummadisingu A, Soni Ms. Concentrating solar power-technology, potential and P9licy in India. Renewable and
'Sustainable Energy Reviews 2011 ; 15:5169-75.
6. Sampathkumar K, Arjunan TV,Pitchandi P, Senthilkumar P..Active solar distillation--A detailed review. Renewable
arid Sustainable Energy Reviews 2010; 14: 1503-26.
7. Tiwari AK, Tiwari GN. Thermal modelling based on solar fraction and experimental study of the annual and
seasonal performance of a single slope passive solar still:the effect of water depths. Desalination 2007;207: 184-
204. .
8. Dwivedi VK,Tiwari GN. Annual Energy and Exergy Analysis of Single and Double Slope Passive Solar Stills.Trends
in Applied Sciences Research 2008;3. .
9. Tripathi R, Tiwari GN. Effect of water depth on internal heat and mass transfer for active solar distillation.
Desalination 2005; 173: 187-200.
1O. Tiwari GN, Dimri V, Singh U, Chel' A, Sarkar B. Comparative thermal performance evaluation of an active solar
distillation system. International Journal of Energy Research 2007;31: 1465-82. .
11. Tiwari GN, ThomasJM, Khan E. Optimisation of glass cover inclinationfor maximumyield in a solar still.Heat
RecoverySystemsand CHP 1994; 14:447-55. .
12. Prasad B, Tiwari GN. Analysis of double effect active solar distillation. Energy Conversion and Management
1996;37: 1647-56.
13. Tiwari GN, Sinha S. Parametric studies of active regenerative solar still. Energy Conversion and Management
----
ICORE2014
1993;34:209-18.
14. Vinoth Kumar K, Kasturi Bai R. Performance study on solar still with enhanced condensation. Desalination
2008;230:51-61.
15. Arjunan T V, Aybar HS, Nedunchezhian N, Sakthivel M. Effect of blue metal stones on the performance of a
conventional solar still. Journal of Convergence in Engineering, Technology and Science 2009; 1:17-22.
16. Gomkale SD. Solar desalination as a means to provide Indian villages with drinking water. Desalination
1988;69: 171-6.
17. Edla PJ, Sonkar N. Solar Water Purifier For Indian Villages - A Review 2013;2: 1758-63.
18. TiwariGN, Singh HN, Tripathi R. Present status of solar distillation. Solar Energy 2003;75:367-73.
19. Ranjan KR,Kaushik SC, Panwar NL. Energy and exergy analysis of passive solar distillation systems. International
Journalof Low-CarbonTechnologies2013:1-11. .
20. TiwariGN, Garg HP.Effect of water flow over the glass cover of a single basin solar still with an intermittent flow
of waste hot water in the basin. Energy Conversion and Management 1985;25:315-22.
21. KumarS, Sinha S. Transient model and comparative study of concentrator coupled regenerative solar still in forced
circulationmode. Energy Conversion and Management 1996;37:629-36.
22. KumarS, Tiwari GN. Performance evaluation of an active solar distillation system. Energy 1996;21 :805-8.
23. KumarS, Tiwari GN. Estimation of internal heat transfer coefficients of a hybrid (PV/T) active solar still. Solar
Energy 2009;83: 1656-67.
Velmurugan V, Pandiarajan S, Guruparan P, Subramanian LH,PrabQharan CD, Srithar K. Integrated performance
of stepped and single basin solar stills with mini solar pond. Desalination 2009;249:902-9.
25. Schwarzer K, Vieira ME, Faber C, MUlier C. Solar thermal desalination system with heat recovery. Desalination
2001; 137:23-9.
26. Garcia-rodriguez L, Palmero-marreroa AI, Gbmez-camachob C. Comparison of solar thermal technologies for
applicationsin seawater desalination. Desalination2002; 142:135-42. .
27. Vander Bruggen B,Vandecasteele C. Distillation vs. membrane filtration: overview of process evolutions in seawater
desalination. Desalination 2002; 143:207-18.
28. LeblancJ, Akbarzadeh A, Andrews J. Modelling Solar-Thermal Desalination Systems. Australian and New Zealand
Solar Energy Society (ANZSES)--2005 Solar Conference, 2005, p. 28-30.
29. Chaouchi B, Zrelli A, Gabsi S. Desalination of brackish water by means of a parabolic solar concentrator.
Desalination 2007;217: 118-26.
30. Nafey AS, Mohamad MA, EI-Helaby SO, Sharaf MA. Theoretical and experimental study of a small unit for solar
desalination using flashing process. Energy Conversion and Management 2007;48:528-38.
31. ScrivaniA, EIAsmar T, Bardi U. Solar trough concentration for fresh water production and waste water treatment.
Desalination 2007;206:485-93.
32. BlancoJ, Palenzuela P,Alarcon-Padilla D,Zaragoza G, Ibarra M. Preliminary thermoeconomic analysis of combined
parabolic trough solar power and desalination plant in port Safaga (Egypt). Desalination and Water Treatment
2013;51: 1887-99.
33. ZhaniK.Solar desalination based on multiple effect humidification process: Thermal performance tlnd experimental
validation. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2013;24:406-17.
34. LiC, Goswa.mi.Y, Stefanakos E. Solar assisted sea water desalination - A review. Renewable and Sustainable
Energy Reviews 2013; 19: 136-63.
35. Riffat S, Maye.re A. Performance evaluation of v-trough solar concentrator for water desalination applications.
Applied Thermal Engineering 2013.
36. KhawajiAD,Kutubkhanah IK,Wie J-M. Advances in seawater desalination technologies. Desalination 2008;221 :47-
69.
37. Amjad Z. Reverse Osmosis: Membrane Technology, Water Chemistry, and Industrial Applications. New York:
Chapman & Hall, International Thomson Publishing; 1993.
38. Greenlee LF,Lawler DF,Fr~eman BD,Marrot B, Moulin P. Reverse osmosis desalination: water sources, technology,
and today's challenges. Water Research 2009;4.3:2317-48.
39. Nebbia G, Menozzi GN. A short history of water desalinati<;m. Federazione delle Associazioni Scientifiche e
Techniche; 1966.
40. HsuiC-Y. The optimal allocating pumping rate of a multi-well system for a brackish water desalination plant.
Desalination 2008;221 :215-24.
41. Abraham T, Luthra A. Socio-economic & technical assessment of photovoltaic powered membrane desalination
III
~-- -._~...-
~
U ICORE2014