Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The efficiency of Integrative Gestalt Therapy on the decrease of undesired types of behaviour measured by the
AAMD scale (Part two) in children with intellectual disabilities has been demonstrated in the authors' earlier
works. The object of this work is to state the effects of the same therapeutic method on the intellectual aspects
of social competence in the children with difficulties, as measured by the AAMD scale (Part one). Integrative
Gestalt Therapy emphasises the wholeness of a person's body, intellect and soul in the social and ecological
environment to which the person is undividedly linked. lt is a multidimensional and multimodal method, a
method that causes changes on different levels, changes of physical, social-interactive and cognitive structure.
Integrative GestaltTherapy has been applied as a group therapy during a period of one year on 13 children
with intellectual disabilities, aged between 7-'l 1 years. The participants have been chosen primarily for their
record in psychological problems and undesired behaviour. As the samples in question were dependent on the
analysis of change of a sample of participants described by a set of quantitative variables in the initial and final
state, a component model was applied. Results show statistically significant progress in the intellectual aspects
of social intelligence.
key words: Integrative Gestalt Therapy, undesired types of behaviour
INTRODUCTION
l\ aily life skills and habits will in this work social competence (Hogg & Mittler, 1983;
lJ be examined according to the Greenspan Grossman, 1983; Gresham & Reschly, 1987;
model of general competence (Greenspan & Guralnik, 1989; Guralnik, 1990). Writing
Granfield, 1992).In this model, competence about social competence, the authors
has two main categories: social competence stress its different components: the
and instrumental competence, both of adequacy of social behaviour regarding
which have intellectual and non-intellectual the norms of the social community, which
components. Persons with mental retar- manifests itself in adaptive behaviour and
dation show considerable deficits in the social skills; the existence or non-existence
intellectual field, more specifically in the of relations with peers; the registration of
fields of practical and social intelligence some specific asocial behaviours; be-
(intellectual aspects of social competence), haviour estimates by adults and peers; as
as well as conceptual intelligence and
information processing (intellectual aspects Anamarija Zic, U. a., Department of Mental Retardation,
of instrumental competence). Faculty of Special Education and Rehabilitation, University
As successful socialisation and adaptation of Zagreb. Branko NikoliC, Ph.D., Department of Logopedics,
Faculty of Special Education and Rehabilitation, University
can partially amend for a conceptual of Zagreb. Ljiljana lgric, Ph.D., is a professor at the Depart-
intelligence and information processing ment of Mental Retardation, Faculty of Special Education
and Rehabilitation, University of Zagreb.
dissability, numerous researchers have Correspondence to: Faculty of Special Education and Reha-
concentrated on the problem of social bilitation, University of Zagreb, Ku5lanova 59a, 10000 Zagreb,
behaviour, often within the framework of Croatia
143
I
144
Crutian Review of Relnbilitation Research 1997, Vol 37, No. 2, pp lll:!!2
therapy can be understood either as a In integrative therapy the elements of
extension of gestalt therapy with the behaviour therapy, psychoanalysis and
incorporation of other elements (active gestalt therapy are present. lt is based on a
psychoanalysis, psychodrama, body the- hermeneutic, theoretical gestalt and system-
rapy), or as an entirely new method which atic theoretical approach, incorporated in
includes gestalt therapy. (Perzold, 1988). such a way that the theoretical and metho-
The therapy takes individuals as wholes, dological characteristics are preserved. This
in their constant interaction with the content of integrative therapy enables
surrounding systems, so interventions complex insight and different action possibi-
directed primarily towards emotional lities. Different methods consist of different
reactions influence the area of affect, but diagnostic methods and different thera-
also, the areas of behaviour and learning. peutical methods, connected respectively by
The person is a living system marked by his/ the principle of synopsis (common view-
her identity, based on which he/she establi- point) and the principle of synergy (common
shes relations with other systems. By his/her action). (Petzold, 1 988)
contacts with the environment the person
experiences his/her personality and indivi-
OBJECTIVE AND HYPOTHESIS
duality.
Therapy work is concerned with the The objective of this work is to state the level
unmasking and elimination of senselessness of acquisition of daily life skills and habits
in the person's individual and social reality, in the group of pupils with learning disabi-
the constitution of meaning in intra- lities, who show behaviour disorders and to
organismic, intra-personal and inter-perso- find whether group work on principles of
nal relations, as well as in relations with the integrative gestalt therapy stimulates the
immediate and wider social and physical development of practical intelligence that
environment. Therapy contributes to the is skills and habits of daily life.
acticulation of sense in everydays situations. In accordance with this objective, the
Here sense is not regarded as a universal and following hypothesis has been set:
absolute truth, but consists of the person's H-l: After the application of grouP
perceiving, acting, feeling and thinking, integrative gestalt therapy in a group of
embedded in experiences and relationships. pupils with learning disabilities showing
Petzold (1988) stresses the close connec- behaviour disorders a statistically rele-
tion between the person and his/her vant improvement of the level of acqu-
environment, as a disturbed environment isition of daily life skills and habits will
always disturbs the biological organism as be observed.
well as the sensitive body subject (Leib-
Subject) and deforms its inner structure.
METHODS
Every influence, whether in the form of
interaction with systems in the environment Participants
or with connected elements of inner Thirteen children (9 boys and 4 girls) with
structure, results in multiple consequences learning disabilities, aged 7 to 12 (95 - 144
(the number of whom equals the number months) participated in this study. The
of existing connections). The person whose range of intellectual abilities, measured by
connections to the environment are distur- Wisc, ranged from lQ 54 to lQ 84. All of
bed will experience disturbances at the the participants lived with their own
physical, emotional and spiritual level, families and attended either regular or
which can manifestthemselves in different special schools in Zagreb. Seven children
intensities and in different areas (Petzold, had parents with lower educational back-
1988). grounds, five children had parents with
145
7
Procedure
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
ln the context of examination' integrative of the
qroup therapy was applied with the basic Practical intelligence as a component
iirlt encouriging the process of maturing' intellectual aspect of social competence
ir," *otf. lastJo iot on" school year' The r"nit"ttt itseli in the daily life-activities'
oarticipants were divided into three groups t""tut"O by the AAMD scale of adaptive
5...tAi^g't" their age' Each group worked --ih; Part l.
behaviour,
i"p"t"t"iy for 90 minutes once a week and acquisition of daily life.skills and
hJ ll ,""n."t. Group leadersPerls were socio- habits in the group of pupils with.learning
tfrerapists educated atthe Fritz
Institute JL"Uit iti"t, wFo show emotional difficulties
in Dusseldorf. and behaviour disturbances has been
The data were obtained in the interviews .otp"t"a to the normative for the children
with the parents of the children involved
in witfr mental retardation of the same age
out with
the therapy. An examination was carried GUt" 1). lt is apperent that the pupils
once nefore the beginning of the group i;;;;i^d disabiiiiies, in spite of emotional
*oif. and again ten months later' that is' O-itf i cu nles and behavi ou r d istu rba nces' have
after the experimental period was over' good level of acquisition of daily life
""iV
"stilts aid habits, compared to the normative
i.ttf," population of the mentally retarded'
Measuring instrument The paiameters of physical development
The intellectual aspect of social competence show that the pupils with learning disa-
*., t"ttured with the AAMD adaPtive Uititi"t in whom emotional difficulties and
(Part which measures the U"f,.uiour disturbances have been observed
tJtuiout scale l),
lt
of daily life skills and habits' have an average rate of physical develo-
"iquititi"n
inciudes 10 areas. ihe areas of Independent ot*,. Regard'ing themore cognitive area the
iunctioning, Physical development' Econo- iuoift obsJrved are communicative
Num- lni tot" operationswith numbers
mic activity, Language development' skilled in
activity' Self - of the population with
bers and iime,bomestlc and time than 90%
also have more
direction, Responsibility and Socialisation mental retardation' They
were used, while the Working activity area developed functional skills, and so are
*"t not included. (Nihira, Foster' Shellhaas among the 10% most independent compa-
- if,"
and Leland,1974) red t5 the population of the mentally
scale (revised 1975) was translated retarded of the same age' These results show
into Croatian. lt was adapted and standar- . f,igl',"t level of social responsibility' The
Oii"a. Finally, the measuring characteristics gtor-p of pupils with learning disabilities in
(lgric'
of the Croatian scale were established iuhot emotional difficulties and behaviour
Fulgosi-Masnjak, 1 991)' disturbances have been observed has more
initiatlue and persistence than 70% of the
population wiih mental retardation' and a
i'rijf,"t level of social interactions than 80%
of the letter group.
146
Croatian Review of Rehabilitation Research 1997, Vol 37, No. 2, pp 143-152
Toble Main statistical parameters in the MMD, Pan I for pupils with learning disabilities who show emotional dfficulties
I.
and. behaviour disturbances, their position in comparison to the normative for children with mental retardation and the main
statistical paraneters for children without development dfficulties
jffiEffffii'
,' ffiit' '*'
Independent f unctioning 86.585 9.1535 10 92.O 8.9 92.5 1 1.1
147
part II for pupils with leaming disabilities who show emotional dfficuhies
Table 2. Main statistical parameters in the AAMD,
retarddtion and the mttin
and behaviour rJisturbances, their position in comparison to the normative for children with mental
statistical parameters for children without development dfficulties
6r decils M2 62 M3 6-
,V€riables Mi
observed to attain lower levels in all areas sample regarding the behaviour distur-
of practical intelligence. The difference, bances has shown great social and personal
however, is always less than 2 standard inadaptation in the group of pupils with
deviations, so it could be said that, regarding learning disabilities (Table 2). In this group,
their adaptive behaviour in the area of antisocial behaviour, unacceptable vocal
practical intelligence, these pupils are not habits, unacceptable and unusual habits and
mentally retarded. In the majority of areas psychicological disturbances are more
their results are up to 1 standard deviation noticeable than in the 90% of the mentally
lower than the results of children without retarded. These pupils also more often
developmentdifficulties. The areas in wich the display violent and destructive behaviour,
difference is greater than 'l standard deviation rebel I ious behaviour, stereotyped behaviour
are self-direction and economic activity. and odd mannerisms, self-abusive beha-
Still, the comparison between the subjects viour, hyperactive tendencies and use of
with learning disabilities and the normative medications than 80% of the normative
148
Croatian Review of Rehabilinqon Research I99, V
that, although their level of personal and takes the greatest part in total improvement.
social adaptation is very low, these pupils lmportant contributions are also made by
have, compared to the population of the the variable Physical development, with a
mentally retarded, developed a high level correlation of (.8318), which also has a high
of daily life skills and habits, and compared function of change and a high discriminative
to the pupils without development diffi- coefficient (.5433). The results show that the
culties, attain results that are about one variables Economic activity (.6656) and Social
standard deviation lower than the average. interaction (.6459) each have a statistically
The results of research investigating the relevant correlation with the function of
influence of Integrative Gestalt Therapy on change in the acquisition of daily life skills
reducing behaviour disorders have been and habits.
reported by the authors at the First Congress It is apparent that, in the group taking
of the European Association for Mental part in lntegrative Gestalt Therapy, an
Health in Mental Retardation (lgric, Zic, improvement has been determined by an
Nikolic, 1995). Apart from the changes increase in the variables of lndependent
affecting behaviour disorders, changes in the functioning, in Physical development,
area of practical intelligence have been primarily in terms of perception and motor
monitored, through results of the AAMD activities, in the more skilful use of money
scale, Part l. and better relations with the social envi-
According to the parent's estimates, ronment. In other words, the improvement
pupils with learning disabilities in whom has been based on better personal indepen-
emotional difficulties and behaviour distur- dence and more successful social interaction.
bances have been observed have, after ten In the therapeutical work with pupils with
months treatment on the principles of learning disabilities we strove to create
Integrative Gestalt Therapy, shown statist- conditions in which the children would feel
ically significant improvement of level 0.1 safe and accepted. The interventions were
(F=10.2131, df 1=1, DF 2=13) in average directed towards the increase of body
values for daily life activities (Table 3). awareness, emotions, self-awareness and
A comparison of changes in the mean social-awareness. Contact with the healthy,
values from the initial to the final state has strong resources of each child was stressed,
Table 3. The anlysis of the progress of everyday life skills and habits measured with the
MMD scale. Part I (vommponent mrsdel)
Mg
Tabte 4. Structure of the function of change measured with the MMD scale, Part I (component model)
M
Vdiiab.la,,:, -.R
Legend:
R- correlation between the variables and the function of change
D - discriminative coefficient
M - mean of the difference in results
which is the premise of overcoming the emotional drives and our most complex
existing behaviour disorders. perceptive, affective and cognitive processes,
The analysis of the bodily functions of the i.e., the basis of our phenomenal body. The
children included in the therapy revealed a body is the primary border between the
perceptive limitations and expressive interior and the exterior, the place of contact
inhibition. Integrative Gestalt Therapy with other systems.
stresses the body as the basis of human Paying attention to the emotional area
existence, as a basis of the personal system. revealed that these children cannot differe-
In Integrative therapy we draw a distinction ntiate between the specific emotions and are
between the physical body, as the physical not ready to react on them. Dosage pro-
and biologicalorganism of the human being, blems are also observed. The therapy strove
and the phenomenal body, constituted by for the development of empathy, creativity
perceiving, sensing, communicating and and emotionalflexibility. The perception of
acting, as an "engaged subject" in which all social situations and possible reactions to
human abilities meet. The phenomenal body them were stimulated through stories and
expresses the whole person. role-playing. 5imultaneously, we worked on
A number of sessions focused on the environment-awareness, the perception of
body, as the element of the holistic "body- differences and similarities between group
m i nd-sou l-subject" system. Visua I a nd tacti le members, between important events in their
perception and oculo-motoric coordination, lives, and between behaviours their enviro-
i.e., body-awareness based on experiencing nment considers desirable and the ones it
one's own body, and its recePtive and does not.
expressive potential, were stimulated. The ln integrative therapy, therapeutic
body is the starting point of therapy, since changes are understood as interconnected
the entire interior structure of the personal processes of learning; these connections are
system is based on it. With the body we interpreted by the principle synergy (co-
perceive and act; it is the basis of our finest action). Petzold understands learning as a
150
Croatian Review of Rehabilitatiol R"se"rch 1997, Vol 37fu 143-152
multidimensional process which simulta- pupils with learning disabilities, who mostly
neously causes changes on different levels, experienced rejection by their peers, the
on physi nteractive
ca l, psych i co I og ica l, soci o-i therapeutical group become a place of
and cognitive structure. There are learning developing the experience of acceptance,
methods for each level, but the different trust and security, a place where their
methods do not exclude one another, but feelings were accepted with respect and
ratter cooperate. understanding. lt is probable that this
Thus, in work with children with learning experience brought increased self-respect
disabilities the learning was on the behavi- and self-security, based on which they were
oural level and, on the emotional level, more ready for co-operation, thoughtfulness
where knowledge is attained through toward others, awareness of others, and
emotional experience, but also on the participation in group activities, all of which
intellectual level, where it is attained are all elements of social interaction'
through insight (i. e., ideas and rules).
Integrative Gestalt Therapy influences a
person's totality in constant interaction with
CONCLUSION
other systems, so that interventions directed This work shows that the level of practical
toward emotional reactions influence the intelligence reflected in the acquisition of
affective area, but also the behavioural and daily life skills and habits in the group of
intellectual areas. pupils with learning disabilities and beha-
Body awareness was stimulated through vioural disorders is high in comparison with
experiencing one's own body, its functions the normative for the mentally retarded, but
and limitations, and its receptive and lower compared to the average population'
expressive potential. The development of After a 10 - month period of application
practical intelligence was also stimulated in of Integrative Gestalt Therapy, a statistically
the group work, which stressed indepen- significant improvement was found, which
dence, physical development, described in corresponds with the acceptance of the
terms of perceptive and motorical ability, research hypothesis. The function of change
communication and socialisation. lt is described here is determined by the increase
therefore hardly surprising that the incre- of independence, perceptive and motoric
ased independence in the independent ability, more skilful money-usage and more
functioning, which includes, among other successf ul socia I interaction.
things, feeding, caring for hygiene and Although primarily focused on the
dressing, is connected with physical develo- elimination and relief of behaviour disorders
pment. The sensitivity and expression in pupils with learning disabilities, Integra-
exercises stimulated body-awareness thro- tive Gestalt Therapy has proved to be
ugh positive body experiences, which helped efficient in stimulating the development of
the children increase thair attention toward practical intelligence. This shows the
themselves, toward their bodies. complexity of the effects of lntegrative
Simultaneously, self-identity was develo- Gestalt Therapy, which takes person as a
ping, based on the which the children whole, and the changes induced reflect with
created relations with their environment, different intensity on all areas of human
which reflected on social interaction. For functioning.
tqt
LITERATURE
Disorder in the Mentally
1. Dosen, A.: Developmental - dynamic relationship
therapy. In: Treatlneltl-o^f .llental lllnes and Behavioural
(Ed A. Dosen, A' van Gennep & G'J' Zwanikken) Logan
of the International congress, May 3rd- 4th, 1990
Retarded, Proceedings
Publications, Amsterdam state of the art'
behavioural disorders in mentally retarded individuals: the
2. Dojen, A.: Diagnosis and treatment of psychiatric and
Journal of Iniellectual Disabilities Research, 1g93, 37,
Supplement 1, 1-7.
p.: Meeting the emotional'needs of handicapp.i p.opt., a psycho - dynamic approach, Journal of Mental Deficiency
3. Frankish,
Research, 1989, 33, 407-414
Disabilities
difficulties within a social framework Journal of lntellectual
4. Frankish, p.: A psychodynamic approach to emotional
Research, 1992, 36, 559-563
in mentally retarded people: the
5. Gaedt, c.:
psychotherapeutic approaches in the treatment of mental illness and behavioural disorders
significance ot pry.no.i.iyt,ii,.itp.Jiu", Journal
of Intellectual Disabilities Research, 1995, vol' 39, 3' 233-239
graniiieti,lames M.: Reconsioering the.onstruct of retardation: lmplications of a model of social
b. Greenspan, Stephen a
--competence,AmericanJournalonMentalRetardation,vol'96'4'1992'Mz-qfi. -1911a1
behaviour'
7. Greshman, Frank M. & Reschly, Daniel J.: Dimension
oiro.iit competence: M-ethod factors in the assessment of adaptive
Psychology' vol'.25' 1987' 357-381
social skills, and peer....pitn,., Journal of School
programmes, Journal of Mental Deficiency Research'
g. Guralnick, Michael J.: Social competence as future direciion toi earfy intervention
1989, 33, 275-281
Early Intervention, Journal of Early Intervention' 1990'
l4' 1' 3-14
9. Guralnick, Michael J.:Social competence and
peer-Related Social Interactions of developmentally Delayed Young Children: Development and
10. Guralnick, M.J. & Weinhouse, E.:
Characteristics, Developmental Psychology, 1984 vol'
20' 5' 815-827
1 1. Guralnick, M.J. & Groom, J.:
correlates of Peer-Related so,i.icotp.t.n.e of Developmentally Delayed Pre-school children' American
Journal of Mental Deficiency, 1985, vol' 90, 2, 140-150 Research' volume
Handicapped People, u: Advances in Mental Handicap
12. Hogg, J. & Mittler, p.J.: Aspects of competence_in tr,tentatty
z, il. UV Hogg, J. & P.J. Mittler, John Wiley & Sons Ltd, 1983
some predictors, Defectology' 1990'' 26' 2' 163-177
13. lgrit uenauiouiin ,r'iHr.n wiih mental reiardation in relation with
Lj.: Adaptive
.14. ,oaptiu. uetrauiour of pupils without development difficulties and pupils with mental
tgriq Lj., stand4 z. trgg6ilo*e diff"rences in
ietardation, Defectology, vol. 26, 2, 193-200' Zagreb'
I 5. tgri(, Lj., Fulgosi-Mas.l.'i, n. enurj scale of adaptive
behaviour, Handbook. university of Zagreb, Faculty of Defectology'
1991.
and their social maturity, Defectology' 1992'28' 1'2
16. lgri( Li. i A. Zic Social adaptation of children with mental retardation
supplement (2l,,29'45 of the
Lj., Zic, A., Nikoli(, B.: Integrative treatmlnt oj undesirable
behaviour in children with learning disabilities' First Congress
17. lgri( '1995,
13-16, Amsterdam
il;p*. lssociation foi uen6l Health in Mental Retardation, September 1988' 24' 1'
Lj.: Some socialisation aspects of integi;tio;of cnitoien witn delayed cognitive development, Defectology'
18. Mavrin-cavor,
152