Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Network Sites:
Latest
A New Manufacturing Method May Pull Nanowires From the Research Realm to Market
Forums
Education
Tools
Videos
Datasheets
Giveaways
Latest
An IoT Halloween Pumpkin | Control LEDs With an Arduino MKR1000 and Blynk App 🎃👻🍭
Projects
Education
Latest
Researchers Develop Self-Powered, Stretchable Micro-Supercapacitors For Health and Diagnostic Wearable Devices
News
Technical Articles
Market Insights
Education
Latest
What NYU and IBM Research May Tell us About Spintronics in Computing
Following the UK’s 2030 Petrol Ban Announcement: What Can the Country Do for a Better EV Infrastructure?
News
Opinion
Interviews
Product Highlights
Research
Forums
Log In
Join
Log in
Join Control.com
Or sign in with
Facebook
Google
LinkedIn
0:00 / 0:00
Podcast
Latest
Subscribe
Google
Spotify
Apple
https://control.com/forums/threads/how-to-assign-cost-to-dcs-points.5954/ 1/14
12/31/2020 How to assign cost to DCS points | Automation & Control Engineering Forum
iHeartRadio
Stitcher
Pandora
Tune In
Menu
Explore
Content
Company Directory
Forums
Industry Articles
Industry White Papers
News
Technical Articles
Textbook
Worksheets
Products
Circuit Protection
Connectors
Control Panel
Control Systems & HMIs
Enclosures, Racks & Cabinets
IIoT
Industrial Controls
Motors
Networking
PLCs & PACs
Pneumatics & Hydraulics
Power
Protocols
Robotics
Safety
Sensors
Simulation
Test & Measurement
Vision Systems
Wire & Cable
View All
Industry
Agriculture
Automotive
Building
Cement
Chemical
Electronics
Food & Beverage
Metal
Military/Aerospace
Mining
Nuclear
Oil & Gas
Medical & Pharmaceutical
Pulp & Paper
Rubber & Plastics
Utilities
View All
Articles
Latest
ABB Partners with CORYS to Advance Simulation Technology in Process and Energy Sectors
HP and AM Solutions Develop the HP Jet Fusion 5200 Series 3D Automatic Unpacking Station
News
ABB Partners with CORYS to Advance Simulation Technology in Process and Energy Sectors
HP and AM Solutions Develop the HP Jet Fusion 5200 Series 3D Automatic Unpacking Station
Emerson Aims for Plant Connectivity with New Toolset to Digital Platform
Technical Articles
Industry Articles
https://control.com/forums/threads/how-to-assign-cost-to-dcs-points.5954/ 2/14
12/31/2020 How to assign cost to DCS points | Automation & Control Engineering Forum
Comparing Commutation Encoders: Quantum Devices QML35/QM35 vs. Renco RCML15/R35i and CUI AMT312S/AMT312D
Forums
Latest
Pressure transmitter calibration
2 hours ago
VA 22 booster compressor suction valve
5 hours ago
GE FRAME 9E COMPRESSOR EFFICIENCY BECOME LITTLE LESS AS COMP...
13 hours ago
Wireshark Trace of S7-1500H Switchover
yesterday
General Discussion
ABB SERVO DRIVE FAULT
2 days ago
How to set threshold for my flame sensor?
6 days ago
Error Indicator on FX3U-ENET-ADP
8 days ago
SRV opens at 200 RPM (MS6001B with MK V)
8 days ago
Hardware
Wireshark Trace of S7-1500H Switchover
yesterday
SIWAREX U not reading LC data
5 days ago
GE Mark VI not in control state
9 days ago
Connect Unity pro L Schneider PLC simulator with Intouch HMI...
13 days ago
Software
Tatsuno Fuel Dispenser Communication to PC
3 days ago
VACON NCLoad
9 days ago
Easy way to get data out of PLC's?
20 days ago
Yaskawa MPE720 VER.5
25 days ago
Communication
Adding an Ethernet/IP Adapter to Micrologix 1400 PLC
11 days ago
Delta PLC Communication
17 days ago
Alternative solution for HART 275
23 days ago
Replacing UHF radio transceiver with Wifi
27 days ago
Education
Vol. I - Fundamentals
Chapter 1
Chapter 2
Chapter 3
Chapter 4
Chapter 5
Chapter 6
Chapter 7
Vol. II - Instrumentation
Chapter 8
Chapter 9
Chapter 10
https://control.com/forums/threads/how-to-assign-cost-to-dcs-points.5954/ 3/14
12/31/2020 How to assign cost to DCS points | Automation & Control Engineering Forum
Instrument connections
Chapter 11
Chapter 12
Chapter 13
Chapter 14
Chapter 15
Chapter 16
Chapter 17
Chapter 19
Chapter 20
Chapter 21
Chapter 22
Chapter 23
Chapter 24
Chapter 25
Chapter 26
Vol. IV - Control
Chapter 27
Chapter 28
Chapter 29
Chapter 30
Chapter 31
https://control.com/forums/threads/how-to-assign-cost-to-dcs-points.5954/ 4/14
12/31/2020 How to assign cost to DCS points | Automation & Control Engineering Forum
Chapter 32
Chapter 33
Chapter 34
Vol. V - Reference
Chapter 35
Chapter 36
Chapter 37
Chapter 38
Worksheets
DC Circuit Calculations
Solenoidcontrolled Systems
Company Directory
Podcast
Connect with us
Network Sites:
https://control.com/forums/threads/how-to-assign-cost-to-dcs-points.5954/ 5/14
12/31/2020 How to assign cost to DCS points | Automation & Control Engineering Forum
Thread Starter #1
Terry Dixon
T Jan 23, 2002
It seems that everyone gets to use the system free, until we run out of space. The next project then has to pay
not only for their project, but for the new processors, and I/O cards. A $50,000 project can easily swell to nearly
twice that.
Is there a formula to determine the value of, say, an analog input, output, and the blocks that make up a level
controler? I can guess what
might go into such a formula, but what do you use, if anything?
Like Reply
Randy Marek #2
Jan 24, 2002
R
What it boils down to this what do you have and what are your licenses. first update the P&ID's, do a detail
point count, write
specification that are detailed and clearly define what you want. Then go get a detailed quote and hold your
contractor to it. He can also hold you to it. Control your scope and if operations what to change things after the
freeze dates issue a change order to them, get a quote for the changes from your contractor befor releasing it.
Randy
Like Reply
Steve #3
Jan 24, 2002
S
I work for a leading DCS manufactuer, integrator, field service, ect. When we want a job such as yours we place a
bid along with other DCS companies. Try contacting Westinghouse Process Control Inc., Bailey/ABB, Honeywell,
Yokagawa, ect. Spec what you need, hardware, MMI, engineering, field service support, and anything else
important to you.
Like Reply
Terry Dixon #4
Jan 24, 2002
T
I think you misunderstood my question (usually because I'm not clear when asking the quesitons)
I'm on staff at a mill and am in charge of the DCS. The problem is that as the process grows, the DCS gets full.
Down the line, a project
comes up that exceeds the remaining capacity of the DCS. The cost of the aforementioned project the swells
because it is necessary to
https://control.com/forums/threads/how-to-assign-cost-to-dcs-points.5954/ 6/14
12/31/2020 How to assign cost to DCS points | Automation & Control Engineering Forum
expand the DCS to accomodate the process control logic. It would be more fair to spread the cost over all
projects instead of blindsiding
someone with the cost of the expansion.
Like Reply
Bruce Durdle #5
Jan 24, 2002
B
I tried to set up a system for handling this a few years ago. The problem is that:
(1) most projects design for about 20% spare capacity in DCS, PLC etc.
(2) after commissioning there is quite a lot of this spare capacity unused
(3) project engineers etc become aware of this and think up bright ideas to use it all - after all, it's "free". Once
cast in stone, these often very trivial uses become cast in stone.
(4) a real project surfaces that will use the remaining spare capacity + 1 input. Result - this project has to bear
the cost of not only the capacity it uses, but also the costs of hardware used in all the trivial projects
carried out previously.
It can get fairly extreme - I know one plant where the next addition of instrumentatio will need an expansion of
the equipment rack room, with all that implies.
The solution I proposed was to look at the actual cost of the complete DCS system, and assign a value to
unused capacity on that basis. So if 20% of I/O is left unused, the associated value is 20% of the cost of I/O for
the complete system. It's pretty easy for the old TDC2000/3000 where each box had a definite number of inputs
and therefore each input or output can be assigned a value, but in more amorphous systems it will need a bit
more
work. It also becomes a lot harder where there is a lot of cost in processing modules.
However, the bean counters werre just not interested, so it turned into a fairly academic exercise. But it's
amazing how the threat to add a cost recovery factor to some projects made them quite uneconomic.
Bruce.
Like Reply
Bruce Durdle #6
Jan 25, 2002
B
I tried to set up a system for handling this a few years ago. The problem is that:
(1) most projects design for about 20% spare capacity in DCS, PLC etc.
(2) after commissioning there is quite a lot of this spare capacity unused
(3) project engineers etc become aware of this and think up bright ideas to use it all - after all, it's "free". Once
cast in stone, these often very trivial uses become cast in stone.
(4) a real project surfaces that will use the remaining spare capacity + 1 input. Result - this project has to bear
the cost of not only the capacity it uses, but also the costs of hardware used in all the trivial projects carried out
previously.
It can get fairly extreme - I know one plant where the next addition of instrumentatio will need an expansion of
the equipment rack room, with all that implies.
The solution I proposed was to look at the actual cost of the complete DCS system, and assign a value to
unused capacity on that basis. So if 20% of I/O is left unused, the associated value is 20% of the cost of I/O for
the complete system. It's pretty easy for the old TDC2000/3000 where each box had a definite number of inputs
and therefore each input or output can be assigned a value, but in more amorphous systems it will need a bit
more work. It also becomes a lot harder where there is a lot of cost in processing modules.
https://control.com/forums/threads/how-to-assign-cost-to-dcs-points.5954/ 7/14
12/31/2020 How to assign cost to DCS points | Automation & Control Engineering Forum
However, the bean counters were just not interested, so it turned into a fairly academic exercise. But it's amazing
how the threat to add a cost recovery factor to some projects made them quite uneconomic.
Bruce.
Like Reply
Arnold Dillon #7
Jan 28, 2002
A
We bid jobs for PLC and DCS systems periodically. Usually, we go through an exercise to total up our
engineering and configuration time, then price the hardware and come up with a total system cost. However, I
then usually check this price against a price of somewhere around $500 per point. This seems to be sort of a
reasonable price average, especially for large systems. A small system could cost up to twice that much per
point just because of the base amount engineering and setup that has to be done, regardless of the system size.
In your case, you have a sunk cost in the installed base of the system. This might be ignored depending upon
what type of system upgrades that you plan. Probably, you should come up with an average amount of
engineering time required to configure a set of new points in the system based upon previous experience. Then
take the incremental cost of adding another processing cabinet with processor, power supply, etc. Finally, assign
cost to the I/O cards. Add it all together and divide by a number of points that you use in an average addition.
This won't be perfect, but it will make a cost assignment like you're trying to achieve. You can adjust your
formula after a few DCS system additions and you determine if you're too high or low. (Better to be 10% high
on the first job. No one will mind if you reduce the cost in the future).
My guess is that you'll come up with one cost for discrete points and another more expensive cost for analog
points.
Like Reply
Bob Pawley #8
Jan 29, 2002
B
Hi Arnold:
Do you have a price breakdown of your $500 estimate between engineering, implementation and hardware
costs per I/O??
Bob Pawley
250-493-6146
Like Reply
Bob Peterson #9
Jan 29, 2002
B
I about choked when I saw this. It seems so far out. But then I thought about it a bit.
Hardware costs:
https://control.com/forums/threads/how-to-assign-cost-to-dcs-points.5954/ 8/14
12/31/2020 How to assign cost to DCS points | Automation & Control Engineering Forum
Labor to assemble and test: $2000
Design/Drafting $5000
Software $7500
Startup 1 week $5000
Total $32,500
Note where the money is at. The purchased items are only about 40% of the cost. Labor is about 60%. (BTW-I
did not adjust the numbers to come out that way-the numbers were just my initial guesses).
By the time you add in end user project management, training, installation, an extra couple weeks of startup,
redesign, etc., and keeping in mind that the cost of hardware and software for a DCS typically far exceeds that of
an equivalent PLC system, $500 a point is not that far off.
By the way, it would not surprise me if it cost $100 or more per point to install the thing. Field work is just
extremely costly. If you want to save money, that's were you can save some. Anything you can do in a shop as
opposed to out in the field will almost always save you money. Unfortunately, the techniques that reduce your
field costs, tend to increase the "control panel" cost, and the PM's driving the projects rarely understand this.
They want the lowest cost "control panel" even if it substantially drives up the cost of field work.
Bob Peterson
Like Reply
Not really. I came up with the $500 per point price tag based upon some survey information that floated around
a couple of years ago. The survey talked about cost-per-point for new DCS installations including hardware and
programming. Mostly it was directed at large systems. Around $500 turned out to be an average for an installed
system cost not including field instruments.
I use it mainly as a reality check when doing proposals. It isn't how I come up with final costs.
-Arnold Dillon
615-346-3400
Like Reply
Bob,
I haven't spent much time looking at your assignment of costs, but they seem reasonable. The only thing that I'll
quibble about is that --"the cost of hardware and software for a DCS typically far exceeds that of an equivalent
PLC system." --That statement was true 5 or 6 years ago, but today I don't necessarily agree.
It is true that some small PLC's and maybe even some good sized systems like SLC-500's can be cheaper,
particularly if the control is mostly discrete with relatively simple logic. On the other hand, if you jump into
something like a ControLogix package, a lot of analog control, isolated inputs, batch logic, and a bunch of
complicated inter-tied process systems, then I'll bet that I may be able to do the job cheaper with some of the
scaled down DCS systems marketed today. This won't be because the hardware is cheaper, but there is more
functionality built into the configuration software that lets some of the more complicated programming happen
a little easier. -At least for me.
Six years ago there were no scaled down DCS systems. Everything was built and initially configured by the
manufacturer. Operator consoles started at $30K and unless you had at least 100 analog loops or some really
special requirements, a DCS didn't start to become cost effective. Today, I can buy and integrate some of the
DCS hardware and software just like the PLC systems. The operator stations are conventional computers and the
processor and I/O racks don't look much different than a lot of PLC's. Only the software is different.
https://control.com/forums/threads/how-to-assign-cost-to-dcs-points.5954/ 9/14
12/31/2020 How to assign cost to DCS points | Automation & Control Engineering Forum
-But for a complicated process control strategy requiring that functionality, the $500 per point number may still
be a rough yardstick (read very rough) regardless if the control system is a PLC or DCS.
-Arnold Dillon
Like Reply
> Bob,
>
> I haven't spent much time looking at your assignment of costs, but they
> seem reasonable. The only thing that I'll quibble about is that --"the
> cost of hardware and software for a DCS typically far exceeds that of an
> equivalent PLC system." --That statement was true 5 or 6 years ago,
> but today I don't necessarily agree.
I think you will find that on a point for point basis the cost of PLC points (I/O and HMI) versus DCS points still
comes down on the side of the PLC. And by a substantial margin.
> It is true that some small PLC's and maybe even some good sized systems
> like SLC-500's can be cheaper, particularly if the control is mostly
> discrete with relatively simple logic. On the other hand, if you jump
> into something like a ControLogix package, a lot of analog control,
> isolated inputs, batch logic, and a bunch of complicated inter-tied
> process systems, then I'll bet that I may be able to do the job cheaper
> with some of the scaled down DCS systems marketed today. This won't be
> because the hardware is cheaper, but there is more functionality built
> into the configuration software that lets some of the more complicated
> programming happen a little easier. -At least for me.
True. The main point being "at least for me". The cost of retraining people who are only familiar with DCS's to
efficiently use PLCs (and vice versa) is typically prohibitive. The same problem occurs when you try to switch
from brand X PLC to brand Y (or brand X DCS to brand Y DCS). I tend to agree there is more built in
functionality in DCS systems then with PLCs. But thats by design. DCS's tend to lock you into their way of
thinking and their method of control. If you do not want to use their built in functionality, it can be substantially
more difficult to roll your own then with a PLC, so
people tend to use the stuff it comes with, forcing the control to fit the DCS. I have seen some rather strange
things done for this very reason.
In my guesses I guessed that the labor cost was 60% of the "control panel" cost, and purchased items was only
40%. It would not take a whole lot of extra engineering time required for a PLC control panel to actually cost
more then an equivilant DCS control panel, even if the DCS purchased items cost more. Just the cost of sending
a couple of engineers to a PLC training class for a week might skew the numbers in favor of a DCS if the
engineers needed the PLC training.
Another issue here is the preferential pricing some integrators or end users get over others. Some people pay
double what others do for the same AB part. I suspect this is probably true in the DCS world as well. Not
knowing what pricing is actually available puts people at a disadvantage when trying to compare actual costs.
And the PLC/DCS sales people like it that way. The more befuddled the users are over real costs the better for
them.
A somewhat humourous aside here. I worked on a job not to long ago where the end user had a DCS
(Honeywell IIRC). For some reason, they could only use a certain number of characters for a tag name. Our tags
came out in our standard numbering system with one more character. It was going to cost something like
$30,000 to "upgrade" the DCS to accept tag names with an extra character, so they elected to delete one letter
in each tag so that it would fit in the allowed number of letters. Seems to me it was like 7 letters was allowed,
but all our tags were 8. Came out with strange tag names in a few cases, but it worked, and they did not have to
spend $30k for this "upgrade".
> Six years ago there were no scaled down DCS systems. Everything was
> built and initially configured by the manufacturer. Operator consoles
> started at $30K and unless you had at least 100 analog loops or some
> really special requirements, a DCS didn't start to become cost
> effective. Today, I can buy and integrate some of the DCS hardware and
https://control.com/forums/threads/how-to-assign-cost-to-dcs-points.5954/ 10/14
12/31/2020 How to assign cost to DCS points | Automation & Control Engineering Forum
> software just like the PLC systems. The operator stations are
> conventional computers and the processor and I/O racks don't look much
> different than a lot of PLC's. Only the software is different.
I concur that today DCS's are much more cost effective then even a few years ago. But I would dispute your
contention that there were no scaled down DCS systems 6 years ago. Bailey had some pretty reasonable stuff, as
did Provox, at least as far as scaled down went. But cost wise it was still insane. And I am talking more like 10-15
years ago, not 6.
I suppose it would depend on the level of complexity and whether the DCS had a builtin function you could use.
I have done some fairly complex math with PLCs and it was relatively easy, but I have been programming PLCs
for almost 20 years now. Particularly in a PLC5 and SLCs with the compute instruction where you can enter an
algebraic formula directly. I have only done a couple DCS projects, but they were all substantially more difficult
(and not by a little bit) to handle the things I was doing then with any PLC. And mostly I was doing simple
sequential control. The thing I like about PLCs is it does what I tell it to do. I am not forced to do what it thinks I
should. In both of the DCS projects I was involved in, we actually had to change the way the equipment
functioned (usually in minor ways) to accomodate the way the DCS worked. To me this is not desirable.
Bob Peterson
Like Reply
Arnold:
From another post it appears that 60% of a typical project cost is labour.
I would suggest that this could be broken down to approximately 25 design labour, 25 implementation labour
and 10 set-up and testing for a total of 60.
Bob
Like Reply
To all those who incur costs due to the differences between hardware units such as PLC, DCS, Networks.
Imagine if the software you used was completely independent of these hardware concerns.
Bob Pawley
250-493-6146
Like Reply
https://control.com/forums/threads/how-to-assign-cost-to-dcs-points.5954/ 11/14
12/31/2020 How to assign cost to DCS points | Automation & Control Engineering Forum
Like Reply
Programmable Logic
P Assign value to tags in wincc 2 Apr 20, 2002
Controller - PLC
Siemens Releases New Flow, Level, and Pump Controllers for Radar Transmitters
by Sara McCaslin
by Dennis Lynch
by Jeff Kerns
https://control.com/forums/threads/how-to-assign-cost-to-dcs-points.5954/ 12/14
12/31/2020 How to assign cost to DCS points | Automation & Control Engineering Forum
Who We Are
Maxim Integrated Releases New Intelligent Actuator for Precise Manufacturing Applications
by Robin Mitchell
More about us
Connect With Us
Contact Us
Advertise
Write For Us
Sign Up
Products
Circuit Protection
Connectors
Control Panel
Control Systems & HMIs
Enclosures, Racks & Cabinets
IIoT
Industrial Controls
Motors
Networking
PLCs & PACs
Pneumatics & Hydraulics
Power
Protocols
Robotics
Safety
Sensors
Simulation
Test & Measurement
Vision Systems
Wire & Cable
View All
Industry
Agriculture
Automotive
Building
Cement
Chemical
Electronics
Food & Beverage
Metal
Military/Aerospace
Mining
Nuclear
Oil & Gas
Medical & Pharmaceutical
Pulp & Paper
Rubber & Plastics
Utilities
View All
Content
Company Directory
Forums
Industry Articles
Industry White Papers
News
Technical Articles
Textbook
Worksheets
https://control.com/forums/threads/how-to-assign-cost-to-dcs-points.5954/ 13/14
12/31/2020 How to assign cost to DCS points | Automation & Control Engineering Forum
Continue to site
QUOTE OF THE DAY
“
”
-
https://control.com/forums/threads/how-to-assign-cost-to-dcs-points.5954/ 14/14