Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gender Differences in Second Career Choice Preference: A Study on Modern Era’s Career
Aqsa Zakir
652-A-B, Assessment
ABSTRACT
The present study aims to develop a vocational interest inventory with respect to the modern era,
based on the concept of Thurston interest schedule and to measure the gender differences among
career choices, a total sample of 572 participant of mean age 16.4 were stratified from the entry
levels of Matric, Cambridge, AKU and Federal board’s schooling system of private, government
and semi-government schools and colleges, through online google form and in person survey.
The findings supported the hypothesis that girls and boys having gender difference in vocational
interest, several factors such as cultural gender beliefs about competence, fidelity approach to
resolve identity confusion, parents support and socio economic status impact on student’s
vocational interest. The new interest schedule has more relevant fields to this digitally globalize
era and can be use to add those career choice into educational system which are purely interest
based.
Keywords: Career choice, Vocational interest inventory, Thurston interest schedule, New
Contents
ABSTRACT ................................................................................................................................................. 2
Rationale .................................................................................................................................................. 6
Hypothesis................................................................................................................................................ 6
METHODOLOGY ..................................................................................................................................... 7
Sample ...................................................................................................................................................... 7
Measures .................................................................................................................................................. 7
Procedure ................................................................................................................................................. 7
RESULT ...................................................................................................................................................... 8
Table 1 ...................................................................................................................................................... 8
Table 2 ...................................................................................................................................................... 9
Table 3 .................................................................................................................................................... 12
Table 4 .................................................................................................................................................... 18
DISCUSSION ............................................................................................................................................ 19
REFERENCES ........................................................................................................................................... 21
Appendix A ................................................................................................................................................. 23
Appendix B …………………….......……………………………………………………………25
CAREER CHOICE: A REVOLUATION IN VOCATIONAL INTEREST 4
ENVIRONMENTAL INFLUENCE
From the era of farming till the era of technology the revolution in fields impact on career
selection. The Selection of a vocational career without having thorough knowledge of it is just
same as diving in the mid of the sea when you do not know to swim. Within the revolution in
fields of career choice a question may arise about beliefs of gender differences regarding career
choice is persisting same as before? To answer this question let first understand the Vocational
interest (Schermer J.A. 2016) is defined as the individual difference and preference for career
choices of certain work and work related environment that are same in different kind of positions
where as Career choices Mwoleka, J. (2011) are the options of preferences of work that in
which particular area of filed he wants to struggle for in his whole life.
Furnham (1992) suggest the six theoretical approaches to vocational interest which are
Developmental; development and changes in vocational interests throughout the lifespan effect
may resolve by Interactions with “significant others” and role models, Motivational; is the needs
of the individual and how they can be satisfied in the context of organizational setting,
factors underpinning individuals’ decision-making schemes and how these affect choices,
Holland’s (1959, 1997) Another theoretical approach to vocational interest is Holland’s RIASEC
Conventional, these all are the individual characteristics which directly effect by environment.
Correll, S. (2001). Cultural beliefs about gender differences in competence that certain
abilities are associated with men ( such as men are good in math’s) and other certain with women
(such as women are good in Arts) makes an impact on adolescent’s decision making of career
preference that they should go in fields associated with gender specific competence handed down by
society e.g. men should be engineer and with these beliefs and decision making the transition process
of and adolescent from school to work is always challenging because it is accompanied by doubt,
worries; imagination work as shaper or constructor for student career (Stead, et al., 2004), this
phenomena may regulate through Identity vs role confusion from the Erick Erikson’s eight
stages of life characterizes the adolescents of age 12-19 is a role confusion resolves by
identification through psychological moratorium in which teens put their identity on hold and
explore further options for their identity and succession in exploration lead the to fidelity that is
with the ideological differences teens are able to commit their selves to others while accepting
A study of (University of East Anglia ,2018; Abiola, J. 2014) suggest that beside of personal
interest, openness to a new experience with individual characteristics and the labor market are
cause of career mobility, that is mobilization from different organizations, industries, to different
occupational options is more in younger and with the age effect being strongest, while
(Qualifix The National Learner’s Database, n.d) whereas Parents wants their children to be
happy and successive and this influence their career choice though, children who are supported
and love by their parents are more confidence in choosing a career which makes them competent
and made to select more satisfying career choices later in life on the other hand excessive
outcomes.
Rationale
From the past the revolution in fields and its dimensions have given us infinite options in
career choice from which we are not aware and it is the demand of every one’s, career planning
to be self-employed apart of being others employ and must have hands on technology or may
have knowledge about technology fields in this era of digitally globalized world also the gender
differences in career choices are consistent with previous findings? which lead us to develop new
vocational interest schedule and to analyze the gender differences in vocational interest . This
study of vocational interest schedule development base on the measure of Thurston interest
schedule which is the old enough tool to measure one’s interest in current different fields of
science and technology. So we develop a new schedule based on current fields and dimensions of
Hypothesis
There will be gender differences in career choice preference 2 among entry level students
METHODOLOGY
Sample
A total of 572 students of entry level (i.e. 9th, 10th, 11th, 12th, O3, A1 & A2) including
49.3 percent boys and 50.7 percent girls of the age range 16 to 19 were selected from private,
government, semi-government schooling system of Cambridge, AKU, Matric and Federal board
Measures
A self- developed questionnaire, attached in appendix A, was used to ask at least 5 career
choices of participants in which they see their-selves in next five years, including the consent of
confidentiality and demographics of their class age, schooling system, board of education and
Procedure
With the collaboration of 57 researchers the sample was drawn from the entry level
students of the Matric, Cambridge, AKU and Federal board through the online platform of
google form and through in person survey. Each researcher had to sampled the 1 boy and 1 girl
RESULT
Table 1
Descriptive Statistics
Table 2
This represents the frequency of each career choice made by 282 boys and 289 girls.
During the pooling, the data above the age of 19 and career choice which identifies the boy’s
Table 3
PHYSICAL BIOLOGICAL
Frequency Frequency
SCIENCES SCIENCES
Sub-Fields Career Choices Boys Girls Sub-Fields Career Choices Boys Girls
Astronomy Astronaut 1 Bio & Biologist 1
Automotive Eng. 2 1 Technology zoologist 1
Engineering
Electrical Eng. 1 1 Microbiologist 4
& Technology
Engineer 4 4 Bio tech 1
Aviation 1 Cosmetologist 2
Civil engineer 5 3 Medicine Cardiologist 2 2
Mechanical
8 Dentist 8
engineer 26
Nuclear Eng. 1 Doctor 11 21
Textile engineer 1 DPT 3
General
Petroleum Engineer 1
physician 1
Car Maker 1 Gynecologist 1 3
Chemical engineer 4 2 Eye specialist 4
Computer engineer 7 Skin specialist 1
Earth & Sup arco 1 Surgeon 1
environmental
science Environmentalist 1 Pharmacist 5 12
Medical 1
Psychiatrist 1 1
Therapist 1
Food
Physiology 1
Nutritionist 2
Physiologist 4
Physiotherapist 1 4
The main field of Biological and Physical Science is same as of Thurstone but We
divided the Physical Science into three subfields of Astronomy, Engineering and Technology,
Earth & Environmental Sciences and Biological sciences into Bio-technology, Medicine and
BUSINESS
MANAGEMENT Frequency COMPUTATIONAL Frequency
& ACCOUNTING
Sub-Fields Career Choices Boys Girls Career Choice Boys Girls
Accounting Accountant 6 Data Scientist 1
Chartered
2 Researcher
accountant 2
Banking Banker 11 3 Scientist 3
Investment banker 1 Gamer 2
Business Zoo Owner 1
Business woman 7
Business man 21
Exporter 2
Freelancer 1
MBA 2
Social Entrepreneur 1
Pvt. Clinic 1
Management Business manager 1
Manager 2
Sales Manager 1
HR manager 1
We characterized the accounting banking business and management collectively into one
field where as computational is same as of Thurstone interest schedule but with the new career
choices.
CAREER CHOICE: A REVOLUATION IN VOCATIONAL INTEREST 14
COMPUTER
SPORTS &
Frequency SCIENCE Frequency
SCIENCE
&TECHNOLOGY
Career Choice Boys Girls Career Choice Boys Girls
Foot baller 1 B.Tech 1
Mountain biker 1 CIT 1
Traveler 1 Computer Master 1
Exercise
1 Game designer 1
physiologist
Cricketer 4 Hacker 2
Information
2
Technology
IT Engineering 1
Software 1
Software Developer 1 1
Software Engineer 6 3
Technologist 1
Video Game Maker 1
Web Developer 1
Graphic Designer 1 1
Web Designer 1 3
The Sports & Science and Computer Science & Technology are new fields that we
emerged and hence are more relevant to the modern era’s revolutionized fields.
CAREER CHOICE: A REVOLUATION IN VOCATIONAL INTEREST 15
Sub-Field Career Choice Boys Girls Sub-Field Career Choice Boys Girls
We classify the Humanitarian into subfields of Law & Enforcement whereas Persuasive
has the Marketing and global forums named as Internet Forums which is another comparative
field to Thurstone
CAREER CHOICE: A REVOLUATION IN VOCATIONAL INTEREST 16
CREATIVE
Linguistic Frequency Frequency
ART
Career
Boys Girls Career Choice Boys Girls
Choice
Anchor 2 Beautician 1
Host 1 Bakery 1
Content
Journalist 1 1 1 1
Creator
Lawyer 1 4 Chef 3 3
News
1 Painter 1 5
anchor
Reporter 1 Sketcher 1
Writer 2 Textile 3
Textile
1 1
designer
We reformed the field Artistic of Thurston into Creative Art and choice that could be fall
in Artistic were classified into Media Science & Media Industry where the field Linguistic has
no change
CAREER CHOICE: A REVOLUATION IN VOCATIONAL INTEREST 17
Table 4
Boys 35 36 47 6 18 7 22 4 7 37 11
Girls 15 90 17 2 12 1 24 10 15 40 11
Total
Frequency
50 126 64 8 30 8 46 14 22 77 22
of Each
Field
N 571 571 571 571 571 571 571 571 571 571 571
Total
100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100
Percentage
1.40105078 2.45 13.4851
8.7566 22.06655 11.2084063 5.25394 1.4011 8.056042 3.85289 3.8528897
Percentage 8 184 138
This represent the gender specific and overall frequency of each field
CAREER CHOICE: A REVOLUATION IN VOCATIONAL INTEREST 19
DISCUSSION
The hypothesis that there will be gender differences in career choice preference two
among entry level students of schools and college is supported with analyzed data. The girls’
frequency is higher in biological and social sciences fields where as boys are more bound with
physical, computational, computer science and technology fields that is approach to fidelity has
the root of cultural beliefs about gender competences that in which fields they should go (Correll,
S. 2001; Stead, et al., 2004). Another fact could be the need of fame or acceptance called
motivation, one of the component of Furnham (1992) theoretical model of vocational interest, is
more high in girls in a men dominating culture leading them to pursue the more respect and fame
related fields in a view of cultural perspective, whereas (Abiola, J. 2014) parent’s role in
choosing vocational interest play an important role, developing them with the vision that what
they are and what they should be can become a key aspect of choosing career and this view could
The more frequencies of girls in social science and Biological science, whereas of boys in
physical and technical filed represent their environmental effects and individual characteristics as
The development of the interest schedule according to modern era reside 11 fields in
which 3 are new which is computer science& technology, Sport science & technology Media
science & Media Industry in comparison to Thurston interest schedule whereas Biological
Accounting, computational, with their sub fields converting the field Artistic into pure Creative
Art while merging the field Musicale into Media science & Media Industry, while the original
Thurston (Review of Thurstone Interest Schedule 1948)was developed by Thurston L.L. and
CAREER CHOICE: A REVOLUATION IN VOCATIONAL INTEREST 20
revised in 1937 has .90-.96 scale reliability only 10 broad fields named : physical science,
artistic, and musical. The pattern of scale scoring and administration is same as of the original
Thurston except of the most of the career choice explored in this study and the 121 boxes in a
sheet in comparison to Thurstone interest schedule which 100 boxes comprising two opposite
career choice in one box and the scoring is done by counting the marked choices across the rows
Limitations: students need career counselling before filling the questionnaire because
most of the students wrote the organization names irrespective of the field in which they want to
work in that organization this create the ambiguity when classifying the name relevant to that
field. Also the career choices are not enough to fill in new interest schedule causing the
The implication of the developed new interest schedule could be used to measure
students interest profile with respect to the modern era’s revolutionized fields and also those
careers and fields which are only interest based such as blogging vloging could be include as a
This study helps in finding out that the results are consistent with the developed
hypothesis and the new interest schedule has more relevant fields according to this digitally
globalize era
CAREER CHOICE: A REVOLUATION IN VOCATIONAL INTEREST 21
REFERENCES
Abiola, J. (Nov. 2014). Impact of Educational Aspirations On Vocational Choices of the Female
Secondary School Students in Ondo West Local Government Area of Ondo State,
Nigeria. European Scientific Journal. (Special eds.) vol.1 ISSN: 1857 – 7881 (Print) e -
Chermer J.A. (2016) Vocational Interests. In: Zeigler-Hill V., Shackelford T. (eds)
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-28099-8_801-1
Correll, S. (2001). Gender and the Career Choice Process: The Role of Biased Self‐
Furnham, A. (1992). Personality at Work: Individual Differences in the Workplace (1st ed.).
Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203134122
45.
Holland, J. L. (1997). Making vocational choices: A theory of vocational personalities and work
https://alfredadler.edu/sites/default/files/Mwoleka%20MP%202011.pdf pg. 7
Paris, Ricardo, Raymond, & Johnson (Jul 22, 2020). Erik Erikson – Theory of Psychosocial
https://socialsci.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Early_Childhood_Education/Book%3A_Child
_Growth_and_Development_(Paris_Ricardo_Rymond_and_Johnson)/15%3A_Adolescen
ce__Social_Emotional_Development/15.01%3A_Erik_Erikson__Theory_of_Psychosocia
l_Development
Qualifix The National Learner’s Database, (n.d). The Parent's Role in Career Selection: How
https://www.qualifax.ie/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=179&Itemid=
207
Review of Thurstone Interest Schedule (1948). [Review of the book Thurstone interest
63. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0050698
Stead, G. B. Els, C., & Fouad, N. A. (2004). Perceived career barriers among South African high
University of East Anglia (July 5, 2018). Age and education affect job changes. ScienceDaily
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/07/180705205142.htm#:~:text=New%20res
earch%20reveals%20that%20people,are%20factors%20in%20career%20mobility
CAREER CHOICE: A REVOLUATION IN VOCATIONAL INTEREST 23
Appendix A
Self-Developed Questionnaire
Demographics
Age:
Gender:
Birth Order: (first / middle /last / only)
Class: (9th / 10th /11th / 12th/ O3/ A1/ A2)
Subject you choose in Class 9th: Biology / Computer / Arts
Subject you choose in First year (If you're an intermediate student tick the faculty below):
• Pre-Medical
• Pre-Engineering
• Commerce
• Arts
Schooling System: (Private / Government / Semi-Government)
Matric Board / Cambridge System
Father’s Education:
Father’s Profession:
Mother’s Education:
Mother’s Profession: