SUPPLEMENTARY TABLE - List of Research Topics and Research Priorities. Descriptive statistics in total sample and by geographical distribution.
Northern Central Europe Southern
Total sample MACROAREA (N=75) Europe (NE) (CE) Europe (SE) POST RESEARCH TOPICS (N=20) (N=31) (N=24) Sig. HOC * ** *** Research Priorities Mean 0 1-2 3-5 Mean Mean Mean P<0.05 n n n n Value(SD) (%) (%) (%) Value(SD) Value(SD) Value(SD) 1 – DEMOGRAPHIC CHANGE 1. OLDER WORKER 73 3.90(0.82) 0.0 4.1 95.9 20 3.80(0.77) 30 3.83(0.87) 23 4.09(0.79) ns 1.1 Extended working lives and prolonged workplace exposures to physical, chemical, biological and psychosocial hazards: development of techniques and models to collect lifelong 71 3.66(1.03) 0.0 14.1 85.9 20 3.40(1.10) 29 3.69(0.93) 22 3.86(1.08) ns exposure data and to assess the effects of such exposures on workers’ H&S. 1.2 Investigate the causes of early departure from work and the potential OSH measures (e.g. products, support, adaptation and 69 3.51(1.02) 0.0 15.9 84.1 19 3.32(1.11) 28 3.64(0.83) 22 3.50(1.19) ns incentives) to improve the work environment, and support, rehabilitate and retain ageing workers over a longer working life. 1.3 Identify the potential impacts of work organisation and job design on older workers’ H&S and the ways in which these can 70 3.70(1.01) 0.0 12.9 87.1 19 3.37(1.01) 29 3.76(0.87) 22 3.91(1.15) ns support individual older workers. Specific areas of interest include MSDs, stress, and interventions for SMEs. 1.4 Investigate the role of HRM and improve their management practices on employee and organisational level outcomes, such as wellbeing/work ability, work engagement, resilience, 67 3.37(1.03) 0.0 16.4 83.6 18 3.17(1.10) 28 3.64(0.99) 21 3.19(0.98) ns retirement intentions, actual retirement transition and productivity. SE>NE 2. WOMEN AT WORK AND GENDER ASPECTS 71 3.14(1.28) 4.2 23.9 71.9 19 2.74(1.45) 29 2.93(1.39) 23 3.74(0.69) 0.023 SE>CE 1.5 Investigate and develop understanding of gender differences in 71 3.30(1.21) 4.2 16.9 78.9 19 3.16(0.96) 29 3.03(1.52) 23 3.74(0.81) ns occupational risks, including new and emerging risks. 1.6 Investigate and reduce negative effects on women’s safety behaviours, health and productivity of the interaction between work organisation and work environment, job insecurity, 69 3.22(1.14) 1.4 23.2 75.4 18 2.72(1.13) 28 3.36(1.25) 23 3.44(0.90) ns women’s work-life balance and women’s physiological conditions. 3. MIGRANT WORKERS 71 3.45(1.27) 2.8 16.9 80.3 18 3.89(0.90) 30 3.03(1.50) 23 3.65(1.07) ns 1.7 Identify OSH issues for workers living away from their home country, for example low pay, poor working conditions, and poor 71 3.37(1.16) 1.4 21.1 77.5 20 3.40(0.88) 28 3.32(1.25) 23 3.39(1.31) ns H&S conditions. 1.8 Understand and address the impact on OSH management of linguistic, cultural and knowledge diversity in multicultural 70 3.57(1.02) 1.4 12.9 85.7 19 3.63(0.83) 28 3.46(1.20) 23 3.65(0.94) ns workplaces: how to develop a sustainable and inclusive OSH system for multinational and multi-ethnic workforces. 4. HEALTH INEQUALITIES AND WORK – VULNERABLE 71 3.48(1.04) 0.0 16.9 83.1 20 3.55(0.95) 29 3.31(1.14) 22 3.64(1.00) ns WORKERS 1.9 Investigate the extent of problems facing vulnerable workers using, for example, longitudinal studies, sector or group specific 68 3.35(1.10) 0.0 22.1 77.9 20 3.30(1.26) 26 3.31(1.05) 22 3.46(1.06) ns studies, comparative studies between countries, taking into account the impact of social determinants. 1.10 Investigate the factors that could improve the situation for vulnerable workers using, for example, workplace intervention 69 3.32(1.01) 0.0 18.8 81.2 20 3.15(0.99) 27 3.37(0.88) 22 3.41(1.18) ns studies and individual solutions. 5. DISABLED AND CHRONICALLY SICK WORKERS (WORK DISABILITY PREVENTION AND RETURN-TO-WORK 73 3.66(0.96) 0.0 11.0 89.0 20 3.50(0.83) 30 3.67(0.99) 23 3.78(1.04) ns RESEARCH) 1.11 Working with disability (chronic degenerative diseases, oncological, neurodegenerative, dysmetabolic conditions): assess the impact of occupational risk factors on older workers 67 3.55(0.99) 0.0 16.4 83.6 18 3.39(0.92) 28 3.54(1.04) 21 3.71(1.01) ns with chronic diseases and define interventions to reduce time off work. 1.12 Investigate ways and tools to prevent disability and to facilitate return to work in order to promote a longer working life, 68 3.88(0.92) 0.0 7.4 92.6 17 3.65(0.86) 29 3.86(0.95) 22 4.09(0.92) ns including adaptation of the workplace and work arrangements. 2 – GLOBALIZATION AND THE CHANGING WORLD OF WORK 6. ENTERPRISES’ REORGANISATION PROCESSES (RESTRUCTURING, MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS, 66 3.15(1.23) 1.5 25.8 72.7 17 2.82(1.19) 29 3.21(1.26) 20 3.35(1.23) ns DOWNSIZING, CLOSURE, OUTSOURCING, DELOCALISATION AND RESHORING) 2.13 Understand the effects of geographical relocation of enterprises (delocalisation and reshoring to and from low wage 62 3.10(1.00) 0.0 27.4 72.6 14 2.93(0.83) 26 3.00(1.02) 22 3.32(1.09) ns countries) on workers’ H&S and local health services in the EU. 2.14 Foster the emergence of a new approach to organisational change which allows enterprises managers to face, understand 61 3.48(1.09) 0.0 21.3 78.7 17 3.06(0.66) 25 3.52(1.12) 19 3.79(1.27) 0.046 SE>NE and overcome the negative impacts of restructuring on motivation, well-being and health of employees. 2.15 Identify practical interventions to reduce OSH risks and to 63 3.62(0.96) 0.0 15.9 84.1 16 3.38(0.96) 26 3.58(0.76) 21 3.86(1.15) ns support employees' wellbeing during restructuring. 2.16 Further improve knowledge on restructuring impact on risk 62 3.44(1.07) 0.0 16.1 83.9 14 3.21(1.12) 27 3.56(0.89) 21 3.43(1.25) ns factors (including psychosocial) for workers’ H&S. 7. OSH CONSEQUENCES OF MARKET INTEGRATION BASED ON THE REDUCTION OF BARRIERS TO FREE MOVEMENT 62 2.85(1.14) 3.2 29.1 67.7 14 2.43(1.34) 27 2.81(1.08) 21 3.19(1.03) ns OF GOODS 2.17 Assess and reduce the risk of introducing unsafe and unhealthy 66 3.68(0.96) 0.0 7.6 92.4 16 3.88(0.81) 30 3.43(0.97) 20 3.90(1.02) ns work equipment, materials and goods into EU manufacturing processes and workplaces. 2.18 OSH research contribution to the development of policies ensuring the trade of goods produced according to globally 61 3.43(1.12) 0.0 16.4 83.6 14 3.57(1.16) 29 3.35(1.08) 18 3.44(1.20) ns shared standards for the protection of workers' H&S. 8. CHANGING EMPLOYMENT PATTERNS AND PRACTICES 69 3.65(1.04) 0.0 14.5 85.5 19 3.32(1.11) 30 3.77(0.94) 20 3.80(1.11) ns 2.19 Precarious work and job insecurity: better understand and 67 3.55(1.00) 0.0 14.9 85.1 17 3.24(0.97) 28 3.57(1.03) 22 3.77(0.97) ns address effects on workers’ H&S. 2.20 OSH management in new forms of employment 67 3.64(1.20) 0.0 20.9 79.1 17 3.35(1.22) 29 3.83(1.07) 21 3.62(1.36) ns (crowdsourcing, internships, zero hours contracts). 2.21 Impact of precarious jobs on work-life balance. 67 3.46(1.06) 0.0 19.4 80.6 18 3.17(1.04) 27 3.48(1.01) 22 3.68(1.13) ns 2.22 Impact of prolonged precariousness on health conditions, SE>NE 67 3.78(0.98) 0.0 11.9 88.1 18 3.44(1.10) 27 3.59(0.93) 22 4.27(0.77) 0.009 wellbeing and quality of life of an ageing workforce. SE>CE 9. WORKING CONDITIONS, WORK ORGANISATION AND JOB 72 3.81(1.03) 0.0 12.5 87.5 18 3.61(1.15) 31 3.94(1.00) 23 3.78(1.00) ns CONTENT 2.23 Identify best work organisation practices to deal with health effects of an increasingly sedentary workforce (e.g. obesity and 69 3.41(1.10) 0.0 18.8 81.2 19 3.11(1.24) 29 3.62(1.18) 21 3.38(0.81) ns Musculo-Skeletal Disorders - MSDs). 2.24 Identify and address consequences on OSH of innovation and new ways of working, such as remote working practices (tele- 68 3.62(1.07) 0.0 17.6 82.4 17 3.06(1.09) 30 3.90(0.92) 21 3.67(1.11) 0.037 CE>NE work, e-work, boundary less work). 2.25 Find a balance between the need of enhancing employees' control over their work practices and the increasing adoption 55 3.13(1.02) 0.0 27.3 72.7 13 2.85(0.80) 26 3.15(1.22) 16 3.31(0.79) ns of Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems. 2.26 Assessment of methods to improve management of psychosocial risks and promotion of psychosocial safety climate 67 3.52(1.05) 0.0 16.4 83.6 16 3.38(1.03) 29 3.62(1.08) 22 3.50(1.06) ns in ever increasingly competitive work environments. 2.27 Assessment of work-related stress influence in companies 69 3.45(0.98) 0.0 15.9 84.1 18 3.22(0.81) 29 3.55(0.87) 22 3.50(1.23) ns (workers’ health, productivity, etc.). 2.28 Use and abuse of substances improving working performance 67 2.75(1.12) 0.0 41.8 58.2 17 2.18(0.88) 28 2.86(1.18) 22 3.05(1.09) 0.041 SE>NE and consequences on OSH. 2.29 Impact of mobile work on workers’ physical and psychosocial 67 3.25(1.09) 0.0 23.9 76.1 17 2.82(0.88) 29 3.52(1.06) 21 3.24(1.22) ns health. 2.30 Management of OSH risks in multi-location work. 66 3.29(1.09) 1.5 21.2 77.3 17 2.94(1.09) 29 3.38(1.15) 20 3.45(1.00) ns 2.31 Better understand and address effects of working-time flexibilisation (long working hours and shift work) on health, 70 3.81(0.86) 0.0 7.1 92.9 19 3.68(0.95) 29 3.76(0.79) 22 4.00(0.87) ns wellbeing and productivity of the working population (specific attention should to be paid to vulnerable workers). 3 – OSH RESEARCH FOR SAFE NEW TECHNOLOGIES 10. NANOMATERIALS 63 3.89(0.95) 0.0 11.1 88.9 15 3.53(1.30) 26 3.69(0.84) 22 4.36(0.58 0.015 SE>CE 3.32 Develop standardised sampling and measurement methods to 58 4.00(0.92) 1.7 1.7 96.6 16 3.63(1.26) 20 4.00(0.80) 22 4.27(0.63) ns quantify and characterise exposure to NOAA. 3.33 Develop regulations, guidelines and good practices for safely 57 3.90(1.08) 1.8 7.0 91.2 14 3.57(1.51) 21 4.05(0.92) 22 3.96(0.90) ns working with NOAA. 3.34 Improve risk assessment for workers exposed to NOAA (toxicological evaluation, studies of effects on human and 58 3.81(1.02) 1.7 8.6 89.7 15 3.47(1.46) 21 3.71(0.96) 22 4.14(0.56) ns biological systems and development of bio-monitoring programs). 3.35 Define Occupational Exposure Limits (OEL) for NOAA. 59 3.63(1.20) 1.6 15.3 83.1 15 3.13(1.51) 22 3.59(1.26) 22 4.00(0.76) ns 3.36 Improve research data and knowledge transfer on physical and chemical properties of NOAA to define the best set of 57 3.79(1.16) 1.8 10.5 87.7 15 3.20(1.37) 21 3.67(1.20) 21 4.33(0.66) 0.015 SE>NE properties for the cause-effect relationship. SE>NE 3.37 Improve risk management tools for exposure to NOAA. 59 3.70(1.10) 1.7 11.9 86.4 16 3.38(1.20) 21 3.48(1.17) 22 4.14(0.83) 0.030 SE>CE 3.38 Develop an information gathering approach for registration and 53 3.57(1.07) 1.9 13.2 84.9 14 3.43(1.40) 21 3.76(1.00) 18 3.44(0.86) ns toxicity testing for fibrous advanced materials. 11. GREEN JOBS 70 3.44(0.97) 0.0 12.9 87.1 18 3.33(1.09) 30 3.37(1.10) 22 3.64(0.66) ns 3.39 Better understand OSH implications in the Green Economy (e.g. green biotechnologies and green construction, renewable energies, waste management and environmental 65 3.57(0.98) 0.0 9.2 90.8 18 3.44(0.78) 25 3.44(1.16) 22 3.82(0.91) ns bioremediation) through data collection and scientific analysis on risk exposure. 3.40 Improve the identification and assessment of biological risks in the field of biofuel production (biomasses production, biogas 59 3.51(1.02) 0.0 15.3 84.7 18 3.67(0.69) 22 3.18(1.26) 19 3.74(0.93) ns plants, organic waste recovery), including the hazards related to the use of biotechnologies. 12. INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY 69 3.58(1.13) 1.4 14.5 84.1 17 3.12(1.36) 29 3.90(1.05) 23 3.52(0.95) ns (ICT) 3.41 Development of smart Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) and adaptive/wearable sensors for the monitoring of 67 3.70(1.10) 0.0 14.9 85.1 18 3.44(1.20) 29 3.55(1.09) 20 4.15(0.93) ns environmental conditions and workers’ physiological parameters. 3.42 Assessing the effects and impact of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) on workers’ H&S, quality of 67 3.36(1.08) 0.0 22.4 77.6 18 3.11(1.08) 28 3.79(1.07) 21 3.00(0.95) 0.013 CE>SE working life and work-life balance. 3.43 Legal and ethical issues of employee monitoring and collected 66 3.38(1.16) 1.5 15.2 83.3 18 3.28(1.13) 28 3.50(1.20) 20 3.30(1.17) ns data protection. 3.44 Data Security and workers’ safety in the Internet of Things (networks of physical objects that are embedded with the 64 3.39(1.35) 0.0 28.1 71.9 16 2.94(1.65) 28 3.75(1.24) 20 3.25(1.16) ns ability to exchange data, to interoperate with existing network infrastructure and that can be controlled remotely). 3.45 H&S factors in the design and engineering of multimodal 64 3.55(1.02) 0.0 17.2 82.8 16 3.13(1.03) 28 3.75(0.97) 20 3.60(1.05) ns human-computer interaction and interaction devices. 13. ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS 61 2.59(1.26) 6.5 41.0 52.5 17 1.82(1.24) 26 2.92(1.20) 18 2.83(1.10) 0.013 NE<CE NE<SE 3.46 Investigation of interaction mechanisms of magnetic, electric 57 2.97(1.31) 5.3 28.1 66.6 14 2.14(1.41) 24 3.17(1.09) 19 3.32(1.29) 0.023 NE<SE and electromagnetic fields with biological systems. 3.47 Electromagnetic fields in the workplace from advanced systems used in wireless communication and diagnostic technologies: 58 2.97(1.32) 3.4 29.3 67.3 14 2.14(1.29) 24 3.29(1.23) 20 3.15(1.27) 0.030 NE<CE human exposure and safe interaction with implantable therapeutic devices. 3.48 Safety evaluation of long exposure to electromagnetic low level 56 2.86(1.47) 8.9 32.2 58.9 12 2.00(1.35) 25 2.88(1.42) 19 3.37(1.42) 0.035 NE<SE fields. 14. EMERGING TECHNOLOGICAL DEVICES 71 3.87(0.96) 0.0 7.0 93.0 17 3.71(0.85) 31 4.03(0.88) 23 3.78(1.13) ns 3.49 Increasing use of 3D Printing and its implications on OSH. 63 3.29(1.10) 0.0 22.2 77.8 16 3.25(0.93) 28 3.36(1.25) 19 3.21(1.03) ns 3.50 Ensure the full exploitation of opportunities and control of risks for workers’ safety related to interaction between humans and 64 3.48(1.20) 3.1 12.5 84.4 17 3.18(0.95) 28 3.86(1.01) 19 3.21(1.51) ns robots. 3.51 OSH implication of Automated Guided Vehicles (AGV) and 62 3.29(1.22) 1.6 19.4 79.0 17 3.06(1.09) 27 3.37(1.25) 18 3.39(1.34) ns Drones. 3.52 OSH related to production, use and maintenance of battery 63 3.06(1.19) 3.2 25.4 71.4 16 2.81(1.05) 28 3.39(1.13) 19 2.79(1.32) ns powered devices, equipment and vehicles. 4 – CHEMICAL AND BIOLOGICAL AGENTS 15. BIOLOGICAL AGENTS 64 3.58(0.97) 0.0 15.6 84.4 17 3.29(1.21) 26 3.62(0.98) 21 3.76(0.70) ns 4.53 Investigate the contribution of microbial debris to the occupational exposure to airborne microorganism and the role 46 3.20(1.19) 2.2 15.2 82.6 13 3.31(1.25) 19 3.26(1.05) 14 3.00(1.36) ns of microorganisms in the development or aggravation of adverse health effects. 4.54 Investigate occupational risks due to the use or production of Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs) and Genetically 55 2.84(1.37) 5.5 32.7 61.8 16 2.44(1.32) 21 3.14(1.35) 18 2.83(1.43) ns Modified Microrganisms (GMMs). 4.55 By means of Personal Protective Equipments (PPEs), new antibiotics and vaccines development, ensure proper protection of European workers' health from emerging 55 3.42(1.21) 0.0 20.0 80.0 15 3.00(1.25) 21 3.43(1.25) 19 3.74(1.10) ns pathogens introduced (or reintroduced) by globalisation and climate change. 4.56 Identification of chemical markers and medical parameters for 53 3.32(1.25) 0.0 28.3 71.7 15 3.13(1.30) 21 3.38(1.16) 17 3.41(1.37) ns correlating the occupational exposure to biological agents. 4.57 Development of appropriate measurement devices and standardised methods for workplace sampling and assessment 55 3.62(1.16) 0.0 12.7 87.3 17 3.35(1.37) 20 3.90(0.91) 18 3.56(1.20) ns of exposure to bio-aerosols. 4.58 Analyses and hazard assessment of biological agents at 58 3.43(1.03) 0.0 19.0 81.0 16 3.56(1.21) 24 3.46(0.93) 18 3.28(1.02) ns workplaces with complex exposure situations. 4.59 Investigate effects of bioremediation technologies and biodegradable substances used to replace chemicals on 54 3.35(0.97) 0.0 18.5 81.5 16 3.13(1.09) 21 3.38(0.97) 17 3.53(0.87) ns workers’ health. 16. CHEMICAL AGENTS 64 3.83(0.94) 0.0 10.9 89.1 17 3.59(1.12) 26 3.96(0.77) 21 3.86(0.96) ns 4.60 Improve sampling and detection devices in providing an early 58 3.62(1.01) 0.0 15.5 84.5 16 3.63(1.20) 23 3.57(0.95) 19 3.68(0.95) ns and reliable detection of chemicals. 4.61 Increase the availability of reliable and non-invasive biomarkers for measuring occupational exposure to chemical substances 54 3.56(1.08) 0.0 16.7 83.3 15 3.53(1.13) 21 3.62(1.02) 18 3.50(1.15) ns and their effects. 4.62 Develop the necessary "a priori" knowledge of chemicals safety to support the increase in the use of "safety by design" 55 3.47(1.15) 0.0 23.6 76.4 15 3.00(1.41) 21 3.71(0.96) 19 3.58(1.07) ns practices in the development of new materials or in the use of known materials in innovative ways. 4.63 Scrutinising existing Occupational Exposure Limits (OEL) and their harmonisation with regulatory models (REACH and 52 3.44(1.18) 0.0 23.1 76.9 14 3.50(0.94) 21 3.24(1.41) 17 3.65(1.06) ns European Food Safety Authority -EFSA) in order to better protect workers' health. 4.64 Deepen understanding of multiple chemical exposures and interactions between chemicals and other risk factors (e.g. shift 59 3.63(1.14) 1.7 13.6 84.7 17 3.47(1.18) 23 3.61(1.20) 19 3.79(1.08) ns work and physical agents). 4.65 Deepen understanding of the relationship between individual 56 2.89(1.29) 1.8 35.7 62.5 16 2.81(1.33) 22 2.59(1.26) 18 3.33(1.24) ns (genetic) disposition and susceptibility against chemicals. 4.66 Develop exposure modelling techniques for Carcinogenic, Mutagenic and Reprotoxic (CMR) and sensitising substances in 53 3.51(1.03) 0.0 17.0 83.0 14 3.36(1.08) 22 3.50(1.10) 17 3.65(0.93) ns order to construct a European Job-Exposure Matrix (JEM). 4.67 Study on trends and significant changes in use of chemical and biological agents in the workplace (including information 56 3.23(1.04) 0.0 26.8 73.2 15 3.33(0.98) 22 3.23(0.92) 19 3.16(1.26) ns provided by Market Analysis). MISCELLANEOUS 5.68 Develop tools and methods to support European companies to better address their specific prevention needs and build 67 3.21(1.25) 3.0 23.9 73.1 16 2.88(1.26) 28 3.36(1.25) 23 3.26(1.25) ns programmes to monitor and “secure” employees’ health. 5.69 From research to practice: translation of OSH research evidence into practical tools to be used at company level and 72 3.82(1.17) 1.4 12.5 86.1 19 3.63(1.21) 30 3.90(1.21) 23 3.87(1.10) ns identification of the best ways to reach workers. 5.70 Development of a cross EU H&S qualification. 66 2.55(1.26) 7.6 34.8 57.6 17 2.29(1.05) 29 2.52(1.53) 20 2.80(0.95) ns 5.71 Studies on polarisation of employees' occupational health resources in the labour market (between employees, workplaces, regions, sectors of employment) and prevention of 59 2.85(1.11) 1.7 33.9 64.4 15 3.20(1.01) 26 2.62(1.20) 18 2.89(1.02) ns processes leading to unequal distribution of health at various levels. 5.72 OSH implementation in micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs): develop methods and tools to exploit available data to 67 3.61(1.17) 1.5 13.4 85.1 18 3.56(1.20) 28 3.75(0.97) 21 3.48(1.40) ns locate, identify, characterise and better regulate ever changing SMEs. 5.73 Development of measurement techniques, assessment strategies and safety requirements for noise exposure in call 62 2.36(1.22) 3.2 46.8 50.0 15 1.87(0.92) 28 2.54(1.29) 19 2.47(1.26) ns centres. 5.74 Non-audible noise: perception, influence, exposure limits, measurement techniques, assessment strategies, sources in 54 2.76(1.26) 5.6 33.3 61.1 14 1.79(1.05) 26 3.31(0.93) 14 2.71(1.44) 0.001 NE<CE new technologies and safety requirements. 5.75 Develop knowledge, concepts, techniques and tools to foster a transdisciplinary approach to research on new technologies 64 3.33(1.31) 4.7 20.3 75.0 16 2.94(1.39) 29 3.66(1.08) 19 3.16(1.50) ns development, able to address OSH issues from the design stage. 5.76 Ultrasound on bioeffects and safety: evaluating cell alterations at both cell membrane and genetic level at non-cavitation 41 2.15(1.37) 12.2 48.8 39.0 12 1.83(1.40) 17 1.94(1.35) 12 2.75(1.29) ns regime. 5.77 Malodorous substances at the workplace: validating test systems determining unacceptable nuisance for Occupational 54 2.07(1.21) 7.4 55.6 37.0 13 1.39(0.96) 24 2.46(1.10) 17 2.06(1.35) 0.037 NE<CE Exposure Limits (OEL) setting purposes.