You are on page 1of 4

NUTRITION & ERGOGENIC AIDS

Effects of Oral Lactate Consumption on


Metabolism and Exercise Performance
Dave Morris, PhD

lactate could enhance energy substrate


Abstract
status during exercise by sparing muscle
Study of lactate metabolism has revealed that orally consumed lactate is
glycogen or by fortifying blood glucose
used as an energy substrate either directly by oxidation or by conversion to
stores. More recent studies of lactate
glucose. Disposal of lactate by oxidation or gluconeogenesis consumes
have called into question its role in pro-
protons and can fortify blood bicarbonate levels temporarily and increase
moting muscle fatigue either directly
pH. These characteristics have led to investigations of lactate consumption
(5,9) or through contributing to meta-
as an energy substrate and as a buffering agent. Evidence has revealed no
bolic acidosis (14). Close examination of
effects of lactate consumption on time to exhaustion during low- to
glycolysis reveals that complete metab-
moderate-intensity exercise, suggesting that it is ineffective as an energy
olism of glucose to lactate results in no
supplement. Lactate ingestion has been shown to increase blood pH and
net release of protons and, thus, does not
bicarbonate levels and increase time to exhaustion in short, high-intensity
contribute to acidosis. In fact, during the
work bouts. Future work should focus on determining optimal doses of
production of lactate from pyruvate,
lactate, temporal relationships between doses and exercise, and the
protons are consumed and acidosis is
efficacy of lactate as an ergogenic in different types of high-intensity
inhibited (14). Furthermore, lactate oxi-
exercise.
dation and lactate consumption via glu-
coneogenesis consume hydrogen ions
and are alkalinizing processes.
Introduction Lactate’s role as an energy substrate and mediator of pH
For many years, the production and metabolism of lactate balance has sparked interest into the metabolic and exercise
have been scrutinized by exercise physiologists. In the early performance effects of orally consumed lactate. This article
days of study, lactate was considered to be a waste product aimed to review published studies on the metabolic and
formed when glucose-6-phosphate was catabolized by gly- ergogenic effects of lactate consumption. The review will first
colysis under hypoxic conditions. Lactate production was address the studies that have focused on lactate consumption
also thought to release hydrogen ions, which promoted as an energy supplement and then will present works that
skeletal muscle fatigue by contributing to acidosis. Others have investigated its use as a buffering agent.
suggested that high levels of lactate in the muscle cell could
promote reductions in work capacity (7). Thus, no viable
reason could be seen for using orally consumed lactate as an Oral Lactate as an Energy Substrate
ergogenic aid. The initial investigations of lactate consumption as an
Viewpoints on lactate started to change in the 1980s, energy supplement evolved from previous works that studied
when researchers began providing evidence that it was not a the metabolic fates of intravenously infused lactate in exer-
harmful waste product but an energy intermediate that could cising subjects (8,11). These studies of lactate metabolism
be further metabolized to provide substrate for the tri- demonstrated that substantial amounts of infused lactate
carboxylic acid cycle or gluconeogenesis (11). In either case, were oxidized in exercising skeletal muscle and led some
investigators to ponder the effects of oral lactate con-
Department of Health, Leisure, and Exercise Science, Appalachian State sumption on endurance exercise performance. Early attempts
University, Boone, NC
of lactate ingestion were unsuccessful because oral con-
Address for correspondence: Dave Morris, PhD, Department of Health, sumption of large boluses was found to result in extreme
Leisure, and Exercise Science, Appalachian State University, 53 Holmes gastric distress. However, Fahey et al. (6) eventually identi-
Convocation Center, 111 Rivers St., Boone, NC 28608; fied tolerable oral doses of lactate and compared the effects
E-mail: morrisdm@appstate.edu of consuming beverages containing 7% lactate, 7% malto-
1537-890X/1104/185Y188
dextrin, or aspartame on various metabolic responses during
Current Sports Medicine Reports 3 h of cycle ergometry at 50% of V̇O2max. The beverages
Copyright * 2012 by the American College of Sports Medicine were provided in 250-mL doses 5 min before and every

www.acsm-csmr.org Current Sports Medicine Reports 185

Copyright © 2012 by the American College of Sports Medicine. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
20 min during exercise. Treatments were applied in a the endurance portion of the exercise challenge were de-
randomized, double-blind, crossover design. Blood was signed to elicit approximately 86% of maximum heart rate
drawn before and during exercise and analyzed for glucose, and were maintained at a cadence of 80 rpm. When the
lactate, pH, and bicarbonate. In each of the three treatments, subjects indicated that they could no longer maintain 80 rpm
blood glucose remained at basal levels through 100 min of they immediately performed a 30-s Wingate test against a
exercise. During the final 60 min of exercise, blood glucose resistance of 0.09 kgIkgj1 body mass. The subjects con-
dropped significantly from preexercise levels, when subjects sumed the beverages at the start of exercise and every 20 min
consumed the placebo, but was maintained at basal levels in thereafter until exhaustion. Identical volumes of each bever-
the lactate and maltodextrin trials. No difference in blood age were given at each consumption period for all treat-
glucose was observed between the lactate and maltodextrin ments, and these volumes were equal to the amount that
trials. Blood pH and bicarbonate increased significantly over would provide 0.3 g of carbohydrate per kilogram of body
basal levels during the final 60 min of the lactate trial, while mass from the 8% carbohydrate beverage. The authors
no differences in these variables were observed in the placebo measured time to exhaustion during the submaximal ride
and maltodextrin trials. and perceived exertion, RER, blood bicarbonate, blood pH,
While these results demonstrated positive metabolic respon- and blood glucose levels before and at 30-min intervals dur-
ses to lactate ingestion, the investigation lacked key evidence to ing exercise. Blood bicarbonate, pH, and glucose levels also
support the use of oral lactate consumption as an ergogenic aid. were measured following the Wingate test. During the 30-s
The exercise intensity was low and not reflective of intensities Wingate test, peak power, and fatigue rate were measured
typically found in competitive endurance events. More impor- and were expressed in absolute terms and in relation to the
tantly, a performance trial was not included in the assessment of same values obtained during an initial 30-s Wingate test
the supplements. that was performed several days before the advent of the
Swensen et al. (15) compared the effects of a combined experimental trials.
7% carbohydrate-lactate beverage to a 7% beverage con- Bryner et al. (3) found no difference in time to exhaustion
taining only carbohydrate on various metabolic variables between treatments. During the 30-s Wingate test, no sig-
and time to exhaustion in trained cyclists during cycle ergo- nificant differences were observed between treatments with
metry at 70% of V̇O2max. The original intent of this study respect to absolute peak power or peak power relative to the
was to compare a 7% carbohydrate beverage to a 7% lactate initial peak power output obtained in the days before the
beverage identical to that used by Fahey et al. (6). However, experimental trials. Inexplicably, the absolute fatigue rate
during pilot trials, the subjects of Swensen et al. (15) devel- was lower in the placebo trial compared with the carbohy-
oped severe gastric distress after consuming the 7% lac- drate and carbohydrate-plus-lactate trials. Perceived exertion
tate beverage. Ultimately, these investigators used a 7% did not differ between the treatments at any point during the
carbohydrate-lactate beverage containing 6.25 g of glucose exercise test to exhaustion. RER was significantly lower
polymer and 0.75 g of lactate per 100 mL of water. This in the lactate trial when compared with placebo and the
combined beverage was similar to a commercially available carbohydrate-lactate trial during the second hour of the
carbohydrate-lactate beverage (CytoMaxA) but with a higher exercise test to exhaustion. No significant drops in blood
concentration of lactate. Consumption of each beverage glucose levels from baseline were observed in the carbohy-
commenced at the beginning of exercise and was repeated drate or carbohydrate-lactate trials at any time point during
every 20 min during exercise. At each feeding, the subjects or following exercise. Blood glucose levels were significantly
consumed enough of each drink to provide 0.3 g of carbo- lower than preexercise levels following the Wingate test in
hydrate per kilogram of body mass. The treatments were both the lactate-only and placebo trials and at 30 and 60 min
applied in a randomized, double-blind, crossover fashion, of the exercise to exhaustion test during the lactate-only trial.
and both solutions were flavored with an artificial sweetener These blood glucose levels were not, however, significantly
to help blind the subjects to the treatments. Blood glucose different from those observed at the same time points in the
levels were maintained at resting levels during the first 3 h of carbohydrate or carbohydrate-lactate trials.
exercise in both trials, and no significant differences were In measurements of pH, Bryner et al. (3) found significant
observed between treatments. Carbohydrate oxidation rates elevations compared with baseline after 30 min of exercise in
also were similar for both treatments. Finally, no significant the placebo and lactate-only trials. This elevation was exten-
difference in time to exhaustion between the two treatments ded to the 60-min measurement in the lactate-only trial. No
was observed (214.7 T 17 min for the carbohydrate trial vs other differences due to time or treatment were observed.
214.4 T 22 min for the carbohydrate-lactate trial). Blood bicarbonate was significantly lower compared with
Bryner et al. (3) measured the effects of beverages contain- baseline after 30 min of exercise in the placebo treatment and
ing only water, 2% lactate, 8% carbohydrate, and a combi- after 60 min of exercise in the lactate treatment. Following the
nation of 8% carbohydrate and 2% lactate on exercise Wingate test, blood bicarbonate levels were significantly lower
performance and physiological responses in trained cyclists compared with baseline in all but the carbohydrate trial.
during cycle ergometry. These investigators also used a ran- The results of Bryner et al. (3) can be difficult to interpret
domly assigned, double-blind, crossover design. The exercise because of the variability in many of the measures and
challenge combined a moderate-intensity exercise test to the statistical approached used to analyze the data. While
exhaustion followed by a 30-s Wingate test in an attempt to means and standard deviations were not presented for all of
mimic a competitive situation in which athletes would have the dependent variables, those that were generally had high
to indulge in a long, exhaustive competition and sprint standard deviations resulting in coefficients of variation
against competitors at the end of the race. Work rates for that ranged from approximately 0.30 to greater than 0.50.

186 Volume 11 & Number 4 & July/August 2012 Oral Lactate Use and Exercise Performance

Copyright © 2012 by the American College of Sports Medicine. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Unfortunately, no tests of statistical power were performed. approximately half of exogenous lactate has is oxidized while
The authors also used a series of paired t-tests to compare the remainder is used as substrate for numerous metabolic
baseline measurements to those recorded during exercise processes, most notably gluconeogenesis (11). Disposal of
and at fatigue. This practice is known to cause alpha infla- lactate by oxidation (C3H5O3 + 3O2 + H+ Y 3CO2 + 3H2O)
tion and increase the likelihood of a type 1 error. Thus, the or gluconeogenesis (2C3H5O3 + 2H+ Y C6H12O6) consumes
statistical approach and low statistical power could have protons and thus has the potential to affect blood bicarbonate
contributed to the seemingly random observations of stat- and pH levels.
istical significance. Van Montfoort et al. (16) were the first to investigate the
Azevedo et al. (1) also used a two-stage exercise test to use of oral lactate consumption as a buffering agent. In their
investigate the metabolic and performance effects of orally investigation, 15 trained distance runners completed a single,
consumed lactate. Trained cyclists performed 90 min of cycle high-intensity run to exhaustion following consumption of
ergometry at a work rate that elicited 62% of V̇O2max fol- 400 mgIkgj1 body mass of sodium lactate, 525 mgIkgj1 body
lowed by an exercise test to exhaustion at a work rate that mass of sodium citrate, 300 mgIkgj1 body mass of sodium
elicited 86% of V̇O2max. Subjects consumed 6% w/v bev- bicarbonate, or 209 mgIkgj1 body mass of sodium chlo-
erages containing either carbohydrate (glucose + fructose) or ride given in a randomized, double-blind, crossover fashion.
a combination of carbohydrate and lactate. Drinks were Ninety minutes following the ingestion of the supplements, the
provided in isocaloric 250-mL doses 2 min before the advent subjects began a 15-min warm-up and then proceeded to the
of exercise and every 15 min during the 3-h exercise period. exercise test to exhaustion. Compared to placebo (NaCl),
Both drinks were enriched with 13C-labeled glucose, fruc- lactate consumption resulted in a 4% improvement in per-
tose, or lactate (carbohydrate + lactate beverage only). Blood formance by increasing time to exhaustion from 77 to 80 s.
and expired air were collected during the initial exercise While these results are promising, there are several con-
period and analyzed for the carbon isotope to assess sub- cerns about this investigation. High-intensity exercise tests to
strate utilization. The subjects performed three trials of exhaustion typically have intrasubject variation in perform-
the carbohydrate-lactate treatment and two trials of the car- ance of approximately 5% to 10% (2,4), which is greater
bohydrate-only treatment to assess substrate utilization of all than the performance improvement that was observed by
of the components of each drink. The treatments were Van Montfoort et al. (16). The limitations of treadmill run-
applied in a randomized crossover fashion, but only the ning as an exercise test also must be recognized. Work per-
subjects were blinded to the composition of the drinks. formed on a treadmill is very difficult to measure and is
The metabolic results revealed a high rate of lactate oxida- affected by the body mass of the subject. No mention was
tion during the carbohydrate-lactate trials. Subjects increased made about monitoring the body mass of the subjects before
their time to exhaustion in the 86% V̇O2max portion of the each exercise trial and, thus, some fluctuation in perform-
exercise trial by 25% from 5.2 T 1.0 min in the carbohydrate ance could have been due to changes in body mass. Yet
trial to 6.5 T 0.8 min in the carbohydrate-lactate trial another possible shortcoming in this investigation is the time
(P G 0.05). Interclass correlation coefficients were high for span between ingestion of the lactate and the performance of
both treatments (r = 0.89, P G 0.03 for carbohydrate only; the exercise trial. The subjects were given 60 min to consume
r = 0.957, P G 0.04 for carbohydrate-lactate), indicating a high their supplements followed by a 90-min rest period before
degree of reliability for this type of performance test. starting their warm-up. The performance trial began
The mechanism for the increase in performance observed approximately 15 min after the commencement of the warm-
during the carbohydrate-lactate trial is not clear entirely. The up, or about 105 min following the consumption of the last
subjects received isocaloric amounts of each beverage, so it is capsule of sodium lactate and 165 min after consumption
doubtful that energy balance contributed to the difference in began. Subsequent data have suggested that the optimum
performance. A possible explanation for the increase in per- time for performance enhancement following lactate inges-
formance is an increase in the blood bicarbonate and pH tion may be closer to 80 min after ingestion (13).
levels following the ingestion of lactate. Significant evidence In a pilot work for the study of lactate ingestion, we
suggests that acidosis contributes to development of muscle measured blood bicarbonate responses for 120 min follow-
fatigue and high-intensity exercise performance has been ing the ingestion of 20, 120, and 220 mgIkgj1 body mass of
shown to be enhanced when the blood is alkalinized by lactate. In contrast to Van Montfoort et al. (16), our subjects
consumption of sodium bicarbonate (10). Lactate con- consumed their supplements in a bolus within a 5-min
sumption also has been shown to increase blood pH and period. Blood samples were taken and analyzed for blood
bicarbonate levels in previous investigations (2,6,15). bicarbonate levels before, and every 20 min for 120 min
Although Azevedo et al. (1) did not measure bicarbonate or following the ingestion of the supplements. These trials
pH levels, prolonged exercise at intensities similar to those revealed that blood bicarbonate levels peaked at 80 min
used in their performance test has been shown to elicit following the ingestion of the lactate supplements followed
acidosis (12). Thus, if acidosis was a major contributing by a steady decline through the 120-min measurement point.
factor to fatigue in their protocol, the consumption of lactate This response pattern was seen in each of the three doses.
could have provided an ergogenic effect by acting as a buf- Furthermore, while the 120- and 220-mgIkgj1 body mass
fering agent. doses resulted in substantially higher blood bicarbonate
levels compared with the 20-mgIkgj1 dose, no differences
Oral Lactate as a Buffering Agent were noted between the 120- and 220-mgIkgj1 doses with
Numerous investigations have monitored the metabolic respect to the magnitude of increase in blood bicarbonate
fates of infused or ingested lactate (1,8,11). During rest, levels. Finally, while Van Montfoort et al. (16) reported

www.acsm-csmr.org Current Sports Medicine Reports 187

Copyright © 2012 by the American College of Sports Medicine. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
that postingestion blood pH and bicarbonate were sig- three studies supported the use of lactate as a buffering agent,
nificantly higher after lactate ingestion when compared continued research in this area is encouraged. Dozens of
with NaCl consumption, they did not compare the post- similar studies using sodium bicarbonate as a buffer have
ingestion to preingestion levels of these variables in any provided conflicting results and revealed the importance of
of the treatments. Thus, the effects of lactate ingestion on proper dosing and timing of the ingestion of buffering agents
blood pH and bicarbonate were not entirely clear. in relation to the exercise task. The intensity, duration, and
In a subsequent investigation by Morris et al. (13), 11 type of exercise challenge, i.e., time to exhaustion versus time
trained cyclists consumed 120 mgIkgj1 body mass of lactate trials, single exercise bouts versus repeated efforts, may in-
in a single bolus 80 min before performing high-intensity cycle fluence the efficacy of buffering agents as ergogenics and
ergometry to exhaustion. The exercise protocol consisted of should be explored in relation to lactate consumption.
four 1-min work intervals at 100% of V̇O2max work rate
each followed by 1-min recovery periods performed at 25%
of V̇O2max work rate. Immediately following the final rest
period, the subjects performed a final work bout to exhaustion The author declares no conflict of interest and does not
at 100% of V̇O2max work rate. Each subject repeated the have any financial disclosures.
protocol under three conditions: following consumption of
lactate, an equal volume of placebo, and no treatment. The
lactate and placebo were provided in a double-blinded manner References
1. Azevedo JL, Tietz E, Two-Feathers T, et al. Lactate, fructose and glucose
and a randomized crossover approach was used for the ap- oxidation profiles in sports drinks and the effect on exercise performance.
plication of the treatments. Time to exhaustion in the lactate PLoS One. 2007; 2:e927.
trial (168 T 31 s) was significantly greater than in the no- 2. Billat V, Renoux JC, Pinoteau J, et al. Reproducibility of running time to
treatment (143 T 29 s) and placebo (137 T 41 s) trials. This exhaustion a V̇O2max in subelite runners. Med. Sci. Sports Exerc. 1994; 26:
254Y7.
represented an increase in performance of 18% compared 3. Bryner RW, Hornsby WG, Chetlin R, et al. Effect of lactate consumption on
with the no-treatment trial and 17% compared with the pla- exercise performance. J. Sports Med. Phys. Fitness. 1998; 38:116Y23.
cebo trial, which is much greater than the variability typically 4. Coggan AR, Costill DL. Biological and technological variability of three
seen in repeated applications of high-intensity exercise tests anaerobic ergometer tests. In. J. Sports Med. 1984; 5:142Y5.
to exhaustion. Furthermore, blood bicarbonate levels were 5. Erdogan S, Kurdak SS, Ergen N, Dogan A. The effect of l-(+)-lactate on
tension development and excitability in in vitro rat diaphragm muscle. J.
significantly elevated following consumption of lactate when Sports Med. Phys. Fitness. 2002; 42:418Y24.
compared with preconsumption levels and when compared 6. Fahey TD, Larsen JD, Brooks GA, et al. The effects of ingesting polylactate
with preconsumption and postconsumption levels of the pla- or glucose polymer drinks during prolonged exercise. Int. J. Sport Nutr.
cebo and no-treatment protocols. No changes due to any of 1991; 1:249Y56.
the treatments were observed in blood pH. 7. Hogan MC, Gladden LB, Kurdak SS, Poole DC. Increased [lactate] in
working dog muscle reduces tension development independent of pH. Med.
Sci. Sports Exerc. 1995; 27:371Y7.
Summary 8. Jorfeldt L. Metabolism of l-(+)-lactate in human skeletal muscle during
The study of exogenous lactate as an ergogenic has exercise. Acta. Physiol. Scand Suppl. 1970; 338:1Y67.
focused on its use as an energy substrate and as an alkalin- 9. Karelis AD, Marcil M, Peronnet F, Gardiner PF. Effect of lactate infusion on
izing agent. Investigations have shown that orally consumed M-wave characteristics and force in the rat plantaris muscle during repeated
stimulation in situ. J. Appl. Physiol. 2004; 96:2133Y8.
lactate is oxidized readily by working muscle and can main-
10. Matson LG, Tran ZV. Effects of sodium bicarbonate ingestion on anaerobic
tain blood glucose levels during extended exercise bouts. performance: a meta-analytic review. Int. J. Sport Nutr. 1993; 3:2Y28.
However, lactate is not well tolerated by the gastrointestinal 11. Mazzeo RS, Brooks GA, Schoeller DA, Budinger TF. Disposal of blood
track and can be consumed only in relatively dilute solu- [1-13C]lactate in humans during rest and exercise. J. Appl. Physiol. 1986;
60:232Y41.
tions (È2% w/v solution vs 6% to 9% w/v solution in car-
bohydrate beverages). Thus, the total caloric load that can 12. Morris DM, Shafer RS. Comparison of power outputs during time trialing
and power outputs eliciting metabolic variables in cycle ergometry. Int. J.
be provided by oral lactate consumption is limited and rela- Sport Nutr. Exerc. Metab. 2010; 20:115Y21.
tively low. Two studies have investigated the effects of lactate, 13. Morris DM, Shafer RS, Fairbrother KR, Woodall MW. Effects of lactate
consumed alone or with carbohydrate, on time to exhaustion consumption on blood bicarbonate levels and performance during high-
intensity exercise. Int. J. Sport Nutr. Exerc. Metab. 2011; 21:311Y7.
during low- to moderate-intensity exercise and neither dem-
14. Robergs RA, Ghiasvand F, Parker D. Biochemistry of exercise-induced met-
onstrated ergogenic effects. However, lactate consumption abolic acidosis. Am. J. Physiol. Regul. Integr. Comp. Physiol. 2004; 287:
may be effective as a buffering agent. Numerous investiga- R502Y16.
tions have demonstrated that oral consumption of lactate can 15. Swensen T, Crater G, Bassett DR, Howley ET. Adding polylactate to a glu-
increase blood pH and/or bicarbonate levels. Three studies of cose polymer solution does not improve endurance. Int. J. Sports Med. 1994;
15:430Y4.
the effects of lactate consumption on performance of high-
16. Van Montfoort MCE, Van Dieren L, Hopkins WG, Shearman JP. Effects of
intensity exercise revealed increases in exercise time to ex- ingestion of bicarbonate, citrate, lactate and chloride on sprint running. Med.
haustions ranging from 4% to 25%. Although each of these Sci. Sports Exerc. 2004; 36:1239Y43.

188 Volume 11 & Number 4 & July/August 2012 Oral Lactate Use and Exercise Performance

Copyright © 2012 by the American College of Sports Medicine. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.

You might also like