Professional Documents
Culture Documents
org
Clinical Rounds
Breast engorgement is an uncomfortable and sometimes painful component of the postpartum period. The effective treatment of breast engorge-
ment may provide an avenue for clinicians to improve postpartum care for women and promote breastfeeding. This case report presents one
woman’s experience with breast engorgement in the early postpartum period. The etiology, evidence-based practices for treatment, clinical impli-
cations, and recommendations for practice are reviewed. The importance of interprofessional care to minimize conflicting information a lactating
woman receives is highlighted. Interprofessional teamwork can optimize care to resolve breast engorgement and facilitate a woman achieving her
breastfeeding goals.
J Midwifery Womens Health 2019;00:1–6 c 2019 by the American College of Nurse-Midwives.
Keywords: breastfeeding, breast engorgement, lactation, lactogenesis, postpartum, midwifery, interprofessional communication
CASE REPORT and hand express in the warm water, pump as much as pos-
A.M. was a 32-year-old woman, gravida 1, para 1, who sible, and apply ice packs to her breasts. The suggestions left
gave birth at a birth center and was discharged home 6 A.M. unsure of the best approach for relief after receiving
hours after birth. A.M. had an uncomplicated, healthy conflicting advice. At the first pediatric visit on postpartum
pregnancy that culminated in the rapid labor and normal day 1, the pediatric team confirmed a newborn tongue tie,
spontaneous vaginal birth of a vigorous, full-term male for which an in-office frenectomy was performed.
newborn. The newborn was placed skin-to-skin imme- By day 3 postpartum, A.M. was still engorged, and her
diately after birth, and breastfeeding was initiated at the breasts were taut, lumpy, hard, and increasingly painful to
birth center. The attending midwife noted a tongue tie touch, with worsening newborn latch. A.M. returned to the
during the preliminary newborn examination and did not pediatrician to find that her newborn had lost 11% of his
recommend intervention at that time. A.M. had inverted birth weight. With increasing concern for newborn well-
nipples but reported her newborn latched well the first being, she was advised to formula supplement. The pedi-
day; however, over the next few days, her breasts became atrician gave A.M. a nipple shield to assist with latch, but
engorged, making newborn latch difficult. A.M. had concerns about using it because of previous ad-
A.M. reported many problems with breastfeeding start- vice from the lactation consultant to avoid a nipple shield.
ing the first day postpartum while at her home. On the first A.M. called the midwives’ practice again, and the nurse
day home, A.M. called the midwives’ office and reported advised her to use belladonna and arnica by mouth and
that her breasts were filling quickly, stating they felt “super continue warm compresses, hot showers, pumping, and
hard and painful.” A nurse triaged A.M.’s call and discour- nursing as much as possible. A friend suggested she apply
aged pumping to avoid increasing engorgement, recom- cabbage leaves to the breasts, which A.M. also tried.
mended applying ice, wearing a well-fitting bra, and hand On postpartum days 4 and 5, the newborn was able to
expressing while taking multiple warm showers daily. A.M. latch with difficulty, but A.M.’s breasts were still painfully
found it difficult to maintain this regimen while caring for engorged. A.M. contacted another lactation consultant,
a newborn. A referral was given for a lactation consultant who came for a home visit and advised her to stop every-
during the initial call. The lactation consultant was con- thing and nurse every 3 hours (with breast massage), pump
tacted, and she advised A.M. to hang her breasts in a tub until breasts feel empty, and apply ice after each feeding.
She encouraged A.M. to wean pumping after 24 hours. This
treatment was effective for A.M., and her breast engorge-
ment resolved approximately 24 hours after the lactation
1
Johns Hopkins University School of Nursing, Baltimore, consultant’s home visit.
Maryland
2
Baltimore Medical Systems, Baltimore, Maryland
3 INTRODUCTION
Herman & Walter Samuelson Children’s Hospital, Baltimore,
Maryland Recent studies suggest that many women (83.2%) who give
Correspondence birth in the United States initiate breastfeeding following
Ashley Gresh birth, but less than 50% of infants are exclusively breast-
Email: Ashley.gresh@jhu.edu fed at 3 months of age.1 The reasons for breastfeeding ces-
ORCID sation in the early postpartum period are complex and
Ashley Gresh https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7181-8219 multifactorial; difficulties with lactation, including breast
1526-9523/09/$36.00 doi:10.1111/jmwh.13011
c 2019 by the American College of Nurse-Midwives 1
engorgement, have been found as reasons for early cessation taught to breastfeed frequently in the first 48 hours of a new-
of breastfeeding.2 Two-thirds of women report experiencing born’s life.3
some form of breast engorgement after giving birth.3 In an
analysis of the Infant Feeding Practices Study II (N = 2572), DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS OF PRIMARY BREAST
60% of women stopped breastfeeding earlier than they had ENGORGEMENT
initially intended.3 The participants identified several reasons
Prior to treating engorgement, it is important to differenti-
for discontinuing breastfeeding; women who stopped breast-
ate breast engorgement from other causes of swelling such
feeding before they intended reported a higher incidence of
as mastitis or gigantomastia. Often preceded by breast en-
breast engorgement (10.9% vs 5.7%, respectively; P = .002),
gorgement, mastitis is characterized by an infection in the
and this study found that engorgement was associated with a
breast tissue leading to inflammation.6 The presence of fever,
higher odds of discontinuing breastfeeding (odds ratio, 1.97;
erythema, purulent drainage, and induration may suggest
95% CI, 1.22-3.52).2
mastitis.11 Gigantomastia is an excessive growth of breast tis-
Stage II of lactogenesis typically occurs 2 to 4 days post-
sue and presents with increased size of the areola and breasts
partum. Most often women leave the birth center or hospital
and may require medication or surgical intervention.12,13
setting before their breasts become engorged;4 therefore, it is
important to educate women and their families about the pro-
cess of lactogenesis and to guide them using evidence-based PREVENTION AND TREATMENT OF PRIMARY
BREAST ENGORGEMENT
practice for managing engorgement.
Primary breast engorgement is a self-limiting condition,
which makes research on effective prevention and treatment
ETIOLOGY AND CLINICAL MANIFESTATION OF modalities difficult.4 Although there are some scales of breast
BREAST ENGORGEMENT
engorgement in use, there is no standardized tool for evalua-
Engorgement can occur at various times throughout the post- tion and diagnosis. Treatment primarily focuses on facilitating
partum period and is classified as primary or secondary excretion of milk from the breast and providing symptomatic
engorgement.5,6 Primary engorgement occurs during stage care.13 The Cochrane Collaboration published an updated re-
II of lactogenesis, which generally occurs between the sec- view of the scientific literature addressing interventions for
ond and fourth day following birth. Primary engorgement breast engorgement during lactation in 2016.13 For the pur-
includes interstitial breast edema, increased vascularity, and pose of this case report, a review of peer-reviewed literature
congestion; initiation of milk production usually lasts approx- was conducted in PubMed and CINAHL Plus to capture ad-
imately 24 to 48 hours.5,7–9 Secondary breast engorgement is ditional publications on the topics since that time. A summary
the result of an imbalance between milk production and ex- of findings is provided in Table 1.
traction. This article addresses treatments for primary breast
engorgement.5
Medication
Women with breast engorgement report a sense of heav-
iness as the breasts fill, leading to tenderness and distension. Medications used to treat primary breast engorgement in-
The skin is often warm, veins become prominent, and skin clude progesterone and agents that reduce inflammation. Pro-
becomes taut. During this stage, the nipples may become firm gesterone inhibits the effects of prolactin and could thereby
or flattened, making it difficult for the newborn to latch.6,9 theoretically slow milk production. The use of a topical pro-
Because of the increased metabolic rate associated with milk gesterone gel applied to the breasts of 23 women with engorge-
production, mild elevated temperatures up to 38°C (100.4°F) ment resulted in only a 2.2% (SD, 2.2%) decrease in measured
may occur despite breast engorgement not involving an in- breast firmness in one study.14 In a randomized controlled
flammatory or infectious process.4,9,10 During this phase of trial (N = 70) conducted in 1989 in Singapore, the adminis-
lactogenesis, women should be able to continue to breastfeed tration of Serrapeptase, a dietary supplement thought to have
comfortably and efficiently, as the sensation of breast full- anti-inflammatory effects, was associated with “marked” im-
ness can be uncomfortable but is rarely severe and is a self- provement in 22.9% of women when compared with placebo
limiting condition.4 Engorgement can be peripheral, in the (P ⬍ .05).15 Additionally, 85.7% of women reported “moder-
body of the breast, or involve the areola, and both breasts are ate to marked” improvement in symptoms while taking Ser-
affected.5 rapeptase, compared with 60% who reported “moderate to
Severe engorgement is a pathologic condition and can marked” improvement while receiving placebo (P ⬍ .05).15
result from mismanagement of milk stasis. With severe en- However, this study was completed more than 30 years ago
gorgement, the breasts become hard, red, hot, shiny, and very and has not been validated in subsequent research.
painful.9 Severe engorgement can occur with delayed initia-
tion of feedings, use of breast milk supplements, infrequent
Hot and Cold Treatments
feedings, history of breast surgery that affected outflow tracts,
or removing the newborn from the breast prior to completely Hot and cold treatments are often used for symptomatic re-
emptying the breast.4,5 If the newborn is unable to latch, the lief of acute pain, inflammation, and symptomatic treatment.
woman’s pain increases, and breast and nipple tissue may be- An experimental study conducted in Iran comparing acupres-
come so taut that trauma to the tissue can occur as the new- sure versus intermittent hot and cold compresses (N = 70) ap-
born vigorously tries to withdraw milk from the breast.4 Se- plied over 2 days found that both treatments were effective at
vere engorgement is less common among individuals who are decreasing symptoms of engorgement (P ⬍ .001).16 Notably,
(Continued)
hot and cold compresses were found to be more efficacious packs reduced pain scores by 2.2 points (P = .001) compared
than acupressure (P ⬍ .001).16 A randomized controlled trial with baseline.20 There was no statistically significant differ-
(N = 500) conducted in Thailand compared the use of hot ence between the posttreatment scores comparing cabbage
compresses with and without an herbal component to re- leaves with cold packs (P = .46).20 Another randomized
duce pain associated with breast engorgement.17 Results of controlled trial (N = 39) conducted in Australia examined
the study revealed that both treatments reduced pain scores: the effects of cabbage leaf extract mixed into cream compared
hot compresses decreased pain scores from 5.8 to 2.8 (on a with cream without cabbage leaf extract. Women who used
10-point scale; P ⬍ .001), and the hot, herbal compresses de- both creams reported subjective improvements in symptoms
creased reported pain scores from 6.9 to 1.0 (P ⬍ .001).17 The and pain scores decreased by 1.2 points (on a 10-point scale)
hot compress with herbal components was associated with without significant differences between groups (P ⬎ .05).21
a statistically significant greater improvement in pain (P ⬍
.05).17 The World Health Organization recommends hot com- Nontraditional Therapies
presses or a warm shower to help facilitate milk removal be- Nontraditional or alternative therapies are often employed for
fore feeding a newborn.9 A systematic review of the literature additional symptomatic pain relief for a wide variety of con-
found unpublished reports that cold compresses are recom- ditions or discomforts. Gua Sha is a Chinese muscle scrap-
mended after or between feedings to decrease symptoms of ing therapy applied to the breast that has been traditionally
pain and swelling.13 used to treat pain based on the Chinese principles of the 12
meridians.22 A randomized controlled trial (N = 54) assessed
Cabbage Leaf Application
the effect of Gua Sha on a subjective scale that measured
The use of chilled cabbage leaves applied to the breast to pain, engorgement, and discomfort on a visual analogue scale.
treat engorgement is popular because of the belief that the Women were randomized to hot packs and massage or Gua
sinigrin substance in cabbage helps reduce engorgement; Sha therapy. Gua Sha reduced reported pain and discomfort
however, studies that have evaluated the effects of cabbage more than did hot packs and massage at 5 and 30 minutes fol-
leaf application have differing results.10 A quasiexperimental lowing the intervention (P ⬍ .001).22
study conducted with 60 women in India found that the Ahmadi compared acupressure with warm and cold
use of cabbage leaves may be equivocal or similar to that compresses and found that acupressure produced statistically
of other warm or cold treatments (P = .07).18 Another significant improvements in pain, but not to the same degree
experimental study conducted with 28 women in India as did the warm and cold compresses (P ⬍ .001).16 An exper-
examined the difference between chilled and room temper- imental study conducted with 88 women in Sweden evaluated
ature cabbage leaves. There was a 37% reduction in pain the addition of acupuncture to standard care (oxytocin spray,
scores associated with room temperature leaves and a 38% massage, and hand expression) and found that it was not
decrease in pain scores with chilled cabbage leaves.19 The associated with a difference in reported symptom severity
difference in pain scores from baseline were equivocal and (P = .11).23
there was no statistically significant difference between the In addition to Gua Sha and acupressure, thermal ultra-
2 interventions (P = .84).19 Another comparison study from sound has been assessed for effectiveness in reducing breast
Australia compared chilled cabbage leaves with cold packs in engorgement. A randomized controlled trial conducted in
34 women and found that cabbage leaves reduced pain scores Australia (N = 109) comparing standard ultrasound with
by 1.8 points (P = .0001) compared with baseline, and cold thermal ultrasound applied to the breast for 8 to 15 minutes