Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Submitted in Partial fulfillment of the requirements for the award of the degree
Of
Bachelor of Architecture
In
Undertaken By
CHANDNI TANDON
Enrollment No. - 14EBGAR006
Bachelor of Architecture
2018-2019
Chandni Tandon
guided by
Ar. Jaideep Vyas Sir
Bachelor of Architecture
Buddha Group of Institutions
Udaipur
1
UNDERTAKING
I Chandni Tandon, the author of the thesis titled ‘Revitalizing Neighborhood
Through Waterfront Development of Nela Lake in Udaipur, Rajasthan’, hereby
declare that this is an independent work of mine, carried out towards partial
fulfilment of the requirements for the award of B.Arch. degree at the Faculty
of Architecture, Buddha group of Institutions, Udaipur, Rajasthan.
Chandni Tandon
V year B.Arch.
Date: June, 2019
Place: Udaipur, Rajasthan
Disclaimer
This document describes work undertaken as part of the B.Arch. Degree at the
Faculty of Architecture, Buddha group of Institutions, Udaipur. All views and
opinions expressed therein remain the sole responsibility of the author, and do not
necessarily represent those of the Institute, the Dissertation Guide(s), or the
Dissertation Committee.
2
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the dissertation titled ‘Revitalizing Neighborhood Through
Waterfront Development of Nela Lake in Udaipur, Rajasthan’ has been submitted
by Chandni Tandon towards partial fulfilment of the requirements for the award of
B.Arch. degree, in accordance with the undertaking signed by the student on the
previous page.
Guide: Ar. Jaideep Vyas Coordinator: Ar. Javed Ali
Date: 20/06/2019
3
ABSTRACT
Historically, waterfronts developments have undergone various stages of
development initiatives and become the most challenging tasks for planners and
urban designers nowadays. It reflected a dynamic natural resources with special
characteristics and regarded as the most important factors that influence the
growth and image of the cities and had a significant impact on urbanization and
modernization of the most cities in the near future, as experienced by most harbor
cities in the world such as Asia, Europe, North America, Australasia, Japan and
others.
This thesis attempts to understand the evolution of waterfront development within
the framework of urban design and public spaces, as practiced by Udaipur
currently. Thus, it also became the reflection of people’s spiritual and physical
culture. This cultural reflection of people on the physical context of the city can be
seen mainly in the stage of urban design, because in this stage, buildings as
individual units of the city structure will be connected to each other by roads, nods
and open spaces. Thus, moving, gathering and getting a place as daily activities of
inhabits affected by their culture from one side and the urban design process from
another side. In the center of the design process is public spaces due to their
important role as places of gathering and hosting the cultural and commercial daily
activities.
This is relating to the need of using water as a source for drinking, agriculture and
then for trade and transport. These water bodies which shaped waterfronts of
many cities, recently, emerged as one of the most important issues of urban design
and planning disciplines. Because they are not only an edge between urban fabric
and water, but due to the variety of roles and functions that waterfront has across
the history from a place for trade, transport, industry and nowadays as public open
space for recreation and tourism. Therefore, this leads to add a new type of public
spaces to the city structure and change the image of many cities through offering a
different water-city integration model. Public spaces have formed the background
of public life, and supported community's needs for commercial activities, sacred
celebrations, social interaction.
This thesis sets out to investigate the development of waterfront within the
framework of urban design and public spaces. In addition, the thesis discusses the
factors that affect this evolution and transformed the waterfront from place for
trade, transport and industry to be a place for recreation, tourism and
entertainment.
4
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Many people have contributed, knowingly or unwittingly, to the preparation of this
thesis, not least the numerous student architects who have been subjected to
various forms of teaching related to its development. Some of them have said
things, or done things in their designs, that have prompted thoughts which are
included here. I have benefited from many discussions with my guide Ar. Jaideep
Vyas, Head of the Department of Buddha Group of Institutions Udaipur, without his
guidance and persistent help this dissertation would not have been possible.
The success and final outcome of this project required a lot of guidance and
assistance which I am extremely privileged to have got this all from Ar. Amit Sen
along the completion of my project.
And from the encouragement & knowledge of my coordinator Ar. Javed Sir who was
kind enough to read the material while in preparation and who made a number of
useful comments. I would like to express the deepest appreciation to our registrar
Mr. Hemant Chaubisa. I am also grateful to the Dean Mr. Sanjeev Gupte who have,
unknowingly, stimulated ideas which are included in the following pages. Also, I
extended my gratitude to Ar. Vijay Damor who have always helped and supported in
each possible way.
In addition, a thank you to all the faculty members for their support and
enthusiasm which had a lasting effect.
Heartily thank you to partner-cum-friend Ar. Jayesh Chauhan that all I have done
is due to his amazing tricks and techniques he his learning during his practice
period such supervision and assistance helped me to always fight the battles. Some
ideas have come from far afield, from family, my parents and brother from their
love, support and help, but with whom I sometimes indulge in discussion and their
views and thoughts come across.
And finally, as always, one must thank those who are close and who put up with
having someone around who is writing a dissertation. In my case these
long-suffering people are Nirali, Akhilesh, Vishvesh, Varun, Jeevan, Asmita,
Poulomi and Namrata.
5
Table of Contents
UNDERTAKING 2
CERTIFICATE 3
ABSTRACT 4
ACKNOWLEDGMENT 6
UNIT I: PRELUDE
CHAPTER I Introduction
1.1 Introduction to Waterfronts 11
1.2 Aim 14
1.3 Objective 14
1.4 What is the need of these Spaces? 15
UNIT II: INTERLUDE
CHAPTER II Research Work
2.1 Description of The Research Work 18
2.2 Web/ Literature Case Studies 19
2.3 Live Case Studies 26
UNIT III: CONCLUDE
CHAPTER III Site Selection & Analysis 38
3.1 Udaipur’s History 39
3.2 Geography of Udaipur 40
3.3 Udaipur as a Tourist Destination 41
3.4 SWOT Analysis 43
3.5 Concept & Design Philosophy 46
6
BIBLIOGRAPHY:
(n.d.). Retrieved from
https://www.google.co.in/maps/place/Fateh+Sagar+Lake/@24.6016326,73.6630766,15z/d
ata=!3m1!4b1!4m5!3m4!1s0x3967e53c8c2ac0e3:0x797deb83de7b53b8!8m2!3d24.6013999!
4d73.6742232.
http://tourism.gov.in/sites/default/files/Other/rajisthan.pdf. (n.d.).
https://udaipurtimes.com/udaipur-stands-second-in-number-foreign-tourists/. (n.d.).
https://www.google.co.in/imgres?imgurl=https%3A%2F%2Ftravel-blog.waytoindia.com%
2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2FJag_Mandir.jpg&imgrefurl=https%3A%2F%2Ftravel-blog.
waytoindia.com%2Fplaces-to-visit-in-udaipur%2F&docid=BuEsuift1VbZ4M&tbnid=I6TY
uhFbDsrljM%3A&vet=10a. (n.d.).
https://www.google.co.in/maps/place/Lake+Pichola/@24.5719986,73.6614904,14z/data=!
3m1!4b1!4m5!3m4!1s0x3967e56041553fe7:0xdfef96846886cdd0!8m2!3d24.572!4d73.679.
(n.d.).
https://www.google.co.in/maps?rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN786IN786&q=ahar+cenotaphs&um=1&
ie=UTF-8&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjxzJi6o5jfAhWKXysKHbTNB98Q_AUIDigB. (n.d.).
https://www.google.co.in/maps?rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN786IN786&q=mahakaleshwar+temple
+udaipur&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj7z-6-oZjfAhUUdysKHTI6AycQ_AUIDyg
C. (n.d.).
https://www.google.co.in/search?q=1553++udaipur&rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN786IN786&source
=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi_m8zl9ZffAhUEXisKHfUFA94Q_AUIDygC&biw=1
536&bih=763#imgdii=B_BpXJb28UUIHM:&imgrc=Sblr2chEYaaKgM:. (n.d.).
https://www.google.co.in/search?q=1553++udaipur&rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN786IN786&source
=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi_m8zl9ZffAhUEXisKHfUFA94Q_AUIDygC&biw=1
536&bih=763#imgdii=B_BpXJb28UUIHM:&imgrc=Sblr2chEYaaKgM:. (n.d.).
https://www.google.co.in/search?q=city+squares&rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN786IN786&source=l
nms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjT4-CZpJjfAhXBb30KHWcLATEQ_AUIDigB&biw=153
6&bih=763#imgrc=Rl6GxD2Fw0w_UM:. (n.d.).
https://www.google.co.in/search?q=gulab+bagh&rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN786IN786&source=ln
ms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwi6oJuQmJjfAhWYWX0KHU0qAFUQ_AUIDygC&biw=15
36&bih=763&dpr=1.25#imgrc=K2u8yJjFneiTjM:. (n.d.).
https://www.google.co.in/search?q=memorial+park&rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN786IN786&source
=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwieyNSCo5jfAhWIXSsKHY13CDMQ_AUIDygC&biw=1
536&bih=763#imgrc=XCGoEJpNOlNVLM:. (n.d.).
https://www.google.co.in/search?q=memorials&rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN786IN786&source=ln
ms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjb7sbJopjfAhUGeCsKHVUSCGMQ_AUIDigB&biw=1536
&bih=763#imgdii=-Qc6bFVPkAoHLM:&imgrc=Ru7ql56ZHesuCM:. (n.d.).
7
https://www.google.co.in/search?q=passive+recreation&rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN786IN786&sou
rce=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiFpJHt-5ffAhVbf30KHTabC3AQ_AUIDigB&biw=
1536&bih=763&dpr=1.25#imgrc=U54CF_ngE1S6PM:. (n.d.).
https://www.google.co.in/search?q=sukhadia+circle&rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN786IN786&source
=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjSgZ2PpZjfAhUKfisKHeHpDakQ_AUIDygC&biw=15
36&bih=763&dpr=1.25#imgdii=AuBMSEg6aTFuoM:&imgrc=X-b3SYKFxz_sFM:. (n.d.).
https://www.google.co.in/search?rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN786IN786&biw=1536&bih=763&tbm=
isch&sa=1&ei=FcYPXPalF9um9QPA0ol4&q=udaipur+geographical+map&oq=udaipur+geog
raphical+map&gs_l=img.3...12611.18926..19141...0.0..0.191.2305.0j15......1....1..gws-wiz-img...
....0j. (n.d.).
https://www.google.co.in/search?rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN786IN786&biw=1536&bih=763&tbm=
isch&sa=1&ei=fL4PXJefNJL8rQHEwbCABw&q=lakefront+development+india&oq=lakefront
+&gs_l=img.3.0.35i39j0i67j0j0i67j0j0i67j0l2j0i67l2.33869.33869..36029...0.0..0.128.128.0j
1......1.. (n.d.).
https://www.google.co.in/search?rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN786IN786&tbm=isch&q=fateh+sagar
+lake&chips=q:fateh+sagar+lake,g_1:udaipur:t9GGfnaUZ8g%3D&usg=AI4_-kSOW45O7m
d7zK9o5qC0WOMuszytiA&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiI8qvAl5jfAhURcCsKHQ0FBQgQ4lYIKSgA&
biw=1536&bih=763&dpr=1.25#im. (n.d.).
8
List Of Figures
Figure 1: Waterfront Promenade 13
Figure 2: View of Waterfront Trail 14
Figure 3: Waterfront Uses 17
Figure 4: Dubai Waterfront 18
Figure 5: Map of Tianjin City 20
Figure 6: Transformation pattern along the Haihe River 21
Figure 7: Three spatial sections along the Haihe River 21
Figure 8: Land Use Plan 23
Figure 9: Circulation Plan 24
Figure 10: Evolution in 9 years 25
Figure 11: Built form updation from 2008 to 2010. 26
Figure 12: Development Photographs 27
Figure 13: Existing Water Activities and sitting 28
Figure 14: Existing Promenade View 28
Figure 15: Existing Promenade View 29
Figure 16: Existing Land Use Condition of Sabarmati
and Surroundings 30
Figure 17: From slum dwellings to apartments 31
Figure 18: Market 32
Figure 19: Development of Dhobi Ghat 33
Figure 20: Event area after the development 33
Figure 21: Development of Urban Forestry 34
Figure 22: Development of Sewage System 35
Figure 23: Promenade after Development 35
Figure 24: Development of Gardens 36
Figure 25: Genesis of the YRDP 37
Figure 26 : Sub-Zones (Area, Extent, Length) 38
Figure 27 : Existing YRPD Promenade 39
Figure 28 : Existing Structure Plan for YRPD 40
Figure 29: Existing Garden Space after development 41
Figure 30: View of Udaipur Town in ancient times 43
Figure31: Geographical map of Udaipur 44
Figure 32: The most prominent tourist spot, City Palace 45
Figure 33: The tourist graph for year 2017 46
Figure 34: Graph 48
Figure 35: Land Use plan upto year 2031 49
9
UNIT I: PRELUDE
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction to Waterfronts
Development of a waterfront area with the aim of connecting and integrating the
city with water. Waterfronts are settlements or civilizations or commercial
developments that come up along the water body. Waterfronts are dynamic and
unique places where the land and water meet. It is the interface of the aquatic and
terrestrial. A waterfront zone is where interaction happens between the urban and
the water. By being an interface between land and water, the waterfront zone is an
area endowed with special characteristics. Waterfront is a zone of interaction and
the waterfront area is considered to be a unique and irreplaceable resource where it
interfaces between the land and water.
1
https://www.google.com/search?q=waterfront&rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN836IN836&source=lnms&t
bm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwim3oqgkLvjAhXz4nMBHVD9DzAQ_AUIESgC&biw=1366&bih=60
8#imgrc=gkulnAilSxZlZM:
10
waterfronts have the potential to become the cultural and heritage hubs of the city
that lie on the banks or shores of the waterfront as well as attract people from the
city and also tourists.
Over recent few decades, waterfront development and redevelopment has evolved
and taken on its own identity in areas such as historic preservation and recreation.
Creating minimum avenues for recreation and green open spaces. Also today many
waterfronts are a staple of modernism, city beautification and helps in tourism.
2
https://www.google.com/search?q=waterfront+tourism&rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN836IN836&source
=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwj9jfG-jrvjAhWc6nMBHTuxC0IQ_AUIECgB&biw=1366&bih
=657#imgrc=Bzm56OE_9JKqfM:
11
serves to unite the community and the visitors in a shared experience of the city. It
develops the city as a major commercial and tourist sector. Establish it as a major
tourism attraction centre and a local identity. Link the community with the
waterfront. Integrate public open spaces with more natural water edge, landscapes,
parks.
1.3 Objective
A wide variety of people and interests are involved in waterfront development, and
understanding these interests and planning for them can only help in the
successful implementation of a waterfront project. There are many important
reasons to develop new, and re-develop existing, waterfronts. Waterfronts are
places to live, places to work, and places we enjoy recreating. People all over the
world have been living with water for millennia, as a source of food,
transportation, and harmony. In recent years, managing water has become a major
political and social topic because of climatic events that have caught a lot of media
attention. People have been questioning whether waterfront property should be
promoted as a place to live, or whether giant walls should be built to protect people
from advancing water levels anticipated by climate change experts.
To demonstrate the significance of waterfront, in the classic phrase, American
anthropologist Loren Eiseley said, “If there is magic on this planet, it is contained in
water, water is a fundamental attraction in all cultures”.
This study deals with the waterfront developments through the perspective of
tourism and recreation and investigates the waterfront development through the
available research examples in the world to formulate the design criteria as a
theory of urban waterfront design.
12
1.3 What is the need of these Spaces?
Waterfront development can include any combination of different land uses, and
waterfront projects can be new projects or re-developments of existing
waterfronts into new places. Some waterfront projects focus on industrial uses,
such as industrial ports, and others focus on more recreational and
tourism-oriented uses. It's important that a diversity of uses can occur along a
waterfront, bringing in as many interests as possible to the waterfront, but it's not
necessary that a diversity of uses occurs within each project. For example, due to
environmental, public safety and security reasons, it may not be appropriate to
locate a public park and residential neighbourhood within the same zone as an
industrial port.
13
Figure 4: Dubai Waterfront3
Any building on the waterfront should boost activity in the public spaces around it.
Ideally, there should be a mix of uses, with seamless interaction between inside
and outdoors. High-rise towers that lack any public uses on the ground floor are
noticeably out of place along rivers, lakes and ocean fronts. They usually create a
wall that physically and psychologically cuts off the waterfront from surrounding
neighborhoods.
3
https://www.google.com/search?rlz=1C1CHBF_enIN836IN836&biw=1366&bih=657&tbm=isch
&sa=1&ei=Kbg_XYnxDs_orQHG1JPoCQ&q=waterfront+city&oq=waterfront+city&gs_l=img.3..
0l10.25208.28706..28830...1.0..0.341.1270.0j5j1j1......0....1..gws-wiz-img.......0i10i24j0i8i30j0i24.yg08
g9WdkOw&ved=0ahUKEwjJqc2-2NvjAhVPdCsKHUbqBJ0Q4dUDCAY&uact=5#imgdii=ahEZwd
YCXcf5FM:&imgrc=2YGRWcg6DuaPBM:
14
UNIT II: INTERLUDE
RESEARCH WORK
2.1 Description of the Research Work
In general, the research involved three kinds of works. Through review of
literature, a study was done on what identity means with respect to cities and how
rivers, lakes contribute to this identity especially in lakes cities. The literature
survey further developed an understanding of the relationship between lakes and
cities, north historically and in modern times. Apart from this, the literature review
included a study of various aspects that should be taken into account while
designing a public space.
The next step involved of this relationship through secondary case studies and
understanding the reasons which triggered the lakefront projects. It also involved
key features of those lakefront development projects.
The features of each case study were analysed and tabulated. A set of indicators was
developed based on three things: key features of the case studies, the points which
were essential to maintain the water- city relationship and the elements of a good
public space.
The primary case study involved of history of Sabarmati and Yamuna and the role
Yamuna played in the identity an evolution of the city. It included the current DUAC
Yamuna Riverfront Development Plan and involved a study of key features of the
project. The report is analysed with respect to previously formed framework.
15
2.2 Web/ Literature Case Studies
TIANJIN HAIHE RIVERFRONT
One of the largest coastal cities in North China, with a population of over eleven
million. The city is located along the Haihe River which has a history of over six
hundred-years. The development plan included capabilities for flood control,
navigation, tourism and entertainment. “Building the river as an economic,
landscape and cultural belt with unique character, and putting forward a great
vision of extolling the river culture and creating Haihe as one of the world's most
famous rivers".
Figure 5: Map of Tianjin City
16
Figure 7: Three spatial sections along the Haihe River
17
Figure 8: Land Use Plan
Redeveloping the Riverfront includes the change of existing Land-use which
comprises of Old factories and aging residential communities which needs to be
demolished and should be replaced with Large parcels of land earmarked for mixed
use or commercial purposes.
18
Figure 9: Circulation Plan
● No physical barrier between the water and inland area.
● Slopes added for people with disabilities.
● Old railway station at the riverfront in the city center reorganised into a
transport hub, with better access to the underground, subway systems and
bus services.
19
Urban fabric
20
21
22
2.3 Live Case Studies
SABARMATI RIVERFRONT DEVELOPMENT
The Sabarmati River Front Development Corporation Limited (SRFDCL) is
established in 1997 for the development of the riverfront in the city. (1) SRFDCL
reached out to a number of NGOs and citizen groups for planning and
implementation. The process of implementation was done by build, maintain,
operate and transfer. SRFDCL appointed Independent Third Parties to supervise the
private sector contractors who were selected on fixed time and rate. The fund for
the project is set out by different sources that are equity capital, loan fund and
proceeds from land sales.
23
Table 2 : Existing Land Use of Sabarmati Riverfront
24
Development in Different Sector
The major component of the project concludes and reclamation works, construction of
road and installation of infrastructure such as water, sewer network, storm water
drainage, etc., resettlement and rehabilitation work, construction of promenades and
garden and maintenance of public spaces.
Rehabilitation of Slum Dwellers
There were around 12000 hutments on both sides of the river bank that cover
nearly 20% of the critical project area. More than 10000 families are allotted with
houses for resettlement, and 9078 odd families have already been shifted. Each
house is of 26.77 sq m carpet area. Commonly the relocation of a slum is provided
on the outskirts of the city, but in this case, it is located near to the prime location
of the city.
25
Gujari Bazar - Sunday Market
It is an age-old Sunday market, where 40% of traders were women and half of
them describe themselves as Dalits. It was unhygienic and also there is a risk of
flooding in monsoon. Now, it is spread over 70.00 sq.mt area, and 1600 vendors can
do their business on 788 pucca platforms and 783 laris.
26
Event Area
Earlier the dry river bed was used to host events like circus and cricket etc.
However, a mega city like Ahmedabad requires a proper event management ground
facilities. So that an area of 60.00 aq.mt, spread between Sardar Bridge and Ellis
Bridge on the west bank has been designed for hosting events such as the Kite
Festival, the Marathon, the Cyclothon and Garib Kalyan Mela are organized.
27
Sewage System
To intercept the sewer running into the river and divert it to the treatment plants,
the interceptor sewer system was constructed. Earlier the sewage from 36 drainage
points directly falls into the river that makes the water dirty, mosquito ridden and
unhealthy environment. Now, there is an extreme change in the environment
around the river because all sewage goes to a pumping station for transformation it
to river quality.
28
Public Garden/ Flower Garden
For parks and garden space 27% of project land is developed. There are three
gardens.
● Garden of 60000 sq.mt between Subhash Bridge and Dadhichi Bridge;
● Garden of 25000 sq.mt at Usmanpura between Gandhi Bridge and Nehru
Bridge on the West Bank and Flower garden of 40000 sq.mt near event area
on the west bank of the river.
29
Y
AMUNA RIVERFRONT DEVELOPMENT PROJECT (YRDP)
● DDA’s initiative of Biodiversity Parks in collaboration with the Center for
Environmental Management of Degraded Ecosystems (CEMDE), Delhi
University.
● Justice Usha Mehra Committee constituted to remove Jhuggies & other
encroachments from the River Bed.
● Following the orders, DDA proposed Golden Jubilee Parks Approval from
Central Water Commission for Golden Jubilee Park.
● Constitution of Delhi Biodiversity Foundation by Gazette Notification dated
01.04.2005.
● High Court Order for 13 enclosures to be made for disposing Puja Samgiri in
the river.
● Embargo on any construction activity by office of Hon’ble LG on Zone ‘O’ till
detail studies are done.
● Yamuna Riverfront Development Project Launched.
● Structure Plan for Zone O was put up for inviting objections & suggestions.
● Structure Plan sought approvals from Delhi Biodiversity Foundation & High
Powered Committee.
● ZDP for Zone O notified with proposals for Riverfront Development.
30
Recommendations of MPD,2021 & ZDP, Zone O
● River Yamuna should be conserved & kept free from unrestricted &
unplanned urban development.
● ZDP has proposed strategies for Sustainable Riverfront Development.
● Strategy for Conservation / Development of Yamuna riverbed area is needed
to be developed & implemented in a systematic manner.
Aim
“Conserve, Protect & Restore the Biodiversity of Yamuna integrated with Public
Recreation spaces that the city needs as envisaged in the Zonal Development of
Zone O”.
31
Figure 28 : Existing Structure Plan for YRPD
32
Figure 29: Existing Garden Space after development
Green Linkages- Interconnecting all zones are Green Linkages which will act as wildlife
movement corridor & provide habitat while providing a buffer to sensitive Biodiversity
areas.
All these Zones are Open to Sly Green Areas.
33
UNIT III: CONCLUDE
SITE SELECTION & ANALYSIS
3.1 Udaipur’s Background
The royal city of Udaipur being the capital of Mewar for several centuries. The city
has a legend behind its establishment. Once during his hunting expedition,
Maharana Udai Singh met a holy sage in the Aravalli ranges. The sage directed the
king to create a kingdom in this fertile valley, which would be protected by the
high-rising Aravalli. Consequently, Maharana Udai Sing established Udaipur in
1553 AD.
Chittorgarh was the former capital of Mewar Kingdom and Maharana Udai Singh
was the successor of the Sisodia clan, as say the descendants of the Sun God, who
believed themselves to be the world’s oldest ruling family. The kings and the
members of this dynasty were known to be the most powerful warrior clan in
Rajasthan. Therefore, the capital was also moved to Udaipur from Chittorgarh,
because of constant enemy attacks.
The Mughal Emperor attacked Chittor in the year 1568, and to keep away from his
clutches, Udai Singh shifted his kingdom to Udaipur, which was a safer place. It
was since that time that Udaipur got transformation modern city.
Overlooking the aquamarine expanses of the Lake Pichola stands the splendid City
Palace - a marvel in granite and marble. Out of the original eleven gates of the
Udaipur City, only five still remain. For the safety of the new capital the king built a
wall with a length of 6 km with its main gates in it namely – Brahmpole,
Ambapole, Hathipole, Udiapole, Chandpole, Surajpole. The area that resides in the
wall is now commonly referred as ‘The Old City’ or ‘The Walled City’. The British
didn’t show their much interest in acquiring Udaipur because it was a mountainous
region which made it difficult for their army to carry heavy armoured horses and
weapons. On the eastern side of the city, the periphery has a Surajpole or Sun Gate
which is the main on entrance to the city. Udaipur being the city of dawn, and a
lovely land around the azure water lakes, hemmed in by the lush hills of the
Aravalli hills. Udaipur is a fascinating mixture of sights, sounds and experiences.
Its kaleidoscope of fairy-tale palaces, lakes, temples, gardens and narrow lanes
strewn with stalls, carry the flavour of heroic past, epitomizing valour and chivalry.
34
Figure 30: View of Udaipur Town in ancient times
3.2 Udaipur’s Geography
Udaipur lying in the shadows of the Aravalli Mountains, at a height of 577m. The
walled city is surrounded by the city wall, on the eastern side of Lake Pichola. The
train station and bus station are both at vicinity to the old city. Udaipur is located at
24.58° N 73.68° E. Udaipur being with an average elevation of 598 meters (1961
feet).
Figure31: Geographical map of Udaipur
35
In the state of Rajasthan, and at the foothills of Aravalli hills is located Udaipur city.
The city of lakes Udaipur lies in southern Rajasthan. Udaipur can cater its tourists
with its enchanting view of the lakes, temples, cafes and restaurants, also
sparkling view of the spotless white palaces, it's interesting historic background,
and unique rural handicrafts. Though Udaipur has some fascinating features which
can appear captivating for any outsider, the weather of Udaipur is not quite
favourable all over the year. Therefore, the lakes encircling the city of Udaipur
make the climate somewhat comfortable and pleasant during the summer season.
The summer is very hot and rainfall is scarce which is not favourable for a pleasant
holiday in Udaipur.
3.3 Udaipur as a Tourist Destination
Udaipur is one of the most popular cities in Rajasthan, and is quite famous for its
lakes and palaces. Also, known as the ‘Jewel of Mewar’, in 1553 this city was
founded by Maharaja Udai Signh, on the banks of Lake Pichola. Udaipur is claimed
as one of the most romantic cities of the world and mini Venice.
36
traditional Ghagra-Choli, laden with huge silver jewellery. People of all different
religion- Hinduism, Islam, Sikhism and Christianity reside here. The modern city
of Udaipur is a vivid hub of social- cultural activities, art, music and folk dance.
While living in Udaipur one can see both kinds of people- those following their
age-old traditions and also those who have adopted a modern style of living. The
city plays as a host to a number of fairs and festivals of the country. Udaipur Stands
Second in The Number of Foreign Tourists in Rajasthan.
37
3.4 SWOT Analysis
This study is about the phenomenon of urban planning processes. The
methodological approach is qualitative research. The data collection relies on live
case studies, interviews and a time graph analysis of different places at different
peak time. The time graph along with age graph are based on their experience of
age or participation in the type of activities, involvement in different urban spaces,
footfall of different spaces, with the analysis of interest and opposition against the
urban project. The theoretical literature and the planning typology are analysed
through the theoretical framework of past, present and future scope.
This process resulted in identifying the Opportunities, Threats, Strengths and
Weaknesses of each case study conducted. Which in turn resulted in the conclusion
that, based on the study’s main findings and recommendations.
As per the live case studies and analysing interests of local as well as tourist public
in Udaipur City, I was able to conclude that the tourists especially like to be in the
Walled City area and are fond of exploring the traditional, heritage architecture &
culture of the city. Instead, there is a bunch of local residents of Udaipur City who
consider accessibility as a priority and then the “View”.
Also, there is another graph to show that annually in the city of Lakes more than 2
lacs people come and go, and all have their own preferences, likings, and
comfortability through which they explore the Udaipur City.
Figure 34: Graph showing annual tourist graph in Udaipur as per their population
and preference list. Here, the population is the annual tourist count from
38
respective countries and preferences mean that where they choose to
accommodate (i.e., choice of hotels) themselves for a stay in the city.
This particular table here exhibits that how being at the maximum population i.e.,
London and Italy tourists arrive in city, and prefer the Walled City for their
accommodation and exploration. Tourist from Australia and Germany will
prioritize access first and then view. Here, of course they will be in the vicinity to
Old city but will not choose a hotel where accessibility is an issue. Moving on to
Indian Tourists, which is majorly from Gujarat & Kolkata, they have a different
taste from foreign tourists. India, the whole country itself celebrates this
traditional architecture and inherits the old ‘Gali’ or let’s say narrow passage
concept in almost all Indian States, so for them the Walled City is not that
something really WOWS!
So, they find resorts or a hotel at outskirts from Walled city because they don’t
want to get into the hustle bustle and crowded streets with jams, animals and
shops on both hands. Rather they try to focus on serenity while booking their
accommodations.
39
Urban open space - both magnitude and spatial arrangement - is critical to urban
living. As the availability of open space, distribution and accessibility are a major
concern for cities. Open space is a necessity and not a luxury.
Due to ongoing urbanisation trend worldwide, the distance between city
inhabitants and nature is increasing. Urban greenery is one of the ways to bridge
this gap between people and nature. With the growth of urban sprawl or the
migration the increase in density is one of the reasons for underdevelopment of
urban greenery sector. Without careful planning, cities will be stressed with
environmental challenges.
As we have found out in the case studies that the geography of all these urban spaces is
more towards western side of Udaipur city, as compared to it as a whole. Open space is a
basic type of land use along with residential, commercial, industrial, transportation etc.
Other than open space, the rest are given due importance for progress and it is neglected
because it caters to natural, recreational and cultural needs that are intangible.
3.5 Concept & Design Philosophy
40
“M A K E I N V I S I B L E V I S I B L E”
The purpose of this thesis is to study how lakes contribute in respect to identity of
a city.
The idea is to create an economically vibrant and safe and inclusive waterfront
providing the best social and physical infrastructure for it’s neighborhood
residences, business tourists, recreational tourists and local visitors.
Also, at developing the waterfront areas by treating the catchment area and to
provide aesthetically pleasing and highly functional spaces and activities that
encourages the city dwellers to experience the beauty and serenity of the
waterfront. Creating a vital waterfront that serves to unite the community and the
visitors in a shared experience of the city.
The concept M ake Invisible Visible says to highlight the unseen neglected spaces
of the city. According to the guidelines, a development close to river/ lake area
would not increase the level of water flow. Demonstrating the connection between
access, greenway development and market demand.
Recommendations and Findings
Waterfront & Green areas -based solutions supply innovative approaches to extend
the standard of urban settings. It enhances local resilience and promote
sustainable lifestyles, improving both the health and the well-being of urban
residents. Parks, playgrounds or vegetation publicly and personal places are a unit
central part of these approaches and may felicitate to make sure that:
● urban residents have adequate opportunities for exposure to nature;
● urban biodiversity is maintained and protected;
● environmental hazards such as air pollution or noise are reduced;
● the impacts of extreme weather events (heatwaves, extreme rainfall or
flooding) are mitigated;
● the quality of urban living is enhanced;
● the health and well-being of residents is improved.
Urban inexperienced area could be a part of “green infrastructure”. It is a vital part
of public open areas and customary services provided by a town and may function
as a health-promoting setting for all members of the urban community. It is thus
compulsory to make sure that all urban, open or public green spaces are easily
accessible for all age groups and distributed equitably within the city.
Land use planning is central for managing issues related to climatic variation in
urban environments. However, Master Plans usually do not include climatic
aspects, and few studies have addressed climate change at the urban scale,
especially in developing countries.
41
This report proposes a framework with the thesis and live case studies helping &
concluding the more and more placement of urban space at one part of the city and
ignoring the rest of it.
Each category comprises attributes that describe a complex of relationships in
influencing amenities for local public as well as the tourists. Proper land use
planning provides the opportunity to assess where you are, where you would like to
go and how you might get there.
Planning now to protect important open space and recreational facilities can
greatly enhance the attractiveness of your community and encourage compatible
growth in the future. Also, planning accordingly helps allowing the City to confront
and manage aspects of growth and development in ways that preserve, protect, and
enhance the environment.
The urban planning process in relation with equitable open space relationship can
expose potential problems while there is still time to prevent them. Open space
plans allow the benefits of open space that make up the character and protects the
"green infrastructure" of a community. With the help of planning the spaces wisely
this "green infrastructure" of water supply, land, working farms and forests, viable
wildlife habitats, parks, recreation areas, trails, and greenways is as important to
the economic future of a community as coming up with for planning for schools,
roads, water, and wastewater infrastructure.
Although open area itself could be an easy concept, the factors that have an effect
on it, which affects, are complex. Through an Open Space Plan, one can identify
and examine these factors and lay out strategies for residents and can use to
protect and enjoy its character, natural resources and open spaces.
Consequently, these findings form a replacement approach to the difficulty of patterns of
spatial use of public spaces, based on the global understanding of the dynamics of the
urban grid and the visual and the permeability connections between public space and
the urban environment.
42
43