Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—An increase in load capacity during the operation of a Contrariwise, a Q-V curve, plotted for a constant power
power system usually causes voltage drop and leads to system [17], gives the change of bus voltages with respect to reactive
instability, so it is necessary to monitor the effect of load changes. power injection or absorption. Procedures for constructing both
This article presents a method of assessing the power system P-V and Q-V curves are time-consuming because a large
stability according to the load node capacity considering number of power flows is needed to be executed using
uncertainty factors in the system. The proposed approach can be conventional methods and models [21]. Due to this drawback,
applied to large-scale power systems for voltage stability they are not suitable to be used for online analysis. Moreover,
assessment in real-time. they could be used only for certain increasing modes and not
Keywords-stability; power system; power plane; uncertainty;
for providing the whole view of the analysis. Generally, they
Gaussian elimination examine an individual bus by stressing the considered bus
independently so they are not able to fully reflect the real
I. INTRODUCTION stability condition of the system. In fact, voltage collapse
occurs when the system load, i.e., real power and/or reactive
Power system stability could be defined as “the ability of an power load, grows over a certain limit. Hence, voltage stability
electric power system, for a given initially operating condition,
boundary needs to be plotted on a power plane [17]. It will
to regain a state of operating equilibrium after being subjected
form a P-Q curve [8, 22-26] that is very useful to determine
to a physical disturbance with most system variables bounded,
boundary and operating regions for the system. Once the
so that practically the entire system remains intact” [1]. In [1],
boundary is determined, the distance from the operating point
power system stability is broadly classified into three groups:
to the voltage collape of the system can be directly assessed.
frequency stability [2-4], rotor angle stability [5-7], and voltage
For this work, stability reserve ratios are widely used in
stability [8-14]. Voltage stability could be defined as the ability
practice. Figure 1 shows, as an example, a P-Q curve (stability
of the system to maintain steady voltages at all buses in the
boundary) that divides power plane into two regions: normal
system after being subjected to a disturbance from a given
region and impossible operating region. From Figure 1,
initial operating condition [1, 8, 11]. Voltage stability is
divided into two subcategories: large and small disturbance stability reserve ratios k P and kQ can be calculated as follows:
stability. System faults, tripping transmission lines or dropping
in generators are considered large disturbances whereas load Plim - P0
kP = 100%
changes are considered small disturbances. Static voltage P0
stability is considered in the present paper in particular. The Qlim - Q0
system is assumed to be operated in an equilibrium state and kQ = 100%
static voltage stability analysis assesses the feasibility of the Q0
operating point to provide the system operators with a where, P0 and Q0 are real and reactive power of the
permissible region in which the system can operate normally. considered load at the operating point; Plim and Qlim are the
Many techniques have been used in static voltage stability limitations of real and reactive power, recpectively. A P-Q
analysis in the literature. The well-known P-V and Q-V curves curve can be determined by various approaches. In [8, 22-24],
are widely used [8, 15-20] to determine the maximum the curve is characterized by a parabolic equation, while it is
permissible loading of the system. In particular, a P-V curve assumed to follow a circle in [25]. Nevertheless, such
provides the relationship between the real power load and bus assumptions on the shape of the curve make it unrealistic. In
voltage and it is depicted with a constant power factor [17]. addition, those techniques usually require high computational
time so they are not suitable for online voltage stability
www.etasr.com Ngo et al.: Assessing Power System Stability Following Load Changes and Considering Uncertainty
Engineerin
ng, Technologyy & Applied Sciience Research
h Vol. 8, No. 2, 22018, 2758-27663 2759
.
Y iN V 1 ...- .
Y iN V F ... .
Y iN V i ...+Y iN V N = 0 (3)
Fig. 1. P-Q curve and operating regions on power plane.
Y NN Y NNN Y NN
In this papeer, we proposee an approachh to assess voltage m the ith equattion in (2) yiellds
Eventually, suubtract (3) from
staability consideering uncertaiinties in pow wer systems w with a . .
number of attracctive features. Firstly, for woorking in a reaal-time . . Y NF Y iN
envvironment, we w adopt Gauussian eliminaation techniqque to Y *iF Y iF .
(4)
simmplify a compplex diagram to t a simple onne, then we uuse the Y NN
anaalytical technnique developeed in [26] foor constructingg P-Q . .
currves. Thanks to these technniques, the prooposed methood can andd the Nth compponent in eachh equation in (2) (i.e., YiN . V N )
proovide results quickly,
q hencee it can be appplied to largee-scale will be eliminatedd.
power systems for voltage sstability assesssment in reall-time.
Secondly, in orrder to take into i account randomness in i the After the abovve steps, we can
c eliminate oone equation inn (1),
sysstem, a large number of P--Q curves is pplotted and voltage i.e.,, the last equaation in (1). Equation
E (4) is used to calcculate
staability is asseessed probabiilistically. In addition, thee P-Q admmittances for the equivalennt network aft fter eliminatingg the
currves built are realistic, sincee no assumptioon on the channge of lastt bus. We reppeat the abovve process unntill obtainingg F+1
loaad is used to coonstruct the cuurves. equuations from thhe initial N eqquations in (1).. Therefore, w
we can
makke an equivaleent network foor the considerred network w with F
II. SIMPLLIFIED POWER SYSTEM
S DIAGR
RAM ALGORITH
HM genneration buses and a load buus considered aas shown in F Figure
Considering a power netwwork with N+11 buses (includding a 2.
groounding bus, denoted 0) in which generation busees are
numbered from 1 to F, loads aare representedd by admittancces so .
E1
.
Z1(F1)
.
V ( F1)
maining busees are interm
rem mediate busees, we can form
admmittance equaations to presennt steady-statee of the system
m as in Y10
.
(1)). . .
E2 Z2(F1)
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
www.etasrr.com Ngo eet al.: Assessingg Power System Stability Folloowing Load Chaanges and Conssidering Uncerrtainty
Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 8, No. 2, 2018, 2758-2763 2760
(so Yi0 can be eliminated) and the load is separated as in Figure by a normal distribution function, while renewable power
3. generation is usually represented by a generic function such as
Beta, Gamma, Weibull functions, etc [29]. Random outage of
. .
an element such as transmission line, transformer, generating
.
E1 Z1(F1) V (F1) unit can be described by a 0-1 distribution function (0: outage
. .
state, 1: working state; an operating element can be failed with
E2 Z2(F1) a certain probability) [29]. If all generating units in a power
SL = PL+jQ L
. . plant are the same, the combination of 0-1 distribution function
Ei Zi(F1) for each unit could be represented by a binomial distribution
. .
. function [29].
EF ZF(F1) Y0
Start
Fig. 3. Simplified equivalent diagram.
G 0 G (F 1)0 G L Calculate
admittances of all Set value k = N
branches of the
B0 B(F 1)0 BL G L PL / V 2
F 1,rated
system
False False
Equation (1) can be represented in a matrix form as in (5),
Compute and form admittance matrix Y of Calculate admittances of the simplified
in which the first matrix is denoted as Y (called admittance the system equivalent diagram with (F+1) buses in Fig. 3
matrix):
Save matrix Y
www.etasr.com Ngo et al.: Assessing Power System Stability Following Load Changes and Considering Uncertainty
Engineerin
ng, Technologyy & Applied Sciience Research
h Vol. 8, No. 2, 22018, 2758-27663 2761
linne connecting the origin O aand M3 that iintersects N2 ccurves Input data of the system
andd the probabbility of unstaability (dangeerous level) oof the (System parameterss, operating parameters
and probability disstribution functions of
sysstem can be caalculated as in (6): random m factors)
N2 Select load at th
he bus considered
loaad on power plane, the stability of the systtem can be asssessed distribution fun ctions of random
factors in the system
greeatter than a ceertain value, thhe operator off the system neeeds to
carrry out approppriate remedial actions to reduce the looad to
avooid instabilityy for the systeem. The prop posed algorithhm for
False
asssessing stabilitty of power syystems accordding to load chhanges k = N1
M
M2
P2
E
End
Q [Mvaar]
0 Q1 Q2
F
Fig. 5. Operatting points on pow
wer plane.
P [MW]
M
M2
P2
P3 M3
M1
P1
Q [Mvaar]
0 Q1 Q2 Q3
www.etasrr.com Ngo eet al.: Assessingg Power System Stability Folloowing Load Chaanges and Conssidering Uncerrtainty
Engineerin
ng, Technologyy & Applied Sciience Research
h Vol. 8, No. 2, 22018, 2758-27663 2762
Fig. 12. Resullt of voltage stabiility assessment aat bus 25 when thhe load
is working at reggion 3.
VI. CO
ONCLUSIONS
In this paper a methodologyy for voltage sstability assesssment
undder uncertaintty is proposedd. Random fa factors in a power
p
Fig. 9. Interrface of the com
mputer program ddevelopped for sstability system related too loads, randdom outages oof elements inn the
assessment of IE
EEE 39-bus systeem according to looad changes.
system, renewabble energy soources can bbe represented by
When we nneed to evalluate the sysstem accordinng to proobability distribbution functioons and taken into account iin the
connditions of staatic stability limit under unccertainty at a certain
c asseessment. The proposed appproach can be b used for online
o
loaad bus, we rigght click on thhe bus. Figuress from 10 to 12,1 for voltage stability study thankss to, adoptingg a technique for
exaample, show tthe results of bus 25 corressponding to various makking a simpliffied equivalennt diagram for a complex syystem
buus operating coonditions. In eaach Figure, a sset of 1000 currves is bassed on Gaussiaan eliminationn method, and,, making use oof the
plootted and thesse curves dividde the power plane into diffferent anaalytical techniique developeed in [26] to plot P-Q cuurves.
reggions. Figuress 10, 11 andd 12 correspoond to stable state Theese techniquess allow us to provide results quickly and can be
(prrobability of innstability of 00%), unstable sstate (probabillity of appplied to largee-scale powerr systems forr voltage staability
insstability of 1000%) and insttability with pprobability equ qual to asseessment in reaal-time. Moreoover, the P-Q curves construucted
30.4%, respectivvely. are realistic becaause no assum mption on the change of looad is
useed for their connstruction.
Refeerences
[1] P. Kundur, J. Paserba, V. A Ajjarapu, G. Andersson, A. Bose, C.
Canizares, N. H Hatziargyriou, D.. Hill, A. Stankoovic, C. Taylor, T
T. Van
Cutsem, V. V Vittal, “Definitionn and classificattion of power ssystem
stability IEEE/C
CIGRE joint task force on stabilityy terms and definitions”,
IEEE Transactiions on Power Syystems, Vol. 19, No. 3, pp. 13877-1401,
2004
[2] J. Hu, J. Cao, J. M. Guerrero, T. Yong, J. Yu, “Improving Freqquency
Stability Basedd on Distributed CControl of Multipple Load Aggreggators”,
IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, Vol. 8, No. 4, ppp. 1553-1567, 20017
[3] N. Nguyen, J. Mitra, “Reliabillity of Power Syystem with High Wind
Penetration Unnder Frequency S Stability Constrainnt”, IEEE Transaactions
on Power Systeems, Vol. 33, No. 1, pp. 985-994, 22018
Fig. 10. Resuult of voltage stabbility assessment at bus 25 when tthe load
is working at reggion 1. [4] N. Hatziargyrioou, E. Karapidakiis, D. Hatzifotis, “Frequency stabiility of
power systems in large islandss with wind pow wer penetration”,, Bulk
Power System Dynamics Contrrol Symposium-IIV, Restructuringg, Vol.
102, 1998
[5] M. Oluic, M. G Ghandhari, M. Beerggren, “Methoddology for Rotor Angle
Transient Stability Assessment ini Parameter Space”, IEEE Transaactions
on Power Systeems, Vol. 32, No. 2, pp. 1202-12111, 2017
[6] L. Meegahapola, T. Littler, “Chharacterisation of large disturbancee rotor
angle and volttage stability inn interconnected power networkss with
distributed windd generation”, IE
ET Renewable Pow wer Generation, Vol.
V 9,
No. 3, pp. 272-2283, 2015
[7] E. Vittal, M. OO’Malley, A Keaane, “Rotor Angle Stability Withh High
Penetrations oof Wind Generaation”, IEEE Trransactions on Power
Systems, Vol. 227, No. 1, pp. 353-362, 2012
[8] C. W. Taylor, Power
P McGraw-Hill Inc., 1994
System Voltage Stability, M
[9] B. Leonardi, V V. Ajjarapu, “D Development of multilinear regrression
Fig. 11. Resuult of voltage stabbility assessment at bus 25 when tthe load models for oonline voltage stability margiin estimation”, IEEE
is working at reggion 2. Transactions onn Power Systems, Vol. 26, No. 1, ppp. 374-383, 20111
www.etasrr.com Ngo eet al.: Assessingg Power System Stability Folloowing Load Chaanges and Conssidering Uncerrtainty
Engineering, Technology & Applied Science Research Vol. 8, No. 2, 2018, 2758-2763 2763
[10] D. Q. Zhou, U. D. Annakkage, A. D. Rajapakse, “Online monitoring of [33] A. Dissanayaka, Risk Based Dynamic Security Assessment, Msc Thesis,
voltage stability margin using an artificial neural network”, IEEE University of Manitoba, 2010
Transactions on Power Systems, Vol. 25, No. 3, pp. 1566-1574, 2010
[11] T. V. Cutsem, C. Vournas, Voltage Stability of Electric Power Systems,
Springer, 1998
[12] J. A. de Leon, C. W. Taylor, “Understanding and solving shortterm
voltage stability problems”, IEEE PES Summer Meeting, Chicago, USA,
pp. 745-752, July 21-25, 2002
[13] Y. Xu, R. Zhang, J. Zhao, Z. Y. Dong, D. Wang, H. Yang, K. P. Wong,
“Assessing Short-Term Voltage Stability of Electric Power Systems by a
Hierarchical Intelligent System”, IEEE Transactions on Neural
Networks and Learning Systems, Vol. 27, No. 8, pp. 1686-1696, 2016
[14] E. Vittal, M. O’Malley, A. Keane, “A steady-state voltage stability
analysis of power systems with high penetrations of wind”, IEEE
Transactions on Power Systems, Vol. 25, No. 1, pp. 433-442, 2010
[15] H. K. Clark, New challenge: Voltage stability, IEEE Power Engineering
Review, Vol. 19, pp. 30–37, 1990
[16] R. K. Gupta, Z. A. Alaywan, R. B. Stuart, T. A. Reece, “Steady state
voltage instability operations perspective”, IEEE Transactions on Power
Systems, Vol. 5, No. 4, pp. 1345-1354, 1990
[17] M. H. Haque, “Determination of Steady-State Voltage Stability Limit
Using P-Q Curves”, IEEE Power Engineering Review, Vol. 22, pp. 71-
72, 2002
[18] P. Kundur, Power System Stability and Control, McGraw-Hill Inc., 1994
[19] R. Toma, M. Gavrilas, “Voltage stability assessment for wind farms
integration in electricity grids with and without consideration of voltage
dependent loads”, International Conference and Exposition on Electrical
and Power Engineering (EPE 2016), Iasi, Romania, pp. 754-759,
October 20-22, 2016
[20] M. S. Rawat, S. Vadhera, “Analysis of wind power penetration on power
system voltage stability”, IEEE 6th International Conference on Power
Systems (ICPS), New Delhi, India, March 4-6, 2016
[21] V. Balamourougan, T. S. Sidhu, M. S. Sachdev, “Technique for online
prediction of voltage collapse, IEE Proceedings - Generation,
Transmission and Distribution, Vol. 151, No. 4, pp. 453-460, 2004
[22] T. V. Cutsem, C. Vournas, Voltage Stability of Electric Power Systems,
Kluwer Academic, 1998
[23] M. Glavic, M. Lelic, D. Novosel, E. Heredia, D. Kosterev, “A Simple
Computation and Visualization of Voltage Stability Power Margins in
Real-Time”, IEEE PES Transmission and Distribution Conference and
Exposition (T&D), Orlando, USA, May 7-10, 2012
[24] Y. Z. Lin, L. B. Shi, L. Z. Yao, Y. X. Ni, S. Y. Qin, R. M. Wang, J. P.
Zhang, “An Analytical Solution for Voltage Stability Studies
Incorporating Wind Power”, Journal of Electrical Engineering and
Technology, Vol. 10, No. 3, pp. 865-876, 2015
[25] P. Zhang, L. Min, J. Chen, Measurement Based Voltage Stability
Monitoring and Control, U.S. Patent Application No. US
2009/0299664A1, 2009
[26] V. D. Ngo, D. D. Le, K. H. Le, V. K. Pham, A. Berizzi, “A
Methodology for Determining Permissible Operating Region of Power
Systems According to Conditions of Static Stability Limit”, Energies,
Vol. 10, No. 8, pp. 1-15, 2017
[27] G. J. Anders, Probability Concepts in Electric Power Systems, Wiley,
1990
[28] K. Krishnamoorthy, Handbook of Statistical Distributions with
Applications, CRC Press, 2006
[29] D. D. Le, A. Berizzi, C. Bovo, “A probabilistic security assessment
approach to power systems with integrated wind resources”, Renewable
Energy, Vol. 85, pp. 114-123, 2016
[30] J. Machowski, J. W. Bialek, J. R. Bumby, Power System Dynamics and
Stability, John Wiley & Sons Ltd., 1997
[31] J. E. Gentle, Random Number Generation and Monte Carlo Methods,
Springer-Verlag, 2003
[32] G. Marsaglia, “Random Number Generation”, in: A. Ralston, E. D.
Reilly, Eds, Encyclopedia of Computer Science and Engineering, Van
Nostrand Reinhold, pp. 1260-1264, 1983
www.etasr.com Ngo et al.: Assessing Power System Stability Following Load Changes and Considering Uncertainty