You are on page 1of 6

Bull. Soc. géol. France, 2013, t. 184, no 3, pp.

267-272

Use of alumina phosphate waste to produce building materials


MABABA DIAGNE1,2

Key-words. – Fines, Alumina phosphate, Refractory materials, Sodium silicate, Formulation, Bricks.
Abstract. – The generation of a fine fraction of sedimentary alumina phosphate before the manufacturing process of
phosphoric acid –used as fertilizer– poses a crucial environmental issue related to the large quantities of fines stored for
a long time in the wildlife without treatment or recycling in the region of Thiès in Sénégal by the Industries Chimiques
du Sénégal (ICS) and the Société Sénégalaise des Phosphates de Thiès (SSPT). This work deals with the use of the fines
particles of phosphate generated by the physical processing (crushing, transport and screening) of the raw material by
the both mining companies. These fines particles of phosphates cover all the fauna and flora surrounding the sector with
whitish dust particularly during the Harmattan, a hot and dry wind, while they can be leached during the rainy season to
contaminate groundwater and then cause diseases to the populations who drink that water. Indeed, these materials,
which are stored in large quantities as “waste”, and which pollute, the space and the environment, can be recycled as re-
fractory materials useful in manufacturing such as bricks or paving blocks. The purpose of this study is to find, from
these discarded fines that are not yet processed, a good and new material in terms of physical and mechanical character-
istics that will meet a customary standard. This will allow not only to reduce their potential hazard by reducing the pol-
lution for the consumption of the fines in order to generate a useful material especially in the surrounding villages of the
mining sector, but also to employ young people in working age in this fines recycling process, to create jobs and
therefore additional economic resources that allow a better life because the majority of the youngsters from these areas
are unemployed.
The formulation of a well-known mixture containing fines of sedimentary alumina phosphate of particles size
ranging between 0.063 mm to 5 mm, with chemical composition similar to that of volcanic slag, sodium silicate called
water-glass as binder of mineral elements; and water, led to the manufacturing of geomaterials blocks with
20×10×6 cm3 size by baking them several hours on an oven at the constant temperature of 225oC. The sodium silicate
density was 1.4.
Good mechanical and physical characteristics were achieved through systematic testing. Strength splitting rup-
ture tests, total water content determination, size measurements of the blocks (length, width and thickness) as well as
the loss on ignition on ambient atmosphere were achieved on the blocks after treatment for a complete identification.
Average values of 3.03 MPa and 2.5% were obtained as results respectively for the splitting rupture strength and for the
total water content. Negative variations of –2.05 mm, –0.59 mm and 1.69 mm on average values were obtained respecti-
vely on their length, their width and their thickness for a value of 5.30% of loss on ignition. The blocks are exposed on
the fire on their upper surface whilst the heating effect falls of rapidly at the other side. The deduction of the compres-
sive resistance strength from the average value of splitting rupture gave a value of 40.5 MPa. This value testifies very
good mechanical resistance strength of the material which is made by the fines of phosphate. These characteristics ob-
tained are compared here to the European Standard values EN 1338 for paving blocks. The values obtained for all the
tests attest good manufacturing material. This new material can also be used as refractory materials in the ovens and in
pottery materials.

Utilisation de déchets de phosphate d’alumine pour produire des matériaux de construction

Mots-clés. – Fines, Phosphates d’alumine, Matériaux réfractaires, Silicate de sodium, Formulation, Briques.
Résumé. – La génération de fines de phosphate d’alumine sédimentaire avant le processus de fabrication de l’acide
phosphorique utilisé comme engrais, pose un problème environnemental crucial. En effet, dans la région de Thiès au Sé-
négal, de grandes quantités de fines sont stockées dans la nature durant de longues périodes sans traitement préalable ou
recyclage par les Industries Chimiques du Sénégal (ICS) et la Société Sénégalaise des Phosphates de Thiès (SSPT).
L’objectif de ce travail est de valoriser ces rejets par l’utilisation de ces fines de phosphate d’alumine sédimentaire gé-
nérées par le traitement physique (concassage, transport et criblage) du tout-venant de phosphate d’alumine. Pendant
l’Harmattan, un vent chaud et sec, ces particules fines recouvrent de poussière blanchâtre toute la faune et la flore envi-
ronnantes du secteur. Ces particules peuvent être lixiviées pendant la saison des pluies pour contaminer la nappe phréa-
tique et ainsi engendrer des maladies chez les populations qui utilisent ces eaux. En effet, ces matériaux stockés en très
grandes quantités comme des « déchets », qui polluent la vue, l’espace et l’environnement, sont recyclés pour produire
des blocs de matériaux réfractaires qui seront utilisés dans la construction comme des briques ou des pavés autoblo-

1. Institut des Sciences de la Terre, Faculté des Sciences et Techniques Université Cheikh Anta DIOP de Dakar, BP. 5396 Dakar-Fann, Sénégal, Tél.: +221
33 825 25 30, Fax: +221 33 824 63 18, Sénégal, Email: mababad@yahoo.fr
2. Université Paris-Est Marne-la-Vallée, Laboratoire Géomatériaux et Environnement, 5 Boulevard Descartes, Champs-sur-Marne, 77454 Marne-la-Vallée
cedex 2, Fax: +33 1 49 32 91 37 France, Email: mababa.diagne@univ-mlv.fr
Manuscript received on November 3rd, 2011 ; accepted on April 28, 2012.

Bull. Soc. géol. Fr., 2013, no 3


268 DIAGNE M.

quants. Le but de cette étude est donc de trouver à partir des ces fines rejetées avant traitement, un nouveau matériau qui
répondra à une norme bien connue en termes de caractéristiques physiques et mécaniques et permettant: (1) d’une part
la réduction de leur degré de nuisance par leur consommation pour générer un matériau utile surtout au niveau des villa-
ges environnants du site minier et (2) d’autre part de faire travailler les jeunes dans ce processus de recyclage des fines
pour générer des emplois et par la même occasion des ressources additionnelles leur permettant de vivre dans de meil-
leures conditions.
Ainsi, une formulation d’un mélange bien défini contenant ces fines de phosphate d’alumine sédimentaire de
composition chimique variée mais semblable à celle de scories volcaniques du point de vue chimique (taille des particu-
les comprise entre 0,063 mm et 5 mm), du silicate de sodium (comme liant d’éléments minéraux) et de l’eau, a permis
la confection de blocs de matériaux de 20×10×6 cm3 de dimensions par cuisson durant plusieurs heures au four pour une
température constante de 225 oC. La densité du silicate de sodium est de 1.4.
De bonnes caractéristiques mécaniques et physiques ont été obtenues grâce à des essais sur ces matériaux. Des es-
sais de résistance à la traction par fendage, des mesures de la teneur en eau d’absorption totale, des mesures des dimen-
sions des blocs (longueur, largueur et épaisseur) ainsi que de perte au feu en milieu ambiant ont été réalisés sur ces
blocs après leur cure pour une caractérisation complète. Des valeurs moyennes de 3,03 MPa et 2,5 % ont été respective-
ment obtenues en résistance à la traction et en teneur en eau d’absorption totale. Des variations négatives de –2,05 mm,
–0,59 mm et –1,69 mm en moyenne ont été obtenues respectivement sur la longueur, l’épaisseur et la largeur des blocs
pour une valeur moyenne de perte au feu de 5,30 %.
La déduction de la résistance à la compression à partir de la valeur moyenne obtenue au fendage donne une valeur
de 40,5 MPa, ce qui se traduit par une très bonne résistance mécanique du matériau. Ces caractéristiques ont été compa-
rées aux valeurs standards données par la Norme Européenne EN 1338 sur les pavés. Ces valeurs obtenues témoignent
d’un bon matériau. Ce nouveau matériau peut également être utilisé comme matériau réfractaire dans les fours et dans la
poterie.

INTRODUCTION damages due to the space itself they occupy, but they are
also sources of air pollution, especially during the Harmattan
The study area is located in the western part of Senegal period characterized by hot, dry and dust-laden winds.
(West of Africa). The geology is dominated by two major The purpose of this paper is to study how to enhance
sets: a Precambrian basement in the extreme southeast and the value of these fines of alumina phosphate by making
sedimentary formations of the Tertiary and Quaternary in refractory materials that can be used in construction (bricks
the centre and the west of the country. This alumina phos- or pottery materials). Many studies have been made on the
phate was defined as the wavelite [Flicoteaux, 1982; enhancement of the value of phosphate waste or recycled
Geoter, 2009]. Among these tertiary formations, it can be aggregates in construction [Poon and Dixon, 2006; Figueroa
noted the existence of a number of phosphate deposits dat- et al., 1987; Ghafoori and Wen, 1993; Negm and Abouzeid,
ing from the Eocene in Matam region in the North-East 2008; Tara and Umesh, 2010].
[Pascal and Faye, 1989], the phosphate deposits of
Ndendouri-Wali-Diala and the deposits of Lam-Lam and The fines of alumina phosphate recycling can also be a
Taïba in the west of the country [CSE, 2012] (fig. 1). The source of youth employment.
exploitation of the latter has been taking place since 1949
and 1960 respectively.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
In the area of Lam-Lam, located at 14 km in the
north-east of the region of Thiès, there are also alumina
phosphate deposits, which are the products of lime phos- Materials
phate weathering. This alumina phosphate was exploited re-
spectively by the Société Sénégalaise des Phosphates de Fines of fines of alumina phosphate
Thiès (SSPT) and the Industries Chimiques du Sénégal (ICS)
in open-pit mine [Pascal and Sustrac, 1989]. Mineable ore Figure 2 shows the size distribution of fines of alumina
had an average thickness of 10 m for a stripping of 3 m. It phosphate in its zone size according to the European Stan-
is crushed, calcined to increase the P2O5 content from dard EN 933-10 [EN 933-10, 2009]. It shows the size distri-
28.5% to 34% in situ. Raw alumina phosphate production bution of the fines of alumina phosphate. The curve fits
was estimated between 180,000 and 280,000 tons between correctly into its size zone. It is obvious that only 10% of
1949 and 1983. This product is sold under the name of the particles are finer than 0.063 mm, 40% lie in the field
“Phospal” as fertilizer [Flicoteaux and Hameh, 1989]. Its 0.063 mm – 0.8 mm and 60% are coarser than 0.8 mm.
chemical formula is Al3(OH)3(PO4)2.5H2O with several im- From the viewpoint of characterization, physico-chemi-
purities related to the presence of organic matter and other cal analysis showed a variable composition with the pres-
chemical elements [Poon and Dixon, 2007]. The material ence of several major chemical elements. Table I gives the
density is 1.24 g.cm-3 and its pH is 6.8. results of physico-chemical properties compared to those
Physical processing (crushing or grinding, transport, obtained from slag [Karl, 1952] (table I). The composition
braking and screening) of alumina phosphate ore results in found for these fines is similar to that of aluminous slag
a very large quantity of fine fraction, about 20% of raw mate- with the exception of P2O5, F2 and organic matter (OM) that
rial. These fines are still stored with no prospective of pro- have not been analyzed. The reaction in aqueous solution is
cessing or valorization. They cause significant environmental neutral.

Bull. Soc. géol. Fr., 2013, no 3


USE OF ALUMINA PHOSPHATE WASTE TO PRODUCE BUILDING MATERIALS 269

TABLE I. – Results of the chemical properties of the sample compared to Methods


aluminous slags.
Chemical Aluminous slags Fines of alumina
Element [Karl, 1952] (%) phosphate (%) A mixture consisting of 2 kg of fines of alumina phosphate
P2O5 -- 29.5
smaller than 1.5 mm in diameter, 10% by weight of sodium
silicate (200 g) and 14% of water content (308 g) was vig-
Al2O3 64.5 30.9
orously mixed by a mixer fitted with small blades to obtain
CaO 4.5 9.2 a homogeneous mixture. The material larger than 1.5 mm
Fe2O3 6.75 7.9 was removed to be cleared up of coarse elements. The mix-
SiO2 2.5 2.5 ture was put into molds of 20×10×6 cm3 size in order to
F2 -- 0.7 make the objects similar to bricks or paving blocks. After
MgO 4.5 -- five minutes of casting, the wet bricks were carefully re-
Organic Matter -- 15
moved from the mold and placed in an oven at a tempera-
ture of 225 oC for 24 hours for a good heat distribution
throughout the material. This duration will allow good reac-
tivity of the various components of the mixture to form a re-
fractory material of good quality. Then, these refractory
Sodium silicate materials are cooled for one hour and exposed to the ambi-
ent air of the laboratory. The laboratory ambient tempera-
Sodium silicate also called disodium of metasilicate
ture was 26oC (fig. 3).
(Na2SiO3) of high purity 95% was mixed with the fines of
alumina phosphate with a water content that gives to the
material a plastic consistency for easy handling. It is a com- Tests of tensile splitting failure, water absorption and
pound consisting of crystalline solids soluble in water. So- loss on ignition were carried out on the sample pieces ob-
dium silicate solubility is equal to 200 g.l-1 at 20oC [INRS, tained in order to see their reactivity to mechanical stress,
2006]. It is widely used as a binder in grindstones industry. soaking in water and exposure to fire. The size of the bricks
Its density is 2.6 g.cm -3 and its reaction in aqueous solution was also measured to see the percentage of shrinkage after
is lightly acid (pH = 6.7). the baking phase of our mixture.

FIG. 1. – Geologic map of Senegal, modified (Centre de Suivi Ecologique, 2012).

Bull. Soc. géol. Fr., 2013, no 3


270 DIAGNE M.

– 0.05 mm is obtained compared to the recommended one


that is ± 2 mm.

Water absorption
The refractory blocks were immersed for three days and
then put into the oven for three days to determine the maxi-
mum water that can clog the finished products. Thus, tests
were conducted on a series of eight refractory blocks. The
data are compiled in table III.
The average water content of refractory blocks is
2.95%; this value is less than that required by the standard
EN 1338 which is 6%. It reflects a very low porosity due to
fineness of the phosphate material. The average dry density
of blocks obtained is 2.084 g.cm-3.

Loss on ignition
FIG. 2. – Particle size distribution curve of the sample in its zone size
(䊏 zone size distribution, 䉱 curve of the sample). This test was performed to show the behavior of the blocks
produced if used in civil engineering among other uses. A
series of eight samples was submitted to fire in ordinary at-
mosphere. The moisture content of samples was zero. The
results obtained are given in table IV. They show an average
value of loss on ignition of 5.30%. This value is quite high
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS due to the high amount of phosphate present in the material
(29.5%). Indeed, the phosphorus element is very reactive to
fire, this value of loss on ignition found can be ascribed to
Resistance to splitting failure the presence of phosphorus in the new material.
Tests of tensile strength and size measurements were con-
ducted on a series of four blocks of 20×10×6 cm-3 sizes. DISCUSSION
The results are compiled in table II.
In the bottom line they are compared to the reference Visual, space and environmental pollutions from fines of
value given by the European Standard [EN 1338, 2004, alumina phosphate generated by extraction, transportation,
Tabl. II, page 8] which sets a value normalized to the hy- crushing and screening of raw alumina phosphate materials
draulic concrete paving blocks of the same size. This com- pose a serious problem in the mining sites of Lam-Lam and
parison is just indicative. The results in table II show that Taïba (Senegal). Nevertheless, the 2003-36 Act of Novem-
the average resistance to splitting of 3.03 MPa was obtained ber 24, 2003 of the Senegalese Mining Code in Chapter 82
and it is below the value required by EN 1338. However, Clause V [Loi no 2003-36, 2003] requires that “every holder
this standard EN 1338 can tolerate up to a limit value of of mining rights must conduct site rehabilitation at the end
2.9 MPa. The values of the average found in the splitting of each mining title...”. This rehabilitation has not been
failure can be correlated to the compressive strength done since the opening of the mine in the early 50s generat-
through the equation 1 [BAEL 91, 2000] (Eq. 1). ing the storage of fines in large areas from mechanical ac-
Rt = 0.6 + 0.06×Rc Eq.1 tivity but also a dumping of phosphogypsum, a waste of the
phosphoric acid process.
Rc gives the compressive strength and Rt the tensile Recycling of mining waste in refractory blocks has
strength. Thus, a theoretical value of 40.5 MPa must be ob- shown promising results. Thus, these results obtained with
tained by compression. This value is indicative of the com- splitting failure tests show that these fines material recycled
pressive strength we should get in these refractory products. in blocks, can be used as construction material because the
Table II also shows that variations in the sizes of the standard requires that only one value may fall below
bricks are within the limits required in terms of thickness 2.90 MPa. Table II shows that all values are higher than the
and width. An absolute variation value in length of latter.

TABLE II. – Results of splitting rupture and measurements of the size of the blocks.

N° Sample 1 2 3 4 Average ⌬ (mm) ⌬ (mm) EN 1338 Standard EN 1338


Length (mm) 199.26 197.48 197.72 197.34 197.95 -2.05 ⫾ 2 --
Thickness (mm) 59.7 58.96 59.96 59.02 59.41 -0.59 ⫾ 3 --
Width (mm) 97.93 98.30 98.84 98.17 98.31 -1.69 ⫾ 2 --
Breaking load (kN) 85 86 84.7 87.3 92.9 -- -- --
Resistance (MPa) 3.00 3.03 2.99 3.08 3.03 -0.57 -- 3.6

Bull. Soc. géol. Fr., 2013, no 3


USE OF ALUMINA PHOSPHATE WASTE TO PRODUCE BUILDING MATERIALS 271

will allow unemployed young people to find work in the re-


cycling process. This work will involve the training of the
youth, the creation of blocks production units in villages on
a small scale in the short term.

CONCLUSION

The fines of alumina phosphate released by the ICS and the


SSPT and stored in large quantities can be recycled into ma-
terials such as refractory bricks for construction etc. In-
deed, the blocks made provide good mechanical properties
FIG. 3. – Procedure of manufacturing blocks of refractory materials. including the splitting failure. A resistance value of
3.03 MPa was found, value correlated to 40.5 MPa in com-
pression and which reflects a good performance in terms of
mechanical resistance of the blocks obtained.
In terms of water absorption, the refractory blocks are
of good behavior in extreme water conditions. Indeed, after
Poon et al. [2002] showed that the replacement of natu- 3 days, the blocks were packed of 2.95% water in average.
ral fines aggregates in concrete material from the waste This value reflects the good reactivity of the different com-
from house demolition allows the production of paving ponents of the mixture during the firing into the oven at
blocks with a compressive strength of 49 MPa. The same 225°C. The reactions between the major chemical elements,
authors showed that the addition of fly ash gave a value of sodium silicate and water have driven the disappearance of
compressive strength of 30 MPa for brick masonry, corre- almost all the empty spaces despite a maximum diameter of
sponding to a value of 2.4 MPa (Equation I, Page 8) in split- the initial material of 3.5 mm.
ting failure, a value below that which we obtain (3.03 MPa). However, the loss on ignition is not negligible because
These values obtained in terms of splitting failure the value found is considered quite high due to the presence
strength, measurement, percentage of total water absorption of phosphorus in the raw material. These refractory materi-
and loss on ignition of the rectangular blocks made evi- als from waste phosphate show good mechanical and physi-
dence of the ability to reduce the pollution of the entire area cal performance for their use as bricks or paving blocks or
studied by recycling these fines in creating Economic Inter- objects in pottery but they can also be tested as refractory
est Groups in the villages surrounding the mining site. It materials in furnaces.

TABLE III. – Results of measurements of water content of the refractory blocks.


N° Sample 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Average Density (g.cm )
3

Weight of wet blocks (g) 2,500 2,498 2,506 2,493 2,524 2,499 2,503 2,489 2,501.5 2.084
Weight of dry blocks (g) 2,436 2,435 2,439 2,419 2,438 2,437 2,415 2,420 2,429.88 2.024
Weight of total water (g) 64 63 67 74 86 62 88 69 71.63 --
Water content (%) 2.63 2.59 2.75 3.06 3.53 2.54 3.64 2.85 2.95 --

TABLE IV. – Results of loss on ignition tests on refractory blocks.

N° Sample 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Average
Weight of blocks before calcination (g) 2,428 2,433 2,440 2,425 2,423 2,429 2,428 2,431 2,430
Weight of blocks after calcination (g) 2,300 2,302 2,297 2,306 2,279 2,306 2,310 2,306 2,301
Loss on ignition (%) 5.27 5.38 5.86 4.91 5.94 5.06 4.86 5.14 5.30

Bull. Soc. géol. Fr., 2013, no 3


272 DIAGNE M.

References

BAEL 91 (2000). – Règles techniques de conception et de calcul des ouvra- NEGM A.A. & ABOUZEID A.Z.M. (2008). – Utilization of solid wastes from
ges et constructions en béton armé suivant la méthode des états phosphate processing plants. – Physicochem. Probl. Miner. Pro-
limites – 3e édition. – CSTB, Paris: France 190 p., France. cess., 42, 5-16.
CENTRE DE SUIVI ECOLOGIQUE C.S.E. (2012). – Carte géologique des grands NF EN 933-10 (2009). – Essais pour déterminer les caractéristiques géo-
ensembles du Sénégal à 1/150 000, modifiée. – Dakar, CSE. métriques des granulats – Partie 10: détermination des fines –
Granularité des fillers (tamisage dans un jet d’air), P18-622-10. –
FIGUEROA J.L., ZHOU L. & CHANG W.F. (1987). – Use of phosphate mining
Assoc. Franç. Normalisation, Paris, 28 p.
waste in secondary road construction. – Transportation Research
Record, 1, 59-64. Norme E.N. 1338 (2004). – Pavés en béton. Prescriptions et méthodes
d’essai. – Service d’études sur les transports, les routes et leurs
FLICOTEAUX R. (1982). – Genèse des phosphates alumineux du Sénégal oc- aménagements. – S.E.T.R.A. Paris, 63 p.
cidental. Etapes et guides de l’altération. – Thèse Sci., Mar- PASCAL M. & M FAYE C. (1989). – The Matam phosphate deposits. In:
seille, 1982. – Mém. Sci. Géol. Univ. Strasbourg, 67, 229 p A.J.G. NOTHOLT, R.P. SHELDON & D.F. DAVIDSON, Eds., Phos-
FLICOTEAUX R. & HAMEH P.M. (1989). – The aluminous phosphate deposits phate deposits of the world, 2. Phosphate rock resources. – Cam-
of Thies, western Senegal. In: A.J.G. NOTHOLT, R.P. SHELDON & bridge University Press, Cambridge, 2, 295-300.
D.F. DAVIDSON, Eds, Phosphate deposits of the world, Phosphate PASCAL M. & SUSTRAC G. (1989). – Phosphorite deposits of Senegal. In:
rock resources. – Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2, A.J.G. NOTHOLT, R.P. SHELDON & D.F. DAVIDSON, Ed., Phos-
273-276. phate deposits of the world, 1. Phosphate rock resources. – Cam-
GEOTER (2009). – Carte géologique de la zone d’activité du Cap-Vert à bridge University Press, Cambridge, 1, 233-246.
1/50 000. Notice explicative de la feuille de Thiès. – 1ère édition. – POON C.S. & DIXON C. (2006). – Paving blocks made with recycled con-
Dakar. Formations superficielles et notice explicative par R OGER crete aggregate and crushed clay brick. – Construction and Buil-
J. et al., 2009, 245p. ding Materials, 20, 569-577.
GHAFOORI N. & W EN F.C. (1993). – Investigation of phosphate mining POON C.S. & DIXON C. (2007). – Effects of contaminants on the properties
waste for construction materials. – J. Mater. Civil Engineering, of concrete paving blocks prepared with recycled concrete ag-
5, 249-264. gregates. – Construction and Building Materials, 21, 164-175.
POON C.S., KOU S.C. & LAM L. (2002). – Use of recycled aggregates in
I.N.R.S. (2006). – Fiche technique. – Institut National de Recherche et de
moulded concrete bricks and blocks. – Constr. Build Mater., 16,
Sécurité, 256, 4 pages.
281-289.
KARL A. (1952). – Process for the production of refractory masses of bricks TARA S. & UMESH M. (2010). – Usage of industrial waste products in vil-
from slags. – United States Patent Office, n° 2764493. lage road construction. – Internat. J. Environm. Sci. Developt, 1,
LOI No 2003-36 (2003). – Code Minier du Sénégal, Dakar, 62 p. 122-126.

Bull. Soc. géol. Fr., 2013, no 3

You might also like