Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/323378181
A study of a new screw press forging process for producing aircraft drop
forgings made of magnesium alloy AZ61A
CITATIONS READS
8 601
4 authors, including:
Grzegorz Winiarski
Lublin University of Technology
25 PUBLICATIONS 127 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
The production of flat parts with ribs by new forging method in three-slide forging machine View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Anna Dziubińska on 16 November 2019.
Access to this document was granted through an Emerald subscription provided by Token:Eprints:R5HVXXGK4WYCMF66WVMP:
For Authors
If you would like to write for this, or any other Emerald publication, then please use our Emerald for Authors service
information about how to choose which publication to write for and submission guidelines are available for all. Please visit
www.emeraldinsight.com/authors for more information.
About Emerald www.emeraldinsight.com
Emerald is a global publisher linking research and practice to the benefit of society. The company manages a portfolio of
more than 290 journals and over 2,350 books and book series volumes, as well as providing an extensive range of online
products and additional customer resources and services.
Emerald is both COUNTER 4 and TRANSFER compliant. The organization is a partner of the Committee on Publication Ethics
(COPE) and also works with Portico and the LOCKSS initiative for digital archive preservation.
Abstract
Purpose – The aim of this study is to develop a die forging process for producing aircraft components made of magnesium alloy AZ61A using a
screw press.
Design/methodology/approach – The proposed forging technique has been developed based on the results of a numerical and experimental
research. The required forging temperature has been determined by upsetting cylindrical specimens on a screw press to examine both plasticity of
the alloy and the quality of its microstructure. The next stage involved performing numerical simulations of the designed forging processes for
producing forgings of a door handle and a bracket, both made of magnesium alloy AZ61A. The finite element method based on simulation
programme, Deform 3D has been used for numerical modelling. The numerical results revealed that the forgings are free from material overheating
and shape defects. In addition to this, the results have also helped determine the regions that are the most prone to cracking. The final stage of the
research involved performing forging tests on a screw press under industrial conditions. The forgings of door handles and brackets were made, and
then these were tested for their mechanical and structural properties. The results served as a basis for assessing both the viability of the designed
technique and the quality of the produced parts.
Findings – The experimental results demonstrate that aircraft components made of magnesium alloy AZ61A can be produced by die forging on
screw presses. The results have been used to determine the fundamental parameters of the process such as the optimum forging temperature, the
method of tool heating, the way of cooling parts after the forging process, and the method of thermal treatment. The results of the mechanical and
structural tests confirm that the products meet the required quality standards.
Practical implications – The developed forging technique for alloy AZ61A has been implemented by the forging plant ZOP Co. Ltd in Swidnik
(Poland), which specializes in the manufacturing of aircraft components made of non-ferrous metal alloys.
Originality/value – Currently, the global tendency is to forge magnesium alloys (including alloy AZ61A) on free hydraulic presses using expensive
die-heating systems. For this reason, the production efficiency of such forging processes is low, while the manufacturing costs are high. The
proposed forging technique for alloy AZ61A is an innovative method for producing forgings using relatively fast and efficient machines (screw
presses). The proposed forging method can be implemented by forging plants equipped with standard stocks of tools, which increases the range of
potential manufacturers of magnesium alloy products. In addition, this technology is highly efficient and ensures reduced manufacturing costs.
Keywords Aircraft, Forging, Magnesium alloy AZ61A, Screw press
Paper type Research paper
1. Magnesium and its applications in the aircraft Gontarz, 2016). It has good noise and vibration-damping and
industry electromagnetic wave-suppressing properties. Its melting point
is equal to 650°C and the boiling point is 1,107°C. Because of
Magnesium is one of the lightest metals among popular its high affinity for oxygen and nitrogen, magnesium has low
construction materials. It has a light silver colour and a density corrosion resistance. It burns with an extremely light white
of 1.738 g/cm3, which constitutes approximately ¼ density of flame in the presence of oxygen.
steel and about 2=3 density of aluminium (Dziubi nska and Its self-combustion temperature ranges from 600 to 650°C,
but with fine-grained structures, the combustion can be already
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available on
Emerald Insight at: www.emeraldinsight.com/1748-8842.htm Financial support of Structural Funds in the Operational Programme –
Innovative Economy (IE OP) financed from the European Regional
Development Fund – Project “Modern material technologies in aerospace
Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace Technology industry”, No. POIG.01.01.02-00-015/08-00 is gratefully acknowledged.
90/3 (2018) 559–565
© Emerald Publishing Limited [ISSN 1748-8842] Received 30 November 2016
[DOI 10.1108/AEAT-11-2016-0238] Accepted 26 December 2016
559
New screw press forging process Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace Technology
Andrzej Gontarz et al. Volume 90 · Number 3 · 2018 · 559–565
observed at temperatures above 500°C. The combustion magnesium alloys for producing structures where weight
temperature of magnesium exceeds 2000°C. Compared to reduction was a significant development factor.
other metals, pure magnesium in the form of ingots does not In particular, the producers of means of transportation began
have high mechanical properties. However, because of its low to look for new light-weight materials that would enable
specific weight, this metal is widely used for aerospace reduced fuel consumption and higher technical parameters of
applications (Dziubi nska et al., 2016; Kuczmaszewski et al., vehicles. Mainly produced by casting techniques, 90 per cent of
2016; Matuszak and Zaleski, 2014). such products were made of magnesium alloy AZ91D
In 1900, the world’s production of magnesium amounted to (Pekguleryuz et al., 2013; Gziut et al., 2016).
approximately 10 tonnes, while in 1915, during the First World Despite relatively low production costs in China, magnesium
War, it increased to 350 tonnes (Dziado n, 2012). The alloys are not highly popular in the market. The interest in
development of magnesium alloys took place in the 1940s magnesium alloys did not revive until the beginning of the
and 1950s. Given the outbreak of the Second World second decade of the twenty-first century. There appeared a
War, magnesium-based materials were used for military number of applications for magnesium alloys in the
applications, mainly in Germany. In the post-war period, they automotive, aerospace, armaments, electronics, energy, textile,
began to be used for civilian production especially in the medical and other industries. The growing use of these alloys
Downloaded by POLITECHNIKA LUBELSKA, Anna Dziubinska At 07:04 21 January 2019 (PT)
aircraft, automotive and sport, as well as recreational, electronic was undoubtedly because of the advancements in the
and medical, industries. The armaments industry continued to manufacturing of magnesium and its alloys and their processing
be a testing ground for the application of magnesium and its into finished products. Nowadays, new types of alloys and
alloys. In the 1950s, Americans used magnesium alloys to methods of casting, metal forming, heat treatment and
produce B36 and B52 bombers (Figure 1). For example, the corrosion protection are being developed. This results in not
production of the B36 bomber involved the use of over 5,500 kg only reduced prices of magnesium alloys but it the development
of sheets, approximately 680 kg of forgings and approximately
of alloys with higher mechanical, technological and commercial
300 kg of casts (Luo, 2013).
properties.
The price of magnesium alloys was a serious limitation to their
Magnesium alloys belong to the group of materials that are
use. Consequently, in the following decade, with the tendency to
relatively hardly deformable by metal-forming processes. Their
reduce production costs in the civil sector, the interest in
temperature range of high plasticity is quite narrow. They are
magnesium alloys decreased. However, they were still used in the
sensitive to strain rate, for example the higher the strain rate is,
aircraft industry, which was less sensitive to production costs. A
the lower their plasticity is (which increases the risk of
good example was the passenger aircraft Boeing 727.
cracking). For these reasons, magnesium alloy forgings are
Manufactured in 1962-1984 in the quantity of 1,832 items, the
forged on slow hydraulic presses using special tool-heating
aircraft’s design was based on the use of approximately 1,200
parts made of magnesium alloys. The Soviet Union also used systems to maintain isothermal conditions during the forging
magnesium alloys in the aircraft industry. The manufacturing of process. As reported in the specialist literature, the forging
the TU95MS aircraft required approximately 1,550 kg of processes for producing forgings of various shapes and
magnesium, while the production of Tupolev Tu-134 involved dimensions require the use of heated tools and must be run at
approximately 780 kg of this metal (Luo, 2013). low velocities (Wang et al., 2010, 2008; Liu and Cui, 2009;
Later on, the use of magnesium alloys in the aircraft industry Henn and Fein, 2010). This results in low efficiency of the
reduced because of the limitations resulting from fire hazards forging process and generates high production costs. Hence,
and its low corrosion resistance property. What is more, the the number of manufacturers of magnesium alloy forgings is
aircraft industry in that period began to use lightweight polymer limited to plants with adequate stocks of machinery and
composites. This led to the slowing down of the development of ancillary equipment.
magnesium alloys and their processing technologies in the For this reason, a study was undertaken to investigate the
1980s and 1990s. At the end of the twentieth century, the forging process for magnesium alloys using standard forging
aircraft industry showed a renewed interest in the use of machines such as screw presses. The main objective of the
study was to develop a basis for industrial implementation and
Figure 1 Assembly line B36 bombers in the 1950s development of a technology for producing aircraft parts made
of magnesium alloy AZ61 by hot forging on these machines.
560
New screw press forging process Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace Technology
Anna Dziubinska et al. Volume 90 · Number 3 · 2018 · 559–565
4 Step 4: Validation of the developed technology and 2.2 Design of the proposed forging method and its
assessment of the quality of produced forgings in relation numerical modelling
to the technical requirements. The next step was to design a screw press-based forging method
for producing the selected forgings used in the design of
AZ61A (MgAl6Zn), its chemical composition given in Table I,
helicopters. Spatial models of the forgings are shown in Figure 4.
is an alloy which is moderately susceptible to hot working. Its The proposed forging technology included the following
properties are similar to those of low-resistant structural operations:
aluminium alloys, that is Rm 275 MPa, Rp0.2 165 MPa cutting the billet (extruded rod) to the desired
and A5 9 per cent, and its hardness is approximately 60 HB. dimensions;
This alloy is used in the design of structures carrying low static heating the billet prior to the forging process in an electric
and dynamic loads, for example, brackets and levers used in chamber furnace to the temperature of 410°C;
aircraft structures. performing a pre-forging operation with approximately 2-
mm underfill of the die impression;
2.1 Plasticity tests trimming of the excess flash;
The experimental tests investigating the plasticity of reheating of the preform;
magnesium alloy AZ61A were performed by subjecting final forging in the die impression;
Downloaded by POLITECHNIKA LUBELSKA, Anna Dziubinska At 07:04 21 January 2019 (PT)
s max d « ¼ C (1)
cooling does not lead to an improved microstructure or higher sH
properties, instead it makes the process more complicated and 0
may generate undesired internal stresses in the product. The
results demonstrate that, prior to the forging process, where s max is the maximum principal stress, s H is the
magnesium alloy AZ61A should be pre-heated to the reduced stress according to the Huber–Mises–Hencky
temperature of 410°C, and the forgings should be subjected to hypothesis, « p is the limit fracture strain and C is the material
air cooling. constant.
According to this criterion, also known as the standardized
Cockroft–Latham criterion, the higher the value of the constant
Table I Chemical composition of magnesium alloy AZ61A according to
C is, the greater is the risk of cracking (Tomczak et al., 2015).
standard ASTM B107-13
The numerical simulations were performed using a thermo-
Al Zn Mn Fe Si Cu Ni Mg mechanical model of the forging process in a three-dimensional
5.8-7.2 0.4–1.5 0.15–0.5 Max Max 0.10 Max 0.05 Max Balance state of strain. The temperature of metal heating was set to
0.005 0.005 410°C, while the temperature of the tools was fixed at 300°C.
The linear velocity of the forming tools (forging dies) on the
561
New screw press forging process Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace Technology
Anna Dziubinska et al. Volume 90 · Number 3 · 2018 · 559–565
Figure 2 Upset samples from AZ61A magnesium alloy in screw press in different temperatures
Figure 3 Microstructure of samples from AZ61A magnesium alloy Figure 4 Spatial models of the forgings from AZ61A magnesium alloy
Downloaded by POLITECHNIKA LUBELSKA, Anna Dziubinska At 07:04 21 January 2019 (PT)
562
New screw press forging process Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace Technology
Anna Dziubinska et al. Volume 90 · Number 3 · 2018 · 559–565
Figure 5 Distributions of: (a) effective strain; (b) temperature; and (c) Figure 6 Distributions of temperature, effective strain and damage in
C-L damage criterion in the forging process for producing door handle the forging process for an aircraft bracket using a screw press
using a screw press
Downloaded by POLITECHNIKA LUBELSKA, Anna Dziubinska At 07:04 21 January 2019 (PT)
Figure 7 Forgings of: (a) door handle and (b) bracket from AZ61A alloy
produced on a screw press before flash trimming
563
New screw press forging process Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace Technology
Anna Dziubinska et al. Volume 90 · Number 3 · 2018 · 559–565
Table II Results of the mechanical properties of forgings of door handles and bracket from AZ61A alloy
Static tensile test
Type of forgings Grade/state of heat treatment Hardness [HB] Yield strength Rp0.2 [MPa] Tensile strength Rm [MPa] Elongation A5 [%]
Door handle AZ61A/after forging 57.5 218 305 12.0
56.8
60.5
Door handle AZ61A/after forging and an annealing 56.5 220 302 10.0
60.5
53.4
Bracket AZ61A/after forging 61.7 180 292 12.5
59.4
53.4
Bracket AZ61A/after forging and an annealing 54.8 183 297 12.0
52.8
Downloaded by POLITECHNIKA LUBELSKA, Anna Dziubinska At 07:04 21 January 2019 (PT)
52.2
metallographic examination of the microstructure in an As a result of the forging process, the forgings have a
etched state. recrystallized fine grain structure and their mechanical
properties meet the requirements for products made of
The results of measurement are presented in Table II. The
magnesium alloy AZ61A.
obtained properties are much higher than the minimum After the forging process, it is recommended that the
requirements specified in ASTM. Moreover, properties of
forgings should be subjected to air cooling. In contrast,
forgings subjected an annealing are similar to those of forgings
there is no point in applying water cooling to induce
in which this operation is not performed. hardening, as it does not improve the mechanical
On the basis of the microstructure examination, it was found
properties of the forgings because of a very low content
that in both analysed forgings after the annealing process, the
of alloying elements.
structure was characterized by recrystallized, equiaxial grains It is recommended that annealing should be performed
and high homogeneity (Figure 8). after the forging process at the temperature of 350°C to
ensure stress relaxation. The stress-relief annealing
does not affect either the strength or functional
3. Conclusions properties of finished products.
The results led to the following observations and conclusions
about the proposed technology:
It is technically possible to produce magnesium alloy References
AZ61A die forgings with the required quality and shape
Dziado n, A. (2012), Magnesium and its Alloys, Publisher Kielce
using a screw press.
University of Technology, Kielce.
The required heating temperature of a magnesium AZ61A
Dziubinska, A. and Gontarz, A. (2016), “A new technology for
billet is 410°C. To prevent rapid heat loss of the workpiece
producing AZ31 magnesium alloy aircraft brackets with a
during the forging process, the tools should be continuously
triangular outline”, Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace
heated and their temperature should be maintained at 300-–
Technology, Vol. 88 No. 3, pp. 452-457.
350°C. This can be done using gas burners instead of very
Dziubinska, A., Gontarz, A. and Dziedzic, K. (2016), “Qualitative
expensive heating systems.
research of AZ31 magnesium alloy aircraft brackets produced
by a new forging method”, Archives of Metallurgy and Materials,
Figure 8 Microstructure of forging Vol. 61 No. 2, pp. 1003-1008.
Gontarz, A. and Winiarski, G. (2015), “Numerical and
experimental study of producing flanges on hollow parts by
extrusion with a movable sleeve”, Archives of Metallurgy and
Materials, Vol. 60 No. 3, pp. 1917-1921.
Gontarz, A., Dziubi nska, A. and Oko n, Ł. (2011),
“Determination of friction coefficients at elevated temperatures
for some Al, Mg and Ti alloys”, Archives of Metallurgy and
Materials, Vol. 56 No. 2, pp. 379-384.
Gziut, O., Kuczmaszewski, J. and Zag orski, I. (2016), “Analysis
of chip fragmentation in az91hp alloy milling with respect to
reducing the risk of chip ignition”, Ekspolatacja i Niezawodnosc –
Maintenance and Reliability, Vol. 18 No. 1, pp. 73-79.
564
New screw press forging process Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace Technology
Andrzej Gontarz et al. Volume 90 · Number 3 · 2018 · 559–565
Henn, Y. and Fein, A. (2010), “Project Magforming – extrusion and drawing”, Journal of Engineering for Industry,
development of new magnesium forming technologies for the Vol. 101 No. 1, pp. 36-44.
aeronautics industry”, Publishable Final Activity Report, Pekguleryuz, M., Kainer, K. and Kaya, A. (2013), “Chapter 5,
pp. 1-58. fundamentals of magnesium alloy metallurgy”, Chapter in
Kuczmaszewski, J., Zag orski, I. and Dziubinska, A. (2016), monograph edited by Pekguleryuz, M., Kainer, K. and Kaya,
“Investigation of ignition temperature, time to ignition and A. (Eds), Fundamentals of Magnesium Alloy Metallurgy,
chip morphology after the high-speed dry milling of Woodhead Publishing Limited, Cambridge.
magnesium alloys”, Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace Tomczak, J., Pater, Z. and Bulzak, T. (2015), “Forming of
Technology, Vol. 88 No. 3, pp. 1-11. hollow shaft forging from titanium alloy Ti6Al4V by means
Liu, J. and Cui, Z. (2009), “Hot forging process design and of rotary compression”, Archives of Metallurgy and Materials,
parameters determination of magnesium alloy AZ31B spur Vol. 60 No. 1, pp. 419-425.
bevel gear”, Journal of Materials Processing Technology, Wang, Q., Zhang, Z., Zhang, X. and Li, G. (2010), “New
Vol. 209 Nos 18/19, pp. 5871-5880. extrusion process of Mg alloy automobile wheels”,
Luo, A. (2013), “Chapter 8, applications: aerospace, Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China, Vol. 20,
automotive and other structural applications of magnesium”, pp. 599-603.
Wang, Q., Zhang, Z., Zhang, X. and Yu, J. (2008), “Precision
Downloaded by POLITECHNIKA LUBELSKA, Anna Dziubinska At 07:04 21 January 2019 (PT)
For instructions on how to order reprints of this article, please visit our website:
www.emeraldgrouppublishing.com/licensing/reprints.htm
Or contact us for further details: permissions@emeraldinsight.com
565