Professional Documents
Culture Documents
________________________________________________
Section:____________
EAS 1600 – Fall 2018
Lab 02: Solar Radiation and Beyond
Lab
Objectives:
In
the
first
part
of
this
lab
we
will
investigate
radiation
laws
and
learn
how
they
apply
to
the
Earth
as
a
planet,
while
the
second
part
will
explore
the
influence
on
this
by
the
greenhouse
effect.
We
will
study
dependence
of
energy
flux
on
the
distance
from
the
point
source.
We
also
will
discuss
characteristics
of
an
ideal
blackbody
and
concepts
of
albedo,
absorbed
and
radiated
energies
and
how
these
combine
to
produce
the
effective
planet
temperature.
Finally
we
will
address
how
greenhouse
gases
affect
this
value.
At
the
end
of
this
lab,
you
should
be
able
to:
• Solar
Radiation:
o Define
a
perfect
blackbody;
o Understand
the
Earth’s
energy
balance;
o Relate
radiative/solar
flux
and
albedo
to
the
Earth’s
effective
temperature;
o Calculate
the
solar
(energy)
flux
under
experimental
conditions;
o Describe
and
explain
what
effects
laboratory
conditions
and
parameters
of
the
experimental
setup
have
on
Earth’s
effective
temperature
in
this
experiment.
• Additional,
via
short
activity
and
demo:
o Briefly
explain
seasons
o Briefly
explain
the
greenhouse
effect
and
how
greenhouse
gasses
affect
temperatures
Figure
1.
The
classification
and
corresponding
wavelengths
of
electromagnetic
radiation
-‐
the
electromagnetic
spectrum.
Image
edited
from
http://hyperphysics.phy-‐astr.gsu.edu
Figure
2.
Blackbody
radiation
curves.
Image
from
http://hyperphysics.phy-‐astr.gsu.edu
Blackbodies
do
not
radiate
at
a
single
wavelength,
but
rather
over
a
wide
diapason
of
frequencies
(wavelengths),
as
shown
in
Figure
2.
2
The
wavelength
at
which
this
radiation
has
a
maximum
flux
is
determined
by
Wien’s
law:
2898 µμm ∙ K
𝜆!"# =
𝑇
where
λmax
is
the
wavelength
of
the
maximum
radiation
flux
in
micrometers
and
T
is
the
temperature
of
the
body
in
Kelvins.
Wien’s
and
Stefan-‐Boltzmann
laws
tell
us
that
the
warmer
the
body
is,
the
more
it
radiates,
and
a
maximum
of
its
radiation
shifts
toward
a
shorter
wavelength
as
the
temperature
of
the
body
increases.
The
Inverse-‐Square
Law.
Consider
the
point
source
radiating
total
power
P
at
distance
R
from
the
point
of
observation.
We
can
assume
that
the
energy
from
the
source
is
evenly
distributed
over
the
sphere
with
radius
R.
The
area
of
this
sphere
is
4π R2
,
and
therefore,
the
energy
flux
(solar
flux
or
solar
irradiance)
S
passing
through
the
point
of
observation
will
be
equal
to
the
amount
of
power
passing
through
a
unit
area
(1m2)
of
this
sphere:
total power
S= =P .
(1)
area this power is spread over 4πR 2
Figure
3.
Inverse-‐Square
Law
demonstrating
the
distribution
of
energy
through
shells
o f
d ifferent
radii,
R.
Now
consider
a
different
sphere,
with
radius
R0.
The
total
power
P
has
not
changed,
while
the
area
this
energy
is
distributed
over
is
equal
to
4π R02,
and
therefore
the
flux
at
this
sphere
(at
a
distance
R0
from
the
source)
is
S 0 = P 2
4πR0
Comparison
of
the
expressions
for
S
and
S0
yields
an
inverse-‐square
law:
3
2
⎛ R ⎞
S = S 0 ⎜ 0 ⎟ ,
⎝ R ⎠
that
relates
unknown
flux
S
at
distance
R
to
the
known
flux
So
at
some
reference
distance
Ro.
Basically,
it
says
that
the
intensity
of
radiation
decreases
as
an
inverse
square
of
the
distance
from
the
source.
Energy
budget
and
planet
effective
temperature.
According
to
the
principle
of
conservation
of
energy,
the
net
radiative
energy
gained
by
arbitrary
body
in
a
unit
time
(Enet)
is
defined
by
the
difference
of
incoming
(Ein)
and
outgoing
(Eout)
energy.
Enet
=
Ein
–
Eout
The
incoming
energy
Ein
due
to
some
distant
source
depends
on
energy
flux
S
(the
amount
of
energy
passing
through
the
unit
area
perpendicular
to
the
direction
of
propagation,
W/m2)
impinging
the
body,
and
cross-‐sectional
area
A
that
intercepts
this
⊥
flux:
Ein = A⊥ ⋅ S ⋅ (1 − a )
where
a
is
the
albedo
of
the
body.
The
albedo
is
defined
as
the
ratio
of
the
energy
lost
via
reflection
or
scattering
to
the
total
incident
energy
(perfectly
reflecting
requires
a
=
1,
while
perfectly
absorbing
requires
a
=
0):
reflected energy
a=
total incident energy
Total
outgoing
energy
of
the
body
according
to
Stefan-‐Boltzmann
law
is
equal
to
outgoing
radiative
flux
times
total
surface
area
of
the
body
𝐴! :
Eout=
A∑ ⋅ σ ⋅ T 4
(2)
Putting
all
the
parts
of
the
energy
balance
together,
the
following
equation
could
be
obtained:
Enet = A⊥ ⋅ (1 − a) ⋅ S − A∑ ⋅ σ ⋅ T 4
(3)
At
the
equilibrium
(or
steady
state)
case
Enet=0
and
absorbed
energy
should
be
equal
to
radiated
energy,
otherwise
the
body
would
warm
or
cool
with
time.
Effective
body
temperature
T
b
is
therefore
constant
in
time
when
Enet=0,
and
can
be
found
from
(1)
as
!/!
𝐴! ∙ 𝑆 ∙ 1 − 𝑎𝑙𝑏𝑒𝑑𝑜
𝑇!"" =
𝐴! ∙ 𝜎
4
For
the
case
of
the
spherical
body
with
radius
r,
the
ratio
of
the
cross-‐section
A⊥ = π ⋅ r 2
and
total
area
A∑ = 4 ⋅ π ⋅ r 2
is
equal
to
4.
Therefore,
equation
(2)
simplifies
to
a
common
expression
for
the
planet
effective
temperature:
!/!
𝑆 ∙ 1 − 𝑎𝑙𝑏𝑒𝑑𝑜
𝑇!"" =
4∙𝜎
(4)
Figure 4. The same amount of sunlight covers different areas at Earth’s surface, producing less energy per
unit area at the polar latitudes than the equatorial latitudes.
Instead of rotating with a spin axis vertical relative to the direction of motion around the sun,
Earth’s spin axis is tilted by ~23.4° and with that spin axis pointed towards the North Star (this is
why if you look at long exposure pictures of the night sky you see a single point around which
all the other stars appear to rotate). As a result, depending on the location of Earth in its orbit
around the sun, different portions of the surface will receive direct sunlight as the northern end of
the spin axis is either pointed towards the sun (June 21, Northern Summer Solstice) or away
from the sun (Dec 21st, Northern Winter Solstice), as shown in Figure 5. Halfway between these,
on March 20th and September 22nd are the equinoxes, where the tilt is partway between this and
so neither points towards nor away from the sun. You can demonstrate this using your hands,
holding your left in a fist representing the sun and your right with only your thumb and pinky
5
stretched out, representing the axis of the Earth; then without changing the angle of your right
hand, move your right hand around your left, mimicking the orbital path of Earth around the sun
and you can see times when the axis points away, towards, and everything in between.
Figure 5. Sunlight distributed onto the surface of Earth at equatorial and polar latitudes for three different
times of the year: June 21, the equinoxes (March 20 and September 22), and December 21, with a
corresponding figure showing how often the sun is directly overhead for various latitudes.
Figure
6:
Comparing
direct
solar
radiation
and
reflection
back
into
space
with
the
greenhouse
effect,
by
which
infrared
radiation
is
reflected
in
random
directions,
and
warming
the
lower
atmosphere
and
surface
of
the
Earth.
Image
credit:
www.realscience.org.uk
7
Name:
________________________________________________
Section:____________
Experiment
set-‐up
and
reference
data.
The
set-‐up
consists
of
four
blackened
spheres,
placed
at
the
specified
distances
(rx)
from
150-‐Watt
lamp,
as
shown
in
the
diagram
above.
Each
sphere
represents
a
planet
and
the
lamp
represents
the
Sun.
In
the
set-‐up,
Mercury
is
placed
at
5
cm
away
from
the
lamp,
Venus
at
8
cm,
Earth
-‐
at
11
cm,
and
Mars
-‐
at
17
cm,
which
is
proportional
to
the
actual
distances
between
planets
and
Sun.
Each
sphere
has
a
thermistor
(temperature
sensor)
mounted
inside.
The
thermistor’s
output
is
resistance
R,
measured
on
Ohms.
In
this
experimental
set-‐up,
we
are
using
the
physical
relationship
between
resistance
and
temperature
in
order
to
measure
resistivity
and
convert
into
temperature
using
a
calibration
curve
or
a
formula.
The
sensors
are
connected
to
a
multi-‐position
switch
that
allows
independent
temperature
measurements
for
4
planets,
one
at
a
time.
The
fifth
planet,
“High-‐
albedo
Earth”
will
be
used
to
compare
the
effect
of
high
versus
low
albedo
of
a
planet.
The
radius
of
each
“planet”
is
0.75
cm
Question
1)
Using
your
own
life
experience
(e.g.
wearing
a
black
vs
white
shirt
on
a
bring
day)
and/or
what
you’ve
learned
in
class,
write
an
hypothesis
that
uses
this
experimental
set-‐up
relating
temperature,
distance,
and/or
albedo/reflectivity
(remember,
a
hypothesis
doesn’t
have
to
be
right,
just
testable):
(2
pts)
Question
2.
Explain
briefly
why
we
can
measure
resistivity
to
determine
temperature
(i.e.
why
measuring
resistivity
is
acceptable)
(1
pt).
I.
Procedure:
1. Connect
the
multimeter
probe
cable
to
the
red
and
black
terminals
of
the
lab
board.
2. Turn
the
multimeter
on,
and
switch
it
into
resistance
measuring
mode
(Ω).
3. At
room
temperature
and
with
the
lamp
off,
record
the
resistance
of
the
sensor,
at
time
0,
for
each
of
the
planets.
Record
your
results
in
Data
Table
1,
row
1.
The
values
should
be
within
an
8
–
13
kOhm
range.
4. Turn
the
multi-‐position
switch
on
the
board
to
the
“Mercury”
position.
5. Start
the
data
acquisition
by
recording
the
time
(t
=
0)
and
corresponding
resistance
of
the
sensor
for
Mercury
in
Table
2.
6. Turn
on
the
Sun
(lamp);
observe
and
record
in
Table
2
how
Mercury
temperature
(resistance)
changes
with
time.
7. In
approximately
10
–
15
minutes
the
system
should
come
into
steady
state
(the
resistance
is
not
changing
any
more
or
is
changing
insignificantly).
You
don’t
need
to
fill
all
columns
for
Table
2
if
you
have
reached
the
steady
state;
do
not
spend
more
than
15
minutes
waiting
for
the
system
to
reach
steady
state,
even
if
the
numbers
are
still
somewhat
changing.
At
this
point
(do
not
turn
the
bulb
off
yet)
measure
the
resistance
for
all
the
planet
sensors,
consecutively
switching
the
board
switch.
Let
the
switch
stay
in
each
position
for
at
least
10
seconds.
Record
the
time
and
your
results
in
Data
Table
1.
8. Turn
the
lamp
off.
9
9. Using
the
formula:
T
(°Celsius)
= 100 − 33 × ln( R )
(where
R
is
the
measured
resistance
in
kOhm),
and
the
relationship
between
Kelvin
and
Celsius
scales
(K=°C+273),
calculate
the
corresponding
temperatures
for
each
of
your
measurements.
Record
the
results
in
Data
Table
3.
Data
:
Questions
and
calculations
Data
Table
1.
(5
points)
High-‐Albedo
Planet
Mercury
Venus
Earth
Earth
Mars
Distance
from
rMe
~5cm
rV
~8cm
rE
~11cm
rHAE
~11cm
rMa
~17cm
the
“Sun”
Time,
min
Measured
Resistance,
kOhm
0
(lamp
off)
Data
Table
3
(5
points)
Planet
Temperature
t = 0
____
(Steady
State)
10
Results:
Questions
and
calculations
On
a
blank
EXCEL
spreadsheet,
enter
two
columns,
one
for
the
distance
of
each
planet
(except
high-‐albedo
Earth)
from
the
Sun
and
the
second
for
the
equilibrium
steady-‐state
temperature
(in
Kelvin)
of
the
planet.
Make
a
scatter-‐
plot
graph
the
effective
temperatures
(Y
axis)
as
a
function
of
distance
(X
axis),
and
label
your
axes.
Question
3.
How
would
you
describe
the
effective
temperature
versus
distance
dependence?
Circle
the
correct
relationship:
linear
vs
nonlinear;
decreasing
vs
increasing)
(1
pt).
Question
4.
Use
the
formula
for
effective
planet
temperature
and
solar
flux
(from
prelab
or
lecture
notes)
to
derive
the
dependence
you
expect
to
find
for
the
effective
planet
temperature
versus
distance
from
the
sun.
Hint:
Combine
the
equations,
convert
all
constants
into
a
single
variable
or
use
a
proportional
sign
instead
of
an
equals
sign,
and
simplify.
Show
your
work!
(6
pts).
Fit
an
appropriate
trend
line
to
your
experimental
data;
include
the
equation
on
the
plot.
Have
your
TA
sign
off
on
your
plot
with
the
trendline
and
equation
(4
pts
for
plot+axes,
2
pts
for
trendline+equation
=
6pts)
____________________
The
total
power
of
the
“Sun”
in
this
experiment
is
the
wattage
of
the
light
bulb
(150
W).
You
may
assume
that
these
150
Watts
of
power
are
generated
at
the
exact
center
of
the
bulb.
Question
5.
In
your
experiment,
the
flux
of
the
electromagnetic
energy
received
by
the
“planet”
is
dependent
on:
(Please
write
in
the
space
provided
below)
(2
pts)
1)
and
2)
11
Theoretical
Calculations:
These
calculations
provide
the
values
of
what
we
would
expect
to
get
during
an
experiment
using
known
equations
and
starting
values
(such
as
the
lightbulb
wattage).
Question
6.
For
your
experiment,
calculate
the
energy
flux,
S,
reaching
“Mercury”.
Use
the
respective
distance
(Show
your
work,
and
include+check
your
units!).
(5
pts.)
Question
7.
For
your
experiment,
report
the
energy
flux
reaching
“Venus”,
“Earth”,
and
“Mars”.
Use
the
respective
distances
(include
your
units!).
(1
pt
ea.)
Venus:
Earth:
Mars:
Question
8.
We
are
assuming
that
the
planets
(spheres)
are
perfect
blackbodies.
How
would
planet
temperatures
change
if
planets
were
not
blackbodies?
Explain.
(2
pts).
Question
9.
How
does
the
energy
flux
at
the
“Earth”
location
(calculated
in
question
7)
compare
to
the
actual
solar
energy
flux
impinging
the
real
planet
Earth
(~1370
W/m2)?
What
percentage
is
the
experimental
to
real?
(2
pts.)
Question
10.
What
are
the
possible
reasons
for
the
differences
between
the
theoretical
effective
temperature
and
measured
values?
Are
these
significant?
(2
pts).
12
Question
11.
Using
your
result
above
for
Mercury,
calculate
the
theoretical
effective
temperature
for
“Mercury”
(assumes
the
electric
bulb
as
a
point
source,
spheres
as
perfect
blackbodies,
and
the
power
of
the
lamp
as
150
W).
Show
your
work
and
don’t
forget
to
include
units
in
your
formulas.
(5
pts)
Question
12.
Repeat
the
calculation
from
Question
10
and
report
the
value
here
for
“Venus”,
“Earth”
and
“Mars”.
(1
pt
ea.)
Venus:
Earth
(low
albedo
/
black
sphere):
Mars:
Question
13.
For
the
spheres
(planets)
used
in
your
experiment,
calculate
the
area
that
intercepts
the
energy
flux
(solar
irradiance)
emitted
by
the
light
bulb
(in
m2).
Spheres
are
the
same,
so
calculate
just
one
value.
(2
pts)
Question
14.
Calculate
the
amount
of
energy
per
unit
time
(in
Watts)
that
is
received
(Ein)
by
the
“Earth”
sphere
in
your
experiment,
assuming
it’s
a
black
body.
Use
the
flux
from
question
8
and
the
intercepting
area
from
17.
(2pts)
Question
19.
Calculate
the
total
surface
area
of
any
of
the
spheres
(planets)
in
your
experiment
(in
m2).
(2
pts).
13
Question
20.
Calculate
the
energy
emitted
(Eout)
by
the
blackbody
“Earth”
sphere
in
your
experiment.
Use
the
temperature
from
your
experiment.
(2
pts)
Question
21.
On
the
real
Earth,
what
could
lower
the
albedo
and
increase
the
planet
effective
temperature?
(2
pts)
Question
22.
On
the
real
Earth,
what
could
serve
as
high-‐albedo
shield
to
lower
the
planet
effective
temperature?
(2
pts)
Question
23.
Most
of
the
energy
is
radiated
by
the
Earth
into
the
outer
space
in
form
of
(choose
one
from
the
following)
(1
pts):
A.
X-‐ray
B.
Radiowaves
C.
Infrared
D.
Visible
light
E.
Ultraviolet
Question
24.
Write
a
simple
qualitative
total
energy
balance
equation
for
an
arbitrary
planet,
which
would
include
incoming
and
outgoing
energy.
Assume
that
the
temperature
of
the
planet
is
not
changing
in
time
(steady
state).
Draw
a
simple
Diagram/Figure
of
another
real
world
application
of
energy
balance.
(2
pts):
Part 2: Seasons
Use Figures 4 and 5, as well as any lecture notes, to assist with the following.
Question 25: Draw an approximate comparative area distribution (in the form of a circle
or ellipse) f for 23.5°N latitude (Tropic of Cancer), the equator, and 23.5°S latitude
14
(Tropic of Capricorn). Note these do not correspond exactly to the three rays shown in
Figure 5. One is completed below for you to see.
23.5°
0°
(eq.)
23.5°
S
N
Equinox (3 pt):
Question 26: Explain how the difference in flux (where the same energy is spread across
different areas) at different times of the year influences what we come to know as
seasons. (4 pt)
Question 27: How might sunlight passing through the atmosphere further affect the
above? (2 pt)
Question 28: Give a hypothesis of how changing a planet’s tilt will affect the seasons
and a simple test or set of measurements that could be done to verify this. (3 pts)
15
Part 3: Introduction to Greenhouse Gasses Demo
Greenhouse
Demo:
In
this
short
demo,
you
will
be
comparing
three
flasks
of
air,
one
with
standard
air
acting
as
a
control,
a
second
containing
extra
carbon
dioxide
(CO2),
and
a
third
with
both
extra
CO2
and
H2O.
This
will
test
for
any
difference
in
temperature
when
heat
is
applied
to
each
system.
We
will
use
vinegar
and
baking
soda
to
acquire
our
CO2
for
this
demo.
Vinegar
and
Baking
Soda
react
when
they
come
in
contact
with
one
another,
causing
a
fizzing
reaction
that
you
may
have
observed
before.
The
fizzing
and
bubbling
indicates
that
a
gas
is
being
produced
as
the
solid
baking
soda
and
liquid
vinegar
react.
Chemically,
here
is
the
process:
Vinegar
(acetic
acid):
CH3COOH
Baking
soda
(sodium
bicarbonate):
NaHCO3
CH3COOH
+
NaHCO3
-‐-‐-‐>
CH3COONa
+
H2CO3
That
last
product
is
carbonic
acid
which
quickly
decomposes
(falls
apart)
into
carbon
dioxide
and
water:
H2CO3
-‐-‐-‐>
H2O
+
CO2
The
CO2
is
what
you
see
foaming
and
bubbling
in
this
reaction.
CO2
gas
is
more
dense
than
air.
It
will
stay
in
the
beaker,
forcing
out
the
air.
You
can
pour
CO2
gas
out
the
beaker,
just
like
you
would
pour
a
liquid.
You
can
feel
the
CO2
being
poured
out
of
the
beaker
because
it’s
cold.
The
reaction
with
baking
soda
and
vinegar
is
“endothermic”
meaning
it
requires
energy,
leaving
the
products
of
the
reaction,
including
CO2,
cold.
Room Temperature:
Table 4. Temperature change for “typical” air vs increased CO2 and H2O+CO2.
Temperature Readings at…
“Typical” Air
High-CO2
H2O + CO2
16
Results:
Question 29: What conclusions can you reach given the results from this experiment?
Specifically, how does the “typical” air compare with high-CO2 and CO2 + H2O? (5 pts)
Question 30: In what ways do you need to be careful in comparing the results from CO2
only with the results from the flask that contained the full reaction? (5 pts)
17