Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Care Nursing)
“By uploading this assignment electronically, I hereby certify that this material, which I now submit for assessment for the module above is
entirely my own work and has not been submitted as an exercise for assessment at this or any other University”
Do you consent to the use of your assignment for the purposes of future education at the School of Nursing and Midwifery RCSI?
I consent
1
Contents
Assignment Title...................................................................................................................................... 3
1. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................... 4
References ............................................................................................................................................ 17
2
Assignment Title
Each baby/family receives high quality palliative and end of life care that is appropriate to
his/her needs and to the wishes of his/her parents (National Standards of Bereavement Care
Critically discuss the above statement in relation to the care of the dying infant within the
3
1. INTRODUCTION
Bereavement is the state of being sad because of a loss of a loved one. Bereavement care
concentrates on the grief development by giving good support to family members after death
of their infant, with the aim of lessening feelings and sorrow (Forte et al, 2004). Death at the
beginning of life is very unpleasant but common in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU)
(Maura et al, 2011). The development of technology and medical advances in neonatal,
midwifery, and obstetrics care have improved the survival rate of infants born premature and
term infants born with multiple complications (Powell et al, 2012). Regardless of these
advances, some newborn will still die in the NICU due to extreme prematurity, anomalies, and
other complicated medical problems (Kain, 2011). The overall mortality rate in 2011 was 4.04
per 1000 live births (Mathew et al, 2013). The death of a newborn infant is certainly a
mortifying and disastrous lost to parents. Furthermore, the death of an infant is a severe lost
that may complicate, upset, or end relationships between parents, resulting to grieving, long
term deceased quality of life, and indications related to psychological morbidity (Rosenbaum
et al, 2011). The family’s grieving process and their ability to absorb the loss into their life
depends on the support that the neonatal team provides. Although the most difficult task is
working with the family of an infant who is dying (Discenza, 2010). In this assignment, the
writer will explore the care of the dying infant within the NICU, focusing on the different
environment for the parents and family during this very sensitive and stressful time of their
life. lastly recommendation for nursing practice and conclusion will be discussed.
4
2.CARE OF THE DYING NEONATE-TRANSITIONING FROM CURATIVE TO
END-OF-LIFE CARE
Palliative care is a way that makes the quality of life to those patients suffering life restricting
or limiting state condition (World Health Organization, 2015). Palliative care focuses on the
limiting of pain physically and lessen suffering, keeping the spiritual and cultural beliefs of the
patient and family (Brook, 2006). McCormick & Meir (2013) suggested that palliative care is a
holistic and extensive family centred care for an infant who is dying (Kain, 2013). Therefore,
earliest introduction of palliative care to a family member of infant that is dying, despite poor
prognosis, may lessen the transition from curative to palliative care (Reid et al, 2011).
Neonatal palliative care is the process whereby health care providers give sincere support to
both family members and dying infant, to have a better quality of life (Brooks et al, 2006).
This includes benevolent care for living infant and support for the family in their bereavement
the dying infant and family members with psychological, physical, emotional, social, and
spiritual suffering, in order that they may remain progressive (Romesberg, 2007). As
neonatologist, nurse, spiritual advisor, social worker, bereavement specialist consultant. This
interdisciplinary team serves to mediate and diminish the bad feeling and conflict felt by
health care providers and families involved in the ethical care of a dying infant, transitioning
from curative to end-to-life care (Callister, 2010). Continuing education on palliative care and
5
bereavement is pivotal, to improve confidence of health care providers in NICU (Mancini,
2011). Counselling relieves anxiety with regards on proper communication with families
towards giving pain- relief medication for infant that is dying (Peng et al, 2012). There are
three components of palliative care namely “pain and comport management”, “assistance
with end-of-life”, “decision making”, and “bereavement support” (Romesberg, 2007). Health
care professionals must have the evidence base knowledge in order to provide the excellent
Decisions of End-Of-Life care (EOL) is severely stressful to all involve in the care (Kain, 2013).
While Moro et al, (2006) describes EOL care as part of palliative care focussing on the
management of the end stages of the medical condition in preparation for death, the National
Institute of Health (NIH, 2011) states that EOL care as one aspect of palliative care, is
beneficial in assisting a peaceful and dignified death to the infant and gives moral support to
the family and health care professionals. For the parents, it is a means of series of actions that
(Eden & Callister, 2010). Implementing and providing comprehensive EOL care for dying
recommended by Callister (2012), when the decision to discontinue life support is made,
proper guidance through the process of EOL care is vital, resulting to healthy grieving does
minimizing regrets. In addition, it is significant that all discussions with parents about care
6
2.3 Introducing End-of-Life-Care to Parents
Consistent and clear communication is an ongoing process throughout the End-of-Life care
(EOL) with parents. As stated by Black (2011) one of the most terrifying aspects of health care
providers is giving information that is traumatic and distressful to parents. Most of infant’s
death happened after parents agreed in decision to EOL and limit sustaining life intervention
making decision, in order to give full support to parents. Catlin (2002) declares that
introducing EOL care to parent is a very hard task. The early management of transition from
curative to EOL care is rendered to a family of a dying infant, despite of the diagnosis and
extend survival. The neonatal conditions that most often require EOL care includes extreme
prematurity, congenital anomalies, and some cases where continuing and aggressive care are
none beneficial and poor outcome of the infant’s condition. Discussing EOL care to parents
must always be reassured, that the health care team will continue to give the best care for
their infant (Reid et al, 2011). Significantly, health care team must give information to parents
on the way that they can easily understand. Give parents time and privacy to understand the
situation (BAPM, 2013). Some parents’ wishes to include extended family members in the
conference meeting, and should be encouraged to give more support and may help them to
remember the information given (Kavanagh et al, 2005). Health care team must give time to
family members to ask question, avoid words such as “withdrawal of treatment” and
“withdrawal of support”. Health care team must emphasize that their infant will be continued
to be cared by skilful health providers, will monitor closely to prevent pain, and will be treated
well (Ward, 2005). The conference meeting should be in private and quiet place, must be
7
2.4 End-OF-Life Care Decision Making
A collapse of an infant and is dying closely is difficult and most complicated situation occurs
in Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU). Parents will be terrified, occasion like this cause a
sudden feeling of anxiety to health care providers as well, they wish to be honest and as open
as possibly with parents, but sometimes the health care providers available information is
limited. In this situation, health care providers must show clarity, simplicity, and empathy.
Reassured parents to know the cause of sudden deterioration of their infant, and encourage
them to be a part of the team, while closely monitoring the infants condition. It is paramount
to fulfil all the reassurance given to parents (McHaffie et al, 2001). Although the sudden
deterioration of infant shows dilemmas ethically. It is vital for the Health care providers to
give full support not only to the infant but also to the parents. This support includes conveying
accurate information with parents thus, ensuring them that their infant short progress will be
possibly pain free and not distressful. Consequently because of the sudden events that made
parents to decide EOL to their infant, they may express their grief and terror by pointing anger
to some health care providers, this is normal (Schott et al, 2007), but this can be prevented if
health care providers have the chance to build a close relationship between parents and
family members and gained their trust (Eden & Callister, 2010). Health care professionals
must reassure parents that they are working as a team, and should listen to whatever parents
may say, stay with them no matter how stressful the situation will be. Furthermore, Health
care providers should be aware of all the legal and ethical issues they are facing. (Reid et al,
2011). There are few factors that will help parents accept the decision to move towards EOL
care such as “the brain-dead child”, “the permanent vegetative state”, the no-chance
8
Paediatrics and Child Health (RCPCH, 2004). The opinion of parents is being sought frequently
as primary decision makers for their infant. Parents desire to avoid responsibility for the death
of their child can be devastating because for parents to be confronted with the prospect of
imminent death of their infant is a time of critical decision making (Paris et al, 2006). In
contrary, some health professionals such as physicians and nurses believed that the final
decision to withdraw support may be too difficult and burdensome and should not be a
parental decision alone. Nonetheless The decision to withdraw life support should be made
by the parents in collaboration with the health care team, chaplain, bereavement specialist,
social workers, family, and close friends (Moro et al, 2011). As stated by Eden & Callister
(2010), decisions are based on the future quality of life, severity of handicaps and projection
of longevity. McHaffie et al, (2001), recommended that the Institute of Medical Ethics
research has recognized that the actual decision is made by the medical team with or without
the parents. Nurses role are special in facilitating ethical decision-making in NICU, by acting
as an advocate for the best interest of the patients and family (Monteresso et al, 2005).
Documentation of the information given by the family and the treatment options, measures
Health care providers must have a good understanding of the responses to loss and grief, to
support effectively the parents and family members during the traumatic time (Buglas, 2010).
Rosenbaum et al, (2011) acknowledge grief as a normal, dynamic, individual, familial healthy
and expected reaction to loss. This grieving process occurs when parents is informed
regarding their infants’ condition, diagnosis, and implication in the future, emotions of
parents might be devastated and response to grief intensely (Lalor et al, 2009). In addition to
9
this, Parents may experience negative feeling such a sadness, shock, guilt, despair, anxiety,
and anger (Fonseca et al, 2011). Consequently, studies result showed some differences
significantly in the process of grieving between fathers and mothers (Locock & Alexander,
2006). On the time of bereavement, father shows more concern and protective about the
mother, they’re trying to be positive and contain their emotions, while mothers normally are
showing grief intensely, and very often to their feelings (Doherty et al, 2009). As stated by
Buglas (2010), grief is a common human response to separation, bereavement, loss specially
of a love one. Bereavement and mourning are two terms that are interchangeably used with
grief. Dyer (2005), described mourning as the process by which the people adjust to loss,
trying to absorb the loss to their lives and move on. Buglas (2010) define bereavement as the
step that follows loss during which mourning and grief occurs. A person who grieves may
experience and suffered from depression or different medical ailments that affects health and
wellbeing (Dyer, 2005). Studies shows different kind of grief Dyer (2005), says “Anticipatory
Grief” as the response that materializes in anticipation of imminent loss, help parents
avoiding the extensive fear of death, preparing emotionally for the worst possible outcome.
“Disenfranchised Grief” a state when person experience loss that cannot be openly
acknowledge, publicly mourned and socially supported (Doka, 2002). “Incongruent Grief”
refers to gender differences in how perinatal loss is experience by the mother and father
condition of grief where death cannot be desegregated into the client’s life, and because of
the intense grief, pre-loss state cannot be achieved. Professional health care providers should
be familiarized and must recognized the types of grief that parents are undergoing.
10
3. NURSING CARE OF THE DYING INFANT AND THEIR FAMILY
Health care providers should concentrate on giving support to the parents at the time of their
infant pre-death care. Giving privacy to parents is the first and most important role of health
care providers. A private room must be allocated to parents, wherein some family members,
close friends may come and visit, light should be dim and decrease activity and noise, assured
that they are not disturbed. Open and clear communication with parents is vital, it gives
parents knowledge and helps understand the condition of their infants. Active listening to
parents, total presence, and non-verbal gestures such as touch and hugs can be a successful
way of communication by referring names to the infant. Nevertheless, parents suffering from
the death of their infant should be guided about the preparation of death. This includes giving
detailed instruction to parents that allows them to be prepared of what is about to happen,
and will decide to respond with the plan, be honest and sincere in explaining the plan. Give
parents and family members time to ask question, and stayed with them if needed (Catlin et
al, 2002). Encourage visits of siblings and other family members, accommodate them into the
dying process (Moura et al, 2011). Photographs of the infant with siblings maybe taken.
Parents will appreciate that importance is being entrusted to both the infant and mother
when health care providers allow the siblings to stay longer (Kavanagh et al, 2010). Support
no visiting hours to parents. Assessing the family’s religious, spiritual, and cultural beliefs is
vital (Rosenbaum, 2011). It is important to ask the family’s preference concerning baptism, or
other religious ceremonies. Informed the Medical Institution chaplain a head of time, and
may contact family’s spiritual advisor if needed (Catlin et al, 2002). The chaplain is one of the
11
important member of the health care team, responsible for giving assistance to families
during spiritual and religious distress, by alleviating them and improve towards positive
religious and spiritual coping adaptation (Rosenbaum et al, 2011). Health care providers must
be aware of the different cultural practices of each religion, parent’s cultural beliefs must not
be neglected and should be respected (Gatrad & Sheikh, 2002). Infants cannot feed
themselves, however adequate nutrition and hydration by mouth can be offered for those
who can tolerate and achieve basic human needs (Dickema & Batkin, 2009). Oral care should
be maintained, keeping the mouth and lips moist and oral sucrose may be in great help to
provide comport (Catlin & Carter, 2002). Furthermore, the breast feeding maybe offered if
desired by mother and infant. However, the general wellbeing of the mother should not be
ignored, thereby advice on suppression of lactation not as well as the comfort measures to
prevent and treat breast engorgement (Gale & Brook, 2006). It is vital that the breast feeding
and the lactation consultant should be informed and take an important part assisting and
teaching the mother. Health care team should give opportunities to parents and be aware
that this is the starting of grieving stages, give them time to bond and support them for any
loving memories they may wish, while their infant still alive.
Care during active dying is the most challenging moments for both parents, family members
and health care providers. Parents should be told of what might they see, smell, hear and feel
(Catlin & Carter, 2002). Compassionately health care providers should identify some physical
changes that might occur, it is mandatory to check the heart beat occasionally of the dying
pharmacological measures to minimize or prevent pain and discomfort of the dying infant
12
must be provided (Moura et al, 2011). Noise must be minimized, such as lowering the volume
of phone ring tone and pagers, staff conversation must be on a low voice, quiet environment
should be maintained (Catlin & Carter, 2002). Parents should be encouraged to get involve
with the caregiving to their dying infant. Allow them to bath and clothes the infant as they
desired, kangaroo care can be done (Feeley et al, 2013). They should also be informed that
their infant might passed away while they are giving cares. Health care providers must have
assured to give their best to support the families. Diminishing the pain in time of life of dying
infant is vital (Lisle & Pudruchny, 2009). Infants are more vulnerable therefore is very sensitive
to pain, compared to children of old age, pain reliever such as opiates are used to alleviate
pain, but must take consideration that it can also hasten death (Mathew & O’Conner Von,
2008). However, the minimizing & controlling of pain must be prioritized and should be
discussed as more often (Larcher, 2013). Intravenous line must remain intact and patent in
order to administer opiates medication (Reid et al, 2011) thus a critically ill infant will then
benefit from dying pain-free, and embraced by the loving parents when death is imminent.
Health care providers should not propose false hope to families (Rosenbaum et al, 2011).
Nurse is responsible for the switching off the alarms on ventilator before endotracheal tube
will be removed. Turning off the ventilator is more of the neonatologist responsibility to avoid
distress and lessen agony of parents. Additionally, parents must also be informed that in some
cases following ventilator withdrawal may result in gasping, agitation, tachypnoea, stridor,
recession, and possibly the death of their infant (Harvey et al, 2008). For some reasons
parents may not be around when their infant is dying. It is vital that one of the health care
providers should take responsibility to hold and embrace the dying infant, and must be
properly documented to reassured parents that their infant was not alone on time of death
13
3.3 After Death Care
When an infant die, health care providers can face different kinds of challenges. Mothers
extensive fear is about that their infant might be forgotten. Parents need psychological,
cultural, and spiritual support (Moura et al, 2011). Making memories that last is an intrinsic
healing to the families. The time they spent on the last few moments of infant’s life is
loving infant to their loving hands, for some parents this is the only time and opportunity to
hold their infant. Although they might not know what to do and what questions to be asked,
a proper guidance from the healthcare providers is what they need most. Allow the families
to stay with the infant if they desire and a complimentary snack or beverages must be offered
(Romesberg, 2004). Parents might not be sure if siblings should be involved, they may have
the feeling that they are too sensitive and very young to deal with death. Making memories
consent from parents prior to any action (Warrick et al, 2011). It is necessary for a healthcare
provider to assist parents, save the memory box collection, such as photographs, locks of hair,
foot and handprints, Hospital tags, small toys, and some touchable reminders that gives
evidence of the infants’ presence (Woodroffe, 2013). Mementos are essential and needed,
because parents can only bring this with them, and not the baby they were expecting
(Branchet et al, 2012). Sensitive and complicated topics such as organ donation, post mortem
is considered to give discomfort to parents, these details must be given in writing (Woodroffe,
2013). Burial and memorial service must be accommodated. Participation of the hospitals
chaplain, bereavement specialist, and social welfare would be of good assistance to parents
14
as well as to health care providers. Necessary documentation and paper work must be
completed by the health care providers, reassured that all relevant personnel were informed
and all the necessary task per hospital policy are completed. Continued care of the family
following the infants’ death is vital, as support accustomed by the medical institution (Gibson
et al, 2011). In writers’ medical institution a memorial service headed by the hospital chaplain
with the participation of the bereavement specialist is being held once a year. To give support
to the families honour and remember all infants who rest in peace. Refreshment will be
served after the ceremony for the get together of families and healthcare workers, sharing
Health care providers spend more time with the family and infants thereby developing
trusting relationship and enhanced empathy. Compassionate care is essential for the infant
and family during this journey. Health care providers must concentrate on supporting parents
as they struggle to make meaning of their infants’ death. Health care providers are also
grieving when taking care of an infant who have collapsed and died, but the grief felt by them
are sometimes neglected (Simpson et al, 2013). Ethical affection and anxiety is experienced
by the healthcare provider when aggressive care is not resulting to cure, and conflicts within
infants’ family, and uncertain decision, to withdrawal of care (Hansen et al, 2009). It can be a
crucial problem, if it affects health care providers job fulfilment, self-image, and psychological
well-being. The importance of formal debriefing of healthcare providers are necessary most
especially when life support to infant has been withdrawn (Larcher et al, 2015). Case review
meetings and critical incidents should be scheduled for discussion and reflection among
members of health care team following death incidents (Reid et al, 2011). This meeting will
15
give knowledge and will be aware if health care team members will need supplementary
to health care providers to support them. Health care providers who have more experience
and education related to EOL care are more proficient and comfortable in rendering this care.
A proper and accurate documentation by the health care provider is vital. The health care
team must ensure that right timing of incident must be recorded and correspond with the
timing of doctors and nurses note for ethical purpose. Debriefing before end-of-life care must
not be neglected, they must find times to make this happen, to update health care members
for the plan of care so they will be aware of the outcome, to lessen the feeling of anxiety of
each member of the team. Though bearing witness to a family’s pain and grief, health care
providers are also grieving and should be considered regardless of expertise and experience.
Support to each health care team must be emphasized. Effective cooperation and mutual
respect between the interdisciplinary team is the optimal model of effective communication.
The observation and insight of others may offer a worthwhile perspective in this difficult
situation (Reid et al, 2011). Building trust to parents is vital and will lead to a good outcome
of transitioning from curative to end-of-life care. Finally, by providing a constant and tender
loving end-of-life care to a dying infant in NICU, families will surely remember health care
team members up to the simplest thing they rendered to their beloved infant and memories
16
References
American Paediatrics, Committee on Bioethics & Committee on Hospital Care (2000) Palliative
Black B.P. (2011) Truth telling and severe foetal diagnosis: a virtue ethics perspective. Journal
BLISS (2007) (Online) Available at: http://www.bliss.org.uk (Accessed 9th June 2013).
British Association of Perinatal Medicine (2010) Palliative Care (support and end of life care):
Buglass E. (2010) Grief and bereavement theories. Nursing Standard 24(41), 44-47.
Callister L.C. (2006) Perinatal loss: a family perspective. Journal of Perinatal & Neonatal
Capitulo K.L., (2005) Evidence for healing interventions with perinatal bereavement. Journal
Catlin A. & Carter B. (2002) State of the art: creation of a neonatal end-of-life palliative care
De Lisle-Porter M. & Podruchny A.M. (2009) The dying neonate: family-centred end-of-life
Dickema D.S. & Botkin J.R. (2009) Forgoing medically provided nutrition and hydration in
17
Discenza D. (2010) When a die: when families need you the most. Neonatal Network 29(4),
259-261.
Doherty N., McCusker C., Molloy B., Mulholland C., Rooney N, Craig B., Casey F. (2009)
Predictors of psychological functioning in mothers and fathers of infants born with severe
congenital heart disease. Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology, 27(4), 390-400.
Dyer K.A (2005) Identifying, understand, and working with grieving parents in the NICU, part
1: identifying and understanding loss and the grief response. Neonatal Network 24(3), 35-46.
Eden L.M & Callister L.C. (2010) Parent involvement in end-of-life care and decision making in
the new-born intensive care unit: an integrative review. The Journal of Perinatal Education
19(1), 29-39.
Feeley N., Sherrard K., Waitzer E. & Boisvert l. (2013) The father of the bedside: patterns of
Fonseca A., Nazare B., Canavarro M. (2011) Patterns of parental emotional reactions after a
Gale G. & Brooks A. (2006) Implementing a palliative care program in a new-born intensive
Gatrad A.R & Sheikh A. (2002) Palliative care for Muslims and issues before death.
18
Gibson J., Finney S. & Boilanger M. (2011) Developing a bereavement program in the new-
born intensive care unit. Journal of Perinatal and Neonatal Nursing 25(4), 331-341.
Hammilton B.E., Hoyert D.L., Martin J.A., Strobino D.M & Guyer B. (2013) Annual summary of
Harvey S., Sbiwdeb C., & Ekbiyrbe D. (2008) Effectiveness of bereavement interventions in
neonatal intensive care: a review of the evidence. Seminars in Foetal & Neonatal Medicine
13(5), 351-356.
Jonas-Simpson C., Pikington F.B., MacDonald C. & McMahon E. (2013) Nurses experiences of
Kain V.J. (2007) Moral distress and providing care to dying babies in neonatal nursing.
Kain V. (2011) Exploring the barriers to palliative care practice in neonatal nursing: a focus
group study. Neonatal, Paediatric and Child Health Nursing 14(1), 9-14.
Kavanaugh K., Moro T.T & Savage T.A. (2010) How nurses assist parents regarding life support
decisions for extremely premature infants. Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic, and Neonatal
Lalor J., Begley C., Galavan E. (2009) Recasting hope: A process of adaption following fetal
Larcher V. (2013) Ethical considerations in neonatal end-of-life care. Seminars in Foetal &
19
Locock L., & Alexander J. (2006) Just a bystander? Men’s place in the process of foetal
Matthews A.L & O’Conner-Von S. (2008) Administration of comfort medication at end of life
McHaffie HE., Lyon A.J & Fowlie P.W. (2001) Lingering death after treatment withdrawal in
the neonatal intensive care unit. Archives of Disease in Childhood: Foetal and Neonatal Edition
85(1), F8-F12.
Monterosso L., Krisjanson L., Sly P.D., Mulcahy M., Holland B.G., Grimwood S. & White K.
(2005) The role of the neonatal intensive care nurse in decision-making: advocacy,
11(3), 108-117.
Moro T.T., Kavanaugh K., Savage T.A., Reyes M.R., Kimura R.E., & Bhat R. (2011) Parent
decision making for life support for extremely premature infants@ from the prenatal through
Moura H., Costa V., Rodrigues M., Almeida F., Maia T. & Guimaraes H. (2011) End of life in the
National Institute of Nursing Research. Palliative cCare: The Relief You Need When You’re
Experiencing the Symptoms of Serious Illness. Bethesda, MD: US Department of Health and
Peng, N., Chen, C., Huang, L., Liu, H., Lee, M., Sheng, C., 2013. The educational needs of
neonatal nurses regarding neonatal palliative care. Nurse Educ. Today 33, 1506-1510.
20
Reid S., Bredmeyer S., van den Berg C., Cresp T., Martin T. & Miara N. (2011) Palliative care in
the neonatal nursery. Neonatal, Paediatric and Child Health Nursing 14(2), 2-8.
Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health. Withholding or withdrawing life sustaining
Romesberg T.L. (2007) Building a case for neonatal palliative care. Neonatal Network 26(2),
111-115.
Rosenbaum J.L Smith J.R & Zolfrank R. (2011) Neonatal end-of-life spiritual support care. The
Schott J, Henley A, Kohner N. Pregnancy loss and the death of a baby: guidelines for
Verhagen AA, Janvier A. The continuing importance of how neonates die. JAMA Paediatrics
2013; 167:987-8.
Ward F.R. (2005) Parents and professionals in the NICU: communication within the context of
Warrick C., Petera L., Murdoch E. & Nicholl R.M 92011) Guidance for withdrawal and
withholding of intensive care as part of neonatal end-of-life care. British medical Bulletin
98(1), 99-113.
Woodroffe I. (2013) Supporting bereaved families through neonatal death and beyond.
World Health Organization (2009) WHO definition of palliative care. (Online) Available at:
21
22