You are on page 1of 14

Transportation Injuries 15

Definitions – Those injured by accidents can be divided into three


• Transportation injuries are blunt force injuries that broad groups: pedestrians, cyclists (pedal or motor)
occur from travel on the ground, in the air and on and the drivers and passengers of vehicles.
water. The most frequent of these are motor vehicle – Pedestrians (most common), cyclists, children and
collision and pedestrian injuries. Less common cases the elderly are among the most vulnerable of road
are associated with railway accidents and aircraft users.
crashes.
• Motor vehicle collision or road traffic accident occurs Pedestrian Injuries
when a vehicle collides with another vehicle,
pedestrian, animal, road debris or other stationary Three patterns of injuries are seen (Fig. 15.1):
barrier, such as a tree or utility pole. i. Primary impact injuries
• Hit-and-run: Failure to stop at scene of accident by ii. Secondary impact injuries
the driver of a motor vehicle without giving assistance
iii. Secondary injuries
or informing the police.

Fig. 15.1: Dynamics of pedestrian injuries and sites of primary impact, secondary impact and secondary injuries
250 Fundamentals of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology

Primary Impact Injuries


Waddell's triad is a classic pattern of injury seen in
• Primary impact injuries indicate that part of the body pedestrian children who are struck by motor vehicles. It
which has been struck first by the vehicle and often comprises of fractured femoral shaft, intra-thoracic or
form recognizable patterns. intra-abdominal injuries and contralateral head injury (Fig.
15.2). Mechanism of injury is an initial impact causing
• When an adult is hit by the front of a car, the front
injury to the pelvis and femur (bumper injury) instead of
bumper or radiator usually strikes the victim at about the knees and tibias; followed by the chest and abdomen
knee level.1 The exact point of contact, whether on the (grill, fender or hood). Then the child is thrown on the
front, side or back of the leg(s), will depend on the ground and sustaining injury to the opposite side of the
orientation of the victim. head.
• They help to establish the position of the victim at the
material moment when struck and help towards On being struck from behind and feet not firmly on
identification of the offending vehicle. the ground: The victim's feet will fall backward and
Behavior of the body and disposition of injuries will be may be propelled upwards and backwards so that the
modified by factors like: head may sustain secondary impact injury by striking
• Whether both the feet were firmly placed on the against the windscreen. The victim can also be ‘scooped-
ground or one of them was raised at the time of up’ or fall to one side and may sustain head injuries by
impact. striking the ground on falling.
• Speed of the vehicle: At low speeds (e.g. 20 kph), the If the victim is struck from front, he may sustain
injuries to the chest and abdomen with fracture of ribs
victim is usually thrown off the bonnet either forwards
or vertebrae. Victim can also sustain fracture of pelvis
or to one side. Between 20 and 60 kph, the victim may
or fracture dislocation of sacroiliac joint from the impact
be tipped onto the bonnet and the head may strike the
of a mudguard and fracture of tibia and fibula of one
windscreen or the metal frame that surrounds it. At or both legs can be sustained from impact by a bumper.
higher speeds (60–100 kph), the victim may be • Bumper impacts usually cause soft tissue damage
projected into the air (‘scooped-up’); sometimes pass and comminuted wedge shaped fractures of the tibia
completely over the vehicle and avoid hitting the and fibula with forward displacement of the bony
windscreen and other points on the vehicle. fragments.2 Base of the triangular fractured fragment
• Nature of road surface: Smooth, rough, full of gravel or will suggest the site of impact and its apex will point
mud and its skidding resistance. to the direction of the moving vehicle (Fig. 15.3).
• Point of impact in relation to centre of gravity. Bumper injuries at different levels in two legs or when
When the pedestrian is knocked down from behind absent on one leg, will suggest that the victim was
with both feet fixed to the ground: There will be fracture walking or running while struck.
of the bones of the lower limbs, the buttocks and back • Bumper fracture when present, the measurement of the
of the pedestrian on being hit by head lamps or the distance from the heel to the fracture site will give an
radiator of car. It may result in fracture dislocation of the idea about the height of the bumper of the offending
lumber or thoracic spine and this injury may drive the vehicle. When brakes are applied before the accident,
femoral head through the acetabulum. the distance from heel to the fracture is less than the
• Stretch-type lacerations are frequent in the inguinal height of the bumper (presence or absence of braking
(groin) regions. may help to determine the driver’s intent).
• Where the vehicle is relatively larger than the victim– • The lack of ‘bumper injuries’ and the presence of tyre
adults impacted by a truck or a bus and children marks could indicate the pedestrian was already prone
impacted by cars—the point of contact is higher up the or supine on the road when ‘run over.’
victim and it is likely that the victim will make contact When the pedestrian walks into the side of a moving
with more of the front of the vehicle. This pattern of vehicle: He will sustain glancing abrasions or crushing
contact may be result in primary injuries to the pelvis, lacerations on the side or front of the face, chest and
abdomen, chest and head. Usually, the victim is arms. Due to primary impact injury over the elbow, there
projected along the line of travel of the vehicle, which may be fracture of ribs with/without laceration of the
may increase the risk of ‘run-over’ injuries. lungs. The victim on being struck on the side will be
Transportation Injuries 251

Fig. 15.2: Waddell’s triad Fig. 15.3: A wedge type bumper fracture of the tibia

pushed forward or to the side and will sustain secondary iv. Avulsion injury occurs when the wheel moves over a
injuries on striking the ground. fleshy part causing degloving of skin and
Fracture of the skull occurs due to direct impact of the subcutaneous tissue, by tearing it away from
vehicle on the head or when the head strikes the ground underlying tissues. It is also called 'flaying injury',
following secondary injuries. and is seen mostly in legs, arms and scalp.
v. Burning and singeing of skin and hair resulting from
Secondary Impact Injuries discharge of hot exhaust.
• These are often seen in case of 'scooped up' victim Secondary Injuries
being thrown over the bonnet, i.e. further injuries
caused by the vehicle following primary impact. He These result from body parts striking the ground
may sustain injuries by hitting his head against the following the primary impact. They are more lethal than
windscreen, its rim or side-pillars. the primary injuries, especially to the head, chest and
• Extensive abrasions, bruises and lacerations may be pelvis. When the pedestrian is thrown to the ground, he
seen. sustains abrasions (skidding brush burns are common),
• Sometimes, pedestrians are ‘run over’ if knocked down bruises or lacerations over the bony prominences, such
by the vehicle. This will tend to occur if the as elbows, knees, etc. which is most pronounced over
pedestrian’s centre of gravity is lower than the impact unclothed areas.3
site or scooped-up victim being run-over by other • Brain damage is frequent without any associated skull
vehicles. Injuries are variable, depending on the area fractures. This is due to the moving head of the victim
of the body involved, the weight of the vehicle and being suddenly stopped on impact (contre-coup injury)—
the surface area of the contact. diffuse damage to axons may be caused by the rotational
There may be: or shearing forces acting upon the brain.
i. Tyre tread marks over the unclothed or not very thickly • Fracture of the skull and ribs due to direct contact
clothed areas on one surface of the body, with graze- with a surface, and fracture of the spine due to
like abrasions on the opposite side, i.e. pavement hyperflexion or extension may be seen. Fractures of
side. the spine, especially in the cervical and thoracic
ii. The head may be crushed causing gross distortion segments may lead to cord damage.
and externalization of the brain or severe injuries • Fractures of the limbs are common but apart from
may occur to the chest, pelvis or abdomen. those of the legs (primary impact sites), they are rather
iii.Compression of the chest may result in multiple rib unpredictable because of the random movements of
fractures, causing a ‘flail chest’ with rupture of internal the limbs.
organs along with fracture of the spine, sternum and Usually, it is very difficult to classify the injuries as
ribs. primary impact, secondary impact or secondary injuries.
252 Fundamentals of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology

In pedestrian accidents, the common cause of death was made exclusively of glass. Windshields, nowadays,
is head injuries and fracture dislocations of cervical are made of a thin outer and inner layer of glass with
spine, mainly at the atlanto-occipital joint. Injuries to the thick plastic core.
chest and abdomen are minimal or absent. The driver tends to receive a different pattern of injury
as compared to either the front seat or rear seat passenger.
Injuries Sustained by Vehicle Occupants The driver may receive a momentary warning of the
impending collision and brace himself against the
• After pedestrians, the driver is the most frequent
steering wheel. Fractures of the wrists and arms may
casualty in road traffic accidents as a high proportion
thus occur, as well as fractures or dislocation of tibia,
of vehicles are occupied only by a driver. Next in
fibula and pelvis may occur from transmission of the
frequency is the front seat passenger, followed by rear
force of impact from pressing on the brake and clutch
seat passengers.
pedals.
• Ejection of both driver and passenger from a vehicle
If the driver is unaware, his knees will impact against
is associated with significantly severe injuries or
the dashboard, his chest against the steering wheel, and
fatality as the doors often burst open.
his head against the windshield. An impact of the knees
• Unbelted rear seat occupants are also at increased against the dashboard commonly causes fractures of the
risk of serious injury in motor vehicle accidents; they tibia, fibula, femur and pelvis. Severe impact against the
may be ejected or thrown forward against the front windshield pillar may cause avulsion of the skin of the
seat. forehead, basilar skull fractures, closed head injury and
• The driver and passenger injuries depend upon the fracture or dislocation of the atlanto-occipital junction.
type of impact crash. It can be: Steering wheel impact injury: The circular rim of the
i. Front impact steering wheel may cause fractures of the jaws and facial
ii. Rear impact bones, as well as imprint abrasions, minor bruises and
iii. Side impact contusions of the chest or bilateral rib fractures.
iv. Roll-over Transverse fracture of sternum is usually seen at 3rd
intercostal space. Damaged steering wheel spokes may
Front Impact Crash (Fig. 15.4) penetrate the chest and lacerate the heart and lungs.
This happens when one car strikes another car head-on Flail chest may occur.
or strikes a stationary object, like an electric pole/tree With severe thoracic compression, partial or complete
(approx. 80% of impacts). While the vehicle rapidly transection of aorta may occur usually at the junction
decelerates and stops, the occupants continue to move of the aortic arch with descending aorta— classical
forward striking against the interior of the vehicle, unless injury. Lacerations of liver and spleen may be seen.
they are restrained. If the head impacts against the Serious steering wheel injuries are less frequent, if the
windshield, the victim does not sustain severe cuts from car is fitted with energy absorbing compressible steering
the fragments of glass which used to happen when it wheel column.

A B

Fig. 15.4: Major sites of injury (black) in (A) Unrestrained driver and (B) Front seat passenger of a car
Transportation Injuries 253

Front seat passenger: The most dangerous place in the be on the right side of the driver, the right arm and leg
car is the front passenger seat. He may not get the may be fractured. Internally, fractures of ribs on the right
momentary warning of the impending collision. Without side are seen. In the abdomen, a lateral impact on the
a seat belt, he is at risk of severe impaction of his head right side commonly causes lacerations of the right lobe
against the windshield with its consequences. The of the liver and right kidney. An impact on the left
occupant may be ejected out of the vehicle through the frequently lacerates the spleen, left kidney and left lobe
windscreen, increasing the risks of secondary injuries or of the liver. The pelvis may be fractured from impact on
running over. There may be peculiar facial lacerations either side.
due to contact with the shattered windscreen known as
Roll-over Crash
‘sparrow foot marks’ (similar to dicing injuries mentioned
below).4 Contact with the dashboard may cause injuries Although the automobile may suffer severe damage in a
to the knee. roll-over crash, the occupants receive surprisingly
Passengers of the rear seat often escape such injuries moderate impact, if the vehicle is not brought to a sudden
because of the absence of impact against the windshield stop and the impact is spread over a period of time. It
and dashboard and of the cushioning effect of the front is usually less lethal than front or side impact collision.
seat. However, they may be injured against internal The crashing of different sides of the vehicle absorbs the
fittings, like door handles or ejected through burst-open forces of impact, if the passenger compartment remains
doors. intact, the belted occupants frequently survive the crash
(anything that prevents ejection of occupants). Non-
Rear Impact Crash belted occupants are involved in two types of injury:
Low velocity rear impacts are relatively common. • Tumbling around inside and striking the interior of
Usually, they cause whiplash injury. Neck fractures are the vehicle
rare. A high velocity rear impact crash can deform and • Ejection out from the vehicle.
rupture the gas tank with ignition of the fuel. There is no specific injury pattern.

Side Impact Crash Role of Seat Belts and Air Bags


The vehicle strikes on the side of another vehicle or Numerous safety features such as safety belts, airbags,
skids sideways into a fixed object. This is a common collapsible steering columns, softened interior
pattern in an intersection and is therefore a frequent dashboards and antilock brakes have contributed to the
occurrence in urban areas. saving of lives.
Injuries are often severe, because the side of a car has The air bag system has reduced the gravity and
a thin metal wall door and no other components to incidence of chest and facial trauma, especially in those
absorb the force of impact. Since the occupants of the individuals not using seat belts. These are intended to
vehicle move toward the side of impact, the persons provide protection only in frontal crashes and to be
sitting on that side run the greatest risk. used in conjunction with seat belts. Compared to 3-
Dicing injuries may occur which are superficial cuts point seat belts, air bags are significantly less effective.
of the skin caused by fragments of tempered glass Seat belts offer the greatest benefits in frontal and roll-
(designed to shatter into small glass cubes on violent over crashes. Wearing seat belts reduces the risk of
impact). They are produced when the side and the back fatalities to front seat occupants by 45%, since:
windows of a car shatter. They are linear, right angled • Injuries are of less severity, except whiplash injury.5
or V-shaped laceration seen typically on the face, forehead • Probability of severe head injury is lower.
and arm on the right side of the driver and left or right • Probability of being ejected from the vehicle is lower.
side of passengers. Fragments of tempered glass • There are fewer fatal/major injuries to head, neck,
embedded in the wound may be seen. They help to chest and abdomen.
locate the position occupied by the victim in the Lap belts can produce tears of the mesentery, omentum
automobile. and laceration of the bowel.6 Shoulder belt may produce
Cervical spine fracture, fractured ribs, contusions, a linear abrasion running downward and medially on
lacerations and explosive tearing of the lungs on the the right side of the driver and left side of front seat
side of the impact are common. External injuries tend to passenger.
254 Fundamentals of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology

Although, seat belts reduce mortality, they cause a injuries and even decapitation, which is known as
specific pattern of internal injuries. Patients with seat ‘under-running’ or `tail-gating’.*
belt marks on their body have been found to have a 4- Pedal cycle injuries are common in India, but severity is
fold increase in thoracic trauma and an 8-fold increase less due to slow speeds. Primary injuries may occur
in intra-abdominal trauma compared with those without from impact by cars and trucks, but secondary injuries
seat belt marks. involving the head and chest are common from falling.
There are three forms of automobile belt restraints: Lap A unique injury seen among bicyclists is stripping of the
belts, shoulder (diagonal) belts and three-point belts (lap skin from the leg due to limb being forced between the
plus shoulder). Lap belts were the first form of restraint wheel spokes.
used in automobiles. The most popular and efficient seat
belt is the 3-point belt which consists of both a diagonal • Motorcyclists experience a death rate 35 times greater
and transverse strap set in inertia recoil housing. than occupants of cars. Helmets reduce the risk of fatal
head injury by 1/3rd and reduce the risk of facial injury
by 2/3rd. Fractures of the lower extremities are common,
Motorcycle and Cycle Injuries occurring in approximately 40% of motorcyclists
hospitalized for non-fatal injuries.
• An accident that might result in minor injuries with
• Injuries to bicyclists: Children aged 5-14 years have the
an automobile, can result in death with a motorcycle. highest rates of injury and head injury accounts for 75%
• The common causes of motorcycle accidents are of the deaths. Helmets have been shown to reduce the
alcohol, drugs, environmental factors (bumps or risk of brain injury for bicyclists by 88%.
potholes), reckless driving and failure by drivers of • Injuries to pedestrians occur disproportionately among
cars to see the motorcycle. The most common cause of school going children, the elderly and the intoxicated.
motorcycle fatality is running off the road.
• Most injuries are due to ejection from the vehicle into Postmortem Examination
the roads, due to high speed and instability of the Photographs of the scene, clothing and injuries should
vehicle. In a high speed impact of a motorcycle, there be taken routinely. Since some countries limit the
may be primary injuries due to the initial impact, damages to be recovered if the victim was not wearing
followed by secondary injuries from striking the a seat belt, any injuries consistent with seat belt injuries
ground. Head and leg injuries are common. Primary should be noted. The role of the automobile to commit
injuries are mostly open fractures of the tibia and homicide is also postulated.
fibula. Secondary injuries are mostly fractures of the
skull, ribs and cervical spine, as well as contusions History
of the brain. There are graze abrasions due to sliding The history should include the condition of the eyes
across the road. (corneal opacities), blindness, if the victim was suffering
• Fracture of the skull: Transverse fracture of the base from any disease, e.g. heart, epilepsy or diabetes, drugs
of the skull—the hinge fracture is common, sometimes that he was using (or abusing), and if he was depressed
referred to as ‘motorcyclists fracture’.7 Temporo-parietal or under unusual stress.
fractures are also quite common. Ring fracture around
Clothing
the foramen magnum may be seen in some cases by
an impact of the crown of the head. The clothing should be described with special attention
• Passengers falling off the backs of the motorcycle will to tyre imprint marks, tears, amount of bleeding and
foreign bodies, especially glass particles, metal, grease
have lacerations of the back of the head, fractures of
marks or oil stains and paint which may indicate the
posterior cranial fossa, contrecoup contusions of
part of the vehicle that struck the victim and provide
frontal lobes of the brain and abrasions of back and
valuable evidence with respect to the suspected vehicle
elbows. If they fall forwards, there will be abrasions
(hit and run cases). Similarly, hair, blood and other
of the face.
tissues can be transferred from the pedestrian to the
• A unique injury is seen wherein the motorcyclist vehicle. For this reason, autopsy surgeon should preserve
drives under the rear of the truck, causing head hair and blood samples for comparison.
* This injury has been reduced by the presence of bars at the sides and rear of trucks to prevent both bikes and cars passing
under the vehicle.
Transportation Injuries 255

Injuries as ‘homicide’ or ‘accident’ or ‘undetermined’ depending


External injuries: It should include: on the existing protocol.
i. The nature of the wound, i.e. whether it is a bruise,
abrasion or laceration. Alcohol, Drugs and Trauma
ii. The wound dimensions, e.g. length, width and Alcohol and substance abuse are major associated
depth. It is helpful to take a photograph of the factors in all forms of trauma. About 10% of the drivers
wound with an indication of dimension (e.g. a tape with blood alcohol level higher than the legal limit
measure placed next to the wound). account for nearly 1/3rd of non-fatal and half of fatal
iii. The position of the wound in relation to fixed driver deaths. Injury to drunken pedestrians shows
anatomical landmarks, e.g. distance from the midline even greater association, as pedestrian accidents
or below the clavicle. account for nearly 3/4th of adult traffic accidents.
iv. The height of the wound from the heel (i.e. ground There is a strong association with alcohol, drug
level)—this is important in cases where pedestrians dependency and dangerous driving, violent and
have been struck by motor vehicles so that the height aggressive behavior.
of an impact point can be compared with any Drugs tested for should include alcohol, carbon
suspect vehicle.
monoxide, acid, basic and neutral drugs. Marijuana
Internal injuries: The distribution of fatal injuries is and opiates testing are indicated in select cases. Blood
mostly related to the head and chest. Due to extraordinary used for testing should be the one which has been
resilience of the skin, serious internal injuries may be drawn prior to starting of IV fluids and blood
present without any evidence of corresponding external transfusion. In case of death, analysis of vitreous fluid
injury. It is therefore necessary to incise suspected areas is valuable as it reflects the alcohol and drug levels 1-
of impact.
2 h prior to death.
Laboratory Specimens
Railway Injuries
A blood sample (of the driver or pedestrian) should be
analyzed for the presence and amount of alcohol (taken These are common in India and China because of a
from peripheral vein and not from heart or viscera, if wide network and unprotected crossings. It is a common
death occurred within 12-24 h of accident) and drugs, mode of suicide, but accidents are common in children.
since the question of contributory negligence may There is nothing specific about railway accidents, except
subsequently arise. If sufficient blood is not obtainable, the frequency of severe mutilation. The body may be
vitreous fluid from the eye can be analyzed for alcohol. severed into many pieces and soiled by axle grease and
The urine should be screened for commonly abused dirt from the wheels and track. When passengers fall off
drugs. from the train, multiple injuries along with abrasions
are seen due to contact with coarse gravel along the line
Whether the victim was the driver or a passenger?
Sometimes, it is necessary to know who was driving the
ballast.
vehicle for insurance purpose. Following can assist the Suiciders either jump in front of a moving train from
autopsy surgeon in determining if a particular occupant a platform, bridge or other structure near to the track, or
was the driver: place their head across a rail causing transected neck,
• Steering wheel impact abrasions may be seen on the either partial or complete with black soiling at the crushed
chest.
decapitation or amputation site. There may be ‘flail chest’
• Dicing injuries on the right side of the body.
• Patterned seat belt abrasion is seen on the right side of along with traumatic asphyxia when the victim is
shoulder going diagonally across the chest to the left. crushed between the buffers of two bogies.
• Imprint marks of the brake and clutch pedals on the Furthermore, a careful search for unusual injuries
soles of shoe if pressed at the time of impact (patterns (stabs, gunshots) and for vital reaction to the severe
on the accelerator and brake pedals are purposefully
blunt force injuries should be made, as there many
different from one another).
occasions when the victim of a homicide has been placed
In different jurisdictions, autopsy surgeons may rule onto the rail track in an attempt to make it appear like
the manner of death in hit-and-run pedestrian fatalities an accident.
256 Fundamentals of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology

MULTIPLE CHOICE QUESTIONS

1. Primary impact injury (1°) most commonly seen in: C. Steering wheel impact
AIIMS 07; AI 10 D. Wind screen impact
A. Head B. Thorax 5. In a motor vehicle accidents, the seat belt leads to
C. Legs D. Abdomen following, except: UPSC 04
A. Reduced incidence of severe thoracic injury
2. Bumper fracture is: Rohtak 06
B. Occurrence of small intestine and mesenteric
A. Primary impact injury injury
B. Secondary impact injury C. Increased severity of decelerating head injury
C. Tertiary impact injury D. Trauma to major intra-abdominal vessels
D. Secondary injury 6. When a seat belt is worn, if an accident occurs, sudden
3. Extensive abrasions are found on the body of a deceleration can result in:
pedestrian. The cause is: AI 09 UP 05; CMC (Ludhiana) 10
A. Primary impact injury A. Rupture of mesentery
B. Secondary impact injury B. Liver injury
C. Spleen injury
C. Secondary injury
D. Vertebral injury
D. Postmortem artifact
7. Motor cyclists fracture is: WB 09; AIIMS 10
4. Sparrow foot marks are associated with which type of A. Ring fracture
injury: Orissa 11; AI 11 B. Comminuted fracture of the vault
A. Motor cyclist’s fracture C. Skull base divided into two halves
B. Under-running or tail gating D. Gutter fracture

1. C 2. A 3. C 4. D 5. D 6. A 7. C
Explosion Injuries and
Fall from Height 16
Explosion Injuries
Definitions
• Bomb is a container filled with an explosive mixture
and missiles which is fired either by detonator or a
fuse.
– Incendiary bombs, e.g. napalm bombs primarily
cause burns. Usually phosphorus and magnesium
are added. Temperature of 1000ºC is produced.
– Molotov cocktail is an incendiary bomb which is
thrown by hand. In its crude form, a bottle is
filled with gasoline and a rag to serve as a wick. Fig. 16.1: Pressure changes occurring in bomb explosion
The wick is lit and thrown at the target.1
• Blast injury is a complex type of physical trauma • The mass movement of air (blast wind) disrupts the
resulting from direct or indirect exposure to an environment, throwing debris and people. This
explosion. phenomenon results in injuries ranging from
traumatic amputation to disruption.
Mechanism of Action • When the body is impacted by a blast pressure wave,
it couples into the body and sets up a series of stress
The explosive pressure that accompanies the bursting waves which are capable of injury, particularly at
of bombs or shells, ruptures their casing and imparts a air-fluid interfaces. Thus, injury to the ear, lungs,
high velocity to the resulting fragments. These heart and the GIT is notable.
fragments have the potential to cause more devastating
injury to tissues than bullets. Classification of explosives (based on material used)
In addition, all explosives are accompanied by a i. High-order explosives (HEs) undergo detonation
complex wave. The two main components of this wave producing an instantaneous blast wave under
are a blast wave (known as dynamic overpressure) with extremely high pressure causing severe primary blast
a positive and negative phase, and the blast wind (mass injury, e.g. TNT, dynamite, ammonium nitrate and
movement of air) (Fig. 16.1). Injuries are mainly due to C-4 ‘plastic’ explosives.
the initial shock wave, but are aggravated by the sub- ii. Low-order explosives (LEs) undergo deflagration
atmospheric phase. rather than detonation and thus lacking in blast
• The positive pressure phase of the blast wave lasts wave—uncommonly to cause the pulmonary and
a few milliseconds, but close to an explosion it may central nervous system injuries unique to primary
rise to over 7000 kN/m2. As the tympanic membrane blast injury. They are composed of propellants, such
ruptures at about 150 kN/m2, the effects on the as black powder and pyrotechnics, such as fireworks
human body of such an explosion can be devastating. and oil- or petroleum based explosives such as
Like sound waves, the blast pressure waves flow Molotov cocktails.
around an obstruction and affect anyone sheltering
Classification of Injuries (Fig. 16.2)
behind a wall or a trench. Also, any person standing
in front of a wall or any surface facing an explosion Blast injuries are divided into four categories: primary,
is subjected to the added effect of a reflected pressure. secondary, tertiary and quaternary.
258 Fundamentals of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology

i. Primary: Primary injuries are caused by blast Although the colon is most commonly affected,
waves and characterized by the absence of external perforation of the stomach, small intestine and
injuries. They are usually internal injuries which caecum are also seen.
are often unrecognized and their severity • Brain: It can cause concussion or mild traumatic
underestimated. The ears are most often affected brain injury without a direct blow to the head.
by the overpressure, followed by the lungs and There may be headache, fatigue, poor
the hollow organs of the gastrointestinal tract concentration, lethargy, depression, anxiety,
(GIT).2 GIT injuries may present after a delay of insomnia or other constitutional symptoms.
hours or even days. Primary blast injuries are: ii. Secondary injuries are due people being injured
• Acoustic barotrauma commonly consists of rupture by shrapnel and other objects propelled by the
of the tympanic membrane, dislocation of the explosion. These injuries may affect any part of
ossicles or widespread disruption of the inner ear the body and sometimes result in penetrating
leading to permanent deafness. trauma. Most casualties are caused by secondary
• Lungs: Considerable disruption at the alveolar- injuries. Some explosives, such as nail bombs, are
capillary membrane (air-fluid interface) leads to purposely designed to increase the likelihood of
capillary leakage, resulting in extensive hemorr- secondary injuries.
hage of both lobes of lung. There is pulmonary • Penetrating thoracic trauma, including lacerations
contusion, systemic air embolism and free radical- of the heart and great vessels is a common cause
associated injuries such as thrombosis and DIC or of death.
a combination of all these—blast lung. ARDS may iii. Tertiary injuries: These are the injuries resulting
be a result of direct lung injury or of shock from from blast wind that can throw victims against
other body injuries. solid objects. Tertiary injuries may present as some
– Blast lung is the most common cause of death combination of blunt and penetrating trauma,
among people who initially survive an explosion. including bone fractures and coup contre-coup
– Clinically characterized by the triad of dyspnea, injuries. Children are at particular risk because of
bradycardia and hypotension and the patient their lesser weight.
may present with dyspnea, cough, hemoptysis iv. Quaternary (miscellaneous) injuries: Injuries not
or chest pain. included in the first three categories. These include
– Chest radiographs in the initial stages may show flash burns,* crush injuries, fall resulting from the
localized contusion injury, but as the time passes, explosion and respiratory injuries (toxic dust, gas)
the effect becomes generalized with bilateral or radiation exposure. Psychiatric injury (some due
fluffy infiltrates spreading out from the hilum to neurological damage sustained during the blast)
of both lungs—‘butterfly’ pattern. is most common, and post-traumatic stress disorder
• GIT: Injury to gas-filled viscera is more common (PTSD) may affect people who are otherwise
in underwater explosions than in air blasts. completely uninjured.

Fig. 16.2: Blast injuries

* When the bomb explodes, the temperature of the explosive gases can exceed 2000°C and the heat radiated momentarily
can cause flash burns
Explosion Injuries and Fall from Height 259

Sequelae of traumatic injuries: Recognizing the ‘suicide bomber’ may be difficult. The nature
• Crush syndrome and acute renal failure may occur of suicide bomber injuries is vital in locating and identifying
in patients rescued from collapsed structures. these types of offenders. The hands are examined to
• Increasing extremity pain after an explosion may determine whether he was holding the explosive.
indicate developing compartment syndrome.
iv. Enlisting the injuries. External and internal injuries
Work up are described in detail.
The most common urgent clinical problem in survivors External injuries
is usually the penetrating injury caused by blast- Total body disintegration indicates high-order
energized debris and fragments from the casing of the condensed explosive at close range.
exploding device. Many of those exposed will have • There may be mangling of body near explosion
blunt, blast and thermal injuries, in addition to more with parts of extremities amputated; craniofacial
obvious penetrating wounds (referred to as combined injuries are seen in case of suicide. Lower limb
injury). The soft-tissue wounds are heavily contaminated amputation is typical of standing or seated
with dirt, clothing and secondary missiles, such as individual. Hand injuries are seen, if explosive
wood, masonry and other materials from the device was held.
environment (flying missiles). • There may be projectile injury.
• Punctate lacerations, dust tattooing and black
Medico-legal Aspects soiling from explosive materials may be seen.
Triad of bruises, abrasions and puncture
Forensic pathologist may encounter blast injuries in both lacerations with tattooing of the body indicates
routine case work and as part of mass casualty events. bomb explosion.
Therefore, recognition, proper interpretation and • Injuries may be seen due to fallen rubble.
documentation of these types of injuries would assist • Burns (flash burns and singed hair seen on victims
with reconstruction of the incident. in immediate vicinity).
i. Whether a bomb has caused the explosion? Internal injuries have been described earlier.
• Full body photographs and complete X-rays of the v. Cause of death: Death may result from variety of
whole body are indicated before the clothes are causes, viz. complete disintegration of body, blast
removed. Any radiopaque fragments and radiolucent shock, burns, blunt force injuries and crush asphyxia.
material (paper fragments, wood and plastic) may vi. Circumstances of death need to be looked for.
be components of an explosive device.
• Residues are either burnt (black or gray) or unburnt Fall from Height
(yellow, brown, gray) material. Swab the soiled skin
Introduction
and hands. Collect hair and fingernail scrapings.
• Foreign body (shrapnel or empty shell) may be found • Deaths due to fall from height are common in urban
during autopsy. settings. In occupational settings, it is the most
• Toxicological analysis may also help. common type of accident. Builders, electricians,
• Extensive burns are usually not caused by localized miners and painters are particularly at risk. It is also
bomb explosion. a major cause of personal injury, especially for the
ii. Number of dead persons: A major initial problem, children and the elderly.
correct fragments are to be allocated to the right • Factors contributing to falls from heights include
individuals. faulty equipment, such as ladders and scaffold
iii. Identification of the dead: The injuries can be structures and human factors, such as intoxication
extreme and thus make identification and inter- and inattention.
pretation difficult for the autopsy surgeon. All body The evaluation of injuries alone during autopsy is
parts and clothing are recovered (clothing is not sufficient to assess whether the manner of death is
submitted in airtight containers). suicide, accident or homicide. Findings at the scene of
• Dentition, dentures and artificial teeth also help in death and medial, psychiatric, social history and
identification. toxicology results of the victim should also be taken
• Fingerprinting may also help. into account to determine the manner of death.
260 Fundamentals of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology

Investigation of Scene characteristic (Fig. 16.4). Bruising in the perineal


• Falls or jumps from places where people normally region is sometimes misinterpreted as a sign of
do not go are highly suspicious of suicide. Suicide sexual abuse prior to the fall.
notes are also indicative of a suicidal fall. iii. Palmar skin tears and open comminuted fractures
• Dangerous work-places like building sites—most falls of the wrists and knees are common in free falls
are usually accidental. wherein the victim may have attempted to cushion
• Signs of a fight at the death scene always suggest the impact.
iv. Blunt injuries such as abrasions and hematoma at
homicide. Distance of the body from the jumping
the site of primary impact (planar impacts) are a
site can be used as an additional tool to determine
frequent finding.
the manner of death. In intentional jumps, the
v. Depending on the impact surface, the ground
distance to the jumping site is likely to be higher
texture might be reflected as patterned injuries.
than in accidental falls. vi. Palmar injuries such as abrasions (‘rope burns’),
Psychiatric history: A history of psychiatric illness is resulting from the attempt of the victim to hold on
most frequently found in suicidal falls from height to objects preventing a fall, suggest a homicidal or
which often includes depression, schizophrenia and/ an accidental fall or fresh wrist incisions (‘hesitation
or substance abuse. marks’) are indicative of a suicidal intention.
Injury Patterns Internal Examination
It is dependent on the part of the body that hits the Severe injuries of the internal organs and/or the
ground first, the height of fall, ground composition, and musculoskeletal system can be found in all fatal falls
age, clothing and body weight of the victim (Fig. 16.3). from height.
Head injuries: All types of brain hemorrhages—
External Examination subarachnoid, subdural, epidural and intracerebral, and
Examination of the clothing can provide some clues brain contusion as well as severe disruption and
about the nature of a fall from a height. In feet-first complete or partial loss of brain structures may be seen.
impacts, longitudinal tears in the loin region of trousers • In head-first impacts there is usually open
may be seen due to inguinal stretching. comminuted skull fractures with additional facial
i. Postmortem staining is sparse due to loss of blood. bone fractures and externalization of the brain over
ii. In feet-first impacts, longitudinal tears of the wide areas and rarely severe internal organ injuries.
inguinal regions may be seen. Plantar injuries with • If feet-first impact, forces transferred upward can
open fractures of the ankle joint or calcaneus are result in significant pelvic trauma, as well as a ‘ring

Fig. 16.3: Factors affecting injury patterns Fig. 16.4: Feet-first impact
Explosion Injuries and Fall from Height 261

fracture’ of the skull, as forces drive the spinal pulmonary ruptures or complete hilus rupture can
column upward into the cranial cavity (Fig. 16.4). be found. Penetrating rib fractures with associated
Brainstem injuries such as laceration, contusion or pulmonary injury are common.
transection are frequent. • Diaphragm: Diaphragm rupture is relatively rare.
• Traumatic subarachnoid hemorrhage can be seen
Abdominal Injuries
where there is no evidence of direct head trauma is
present. • Liver: Liver ruptures are more frequent in falls from
height than in other mechanism of blunt abdominal
Neck injuries: If neck injuries along with sub-
trauma. The right lobe of the liver is involved more
conjunctival hemorrhages are present, then possibility
often than the left lobe. Tears are often irregular in
of strangulation prior to the fall should be considered.
nature but have been shown to be almost parallel in
However, blunt force neck injuries directly related to
many cases.
the fall are frequent. Mild to moderate hemorrhage in
• Spleen: Multiple splenic rupture is common.
subcutaneous and muscular layers, thyroid hematoma
• GIT: Ruptures or bruises of the intestinal root are a
along with fractures of hyoid bone may be seen in
common finding in greater falling heights but
falls from > 10 meters.
traumatic ruptures of the esophagus, stomach and
Chest Injuries bowel are relatively rare—due to their compliance
Thoracic cage injures like abrasions and bruises of the and relative mobility within the abdominal cavity.
chest wall and rib fractures are found in all fatal falls. • Retroperitoneal organs: Rupture of the abdominal
Rib fractures are mostly bilateral; multiple fractures of aorta, in contrast to thoracic aortic rupture, is
the whole thoracic cage, including the sternum and relatively rare. Psoas muscle bleeding may result
thoracic spine are found when height of fall is > 25 from inguinal stretching especially in feet-first
meters. impacts. Renal injuries are seen rarely.
• Heart: Cardiac injuries are frequently seen in fatal Cause of Death
falls from height. • The majority of victims die instantaneously at the
– Pericardial tears are most common and occur in scene or within minutes, the cause of it is polytrauma,
the right posterior part of the pericardium and followed by head trauma and blood loss.
tend to be of longitudinal orientation. Endocardial • In free-fall victims who survive for few hours to days,
tears are more likely to be found in falls from head trauma is most common cause of death.
greater heights. • In victims who survive for few days, causes of death
– Complete or incomplete transmural tears of the include septicemia, multiple organ failure and
heart affect the right heart (atrial posterior wall) pulmonary embolism.
more often than the left heart. Tears of the Medico-legal aspects: The questions of medico-legal
interatrial septum are more common than importance in fatal falls concern the manner of death
interventricular septal tears. and the toxicology. The determination of manner of
– In falls from great heights, the heart can be death is quite difficult in some cases and it may remain
completely or subtotally torn off from the great ‘undetermined’ even after complete autopsy.
vessels which usually results in immediate death. • Most cases of fatal falls from height are suicidal.
• Thoracic blood vessels: Ruptures of the thoracic • Accidents may occur at work, domestic settings and
aorta are a common finding in free fall victims and during recreational sports activity.
are mostly located in the isthmus area (aortic arch). • Homicide is rare. There may be additional injuries
The frequency of aortic rupture increases with the that cannot be explained by the fall alone like defense
increase of height of fall. or offence injuries. However, injuries inflicted prior
• Lungs: Contusions of the lungs can be found in to the fall might well be masked by the impact
almost all fatal falls. With greater falling heights, injuries.
262 Fundamentals of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology

MULTIPLE CHOICE QUESTIONS

1. Molotov cocktail is: Kerala 06; Manipal 06; UP 07; Bihar 11 2. In blast injury, most common organ affected:
A. Mixture device of bomb CMC (Vellore) 07; AI 09; AIIMS 10
B. Simple petrol bomb thrown by hand A. Eardrum
C. Molotov, foreign minister of Russia died after having B. Stomach
the cocktail C. Lungs
D. Type of tank D. Liver

1. B 2. A

You might also like