Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
The atmospheric corrosion of Calabar, Cross River State environment has been investigated for 12
months using weight loss technique. The extent of pollution of the environment was also determined via
measurements of the precipitation and air quality parameters. Apart from the suspended particulate
matter (SPM) (113-630 μg/m3) and NO2 (> 0.06 ppm) values, other measured atmospheric parameters
(CO < 9.2 ppm, NH3 < 4.3 ppm and SO2 < 0.380 ppm) and precipitation parameters (pH > 5.0,
conductivity < 60 µScm-1, TDS < 41.48 mg/l, TSS < 0.05 mg/l, NO3- < 3.00 mg/l, SO42- <1.00 mg/l and
NH4+ <1.00 mg/l) indicate that the environment has received little or no detrimental influence by human
activities. The average corrosion rates for all the stations studied were below 35 μm/yr, and are due
principally to natural phenomenon (high rainfall, humidity and temperature).
P. C. Okafor, Department of Pure and Applied Chemistry, University of Calabar, P. M. B. 1115, Calabar, Nigeria
U. J. Ekpe, Department of Pure and Applied Chemistry, University of Calabar, P. M. B. 1115, Calabar, Nigeria
U. J. Ibok, Department of Pure and Applied Chemistry, University of Calabar, P. M. B. 1115, Calabar, Nigeria
B. O. Ekpo, Department of Pure and Applied Chemistry, University of Calabar, P. M. B. 1115, Calabar, Nigeria
E. E. Ebenso, Department of Pure and Applied Chemistry, University of Calabar, P. M. B. 1115, Calabar, Nigeria
C. O. Obadimu, JVO-East Area Gas Operations Platform, ExxonMobil Producing Nigeria, Qua Iboe Terminal,
P. M. B 12054, Lagos, Nigeria
10 P. C. OKAFOR, U. J. EKPE, U. J. IBOK, B. O. EKPO, E. E. EBENSO and C. O. OBADIMU
environment and corrosion cannot necessarily be River. It expands from the coast to about 150 km
directly transferred to Nigeria. inland and much of the area is under the
influence of the sea.
In the Niger Delta region of Nigeria emissions
resulting from the activities of the oil and gas The climate of Calabar Municipality is
industries and high rise in road unworthy vehicles characterized by seasonal north-south movement
as well as other environmentally unsafe activities of a zone of discontinuity which separates the
are increasing and may increase dramatically in continental air masses; that is, the wet and dry
the near future if the conventional development continental air masses. Wet continental air mass
path is followed. This is bound to increase the brings about wet season which lasts from April to
corrosivity of our atmospheric environment and October while the dry continental air mass brings
consequently aggravate its detrimental effects on about dry season which extends from December
structures. to February. November and March are
transitional months (Offiong and Edet, 1996).
This study is therefore aimed at assessing the
extent of atmospheric pollution using precipitation Calabar is an urban site and is subjected to
quality and air quality parameters and the impart normal precipitation patterns typical of urban
of these parameters on the corrosion of mild steel contaminants. Two major rivers cross the
exposed to the atmosphere in Calabar municipality: the Great Kwa and the Cross Rivers
Municipality, South – Eastern Nigeria, being a (Figure 1). The area is sandwiched between
part of the Niger Delta region of Nigeria. Akpabuyo and Odukpani Local Government
Areas. Although Calabar is in the Niger Delta
1.1 Description of study area region of Nigeria, there is no flow station and no
gas flaring in the area. The only presence of Oil
Niger Delta Company in the city is the NNPC tank farm at
The Niger Delta of Nigeria extends from the Ekorinim. However, increase in the number of
Benin River in the west of the Bonny River in the road unworthy vehicles and the associated traffic
East of the country inland (Figure 1). It is situated jams and other environmentally unsafe activities
a few kilometres from the village Aboh at a point in the city has led to an increased emission of
where the Niger forks into the Nun and gaseous pollutants in the city (Etiuma et al.,
Forcadoes Rivers. It is a low-lying region riddled 2006).
with an intricate system of nature water channels
through which the Niger finds its way into the sea Experimental
(Uwah, 2002). The Niger Delta occupies an area Weight loss determination
2
of 75,000 km which is approximately 10 % of The mild sheet used in the present work was
Nigeria’s total land space (Ekweozor, 1997). The obtained from Ejison Resources (Nigeria) Ltd.,
area is very rich in oil and gas reserves and thus Onitsha, Nigeria with the composition presented
attracts extensive human activities including oil in Table 1. Mild steel specimens of size 15 x 15
and gas exploration and exploitation. cm and thickness 0.8 mm were used. Before
weight loss measurements, all test mild steel
Calabar samples were polished using emery paper up to
Calabar lies roughly between latitude 4o and 7o 800 grits. They were degreased in absolute
North of the Equator and between longitude 8o ethanol, dried in acetone and weighed. All
and 9o30’ East of Greenwish. The area is chemicals used were Analar grade.
bordered in the East west of South by Cross
Six coupons were exposed at four different Uwanse by Mount Zion (UWANSE) as indicated
locations in Calabar City for a total of twelve in the map (Figure 1). The coupons were
months. The locations were University of Calabar exposed facing south at an angle of 30o to the
(UNICAL), West African Peoples’ Institute ground. All coupons were uniformly prepared and
(WAPI), Egerton/Johnstone (EGERTON) and exposed on the same day (June, 2005).
8o20`` 9o 00``
NIGERIA a
8o
Study area
7o
Lagos
Enugu
Benin
C ala b
6o NIGER DELTA COMPLEX a r ri ve
Warri
C ro
er
Owerri
ri v
ss r
5o
Port Authority
wa
i ve r
tK
er Excel Plastics
Port Harcourt
ea
es t u
System Metal
Gr
ue
Eket Eastern Match
ar y
4o ary Ind.
Wood industry
Flour Mill
SCALE:
Cement factory
1:50,000
Atlantic ocean 4o20``
Towns
Sampling point
4o 5o 6o 7o 8o 9o
Figure 1: Map of the Niger Delta region of Nigeria showing the study area
After six months of exposure, the coupons were where (WL) is weight loss in g, ρ is the density of
removed and cleaned. The corrosion products iron in g/cm2, A is surface area of the coupon in
were removed by scrubbing the metal surface cm2 and T is time of exposure in hours.
with a soft brush using a boiling solution of 20%
NaOH/200 g/l zinc powder. After removal of the Precipitation analysis
rust, the coupons were degreased and rinsed Rain water samples were collected monthly from
with ethanol, dried (with acetone), weighed to June 2005 to December, 2006. Samples were
determine their weight losses and replaced in the collected as direct rain water in plastic bottles,
test rack for another six month exposure. mounted on the platforms in an open space free
from any interfering matter that could
From the weight losses, the corrosion rates (CR) contaminate the rainwater. A week prior to the
were calculated using equation 1 (Jones, 1996): day of collection of samples, the plastic bottles
87600(WL) were carefully rinsed with de-ionized water.
CR = 1
ρAT
12 P. C. OKAFOR, U. J. EKPE, U. J. IBOK, B. O. EKPO, E. E. EBENSO and C. O. OBADIMU
Samples were analysed using the methods and Naeher, 2006). The average CO
described by World Meteorological Organisation concentrations obtained from UNICAL and
(WMO) operations manual for sampling and Ekorinim during the period of study are as shown
analysis techniques for chemical constituents in in Figure 2(a). For both studied area, CO
air and precipitation. The pH was determined with concentration varies from June, 2005 to July,
the aid of Mettler Toledo MP 220 pH Meter and 2006 with levels falling between 5.4 – 7.7 ppm for
the conductivity with HANNA H18733 UNICAL and 7.5 – 9.2 ppm for Ekorinim. The
conductivity meter. The nutrients; nitrate (NO3-), difference is probably due to the relatively heavy
sulphate (SO42-), and ammonium (NH4+) ions traffic in Ekorinin area. However, the levels
concentrations were determined using HACH obtained falls below the guidelines of ambient air
3000 DREL UV spectrophotometer. pollutants establish by WHO (2001) (which is 26
ppm at averaging time of 1 hour and 8.7 ppm at
Atmospheric quality assessment averaging time of 8 hours) and thus may not
For the atmospheric assessments, suspended make any significant contribution to metallic
particulate matter (SPM), carbon monoxide (CO), corrosion.
sulphur dioxide (SO2), ammonia (NH3) and
nitrogen dioxide (NO2) gasses were determined. Nitrogen compounds
High volume air sampler (General Metal Works The average concentration of nitrogen dioxide
and Staplex samplers) with a constant flow rate (NO2) in UNICAL was between 0.260 to 0.329
ranging from 1.1 to 1.7 m3/min. was used for ppm and Ekorinim 0.200 to 0.521 ppm (see
measuring the suspended particulate matter Figure 2(b)) and falls within data already
(SPM) within 6 hour duration. Ambient air was published for Calabar metropolis but quite high
drawn through a Gelman quartz micro fibre filters when compared with the limits set by the
(20 x 25 cm) of known weight which had been Nigerian Federal Ministry of Environment for NO2
annealed for 8 hours at 500oC to remove which is 0.06 ppm (Etiuma et al., 2006). This is
potential background contaminants. After the 6 most likely due to high traffic density and
hours collection period, the sample filter was stationery fuel combustion process emissions
collected. Re-weighing of the filter after sampling from running of generators and domestic
under controlled condition gave a direct purposes like cooking (Etiuma et al., 2006) and
measurement of particulate matter. The burning of bushes.
concentration of the particulate was determined
by dividing the mass of the SPM by the volume of The average values of ammonia (NH3) in the
air sampled. The CROWCON GASMAN portable atmospheres at the studied locations are
CO, SO2, NH3 and NO2 monitors were used for between 1.000 and 4.300 ppm for UNICAL and
measuring the values of CO, SO2, NH3 and NO2 0.869 and 3.900 ppm for Ekorinim as depicted in
gasses, respectively, in the atmosphere during Figure 2 (c). NH3 sources in the atmosphere are
the period of study. animal waste, ammonification of humus followed
by emission from soils, loss of NH3-based
Meteorological data fertilizers from soils, and industrial emission. The
Meteorological data were collected from the values of NH3 are quite below the FEPA (1991)
Metrological Unit of the Margaret Ekpo maximum limit and may not make any significant
International Airport, Calabar. contribution to the metallic corrosion of mild steel.
cooking. The values obtained were less than 0.5 Naeher, 2006). Data obtained from Calabar City
ppm and may result only in a weak attack on show that the average SPM are similar for both
metal surfaces (Oesch and Faller, 1997). UNICAL and Ekorinim as shown in Figure 2 (e).
However, the values vary from season to season.
Suspended particulate matter The highest being between January to June,
3 3
Airborne particulate matter refers to particles or 2006 (630 μg/m for Ekorinim and 636 μg/m for
droplets of various sizes, physical characteristics UNICAL) which is the peak of the dry season
and chemical compositions present in the air which is associated with dust. Other values
(Han and Naeher, 2006). Their anthropogenic obtained are 329 and 325 μg/m3 for Ekorinim and
sources include but are not restricted to traffic, UNICAL, and 113 μg/m3 and 115 μg/m3 for
industries, commerce and domestic heating and Ekorinim and UNICAL in the months of June to
cooking (Han and Naeher, 2006). In highly December, 2005 and July to November, 2006,
industrialized countries, more than 50 % of the respectively. Apart from the July to November,
total emissions of particulate mater in the urban 2006 values, the average SPM values were
areas are from traffic generated emissions above FEPA (1991) limit of 250 μg/m3.
(Laden et al., 2000; Wrobel et al., 2000; Han and
14 P. C. OKAFOR, U. J. EKPE, U. J. IBOK, B. O. EKPO, E. E. EBENSO and C. O. OBADIMU
10
(a) (b)
0.6
C O c o n c e n tr a ti o n / (p p m ) 9
N O 2 c o n c e n tr a ti o n / (p p m )
8 0.5
7
0.4
6
UNICAL UNICAL
5 0.3
EKORINIM EKORINIM
4
3 0.2
2
0.1
1
0 0
June to December, Jan. to June, 2006 July to November, June to December, Jan. to June, 2006 July to November,
2005 2006 2005 2006
Period Period
S O 2 c o n c e n tr a ti o n / (p p m )
N H 3 c o n c e n tr a ti o n / (p p m )
4 0.35
3.5 0.3
3
UNICAL 0.25 UNICAL
2.5
EKORINIM 0.2 EKORINIM
2
1.5 0.15
1 0.1
0.5 0.05
0 0
June to December, Jan. to June, 2006 July to November, June to Jan. to June, 2006 July to November,
2005 2006 December, 2005 2006
Period Period
0.7 (e)
S P M c o n c e n tra tio n /(m g /m 3 )
0.6
0.5
0.4 UNICAL
0.3 EKORINIM
0.2
0.1
0
June to December, Jan. to June, 2006 July to November,
2005 2006
Period
Figure 2: Average atmospheric concentrations of (a) CO, (b) NO2, (c) NH3, (d) SO2 and (e) SPM in
UNICAL and EKORINIM (near WAPI) in Calabar from June to November
ATMOSPHERIC CORROSION OF MILD STEEL IN THE NIGER DELTA REGION OF NIGERIA 15
40
June 2005 to Dec., 2005
35 Dec., 2005 to June, 2006
/yr)
30
Corrosionrate/(µm
25
20
15
10
5
0
UNICAL WAPI EGERTON UWANSE
Locations
Figure 3: Average corrosion rate for mild steel exposed in Calabar from June 2005 to June 2006
Table 3: Average meteorological date for Calabar from June to December 2006
Periods
Parameters
June to Dec., 2005 Jan. to June, 2006 July to Dec., 2006
Maximum
29.2 31.42 29.48
temperature/(oC)
Total rainfall/(mm) 406.03 173.77 259.02
Relative humidity/(%) 89.14 85.33 87.17
`
This interference leads to acceleration in Chen, Z. Y., Zakipour, S., Persson, D. and
corrosion rates. However, the corrosion rates for Leygraf, C., 2004. Effect of sodium chloride
all the stations fall within the excellent relative particles on the atmospheric corrosion of
corrosion resistance range (Jones, 1996) and pure copper. Corrosion, 60(5): 479-491.
thus the atmosphere can be considered not to be
corrosive to mild steel. Dunn, D. S., Bogart, M. B., Brossia, C. S. and
Cragnolino, G. A., 2000. Corrosion of iron under
CONCLUSIONS alternating wet and dry conditions.
Corrosion, 56(5): 470 – 481.
The measured atmospheric and precipitation
parameters indicate that Calabar, Cross River Ekweozor, C. M., 1997. Niger Delta Basin: From
State, Nigeria environment has received little or where is all that Oil and Gas? (University
no detrimental influence by human activities and of Ibadan Postgraduate School
thus can be used as a control environment for Interdisciplinary Research Discuss).
atmospheric studies. Ibadan: University of Ibadan.
18 P. C. OKAFOR, U. J. EKPE, U. J. IBOK, B. O. EKPO, E. E. EBENSO and C. O. OBADIMU
Etiuma, R. A., Uwah, I. E. and Etiuma, A. U., Oesch, S. and Faller, M., 1997. Environmental
2006. Level of nitrogen dioxide (NO2) in Calabar effects on materials: The effect of the air
City, Nigeria and health implications. pollutions SO2, NO2, NO, and O3 on the
International Journal of Chemistry, 16(4); corrosion of copper, zinc and aluminium.
229 – 233. A short literature survey and results of
laboratory exposures. Corrosion Science,
Feliu, S., Morcillo, M. and Chico, B., 1999. Effect 39(9): 1505-1530.
of distance from sea on atmospheric
corrosion rate. Corrosion, 55(9): 883 – Phipps, P. B. P. and Rice, D.W., 1979. The Role
891. of Water in Atmospheric Corrosion, in
Brubaber, G. R. and Phipps, P.B.P.
FEPA, 1991. National Interim Guideline and (Eds.) Corrosion Chemistry, American
Standards for Industrial Effluents, Chemical Society Series 89. Washington,
Gaseous Emissions and Hazardous DC: American Chemical Society.
Wastes Management in Nigeria. Abuja:
FEPA Seinfeld, J. H., 1986. Atmospheric Chemistry and
Physics of Air Pollution. New York: John
Han, X. and Naeher, L. P., 2006. A review of Wiley & Sons
traffic-related air pollution exposure
assessment studies in the developing Tidblad, J., Kucera, V., Samie, F., Das, S. N.,
world. Environmental International, 32, Bhamornsut, C., Peng, L. C., So, K. L. Dawei, Z.,
106 – 120. Lien, L. T. H., Schollenberger, H., Lungu, C. V.
and David Simbi, D., 2005. Corrosion impacts of
Hou, W. and Liang, C., 1999. Eight years air pollution in developing countries.
atmospheric corrosion exposure of steels
in China. Corrosion, 55(1), 65 – 73. Townsend, H. E., 2001. Effects of alloying
elements on the corrosion of steel in
Jones, D. A., 1996. Principle and Prevention of industrial atmospheres. Corrosion, 57(6),
Corrosion. New Jersey: Prentice Hall. 497 – 501.
Knotkova, D., 2005. Atmospheric Corrosion – Uwah, I. E., 2002. Physico-chemical Studies of
Research, Testing and Standardization. Rain and Surface Water and Sediments
Corrosion, 61(8): 723 – 738. in some Selected Oil Producing Towns in
South – Eastern Nigeria. Ph.D. Thesis.
Laden, F. Neas, L. M., Dockery, D. W. and Department of Pure and Applied
Schwartz, J., 2000. Association of fine particulate Chemistry, University of Calabar,
matter from different sources with daily Calabar – Nigeria.
mortality in six US cities. Environ Health
Perspect, 108: 941 – 947. Wang, J. H., Wei, F. I. and Shih, H. C., 1996.
Modelling of atmospheric corrosion
Leygraf, C. and Graedel, T. E., 2000. behaviour of weathering steel in sulphur
Atmospheric Corrosion. Pennington, New dioxide-polluted atmospheres. Corrosion,
Jersey: The Electrochemical Society. 52(12): 900 – 909.
Matthes, S. A., Holcomb, G. R., Cramer, S. D., WHO, 2001. Guidelines for Air Quality. Geneva:
Covino, B. S. and Bullard, S. J., 2004. WHO.
Atmospheric corrosion and chloride
deposition to metal surfaces. Wrobel, A., Rokita, E. and Maenhaut, W., 2000.
Proceedings of CORROSION/2004, Transport of traffic-related aerosols in
Paper Number 04306. Houston: NACE urban areas. Science Total Environment,
International 257: 199 – 211.
Offiong, O. E. and Edet, A., 1996. Environmental Zhang, X. G., Alhassan, S. and Goodwin, F. E.
pollution: water, land, air and noise in Cross 2004. Predicting life of galvanized steel on
River State. Technical Report submitted to internet. Proceedings of CORROSION/
Cross River Environmental Protection 2004, Paper Number 04067. Houston:
Agency, Calabar. NACE International.