Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Veena
This is sad. Veena Malik was going great guns. She was, and perhaps still is, the
biggest star that Indian television industry has produced in recent times. And
then… nazar lag gaee.
The Indian TV channel on which Veena M’s most anticipated reality show Swyamvar
was going to air has been closed by its US-based top management. Till last reports came
in no specific reason was given by the management to its employees for shutting down
business. The biggest catch of the channel was the programme on which Veena M was to
make an appearance where she was supposed to find a groom for herself. Already
thousands of men had applied to woo Veena. So not only is she now workless, has also
been deprived of possible suitors.
The growth of electronic media over past few decades is very rapid in Pakistan. The
media can impact public opinion in a significant manner. In Pakistan the national
integration and cohesion, is indeed a serious issue, which needs to be analyzed. The
media’s extraordinary growth can impact this problem. The media is being considered as
a fourth pillar of the state.
The uncertainty about peace, security, bad-governance and system of justice has
generated a sense of deprivation in the society. The stake holders in maintenance of
national cohesion and integration are State Institutions, Judiciary, Defence Forces, Law
and Order Machinery, Political Parties, Civil Society, Public Opinion Groups, and
electronic media. The growth and development of electronic media as fourth pillar of the
state is a reality. The television is the most favoured medium of communication with a
large number of viewer ship with significant results. The national cohesion and
integration demonstrate fault lines that threaten very existence of the state.
The National Integration for Pakistan does not mean creating ethnic or national
homogeneity throughout the country; rather it only means establishing a bond that may
bind the population in common political and social structures, statehood, a sense of
identity and of belonging together.
It has been established that the electronic media has a role to play for resolution of
problems being faced by Pakistan i.e. political instability, bad governance, weak
economy, sectarian and ethnic divide/religious activism, population growth, friction
between the provinces and centre, violence and intolerance in the society, lack of national
integration and harmony etc.. The impression that the media could solely and
independently play a role in making society and the people to behave in a certain way,
cannot succeed, there appears no empirical evidence to support this.
The healthy relationship between electronic media and the government and its agencies is
essential for accurate dissemination of news. There is need to draw a fine balance
between the excess and denial of freedom to the media. It has been found that
government need to evolve a new media policy.
The electronic media in Pakistan as a source of immense influence and change has also
come and has to stay as fourth pillar of the State. The state policies against the aspirations
of people and pressure groups are being exposed in the electronic media. The electronic
media has also occupied globally a significant and very central position.
The electronic media has emerged as an effective tool, globally, and at home for building
favourable / unfavourable opinions and attitudes of the masses for the preferred themes,
to achieve the desired objectives. If applied positively, its contribution in achieving
national integration, socio-economic uplift and in building a cohesive, tolerant and
forward looking society cannot be over emphasized.
The 20th century can be termed as the century of communication. The main mean of
mass communication grew in succession as the century unfolded. Motion pictures arrived
on scene in the first decade of this century. Regular radio broadcasts started in 1920s.
Television entered the arena in 1940s, followed by cable television in 1950s, and satellite
television in 1970s. Lastly the personal computer gave access to Internet in 1980s. It
transformed the interconnected computer networks through World Wide Web by the
1990s.
The electronic media has touched every sphere of the human aspect. In the present times,
information and technology are interwoven with the society’s economic progress. The
evolution of electronic media has had an overwhelming impact on the society. The
Opportunities of communication have broken all barriers across national boundaries and
have led to the germination of new ideas through the cross pollination of cultures.
Electronic information has had a positive impact in the promotion of various social
regimes.
The electronic Media was primarily and popularly used by our previous regimes as tool
of self propaganda, the quality of news poor, unreliable and un-imaginative presentation
of events and stories, ultimately losing the confidence of general public. Introduction of
Satellite TV, Cable and Private Channels and Dish widened the scope of awareness of
people. The Government of Pakistan realized the sensitivity and potential of private
electronic media which could not be avoided through State controlled TV only. The
governmental policies regarding electronic media took a different direction, to regulate
this sector.
Challenges
In a democratic country like Pakistan where freedom of speech and expression is
guaranteed to every citizen by the Constitution. This fundamental right has to be
exercised by all with due care to ensure that it may not incite violence, terrorism, racial,
ethnic or religious discrimination, sectarianism, extremism, militancy, hatred,
pornography, obscenity, vulgarity or anything offensive to the commonly accepted
standards of decency. Similarly, the sanctity of national institutions needs to be respected
at all costs. In this regard, PEMRA has formulated a Code of Conduct for the
broadcasters. However, the concept of Self-Regulation is promoted to encourage the
broadcasters to formulate the rules of the game, themselves.
The Pakistani society is in transition, and it faces challenges but still the national interest
is to make Pakistan as a unity-in-diversity and there is an ever-growing need to develop a
harmonious society. “The balance sheet of social changes in Pakistani society over the
past half century has both cost and benefits. Pakistani society has split into class-cum-
lifestyle segments. Its social institutions do not dovetail into each other; instead fissures
of institutional lag run through them. Its cohesiveness has given way to the fragmentation
and the erosion of value and moral consensus”.
The electronic media direct social change and values. The electronic media may be
successful in stimulating the change in the tightly held ideas and rigid attitudes to bring
desired change. The media can give direction to social change, and positively guide the
society towards the desired goals.
These days no news is good news on Pakistani media. Media has taken away the sense of
hope from the masses and has made them over sensitive to their surroundings.
Commercialism and Electronic Media.
In some instances, the electronic media is accessed by a small segment of society; due to
vested interests this group projects its identity disproportionately. The media coverage of
such groups is likely to create a polarized society.
All events and happenings in Pakistan are not bad. On the contrary sometime nothing
positive is discussed in the electronic media. The projection of crimes and anti- social
elements all the time is eroding and diminishing the contours of our true identity across
the globe.
Pursuance of Foreign Agenda. It is believed that some of Pakistani media has
reportedly links with shady foreign characters, are being funded by different foreign
elements and their anchors are on their pay rolls and thus are furthering their anti- state
agendas.
Analysis of role of electronic media
The society and culture are threatened in Pakistan. The patterns of life are changing
because of impact of education and electronic media, which have to be facilitated in a
positive manner. “With regards to media’s role in promoting national cohesion and unity,
Media can shape public perceptions on these issues but does not create or solve these
problems. What matter the most are government policies and their impact. Media can be
a force for national unity only if it adheres to an agreed code of ethics. Finally, a liberal
media policy is a prerequisite to play its due role as a vehicle for national unity and
cohesion. We are a highly polarized society, segmented along ethnic, sectarian,
ideological and gender issues. Faltering economic growth and stagnant social
development have only reinforced these tensions. Without achieving economic solvency
and the promise of a better future, our national cohesion will remain under stress. Our
biggest fault line is the rising demographic pressure on our resources. We need to launch
a sustained media campaign to bring this pressure down. This is one area in which media
can play a pivotal and non-partisan role”.
The strengths of electronic media include the viewer ship which has reached to eighty
six million according to 2009 Gallop survey . Since more than 2000, TV cable operators
have emerged as audio-video platforms promoting and influencing the society.
Meanwhile, increasing influence of internet and TV channels are raising power potential
of these audio and video platforms. It is not making values but just making the people
aware of events and happenings. The media is often blamed for social ills to the
determinant of identifying the real causes of the problems. We have to see the impact of
the dynamics of the society, the governmental culture of power and governance, and
various policies and actions, instead of putting blame on media. The relationship between
electronic media exposure and behaviour is very complex and many other factors do
intervene. It has been impossible to prove that the media has direct “effects”; however it
has impact on public opinion formation.
The Pakistani electronic media can play its role to enhance national cohesion and
integration, can give the right direction and can still play a vital role to create awareness
in all the spheres of its reach.
The track record of electronic media on ethnic and sectarian clashes between Mohajir –
Pathan, Mohajir – Sindhi and Shia – Sunni is extremely encouraging. The media has
always followed the neutral line and supported the efforts of government in fighting these
internal security issues. The electronic media in this area can play a decisive role as a
continuous effort to keep the situation defused by creating harmony between various
sects.
Role of Electronic Media against Social Evils.
The electronic media can play a very vital role in educating the masses about ill effects of
social evils like ignorance and backwardness including gun culture and drugs in the
society. The awareness can make the society robust and well informed to fulfil their
obligations
The electronic media should help to develop a harmonious society, bridge gap between
reality and the distortions. The media should project objective analysis of the events. The
media should present the events by avoiding biases, prejudices and negative perceptions
of various groups operating in the society.
We can conclude however that media is often blamed for social ills to the determinant of
identifying the real causes of the problems. We have to see the impact of the dynamics of
the society, the governmental culture of power and governance, and various policies and
actions, instead of putting blame on media. It is easier to pass a law to prevent conduct of
violence. But the real causes of violence in society- such as poverty, instable family
system, role of agencies, mental state of the members of the society, are difficult to
solve.We have to examine what causes of a certain phenomena, there may be some more
research to study about casualty. What causes something to happen? Is it possible that
watching a particular television programme could cause a person to behave in a certain
way? The relationship between electronic media exposure and behaviour is very
complex and many other factors do intervene. It is not possible to prove that the media
has direct “effects”, to cause disintegration in the society however it has impact on public
opinion formation. The impression that the media could solely and independently play a
role in making society and the people to behave in a certain way, cannot succeed, there
appears no empirical evidence to support this explanation.
Pakistani media is a business like other businesses, a billion dollar industry and thus its
primary motive remains to earn money. The media often looks for controversy,
sensational and negative news to make it breaking news. The Media feels it has the right
to interpret what is good or bad for society using its own standards. It, however, has its
own agenda of exploitation and money making, and it has also power of projection of its
cause directly to the public.
The electronic media because of its very fast growth in Pakistan significantly influenced
the public opinion on national issues. However for an effective role of electronic media
towards these national objectives, media has its inherent strengths and limitations.
The electronic media in Pakistan has recorded tremendous growth in a limited time
period. In terms of audience both television and radio has significant reach. It can be
termed as fourth pillar of the state. The electronic media has impact (both positive and
negative) on generating public opinion on national issues. There are serious socio-
political and socio- economic distortions that have caused fault lines in national cohesion.
The media, besides the society, has a direct linkage with the politics as well. The
electronic media is an agent of change but the direction of change depends upon the
reported information. The media has constraints and limitations, like vested interests,
corruption, political motives and monetary gains. Because of lack of objectivity in its
activities the creditability of media is sometime questioned. The media reporting is also
scandalous and unrealistic to define an issue, this aspect of media needs improvement.
The main thesis of this argument is that electronic media is not the master of events
because of its structural constraints; therefore, the myth of powerful electronic media is
not true. The electronic media is striving hard to become an effective pillar of statecraft.
The electronic media is to provide, not to create and media is playing this role to a great
extent.
http://zjeddy.wordpress.com/2010/07/28/electronic-media-in-pakistan-by-azam-
khan/
MASS MEDIA Raja Kamran Topic Factors / Reasons for Growth of Media
(a)Liberalization of airway in India led to mushroom growth of TV channels.
(b)In Kargil war India was able to sell its viewpoint to the world and cashed on its
version while Pak suffered since it had only the state channel.
(d)Literacy rate / level grew in Pakistan and played a role in media development.
1.
Level of Awareness
2.
3.
4.
5.
Supports Democracy
Media supports democracy by bringing out the democratic norms and inculcating
the same in the general public / polity. Providing live coverage of parliament
proceedings, activities of politicians, programmes on democracy etc are few of the
examples.
6.
Media provides viewpoint of the public on public issues. Media has given voice to
the public.
1.
Consumerism
2.
Moral Vacuum
3.
Westernization
Western / Indian cultural invasion has taken place through media and is permeating
Pakistan society. Our commercials are depicting western
values and causing a loss of national identity.
4.
5.
False Values.
Pakistani Media is projecting false values in its programmes, etc. The projection of
family planning, love stories in dramas, hi-fi living styles / material depicted in
dramas, etc. are not real and are not based on ground realities
(b)Projected values on media are not congruent with our values / ground realities
6.
Manifestation of Interests.
7.
Exaggeration
Pakistani media is also blamed for overwhelming negative exaggeration
.8.
Dangers to Socialization
http://www.scribd.com/doc/18271317/Mass-Media-in-Pakistan-by-Raja-Kamran
Communication in this era is experiencing its boom, reflecting on the human psychology
in a manner that could virtually transform the whole generation of the global village.
"There are striking degree of University about the global phenomenon, we recognize as
mass media, whatever reason for the convergence. In the history of Mass media we deal
with four elements, a technology, the political social, economics and the cultural situation
of a society; a set of activities and functions or interests. The more prominently the media
have features in the life of the people, the sharper has been the debate on what purpose or
functions we ought to serve in a society( Dr. Muhammad Nawaz Mahsood,2006)
Asia has taken a quantum leap in the use of advanced communication technology in
recent years. A large number of local, regional and multi national television companies
and Internet networks have established a strong impact on Asian countries. Pakistan
among the Asian countries is the one who have seen a great impact of the rapidly
changing communication technologies. Pakistan's media especially the electronic
media is very vibrant and has become the most powerful in creating a change and
moulding the public opinion. The role of electronic media in general promises in
spreading education, information and powerful entertainment. The role of media
especially the electronic media in Pakistani society is tri- dimensional; that is informing
the public, educating the unknowledgeable and providing entertainment. "When we cast
an eye on the electronic media in Pakistan it seems to be microscope of the country's
history. Burst of enthusiasm, followed by extreme official apathy; period of accelerated
growth giving away to long era of stagnation; bold and daring decisions overturned by
nervous governments whose vision doesn't extend beyond the obvious. However, in spite
of all these ups and downs, it seems the Pakistan's electronic media has finally come of
age and is all set to make its mark in world ( Shahida Qazi, 2004). A number of private
Radio and Television channels are appearing in Pakistan's media scene. These two media
mirroring Pakistan, where low literacy rate results in reaching of these to mediums to a
large number of audiences than all Newspaper and Magazines combined. Pakistan's
society has been exposed to transnational satellite channels, divided into three major
categories in terms of their socio - cultural settings and content. The first group comprises
of the English language channels, which are operating from the Western countries
carrying mostly the content presenting the Western Urban culture and offering a palate of
programs from the present socio-cultural settings and conditions of Pakistan. Then there
are a large number of Hindi channels depicting their cultural values and norms, offering a
platter of programs from news to soap operas and from dramas to discussions, mostly
from India, which is at cultural and ideological divergence from Pakistan. The third
group are the private and public satellite channels added very recently in Pakistan's
satellite channels, broadcasting programs mainly in Urdu, including the channels devoted
entirely to telecast programs in regional languages.
The recent FM boom in Radio, it is been accessible and catering the need of the diverse
segment of the society. The recent growth of electronic media in the past ten years has
remarkably the social, cultural, educational scenario of our society, the impact of
electronic media and its role in Pakistani society require a complete research. According
to Williams," Unlike all previous communication technologies, radio and television were
systems primarily designed for transmission and reception as abstract processes, with
little or no definition of preceding content".
The electronic media is responsible for a major cultivating and acculturating process
according to which tends to shape up the belief and values accordingly. Cultivation is
cumulative and slow process which slowly and gradually shape up the audiences opinion
which bring effect in a very subtle manner. The newspaper, magazines and books portray
the standstill life and cannot show any activity or event happening instantly, they do use
the exemplary language, and describe only what did or did not happen. Print media has
the advantages of being low price, readily available, transportable and easy to keep
record, however, they are not meant for the masses in developing countries like Pakistan
where literacy rates and income are low. on the contrary, the electronic media, stand out
as a medium of information, economic, education and entertainment. The electronic
media along with its traditionally perceived role, is playing a very vibrant role in
promoting patriotism in Pakistani society. It is a value protected by the media when an
individual is accused of disloyalty, favorable discussion of him by the media is checked
by the media organizations and he cant be dramatized as a hero but only as a
controversial person under suspicion. A country like Pakistan, which is a country of
diverse cultural, ethnicity and religious background, electronic media is working very
hard to create a harmony between different cultural, ethnic and religious communities
and identifies them into one nation. Along with this we have seen the Pakistani electronic
media have made some progress toward the area of consumer awareness, especially in the
case of television, there are movements underway to enable the television viewers to
beam a mere educated and more aware and critical user of programming with the help of
radio and television discussion programs, talk shows, morning shows, where a
progressive discussions have been took place on such subjects as death, violence, drugs ,
morality, human relationship, the women liberation movement, politics, religion and
culture. Another effect along the same lines is based on the concept of average viewers
need to have certain areas of consumer awareness heightened, therefore the experts and
leaders in electronic media awareness put through a rigorous training program that
educate them to see through some of the showbiz tactics of television advertising, role of
women in television, the impact of television on children, the presentation of violence
and stereotyping ( Muhammad Nawaz, 2006).
The primary role played by electronic media in Pakistan is the representation of order,
they produce stories that help to make sense, and express sensibilities about social order,
things are represented in terms of truth or falsehood. In their capacity as watchdogs the
electronic media keeps a close watch on the government and institutions to report their
misdeeds and wrong doings to the masses. The recent boom of news channels, by their
reporting they locate the dividing conformity from deviance, and in doing so become the
definers of the deviance.
Electronic media, on the whole along with its revolutionary role they played for the
democracy, human right, women right, dissemination of news and education is the
biggest source of entertainment in Pakistani Society. Their dramas, music videos, comedy
programs and sports coverage are the biggest source of entertainment for all segments of
the society.
Revolutions do not take place overnight because the human societies take their time to
change, the electronic media however, largely used to project a particular view and is
meant to inculcate in the public mind officially view than to inform them of the reality.
This most powerful medium of public education and awareness cannot became a vehicle
for social change as long as it remains under the governmental control. It has to be
opened up and made to respond the needs of a society, whose problems have grown
enormously complex and whose members need to take up cudgel on their own. Although
electronic media is under the state control, but it has a history of struggle for its rights and
democracy. Unfortunately no independent, comprehensive and credible research of mass
audience has ever been conducted in Pakistan on the impact of electronic media in
Pakistani society, however the electronic media is perceived to be perform the role of
informing, educating and entertaining the society, which is why the most popular
programs in television and radio are the news, live coverages of national and international
events, sports programs as cricket, Hockey, Football, and international sports events that
provide a healthy relief to the viewers from the grinding stresses of the life. The glamour
and movies has also bee adequately covered.
The only criticism that can be done in the field of entertainment is that it has not shown
native genius in innovation, it is applying Indian model of entertainment and a western
model. Part it is not try to innovate and produce quality entertainment programs and news
programs. With its many sources and expertise it is required that the two medium has
to improve its performance in all three aspects of its role in the society and can play it
more effectively and successfully.
http://mahedarakhshan.blogspot.com/2011/06/role-of-electronic-media-in-
pakistani.html
http://www.defence.pk/forums/current-events-social-issues/39909-impact-media-
pakistan-3.html
http://post.polls.yahoo.com/quiz/quizresults.php
Pakistan has allowed cross-media ownership in the year 2003. This still leaves us with
multiple problems and issues. The most pressing issue here is that culturally and
politically Pakistan is very difficult to define. The State itself has recently been struggling
to assert a cultural identity of its own in the face of fragmentation and the influx of
American culture. Indeed the most important cultural issue facing Pakistan is the current
explosion of tensions and terrorism and political hatred. These are obviously not
problems that can be solved by Mass Media Policy alone. Although it forms the
backcloth of any attempt to rethink its importance in a national context.
Employment Generation
At the moment 30,000 people are directly employed in Cable TV business claiming to
support 500,000 persons, PTV has 6000 employees. Radio Pakistan has more than 3,000
employees. This sector will become a high potential employment area by 2010. It is
expected that Radio can provide direct employment to around 1,000 people while satellite
TV has potential to employ up to 4000 people. Direct to home technology can
accommodate up to 200 people directly or indirectly associated with it. Cable has the
potential to employ around 10,000 people. MMDS technology has the capacity to employ
around 1,000 additional people.
Table-2
1. Cable TV 30000
2. Television 6000
3. Radio 3000
4. MMDS 1000
5. DTH 200
Source : PEMRA
In the field of Electronic Media new technological breakthroughs are expected in the
coming five years which are likely to create yet new challenges. There is a need for
building the capacity within Information and Broadcasting sector of reviewing the new
trends, forces and innovations annually so that the country is not overtaken by events
technologically. The era of technological predominance is knocking at our doors and in
the words of Marshall McLuhan- the Media Guru, the worldwide relationship will be
shaped by media technology in future. There is need for a Strategy Group in Information
and Broadcasting sector to review the emerging challenges which should submit an
annual report to Government for speedy actions. Research Studies should be undertaken
through Information related Institutes and Universities on the media scenario and its
comparison with the rival forces. In addition to this, the role of regulation will have to be
constantly redefined. Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authorities' role in
expanding and strengthening the media market and providing a workable policy model to
operators with principles of social responsibility will be of foremost importance. It should
perform this role through wide stakeholder consultation and recourse to the general
public through authentic surveys.
http://www.aiou.edu.pk/gmj/artical4.asp
http://www.cyberessays.com/Term-Paper-on-Role-Of-Media-In-Pakistan/30557/
47
Role/ State of Electronic Media in Pakistani Society: A Sociological Analysis
By
Pakistani media deserve better marks as far as providing entertainment and information
is concerned. Live coverage of International events, and of games that are a craze in
Pakistan,
like cricket, hockey and football, provide a healthy relief to the viewers from the grinding
stresses of life. Glamorous world of fashion and movies has also been adequately
covered. The
Pakistani print media has become significantly pictorial and the quality of pictures has
also 50
improved considerably but major focus is still on portraying females. TV too has been
jazzed up
since the private channels have been allowed to telecast its programs. The entertainment
that
private channels provide is much more liberal and flashier than PTV, which too is trying
to
catch.
Pakistan’s media outlets are full of vibrant and talented journalists. Pakistan’s news
organizations increasingly provide a constructive channel for debate and dissent. These
media
organizations also have businesses and contribute to the economic growth of the country.
The only criticism that can be done on the media in the field of entertainment is
that it has not shown native genius in innovation. It is aping the Indian model of
entertainment-
high heels and lower necks. The media can improve its performance in the three aspects
of its
role in the society and can play it more effectively and more successfully.
Trend of privatization has been increased due to competition which is the root cause
to minimize the share of government commercials. So far there is a control of state on
macro
level. Reduction in Government commercials will keep up editorial liberty in the country.
Many
states exploit commercials as a tool against publication.
We cannot escape globalization, so why not reap its benefits? But to achieve this we
have to be part of the global village. This objective will be achieved only if we allow
liberalizing
and totally independent radio and television stations and channels, including news
broadcast.
The electronic media is the most powerful medium of public education and
awareness. It
has to be opened up and made to respond to the needs of the society, whose problems
have
grown enormously complex. Another problem with media in Pakistan is providing
entertainment. Entertainment is the order of the day. Until Pakistani media realizes this it
cannot
expect to be competitive. 51
REFERENCES
¾ Dr. Muhammad Nawaz, (2006) Mass Communication, An Introduction to Information
Revolution, Theories, Skills and Practices. Higher Education Commission, Islamabad,
Pakistan.
¾ Lanham, R. (1993). ‘ The Electronic Word: Literacy Study and the Digital
Revolution:’
In the Electronic Word: Democracy, Technology, and the Arts. Chicago: University of
Chicago Press.
¾ Ramanathan, S. (2000). ‘ Internet in Asia: Introduction,’ in Becker, J. and S.
Ramanathan (eds). Internet in Asia, Singapore: AMIC.
¾ Sharma, J.T (2003). Digital Broadcasting Journalism. ( Author Press, Tarun Off,
Dehli). 1st Edition.
¾ S.M. Shahid. (2006) Mass Communication, An Introduction, Publishers Emporium.
¾ Jennings Bryant, Susan Thompson, Fundamentals of Media Effects, 1st Edition.
¾ Watson, J. (2003). Media Communication: An Introduction to Theory and Process. (2
nd
Edition) Palgrave.
WEB ADDRESSES:
http://www.pakistantimes.net
http://www.asiamedia.ulca.edu
http://dspace.unimap.edu.my/dspace/bitstream/123456789/5835/1/ROLE
%20%20STATE%20OF%20ELECTRONIC%20MEDIA%20IN%20PAKISTANI
%20SOCIETY%3B%20%20A%20SOCIOLOGICAL%20ANALYSIS.pdf