Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Analysis and Realization of A Pulsewidth Modulator Based On Voltage Space Vectors
Analysis and Realization of A Pulsewidth Modulator Based On Voltage Space Vectors
JANUARYIFEBRUARY I O X X
Space Vectors
ripples are evaluated and compared with those of established sinusoidal Fig 1. Induction motor drlve with pulsewidth-modulated vvltdge w u r c e
pulsewidth modulation. The realization of a pulsewidth modulator is inverter
described in the range of synchronous sinusoidal pulsewidth modulation,
which generates-by software-symmetrical synchronous pulse patterns. widths. They will be referred to as established sinusoidal
The performance has been proved by laboratory tests. modulation in this paper. If the switching frequency is an
integer multiple of the fundamental output frequency, this will
INTRODUCTION be called synchronized sinusoidal modulation, in contrast to
free-running sinusoidal modulation, where the switching
V ARIABLE-FREQUENCY ac drives are increasingly
used for various applications in industry and traction.
Due to the improvement of fast-switching semiconductor
frequency and the fundamental output frequency are indepen-
dent of each other.
Sinusoidal modulation maintains good performance of the
power devices, voltage source inverters with pulsewidth-
modulated (PWM) control, as shown in Fig. 1, find particu- drive in the entire range of operation between zero and 100-
percent modulation index m.If the modulation index exceeds
larly growing interest.
Control methods that generate the necessary PWM patterns unity, sinusoidal modulation is no longer possible. In this
have been discussed extensively in the literature. Two basic range of operation it is useful to apply optimized PWM with
concepts may be distinguished: for small and medium-size precalculated switching points, which are stored in a look-up
drives, the current-controlled PWM has proved to be advanta- table. Optimized PWM is also recommended for low-fre-
geous. For big drives employing inverters with low switching quency ratios. It is practical to calculate the notches off-line in
frequency, PWM voltage control is more advantageous. such a way that current ripple or losses or torque pulsations are
However, this method is also an option for small and medium- minimized.
size drives. A detailed description of the basic methods may be SINUSOIDAL
MODULATION
found in [I] and [2]. This paper deals with PWM voltage
control methods. In the following the sinusoidal modulation will be discussed
in more detail. For this purpose an inverter leg, as shown i n
PWM VOLTAGE
CONTROL
METHODS Fig. 2(a), is represented by an equivalent circuit. shown in
If the switching frequency fJ is high compared to the Fig. 2(b).
fundamental output frequency fiof the inverter (frequency If the changeover switch is operated according to sinusoidal
ratio zT 2 9, * 15), sampling methods with sinusoidal
0 .
modulation, the line-to-center voltage U , follows a shape as
reference signals, e.g., n a u a l sampling [3] or regular shown for instance in Fig. 3 in per-unit notation. The mean
sampling [4], may be used. These methods aim at generating value of the voltage u averaged over each cycle of the
an inverter output voltage with sinusoidally modulated pulse- switching frequency follows a staircase shape, which will be
replaced with a smoothed curve u(t) for sufficiently high
Paper IPCSD 87-19, approved by the Industrial Drives Committee of the frequency ratios zr. This curve will be called mean value
IEEE Industry Applications Society for presentation at the 1986 Industry herein. In a symmetrical three-phase inverter the mean line-to-
Applications Society Annual Meeting, Denver, CO, September 28-October 3 . center voltages are
Manuscript released for publication April 14, 1987.
H. W. van der Broeck is with Philips Forschungslaboratorium Aachen,
Weisshausstrasse, 5100 Aachen, West Germany.
H . C . Skudelny and G . V. Stanke are with the Institut fur Stromrichtertech-
nik und Electrische Antribe, Jagerstrasse 17/19, 5100 Aachen, West
Germany.
lEEE Log Number 8716204.
(a) (b)
F I ~2.. (a) Inverter leg. (b) Inverter leg equivalent circuit.
-,
-it-
llf,
Fig. 3 . Single-phase inverter output voltage by established sinusoidal
modulation.
f,
zr=-=3 n ( n = 1 , 2 , 3, - . e ) . (3)
fl
The upper limit of the phase-to-center voltage for sinusoidal
modulation is theoretically m = 1 with zl = 1. This is only 78
percent of the value that would be reached by square-wave
operation. (a) (b)
+
SPACE-VECTOR
MODULATION
-e
A different approach to PWM modulation is based on the u-u
space vector representation of the voltages in the CY,/3 plane.
The CY,/3 components are found by Park transform, where the (C)
total power, as well as the impedances, remains unchanged Fig. 5 . Equivalent circuit of induction machine. (a) Single-phase representa-
tion. (b) Simplification for harmonic current calculation. (c) Simplification
(see also (23)). This concept was discussed in publications for space vector calculation.
such as [4]-[6]. For our purpose the basic ideas are summa-
rized. mean voltage vector is equalized to the fundamental voltage
The three machine voltages are represented by a voltage vector and the average deviation current vector becomes zero.
space vector 0. There are eight states available for this vector Within one switching state the deviation current vector
according to eight switching positions of the inverter, which changes by the amount
are depicted in Fig. 4. 2
We define a mean space vector U , which is almost constant
during a switching period. This vector generates the funda-
A?’_ =-
L,
{1 t2
I1
- !
(I??- U ) dt =min (4)
mental behavior of the machine, e.g., currents and torque.
-> -.
The difference space vector U - u causes the current harmon-
where
ics. For discussing the current harmonics, a simplified t , beginning of switching state.
equivalent circuit of the induction machine according to Fig. t2 end of switching state.
5(c) can be used.
An optimum PWM modulation is expected if
For the quality of PWM control, the deviation of the
machine currents from the fundamental currents is highly the maximum deviation of the current vector for several
important. For the ideal case of sufficiently high frequency switching states becomes as small as possible, and
ratios, cycles of switching states can be found wherein the the cycle time is as short as possible.
144 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. 24, NO I , JANUARYIFEBRUARY 1988
00 . TI+ O a *
-
T2= Uref* Tz. (6) PWM concepts, the mean values of the phase-to-center
If the space vectors in this equation are described in voltages averaged over one switching cycle are evaluated. For
sector I one finds
rectangular coordinates, it follows that
Hence
T7= TX= To= Tz- T2- T I . ( 2 sin w1t for 0 5 w,t 30"
(1 1)
For the sectors 11-VI the same rules apply. This results in a
definite switching order according to Fig. 7, which shows
exactly the same symmetry as derived for established sinusoi- U,(t ) = - U,( - t ) = - U,(t - T / 2 ) (16)
dal modulation [ 1 11.
To compare the results of the space-vector PWM with other Ul(t)=U2(t- T/3)= U3(t+ T / 3 ) . (17)
V A N DER BROECK el at.: PULSEWIDTH MODULATOR BASED ON VOLTAGE SPACE VECTORS 145
4
m = - . a.
3
Looking at Fig. 4 one finds that the maximum value for a The harmonic content of the stator currents can be calculated
sinusoidal PWM is a = 4 1 2 .
This leads to the maximum modulation index in the case of
space vector PWM:
rn,,,, = 2/&. (21)
]:I;[ =: [
in a similar way:
1
-1/2 -1/2
1 -1-21
-1/2 . [ . (24)
-2
VECTOR-PWM
0 00 -- -
0 02 OL 06 08 1 0 115
rn --
Fig 11 Square of rms harmonic current
f ,":PI SIN-PWM
0 ' ~ r n
0 2n
(a)
SPACE-VE CTOR-PWM
. ,
rn'
1 , ,
1'3
,'
-
, 61
0 Zn
Ip=Z?Tf,t
(b)
Fig 12 (a) Envelope curve for establlshed sinurotdal PWM ( T r , =
TH_.fs.L,*/(Uq $)) (b) Space vector PWM
r
W
L
d
3
-4-
.I-
O
I/)
I
I
L. _a
_c
2
c
-
c
VAN DER BROECK ei al.: PULSEWIDTH MODULATOR BASED ON VOLTAGE SPACE VECTORS 149
10
I !
“214 I
II1111111111111I (I
I
1‘1
p=21-1-p=15
U
llU
l UUUUllI‘ lorn
c _
I
Fig. 15. Measured shape of motor current and line-to-line voltage with pulse
ratio changing.
modulation index can be changed independently. The transi- Peak value of torque pulsa-
tion from one mode to another is without current transients. tions.
The described modulator was realized by means of an 8086 Fundamental pull-out torque.
microprocessor. Although rather complex programs are Fundamental frequency.
needed, the modulator is capable of switching frequencies up Switching frequency.
to 2 kHz. Frequency ratio.
Modulation index.
CONCLUSION Leakage factor.
It was shown that sinusoidal modulation generated in a Leakage inductance.
space vector representation has the advantages of lower Leakage inductance for cal-
current harmonics and a possible higher modulation index culation of torque pulsations.
compared with the three-phase sinusoidal modulation method. Phase angle 0 5 y 5 60”.
A modulator on the basis of an 8086 microprocessor = 27rfit = Ult Phase angle 0 5 cp 5 360”.
suitable of operating in the free-running mode, in the
sinusoidal modulation mode, and in the fixed-pattern mode REFERENCES
was developed. As an example the operation of this modulator A. Schonung and H. Stemmler, “Static frequency changers with
was shown in the sinusoidal modulation mode. subharmonic control in conjunction with reversible variable-speed a x .
drives,” Brown-Boveri Rev., vol. 51, pp. 555-577, 1964.
A. B. Plunkett, “A current-controlled PWM transistor inverter drive,”
NOMENCLATURE in Conf. Record of 1979 IEEE-IAS Ann. Meeting, pp. 785-792.
DC source voltage. J. Zubek, A. Abbondanti, and C. Nordby, “Pulsewidth modulated
inverter motor drive with improved modulation,” IEEE Trans. Ind.
Phase-to-center voltage. Appl., vol. IA-11, no. 6, pp. 695-703, Nov./Dec. 1975.
Per-unit value of U,(t). G. Pfaff, A. Weschta, and A. Wick, “Design and experimental results
Fundamental amplitude of of a brushless ac servo-drive,” in Conf. Rec. 1982 IEEE-IAS Ann.
Meeting, pp. 692-697.
u,w. J. Eibel and R. Jotten, “Control of a 3-level switching inverter, feeding
Mean value of U ( t ) for a 3-phase a.c. machine, by a microprocessor,” ETG-Fachberichte,
switching period T = l/f,. vel. 11, pp. 217-222, 1982.
A. Bellini, G. Figalli, and G. Ulivi, “A three-phase modulation
Park components of voltage. technique suitable to supply induction motors,” in Conf. Record of
Phase-to-phase voltage. IPEC 1983, Tokyo, pp. 396-406.
Voltage space vector. K. Kovacs and I. Racz, Transiente Vorgange in Wechselstromma-
schinen, Bd. I and 11. Budapest: Verlag der Ungarischen Akademie der
Machine currents (star con- Wissenschaften, 1959.
nection). J. Schorner, “Bezugsspannung zur Umrichtersteuerung,” ETZ-B, vol.
Park components of I A , I B , 27, no. 7 , pp. 151-152, 1975.
D. Grant, J. Houldsworth, and K. Lower, “The effect of word length
IC. on the harmonic content of microprocessor-based PWM waveform
Harmonic content of current generators,” in Conf. Rec. 1983 IEEE-IAS Annual Meeting, pp.
for single-phase calculation. 643-650.
H. van der Broeck and H. C. Skudelny, “Analytical analysis of the
RMS value of harmonic con- harmonic effects of a PWM ac drive,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron.,
tent of current. vol. 3, no. 4, Apr. 1988.
t RMS value of fundamental H. van der Broeck, “Vergleich von spannungseinpragenden Wech-
selrichtern mit zwei und drei Zweigpaaren zur Speisung einer Drehstro-
machine current at no-load. masynchronmaschine unter Verwendung der Pulsweitenmodulation
d Flux, crest value. hoher Taktzahl,” Dissertation, Rheinisch-Westfalische Technische
T- Torque pulsation. Hochschule, Aachen, 1985.
S. Bowes and M. Mount, “Microprocessor control of PWM invert-
TH - (cp) Envelope curve of torque pul- ers,” in IEE Proc., vol. 128, Pt. B, no. 6, Nov. 1981, pp. 293-305.
sations. B. Bose and H. Sutherland, “A high-performance pulse-width modula-
150 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL 24 NO I , JANUARYIFEBKUARY I O R X
tor tor an inverter-fed drive system using a microcomputer,” in Conf. Hans-Christoph Skudelny (M’79) W ~ Sborn 111
Rec. 1982 Ann, Meeting IEEE-IAS, p p . 847-853 1932 He received the Dip1 Ing degree in 1957 m t l
[I41 K Manch and M Ito, “A multimicroprocessor ac drive controller,” in the Dr Ing degree in 1960. both froni Adihen
Con!. Rec. 1980 IEEE-IAS Annual Meeting, pp 634-640 Universit) of Technology
[15] B Cook, A. Cantoni, and R Evans, “A microprocessor based, 3- From 1961 to 1973 he wds with Brown-Boveri &
phase pulse width modulator,” in Conf. Rec. 1982 Znt. Semiconduc- Cie AG, Mannheim, Germany. where he worked
tor Power Converter Conf. of IEEE-IAS, pp 375-384 in the fields of power electronics and trdctio? He
[ 161 A. Pollmann, “A digital pulsewidth inodulator employing advanced became a Professor of power eleitronics m d electri
modulation techniques,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol IA-19, no 3, cal drives at Aachen University ot rechnology in
pp 409-414, MayiJune 1983 1973 His main re\edrch interebts are Lonverter
circuits, industrial and trdction drives. and bdtery
electric vehicles
Heinz W. van der Broeck was born in Fussenich,
Germany, on November 25, 1952 He received the
Ing Grad degree in electr~calengineering from the
Fachhochschule, Koln, Germany, in 1975, and the Georg V. Stanke was born in Baden Bden. Gcr
Dip1 Ing. degree in electrical engineering from the many, on July 25, 1956 He received the Dip1 Ing
Aachen Universlty of Technology, Germany, in degree in electrical engineering from the A‘ichen
1980 University ot Technology, Gerrndny in I9X I
From 1980 to 1987 he was on the scientific staff In 1983 he joined the InTtitute ot Power Electrim
of the Institute of Power Electronic? and Electrical ics and Electricdl Drives of the baiw bniver\ity <I
Drives at the Aachen University of Technology In Scientific Assistant He is mainly engaged i n the
1985 he received the Dr Ing degree from the same investigation of control syjtems for \oltdge source\
University Since 1987 he has been with the Philips Research Laboratory. inverters which dre employed i n d~ traction drive\
Aachen, Germany with single-phase ac power >upply