Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1, April 2010
Nova Mujiono
Abstract
Jellyfish sting cases are reported between the years 2005 to 2009 from Indonesian waters. Three fatal cases
occurred in Jebus and Situbondo in 2008 which predicted to be caused by Chrysaora quinquecirrha and Physalia
physalis. Another species, Physalia utriculus is causing no fatality. Seasonality, treatment of the injury and prevention
from the sting also discussed.
Key words : jellyfish sting, Indonesia
1
Jellyfish Sting ......
beach. Their body, back, stomach and feet are getting also reported in October 2008 causing the victim dies
reddish. When they evacuated, their body cramping (Jaka, 4 years old). He was playing in the beach with his
continously, a foam like liquid comes out from their old brother when suddenly stung by jellyfish on his
mouth. Finally, they die during the evacuation into the feet. Soon, he getting unconscious, his left tight and
local health facility (Radar Banyuwangi, 05/06/2008 genital are getting reddish. By the time running, they
and 05/07/2008). Another case which occur in Jebus change into bluish. He also dies during the evacuation
Radar
Mlandingan, 19 years old
05/06/2008 1 Physalia utriculus Banyuwangi
Situbondo boy die
05/06/2008
Radar
Banyuputih, 10 years old
04/07/2008 1 Physalia utriculus Banyuwangi
Situbondo boy die
05/07/2008
Parangtritis
Severe pain, Waskita,
19/07/2009 and Samas Tens Physalia utriculus
unconcscious 2009
beach, Bantul
Glagah Indah
and Trisik Asphyxia, Kuntadi,
23/09/2009 Tens Chrysaora quinquecirrha
beach, unconscious 2009
Kulonprogo
Pikiran
Pangandaran Almost
02/10/2009 1 - Rakyat
beach, Ciamis unconscious
03/10/2009
2
Jurnal Ilmiah Perikanan dan Kelautan Vol. 2,No. 1, April 2010
into the local health facility. Fortunately, his brother The classification of both species are as
survive (Bangka Pos, 07/10/2008). follow (Boullion et al., 2006; Arai, 1997) :
Several cases from foreign countries also Class : Hydrozoa Scyphozoa
reported. At least 3 deaths have occurred due to Order : Cystonecta Semaeostomeae
Physalia species since 1989 in USA (Daubert, 2008; Family : Physaliidae Pelagiidae
Burnett & Gable, 1989; Stein et al., 1989). About 500 Genus : Physalia Chrysaora
cases of Physalia species sting also reported from Species :Physalia utriculus, Physalia physalis,
Western and Southern Australia with several fatalities Chrysaora quinquecirrha
in Western hemisphere (Goggin et al., 2004). In the Physalia utriculus : Siphonophores with a
tropics, most cases occurred in summer months, while relatively large asymetric horizontal pneumatophore,
in Australia common in many months in the year purplish blue in color, up to 10-15 cm in length, top of
(Fenner, 1997). Over 100 people were stung by the pneumatophore formed by an erectile “sail”
Chrysaora quinquecirrha at Yorktown Beach, Virginia- running diagonally, cornidia attached to one side of the
USA on July 4, 2009 which it also in summer month. float, a single large deep blue fishing tentacle hangs
No fatalities reported (Cawley, 2009). beneath the bell, this is retractile and curled up to a few
At least 30 species of stinging planktonic centimetres or extended 10 metres in length. It
jellyfish are known as well as the grade of injury and surrounded by a number of smaller and shorter, fine
geographical distribution (see Table 2. for details). pale-blue tentacles (Goggin et al., 2004, Bouillon et
Three species of jellyfish which reported as a al., 2004) (see Figure 1.A for details).
cause of accident in Indonesia also listed in the table. Physalia physalis : Siphonophores with a
relatively large asymetric horizontal pneumatophore,
purplish blue in color, up to 30 cm in length.
CUBOZOA
Carukia barnesi
2 + + Marsh & Smith, 1986
(irukandji)
Chironex fleckeri
1 + + Marsh & Smith, 1986; Burke, 2002
(sea warsp)
3
Jellyfish Sting ......
Distribution
Class/species Grade References
NA SP NP SP IO
HYDROZOA
Leuckartiara gardiner
3 + Marsh & Smith, 1986
(little red stinger)
Physalia physalis
1 + + + + + Marsh & Smith, 1986; Woodcock, 1997
(Portuguese man of war)
Physalia utriculus
2 + + Goggin et al., 2004
(blue bottle)
SCYPHOZOA
Catostylus mosaicus
3 + + + Halstead, 1971
(mosaic sea jelly)
Cyanea mjobergi
2 + Marsh & Smith, 1986
(hairy stinger)
Phyllorhiza punctata
2 + + Marsh & Smith, 1986
(spotted jellyfish)
Pseudorhiza haeckeli
2 + Marsh & Smith, 1986
(net patterned jellyfish)
Chrysaora hysoscella
2 + Burke, 2002
(sea nettle)
Chrysaora lactea
2 + + Burke, 2002
(sea nettle)
4
Jurnal Ilmiah Perikanan dan Kelautan Vol. 2,No. 1, April 2010
Distribution
Class/species Grade References
NA SP NP SP IO
Pneumatophore enantiomorphic, two forms, each the were shallow notches. In each octant three large
mirror image of the other, top of the pneumatophore tentacles and usually two or sometimes four smaller
formed by an erectile “sail” running diagonally. There ones issuing from subumbrella side of the rhopalar
are many (up to 7-8) retractile large fishing tentacle, lappets tentacles arise from the umbrella margin
may reach extended length of 30 meters. It surrounded between the clefts of lappets, oral arm long, pointed,
by a number of smaller and shorter, fine pale-blue much folded. Colour very variable, usually rather pale,
tentacles (Goggin et al., 2004, Bouillon et al., 2004) yellowish or pink, sometimes in radiating stripes
(see Figure 1.B for details). (Kramp,1961) (see Figure 1.C for details).
Chrysaora quinquecirrha : Semaeostomeae Jellyfish can be subdivided into three main
in which the central stomach gives rise to completely group, based on the symptoms they caused : those
separated, unbranched radiating pouches, without a causing human fatalities, those causing severe
ring canal. Umbrella up to 25 cm wide, marginal envenomation with systemic effects and those causing
lappets semicircular or tongue-shaped the lappet-clefts nuisance stings (Fenner, 1998). A jellyfish tentacle
of primary and secondary tentacles deep, the tertiary contains huge numbers of stinging cells arranged in
Figure 1. Three stinging jellyfish which reported for causing several accidents. A) Physalia utriculus
(source: Waikiki Aquarium Education Department, 2009); B) Physalia physalis
(source : Bouillon et al., 2004); C) Chrysaora quinquecirrha (source : Calder, 2008)
Figure 2. A) Non active nematocysts, B) Active nematocysts; C) Barbed threads passing through skin tissue
5
Jellyfish Sting ......
clusters called “batteries”. Activated by touch or Burnett et al (1983) reported that baking soda (Sodium
chemical cues, the nematocysts in the stinging cells bicarbonate/NaHCO3) was an effective nematocyst
fire. Barbed threads deliver toxin that may affect the inhibitor for Chrysaora quinquecirrha. Paramedics in
victim's muscles, nerves and other tissues (Waikiki Yorktown Beach mix them with Acetic acid
Aquarium Education Department, 2009) (see Figure 2. (CH3COOH) in sterile water for curing the victims
for details). (Cawley, 2009). It is not recommended to use vinegar
During discharge, many nematocysts inject because it might precipitate nematocyst firing (Little,
venom, including inert fluids, salts and toxins, some 2008).
materials having a known negative influence on Meanwhile the victims due the sting of
biological systems. Injury may occur directly by action Physalia utriculus are reported from six places (Sanur,
of the toxins or indirectly by involvement of immune Depok, Teleng Ria, Parangtritis, Samas and
reactions. Most toxins are proteinaceous molecules, Widarapayung) with no fatalities occurred, the victims
many of which target plasma membranes (Arai, 1997). due the sting of Physalia physalis are reported from two
Jellyfish toxin can be classified according to their places (Mlandingan and Banyuputih) which both are
works : neurotoxic which attacks nerves, cardiotoxic fatal. Firdaus (10 years) and Junaidi (19 years) are
which attacks the heart; dermatonecrotic which swimming in the beach while suddenly they stung by
destroy skin; cytotoxic which destroy body cells and jellyfish. They felt burnt and itchy on the skin, back
haemolytic which destroy blood cells (Goggin et al., pain, abdomen and feet are getting reddish with caused
2004; Arai, 1997). by the sting. Their body spasming, a foam like fluid
Victims due the sting of Chrysaora coming out from the mouth and getting unconscious.
quinquecirrha are reported from Glagah and Jebus. A Their friends evacuated and treated using beach sand
woman who have been stung in Glagah said that her for smearing their body. They transported to local
feet felt burning and tender from the wound caused by medical facility, however, they die during this
jellyfish sting. Two other victims suffered from evacuation (Radar Banyuwangi, 06 June 2008; 05 July
asphyxia and getting unconscious. However, after 2008). Toxin of Physalia work as carditoxic,
having medical treatment, both are recover from haemolytic and dermatonecrotic (Alam & Qasim,
unconscious and healing (Kuntadi, 2009). A four years 1991). Physalia utriculus stings are usually somewhat
old child from Jebus who stung by this species on his painful, but bearable and not too severe. Pain is also
feet and genital suddenly getting unconscious. His feet often felt in the draining lymph glads, in the groin if the
and genital are getting reddish which soon change into legs are stung, and the arm pit if the upper limbs are
bluish. These symptoms are believed to be caused by stung. Physalia phisalis stings are more painful. There
jellyfish sting as said by local doctor. Even having is usually pain in the draining lymph glands and often
medical treatment, this child cannot survive (Bangka nausea, back pain, muscle cramps in the limbs,
Pos, 07 October 2008). Toxin of Chrysaora abdomen and chest, which cause painful breathing.
quinquecirrha work as haemolytic, dermatonecrotic General symptom are blistering and intense pain in
and cytotoxic agent (Balamurugan et al., 2009). near-by muscle, general paralysis, intense general
General symptoms are sudden burning, as pain spreads distress and weakness, particularly breathing difficulty
leading to muscle cramps and excruiating pains across (Fenner, 1998; 2000). The case from Mlandingan and
the lower back after 15 minutes so that patients being Banyuputih showed that the toxin of Physalia phisalis
hysterical. Restlessness, weakness and mental is powerful to kill young and mature person. In
deperession may follow a severe sting. Constriction of Australia, particularly on the east coast, up to 10.000
the throat and chest with constant coughing and a stings occur each summer from Physalia spp. alone.
profuse discharge from the noose and eyes may occur. More stings occur in South Australia and Western
Nausea and vomiting can occur. The sting is followed Australia. Three fatal envenomations from Physalia
by grossly raised red weels, which swell, weep like phisalis have been reported from Florida and North
eczema and blister, taking two or three weeks to heal Carolina, in the United States and both sides of the
(Marsh & Smith, 1986). Some of these symptoms are Atlantic (Fenner & Williamson, 1996). For treating the
occur to the victims reported above. The child dies victims, it is necessary to use hot water (60oC) to rinse
probably because of his immunity system is not the wound. As most toxins are proteinaceous
develop yet compare to older victims from Glagah, so molecules, heating can be denature the structure and
the toxin's effect are much powerful. However, there is reduce it's effect (Halstead, 1971; Taylor, 2007;
no report of medical treatment applied for them. Daubert, 2008). Vinegar or Acetic acid (CH3COOH) in
6
Jurnal Ilmiah Perikanan dan Kelautan Vol. 2,No. 1, April 2010
solutions of 4-6% is the most widely accepted Balamurugan, E., Kumar, D.R, and Menon, V.P. 2009.
treatment of initial stings. Pour vinegar over adhering P r o a p o p t o t i c e ff e c t o f C h r y s a o r a
tentacles for at least 30 seconds. In the absence of quinquecirrha (Sea Nettle) Nematocyst
vinegar, Coca cola or old wine may be used (Fenner et venom peptide in HEp 2 and HeLa Cells.
al., 1993; Fenner, 1997; Daubert, 2008). European Journal of Scientific
Other first aid measures for jellyfish sting Research 35 (3) : 355-367.
have been advocated, including urinating on tentacles, Bali Post. 30 July 2005. Stinging jellyfish making a
use of papain containing meat tenderizer, aluminium rare and hopefully short appearance along
sulfate (Al2(SO4)3, alcohol/ethanol (C2H5OH), sodium Bali's Sanur beach.
hypochlorite (NaClO) bleach, Ammonia (NH3), Bangka Post. 07 October 2008. Balita tewas
gasoline/kerosene and rubbing sand on the involved akibat ubur-ubur saat mandi di pantai
area (Burke, 2002). Bembang.
There are several procedures advocated by Bouillon, J., Medel, M.D., Pages,F., Gili, J.M.,
Halstead (1971), Fenner (1998) and Goggin et al Boero, F., and Gravili, C. 2004. Fauna of
(2004) which can prevent and keeping save from the Mediterranean Hydrozoa. Scientia
jellyfish sting: Marina 68 (Suppl. 2): 5-438.
1. Wearing tight-fitting long woolen underwear or Bouillon, J., Gravili, C., Pages,F., Pili, J.M., and
rubber skin diving suits, Boero, F. 2006. An Introduction to
2. Wearing other equipment such diving shoes and Hydrozoa. Memoires du Museum Nacional
head protector like helmet if you want to dive with d'Histoire Naturelle 194. 591pp.
your head drown into the water, Brodeur, R.D., Mills, C.E., Overland, J.E.,
3. Swim in supervised areas such as a beach where Walters, G.E. and Schumacher, J.D. 1999.
lifeguards monitor the presence of dangerous Evidence for a substantial increase in
jellyfish, gelatinous zooplankton in the Bering Sea,
4. Obey warning signs (advising of dangerous with possible links to climate
jellyfish) change. Fisheries Oceanography. 8 (4) : 296-
5. Swim in stinger-resistant nets, if available. 306.
Burke, W.A. 2002. Cnidarians and human skin.
Summary Dermatologic Therapy 15: 18-25.
During the years 2005 to 2009, there are Burnett, J.W., Cobbs, C.S., Kelman, S.N and
thirteen cases of jellyfish sting reported from Calton, G.J. 1983. Studies on serologic
Indonesian waters with three fatal cases occurred in response to jellyfish envenomations. Journal
Jebus and Situbondo. At least three species of jellyfish American Academy of Dermatology 9 : 223-
suspected responsible for these case Physalia 231.
utriculus, Physalia physalis and Chrysaora Burnett, J.W., and Gable, W.D. 1989. A fatal
quinquecirrha. All case occurred between June to jellyfish envenomation by the Portuguese
October which is in dry season in Indonesia. man-o-war. Toxicon 27 : 823-824.
Calder, D.R. 2008. An Illustrated key to Cubozoan and
References Scyphozoan jellyfish of the South Atlantic
Adi, O.N. 2007. Ubur-ubur Api Serang Pantai Pacitan. Bight. Southeastern Regional Taxonomic
http://surabaya.detik.com/read/2007/07/21/ C e n t e r ( S E RT C ) , S o u t h C a r o l i n a
15312 0/807738/475/ubur-ubur-api- Department of Natural Resources. 18pp.
serang-pantai-pacitan. 21 July 2007. Daubert, G.P. 2008. Cnidaria Envenomation.
18/02/2010. h t t p : / / e m e d i c i n e .
Alam, J.M and Qasim, R. 1991. Toxicology of Medscape.com/article/769538-overview.
Physalia's (Portuguese man-o'war) Updated: Aug 18, 2008. 18/02/2010.
venom. Pakistan Journal of Pharmaceutical Fenner, P.J., Williamson, J.A., Burnett, J.W and
Sciences 4(2) : 159–168. Rifkin, J. 1993. First aid treatment of
Arai, M.N. 1997. A functional biology of Scyphozoa. jellyfish stings in Australia : response to a
Champman and Hall. 316 pp. newly differentiated species. Medical
Journal of Australia 158 : 498-501.
7
Jellyfish Sting ......
Fenner, P.J. 1997. Awareness, prevention and treatment Kuntadi. 2009. Sengatan Ubur-ubur Serang
of world-wide marine stings and bites. Wisatawan Pantai Glagah.
Proceedings International Live Saving http://news.okezone.com/read/2009/09/24/3
Federation Medical/Rescue Conference. 1- 40/259634/340/sengatan-ubur-ubur-serang-
12. wisatawan-pantai-glagah. 24 September
Fenner, P.J and Williamson, J.A. 1996. Worldwide 2009. 18/02/2010.
deaths and severe envonomation from Little, M. 2008. First aid for jellyfish stings: Do we
jellyfish stings. Medical Journal of Australia really know what we are doing? Emergency
165 : 11-12. Medicine Australasia 20: 78-80.
Fenner, P.J. 1997. The Global Problem of Cnidarian Marsh, L and Slack-Smith, S. 1986. Sea Stingers and
(Jellyfish) Stinging. M.D. Thesis, University Other Venomous and Poisonous Marine
of Lodon. 205pp. Invertebrates of Western Australia Museum.
Fenner, P.J. 1998. Dangers in the ocean: the Perth. 133pp.
traveler and marine envenomation. I. Mills, C.E. 2001. Jellyfish blooms: are populations
Jellyfish. Medical Journal of Australia 5 increasing globally in response to changing
:135-141. ocean conditions? Hydribiologia. 451: 55-
Fenner, P.J. 2000. Physalia Species: Physalia 68.
utriculus – T h e “ B l u e b o t t l e ” . Pikiran Rakyat. 03 October 2009. Warga padati objek
h t t p : / / w w w . m a r i n e - wisata.
medic.com.au/pages/biology/biologyBreak Purcell, J.E. 2005. Climate effect on formation of
up/physalia.pdf 17/02/2010. jellyfish and ctenophore blooms: a review.
Goggi, L., Gershwin, L., Fenner, P., Seymour, J. and Journal of Marine Biology Association of
Carrette, T. 2004. Stinging Jellyfish in United Kingdom. 85: 461-476.
tropical Australia (brochure). CRC Reef Radar Banyuwangi. 05 June 2008. Tewas disengat
Research Centre. ubur-ubur.
Graham, W.M., Pag'es, F., and Hamner, W.M. 2001. A Radar Banyuwangi. 05 July 2008. Bocah SD Tewas
physical context for gelatinous zooplankton Disengat Ubur-ubur.
aggregations : a review. Hydrobiologia 451 : Republika. 24 September 2009. Wisatawan pantai
199-212. Widarapayung diserang ubur-ubur.
Halstead, B.W. 1971. Venomous Coelenterates: Stein, M.R., Marraccini, J.V., Rothschild, N.E. and
Hydroids, Jellyfishes, Corals and Sea Burnett, J.W. 1989. Fatal Portuguese man-o'-
Anemones. In : Bucherl, W and Buckley, E.E war (Physalia physalis) envenomation.
(eds). Venomous A n i m a l s a n d T h e i r Annals of Emergency Medicine 18 (3) : 312-
Ve n o m s . Vo l u m e I I I : Ve n o m o u s 315.
Invertebrates. Academic Press. New York. Utsntoro, A. 2007. Puluhan wisatawan Parangtitis
395-417. tersengat ubur-ubur. Media Indonesia. 12
Heru, C.N. 2009. Pengunjung Parangtritis diminta August 2007.
waspadai serangan ubur-ubur. http://ip52- Uye, S. 2008. Blooms of the giant jellyfish
210.cbn.id/hg/nusa/2009/09/22/brk,20090 Nemopilema nomurai: a threat to the
22-199027,id.html. 22 September 2009. fisheries sustainability of the East Asian
18/02/2010. Marginal Seas. Plankton Benthos Research
Hughes, S. (2006). Impacts of Climate Change on Sea 3(Suppl.): 125-131.
Temperature in Marine Climate Change Wakiki Aquarium Education Department, 2009.
Impact Annual Report Card 2006 (Eds. Marine Life Profile: Indo-Pacific Portuguese
Buckley, P.J, Dye, S.R. and Baxter, J.M), Man-Of-War. 4pp.
Online Summary Reports, M C C I P , Waskita, D. 2009. Teror Ubur-ubur Melanda Pantai
Lowestoft, www.mccip.org.uk. 18/02/2010. Parangtritis.http://news.okezone.com/read/2
Jon Cawley. Look Out! Jellyfish Hordes Back For 009/07/20/1 /2402 98/1/teror-ubur-ubur-
Another Summer. Daily Press. July 11, 2009. melanda-pantai-parangtritis. 20 July 2009.
18/02/2010.
8
Jurnal Ilmiah Perikanan dan Kelautan Vol. 2,No. 1, April 2010
Werdiono, D. 2007. Kompas. 09 July 2007.”Balon Wulan, M.K. 2009. Lima wisatawan terseret ombak,
biru”, ubur-ubur lucu yang bikin gatal. 64 tersengat ubur-ubur.
Woodcock, A.H. 1997. Why sailing sea animals h a v e http://oase.kompas.com/read/2009/09/27/22
mirror images. Pacific Science 51 (1) :12-17. 061990/lima.wisatawan.terseret.ombak.64.
tersengat.ubur-ubur. 27 September 2009.
18/02/2010.