Professional Documents
Culture Documents
15.1 INTRODUCTION
Structures such as chimneys, which are in the form of a cylindrical shaft rising from the ground,
are generally founded on an annular or circular raft (Figure 15.1). Similarly, in the case of an
elevated circular water tank supported by a number of columns positioned along a circle, the
columns rest on a ring beam with a slab below the beam. The slab below acts as a circular raft.
For the conventional design of this water tank foundation, the design of the ring beam is taken
separately and assumed to transmit a uniform line load on to the annular raft. The annular raft
is designed to carry this line load. In other places where the dimension of the annular raft is
much greater than that of the vertical shaft as may be the case in a chimney, a frustum of a cone
can be introduced in between as shown in Figure 15.1(c).
In this chapter, we first examine the formulae for the design of the annular raft subjected
to a "circular line load." We will also examine the formulae for the design of the ring beam
supported on columns. A detailed analysis of the subject is given in Refs. [1] and [2],
Computer-based elastic design is given in Ref. [3].
211
212 Design of Reinforced Concrete Foundations
(c) (d)
Figure 15.1 Annular rafts in foundations: (a) Chimney foundation, (b) Water tank with ring
beam on annular raft foundation, (c) Enlargement by conical structure on annular
foundation, (d) Definition of outer radius a, loading radius b = /3a and inner radius
c = aa. Any general radius r = pa.
b = fia =
J" q0r2 dr ÿ ( J>
a - c„3
N
2 c-"3)
(15,)
f a
I qQrdr
~2
a -c
2
-3°ÿ
Jr.
This positioning will give uniform pressure under dead load. We can also prove that an
annular raft with the above positioning of load is much superior to a full circular raft without
a central hole. It will not only save material but also lead to a more uniform distribution of the
Circular and Annular Rafts 213
base pressure in cohesive soils. This prevents tilling due to non-uniform pressure and
settlement. There will also be no reversal of bending moment (in such annular rafts), along its
radius as compared to full circle rafts. The reversal of bending moment makes it difficult to
place reinforcements in the slab. It has been also found that it is best to keep the size or annular
ratio (inner to outer) about 0.4.
do
n \ \ \
' t
(b)
ÿrrrTTTfl (c>
<7i
Figure 15.2 Ground reaction pressure due to vertical load and moment: (a) Load and
moment on annular raft, (b) Uniform ground pressure due to vertical load,
(c) Nonuniform ground pressure of opposing signs due to moment.
For a uniform pressure under the dead load and the varying pressure under moments, the
formulae for the calculation of shear and moments by approximate method will be as follows.
Let q0 be the uniform pressure due to the dead load and ± q{ the maximum pressure due
to wind moment as shown in Figure 15.2.
The following are the values for shears and moments per unit length at any radius r. Let
r = pa or p = r/a. The pressure is from the bottom of the slab upwards and we take positive
moment as that which produces tension at the bottom.
p -a (15.4a)
(r < h) Q inner part = q{)a
2P
1 -fa¬
(r > b) Q outer part = - q0a (15.4b)
2p
p" -Qp-2a)cc
(r < b) Mr inner part = qf)az (15.4c)
6p
Case 2; Approximate shears and moments (Q and Mr) due to external moment producing
maximum pressure qx
p* - (4/3 - 3or)o3
(r < b) Mr inner part = q xa~ 12p
cos 6 (15.5c)
p (4p - 3ar)
(r > b) Mr outer part = qÿai cos 6 (15.5d)
12p
zone 1 zone 1
(1) Radial moment Mr
(2) Tangential
moment M, zone 2 zone 2
and
(3) Shear (2r
Note: The formulae have been derived in terms of radius 'a' and the following non-
dimensional parameters (Figure 15.1(d)):
216 Design of Reinforced Concrete Foundations
15.7.1 Chu and Afandi's Formulae for Analysis of Circular Rafts Subjected to Vertical Loads
(Chimney simply supported by slab; for circular raft, put b = 0) [2]
c b v
a = —\p=—\ p = —\fi = 0.15 (Only p is variable)
a a a
where
3 +p 8 a log, a 2 1-p
K, =2(1 + or) - 8(1 + log, p) (15.6d)
l+p I-a2 l+ p
Mr2 =ÿbr[4(3
64
+ Aft - 16(1 + A log, p - 8(3 + A + 2(1 + AA' - (1 - p)K2'pr2]
2
W, =ÿ_[4(1 + 3AP2 - 16(1 + A log, P - 8(1 + 3//) + 2(1 + p)K{ + (1 - p)Kfpr2\
64
(Tangential moment) (15.7b)
Qr2=*f(p-p-') 05.7c)
where
K{ = K] + 8(1 + log, A (1 - a2) (15-7d)
K{ = K2 - 8/?(l - a2) (15.7e)
15.7.2 Chu and Afandi's Formulae for Analysis of Circular Rafts Subjected to Moment
(Chimney simply supported to slab; for circular raft, put b = 0)
Zone 1 (r < b) (Let q = maximum pressure due to moment when cos 6 = 1 and 0=0 with
respect to the direction of the moment, say, due to the wind, 6 is the angle with xx axis.)
The wind can blow from any direction. Hence wind from right to left and left to right must
be considered along with the effect of q0.
Values of radial moment, tangential moment and shear can be calculated from the
following formulae for zone 1: (These varies with cos 6.)
where
(\-/u \
-8 14
aA } ti+A (15.8d)
1,3 4 ft) 14 a2) (34/z J
4 (3 + p [2 + p
A-4=3/SV-ÿ 1 -<u
48
,1+ a2 J (15.8e)
K« = 12a4 (15.80
Zone 2 (r > b) Values of Ml2, Mr2 and Qr2 can be obtained from the above equations also by
using the following arbitrary constants instead of K3, K4 and K5
218 Design of Reinforced Concrete Foundations
(15.9a)
Kf = 12.0 (15.9c)
(a)
Distribution
of torsional
moment
Distribution
of BM ÿ
(c)
Figure 15.3 Annular raft foundation: (a) General arrangement for a circular water tank.
[(T) Column, (2) Ring beam, (3) Annular raft], (b) Ring foundation, (c) Bending
moment and torsional moment in a ring beam on four supports (n = 4).
As the beam is fixed at the column, the maximum positive (sagging) moment will be at
the centre of the beam, the maximum negative (logging) moment at the support. The torsional
moment is maximum between the columns. The angle at which the torsional moment is
maximum measured from the centre line of supports (columns), is designated as G0. The
distribution of bending moments and torsion is shown in Figure 15.3 for four supports. These
maximum values can be obtained from the following expressions:
Sagging (+ve) moment at mid-span = 2wr2a,A1 (15.11a)
Hogging (-ve) moment at support = IwÿaAi (15.11b)
Maximum torsional moment = 2wPaAÿ (15.11c)
where Aj, Ai and A3 are coefficients, given in Table 15.2.
The values of Ah Aq_, /I3 and 0O for various conditions of supports can be tabulated as in
Table 15.2.
TABLE 15.2 Coefficients for Bending and Twisting Moments in Circular Beams
No. of
supports (n) 2 a (degrees) A, As <90 (degrees)
4 90 0.070 0.137 0.021 19.25
5 72 0.054 0.108 0.014 15.25
6 60 0.045 0.089 0.009 12.75
1 51.43 0.037 0.077 0.007 10.75
8 45 0.033 0.066 0.005 9.5
9 40 0.030 0.060 0.004 8.5
10 36 0.027 0.054 0.003 7.5
12 30 0.023 0.045 0.002 6.25
- -J
— ©
Binders
r. . 1
Figure 15.4 Detailing of annular raft foundation for a circular water tank: (1) Column,
(2) Ring beam, (3) Annular raft.
Circular and Annular Rafts 221
15.12 SUMMARY
Annular rafts and full circle rafts are used in many situations such as foundations. The basic
principles of their design are described in this chapter.
EXAMPLE 15.1 (Design of annular raft for a chimney)
A chimney one metre thick and of mean radius 8 m has a weight of 30000 kN. The weight of
the soil above the foundation is estimated as 1000 kN. The moment due to wind is 8600 kN.
Design an annular raft for the foundation assuming a safe bearing capacity of 85 kN/m2 for the
222 Design of Reinforced Concrete Foundations
dead load and an increase of 20% for the wind load. Grade 20 concrete and Fe 415 steel are
to be used.
~Total, foundation
*
, - area , 30000 + 1000 = 365 m
required = -
85
ÿ
2
31000 8600x11.3
q ~
370 12.726
= 83.78 ± 7.64
Max pressure = 91.42 kN/m2 < 1.20 x 85 (i.e. < 102 kN/m2)
Min pressure = 75.14 kN/m2 is +ve.
4 Calculate pressure with factored loads for design
1.5x30000 n
[Note: The types of tabular forms Tables El5.1 to El5.4 are necessary
for the analysis of a full circular raft as there can be reversals of
Mr and M,.] However, for an annular raft, we need to calculate the
following quantities only:
(1) Radial bending moment Mr at the junctions of the chimney with
the raft (inner and outer junctions). Mrp and also at Mri (outer
edge)
(2) Tangential bending moment Mrl (outer end); M,a at inner edge
and M,p at loading points
(3) Q at Qp
For the given annular raft with the inner radius 3.1 m, we start our
calculation with radius 3.5 m. We calculate for radii 3.5 m, 4 m, 6 m,
7.5 m, 8.5 m, 9 m, 10 m and 11.3 m. For r = 3.5 m, r = 3.5la = 3.5/1 1.3
8 m assumed = 0.31. Let the chimney have a thickness of 1 m with centre line at
in Step 1 8 m. Thus, we find the moments, shears at 7.5 and 8.5 m the meeting
points of the chimney with the raft.
6 (Let chimney he loaded at 7.5-8.5 m radius)
Tabulate values of Mr, M, and Qr using formulae and also maximum
values as in Tables E15.1 to E15.4.
[Note: As the wind can blow from any direction, we should consider
(a) wind from left to right and (b) wind from right to left to find
whether there is any reversal of moments in the raft. If there is
reversal, designed steel should be provided on top and bottom of the
raft. The following tabular form is needed for the design of full rafts
only].
TABLE E15.1 Calculation of Radial Moment Mr by Eqs. (15.6) and (15.7) for Factored Load
DL
WL
Total
DL
WL to left
WL to right
Total
224 Design of Reinforced Concrete Foundations
TABLE E15.4 Summary of Max +ve and -we Moments and Shear Along Radius
(Assumed Values)
Radius r (m) II
Mr = (kNm/m) M, = (kNm/m) Q (kN)
3.5 0.310 30 -4.87 200
4.0 0.354 - - —
6.0 0.531 - — —
7.5 0.664 1025.0 + 19.3 480
8.5 0.752 580.0 + 18.0 430
10.0 0.885 103.0 - —
11.3 1.000 -0.3 105 0
(Note: For positive moment, we provide steel at the bottom and for negative steel, we provide steel at
the top.)
, 0.9x1000 x 800 2
- 7200 mm
ÿ
A, = -
100
10 Design for M,
M, is -ve (steel at top near the interior) and M, is +ve in the interior.
M, @ inner edge = 480 kNm/m
M 480 xlO6
Table B.l —- = - = 0.664
bd 1000 x 800 x 800
Percentage of steel required = 0.187
0.187x1000 x 800 t Jn, 2
Ar=- = 1496 mm
100
Provide 16 mm @ 125 mm giving 1608 mm2
11 Find or estimate tangential steel at other places and detail steel
Nominal steel @ 0.12%
0.12x1000 x 800 2
=-= 960 mm"
100
Provide distribution steel as 16 mm @ 200 mm giving 1005 mm2. •
EXAMPLE 15.2 (Design of ring beam over an annular raft for a circular water tank)
The load from a circular water tank supported by six columns rests on a ring beam, which, in
turn, rests on an annular raft. Assuming the near diameter of the centres of column line is 8 m
and the total load from the tank is 30,000 kN, design the ring beam.
4-
226 Design of Reinforced Concrete Foundations
i. 1 4 x 30
a = 30° = --= 0.5233 radians
180
30 000 59?kN/m
w = =
7TX. 16
Find max +ve moment at centre of beam
(a) M +ve = wFaXx
= (2 x 597 x 64 x 0.5233) 2,
= 39991 x 0.045 = 1799 kNm
Sec. 15.8 (b) M -ve = 39991 x ÿ (0.089) = 3559 kNm
(c) Max torsion at &= 12.75°
T = 39991 x Xi (0.009) = 360 kNm
(d) Shear =
Load
2 ÿ |2xÿx8x 6x2
597
= 2500 kN at support
Design of beam
The beam is above the annular foundation. It can be designed as a T
beam with the tension reinforcement placed just above the bottom
reinforcement of the annular raft. The raft itself can be of sloping
section as shown in Figure 15.3(a).
Assume width more than the size of the column and design the beam
for the above bending moments, shear and torsion (as per normal
cases).
REFERENCES
[1] Manohar, S.N., Tall Chimneys, Tata McGraw Hill (Torsteel Research Foundation of
India), New Delhi, 1985.
[2] Chu, R.H. and O.F. Afandi, Analysis of Circular and Annular Slabs for Chimney
Foundations, Journal American Concrete Institute, Vol. 63, December 1966.
[3] Hemsley, J.A., Elastic Analysis of Raft Foundations, Thomas Telford, London, 1998.
[4] IS 11089 (1984), Code of Practice for Design and Construction of Ring Foundation, BIS,
New Delhi.