Professional Documents
Culture Documents
danger situations
Stockholm 2016
Electromagnetism Engineering
School of Electrical Engineering
Kungliga Tekniska Högskolan
Abstract
The fast growing field of wearable technologies has a big impact in antenna research.
Antennas integrated into clothing for body centric communications allow the user’s
situation to be measured without restricting his activities. Implementing textile
antennas to operate as personal transmitters for existing satellite communication
systems increases its availability and uses, specially localized in places where mobile
communications infrastructures are not developed but satellite communications has
a full coverage.
The aim of this thesis is to design and manufacture a system of two fully textile
microstrip antennas: a GPS antenna with right hand circular polarization operat-
ing at 1.575 GHz and a PLB antenna operating at 406MHz working as a distress
beacon for Cospas-Sarsat search and rescue international programme. We describe
the design, manufacture and performance of both antennas, as well as the material
used as a key choice for textile antennas.
Antennas were measured with a near field scanner to evaluate their performance
which resulted to be working at the established operational frequency with a good
matching and the expected radiation patterns from the simulations and studied lit-
erature. Further development regarding the feeding circuit of the GPS antenna is
needed to ensure its circular polarization.
I
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank my friends for everything we have lived together and new
experiences yet to come. I am also thankful to my newest friends for this experience
in Stockholm and making my stay at KTH unforgettable. A very special dedication
to Laura for her patience, love and being always there for me besides the distance.
Anything is possible when we are surrounded by good friends.
Finally, I would also like to thank my family for their support and love during this
time. Special gratitude to my parents, Lourdes and Xavier, who have always en-
couraged me to study and believed in me, to my sister Mar for her unconditional
support during my whole life, to my brother Xavi for his life philosophy "Tot i res",
and to my grandma Rosa for her help, fast learning with new technologies and her
care despite the distance.
This accomplishment would not have been possible without them. Gràcies.
III
Contents
List of Tables XI
1 Introduction 1
1.1 Background and motivation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
1.2 Aim and objectives. Boundaries of the study . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
1.2.1 Boundaries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
1.3 Methodology. Report outline . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
1.3.1 Report outline . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
2 Background Theory 5
2.1 Antenna Parameters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
2.1.1 Radiation Pattern . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
2.1.2 Radiation Power Density . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
2.1.3 Radiation Intensity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
2.1.4 Directivity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
2.1.5 Efficiency . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7
2.1.6 Gain . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
2.1.7 Bandwidth . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
2.1.8 Bandwidth, Quality factor and Efficiency . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
2.1.9 Polarization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
2.1.10 Axial Ratio . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
2.1.11 Input impedance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11
2.1.12 SAR - Specific Absorption Rate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
2.1.13 Scattering Matrix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
2.2 Microstrip line . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
2.3 Microstrip Antennas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
2.3.1 Advantages and disadvantages . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
2.3.2 Feeding Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
2.3.3 Rectangular Patch . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
2.4 Communication Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
2.4.1 Introduction to satellites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
2.4.2 Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) . . . . . . . . . . 22
2.4.3 Cospas-Sarsat System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
V
Contents
Bibliography 67
VI
List of Figures
VII
List of Figures
VIII
List of Figures
IX
List of Figures
X
List of Tables
XI
List of Tables
XII
1
Introduction
Emergency beacons transmitters are carried aboard ships (EPIRBs), aircraft (ELTs),
or used as personal locator beacons (PLBs), and activated manually when needed.
EPIRBs and ELTs can be easily integrated in ships and aircraft’s structure but
PLBs need to be carried by the user. PLBs are similar to portable radios both in
terms of size and weight and are supposed to be carried in pockets or attached to
safe vests. They are sold as self standing transmitters [5] [6].
The integration of PLB transmitters as textile antennas could increase its availability
to non-professionals and its uses could be diversified adding new distress situations
as attacks or children and domestic abuse, specially localized in places where mobile
communications infrastructures are not developed but satellite communications has
a full coverage.
1
1. Introduction
There are two possible ways of combining these antennas for a proper localization.
• Independent: Both antennas work independently, PLB sends the distress sig-
nal and GPS is used for localization. In this case, localization can be done
with the PLB signal or using the GPS.
• Combination: GPS antenna is used to determine its location and after some
processing (out of the scope of the thesis), it is codified and transmitted
through the PLB distress signal allowing a simpler localization.
Frequency 1.565-1.585GHz
Axial Ratio <3dB
Polarization RHCP Frequency 406MHz
S11 <-15dB S11 <-15dB
S12 <-25dB S12 <-25dB
1.2.1 Boundaries
• The viability of the proposed system has not been consulted with Cospas-
Sarsat professionals.
• The thesis was focused on the design of the antennas, excluding the commu-
nication protocols, data processing and codification.
• Power supply and consumption of the antennas were not studied.
• Bending of the antennas, material degradation and weather changes have not
been taken into account.
• GPS antenna has not been designed for a specific positioning on the human
body.
2
1. Introduction
(a) Literature review: the first step to start this study was reading up some litera-
ture related to wearable antennas focusing on their designs and used materials,
as well as doing research about communication systems intended to rescue peo-
ple in distress situations. With all these information and help from a most
experienced person designing antennas as my supervisor, the purpose of the
thesis was established, a project plan and schedule were defined.
(b) Design and simulations: the following step was to select a suitable design
model to be implemented with CST Microwave Studio simulation software.
Parametrized simulations allowed us to dimension both antennas until reliable
results for a correct performance were achieved. This process was simultaneous
with the study of the materials that were characterized with some tests. Both
processes combined concluded to the final design for both (GPS and PLB) an-
tennas.
(c) Manufacture, measurements and results: based on the previous step, both anten-
nas were manufactured while checking that the characteristics followed during
the design remained intact. Finally, the antennas were tested to check if the
requirements for a proper performance were achieved. The use of some labora-
tory material as a Vector Analyser - Anritsu MS2026B and Signal Generator -
HP 8665B were required, as well as the Near Field Scanner for the final mea-
surements.
Figure 1.1: Scheme of the relevant steps followed during the project.
3
1. Introduction
4
2
Background Theory
This chapter summarizes the notions for comprehending the main concepts studied
for a correct design of the antennas and their integration to the existing commu-
nication systems. Firstly, a review of the fundamental parameters of antennas and
their mathematical derivations. Secondly, an overview of microstrip technology is
exposed to focus later on its characteristics which determine our design. Finally, a
description, functionality and requirements of the satellite communication systems
used by the antennas designed and manufactured.
5
2. Background Theory
W =E ×H (2.1)
1 1
W = E × H = Re[E × H ∗ ] + Re[E × Hej2wt ] (2.2)
2 2
The total power crossing a closed surface can be obtained integrating the normal
component of the Poynting vector over the surface:
‹
P = W · ds (2.3)
S
The radiation pattern represents the average power density radiated by the antenna
as a function of direction.
6
2. Background Theory
U = r2 Wrad (2.5)
where U is the radiation intensity and Wrad is the radiation density.
The radiation intensity is related to the far-zone electric field of an antenna so the
total power can be derived from its mathematical expression:
‹ ˆ 2 ˆ π
Prad = U dW = π U sinθdθdφ (2.6)
0 0
W
2.1.4 Directivity
Directivity of an antenna is defined as "the ratio of the radiation intensity in a given
direction from the antenna to the radiation intensity averaged over all directions"
according to [7]. Therefore, the directivity of a nonisotropic source is equal to the
ratio of its radiation intensity in a given direction over the radiation intensity of an
isotropic source.
U 4πU
D= = (2.7)
U0 Prad
where
ˆ 2π ˆ π
Prad = U sinθdθdφ (2.8)
0 0
and
U = B0 F (θ, φ) (2.9)
so we can compute a general expression for the directivity
F (θ, φ)
D(θ, φ) = 4π ´ 2π ´ π (2.10)
0 0
F (θ, φ)sinθdθdφ
If the direction is not specified, it implies the direction of maximum directivity that
can be expressed as
U |max 4πUmax
Dmax = D0 = = (2.11)
U0 Prad
2.1.5 Efficiency
The efficiency of an antenna expresses the losses at the input terminals and within
the structure of the antenna.
In general can be written as
et = er ec ed (2.12)
7
2. Background Theory
where et is the total efficiency, er is the mismatch between the transmission line and
the antenna, ec is the conduction efficiency and ed in the dielectric efficiency.
The mismatch efficiency can be easily computed as
e0 = (1 − |Γ|2 ) (2.13)
2.1.6 Gain
The absolute gain of an antenna in a given direction is the ratio of the intensity to
the radiation intensity if the antenna radiated isotropically, in a given direction [7].
It can be expressed as
2.1.7 Bandwidth
The bandwidth of an antenna is the range of frequencies which the performance of
the antenna is reliable according to some characteristics (input impedance, radiation
pattern, polarization, directivity...) [7].
fmax − fmin
BW = · 100 (2.19)
fc
8
2. Background Theory
For broadband antennas, the bandwidth is expressed as the ratio of the upper-to-
lower frequencies of operation.
fmax
BW = :1 (2.20)
fmin
1 1 1 1 1
= + + + (2.21)
Qt Qrad Qc Qd Qsw
For a very thin substrate (h λ0 ), Qrad is the dominant factor which can be
calculated as
2ωr W
Qrad = (2.22)
hGrad
for a rectangular patch operating in the dominant T M010 mode where Grad is the
conductance across the gap between the patch and the ground plane.
In general, the bandwidth is proportional to the volume. For a rectangular mi-
1
crostrip antenna means that the bandwidth is inversely proportional to √ . In
r
this case, the bandwidth increases as the substrate height increases.
The radiation efficiency of an antenna can be also expressed in terms of quality
factors
Qt
ecdsw = (2.23)
Qrad
2.1.9 Polarization
The polarization of an antenna is defined as "the polarization of the wave transmitted
in the direction of the maximum gain" [7].
Polarization of a radiated wave is defined as the property of an electromagnetic
wave describing the time varying direction and relative magnitude of the electric-
field vector [7]. In other words, polarization is the curve traced by the end point of
the instantaneous electric field observed along the direction of propagation.
Polarization can be classified as linear, circular or elliptical depending on the figure
that the electric field traces, as represented in Figure ??.
9
2. Background Theory
Linear Polarization
The electric and magnetic field vector at a point are always oriented along the same
straight line at every instant of time. Linear polarization is accomplished if the
electric and magnetic vector possess any of these conditions:
• They have only one component.
• They have two orthogonal linear components in time phase or 180°phase dif-
ference (or multiples of 180°).
Circular Polarization
The electric and magnetic field vector at a point trace a circle as a function of time
as in Figure 2.3. The conditions to accomplish circular polarization are:
• The field has two orthogonal linear components.
• The two components have the same magnitude.
• The two components have a time-phase difference of 90°or odd multiples of
90°.
The electric field can be traced according to a clockwise rotation which is designated
as right-hand polarization or counterclockwise designated as left-hand polarization.
For example, Figure 2.3 is left-handed polarized considering the axis origin the source
of the field.
10
2. Background Theory
Elliptical Polarization
The electric and magnetic field vector change continuously with time describing an
elliptical locus in space. The conditions to accomplish elliptical polarization are:
• The field has two orthogonal linear components.
• The two components can have the same or different magnitude:
– If the two components do not have the same magnitude, the time-phase
difference between the two components must not be 0°or multiples of
180°.
– If the components have the same magnitude, the time-phase difference
between the two components must not be 90°or odd multiples of 90°.
As mentioned for circular polarization, the same rules apply to design right-hand(clockwise)
or left-hand (counterclockwise) polarization.
Although linear and circular polarizations are special cases of elliptical polarization,
a wave is considered elliptical polarized if it is not linearly or circularly polarized.
Axial Ratio is used to evaluate the polarization of the antenna: it tends to ∞ when
linear polarization, it is 1 (0dB) when circular polarization and larger than 1 for an
elliptical polarized antenna.
The axial ratio tends to degrade away from the main lobe, so it is a factor that
has a big influence to determine the bandwidth. It is usually indicated the angle
deviation from the main beam that maintains the polarization required.
11
2. Background Theory
ZA = RA + jXA (2.25)
where ZA is the impedance, RA the resistance and XA the reactance at the terminals
of the antenna.
RA = Rr + RL (2.26)
where Rr is the radiation resistance and RL is the loss resistance of the antenna.
The radiation resistance determines the radiated power of the antenna and the loss
resistance the dissipated power. Therefore the power delivered to the antenna is
also formed by two components:
The antenna radiation efficiency η is defined as the ratio between the radiated power
and the power delivered to the antenna or in terms of impedance:
Pradiated Rr
η= = (2.28)
Pdelivered Rr + RL
SAR is critical to antenna design, because if the SAR is too high the antenna
must be changed. Typically, if the SAR is too high the transmit power is lowered,
which directly yields lower SAR. However, since there are minimum transmit power
specifications for mobile devices, the SAR cannot be dropped indefinitely [12].
As a result, the antenna positioning is critical. The antennas for mobile phones are
typically on the bottom of the phone, to keep the radiating part of the phone as far
as possible from the brain region [12].
Other methods for dropping the SAR include impedance matching changes and
parasitic resonators which will disturb the antenna’s radiation pattern (hopefully
lowering SAR) [12].
12
2. Background Theory
Defining voltages and currents for non-TEM lines is difficult therefore some tools
are used to simplify microwave circuits analysis. More intuitive ideas of circuit
analysis can be used to determine voltages, currents and power flow through a
specific element.
As equivalent voltages and currents can be determined with this techniques, impedance
and admittance matrices of circuit theory can be used in order to determine a matrix
description of the network.
The scattering matrix provides a complete description of the network seen as N
ports. It relates the voltage waves incident on the ports to those reflected from
them.
Considering a N-port network where Vn+ is the amplitude of the voltage wave incident
on port n and Vn− is the amplitude of the voltage wave reflected from port n.
−
V1+
V1 S11 S12 . . . S1N
− +
V2 S21 S22 . . . S2N
V2
.
. =
.. .. ... .
. (2.30)
. . . .
VN− SN 1 SN 2 . . . SN N VN+
h i h ih i
V− = S V+ (2.31)
13
2. Background Theory
Microstrip line is one of the most popular types of planar transmission lines primarily
because it is easily miniaturized and integrated [8]. The geometry of a microstrip
line is a conductor of width W printed on a thin, grounded dielectric substrate of
thickness d and relative permittivity r which is shown in Figure 2.6.
The analysis of microstip line is complicated because the dielectric does not fill
the region above the strip, therefore all the fields are not contained within the
homogeneous dielectric region in contrast with the stripline. Some (usually most) of
its field lines are in the dielectric region between the strip conductor and the ground
plane and some fraction in the air region above the substrate like Figure 2.7. For
this reason microstrip line cannot support pure TEM wave. The exact fields of a
microstrip line constitute a hybrid TM-TE wave.
14
2. Background Theory
Figure 2.7: Electric and magnetic fields of microstrip transmission line [8].
In most practical applications, where the dielectric substrate is electrically very thin
(d λ) the fields are essentially the same as the static (DC) case. So, good approx-
imations for the phase velocity, propagation constant and characteristic impedance
can be obtained from static or quasi-static solutions following the represented ge-
ometry in Figure 2.8.
Phase velocity and propagation constant can be expressed as
c
vp = √ (2.32)
e
√
β = k0 e (2.33)
where e is the effective dielectric constant of the microstrip line and as some of the
field lines are the dielectric and some are in air satisfies the relation
r + 1 r − 1 1
e = + s (2.35)
2 2 d
1 + 12
W
15
2. Background Theory
!
60 8d W W
√ ln + for ≤1
e W 4d d
Z0 = (2.36)
120π W
for ≥1
√ W
W
d
e + 1.393 + 0.667ln + 1.444
d d
The patch and substrate are very thin in terms of free-space wavelength t λ0
λ0 λ0
and h λ0 . For a rectangular patch, usually < L < . The substrate is
3 2
a dielectric sheet with a constant r usually in the range of 1 ≤ λ0 ≤ 12. Thick
substrates with a low dielectric constant are desirable because the bandwidth and
the efficiency increase. Thin substrates with higher dielectric constants are desirable
for microwave circuitry because undesired radiation and coupling are minimized. A
compromise has to be reached between a good performance and design.
The radiating patch can have different shapes: rectangular, square, circular, dipole,
elliptical... Selecting the patch shape is important for the design as the radiation,
analysis and fabrication depend on it. Figure 2.10 illustrates some of the possible
shapes of the patches.
16
2. Background Theory
Advantages Disadvantages
17
2. Background Theory
Transmission-line Model
Basically, the transmission line model represents the mictrostrip antenna by two
slots, separated by a low-impedance Zc transmission line of length L. This model
and its electric field is shown in figure 2.12.
This model follows the same development described in the Section 2.2, where a mi-
crostrip line can be characterized as a new microstrip line with an effective dielectric
constant that approximates the behaviour of all the electric field lines, most of them
that reside in the substrate and the portion that exit through the air.
The effective dielectric constant is a function of the frequency but for low frequencies,
it can be approximated to the static value:
r + 1 r − 1 1
e = + s (2.37)
2 2 h
1 + 12
W
The size of the patch looks electrically greater because of the fringing effects, and
this extension depends on the effective dielectric constant e and the width-height
ratio. We can assume that
Le = L + 24L (2.38)
as represented in Figure 2.13.
18
2. Background Theory
If we do not take into account this fringing, the resonant frequency for the dominant
T M010 mode can be approximated by
1 c0
(fr )010 ' √ = √ (2.39)
2L µr 2L r
For a more exact computation, the edge effects can be included achieving a new
formulation
1 1 c0
(frc )010 = √ =q √ =q √ (2.40)
2Le µ0 0 e 2L µ0 0 e 2L r
therefore, we can assume that q factor is the fringe factor (length reduction factor).
(frc )010
q= (2.41)
(fr )010
Cavity Model
Microstrip antennas can be treated as a cavity (substrate) bounded by electric con-
ductors (the patch above and the ground below) and by magnetic walls (open circuit)
along the perimeter of the patch. It is an approximate model which leads to a reac-
tive input impedance (zero or infinite value) and does not radiate any power but it is
an accepted approach in terms of radiated pattern, input admittance and resonant
frequencies.
The field configuration within the cavity can be found using the vetor potential,
which mus satisfy the homogeneous wave equation of
∇2 Ax + k 2 Ax = 0 (2.42)
Ax = [A1 cos (kx x) + B1 sin (kx x)] [A2 cos (ky y) + B2 sin (ky y)] [A3 cos (kz z) + B3 sin (kz z)]
(2.43)
where kx , ky and kz are the wavenumbers along the x, y and z directions.
Applying the boundary conditions, the final form of the vector potential within the
cavity is
Ax = Amnp cos (kx x0 ) cos (ky y 0 ) cos (kz z 0 ) (2.44)
19
2. Background Theory
The wavenumbers are subject to the constraint equation. Therefore, the resonant
frequencies for the cavity are given by
s
2 2 2
1 mπ nπ pπ
(fr )mnp = √ + + (2.45)
2π µ h L W
The mode with the lowest order resonant frequency is the dominant mode. If L >
W > h, the dominant mode is the T M010 :
1 c0
(fr )010 = √ = √ (2.46)
2L µ 2L r
If W > L > h, the dominant mode is the T M001 :
1 c0
(fr )001 = √ = √ (2.47)
2W µ 2W r
Differents modes are represented in Figure 2.14.
20
2. Background Theory
Centric classification
• Geocentric orbit: An orbit around the planet Earth, like the Moon. It is by
far the most common type of orbit.
• Heliocentric orbit: An orbit around the Sun, like all planets in the Solar
System.
• Areocentric orbit: An orbit around the planet Mars.
Altitude classification
• Low Earth orbit (LEO): Geocentric orbits ranging in altitude from 0-2000km.
• Medium Earth orbit (MEO): Geocentric orbits ranging in altitude from 2000km
to 35,786km.
• Geosynchronous Orbit (GEO): Geocentric circular orbit with an altitude of
35,786km.
• High Earth Orbit (HEO): Geocentric orbits above the altitude of geosyn-
chronous orbit 35,786km.
Inclination classification
The orbit can be inclined in reference to the equatorial plane:
• Polar orbit: An orbit that passes above or nearly above both poles of the
planet on each revolution.
• Polar sun synchronous orbit: A nearly polar orbit that passes the equator at
the same local time on every pass.
Eccentricity classification
• Circular orbit: An orbit that has an eccentricity of 0 and whose path traces a
circle.
• Elliptic orbit: An orbit with an eccentricity between 0 and 1 whose orbit traces
the path of an ellipse.
21
2. Background Theory
Doppler effect
The frequency and wavelength of an electromagnetic field are affected by relative
motion, this is known as Doppler effect. This effect is significant in low-earth-orbit
(LEO) satellites because all LEO satellites are constantly moving relatively to each
other and to points on the surface which causes variations in the frequencies and
wavelengths of received signals [15]. In geostationary satellite systems, Doppler
effect is not an important factor and therefore it can not be used as a tracking tool.
A measurement of the Doppler Shift is used as a tracking technique to determine the
distance between the satellite and the receiver at a time. A Doppler curve can be
produced with the measurement of frequency against time. As a satellite approaches,
the frequency appears raised relative to the actual transmission frequency. As it
goes away, the frequency appears to be lowered. At the time of closest approach,
the transmitted and received frequencies are usually the same [16].
GPS
The Global Positioning System (GPS) is a satellite-based navigation system made
up of a network of 24 satellites placed into orbit by the U.S. Department of De-
22
2. Background Theory
fense. GPS was originally intended for military applications, but in the 1980s, the
government made the system available for civilian use. GPS works in any weather
conditions, anywhere in the world, 24 hours a day [18].
GPS satellites fly in medium Earth orbit (MEO) at an altitude of approximately
20,200 km. Each satellite circles the Earth twice a day. The 31 satellites are arranged
into six orbits surrounding the Earth which ensures users can view at least four
satellites from any point on the planet.
The accuracy users attain depends on different factors: atmospheric effects, sky
blockage and receiver quality.
Galileo
Galileo is Europe’s own global navigation satellite system, providing a highly accu-
rate, guaranteed global positioning service under civilian control. It is interoperable
with GPS and GLONASS, the US and Russian global satellite navigation systems
to increase performance and robustness of the navigation services. By offering dual
frequencies as standard, Galileo is set to deliver real-time positioning accuracy down
to the metre range [19].
First satellite launches were in 2011 with operational satellites to validate the Galileo
concept, by the end of 2016 initial services will be available and in 2020 the constel-
lation system will be completed and like represented in Figure 2.16. It will consist of
24 operational satellites plus six in-orbit spares positioned in three circular Medium
Earth Orbit(MEO).
23
2. Background Theory
Galileo MEOSAR satellites will be equipped to relay distress signals from emergency
beacons according to the Cospas-Sarsat System. The incorporation of a response
signal to the user informing that the situation has been detected and that help is
on its way is a major upgrade to the existing system.
GLONASS
GLONASS is a satellite-based navigation system operated by the Russian Aeropspace
Defence Forces that works alongside GPS (Global Positioning System) with a similar
precision [20].
Since 2001, Russian Government approved a new program to modernize and restore
the network that had stopped working during the crisis years (1989-1999). A big
economic investment allowed the program to develop a full orbital constellation of
24 satellites in 2011.
COMPASS
The COMPASS also known as BeiDou Navigation Satellite System is a Chinese
satellite navigation system. It consists of two separate satellite constellations: a
limited test system that has been operating since 2000, and a full-scale global navi-
gation system that is currently under construction [21].
The first BeiDou system consists of three satellites and offers limited coverage and
applications. It has been offering navigation services, mainly for customers in China
and neighbouring regions, since 2000. The second generation of the system, will be
a global satellite navigation system consisting of 35 satellites that offer full coverage
of the complete globe.
It is composed of [22]:
• Distress radio beacons like ELTs (Emergency Locator Transmitters) for avia-
tion use, EPIRBs (Emergency Position Indicating Radio Beacons) for maritime
24
2. Background Theory
use and PLBs (Personal Locator Beacons) for personal use, which transmit
signals during a distress situation.
• Instruments on board satellites in geostationary (GEOSAR) and low-altitude
(LEOSAR) earth orbits, which detect the signals transmitted by distress bea-
cons.
• Ground receiving stations, referred to as Local Users Terminals (LUTs), which
receive and process the satellite downlink signal to generate distress alerts.
• Mission Control Centers (MCCs) which receive alerts produced by LUTs and
forward them to Rescue Coordination Centers (RCCs), Search and Rescue
Points Of Contacts (SPOCs) or other MCCs.
Satellites
A combination of LEOSAR, GEOSAR and MEOSAR systems are used in the
Corpas-Sarsat system. Both contribute respective advantages to detection and lo-
cation of activated distress beacons.
25
2. Background Theory
26
2. Background Theory
Distress Beacons
Since February 2009, the Cospas-Sarsat system only detects and locates distress bea-
cons operating at 406MHz. In the past, 121.5MHz beacons were used but they were
considered obsolete because the 406MHz beacons specific design for the LEOSAR
system improved its performance. Some requirements are needed such as stability of
the transmitted frequency (406.0-406.1 MHz) and the inclusion of a digital message
which allows the transmission of encoded data such as unique beacon identification.
27
2. Background Theory
The data that MCCs manage are system information and alert data. System infor-
mation keeps the Cospas-Sarsat system operating effectively providing accurate and
timely alert data to the users. Alert data is the data derived from distress beacons
with its location and coded information.
28
3
Design and Results
This chapter explains the procedure developed in order to design, simulate, manu-
facture and measure the antenna system. A preliminary section is needed to explain
the material choice, the laboratory instruments and software used.
Even though both antennas operate together, they have been designed, manufac-
tured and tested independently. Thus, the GPS antenna is explained in the first
place, and then the PLB antenna.
3.1.1 Materials
A very sensitive choice in every antenna design is the selection of materials, but it
is even more important when the antenna is textile. Textile antenna needs to be
flexible, low cost, easy to manufacture and suitable to be integrated into clothing.
Following the microstrip structure, it is needed an electrical conductive fabric for
the ground plane and the patches; and a fabric substrate with constant thickness
and stable permittivity.
An accurate determination of the electrical parameters for the fabrics (dielectric sub-
strate and conductive textile) is crucial for correct antenna simulations and agree-
ment with measurements [1].
• Textile substrates:
The textile substrate defines the dielectric between the antenna patch and the ground
plane, therefore we need to select it according to its permittivity and thickness. As
textile materials are not specifically used for antenna manufacturing, their permit-
tivity is not previously characterized. We used |S11 | measurements of two microstrip
antennas with two different dimensions of the patches for the study of 9 felts showed
in Figure 3.1.
29
3. Design and Results
(a) Dark green (b) Stripped (c) Sq. green (d) Green (e) Brown
Once we know the operating frequency of the two antennas with each felt, we used
CST simulations to estimate their permittivity. Two different calculations were used
to produce a more reliable value. The thickness of the fabric is also important as it
has a direct influence on the bandwidth. In Table 3.1 the measured parameters are
displayed.
Finally, we decided that the most appropriate felt is Red from Figure 3.1i which has
r =1.35 and 1mm of thickness. The reasons of this choice were the stable calculation
of the permittivity as the two calculations do not differ considerably, the thickness
of 1mm which is not easily compressed and its robustness which is stable but easily
bended. We decided to use two sewed felt layers for the GPS and three for the PLB
to increase the antenna’s bandwidth.
• Conductive fabric:
30
3. Design and Results
Conductive fabric is used as a ground plane and patch of both antennas. Many
examples from the literature using Shieldex woven fabrics led us to contact this
company for more information. They provided us with some samples to use for the
antennas manufacturing.
We have used two different fabrics provided by Shieldex: Norra Dell and Zell. They
are woven fabric for general use (outside skin for EMI/RFI fabric over foam gaskets,
shielding material for laminated flat I/O shielding panels, base material for EMI/RFI
garments, EMI/RFI cable shielding).
Nora Dell is a nickel copper silver plated polyamide fabric with a resistivity around
0.009W/ with 100dB shielding effectiveness from 30MHz to 10GHz. It is shown in
Figure 3.2a.
Zell is a tin copper silver plated polyamide ristop fabric with a resistivity around
0.02W/ with 80dB shielding effectiveness from 300MHz to 10GHz. It is shown in
Figure ??. Both work in a temperature range from -30°C to 90°C.
Both fabrics are suitable for any of the two operating frequencies we are working
at, but to ensure its correct performance, we used Nora Dell for the PIFA antenna
(lower frequency) and Zell for the GPS antenna and its feeding circuit.
• Conductive thread:
Conductive thread is used in the manufacturing process to connect the patch of the
antenna to the SMA connector pin during the measurements. It is also integrated as
a definitive connector from the 90°feeding circuit to the patch of the GPS antenna.
Figure 3.3 shows the conductive thread used.
We have used Shieldex 235/34 a 99 % pure silver polyamide 6.6 filament yarn.
31
3. Design and Results
3.1.2 Laboratory
Some instruments have been used during the manufacturing, material testing and
measuring process in the laboratory. The most important instruments are explained
in Table 3.2.
Other elements used during the lab manufacturing and measuring were:
3.1.3 Software
Different software tools have been used to design the model of the antenna, simulate
the electrical parameters and evaluate and plot the results of its performance. These
software are CST Microwave Studio 2014, Matlab R2014b and RFxpert.
32
3. Design and Results
• RFxpert:
It is used to run the RFxpert near field scanner which instantly characterizes anten-
nas without the need for a chamber providing far-field patterns, bisections, EIRP,
S11 graph, gain and efficiency. A Circular Polarization option can be selected to
calculate the right and left hand circularly polarized patterns and display axial ratio
patterns. Large scan area allows designers to test antennas up to 32cm x 32cm and
frequencies between 300MHz and 6GHz [24].
We have used the near field scanner to evaluate the performance of the manufactured
antennas, specifically far field patterns in both 3D and bisections representations.
Comparing them with the previously simulated results, we can determine if the
behaviour is reliable.
Results data can be easily exported to an excel file for further evaluation and im-
porting them to another software as Matlab.
• Matlab:
It is a high-level language and interactive environment used by millions of engineers
and scientists worldwide. It lets you explore and visualize ideas and collaborate
across disciplines including signal and image processing, communications, control
systems, and computational finance [28].
We have used this software to evaluate the results obtained with CST simulations
and RFxpert.Its high precision and versatile environment allow us to process and
compare graphs to determine the reliability of each antenna.
33
3. Design and Results
tolerated with a circular polarization. A right hand circular polarized signal becomes
a left hand circular polarized after a reflection (and vice-versa).
In an antenna, circular polarization can be achieved through a single feed in a
diagonal place of an non-symmetric patch or using two feeds in the same patch with
different phases [7].
To avoid complexities related to dual-feed designs, a single feed can also be used to
achieve circular polarization. One way to accomplish this is to feed the patch at a
single point in which two orthogonal modes are generated. The 90° phase difference
is induced by using this asymmetric configuration.
Some of the the most used techniques are trimming the ends of two opposite corners
of a square patch and feed points 1 or 3 as in Figure 3.4a and cutting very thin slots
as in Figure 3.4b.
(a) Trimmed square [7] (b) Square patch with thin slots [7]
A single feed circularly polarized antenna is simpler than a dual-feed design and
very useful when the space is a restriction of the design. On the other hand, the
tolerances are very stric and the bandwidth narrow. For this reason, in this thesis
we have decided to use a dual-orthogonal feed.
The most common and direct way to generate a circular polarization is using a
dual-feed technique. It is needed to generate two orthogonal modes with 90° phase
difference between them like in Figure 3.5.
34
3. Design and Results
Figure 3.5: Rectangular microstrip antenna with two orthogonal feeds [29].
There are many well known power divider circuits which can be used to split the
input power in two and feed the patch. Some of them, which have been successfully
employed in a feed network of a patch, are:
• The 180-Degree Hybrid
• The Wilkinson Power Divider
• The T-Junction Power Divider
• The Quadrature 90°Hybrid
But, as we need a 90° phase difference between the two output ports, in this thesis
we have decided to use the Quadrature 90°Hybrid.
The high symmetry of the branch-line coupler, as any port can be used as the input
port with the output ports at the opposite part of the junction. Its scattering matrix
proves this symmetry:
0 j 1 0
h i −1 j 0 0 1
S =√
(3.1)
1 0 0 j
2
0 1 j 0
35
3. Design and Results
Patch
The first step to design a microstrip antenna was to determine the patch’s dimensions
W and L which are inversely proportional to the frequency:
1 c0
(fr )010 = √ = √ (3.2)
2L µ 2L r
1 c0
(fr )001 = √ = √ (3.3)
2W µ 2W r
As both operating frequencies needed to be the same, the patch is a square where:
c0 λ
L= √ = √ =W (3.4)
2f r 2 r
On the basis of these values, we built the simulation model to adjust the patch’s
dimensions to the exact GPS frequency and select matched feeding points. The
model follows the geometry of microstrip antennas which consists of three squared
layers: ground plane, substrate and patch. Figure 3.7 is a representation of the top
view and side view of the antenna model with all adjusted parameters.
(a) Top view of the antenna (b) Side view of the antenna
36
3. Design and Results
Parameters Value(mm)
hg 0.2
hs 2
hp 0.2
W-patch 78
L-patch 78
W-substrate 100
L-substrate 100
The feeding points of the patch are the most determinant parameters to achieve a
good matching. After some attempts, satisfactory results were achieved with Port
1=(11.3, 0)mm and symmetrically Port 2=(0, 11.3)mm.
This configuration was studied using the Time Domain Simulation of CST Mi-
crowave Studio. The antenna was evaluated in terms of S parameters, Electric field
distribution and Far Field.
• S-parameters:
S-parameters illustrate the return loss of the antenna and the coupling between port
1 and 2. As it is shown in Figure 3.8, S11 has a good performance for the whole
GPS bandwidth (lower than -15dB) which indicates that the feeding points are
appropriate and that the patch’s dimensions are suitable for the operating frequency.
S21 determines the coupling between port 1 and port 2, since the level is lower than
-35dB, the ports do not interfere each other.
• E-Field distribution:
37
3. Design and Results
Electric field simulations at the operating frequency 1.57GHz are illustrated in Fig-
ure 3.9. T M10 is excited using Port 1 and with port 2, T M01 .
• Far field:
Far field simulations represent the radiation pattern of the microstrip antenna. The
main lobe is formed in z-direction with 8.15dBi and 75.5 degree 3dB beam width
and the back lobe is -8.4dBi. The difference between the main lobe, which will be
the useful power, and the back lobe which will be dissipated power towards the
body, gives us a figure of merit of the antenna. The radiation pattern is represented
in 3D in Figure 3.11a and in 2D in Figure 3.11b when φ =0.
(a) 3D far field radiation pattern (b) Polar representation when φ=0°)
Figure 3.11: Far field simulations from port 1 of the GPS antenna.
38
3. Design and Results
Combining the two ports with a 90 ° phase difference, the obtained radiation pattern
is shown in Figure 3.12.
(a) Right hand circular polarization (b) Polar representation when φ=0°
Figure 3.12: Far field of a patch antenna with two orthogonal ports and 90° phase
shift.
We used the same materials (substrate and conductive) as for the patch so r =1.35,
λ Z0
=41.09mm and if Z0 =50W, √ = 35.35W. Using CST macro calculations, the
4 2
Z0
necessary width of the lines in order to achieve the needed impedance Z0 and
2
can be determined.
The feeding points of the patch determined where the output ports needed to be,
so we needed additional lines from the junction to these points. It is very impor-
tant that both additional lines have the same length in order to respect the phase
difference achieved with the quadrature hybrid.
After an optimization process, the final design is the one illustrated in Figure 3.14
with the values indicated in Table 3.4.
39
3. Design and Results
Parameters Value(mm)
hg 0.2
hs2 2
hc 0.2
w50 4.3
w35 6.3
W-substrate 100
L-substrate 100
Figure 3.14: Top view of the 90°circuit. Table 3.4: Antenna’s dimen-
sions.
In Figure 3.20a, |S12 | and |S13 | show that input power from port 1 is equally dis-
tributed to port 2 and 3 as both parameters are -3dB in the whole GPS bandwidth.
|S11 | is well matched with values below -10dB In Figure 3.16b, it demonstrated that
a phase difference of 90° at the operating frequency between S12 and S13 can be
obtained.
40
3. Design and Results
(a) |S11 |,|S12 | and |S13 | (b) S12 and S13 ’s phase
Parameters Value(mm)
W-patch2 78
L-patch2 78
L-slot 32
W-slot 2
w50 4.3
41
3. Design and Results
The separation between the load patch and the circuit is crucial because the electric
field going through the circuit must not be couplet to the patch. Therefore we
extended the connecting line between port 4 and the secondary patch. To increase
the length of the connecting line, we also needed to increase substrate’s width from
100mm to 150mm, achieving the final designed from Figure 3.19.
Complete antenna
The final step of the antenna’s design was to join and unify patch and circuit’s
geometry. As a consequence of the changes for the correct circuit’s design, we needed
to adapt the patch design to the new substrate’s width which does not affect any
other parameter preciously calculated. Therefore, the definitive model is represented
in Figure 3.20 with the values from Table 3.6.
42
3. Design and Results
(a) Top view of the complete antenna (b) Back view of the complete antenna
Parameters Value(mm)
hg 0.2
hs 2
hp 0.2
W-patch 78
L-patch 78
w50 4.5
w35 7.2
W-patch2 30
L-patch2 81.5
W-substrate 150
L-substrate 100
Figure 3.21: Side view of the complete Table 3.6: Dimensions of the
antenna. complete antenna.
43
3. Design and Results
• Axial ratio:
The axial ratio of a circularly polarized antenna is lower than 3dB. The axial ratio is
very frequency dependent because an exact 90° phase difference can only be achieved
for a specific frequency since it depends on the length of the lines of our circuit.
Therefore, and as it is shown in Figure 3.23, a reliable axial ratio covers the GPS’
bandwidth.
• E-field distribution:
Circular polarization can be seen with the electric field evolution with the time.
44
3. Design and Results
• Far field:
Comparing absolute far field simulations with circular polarized simulation we can
see that is practically the same, confirming the good performance in terms of po-
larization. It is also remarkable from the 3D representation in Figure 3.26a and the
polar representation in Figure 3.26b that the main difference is the dimension of the
back lobe which is not important for the design that it is circularly polarized.
45
3. Design and Results
Figure 3.26: Far field right circular polarization simulations of the complete antenna.
46
3. Design and Results
After obtaining the required dimensions from the simulations, we proceeded to sew
together two 100x100mm layers of felt which constitute the substrate. Next, we
sewed the patch made of Shieldex Dell with dimensions of 80x80mm. It is 2mm
larger than the established dimensions during the simulations to adjust it to the
correct frequency band.
To measure the patch’s dimensions, we used the Vector Network Analyser (VNA).
We placed the ongoing antenna on an aluminium sheet with a SMA connector sol-
dered through it. We used some Shieldex conductive thread to connect the SMA pin
to the patch going through the substrate. With this configuration, we determined
a matched feeding point (one at a time) by changing the position of the conductive
thread respect to the patch. Once a good matching was achieved, the operating
frequency was adjusted cutting the patch. This procedure allowed us to double
check the simulation dimensions and adjusted them until an adequate performance
was reached and measured with the VNA as in Figure 3.28. In Table 3.7 the values
of the parameters of the microstrip antenna are displayed following the notation
represented in Figure 3.7a.
Parameters Value(mm)
hg 0.2
hs 2
hp 0.2
W-patch 78.5
L-patch 78.5
W-substrate 100
L-substrate 100
Figure 3.28: |S11 | measured with the Table 3.7: Dimensions of the
VNA. manufactured patch.
Once the performance of the patch was demonstrated, we finished the manufac-
turing: the textile Shieldex ground plane was sewed and a felt layer was added to
increase the robustness of the antenna, two SMA connectors were placed through
holes on the ground plane and substrate and soldered to the patch.
47
3. Design and Results
(a) Top view of the patch (b) Back view of the patch
Figure 3.30: Configuration of the complete full textile dual-orthogonal feed mi-
crostrip.
The patch was manufactured following the same procedure as the basic microstrip
explained in the section 3.2.4, with the only difference of the substrate’s width which
was 150mm instead of 100mm. The dimensions of the patch were checked once again
to operate at the proper frequency and accordingly the feeding points resulting in
the manufactured patch antenna in Figure 3.31a. We made a hole at the ground
plane for each feeding point where the conductive thread goes through to connect
the patch to the feeding circuit as it is shown in Figure 3.31b.
48
3. Design and Results
(a) Top view of the patch (b) View of the ground plane of the patch
With the patch perfectly manufactured, we continued with the 90°feeding circuit.
The main characteristics of this circuit is that the microstip lines forming the junc-
λs
tion need to be exactly which also means a 90° phase difference at 1.575GHz
4
with r =1.35. The Vector Network Analyser was used to measure the phase differ-
ence between the beginning and the end of a microstrip line and adjusting it to 90°
λs
showed in Figure 3.32. The final value for a line was 43mm.
4
λs
Figure 3.32: Phase’s measurements to determine .
4
After determining the length of the lines, we needed to decide its width. In this
case, we used the VNA to measure the impedance and represent it with the Smith
Chart. We adjusted each line’s width achieving the final values of 7.5mm for 35W
and 4.5mm for 50W.
With the previous parameters, we implemented the circuit and analysed its per-
formance. We measured the S-parameters of all 4 ports using the Vector Network
Analyser. While measuring S-parameters of two ports, the other two ports need to
be matched with 50W loads. In Figure 3.33a, port 1 and 2 are being measured while
port 3 and 4 are matched. One of the measurements is shown in Figure 3.33b.
49
3. Design and Results
To manufacture the load patch, we followed the same procedure as the main patch.
Adjusting the dimensions with the |S11 | results to match the feeding point and
the operating frequency with the substrate placed over the aluminium sheet and
connecting the patch with conductive thread using a probe feed. This process is
shown in Figure 3.34a with load patch being matched and its final measurement in
Figure 3.34b. Once the feeding point was selected, two slots were cut forming the
feeding microstip line which was attached to the circuit’s port 4.
Finally, the final circuit was manufactured with the Shieldex fabric and attached to
the load patch. The substrate was made with two layers of felt sewed together. In
this case, we did not sew the circuit and the load patch to the substrate because
their small dimensions made it difficult to achieve a flat layer. So we pasted them
with textile glue.
When both parts were ready we sewed them together and added the conductive
thread from the patch feeding points to the circuit ports through the substrate and
the ground plane’s holes. To finish we soldered a SMA connector to the microstrip
line of port 1 to feed the circuit and therefore, the antenna.
Figure 3.35a and Figure 3.35b show top and back view of the finished fully textile
antenna and its feeding circuit.
50
3. Design and Results
Figure 3.35: Manufactured fully textile complete microstrip antenna with a 90°
feeding circuit integrated.
The completed antenna was measured to check that it was matched in the whole
GPS band. This measurement is shown in Figure 3.36.
To analyse the performance of this antenna we used a 90° phase shifter, according
to the configuration displayed in Figure 3.37.
51
3. Design and Results
Figure 3.37: Configuration for the measurements of the dual-orthogonal feed mi-
crostrip antenna.
A comercial phase shifter was adjusted for a exact 90° phase at the GPS frequency
with the VNA.
Using RFxpert near field scanner, the radiation pattern of the antenna was mea-
sured. Comparing the two 3D plots, it is clear that its power radiation majority is
right hand circularly polarized as both measurement, total radiation pattern showed
in Figure 3.38a and RHCP radiation pattern showed in Figure 3.38b, are very sim-
ilar. In the 2D plots, the total (blue), right hand (magenta) and left hand (red) far
fields are shown in Figure 3.38c when φ=0° and in Figure 3.38d when φ=90°. There
is a difference of 20dB between RHCP and LHCP for all θ directions.
Figure 3.38: Far field measured of the manufactured dual-orthogonal feeding mi-
crostrip antenna.
The axial ratio is represented depending on the angle θ for two different values of
φ, 0° and 90°, in Figure 3.39. When the axial ratio is lower than 3dB, it indicates
that the antenna is circularly polarized. For angles around θ= 0°, which is the more
52
3. Design and Results
important direction because the maximum radiated power is in this direction, values
of the axial ratio ate lower than 3dB, therefore it is circularly polarized.
Figure 3.39: Axial ratio of the manufactured microstrip antenna measured with the
near field scanner
In this case we only needed to connect the signal generator to the antenna port and
place it on the near field scanner, shown in Figure 3.40, as the feeding circuit is fully
textile and integrated in the microstrip antenna.
Figure 3.40: Configuration of the complete full textile dual-orthogonal feed mi-
crostrip.
The results form the radiation patterns measurements of the microstrip antenna
with the integrated circuit, are shown in Figure 3.41. The 3D representation shows
a more directive radiation than the microstrip antenna without the feeding circuit
from Figure 3.38, and a similar directivity 7dBi. Also, the total radiation pattern
from Figure 3.41a and the RHCP radiation pattern from Figure 3.41b, are almost
identical which can easier be seen in the 2D representations from Figure 3.41c and
3.41d, as the maximum directivity from the right polarization and the total radiation
pattern are 7dBi for both cases of φ=0° and φ=90°.
53
3. Design and Results
Figure 3.41: Far field measured of the manufactured microstrip with 90° feeding
circuit integrated.
The axial ratio measurement shown in Figure 3.42 indicates that the antenna is
not circularly polarized as its values are not lower than 3dB. The axial ratio mea-
surements from the microstrip antenna with the integrated circuit in Figure 3.42
have increased more than 2dB in all θ directions, compared to the the axial ratio
measurements from the microstrip antenna without the circuit represented in Figure
3.39. This measurements indicate that the integration of the circuit does not have
a good performance as the circular polarization is compromised.
Figure 3.42: Axial ratio of the measured microstrip antenna with the integrated
feeding circuit.
54
3. Design and Results
PLB antenna has designed as a PIFA operating at 406MHz. Once its performance
was considered reliable, it was integrated on a belt with two identical patches, one
at the front and another at the back. The belt is thought to be worn around the
body like in Figure3.43. Therefore the bending produced by the shape of the body
needs to be taken into consideration.
The design has been done in two parts: first it has been designed a flat single PIFA
and then it has been adjusted to be integrated into a belt around the body.
55
3. Design and Results
PIFA
λ0
L= √ (3.5)
4 r
Assuming f =406MHz and r =1.35 (we used the same materials as for the GPS
antenna), then L =158.88mm. Taking this value as a reference, we proceeded to
design the model presented in Figure 3.44 and Figure 3.45 with the values displayed
in Table 3.8.
56
3. Design and Results
Parameters Value(mm)
hg 0.2
hs 2
hp 0.2
W-patch 55
L-patch 158.2
W-substrate 90
L-substrate 300
Figure 3.45: PIFA’s Top view. Table 3.8: PIFA’s final dimen-
sions.
Some simulations were used to determine this parameters’ values as well as the
feeding point to achieve a good matching:(-60,0)mm.
We can evaluate the performance of the antenna with the following figures of merit:
• S parameters:
Figure 3.46 shows that the antenna operates at 406MGz where the |S11 | is bellow
-10dB. It can be observed that the bandwidth is narrow because the patch’s width
λs
of the designed antenna is much smaller than .
4
• E-field distribution:
Electric field representation shows the typical distribution of a PIFA, with the
shorted part at one edge of the patch
57
3. Design and Results
• Far field:
The radiation pattern of the designed PIFA is represented in Figure 3.48. The main
lobe is 3.85dBi and 221.2° 3dB beam width and the back lobe is -0,8dBi. The back
lobe level is very low which is one of the advantages of PIFA’s design.
To simulate the total antenna we used a model which consists of a elliptical cylinder
of a 400mm width, 150mm length and 400mm height, that represents the human
body. The antenna has a ground plane and substrate with elliptical shape around
the body model and two shorted patch, one at the front and another at the back,
as it is illustrated in Figure 3.49 with the values displayed in Table 3.9.
Human body has different relative permittivities depending on the body tissues:
muscle(57), skin(20-38) and fat(5), at 400MHz . The model used is an homogeneous
elliptical cylinder with r =30 [31]. Dielectric losses were added to quantify the
dissipation of electromagnetic energy. The employed loss tangent was tan δ=0,001
which is the typical value at 400MHz [32].
58
3. Design and Results
Parameters Value(mm)
hg 0.2
hs 2
hp 0.2
Body’s height 400
W-patch 55
L-patch 156.92
W-substrate 90
L-body 400
W-body 150
Table 3.9: Dimensions of the final PIFA integrated to the body model.
We can evaluate the antenna’s performance analysing the following simulated results:
• S-parameters:
|S11 | is represented in Figure 3.51a. Due to the lossy body the bandwidth has become
narrower than at the original PIFA and the frequency was shiftet. Adjustments were
made on the patch’s length to operate at the decided frequency.
59
3. Design and Results
Figure 3.50: |S11 | simulated of the PIFA integrated to the body model.
• Far field:
The radiation pattern of one patch of the integrated PIFA is represented in 3D in
Figure 3.51a and in 2D when φ=0° in Figure 3.51b. It has a main lobe of 3.14dBi
and a radiation efficiency of -0.31dB. The back lobe is -2dB, this value is lower due
to the effect of the absorption of the body.
60
3. Design and Results
In real conditions, different phases at both patches can be employed to achieve the
radiation at different directions. Figure 3.53 shows the radiation pattern for 4 values
of phase difference: 45°, 90°, 135° and 180°.
61
3. Design and Results
The next step was dimensioning the patch so the operating frequency of the PIFA
was 406MHz. We used the VNA to measure |S11 | and to adjust the patch’s length.
As it is explained before, we used an aluminium sheet with an SMA connector
soldered as a ground plane for the measurements and a conductive thread from
the SMA pin to the patch. We also needed to short the patch sewing a line of
conductive thread from the patch through the substrate and making sure that had
a good connection with the aluminium sheet. Selecting the proper feeding point
was also needed. Figure 3.55 shows the front view of the final belt and its |S11 |
measurement.
62
3. Design and Results
Once the patch was properly dimensioned, we sewed the ground plane of Shieldex
and the other shorted patch at the opposite side of the belt. We solder a SMA
connector to each patch going through the ground plane and the substrate. The
final belt is presented in Figure 3.56a and its top view in Figure 3.56b.
(a) Perspective view of the belt (b) Top view of the belt
We measured the manufactured PLB antenna. We used the RFxpert Near Field
Scanner to evaluate its performance. Because of RFxpert’s functioning it was not
possible to make on-body measurements therefore, they were performed in the next
conditions: the belt was positioned on the scanner with two arms on it covering the
belt total surface scanned simulating the effect the body might have. All results
displayed are at the operating frequency: 406MHz.
63
3. Design and Results
64
4
Conclusion and Future Work
This chapter describes a general conclusion based upon the work done during this
thesis project and provides suggestions for next steps in order to continue the work.
The intention is to point out the most relevant ideas of the thesis and then consider
how to build upon them in future researches.
4.1 Conclusion
The achieved results lead to think that the designed textile antennas could be used
as GPS and PLB antennas for the Cospas-Sarsat International System. Both an-
tennas have resulted to be working at the established and demanding operational
frequency with a good matching proving correct designs and simulations. Radiation
patterns from the simulations and calculated using the near field scanner showed a
resemblance which reflects the correct study through the literature, design, simula-
tions and manufacture.
Even though, the achieved results regarding the axial ratio of the GPS antenna do
not fulfil the established requirements for a proper circular polarization, they in-
dicate that with a more precise manufacturing process of the feeding circuit they
would have been accomplished. Because of the frequency dependence of the circuit,
the variation of one millimetre could be the cause of this problem. As the most
innovative part of the thesis and non literature available, it is accepted as an im-
portant result which needs to be more developed.
PLB antenna performance is promising because of its radiation pattern and a com-
plete adaptability to the belt geometry around the body. Further studies need to
be performed in order to study the body effect more into detail, both with a more
precise simulation model and with on-body measurements.
Implementing both antennas with textile materials has represented an added dif-
ficulty during the manufacturing process as the laboratory instruments and the
connectors normally used are not easily adapted to textiles. These difficulties were
encouraging to come up with more creative ideas and configurations, extending the
range of learning during the project.
Regarding the materials used, its reliability has been checked proving a good sta-
bility and durability. However, the conductive Shieldex fabric has experienced some
65
4. Conclusion and Future Work
fraying after being cut. Belt sewing done with a sewing machine has resulted more
reliable, stronger and faster than hand-made sewing. The solution of using textile
glue for smaller pieces turned into a good alternative as it remained stable and im-
mobile.
The evaluation of the antenna’s functionality was only done with the RFxpert near
field scanner and the S parameters’ measurement with the Vector network analyser,
which resulted to be satisfactory. However, additional measurements as using an
anechoic chamber or on-body measurements would have improved the reliability of
the results.
To sum up, the proposed antennas and their operation are promising according
to the results achieved. Innovation topics as textile feeding circuits proved to be
decisive to accomplish a reliable circular polarization and therefore, more research
is needed. The combination of Cospas-Sarsat system and the growing market of
wearable antennas, is a field to be studied as it has a wide range of applications to
improve our life.
66
Bibliography
[1] Ivo Locher, Maciej Klemm, Tunde Kirstein, and Gerhard Troster. Design and
characterization of purely textile patch antennas. Advanced Packaging, IEEE
Transactions on, 29(4):777–788, 2006.
[2] Luigi Vallozzi, Waldo Vandendriessche, Hendrik Rogier, Carla Hertleer, and
Maria Lucia Scarpello. Wearable textile gps antenna for integration in protec-
tive garments. In Antennas and Propagation (EuCAP), 2010 Proceedings of the
Fourth European Conference on, pages 1–4. IEEE, 2010.
[3] Hasna Rais, Ping Jack Soh, Farek Malek, Shahad Ahmad, and Baya Hashim.
A review of wearable antenna. In Antennas & Propagation Conference, 2009.
LAPC 2009. Loughborough, pages 225–228. IEEE, 2009.
[4] Jim King. Overview of the cospas-sarsat satellite system for search and rescue.
Online Journal of Space Communication, 4, 2003.
[5] Juha Lilja, Vesa Pynttari, Tero Kaija, Raino Makinen, Eerik Halonen, Hannu
Sillanpaa, Juuso Heikkinen, Matti Mantysalo, Pekka Salonen, and Peter
de Maagt. Body-worn antennas making a splash: Lifejacket-integrated an-
tennas for global search and rescue satellite system. Antennas and Propagation
Magazine, IEEE, 55(2):324–341, 2013.
[6] Andrea Serra, P Nepa, G Manara, et al. A wearable multi antenna system on
a life jacket for cospas sarsat rescue applications. In Antennas and Propagation
(APSURSI), 2011 IEEE International Symposium on, pages 1319–1322. IEEE,
2011.
[7] Constantine A Balanis. Antenna theory: analysis and design, volume 1. John
Wiley & Sons, 1997.
[8] David M Pozar. Microwave Engineering. John Wiley & Sons, 1998.
[9] IEEE Antennas and Propagation Society. Ieee standard definitions of terms for
antennas. 2014.
[10] Hyper Physics. Classification of polarization, 2016. http://hyperphysics.
phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/phyopt/imgpho/polcls.gif, visited 2016-01-16.
[11] Wikipedia. Circular polarization. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/
Circular_polarization, visited 2016-01-16.
[12] Peter Joseph Bevelacqua. Sar- specific absorbtin rate. http://www.
antenna-theory.com/definitions/sar.php, visited 2016-01-13.
[13] Wikipedia. Satellite. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satellite, visited
2016-01-10.
[14] Sakshat Virtual Labs. Simulation of a satellite network. http://vlssit.
iitkgp.ernet.in/ant/ant/4/theory/, visited 2016-01-22.
67
Bibliography
68
Bibliography
69
Bibliography
70