Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
The demand for electricity in Israel is growing exponentially and is increasingly based on power generated from coal. Current means of ash
disposal are both inadequate and wasteful and have reached their maximum potential, thus future ash disposal presents considerable
economic and environmental problems. Two representative samples of coal fly ash from Israeli power plants were examined for their
mineralogical, chemical, physical and technical properties. Both samples are good-quality type F fly ashes (ASTM nomenclature) with
excellent pozzolanic characteristics. On the basis of strength index data, the South African fly ash was found to be a better pozzolan than the
Colombian. A simple beneficiation process is suggested to produce a high-quality, reproducible and valuable raw material. Some specific
uses for fly ash in the Israel context are suggested. 䉷 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Fly ash utilization; Characterization; Israel
Table 1
Amounts of ash produced, utilized and disposed of in Israel: total and recent
years (thousands of tonnes)
2.1. Morphology
Table 5
Mineralogical composition of representative fly ash samples determined by optical microscopy. All results in %
Sample Size Glass Mullite Spinel Quartz a Isotropic coke Anisotropic coke Inertinite Total C Chemical carbon Carbonate a Crystalline non-quartz Lime a
SA Whole 94.0 0.0 0.8 1.5 2.0 1.6 1.4 5.0 3.9
⫹ 100 56.0 0.0 0.0 12.5 12.0 9.0 4.5 25.5 24.6 2.5 2.0 3.5
100 to 200 81.4 0.0 1.6 1.5 8.8 4.6 3.4 16.8 13.7 0.5
200 to 325 97.2 0.0 1.2 0.5 0.4 0.8 0.4 1.6 4.2
⫺ 325 97.8 0.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.4 1.4 1.6
CO Whole 90.0 0.4 1.4 1.0 1.2 5.6 0.6 7.4 6.7
⫹ 100 46.5 0.0 2.5 9.0 11.0 31.0 3.5 45.5 46.8
100 to 200 68.0 0.0 2.0 5.0 11.0 13.6 2.0 26.6 16.2
200 to 325 92.8 0.0 2.0 1.5 1.2 2.4 0.6 4.2 4.1
⫺ 325 92.6 0.0 1.2 1.0 1.8 0.8 4.6 2.8
H.A. Foner et al. / Fuel 78 (1999) 215–223
a
Thin section, transmitted light.
H.A. Foner et al. / Fuel 78 (1999) 215–223 219
of graphite although this sample contains significantly more improved material with a lower carbon content and fewer
carbon than the South African. The use of carbon from fly non-reactive large particles as shown in Table 7. With the
ash as an adsorbent has been suggested [7]. Differences in gradual introduction of low-NOx burners, the amount of
the types of carbon present should be considered in any plan residual carbon in fly ash is expected to increase [10,11]
to utilize them for other than their fuel value. and so carbon removal will become a more important factor
in ash beneficiation. Possible uses for the separated carbon
2.5. Particle size and carbon content are discussed later.
The particle size of the ashes was also measured with a
The particle-size distribution of fly ashes is very impor- Quantachrome model 1064 granulometer using ultrasonic
tant factor for their use as pozzolans. ASTM 618C [8] speci- mixing to disperse the materials in water. The ashes were
fies that ⬍ 34% of the ash must remain on a 45 mm sieve on passed through a 10 mesh sieve to remove large stray pieces
wet sieving. Table 6 shows both the particle-size distribu- of debris before the experiment. The SA sample is of much
tion of the ashes and the amount of carbon in each size finer particle size than the CO. Table 8 summarizes some of
fraction. From the point of view of particle size, these the statistical data produced by the granulometer. These
samples easily pass the standard specification. results are consistent with those obtained by sieving.
The maximum carbon content of the Israel ashes deter-
mined in these experiments is CO 7.1% and SA 4.2%.
2.6. Technical properties
The ASTM standard has an upper carbon (or more accu-
rately, loss on ignition) limit of 6%, although up to 12% may The principal technical test of the suitability of a fly ash
be allowable in certain circumstances [8]. National and for use as a pozzolan is the strength activity index (SAI).
international standards for fly ash specify loss on ignition This is an accelerated test [12] which compares the
values of from 4 to 12% [3]. In general, low-carbon ashes compressive strengths of two cement/sand mortars: one
are required because carbon may interfere with air entrain- made with an ordinary Portland cement (OPC) and the
ment by adsorbing entrainment additives [9], although the other made with the same OPC but with 20% of the cement
carbon content does not always have this effect [10]. Table 6 substituted by fly ash. Table 9 shows the results obtained on
shows that the large size fractions have much higher carbon the original Israel ash samples and on various size fractions
contents than the small. Thus a relatively simple fractiona- obtained from them by careful dry sieving.
tion at ⫺ 100 or ⫺ 200 mesh would produce a greatly Both raw ash samples give SAI values greater than the
minimum required by the ASTM standard, with the SAI
Table 6
Size fractions of the ash components and the percentage of carbon in each
Table 7
Size SA CO Carbon content (%) of classified ash samples
3.3. Environmental
3. Economic and ecological aspects The mining of calcium carbonate and clay for cement
production causes many problems. In particular, the mining
Building and construction materials in Israel are expen- of clay (in fact, often agricultural soil) makes large demands
sive. They are all either imported or dependent in some way on available resources. In addition, the use of fly ash as a
on imported fuel. This should make the possibility of using pozzolan represents a considerable saving in fuel use for
coal ash in construction particularly attractive. Fly ash with cement production and the consequent pollution from both
improved properties should make its increased use in fuel oxidation products and CO2 from the calcination of
construction particularly attractive. Also, power stations in limestone. The possibility of using fly ash as an artificial
Israel are near the areas of maximum population density, aggregate would also reduce the need for unsightly quarry-
building activity and the cement plants. ing operations.
There is a serious shortage of sea sand for construction
3.1. Cement and concrete purposes in the central and northern parts of Israel, and
removal of sand has seriously affected the stabilizing
Fly ash is already added to cement at the 10% level. Thus, dunes along the shore line. Thus replacement of sand as a
the value of this ash has been increased from effectively construction material has environmental and economic
zero to $80 per tonne (the current price of cement). This advantages.
illustrates what a potentially valuable material fly ash can The use of fly ash as landfill in Israel is forbidden by the
be. A further addition to the 20% level (which would be Ministry of the Environment. The main reason for this is the
facilitated by beneficiation), either at the factory or in the fear of contaminating groundwater aquifers, which are very
concrete mix, would effectively solve the excess ash near the surface in many areas. The use of fly ash in
Table 9
Compressive strengths and SAI at 7, 34 and 56 days for various ash fractions passing different sieve sizes. Note: ASTM requirement for SAI 75% at 7 or
28 days
Compressive strength (psi) SAI (%) Compressive strength (psi) SAI (%) Compressive strength (psi) SAI (%)
Sample Blaine fineness (m 2/kg) Water requirement (%) Retained on wet 45 mm sieve (%) SiO2 ⫹ Al2O3 ⫹ Fe2O3 (%) SO3 (%) LOI (%) Moisture (%) Multiple factor
Limit 280 min. 105 max. 34 max. 70 min. 10 max. 3 max. 255 max.
The following are some suggested uses for fly ash in The authors wish to thank Dr Samuel Grossman of the
Israel. Although some of these simply replace existing National Coal Supply Company, Israel, for his generous
materials with fly ash, others could be the basis of comple- help with both the supply of samples and information. We
tely new industries. Because of the desirability of supplying also wish to thank the staff of the Geochemistry Division of
a high-quality reproducible material, it is suggested that the the GSI and our colleagues at CAER, G.A. Thomas, M.B.
coarse fraction be removed from the ash by a simple bene- Grider and W.H. Schram, for carrying out analyses.
ficiation technique such as air classification. This would
have the added advantage of supplying products which
could easily be blended to give particular desirable References
properties.
[1] Statistical Abstract of The State of Israel, 1996. Jerusalem: State of
• A pozzolan for cement in addition to the amounts already Israel, Central Bureau of Statistics, 1997.
used. In large-scale projects such as dams, ports, etc., the [2] Metzger LA. In: Chiang S-H, editor. Proceedings of the 13th Inter-
proportion of ash that can be used is considerably more national Coal Conference (Pittsburgh, PA, 3–7 September 1996), vol.
1. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh, School of Engineering,
than the approximately 20% which is routinely be added Center for Energy Research, 1996:749.
to OPC in the USA [16–20]. This has special importance [3] Manz OE. In: 1995 International Ash Utilization Symposium
in reference to the current ‘Peace Process’ in the Middle Proceedings. Lexington, KY: University of Kentucky Center for
East as many large-scale construction projects are Applied Energy Research, 1995.
planned, especially in the Gaza area. The use of fly ash [4] Grossman S. Personal communication. Israel: National Coal Supply
Company, 1997.
in these projects would represent a considerable saving [5] Shapes S, Cohen C, Foner HA, Nathan Y, Dorfman E. Analytical
of money to all the parties involved. It should be noted methods for testing leachates from coal ash and recommendations
that the Ashkelon power station is situated very close to for test methods for pollutants (in Hebrew). Final Report to the
the Gaza strip. Professional Committee of the Ash Administration, May 1996. Beer-
• As a replacement for the fine aggregate (sea sand or sheva and Jerusalem: Bloch Coal Center, Ben Gurion University; and
Geological Survey of Israel, 1996:139 pp.
machine-ground sand) in concretes and mortars. The [6] Method 3B — available lime index. In: FGD chemistry and analytical
shortage of sea sand in Israel has been mentioned methods handbook, vol. 2: Chemical and physical test methods, B3.
previously. CS-3612 vol. 2, revision 1. Research project 1031-4. TOL No. 5. Final
• As a raw material for lightweight aggregate production. Report November 1988. Palo Alto, CA: Electric Power Research
Some commercial systems are available for this purpose Institute, 1988.
[7] Graham UM, Robl TL, Rathbone RF, McCormick CJ. In: Preprints of
[21,22]. papers presented at the 211th National Meeting of the ACS (New
• As a constituent of lightweight aerated concrete, espe- Orleans, LA, 21–28 March 1996). New York: American Chemical
cially for the construction of insulating building blocks Society, 1996;41(1):265.
[22–24]. These could replace many of the low-fines [8] ASTM. In: Annual book of ASTM standards, vol. 4.02: Concrete and
concrete blocks used at present. aggregates. Philadelphia, PA: American Society for Testing and
Materials, 1996:293.
• As a constituent of ‘flowable fill’ for filling trenches and [9] Keenan GH. In: 1995 International Ash Utilization Symposium
surrounding insulation in building basements, shelters, Proceedings. Lexington, KY: University of Kentucky, Center for
foundations, etc. [22,25]. Applied Energy Research, 1995.
• Export of fly ash. Good-quality fly ash can be sold for up [10] Hill RL, Sarkar SL, Rathbone RF, Hower JC. Cement and Concrete
to $20 per tonne. This is similar to the price obtained for Research 1997;27:193.
[11] Robl TL, Hower JC, Graham UM, Groppo JG, Rathbone RF, Taulbee
some good-quality phosphates ores. In fact, low-quality DN, Medina SS. In: Frazier WF, Smouse SM, editors. Proceedings of
(but beneficiated) phosphates are currently sold in Israel the 1995 International Joint Power Generation Conference, vol. 1:
at $8 per tonne at the factory gate. Environmental control/fuels and combustion technologies. 3/20 in
H.A. Foner et al. / Fuel 78 (1999) 215–223 223
EC/FACT. New York: American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Hemmings RT, Zhang MH, Malhotra VM, editors. Supplemental
1995:469. Proceedings: Fourth International Conference on Fly Ash, Silica
[12] ASTM. In: Annual book of ASTM standards, vol. 4.02: Concrete and Fume, Slag, and Natural Pozzolans in Concrete. Palo Alto, CA: Elec-
aggregates. Philadelphia, PA: American Society for Testing and tric Power Research Institute, 1992:3.
Materials, 1996:184. [20] Bilodeau A, Sivasundaram V, Painter KE, Malhotra VM. In: Berry
[13] Gutierrez B, Pazos C, Coca J. Waste Management and Research EE, Hemmings RT, Zhang MH, Malhotra VM, editors. Supplemental
1993;11:279. Proceedings: Fourth International Conference on Fly Ash, Silica
[14] Swaine DJ. In: Swaine DJ, Goodarzi F, editors. Environmental Fume, Slag, and Natural Pozzolans in Concrete, Palo Alto, CA: Elec-
aspects of trace elements in coal. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic tric Power Research Institute, 1992:4.
Publishers, 1995:204. [21] Mahadew D. In: Krüger JE, Krüger RA, editors. Second International
[15] Negi BS, Meenakshy V. In: Sahu KC, editor. Environmental impact Symposium: Ash a Valuable Resource, vol. 2. Halfway House, South
of coal utilization (from raw material to waste resources): Proceed- Africa: South African Coal Ash Association, 1994:423.
ings of the International Conference. Bombay: Indian Institute of [22] Tyson SS. In: Ghafoori N, editor. Utilization of industrial by-products
Technology, 1991:143. for construction materials. Proceedings of a session of the ASCE
[16] Carette GG, Bilodeau A, Chevrier R, Malhotra VM. In: Berry EE, National Convention in Dallas, TX, 24–28 October 1993. New
Hemmings RT, Zhang MH, Malhotra VM, editors. Supplemental York: American Society of Civil Engineers, 1993:1.
Proceedings: Fourth International Conference on Fly Ash, Silica [23] Kirchen G. In: 1995 International Ash Utilization Symposium
Fume, Slag, and Natural Pozzolans in Concrete. Palo Alto, CA: Elec- Proceedings. Lexington, KY: University of Kentucky, Center for
tric Power Research Institute, 1992:1.1–1.33. Applied Energy Research, 1995.
[17] Naik TR, Singh SS, Hossain MM. In: Krüger JE, Krüger RA, editors. [24] Halmagiu M, Halmagiu A, Fliss L. In: Krüger JE, Krüger RA, editors.
Second International Symposium: Ash a Valuable Resource, vol. 2. Second International Symposium: Ash a Valuable Resource, vol. 2.
Halfway House, South Africa: South African Coal Ash Association, Halfway House, South Africa: South African Coal Ash Association,
1994:493. 1994:303.
[18] Berry EE, Hemmings RT, Zhang MH, Cornelius BJ, Golden DM. In: [25] Ramme BW, Naik TR, Kolbeck HJ. In: Ghafoori N, editor. Utilization
Berry EE, Hemmings RT, Zhang MH, Malhotra VM, editors. Supple- of industrial by-products for construction materials. Proceedings of a
mental Proceedings: Fourth International Conference on Fly Ash, session of the ASCE National Convention in Dallas, TX, 24–28
Silica Fume, Slag, and Natural Pozzolans in Concrete. Palo Alto, October 1993. New York: American Society of Civil Engineers,
CA: Electric Power Research Institute, 1992:2. 1993:41.
[19] Zhang MH, Berry EE, Hemmings RT, Golden DM. In: Berry EE,