Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Open Campus
GROUP PROJECT
By
December 2, 2019
videos for the local and international media market. The company aspires to be a leader in the
film industry highlighting different social and cultural aspects of a wide demography through
collaboration with stakeholders. Its mission is to support and develop the Jamaican Film Industry
through the production of high quality content that represents the cultural diversity and
innovative creations of the people. It is their intention that this will encourage people to share
knowledge and ideas, tell their stories and inspire their audience in relating, emulating and
GD Films is operated by 3 core members: The CEO who also functions as the Director of
Photography and steadicam operator; the Production Coordinator and the accountant. Based on
the small number of core team members, the company has to outsource crew members when it
In the film industry, a company develops its competitive position by aligning itself with
corporations and projects that will showcase its level of experience and expertise and strengthen
the chances of being selected for job bids that may arise from time to time. GD Films seeks to
increase its profitability and enhance its competitive position in the media production market.
The company aims to achieve an annual project intake of 70-80 jobs which amounts to
approximately 6-7 jobs per month. This should be a mixture of both small and large scale
jobs per year. A steady monthly profit is also not being maintained. In addition, there is the
problem of not being able to develop and fund in-house projects that can be distributed on a
variety of platforms such as television and the internet. These projects will provide a sustainable
income for the company once distributed through the right outlets. Team Educo has been tasked
with investigating the root causes of the performance gaps that exist in order to determine
appropriate solutions that will place the company in the position it desires to be.
The target for this needs assessment is bi-fold and includes the employees of the GD
Films Company and the client group of existing and potential clients. These participants are
described below:
● The Chief Executive Officer who is responsible for securing jobs and clients, making
project ideas come to life, selection of crew members, ensuring that projects are executed
and overall project management. He is in his late 30’s and and is passionate about the
growth of the company but also wants to have the right team to work with who shares a
similar vision. At the moment, he is the main camera operator for jobs coming into the
company. In most cases, he has to source a camera assistant who goes along with him on
shoots to do camera preps, change lenses and batteries, etc. Not only does the CEO have
to work assiduously to run the company and get the team to meet estimated targets, but
he has to ensure that he keeps up to date with the latest technology and sharpen his
creative skills so as to be efficient at the work he does for clients. If the company does
not perform up to standard, it may affect sustainability and how well he is able to
● The Production Coordinator who performs project management duties such as: project
company documents maintenance. She is a recent university graduate in her 20’s, and a
previous intern at GD Films. She has been with the company for the past 2 years. She is
the only other employee who works in-office with the CEO and will sometimes go out on
shoots to ensure the smooth running of the production. She has to ensure she does a
thorough job to maintain the integrity of the product and services the company is known
for. Outside of all these tasks, she has to come up with new ideas that the company can
● The Accountant who manages the company’s finances, financial records and
administrative tasks. She primarily works remotely but communicates with the team on a
daily basis. She has been with the company for the past 4 years. She has to ensure that the
financial viability of the company is maintained and look for ways in which the company
● Existing and potential Clients from corporate, independent, non-profit organizations and
other entities. These clients usually request services for content such as advertisements,
music videos, documentaries, short films and features. GD Films’ performance has a
large bearing on whether or not clients contract them in the future but the company would
also benefit from tips that could help them grow in the industry.
Performance Gaps Stated
Misdirected Service
targeting, and niche
development.
In order to confirm the identified gaps, an Organizational Scan will be done to identify
the factors linked to the performance problems to point us in the direction of the right
how it can achieve its intended goals amidst the current challenges. A cause analysis will
uncover the issues that directly or indirectly contribute to the problems so as to efficiently arrive
at feasible interventions.
1. Human Resources
2. Financial management
The following areas will be considered in assessing the company’s organizational performance:
meeting client expectations and providing the relevant services to meet their demands
Financial Viability which includes its sources of funds, how reliable they are and whether
information that will be collected from other sources primarily through interviews and surveys
capacity is the ability of an organization to use its resources to perform”. Based on the nature of
the company, 5 key areas were examined under capacity namely: Human resources, financial
Organizational Capacity
Human Resources
capital which refers to the knowledge and skills of the labour force” and these human resources
are considered to be the most valuable assets. In the organization under review, it is seen where
the CEO is primarily tasked with firmly establishing the mission and vision of the company and
ensuring that each person employed to the company performs according to these core values.
The following questions were posed to the CEO of GD Films to identify the needs that are
lacking in the organization and ascertain the necessary steps to meet these needs. Would you say
the organization is efficient in its efforts to plan for its human resources needs?
2. Does the organization know how and where to identify people with the requisite skills to
maintaining the right number of staff members to effectively carry out intended plans. Currently,
the company is short-staffed and one of the main positions it is looking to fill is that of an in-
house video editor, who will more efficiently meet the demands of the market. The company has
had to turn down video editing jobs because of the lack of human capital and not having
sufficient funds to outsource video editors because the process is not very profitable for them.
The organization has opened its doors to interns from major universities who are desirous
of working in the production field with the hope of finding students who could be recruited as
members of the team. However, in most cases the interns do not perform up to standard and the
In terms of benefits for current employees, there is a system wherein they are given a
bonus at the end of the year for services throughout the year.
Financial Management
The company’s accountant revealed that the company has worked diligently at managing
its finances to ensure it remains in operation. The accountant ensures that all funds are accounted
for and financial statements are produced at the end of each financial year. With this in mind, she
has been able to predict how much funds will be needed to successfully run the company with a
long term view in mind. This has been one of the contributing factors leading to the decision of
the number of projects the company needs to honour as is represented by the optimal
However, the company has not been able to secure sufficient financial resources from
jobs to offset costs directly or indirectly related to its in-house expenses. In addition, it has been
difficult to secure grants or loans which could assist with equipment purchase or aid in the
Operating Structure
Meyer, 1995 points out that the operating structure of an organization includes how labor
is divided which includes authority and responsibility and also the coordination of labour and
this structure must be assessed to see whether it is facilitating or preventing the company’s
movement towards accomplishing its desired goals. In the case of GD Films, roles and
responsibilities are not evenly distributed so you find that persons are performing in more than
one capacity. For example the CEO, who, outside of being in charge of the overall operation of
the company, is also tasked with being the main videographer and photographer, among
performing other roles. This sometimes works to inhibit efficiency in the organization as there
are times when the attention given to one area is greater than another that is equal in importance.
Organizational Infrastructure
seen that while the company uses high quality equipment in its operations that are capable of
producing the high quality products it is known for, most of them are not company-owned.
Equipment deficiency is mainly a result of the high cost of bringing new equipment into the
country. The company however does not entirely escape high costs because it is also very costly
to do rentals.
Organizational Performance
The company has managed to efficiently meet client expectations through its strategy of
finding out from them directly what their needs are and walking them through the process of
what can be done to help them achieve those needs. GD Films offers equal dedication towards all
clients and ensure that they are happy with the high quality service and end product that is
delivered in a timely manner. However, the CEO has noted that the company has to improve in
this area if it is to meet the desired outputs and remain competitive in the industry.
In terms of financial viability, the company gets its revenue from the jobs completed for
external clients. These products are not owned by the company and as such represents a one-time
earning. The company has not been able to produce its own content to facilitate a reliable
alternative source of funds to promote sustainability. The company has managed to pay the bills
to keep the company in operation and also provide monthly salaries for staff members but has
not been able to account for any real profits. As seen in Lusthaus et al (2002), for an organization
to perform well it has to “pay attention to its ability to generate the resources it requires” so it
must not only be able to pay its operational bills but should have some “excess of revenue over
expenses”.
Data Collection
The research design for this needs assessment is a mixed method enquiry. The data will
be derived using three main data collection techniques: Interviews, Surveys and Document
Reviews. The information gathered will be used to redefine the data collection aims and
methods, guide the further analysis to follow, such as the gap and cause analysis, and to
Interviews- The interview process allows for in depth responses and follow up questions
and will be conducted at the initiation of the needs assessment activity with the first group of key
stakeholders, the staff of GD Films. We have designed a 3 phase interview process, where the
first interview will be a structured process with pre-constructed questions. The second interview
will follow an unstructured, informal style, to help the assessor gain further insight into areas
highlighted in the first set of interview responses. The last interview will also be informal, and
serve to consolidate the data findings and form conclusive ideas on the needs of the company.
Surveys- This tool will be employed after the interview process, and be administered to
present and prospective clients via an online platform which is cost effective and the results can
be easily quantified and analysed. The questions will be constructed using the data collected in
the interviews. The survey will serve as insight from the target on their perspective of the needs
they have that are currently not met by GD Films and suggestions as to how the company can
Document/ Data Review- Our final data collection tool will be used by the assessor to
fill in the information gaps of the interviews and surveys. The documents used will include the
companies executive plan, financial records, client and employee records, as well as the contracts
The two most impactful factors affecting the data collection process are listed below:
1. The availability of the potential and present customers to participate in the data collection
process.
2. The process of obtaining the documents for the data review proved to be a bit tedious as
the company did not want to divulge too much information that was considered
confidential.
The following protocol was used to ensure the data collection process was initiated with the
2. Signing of official contracts that employ and describe the services of Team Educo.
5. Distribution of invitations to clients for their participation in the data collection process.
9. Data analyzed.
Following the interview with the CEO of GD Films, it was seen that outsourcing crew
members puts a big dent in the budget because of the high rates they have to pay for their labour
as opposed to having full time employees who could be paid a standard monthly salary. It is
difficult for the company to escape paying these rates as the alternative would have been to turn
down the jobs and this results in a loss of revenue for the company.
The CEO has sought to use the internship program as the main avenue to recruit potential
full-time employees however, with the exception of the current Production Coordinator, they
have not satisfied the requirements that would be in line with the standards of the company. In
The primary causes for not developing in-house content has been linked to lack of
adequate labour force and insufficient funds to cover production costs. The CEO also revealed a
desire for sponsorship that would help to offset some of these costs.
In relation to customer retention, the CEO declined to answer what that rate would be but
agreed that they got referrals from clients. Consequently, this prompted us to find out from the
clients the nature of their relationship with the company, what they liked most and least about
their services and the qualities they in turn are looking for in similar production companies. See
Cash flow in the company is somewhat steady but there is room for improvement as the
company is not realizing a yearly surplus. When asked if he is charging enough to grow the
business the CEO confirmed that his prices are reasonable but he still gets asked to lower his
prices, which he does based on the uniqueness of the situation. This is also in line with the
company’s mantra of extending its services to bring about guaranteed customer satisfaction.
Survey
The data collected by the survey rendered online, is Qualitative in nature, and will be
described and presented in the following sections. The Key findings will summarize the most
important aspects of the data analysis and focus our efforts in the rest of the needs assessment
report. Certain themes were recognized in the data analysis and thus the results are organized as
follows:
2. GD Films’ Strengths
3. GD Films’ Weaknesses
Client History
The data collected in the survey showed that the participants were 65% male and 35%
female. This was confirmed to be reflective of the general population of clients. Ten percent of
the participants were occupied under the Government while 20% each worked in the Private
sector or Non-Governmental Organizations. Fifty percent of the respondents were from the
Advertising field. This was also reflective of the total client population, as the largest client
group were Ad Firms and the smallest Government. Half of respondents had interacted with the
company and its services less than 6 months ago, while 30 and 20 % of the respondents engaged
before July 2019. This helps our investigation to examine both new and older opinions of the
company, and thus make a sound decision. Of the 20 participants in the survey, 45% of them
contracted GD Films for their projects while 55% either chose another production company
(20%) or dissolved the contract between themselves and the company before the end of the
project (35%).
Company Strengths
Of the 45% of persons who contracted GD Films for their project, 56% percent said it
was because of the high quality service. Another 34% said it was because of their competitive
price and the final 11% said it was because of the competence of the staff. These clients used the
company for Videography (56%), Production (22%), Directing (11%) and Video Editing (11%).
Of that list the best services, as rated by the customer, were Videography (78%) and Production
(22%). These clients, who had previously contracted the company recommending the following
areas to focus on improving their services: improve the quality of service and marketing (34%),
employ more innovative solutions to client needs (33%), improve on employee soft skills (22%),
and lower the cost of services (11%). None of the respondents indicated that GD Films should
provide more holistic services, which indicates that the services provided are enough.
Company Weaknesses
Of the 45% who employed GD Films’ service, the group indicated that their worst
services were Video Editing (45%), Directing (33%), and Videography and Production (11%
each). The 55% of respondents who chose not to use GD Films for the completion of the project
explored their reasons why. Of the group 35% were contracts lost by the company which
indicates a problem in client retention during the filming process. Of the entire group, 64%
indicated that the company’s portfolio was outdated. Twenty-seven percent said the rates for
services were too expensive and 9% revealed that they had received negative feedback on the
company. Forty-six and forty-five percent of these participants showed that the company’s they
hired had an up-to-date portfolio and used modern trends in the industry in their work. Nine
percent said their hires were because of their good reputation in the field. Finally, the survey
revealed that what they were seeking most from service providers was high quality, modern
Key Findings
1. The company’s largest client audience were from the Advertising Industry, and should
3. The stronghold service in the company was videography, while video editing was their
weakest rated service. These should therefore require some attention to maintain and
4. The portfolio of the company needs to be updated and modern trends in production
5. The company would see greater financial results from having full time employees than
6. The limited number of employees along with insufficient funds/ sponsorships have
hindered the company’s ability to develop company owned products that can assist in its
sustainable development.
Presentation of Raw Data
The following images illustrate the findings of the Survey conducted for this Needs Assessment.
Figure 4 . Showing the means through which the participants engaged with GD Films.
Figure 5 . Showing the percentage of participants who worked with GD Films.
Cause Analysis
Having pinpointed the performance gaps, a cause analysis was then carried out to identify
possible causes of these performance problems. Van Tiem et al (2004) states, “Cause analysis
determines why the performance gap exists and how it affects the unique mission, needs, wants,
and desires of the organization.” Drivers or causes of the gap were identified, classified and
prioritized and the possible reasons for their existence were proffered. The data gleaned were
used to determine potential solutions to GD Film’s performance issues. Data were compiled from
interviews and surveys of key stakeholders, summarized and analyzed in the table below.
Cause Analysis Results
Table 1
Cause Analysis
Lack of GD
Films
distributive
material.
Lack of
sponsorship.
Lack of training
in industry
specific skills.
identify barriers to optimal individual and organizational performance and shed light on specific
Table 2
Causes impacting performance were attributed to both a lack of environmental support as well as
individualistic factors, with a greater lean towards environmental factors having a greater
influence on performance problems. The data assembled from a plurality of sources served to
shed light on all the significant factors responsible for causing performance gaps. This
Table 3:
performance output of GD Films. This caused a domino effect whereby a lack of manpower
triggered outsourcing of personnel which in turn negatively impacted the financial resources of
GD Films. The outsourcing of equipment and absence of income generating GD Film content
further contributed to financial strains. It also follows that with extra staff coming onboard,
manpower will be increased which will open up avenues for more projects to be facilitated, in-
Proposed Solution
1. A recruitment drive to build human resources where potential employers with the right
attitude to learn and are serious about joining the team are trained according to the
company’s standards. Both current and prospective employees will be trained in specific
skill areas by experts in the industry according to the company’s and customer’s needs.
For example, video editing, producing, modern techniques in film/ editing and camera
operation to name a few. In this way, the human resources will be strengthened and the
company will be able to efficiently tackle a larger number of jobs, while meeting the
client needs with innovative productions. The full time employees will be paid at a fixed
monthly rate and this will stabilize expenditures, and motivate their efforts at work.
by improving their skills, knowledge and attitudes, there is the potential of removing or
preventing performance deficiencies, while making employees more flexible and adaptable and
increasing their commitment to the organization. The recruitment drive that GD Films would
carry out would train the individuals for specific roles within the organization and when the
company has control over what is being taught they can rest assured that they will not
compromise on quality so as to always keep their customers satisfied. Also, the resulting
increased labour force will allow the company to better meet its desired number of annual job
intake. The more high quality outputs the company can manage to undertake, the more
2. An assessment and rewards system where, in addition to getting a bonus at the end of the
year, employees who have performed exceptionally on particular jobs are rewarded for
their contributions. This will help to motivate staff to continue doing their best and will
Research has identified factors such as quality, value and satisfaction, which are
ingredients of customer loyalty building (Akbar, M.M. & Parvez, N., 2009). There are other
studies, which also found that these are important variables, which impact customer loyalty
(Kandampully, J., Zhang, T. & Bilgihan, A., 2015) but these are only partial insight into building
customer loyalty. As it relates to GD Films, this would help to build their clientele as well as
generate additional income, that will allow them to be able to hire the required staff needed to
3. Building a stronger online presence with an updated website which includes a modern
layout, updated portfolio, social media interactions , and a customer loyalty program to
help retain customers and help to attract new businesses as well. This will allow the
opportunity for clients to spend more money with the company which will pay off in the
long run.
For employees to perform at their best they need intrinsic or extrinsic motivation, it has
has always been one of the most important methods in managing employees’ performance.
Studies have shown that employees are highly conscious of reward systems as well as
performance recognition and thus they are important variables in job satisfaction. Carrather,
Gibson, & Buckley (2006) found that in order to retain high performance an organization must
have a good reward system that has the ability to meet the expectation. In the case of GD Films,
the use of expectancy theory could be the best system of compensation for their employees as a
principle that will keep their staff highly motivated, which will in return maximize their
Conclusion
Based on a needs assessment carried out on the company GD Films, Team Educo found
that there were gaps in the number of jobs acquired yearly, the ability of the company to retain
jobs, the human resource capacity and funding recruitment, and the company’s ability to develop
in-house productions that would facilitate sustainable development. These gaps were directly
linked to the initially identified problem of not securing enough revenue. The data collected
revealed that the company's marketing strategies were insufficient and possibly aimed at the
wrong target. The study showed that they were losing as many clients as they had secured and
they needed some modern rebranding measures to help bring in fresh work. It was also seen that
there were greater financial gains to be had from a full time workforce and possible room for in
The interventions suggested to address these gaps included a rebranding measure through
greater more modern online presence, recruitment programs, training, customer loyalty program
and employee reward and feedback system. Once these intervention strategies are enacted and
implemented greater success can be achieved. The solution prescribed can be initiated as seen fit
by the organization based on their funding abilities and the priorities of the gaps. The next step
for GD Films is to put swift action into place, learn from the mistakes made and aim for
Akbar, M.M., Parvez, N., 2009. Impact of service quality, trust, and customer satisfaction on
Carraher, S.M., Whitney Gibson, J. and Buckley, M.R., (2006). Compensation Satisfaction in the
Baltic’s and the USA. Baltic Journal of Management, l (1), pp. 7-23.
Kandampully, J., Zhang, T., Bilgihan, A., 2015. Customer loyalty: a review and future directions
Lusthaus, C., Adrien, M., Anderson, G., Carden, F., & Montalvan, G.P. (2002). Organizational
Meyer, D. (1995). Structural Cybernetics: An Overview. Dean Meyer & Associates Inc.
https://www.clarktraining.com/content/forms/CC-NA.pdf
Van Tiem, D. M., Moseley, J. L., & Dessinger, J. C. (2004). Fundamentals of performance
https://flylib.com/books/en/3.398.1.14/1/
Appendices
APPENDIX A
CEO
2. What is the impact of outsourcing on your overall payroll system and have you observed
any benefits in this regard?
Answer: We do outsourcing primarily when we have large jobs that require a large number of
crew members. However, this is very expensive as these people often times come at high
rates. This could have been avoided if we had the people in-house so you know we would be
paying them a fixed monthly rate that we make plans for in the budget. But if we don’t get
these people we have to turn down the jobs, so you see our dilemma.
3. What were the most important factors you consider in hiring an intern?
Answer: They must be proficient with video and the tools, obviously. Ease of use with
technology. Social media, computer programs, iPads – these are a piece of cake for young
professionals, you can always use a hand from a fellow Gen Y tech-savvy professional. They
must also know how to use their initiative. There is no such thing as not having work to do.
There is always work to be done, come up with new ideas for projects and think of what the
company can do to better itself. I hardly get that from the interns that come here. There are
certain skills that can be taught but they must know how to adapt to their surroundings.
5. How much time do you and your team spend on generating revenue?
Answer: Most of the time is spent on either formulating strategy or generating revenue. Often
as CEO I have so many other tasks to do that some things will get neglected but I know we
have a lot more grounds to cover where this is concerned.
6. What are the main causes for your company not developing its own content?
Answer: This mainly due to lack of staff and time to get the work done but we also do not
have sufficient funds to cover all the production costs involved. If we could get sponsors that
would help a lot.
7. What is your client retention rate?
Answer: Honestly, I prefer not to answer that question.
8. Will your clients refer other people they know to your company?
Answer: Yes, we get referrals and we have a good social media following.
11. How can you add more value for your customers?
Answer: By creating quality work and making sure that I meet the demands of my clients.
Please select the most suitable answers for the questions below. Do not include any
identification as your responses will remain confidential.
2. Occupation _________________
( )More than 1 year ago ( ) less than 1 year ago ( ) within the last 6 months
( ) Responded to an advertisement
5. Have you worked previously with the company on any project? (Including consultations)
( ) Yes ( ) No
( ) We began working together, but dissolved the contract after a short time.
If you did not respond ‘Yes’ to Question 5 answer the following questions.
11. Why did you choose to not work with GD Films on your project?
( ) They are too expensive
( ) Their portfolio needs to be updated
( ) They have negative feedback from previous clients
( ) Other ________________________________________________________________
12. What were the key characteristics of the company that you chose for your project?
( )An up-to-date portfolio
( )Use of modern trends
( )Respect for clients
( ) Good track record
13. What do you seek most from organizations like GD Films?
( ) Commitment to quality service
( ) Affordable prices
( ) To be respected and treated equally
( ) Other ________________________________
APPENDIX C
Contract Sample
GD Films Productions
Employees contract.
NAME: ___________________________________
ADDRESS: ______________________________________________________
CITY: __________________________
Phone : __________________________
***********************
POSITION: ______________________________________
1. Hours of work
Overtime will only be worked if agreed upon between the parties from time to time.
The employee will be paid for overtime at the rate of one and a half times his/her total wage as set out in
clause
Unless expressly provided elsewhere in this deal memo, no increased or additional compensation shall
accrue or be payable to employee for the rendering of services at night or on weekends or holidays, or after
the expiration of any particular number of hours of service in any period.
2. MEALS: The Production Company will provide meal breaks and/or food service at approximately four
(4) hour intervals. The cost of food services will be covered by the Production Company.
3. EXCLUSIVITY: Employee's services are on an exclusive basis to the production of the motion picture
(the "Picture") referred to in this deal memo for such period of time as required unless otherwise specified
in this deal memo.
4. Wage: The employee/s wage shall be paid in cash on the last working day of every week/month and
shall be: A weekly/monthly transport allowance of:
5. NO WAIVER: The terms and conditions of this deal memo are binding on Production Company and
employee and shall not be waived or altered by any method. Any added conditions on the front of this deal
memo inconsistent with these conditions of employment shall be null and void.
6. WORK-FOR-HIRE: Production Company shall be the owner of all of the results and proceeds of
employee's services, including any copyright, trademark and any other intellectual property rights in any
work or property created by Employee, or anyone under Employee's direction. Employee acknowledges
that Employee's work is a "work made for hire" within the scope of Employee’s employment, and therefore
Employer shall be the author and copyright owner of any work created under this agreement. In the event
that any of proceeds of Employee's work are not considered a work for hire, then Employee's copyright to
such work is hereby assigned to Employer.
7. PUBLICITY: Employee shall not directly or indirectly circulate, publish or otherwise disseminate any
news story, article, book or other publicity concerning the Picture, or employee's or others' services without
Production Company's prior written consent, provided that employee may issue personal publicity
mentioning the Picture so long as such references are not derogatory. Employee has permission to show a
videotape of Picture in connection with seeking future employment. Employer shall have the right to use
employee's name, voice, picture and likeness in connection with the Picture, the advertising and publicizing
thereof, and any promotional films or clips respecting the Picture without additional compensation
therefore.
___________________________________________
___________________________________________
EMPLOYEE SIGNATURE
___________________________________________
DATE
___________________________________________
___________________________________________
DATE