Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/262284083
CITATIONS READS
2 3,478
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Empowerment,Participation and Leadership in strengthening Local Government system: A study on elected representatives at Union Parishad Level View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Mohammad Samiul Islam on 04 March 2015.
Articles
Abstract. Basically, e-Governance is generally understood as the use of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) at
all levels of the Government in order to provide services to the citizens, interaction with business enterprises and communication
and exchange of information between different agencies of the Government in a speedy, convenient, efficient, and transparent
manner. It makes government process more accountable, responsive and transparent. On the other hand, Good governance means
participation, transparency and accountability in administration. E-Governance and Good Governance are interrelated issue in
the process of Public Administration. This study aims to explore the overall view of e-Governance, Good Governance and their
relationship. In order to clarify of this study; It has taken Divisional Comptroller of Accounts office at Charadigirpar, Sylhet,
Bangladesh as the study field. Data has been collected from the officials and services recipients as well as different e-governance
related articles, research findings etc. help us to prepare this paper.
∗ Corresponding author: Zayeda Sharmin, Department of Politi- The main focus of this study is to explore impact
cal Studies, Shahjalal University of Science and Technology Sylhet, of e-Governance on public offices could for ensuring
Bangladesh. E-mail: zayeda_sharmeen@yahoo.co.in. Good Governance in the studied area. Society could be
ISSN 1878-7673/13/$27.50
c 2013 – IOS Press and the authors. All rights reserved
144 Z. Sharmin and M.S. Islam / Impact of e-governance in public offices
change by the application of e-Governance. It is con- national donors, multinationals corporations etc. These
sidered as potential area in the process of development have been playing significant role in decision making
in Bangladesh. The specific objectives of this study are process.
follows:
– To get on exposure view of term “Governance and
e-Governance” and its status in Bangladesh. 5. Conceptualizing of good governance
– To identify the problem and opportunity of e-
Governance. Governance can be viewed both in positive and neg-
– The concept of e-Governance and its relation to ative terms (1) Good governance and (2) Poor gover-
Good Governance. nance. Good governance means ideal governance sys-
– To suggest or comments about the implementa- tem that is inevitable for political, economic, social and
tion of e-Governance to achieve Good Gover- cultural development of a country. It is the ideal orien-
nance in the Public Offices. tation of a state that works best to achieve self-reliance,
– Highlighting prospects and problem of e-Govern- sustainable development and social justice. Good Gov-
ance in development administration through ana- ernance, for the World Bank, includes following fea-
lyzing different issues of development. tures [http://www.unescap.org access on 11 October
2011]:
– An efficient public service;
3. The methodology of the study – An independent judicial system and legal frame-
work to enforce contracts;
This study has been followed multiple research – Accountable administration of public funds;
methods such as Interview and Content Analysis. Both – An independent public auditor, responsible to a
secondary and primary data has been collected by representative legislature;
books, articles, journals, and concern public office’s – Respect of the law and human rights at all levels
websites as well as interview public personnel and ser- of government;
vice receivers through questionnaire respectively. – A free press.
There is no doubt that today Governance has be- The United Nations emphasizes reform through hu-
come the focal discourse of contemporary develop- man development political institution reform. Accord-
ment and got serious attention from development prac- ing to the UN, Good Governance consists of 8 ma-
titioners, policymakers, policy analysts and interna- jor characteristics [http://www.unescap.org/huset/gg/
tional development agencies both in Bangladesh and governace.htm access on 26/12/2011]. These are:
across the world. In its broader perspective governance i. Participation
involves actions of publicly vested authorities. How- ii. Rule of Law
ever, the concern of all and any governance analyses iii. Transparency
moves around three fundamental questions What, How iv. Consensus
and how well. An analysis of governance focuses on v. Equity and Inclusiveness
the formal and informal factors involved in decision vi. Effectiveness and Efficiency
making and implementing the decisions made and the vii. Responsiveness and
formal and informal structures that have been set in viii. Accountability.
place. E-Governance is one of the important factors
These criteria assure that:
for improving the quality of public services which is
indicates better Governance. There are many factors – Corruption is minimized
involved with governance system and vary depending – The views of minorities are taken into account
on the level of governance is depends on the quality – The voice of the most vulnerable in society is
of decision which has taken by the respective author- heard in decision making
ity. In addition, quality of Governance can be influ- – It is also responsive to the present and future
enced by an effective role of media, lobbyists, inter- needs of society.
Z. Sharmin and M.S. Islam / Impact of e-governance in public offices 145
– A new model of governance would be based upon 13.4. The conceptual relationship between
the transactions in virtual space, digital econ- e-governance and good-governance
omy and dealing with knowledge oriented soci-
eties [8]. The Relationship between E-governance and Good
Governance has given below [6].
13.2. Development of e-governance in Bangladesh
13.5. The perception of accounting
There are three stages for development of e-govern-
ance in Bangladesh which are The term Accounting denotes certain theories, mea-
– Phase I Informational surement rules and procedures for collecting and re-
– Phase II Interactional porting useful information concerning the activities
– Phase III Transactional. and objectives of an organization. In less general
terms, accounting is classification, analysis, and inter-
Informational phase main objective is to gather in-
pretation of the financial or bookkeeping records of
formation and update the information time to time.
an enterprise. The various aspects of accounting are:
In the second phase increase the interactive commu-
constructive (theoretical accounting), practical (cost
nication between government and citizen. Transaction
accounting and financial accounting), critical (finan-
and online use increase in the final phase. In this way
cial audit and cost audit), communication (manage-
growth of e governance happened. E governance goes
rial accounting and accounting information system),
with two processes. One is structural process which is
and structural (accounting system design). The ba-
directly related with a government and other is cable
sic accounting and auditing organizational structure of
process which involve in e governance [8].
Bangladesh was inherited from British India. Consti-
tutional Reforms in 1919 and the Government of In-
13.3. Why essential e-governance
dia Act 1935 put forward the need for an independent
Auditor General. After the end of the British period,
New information and communication technology the Pakistan (Audit and Accounts) Order of 1952 and
(ITC) can make a significant contribution to achieve thereafter in Bangladesh, articles 127–132 of the Con-
Good Governance goal. This e-Governance ensures stitution and the C&AG (Additional Functions) Act of
good governance by making governance more efficient 1974 have replicated the basic framework of the previ-
and more effective, and brings other benefits too. There ous centralized audit and accounts system.
are many possible reasons and goals for e governance The major segments of financial accounting in
such as [World Bank, 2005]. Bangladesh are: private sector accounting, public sec-
– Improving the quality of life for disadvantage tor accounting, non-government organization account-
communities strengthen Good Governance. ing, and government accounting. Accounting of all the
– Improving the efficiency of government agencies. different types of private sector enterprises (sole pro-
– For providing better public service. prietorship, partnership, limited companies, and co-
– Promoting priority and special sector. operatives as well as enterprises in manufacturing, ser-
– Strengthening the legal system and law enforce- vice, and merchandising) are influenced by various
ment. acts.
– For ensuring accountabilities. Accounts of the government of Bangladesh are
– Increasing the transparency of public administra- supervised by the Controller General of Accounts
tion (CGA) responsible for keeping accounts. Central ac-
– Provision of quality service tailored to the need of counts offices are those of a Controller General of
the citizen and business. Accounts, Additional Director General (Finance) of
– Increasing the quality of public services. Railway, Controller General of Defense Finance. As
– Broadening public participation. of December 2001, following are the key officers un-
– Enhancing service to citizens. der the Controller General of Accounts: Chief Ac-
– Removing the complexity of public offices. counts Officers (51), Divisional Controllers of Ac-
– Fight corruption and encourage bittern implemen- counts (6), District Accounts Officers (64), and Up-
tation of public policy. azila Accounts Officers (400). The Additional Direc-
– To save time, Labor. tor General (Finance) of Railway has a Joint Direc-
Z. Sharmin and M.S. Islam / Impact of e-governance in public offices 147
Fig. 1. The Conceptual Relationship between e-Governance and Good Governance, Source: Authors, 2012.
tor General and under him, FA&CAOs (Financial Ad- 13.6. Legal basis of controller of accounts,
visor and Chief Accounts Officers), one each for east Bangladesh
zone, west zone and projects. Officers under the Con-
CAG is a constitutional body which would be re-
troller General of Defense Finance are Senior Fi- sponsible for audit in all level Public Offices. It has
nance Controllers (5), Finance Controllers (5), and been directed by article 127–131 in the constitution of
Area Finance Controllers (6) [http://www.banglapedia. Bangladesh. According to the Article 127 of the consti-
org/HT/A_0021.HTM access on 15/12/12]. tution there shall be a comptroller and Auditor General
148 Z. Sharmin and M.S. Islam / Impact of e-governance in public offices
Pen-drive
Transfers file
Webcam Emergency
meeting, video
Conference
trict Controller of Accounts office has been computer- been working actively and four computers are not per-
ized respectively but both mentioned offices have not forming vigorously. Total number of computers in Di-
been computerized completely. On the other hand, Up- visional controller of Accounts office:
azila Controller of Accounts office has been serving Table 1
to the people by traditional procedure/way which are Statistics of computers in Divisional controller of Accounts office
called Manual. DCA and ZCA have been introduc- Name of items No
ing e-Governance system in a specific field. Upazila i. Cash 2
Controller of Accounts offices has under considera- ii. Audit and Account Officer 1
tion to introduce e-Governance system. The Divisional iii. Lab (for bill posting) 7
iv. ADCA 1
Controller of Accounts office have been using differ- v. DCA 1
ent computers and made web portal to provide better vi. Accounts 1
services. Computerization and electronic service deliv- Total 13
ery system have been increasing their performance by
which confidence of stakeholders have also improved
in the study area. Such system has to perceive for mak-
ing digital Bangladesh. The findings of the study are 16. Impact of e-governance in public offices for
that e-Governance approach has been facing infrastruc- achieving good governance
tural constraint. Therefore, the service system has been
interrupting by above mentioned limitations and which E-Governance has a huge blessing on public offices.
could not established/ensures to promote frequent and It reduces corruption rate, increases efficiency of the
smooth services. For instance, thirteen computers have people makes people responsible to their work. The
150 Z. Sharmin and M.S. Islam / Impact of e-governance in public offices
overall development of e-Governance cannot describe 17. Comparison between present and previous
in words. Impact of e-Governance has had on various condition of divisional controller of accounts
sectors of works for ensuring Good Governance. In or- office
der to identify Good Governance in Sleet Controller
of Accounts office, the study had to distinguish cri- DCA has been using Computer IBAS (Integrate
Budgeting and Accounting System) process while ear-
teria for drawing inference on condition of GG situa-
lier system was Manually TAS (Transaction Account-
tion. On the basis of those indicators, DCA’s working
ing System) process. Type writer had been used for
environment, ideas and decision making process has writing and now they have done their writing through
been influencing by the assistance of electronic device computer. Before adapting e-Governance system, ap-
which has given contribution to transparent of their ac- pointment letter had post by postman but now such job
tivities, receiving people e-participation and respond- has been doing by Email, fax. DCA had previously
ing to people when they have frequently asked any sort filed storage by using traditional way such papers and
of query. The following information reflects that appli- documents. On the other hand, now they have been
cation of e-Governance is ensuring Good Governance adopting internet, hard drive for storing information.
to the Divisional Controller of Accounts Office, Syl- Using of large human resources for accomplishing the
het. The study has found some remarkable constraints goal while reduces the use of human sources and saves
and these reasons are directly responsible to make sure money of an organization. All official had been work-
ing through using pen and paper. On the contrary, they
Good Governance at the DCA.
have been doing same job by electronic device. There
Transparency: In manual system an employee de-
is little Probability to make mistake as well as modest
lay to pass bill and can even hide the check and creates chance to recover if any sort of documents have lost.
trouble. But in e-governance, all works are monitoring To collect superior signature for approval of file em-
through computer which ensure transparency. ployees had to go to his superior chamber. In emer-
Accountability: Through posting the bill and pre- gency, such duties could be done by assistance of e-
serving the record, file and date simplifying works and mail. Although internet infrastructures have not been
ensure accountability. So, there is no scope to do crime. develop without risk level. In earlier, DCA had been
Efficiency: In manual system so many mistakes working slow and stable but after entering on line high-
were done by the employee and it took a lot of time to way mentioned accounts office has become very first
change or recover it. But in e-Governance, the use of and dynamic. E-participation, E-decision making, e-
communication have been improving towards better-
‘Journal Entry’ helps to turns mistake into correct. By
ment (for instance people have not need to come in
debit, credit system all takes accomplish in a planned
DCA to know general information if they connected
way. with internet). E-Service system of DCA has been pop-
Consensus Oriented: The Divisional Controller of ularized to the inhabitants to make easy access for nec-
Accounts office has their own website in which a citi- essary information but such kind of access had not ex-
zen or a service holder can complain about their prob- isted before development of e-service. As a result, this
lems. And also can claim against any mismanagement. system has becoming popularity due to reduce harass-
Their opinions are accepted. ment, corruption, cost effectiveness etc. Heavy work-
Responsiveness: The responsibility of the govern- load files were gathered while Files are transferred
ment official increase as their work load has been de- from one hand to another through pen drive.
creased. As a result, they are satisfied and providing
best service to their client. 17.1. Outcome of the study
Equity and Inclusiveness: As service are providing
i) According to the organogram there shall be
via e governance all are equal and inclusive. And there
number 72 employees but only 40 employees
is no particular class which is given better service. exist.
Participation: A people can participate by giving ii) There is no dealing with public. Only Govt. Of-
their opinion about any matter through e-mail which ficial comes for their service.
might be called e-participation. Such participation sys- iii) Transact report, advice comes everyday from
tem has not been working frequently and smoothly. Bangladesh Bank. It’s a lengthy process.
Z. Sharmin and M.S. Islam / Impact of e-governance in public offices 151