Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Battery pack (B) in both parking mode and driving PEM − PEG (2)
conditions, through the Electric Node (EN). The Electric NB =
PB , u
Motor (EM) can either provide the mechanical power
for the propulsion or restore part of the braking power where PB,u is the nominal power of a single battery
during regenerative braking (Fig. 1 ). In this structure, module.
the thermal engine can work mostly at constant power, The power of the electric machine (PEM) is computed
corresponding to its optimal efficiency, while the imposing that the HSV Power to Weight ratio (PtWHSV),
electric motor EM is designed to assure the attainment corresponds to a 1250 kg conventional vehicle (CV)
of the vehicle peak power. powered by a 75 kW gasoline engine, as reported in
Tab. I.
PICE ,CC
PV PtWHSV = (3)
Wbody ,CC
PEM = PtWHSV ⋅ WHSV (4)
EG EN EM
CV HSV
PICE [kW] 75 46
Fuel gasoline gasoline
ICE B
PEG [kW] 0 43
PEM [kW] 0 90
NB [/] 0 27
Fig. 1 - Scheme of the series hybrid solar vehicle. APVH [m2] 0 1.44
W [kg] 1250 1465
2.1 Solar energy for vehicle propulsion
Tab. I – Vehicle Technical Data.
The estimation of net solar energy captured by PV
panels in real conditions (i.e. considering clouds, rain 3 ENERGY FLOW MANAGEMENT AND
etc.) and available for propulsion is accomplished by a CONTROL IN A HYBRID SOLARVEHICLE
solar calculator developed at the US National
Renewable Energy Lab has been used [13]. The Hybrid Solar Vehicles have of course many similarities
maximum panel area can be estimated as function of car with Hybrid Electric Vehicles, for which many studies
dimensions and shape, by means of a simple geometrical on the optimal management and control of energy flows
model. The instantaneous power (P(t)) is estimated for have been presented in last years [6], [7], [8], [9], [22].
assigned vehicle data and driving cycle, integrating a Nevertheless, the presence of solar panels and the
longitudinal vehicle model based on a dynamic vehicle adoption of a series structure may require to study and
simulator [15]. The required driving energy depends on develop specific solutions for optimal management and
vehicle weight and aerodynamic parameters, which in control of an HSV.
turn depend on the sizing of propulsion system In fact, in most electric hybrid vehicles a charge
components and on vehicle dimensions, related to solar sustaining strategy is adopted: at the end of a driving
panel area. Battery, electric motor and generator are path, the battery state of charge should remain
simulated by the ADVISOR model [16]. unchanged. With a solar hybrid vehicle, a different
strategy should be adopted as battery is charged during
2.2 Vehicle weight parking hours as well. In this case, a different goal can
be pursued, namely restoring the initial state of charge
The parametric weight model of the HSV can be within the end of the day rather than after a single
obtained adding the weight of the specific components driving path [13].
(PV panels, battery pack, ICE, Generator, Electric Moreover, the series configuration suggests quite an
Motor, Inverter) to the weight of the Conventional efficient solution, namely to operate the engine in an
Vehicle (CV) equipped with ICE (WCV) and by intermittent way at constant operating conditions. Of
subtracting the contribution of the components resized course, the maximum gain in terms of fuel consumption
or not present in the HSV (i.e. ICE, gearbox, clutch, as occurs when the ICE power corresponds to the most
detailed in a previous work [12]. efficient value. In such case, the engine-generator
Considering the lay-out described in Fig. 1 , the required system may be designed and optimized to maximize its
nominal battery power is: efficiency, emissions and noise at design point, while in
PB = PEM − PEG (1) current automotive engines the maximum efficiency is
usually sacrificed to the need of assuring stable
In Eq. (1) the power contribution from the PV array is operation and good performance in the whole operating
not accounted for because of two reasons: the first is the range. The techniques developed for HEV, mostly
unpredictability of sunshine availability (e.g. rainy adopting parallel or series/parallel structure, tend to treat
days); the second is linked to the relatively small PV the engine as a continuous system working in the whole
nominal power that can installed on cars at the current range of operating conditions. This approach is also
technology stage. Therefore the number of battery followed in some recent studies to HSV, based on the
modules is evaluated as:
3363
17th IFAC World Congress (IFAC'08)
Seoul, Korea, July 6-11, 2008
application of Dynamic Programming and Model extending to HSV the approach based on provisional
Predictive Control [21]. In case of engine intermittent load estimate recently applied to HEV real-time control
operation, the effects exerted on fuel consumption and [9].
emissions by the occurrence of thermal transients in The minimum and maximum allowed values for SOC
engine and catalyst should be considered. These effects are imposed considering battery reliability, while the
are neglected in most studies on HEV, where a steady- limit on maximum SOC during driving phases is due to
state approach is usually used to evaluate fuel the exigency to assure a battery capacity sufficient to
consumption and emissions. store the expected solar energy during parking time.
A preliminary analysis of HSV energy management has Further constraints are introduced to limit the ICE power
been presented by considering a single period for ICE within the operating range and to avoid ICE operation
operation within the driving cycle module, at specified phases overlapping.
position (i.e. at the end of driving cycle) [13]. This The driving cycle is composed of 4 modules of ECE-
approach allows to take into account the key aspects EUDC cycle, as shown in Fig. 2.
related to control, in a framework where the main target Reference vehicle speed [km/h]
140
was to estimate the effects of different vehicle and
powertrain variables on energy flows. This procedure 120
has been integrated in the vehicle dynamic model, also
100
considering weight and costs, and used to study optimal
vehicle design. 80
In order to develop a supervisory control to be
implemented on the vehicle, a more accurate analysis of 60
the optimal ICE power distribution over an arbitrary
40
driving cycle has to be performed.
20
4 EFFECTS OF ICE INTERMITTENT OPERATION
0
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200
The intermittent operation of the ICE produces the Time [s]
occurrence of thermal transients both in engine and in Fig. 2 – Module of the ECE-EUDC driving cycle.
catalyst, so influencing fuel consumption and emissions.
These effects should be analyzed and taken into account 4.1 Modeling of engine thermal transient
for energy flow management and control, also in order
to develop suitable solutions for vehicle thermal The effects of thermal transients have been accounted
management. In this paper, the aspects related to engine for assuming that: (i) the ICE power does not reach
thermal transients and HC emissions are considered. instantaneously its reference value and (ii) the specific
A study on the optimal ICE power trajectory has been consumption depends not only on ICE power but also on
performed by solving the following constrained the actual engine temperature.
optimization problem: The coolant temperature T has been assumed as engine
min m&
X ∫ ( X )dt
f , HSV
(5) reference temperature. The time variation of T has been
estimated as a first order process by the following
subject to the constraints: equation:
ΔSOCday (PEM , PICE ( X ), PSUN ) = 0 (6) −
t
T (t ) = Tss + (Tin − Tss ) ⋅ e K (9)
SOC > SOCmin (7)
The values of steady state temperature Tss and of the
SOC < SOCmax (8) time constant K have been assigned according to the
following table, based on some experimental tests
The decision variables X include, for each ICE-on event, performed at the test bench:
starting time, duration and ICE power level, while the
number N of ICE-on phases has been assigned, in order ICE operation Tss [°C] K [s]
to analyze its influence on the results.
ON 82 150
The first constraint allows to restore the initial state of
OFF 27 600
charge within the end of the day, also considering
parking phases. It requires the integration of the vehicle
Fuel consumption (Eq. 10) is estimated by correcting the
dynamic model over the day. PEM is known from the
steady-state values, corresponding to thermal
assigned mission profile, while also net power from sun
equilibrium conditions, by a factor depending on the
is considered known. PICE depends on the decision
ratio between the actual and steady-state values of
variables X.
engine temperature.
It is worth noting that the proposed control strategy is
based on the knowledge of the vehicle route, thus being ⎛T ⎞
unsuitable for real-time control. Nevertheless the P (t ) = Pss ⋅ f ⎜⎜ ⎟⎟ (10)
⎝ Tss ⎠
proposed approach is consistent with the purpose of the
paper, that is aimed at analyzing the effects of engine
operation on fuel efficiency. This task will be helpful for
the future development of supervisory HSV control,
3364
17th IFAC World Congress (IFAC'08)
Seoul, Korea, July 6-11, 2008
⎛ T ⎞ 0.3
HC in = HC in _ cold ⋅ f ⎜ in ⎟ (13)
⎜T ⎟
⎝ in _ cold ⎠
0.2
0.1
this way the model can predict HC emissions even in
case of engine warm start. The correcting factor has 0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300
been evaluated as function of a fuel delivery efficiency Time [s]
that expresses the ratio between actuated and effective
Air to Fuel Ratio (AFR) [14] Actually, the fuel delivery Fig. 4 – Simulated engine temperature and tail-pipe
efficiency accounts for the wall wetting process and the HC emissions in case of cold (27 °C) and warm (49
effect of fuel enrichment on HC formation mechanism. °C) engine start maneuver.
Of course, assuming fixed engine speed, load and spark
advance, the correcting factor mainly depends on the 5 SIMULATION RESULTS
engine thermal state [14], [20].
The steady state value HCss is computed by a look-up The simulations were performed by solving the
table expressing the dependence of HC concentration constrained optimization problem, as defined in Eqs. (5-
from engine temperature. Hence, when the early 8), for the HSV configuration described in Table I. It is
transient has been extinguished (i.e. after the first 20 s), worth mentioning that such configuration corresponds to
the HC emissions are evaluated as function of the engine the one that maximizes fuel economy, as indicated by
thermal state, regardless to gas composition and the authors themselves in a previous work [13]. The ICE
temperature and to catalyst thermal state. intermittent operation was analyzed for a number of
Actually, the experimental data were measured imposing ICE-on phases N ranging from 1 to 8, thus allowing to
stoichiometric mixture and fixed spark advance, engine extensively assess the effect of several engine start/stop
speed and load along the whole warm-up maneuver. maneuvers on both fuel consumption and emissions.
Therefore, if a similar transient is imposed for each Fig. 5 shows the dependence of fuel consumption and
engine start operation then gas composition and HC emissions on N. It emerges from the figure how fuel
temperature are not affected by anything else than consumption initially decreases towards a minimum
engine temperature. Consequently, also catalyst value, in correspondence of N=3. This is explained by
3365
17th IFAC World Congress (IFAC'08)
Seoul, Korea, July 6-11, 2008
the tendency, with higher number of ICE-on phases, to (here set to 9 hours whereas driving time is 1 hour per
operate the engine as close as possible to its most day).
efficient operating point (i.e. 22 kW, which is
HSV power [kW] - N = 4 (a)
approximately ½ of maximum power as reported in 60
Table I). Then, due to the negative effect of thermal 45 drive
gen
transient on ICE efficiency, taken into account by Eqs. 30
15
(10) and (11), the advantage related to the higher 0
number of ICE operation vanishes, thus causing fuel -15
consumption to increase. -30
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000
On the other hand, HC emissions show an undesirable Time [s]
State of charge [/] N = 4 - (b)
increasing trend when more ICE-one events are 0.8
considered. This happens because of the initial large
0.75
amount of HC released when ICE is turned on, as a
consequence of the rich air-fuel mixture delivered to the 0.7
engine for fast warm-up. Nevertheless, after the first
0.65
ICE-on event, the relatively slow decay in engine 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000
Time [s]
temperature (see Fig. 7) causes this effect to reduce at
following engine starts (see Fig. 4). Particularly, Figure Fig. 6 – Simulated power (a) and state of charge (b)
7 shows that in case of N=3 the engine is turned on for trajectories for the selected driving cycle.
the second and third time at temperature as low as 40
Engine temperature [°C]
°C, whereas in case of N=4 ICE is always turned on at 90
higher temperatures. Moreover, the last ICE-on for N=4
80
is enabled at temperature around 55 °C, which results in
a small HC release in this phase. Therefore, fuel delivery 70
2.45 6 CONCLUSIONS
2.4
1 2 3 4 5
Number of ICE-on events
6 7 A study on energy flow management in a hybrid solar
8
HC emissions [g] - (b) vehicle with series structure has been presented. In spite
1.7
of the many similarities, there are some significant
1.5
1.3
differences between HSVs and HEVs: the presence of
1.1
solar panels, contributing to recharge the battery also
0.9 during parking phases and the adoption of a series
0.7 structure, more suitable with plug-in hybrid concept,
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Number of ICE-on events instead of the prevailing parallel or series/parallel
structure in HEVs. These differences suggest that HSV
Fig. 5 – Effects of number of ICE-on phases (N) on control cannot be simply borrowed by the solutions
fuel consumption (a) and HC emissions (b). adopted for HEV. In order to develop a supervisory
Fig. 6a and 6b show the model outputs computed in case control for a HSV prototype, a study on the performance
of 4 ICE-on events. Particularly, Fig. 6a shows the achievable by using the ICE at maximum efficiency in
power contributions from the electric generator (red intermittent mode is presented. The analysis also
line) to meet the traction power demand, whereas battery considers thermal transient effects on engine power and
and solar panels (the latter being constant and quite fuel consumption and HC emissions transient during the
negligible during driving phases) power trajectories engine start maneuver. The optimal ICE power
were omitted for sake of clarity. It is interesting to note trajectory is found by solving a non-linear constrained
how for N=4 the constrained optimization analyses led optimization that accounts for fuel mileage and state of
to place the ICE-on events in correspondence of the charge, also considering solar contribution during
highest power demands. This result can be explained by parking mode. The results show that the presence of
considering that it allows to reduce low-load, less engine thermal transients due to start-stop operation
efficient ICE operations. cause a non negligible reduction in fuel economy with
Fig. 6b shows that the final state of charge differs from respect to the results obtained in steady-state warmed-up
the initial one by the value corresponding to the energy case. Moreover, the distributions of ICE operation
storable through the solar panels during parking hours phases differ from steady-state case, indicating that such
3366
17th IFAC World Congress (IFAC'08)
Seoul, Korea, July 6-11, 2008
effects should be taken into account in HEV and HSV [15] Arsie I., Flora R., Pianese C., Rizzo G., Serra G., A
control where ICE start-stop operation can occur. Computer Code for S.I. Engine Control and Powertrain
Concerning HC emissions, simulation results evidence Simulation. SAE Paper 2000-01-0938, SAE 2000
that the intermittent ICE operation usually results in Transactions - Journal of Engines, Vol. 109-3, pp. 935-
higher HC though a local minimum can be detected 949, 2001.
considering the trade off between number of engine start [16] Burch, S., Cuddy, M., Johnson, V., Markel, T., Rausen,
events and catalyst light off. Future developments will D., Sprik, S., and Wipke, K., ADVISOR: Advanced
include the development of a supervisor control for a Vehicle Simulator, www.avl.com/advisor.
HSV prototype and the study of thermal transient in [17] Leonardo Program I05/B/P/PP-154181 “Energy
catalyst and their effects on vehicle emissions. Conversion Systems and Their Environmental Impact”,
www.dimec.unisa.it/leonardo.
7 REFERENCES
[18] Arsie I., Cacciato M., Consoli A., Petrone G., Rizzo G.,
Sorrentino M., Spagnuolo G., Hybrid Vehicles and Solar
[1] Saitoh T., Hisada T., Gomi C., Maeda C., Improvement
Energy: a Possible Marriage? ICAT06, Istanbul,
of urban air pollution via solar-assisted super energy
November 17, 2006.
efficient vehicle. ASME JSES KSES Int. Sol. Energy
[19] Zavala J.C., Sanketi P.R., Wilcutts M., Kaga T., Hedrick
Conf., pp. 571-577, 1992.
J.K., Simplified Models of Engine HC Emissions,
[2] Sasaki K., Yokota M., Nagayoshi H., Kamisako K.,
Exhaust Temperature and Catalyst Temperature for
Evaluation of an Electric Motor and Gasoline Engine
Automotive Coldtsart. 5th IFAC Symp.on Advances in
Hybrid Car Using Solar Cells. Solar Energy Material and
Automotive Control, Aptos (USA), August 20-22, 2007.
Solar Cells (47), 1997.
[20] Arsie I., Pianese C., Rizzo G., Models for the Prediction
[3] Seal M.R., Viking 23 - zero emissions in the city, range
of Performance and Emissions in a Spark Ignition Engine
and performance on the freeway. Northcon –
- A Sequentially Structured Approach. SAE 980779, SAE
Conf.Record, IEEE, RC-108, pp. 264-268, 1995.
1998 Transactions - Journal of Engines, Section 3, Vol.
[4] Seal M.R., Campbell G., Ground-up hybrid vehicle
106, pp. 1065-1079.
program at the vehicle research institute. SAE Special
[21] Preitl, Zs., P. Bauer, B. Kulcsar, G. Rizzo, J. Bokor,
Publications, vol. SP-1105, pp. 59-65, 1995.
Control Solutions for Hybrid Solar Vehicle Fuel
[5] S. Letendre, R. Perez, C. Herig, Vehicle Integrated PV: a
Consumption Minimization. 2007 IEEE Intelligent
Clean and Secure Fuel for Hybrid Electric Vehicles.
Vehicles Symposium, June 13-15, 2007, Instanbul.
Annual Meeting of the American Solar Energy Society,
[22] Bin Wu, Chan-Chiao Lin, Zoran Filipi, Huei Peng,
Austin, TX, June 21-26, 2003.
Dennis Assanis, Optimal Power Management of a
[6] Powell B.K., Bailey K.E., Cikanek S.R., Dynamic
Hydraulic Hybrid Delivery Truck. Vehicle System
modeling and Control of Hybrid Vehicle Powertrain
Dynamics 2004, Vol. 42, Nos. 1–2, pp. 23–40, 2004.
Systems. IEEE Trans.Contrl Syst., vol. 18, no. 5, 1998.
[7] Baumann B., Rizzoni G. and Washington G. Intelligent
8 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Control of Hybrid Vehicles using Neural Networks and
Fuzzy Logic. SAE paper 981061, 1998. This research has been financed by University of Salerno,
[8] Guzzella L. and Amstutz A., CAE Tools for Quasi-Static European Commission “Education and Culture” within the
Modeling and Optimization of Hybrid Poweretrains. Leonardo Program “Energy Conversion Systems and Their
IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, vol. 48, no. Environmental Impact”, Italian Ministry of University and
6, November 1999. Research MUR within the project PRIN “Integration of Photo-
Voltaic Systems in Conventional and Hybrid Vehicles".
[9] Arsie I., Graziosi M., Pianese C., Rizzo G., Sorrentino
M., Optimization of Supervisory Control Strategy for
Parallel Hybrid Vehicle with Provisional Load Estimate.
JSAE Review of Automotive Engineering, Vol. 26, No. 3,
pp. 341-348, 2005.
[10] Statistics for Road Transport, UK Government,
www.statistics.gov.uk/CCI/nscl.asp?ID=8100.
[11] www.itee.uq.edu.au/~serl/UltraCommuter.html.
[12] Arsie I., Marotta M., Pianese C., Rizzo G., Sorrentino M.,
Optimal Design of a Hybrid Electric Car with Solar Cells.
1st AUTOCOM Workshop on Preventive and Active
Safety Systems for Road Vehicles, Istanbul, Sept.19-21,
2005.
[13] Arsie I., Rizzo G., Sorrentino M., Optimal Design and
Dynamic Simulation of a Hybrid Solar Vehicle. SAE
paper 2006-01-2997, SAE Transactions – Journal of
Engines, vol. 115-3, 2007.
[14] Cheng W.K. and Santoso H., Mixture Preparation and
Hydrocarbon Emissions Behaviors in the First Cycle of SI
Engine Cranking. SAE paper 2002-01-2805.
3367