You are on page 1of 23

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/235273318

Is a glass of Merlot the symbol of globalization?: An examination of the impacts


of globalization on wine consumption in Asia

Article  in  International Journal of Wine Business Research · August 2009


DOI: 10.1108/17511060910985971

CITATIONS READS

34 283

1 author:

Kyuho Lee
Sonoma State University
24 PUBLICATIONS   291 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Special issue on “Entrepreneurship in the Wine Sector” in the International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Small Business View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Kyuho Lee on 02 November 2018.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


ARTICLE
10.1177/1096348004268195
JOURNAL
Lee et al. / OF
KOREAN
HOSPITWINE
ALITYMARKET
& TOURISM RESEARCH

EXPLORING THE KOREAN


WINE MARKET
Kyuho Lee
Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
Jinlin Zhao
Florida International University
Jae-Youn Ko
Kyung-Hee University

This exploratory study identified specific preferences and characteristics of Korean wine
consumers. Relevant literature was reviewed in an attempt to find the most suitable market
strategy in the Korean wine market. This study employed samples from members of a Ko-
rean wine association (KISA) to identify Korean wine consumers’characteristics and pref-
erences. The study found Korean wine consumers had interesting preferences and that
there were some significant differences between these preferences and demographic char-
acteristics among the Korean respondents. The paper offers wine marketers suggestions
about what they need to understand in order to attract Korean wine consumers and what
may be appropriate and effective wine-marketing strategies and practices in Korea.

KEYWORDS: wine; Korean wine consumers; wine-marketing strategy

Historically, Western European countries have dominated wine production. In


recent years, however, new wine-producing countries, such as Argentina, Chile,
Australia, the United States, and South Africa, have entered the world’s wine mar-
ket (Spahni, 2000). These countries have several competitive strengths, such as
low labor costs; grape varieties, such as Chardonnay, Cabernet Sauvignon, Mer-
lot, and so on; technological improvements, such as controlled fermentation
instead of natural fermentation; and ideal climate conditions (Carreyrou, 2003;
Johnson, 2001; Oldroyd, 2001; Solana-Rosillo, 1997).
As a result, the $100 billion global wine industry is becoming more competi-
tive, and traditional wine-producing countries are facing challenges from the New
World wine countries (Carreyrou, 2003). For example, the global share of French
wine exports decreased to 23% in 2002, compared to 32% a decade prior.
Although wine consumption in Britain has increased sharply (Johnson, 2001), the

Authors’ Note: The authors wish to thank three anonymous reviewers for their valuable comments
and suggestions for this study.
Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research, Vol. 29, No. 1, February 2005, 20-41
DOI: 10.1177/1096348004268195
© 2005 International Council on Hotel, Restaurant and Institutional Education
20
Lee et al. / KOREAN WINE MARKET 21

Figure 1
U.S. Wine Exports to South Korea (value $000)

6,000
5,620
5,000
4,000
Amount

3,682
3,000 2,782
2,000
1,000 1,191

0
1998 1999 2000 2001
Year

Note: Adapted from Walker (2002).

famous Bordeaux wine lost 15% of its market share in the United Kingdom. How-
ever, the global wine export share from New World countries, such as the United
States and Australia, has increased. For example, wine exports from Australia
increased 20% in 2002 compared to 6% a decade prior (Angulo, Gil, Gracia, &
Sanchez, 2000; Carreyrou, 2003; Orth & Krska, 2002).
At the same time, world wine production exceeds world wine consumption
(Dodd, 1997). It is estimated that global wine production surpasses consumption
by about 20% (Oldroyd, 2001). The total world production was 27,400.74 million
liters, with an increase of 17.1% from 1994 to 2000. This result is attributed to
increased production of 63%, 52.8%, and 51.7% respectively, in North America,
Asia, and Oceania (Vinexpo avec le Concours de Vertumne International &
Associes, 2002b).
Around the world, vineyards increased by 7.2% from 1994 to 2000, an expan-
sion of 6,003.67 thousand hectares. As early as 1988, there was a total of 3,320
million liters of surplus wine in the world; this surplus soared to about 6,401 mil-
lion liters between 1999 and 2000 because of a major decrease in wine consump-
tion in Western Europe (Beckett, 2001; Spawton, 1990). This growing gap
between production and consumption has challenged the global wine industry for
more than two decades.
It appears that the world wine industry should explore opportunities for expan-
sion into new wine markets, such as Korea. Koreans have increased their wine
consumption rapidly, with an annual growth rate of 20% from 1996, except dur-
ing the 1997-1998 Asian economic crisis. It is estimated that Koreans will con-
sume 20,000,000 liters of wine by 2006, which is a 36% increase from the
14,632,000 liters of wine consumed in 2000 (Vinexpo avec le Concours de
Vertumne International & Associes, 2002a).
Figure 1 presents U.S. wine exports to South Korea from 1998 to 2001. Korean
wine imports from the United States have increased sharply, and the Korean mar-
ket will be a key export market for U.S. wineries within 5 years (Stephens, 2003).
Because of increased disposable income, health concerns, and growing wine
demands from Korean working women, wine is gaining popularity in Korea
22 JOURNAL OF HOSPITALITY & TOURISM RESEARCH

(Bang, 2000; Ryu, 1994; Seo, 2002; Stephens, 2003). Wine has become an attrac-
tive substitute for higher alcohol-content beverages.
For global wine marketers, the export of wine to Korea can be appealing, as the
Korean government has begun to remove tariffs on imported wine. For example,
according to the recent Free Trade Agreement (FTA) between Korea and Chile,
the Korean government will remove the 15% tariff on Chilean wine in 5 years
(Choi & Huh, 2002). The Korean wine market has huge growth potential for the
global wine industry (Bang & Cho, 2001; Kim, 2002; Stephens, 2003).
According to Spawton (1991a), the wine industry has focused more on sales
than on marketing; however, wine industry managers should emphasize market-
ing because of the global changes in consumers’ behavior and the competitive
environment (Sharp, 1991; Spawton, 1990). However, most wine-marketing
research is limited to the European market because of the market’s importance for
both wine production and consumption. For instance, the European wine coun-
tries produced almost 74% of the world’s wine, and the market accounted for
approximately 72% of the world’s wine consumption in 1998 (Spahni, 2000).
Considerable marketing research has focused on Europe and North America.
For instance, studies include British wine consumers (Mitchell & Greatorex,
1989); the Spanish wine market and consumers (Angulo et al., 2000; Gil &
Sanchez, 1997); port wine–marketing strategies (Lages & Shaw, 1998); Greek
wine consumers (Kalogianni, Klavdianou, Alexaki, & Tsakiridou, 1999); the
Hungarian wine market (Williams & Pearson, 1992); European consumers’ wine
consumption patterns (Smith & Solgaard, 2000); Irish consumers’ wine prefer-
ences (Keown & Casey, 1995); cross-cultural European wine consumers’motiva-
tions (Hall, Shaw, & Doole, 1997); information sources of American wine drink-
ers (Dodd, Pinkleton, & Gustafson, 1996); and consumers’ characteristics of
wine clubs in Canada (Schell, Amero, Cameron, & Scott, 1985).
Because the global wine industry has become more and more competitive
(Stephens, 2003; Walker, 2002), wine marketers should begin to explore emerg-
ing wine markets, such as South Korea. Very little wine-marketing research has
been conducted in Korea, where there is a large potential for increased wine pur-
chasing. It is critical for the wine marketers to better understand Korean wine con-
sumers’purchasing behaviors, needs, and preferences in order to develop market-
ing strategies for export to Korea (Beverland, 2002; Dodd, 1997; Sharp, 1991).
The objective of this article is to answer the following questions:

• What are Korean wine consumers’ characteristics and specific preferences when se-
lecting a wine?
• Are there any significant relationships between key demographic variables (age,
gender, income, and the years of wine drinking experience) and their wine selecting
preferences?
• What could be effective marketing strategies in the Korean wine market?
• How should wine marketers implement marketing strategies in Korea?
Lee et al. / KOREAN WINE MARKET 23

LITERATURE REVIEW

Wine Attributes and Consumer Preferences


Several researchers have studied wine consumer preferences in various coun-
tries. Gil and Sanchez (1997) examined wine attributes that affected Spanish
wine-purchasing preferences. The origin of the wine played the most important
role when Spanish consumers purchased a local wine. Spanish wine consumers
also considered price and grape vintage as important attributes.
Kalogiann et al. (1999) identified the wine preferences of Greek consumers.
The study found that most Greek consumers considered the following wine attrib-
utes (listed in order of importance) when purchasing wine: full taste, clarity,
appellation of origin, aroma, and attractiveness of the label. It was also found that
most Greek wine consumers preferred to buy wine in supermarkets rather than in
wine cellars because of the lower price.
Keown and Casey (1995) examined the wine purchasing behaviors of North-
ern Irish consumers. The researchers found that the country of origin, brand
name, grape variety, and region of origin were the most important factors influ-
encing Northern Irish wine purchasing.
Gluckman (1986) analyzed British wine consumers’ behaviors and attitudes.
He found that there were two groups of considerations influencing British con-
sumers’ wine-purchasing decisions: implicit considerations, such as color, pack-
aging appearance, country of origin, and size of container; and explicit consider-
ations, such as price, quality, reliability, taste, and suitability for all tastes.
Thomas (2000) discussed the factors influencing New Zealand consumers’
wine drinking. According to his study, the New Zealand wine consumers relied
mostly on the opinions of family and friends, followed by any awards a wine has
won, price and promotions, and the fame of the label. The New Zealand wine con-
sumers tended to listen to friends or family opinion to avoid any risk in their wine
purchase.

Effective Wine Marketing


Spawton (1990) discussed effective wine-marketing methods and global
wine-marketing strategies. He argued that because of mass wine production and
intensive competition in the global wine market, wine marketers should identify
wine customers’ characteristics and purchasing behaviors and anticipate their
needs. The success of the wine industry depends on how wine marketers establish
and implement global marketing strategies, not on how much wine they produce
(Spawton, 1990).
Goldsmith and d’Hauteville (1998) investigated the characteristics of heavy
wine drinkers. The researchers found that the enthusiasm and interest of wine
consumers are key factors motivating heavy wine consumption. The researchers
suggested that marketers who wish to capture heavy wine consumers should con-
centrate their marketing tactics on the enthusiasm, interest, and involvement of
those wine consumers.
24 JOURNAL OF HOSPITALITY & TOURISM RESEARCH

Dodd (1997) and Goldsmith (1998) examined the characteristics of wine inno-
vators. As opinion leaders, wine innovators are likely to buy new wines, purchase
wine more frequently than noninnovators, and spread favorable or unfavorable
word-of–mouth to other consumers about wines that they experienced (Dodd,
1997; Goldsmith, 1998).
Most wine innovators acquire wine information from wine magazines, journal
articles, and wine tastings, in comparison to wine noninnovators, who obtain
wine information through word-of-mouth from friends or relatives (Dodd, 1997).
It is important for wine marketers to develop marketing programs, such as a
frequent-buyer reward program, to attract and retain the wine innovators because
they are frequent wine buyers as well as opinion leaders who influence other con-
sumers’ wine purchases (Goldsmith, 1998).
Spawton (1991b) claimed that wine consumers felt risk psychologically, func-
tionally, and economically when they purchased wine. Psychological risk was
related to the consumer’s self-esteem. For example, consumers might worry
about selecting the wrong wine. The functional risk occurred when consumers
could not decide which wine they should buy for their specific meals or occasions.
Insufficient wine knowledge could cause the functional risk. The economic risk
was associated with the value of wine. Consumers often were not confident of the
true value of wine that they purchased. In particular, when the consumers bought
an unfamiliar bottle of wine, their sense of an economic risk tended to increase.
Mitchell and Greatorex (1989) indicated that reducing risk was a key factor in
purchasing wine and illustrated methods for reducing those risks. They suggested
taking the opportunity to taste wine and following the recommendation of friends
and relatives as effective ways to reduce the risks of purchase. In comparison,
using a store image and buying the most or least expensive wine were considered
the least popular ways for consumers to avoid the risk of purchasing wines. Nov-
ice wine consumers were more likely to buy well-known brands based on family
members’ or friends’ opinions, thereby reducing the risk of wine purchasing
(Spawton, 1991b).
Thompson and Vourvachis (1995) argued that consumers tended to depend on
friends’ or family members’ opinions in their wine selections because wine had
many attributes, such as flavor or tastes, making identification of those attributes
difficult. Therefore, wine marketers can be more effective if they offer consumers
enough opportunities to taste and test wine flavors before purchase (Thompson &
Vourvachis, 1995).
Orth and Krska (2002) claimed that international or regional exhibition awards
for wine products influenced consumer wine purchases significantly. They
pointed out that wine consumers preferred to buy wine with exhibition awards
rather than without because the consumers perceived that exhibition awards were
a quality assurance indicator.

The Korean Wine Market


Alcohol consumption is deeply related to a society’s culture (Smith &
Solgaard, 2000). Traditionally, Korea is a heavy-alcohol-consumption country
Lee et al. / KOREAN WINE MARKET 25

(Stephens, 2003). Koreans have preferred to consume high-alcohol-content bev-


erages, such as the traditional Korean sake, Soju (Kim, 2002; Stephens, 2003).
However, the increasing household income in an improved Korean economy, the
growing numbers of female drinkers, and the Westernizing of the Korean life style
have led to a change in Korean drinking patterns, away from strong-alcohol bev-
erages to low-alcohol and high-quality alcoholic beverages (Bang, 2000; Ryu,
1994; Stephens, 2003).
Dodd and Morse (1994) discussed how wine consumers reflected health con-
cerns when they bought wine. The researchers examined sales before and after the
airing of CBS’s 60 Minutes program The French Paradox. The French paradox
refers to the fact that the French have a low risk of heart disease, in spite of their
high fat diet, because of their moderate consumption (one or two drinks daily) of
red wine. After the program showed that moderate red wine consumption could
lower heart disease by about 40% or 50%, red wine sales increased by 44.5% in
the United States. When the Koreans heard the report that moderate red wine
drinking may reduce heart disease, more and more of them became interested in
drinking red wine (Bang & Cho, 2001). The heightened health concerns have
motivated increased wine consumption in Korea.
Ko, Lee, Park, Lee, and Kim (2002) conducted a study to investigate the
importance of wine sales in hotel restaurants in Korea. They found that wine sales
account for an average of 72% of total alcohol sales in the Western restaurants of
major hotels in Korea, whereas the average wine sales in Korean and Chinese res-
taurants in the hotels are 40% and 15% of the total alcohol sales revenue of the res-
taurants, respectively. They suggested that fewer Koreans consume wine with
Asian food than with Western food. Ryu (1994) suggested that the wine industry
may develop a smaller sized bottle of wine in Korea to appeal to new wine drink-
ers because the size reduces the risk of wine purchasing in terms of taste and price
for the increasing number of new wine drinkers in Korea.
Many Koreans believed that Western food pairs well with wine (Stephens,
2003). For example, French wine goes well with French cuisine. Actually, many
Korean traditional dishes, such as bulgogi and kimchi, could be harmonious with
full-bodied Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot (Stephens, 2003).
Beverland (2002) stressed that global wine companies should tailor their mar-
keting strategies to Asian markets. Most of the Asian markets are totally different
from Western markets in terms of distribution channels, legal systems, cultural
values, languages, and consumer preferences. According to Beverland (2002),
Western-style sales and marketing, which emphasize product quality, may not be
effective in the Asian markets because Asians place a greater importance on form-
ing good relationships with their business partners; Asians value trust and human
association in addition to product quality (Bretherton & Carswell, 2001). For
example, giving assistance to the local distributors by arranging wine tastings and
educating sales people could be an effective way to build a good relationship
with the local distributors in Asian countries (Beverland, 2002; Bretherton &
Carswell, 2001).
26 JOURNAL OF HOSPITALITY & TOURISM RESEARCH

METHOD

Instrument
A quantitative method (self-administered questionnaire) was used to collect
data regarding Korean wine drinkers’ characteristics and preferences. The ques-
tionnaire was composed of three major parts, with 35 variables measuring Korean
wine consumers’ preferences and characteristics.
The questionnaire was based on relevant literature reviews (Gil & Sanchez,
1997; Kalogianni et al., 1999; Keown & Casey, 1995). The first part of the ques-
tionnaire dealt with respondents’ preferences and characteristics when drinking
or selecting wine. The second part included wine attributes, the purpose of wine
drinking, and factors influencing wine drinking among Koreans. The last section
consisted of the respondents’ demographic characteristics, such as age, gender,
education, occupation, and income. A 7-point Likert-type scale was used to mea-
sure Korean wine drinkers’ preferences, characteristics, purpose in drinking
wine, and factors affecting wine consumption.
The questionnaire was originally developed in English because most of the
pertinent literature reviews referred to in developing the questionnaire were writ-
ten in English. A Korean Ph.D. student who is fluent in both English and Korean
and has an extensive knowledge of wine translated the original English question-
naire into Korean. A bilingual Korean professor back-translated into English to
test the readability of the translated instrument. Before data collection procedures
began, the questionnaire was pilot-tested on 10 Koreans to ensure the reliability
and clarity of the questionnaire.

Participants
The survey was conducted among the members of a wine association (KISA)
in Seoul during the months of September and October 2002. KISA’s members are
interested in wine and the sharing of wine information. KISA is one of the largest
wine associations in Korea and offers regular wine seminars and wine-tasting
events. Membership is very diversified, ranging from hotel managers to house-
wives. The survey was conducted during KISA’s regular meetings in September
and October, 2002. The survey questionnaires were distributed to 280 members
who attended the meetings. Some 218 filled out the questionnaires, generating a
response rate of 78%. This is a convenience sample of active Korean wine con-
sumers. The data were analyzed by using SPSS 10.0 software.

Data Analysis
Frequencies and percentages of age, gender, income, education level, and
occupation of respondents are given in Table 1. In addition, t tests and one-way
ANOVA tests were employed to analyze Korean wine drinkers’preferences, char-
acteristics, and other factors influencing wine drinking by age, gender, and years
of wine-drinking experience. The researchers also utilized multiple regression
tests to examine whether any relationships existed between frequency of wine
drinking, income, gender, and age.
Lee et al. / KOREAN WINE MARKET 27

Table 1
Descriptive Characteristics of Participants (N = 218)

Characteristic n Percentage

Age (years)
20-29 81 37.2
30-39 66 30.3
40-49 48 22.0
50 or older than 50 23 10.5
Total 218 100.0
Gender
Male 108 50.0
Female 108 50.0
Total 216 100.0
Income
Below $14,999 74 34.7
$15,000-$24,999 58 27.2
$25,000-$39,999 58 27.2
$40,000 or older 23 10.8
Total 213 100.0
Educational level
High school 17 7.8
Collegea 66 30.3
University/graduate 135 61.9
Total 218 100.0
Occupation
Self-employed 15 7.7
Government worker 5 2.6
White-collar worker 44 22.5
Service sector 127 64.8
Not in workforce 5 2.6
Total 196 100.0
Years of wine drinking
More than 15 years 33 15.2
10-14 29 13.3
5-9 50 22.9
1-4 74 33.9
Less than 1 year 32 14.7
Total 218 100.0

a. College is usually a 2-year program in Korea.

RESULTS

Participants
Table 1 shows the demographic profile of the respondents. The number of
male respondents (50.0%) was the same as that of female respondents (50.0%).
The majority of respondents was between 20 and 49 years old (89.5%).
Most of the respondents had university or graduate degrees (61.9%). A total of
30% of the respondents had a 2-year college education; 34.7% of the respondents
had annual household incomes below US$14,999; and 27.2% and 10.8% had
28 JOURNAL OF HOSPITALITY & TOURISM RESEARCH

Table 2
Descriptive Statistics for Wine Specific Attributes, Factors Influencing Wine
Purchasing, and Purpose of Wine Drinking

Mean Importance Score Standard Deviation

Wine attributes
Flavor 5.92 1.80
Taste 5.75 1.51
Price 5.02 1.55
Appelation of origin 4.99 1.69
Wine brand 4.97 1.52
Wine reputation 4.68 1.66
Regional label 4.27 1.62
Grape vintage 4.01 1.80
Factors influencing wine purchase
Friends’ or relatives’ recommendation 4.54 1.83
Wine publications 4.35 1.68
Wine promotion 3.79 1.75
Wine advertising 3.78 1.64
Wine tasting 3.71 1.79
Wine seminar 3.28 1.80
Purpose of wine drinking
Harmony with food 4.97 1.58
Status and ambience 4.61 1.67
Health 4.18 1.78

Note: 7-point Likert-type scales ranging from 1 to 7, where 1 = not at all important and 7 =
very important.

yearly household incomes of US$25,000-$39,999 and US$40,000 or more,


respectively.
A total of 65% of the respondents worked in the service industry, 22.5% were
white-collar workers, 7.7% of respondents were self-employed, and 2.6% were
government workers.

Consumers’ Preferences Affecting


Purchasing and Drinking of Wine
As presented in Table 2, Korean respondents ranked flavor as the most impor-
tant attribute when purchasing wine (5.92 on a 7-point Likert-type scale), fol-
lowed by taste (5.75) and price (5.02). The lowest wine attributes were grape vin-
tage (4.01) and regional label (4.27).
While being tested for factors influencing their wine purchasing, the respon-
dents indicated that recommendations from friends or relatives had the greatest
influence on their wine purchasing (4.54). Wine seminars had the least effect on
consumers’ wine purchasing (3.28 mean score). Regarding the purpose of wine
drinking by the participants, harmony with food had the highest mean score
(4.97), followed by status and ambience (4.61), and health (4.18).
As shown in Table 3, the majority of the respondents preferred to drink red
wine (5.12) followed by white wine (4.59). The mean score of rose wine was the
lowest (3.10). Table 3 also shows the mean score of the respondents’ preference
Lee et al. / KOREAN WINE MARKET 29

Table 3
Descriptive Statistics for Different Wine Varieties and Origin of Wine

Mean Preference Score Standard Deviation

Wine Variety
Red 5.12 1.60
White 4.59 1.52
Sparkling 3.19 1.71
Rose 3.10 1.56
Origin of wine
France 5.24 1.61
U.S. 4.34 1.87
Italy 4.16 1.82
Australia 3.62 1.72
Chile 3.56 1.73
Germany 3.54 1.46
Spain 3.09 1.56
Korea 3.08 1.54
South Africa 2.67 1.51

Note: 7-point Likert scales ranging from 1 to 7, where 1 = least like and 7 = the most like.

Table 4
Price and Wine Bottle Size That Wine Consumers Prefer to Purchase

Percentage

Price
Under $7.99 1.8
$8.00-$24.99 24.8
$25.00-$41.99 34.4
$42.00-$58.99 29.4
$59.00-$75.99 8.7
Over $76.00 0.9
Size of wine (ml)
750 75.7
375 21.4
200 2.9

for wine origin. The country of origin most preferred was France (5.24), followed
by the United States (4.34), and then Italy (4.16). South African wine had the low-
est mean score (2.67).

Wine Size and Wine Price


As presented in Table 4, 34.4% of the participants preferred to buy wine priced
between $25.00 and $41.99, and 29.4% of the participants preferred to buy wine
priced between $42.00 and $58.99. Only 0.9% of the respondents preferred to buy
wine priced over $76.00. The majority of the respondents preferred to buy 750 ml
bottles (75.7%). On the other hand, approximately 25% of the respondents
favored the purchase of 375 ml or smaller bottles of wine.
30 JOURNAL OF HOSPITALITY & TOURISM RESEARCH

Table 5
Significant Differences in Wine Selection by Gender

Mean Score
Variable Male Female t Value p Value

Preferences
Red wine 5.49 4.79 3.110 .002
Italian wine 4.42 3.90 2.150 .033
South African wine 2.91 2.42 2.429 .016
Importance
Grape vintage 4.27 3.75 2.135 .034
Regional label 4.49 4.06 1.986 .048
Health 4.48 3.89 2.484 .014

Note: Significance level at .05.

Relationship Between Demographic


Variables and Wine Preferences
The researchers examined the relationship between key demographic vari-
ables (gender, age, years of wine drinking, income, and frequency of wine drink-
ing) and the importance of each preference; however, this study reports only on
the significant variables.
Significant Differences in Wine Selection by Gender
To determine whether gender is related to importance and preference levels for
attributes, the researchers utilized t tests to compare males and females on each
preference and importance rating.
As presented in Table 5, the participants’ responses to red wine, Italian wine,
and South African wine were significantly different. Male participants liked red
wine (df = 217, t statistic = 3.110, p = .002), Italian wine (df = 217, t statistic =
2.150, p = .033), and South African wine (df = 217, t statistic = 2.429; p = .016)
significantly more than female participants did. In addition, male respondents
placed more importance on the grape vintage (df = 217, t statistic = 2.135, p =
.034) and regional label (df = 217, t statistic = 1.986, p = .048) than did female
respondents.
Consideration of health in drinking wine also differed significantly by gender.
Health issues were more important to males than to females (df = 217, t statistic =
2.484, p = .014). However, other variables, such as white wine (df = 216, t statis-
tic = 1.394, p = .165), taste (df = 216, t statistic = .090, p = .928), and wine reputa-
tion (df = 216, t statistic = .861, p = .390), did not differ significantly by gender
when the respondents selected wine.
As shown in Table 5, all the mean scores of male respondents are higher than
those of female respondents. The reason may be that the Korean female respon-
dents were more cautious and conservative in responding to the questionnaire
than the Korean males because female Koreans do not drink alcoholic beverages
as much as men do.
Lee et al. / KOREAN WINE MARKET 31

Traditionally, Korean women do not often drink alcoholic beverages because


most Korean women tend not to work after marriage, thus having less opportunity
to drink for social or business purposes. This factor might lead the female Korean
respondents to answer the questionnaire more conservatively than the male
respondents did.
Significant Differences in Wine Selection by Age
To determine whether age is related to importance and preference levels for
attributes, the researchers used one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s HSD to identify
specific group differences. In addition, each significant variable was followed up
with a linear trend test to see whether the group differences followed a consistent
pattern.
ANOVA results in Table 6 show that the red wine preferences of the four age
groups are not all the same (F = 4.39, p = .005). The researchers used Tukey HSD
to conduct further post hoc tests to explain the differences by age group as seen in
Table 7. The results indicated that consumers aged 30 or older liked red wine sig-
nificantly more than did younger respondents.
Sparkling wine preferences differ according to age group (F = 4.63, p = .004).
The respondents aged 20 to 29 liked sparkling wine significantly more than
respondents aged 40 to 50 or older. The importance of the regional label differs by
age group (F = 2.88, p = .037). Respondents aged 30 to 49 placed greater impor-
tance on the wine’s regional label when selecting it compared to respondents aged
20 to 29. The importance of health concerns in Korean wine drinking varies with
age (F = 4.22, p = .006). Health played an important role in wine drinking to older
consumers compared to younger consumers. Wine reputation (F = 0.60, p = .618),
wine brand (F = 0.52, p = .670), and the impact of status and surroundings (F =
1.39, p = .247) did not differ significantly by the age of the respondents.
The results of the study indicated that there is a linear relationship between
consumers’ health concerns and age, as shown in Figure 2. As age increases,
health concerns become a greater influence on wine drinking. In addition, youn-
ger consumers tended to like sparkling wine more than older consumers did.
Significant Differences in Wine Selection by Experience
To determine whether the number of years of wine drinking is related to impor-
tance and preference levels for attributes, one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s HSD
was used to identify specific group differences.
The number of years a respondent has been drinking wine is significantly
related to mean responses for preference and importance levels in some variables.
Table 8 illustrates that the levels of preference and importance are significantly
different at α = .05 with respect to the respondents’ years of wine drinking. Red
wine preference, as related to years of wine drinking experience, were not all the
same (F = 4.74, p = .001). A greater level of preference was placed on red wine by
respondents who had been drinking for 10 to 14 years, compared to respondents
who had been drinking wine for 1 to 4 years or less (see Table 9).
The importance of price and grape vintage were different by the respondents’
years of wine-drinking experience. Price and grape vintage were more important
32
Table 6
Significant Differences in Wine Selection by Age

20 to 29 30 to 39 40 to 49 50 or Older Linear Trend


b
Variable Years Old Years Old Years Old Than 50 Years Overall F Valuea p Value (p value)

Preference
Red wine 4.64 5.44 5.50 5.09 5.12 4.39 .005 .225
Sparking wine 3.38 3.56 2.81 2.26 3.19 4.63 .004 .001
Importance
Regional label 4.02 4.33 4.79 3.87 4.27 2.88 .037 .995
Health 3.65 4.39 4.54 4.70 4.18 4.22 .006 .011

Note: Significance level at .05.


a. One-way ANOVA test to see if age groups differ on each variable.
b. Test to see whether age is linearly related to variable.
Lee et al. / KOREAN WINE MARKET 33

Table 7
Significant Differences in Wine Selection by Age:
Multiple Comparison Post Hoc Test

20 to 29 30 to 39 40 to 49
Variable Years Old Years Old Years Old 50 or Older

Preference
Red wine 20-29 < 30-39a 20-29 < 40-49
a

Sparking wine 50 or older 50 or older


< 20-29a < 30-39a
Importance
Regional label 20-29 < 40-49a
a a
Health 20-29 < 30-39 20-29 < 40-49

a. Tukey HSD approach to compare all pairs of age groups (significance level at .05).

factors to respondents whose wine-drinking years were 10 or more compared to


respondents whose wine-drinking years were fewer than 10. Regarding health
and harmony with meals, respondents with 10 to 14 years of wine-drinking expe-
rience considered health and harmony with meals to be more important than those
with 1 to 4 years of wine experience. Status or surroundings were significantly
related to respondents’ years of wine drinking, with those having 5 to 9 years
of experience rating status or surroundings as more important than those hav-
ing 1 to 4 years of wine-drinking experience. Variables such as taste (F = 1.75, p =
.140), flavor (F = 1.32, p = .265), and brand (F = 1.12, p = .349) did not differ sig-
nificantly by respondents’ years of wine-drinking experience.

Relationship Between Frequency of


Wine Drinking and Income, Sex, and Age
The researchers attempted to identify whether any relationships existed between
respondents’ frequency of wine drinking and demographic characteristics, such
as income, gender, and age. To detect such relationships, the authors performed
multiple regression using frequency of wine drinking as the dependent variable,
and income, gender, and age as the independent variables. The results of the mul-
tiple regression test indicated that the respondents’ income, gender, and age had a
significant role in predicting the frequency of wine drinking. Respondents’
income, sex, and age explained 14% of the variance in the frequency of wine
drinking, which finding was statistically significant (F = 1.47, p = .000).
There was a significant positive correlation between respondents’ income and
frequency of drinking (p = .002). Also, there was a significant positive correlation
between age and frequency of drinking (p = .007). However, gender was not sig-
nificantly related to frequency of drinking.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION

The Korean wine market has huge potential for growth and development. Iden-
tifying consumer preferences and characteristics is critical to expanding and
34
Table 8
Significant Differences in Wine Selection by Experience

More Than 10 to 14 5 to 9 1 to 4 Less Than


Variable 15 Years Years Years Years 1 Year Overall F Valuea p Value

Preference
Red wine 5.21 6.14 5.18 4.68 5.03 5.12 4.74 .001
Sparking wine 2.48 3.03 3.40 3.12 3.91 3.19 3.20 .014
Importance
Price 5.24 5.90 4.78 4.93 4.59 5.02 3.65 .007
Grape vintage 4.24 4.86 3.64 3.76 4.16 4.01 2.83 .026
Health 4.70 4.86 4.14 3.77 4.06 4.18 2.93 .022
Harmony with meal 5.18 5.59 5.20 4.49 4.94 4.97 3.46 .009
Status and surroundings 4.79 4.34 5.12 4.12 5.00 4.61 3.70 .006

a. One-way ANOVA test was used to see whether the years of wine drinking experience was significantly related to variables (significance level at .05).
Table 9
Significant Differences in Wine Selection by Experience:
Multiple Comparison Post Hoc Test

More Than 10 to 14 5 to 9 1 to 4
Variable 15 Years Years Years Years Less Than 1 Year

Preference
Red wine 1-4 < 10-14 yearsa,
less than 1 < 10-14 yearsa
Sparkling wine more than 15 years <
less than 1 yeara
Importance
Price 5-9 < 10-14 yearsa, 1-4 < 10-14 yearsa,
less than 1 < 10-14 yearsa
a a
Grape vintage 5-9 < 10-14 years , 1-4 < 10-14 years ,
less than 1 < 10-14 yearsa
a
Health 1-4 < 10-14 years
a
Harmony with meal 1-4 < 10-14 years
a
Status and surroundings 1-4 < 5-9 years

a. Tukey HSD test was used to compare all pairs of the years of wine drinking experience group (significance level at .05).

35
36 JOURNAL OF HOSPITALITY & TOURISM RESEARCH

Figure 2
Significant Difference of Wine Preference and
Purpose of Wine Drinking by Age Group

5
4.5
4
7-point Likert Scale

3.5
3
2.5 Sparkling Wine
2 Health
1.5
1
0.5
0
20-29 30-39 40-49 50 or over
50
Age

developing that market. The purpose of this study was to identify Korean wine
consumers’ preferences and characteristics and provide suggestions for promot-
ing wine in the Korean market.
According to the results of the study, the majority of female respondents (65%)
had started drinking wine within the previous 4 years. Recently, wine has become
popular among Korean female drinkers because it is easy to drink and has lighter
alcohol content in comparison with strong, traditional Korean liquors, such as
Sochu, which is brewed from rice (Seo, 2002). It is expected that the female wine
market will increase significantly in the total Korean wine market (Bang & Cho,
2001). Therefore, developing female wine drinkers is an important issue for
expanding that market.
The results of the study indicated that young respondents (aged 19-29) liked
sparkling wine significantly more than did older age groups. Wine marketers may
introduce a broad range of sparkling wine in the Korean market for the young
wine drinkers.
This study revealed that the flavor and taste of wine were the most important
factors (ranked first and second) in the respondents’ wine selections. Wine mar-
keters should facilitate flavor and taste of wine in their marketing effort so that the
consumers better understand these attributes.
Harmony with meals was ranked first as the purpose for drinking wine. Asia
will be the fastest growing region in wine consumption in the next 5 years
(Vinexpo avec le Concours de Vertumne International & Associes, 2002b). Ko
et al. (2002) argued that it is critical for wine companies to identify and develop
wine products that can be easily matched with Asian food in order to boost wine
consumption and achieve a long-term success in the highly promising Asian mar-
ket. At the same time, it might be necessary for a wine company to educate Korean
wine drinkers that certain wine can be harmonious with traditional Korean food.
For example, full-bodied red wines, such as Carbernet Sauvignon and Merlot, go
well with traditional Korean barbecue, bulgogi (Stephens, 2003). However, many
Korean consumers perceived that Western wine always goes with Western food
Lee et al. / KOREAN WINE MARKET 37

(Stephens, 2003). Therefore, it is suggested that the wine marketers need to pro-
mote the fact that Korean wine consumers do not have to restrict themselves to
Western food whenever they drink wine; they should try Korean food as well.
The results of the study showed that recommendations from relatives or
friends played an important role in Korean consumers’ wine-purchasing deci-
sions. Keown and Casey (1995) pointed out that many consumers hesitated to buy
wine because of the risk and uncertainty. According to the results of the study,
Korean consumers tended to reduce the risk in wine purchasing by listening to
friends’ or relatives’ recommendations.
Recently, several wine clubs were established in Korea so that wine consumers
could share wine information (Lee, 2002; Stephens, 2003). Wine marketers
should build a good relationship with the wine club members because the mem-
bers, as opinion leaders, may play an important role in spreading wine informa-
tion to their friends or relatives.
In addition, professional staff can be helpful in providing information and
advice about wine. Marketers can invite sales personnel from key wine stores, and
food and beverage managers from major hotels and restaurants in Korea, to their
wineries and provide tours and tastings. In this way, the personnel can become
familiar with wine products and eventually provide better wine information or
suggestions to customers. Also, the knowledge gained helps wine consumers
reduce any uncertainty or risk regarding their wine purchases (Keown & Casey,
1995). Roberto (2002) reported that Robert Mondavi has provided a series of
training seminars and educational events to fine restaurants and hotels. The pur-
pose of these events has been to help restaurant and hotel operators better under-
stand Robert Mondavi wines as well as successful wine service. Other wine dis-
tributors and marketers should learn from Robert Mondavi and provide seminars
and trainings for hotel and restaurant employees.
The results of the study showed that the level of preference and importance in
certain research variables differed significantly by age. For example, middle-aged
and older participants (40 years or older) preferred red wine, compared to youn-
ger ones, aged 20 to 29. The middle-aged and older respondents’ preference for
red wine was closely related to their health concerns. According to the results of
the study, there was also a strong linear relationship between consumers’ health
concerns and age. As consumers’ age increases, health concerns become an
important factor in their wine drinking.
The fact that moderate red-wine drinking could reduce heart disease affected
older consumers’red-wine preferences. Wine marketers should take advantage of
the older Korean consumers’ health concerns in promoting red wine in their mar-
keting. To attract the older wine drinkers, marketers’ advertisements and publica-
tions can focus on explaining the health benefits of drinking red wine.
The results of the study illustrated that the levels of preferences and impor-
tance in many variables differed significantly, according to how many years the
respondents had been drinking wine. Price and grape vintage were more impor-
tant attributes to consumers who had been drinking more than 10 years than con-
sumers who had been drinking wine less than 10 years.
38 JOURNAL OF HOSPITALITY & TOURISM RESEARCH

In addition, health concerns and harmony with meals were more important
issues to consumers who had drunk wine 10 to 14 years than to consumers who
had started to drink wine only within the past 4 years. However, the considerations
of surroundings and status were more important aspects in influencing consumers
whose wine-drinking periods were less than 4 years than to consumers who had
been drinking wine for 5 to 9 years. These results imply that the consumers whose
wine-drinking period is less than 4 years may not have enough wine knowledge to
appreciate the wine attributes, such as grape vintage and health benefits of wine
drinking.
Also, these new wine drinkers drink passively in keeping with external factors,
such as status and surroundings. Therefore, it is recommended that wine market-
ers provide information related to wine attributes and health benefits to this young
wine market segment in Korea. For example, a wine retailer in Korea developed
traditional Korean paintings that also include wine information in Korean and
attached them to the labels of their imported wine bottles so that Korean custom-
ers could become familiar with their wine (Seung, 2002). In addition, it might be
helpful for wine marketers to design and offer wine cultural events so that wine-
drinking beginners can better understand wine (Roberto, 2002).
The results of the study indicated that two demographic characteristics,
income and age, are closely related to the frequency of wine drinking. High-
income consumers drink wine more frequently; older consumers drink wine more
frequently compared to relatively low-income consumers and younger consum-
ers. Wine marketers may group Korean wine-drinker segments according to their
income and age. It will help the wine operators to develop their marketing strategy
by the characteristics of each wine-consumer segment to accommodate the differ-
ent needs and preferences of each.
The traditional wine market has been saturated, and the global wine industry
has become very competitive. Thus, wine marketers need to find new markets.
The Korean wine market has great potential. The worldwide wine industry has a
real opportunity in the Korean wine market if it understands the characteristics
and preferences of the Korean wine consumers, and if it customizes products, ser-
vice offerings, and marketing. Worldwide wine-marketing managers need to real-
ize that they can achieve long-term success in foreign markets if they understand
the consumer preferences and characteristics of each market.

Limitations of the Study and Future Study


The researchers chose the members of KISA as the target population. The
researchers believe that the Korean wine market is still limited even though,
recently, the population of wine drinkers has increased rapidly. For example, in
2002, wine consumption per capita in South Korea was only 0.3 litre, which is
extremely small compared to the average of French consumers, who drink about
75 bottles of wine annually (Lankov, 2003; Seoul Wine Expo, 2003). Therefore, it
is difficult to identify Korean wine drinkers’preferences and characteristics based
on a systematic approach or a nonconvenience sampling method. The results of
the study may not represent the general Korean wine consumers because the pop-
ulation of the study consisted of Korean wine association members. However, the
Lee et al. / KOREAN WINE MARKET 39

researchers believe that the findings are valid, albeit with the limitations of the
survey method because the current population of wine consumers in Korea has
been driven by the more wealthy and educated consumer group. This finding is
consistent with the characteristics of samples in the study in terms of age, gender,
occupation, education, and income (Lankov, 2003).
In addition, the study focused on identifying Korean wine drinkers’ character-
istics and preferences. It did not discuss other key issues, such as the choice of a
wine firm’s entry mode, a factor crucial for a foreign wine firm’s success in the
Korean markets. A firm’s profit in the foreign markets is highly correlated to the
appropriate selection of its entry mode (Solana-Rosillo, 1997). Most Asian wine
markets are fundamentally different from Western markets in terms of their mar-
keting practices, distribution channels, and pricing strategies (Beverland, 2002).
Future research may investigate foreign wine firms’ entry mode into Asian wine
markets as a factor for developing these markets.

REFERENCES

Angulo, A. M., Gil, J. M., Gracia, A., & Sanchez, M. (2000). Hedonic price for Spanish red
quality wine. British Food Journal, 102(7), 481-493.
Bang, J. (2000). Korean wine consumption’s prediction. Unpublished masters’ disserta-
tion, Kyounggi University, Seoul, Korea.
Bang, J., & Cho, K. (2001, October). Korean wine industry development. Korean Tourism
Research, 13, 111-122.
Beckett, N. (2001, January 10). Global surplus—Part I. Wine & spirit weekly. Harpers.
Retrieved April 5, 2003, from http://www.harpers-wine.com/featuresitem.cfm?
featureID=14
Beverland, M. (2002). Unlocking the Asian wine market: An exploratory case study. Inter-
national Journal of Wine Marketing, 14(3), 53-64.
Bretherton, P., & Carswell, P. (2001). Market entry strategies for Western produced wine
into the Chinese market. International Journal of Wine Marketing, 13(1), 23-35.
Carreyrou, J. (2003, May 30). Austrians give French a lesson in winemaking, The Wall
Street Journal, pp. A1, A3.
Choi, W. S., & Huh, I. J. (2002, October 24). FTA between Korea and Chile. Daily Chosun
[in Korean]. Retrieved October 29, 2002, from http://www.chosun.com/w21data/html/
news/200210/200210240344.html
Dodd, T. H. (1997). Factors that influence the adoption and diffusion of new wine products.
Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research, 20(3), 123-136.
Dodd, T. H., & Morse, S. (1994). The impact of media stories concerning health issues on
food product sales. Journal of Consumer Marketing, 11(2), 17-24.
Dodd, T. H., Pinkleton, B. E., & Gustafson, A. W. (1996). External information sources of
product enthusiasts: Differences between variety seekers, variety neutrals, and variety
avoiders. Psychology & Marketing, 13(3), 291–304.
Gil, J. M., & Sanchez, M. (1997). Consumer preferences for wine attributes: A conjoint
approach. British Food Journal, 99(1), 3-11.
Gluckman, R. L. (1986). A consumer approach to branded wines. European Journal of
Marketing, 20(6), 27-44.
40 JOURNAL OF HOSPITALITY & TOURISM RESEARCH

Goldsmith, R. E. (1998). Some characteristics of wine innovators. International Journal of


Wine Marketing, 10(1), 5-12.
Goldsmith, R. E., & d’Hauteville, F. (1998). Heavy wine consumption: Empirical and the-
oretical perspectives. British Food Journal, 100(4), 184-194.
Hall, J., Shaw, M., & Doole, I. (1997). Cross-cultural analysis of wine consumption moti-
vations, International Journal of Wine Marketing, 9(2/3), 83-92.
Johnson, J. (2001, November 13). French wine all at the sea: Wine-makers in France—and
their marketing—have yet to enter the 21st century but they will need to for survival.
The Financial Times, p. 1.
Kalogianni, I. T., Klavdianou, A. P., Alexaki, A., & Tsakiridou, E. (1999). Wine route in
Northern Greece: Consumer perceptions. British Food Journal, 101(11), 884-892.
Keown, C., & Casey, M. (1995). Purchasing behavior in the Northern Ireland wine market.
British Food Journal, 97(1), 17-20.
Kim, J. (2002, April 14). Wine companies’ wine marketing in Korea [in Korean}. Daily
Choung-ang, pp. B1.
Ko, J., Lee, Y., Park, H., Lee, K., & Kim, T. (2002). The role of sommelier and wine service
marketing (Working paper at the Emerging Korean Wine Market). Seoul: Kyung-Hee
University.
Lages, L. F., & Shaw, V. (1998). The marketing strategies of port wine companies. Interna-
tional Journal of Wine Marketing, 10(2), 5-23.
Lankov, A. (2003, October 22). Popularization of wine. The Korean Times. Retrieved
December 22, 2003, from http://times.hankooki.com/lpage/opinion/200310/
kt2003102219304311410.htm
Lee, G. (2002, August 1). Growing wine market in Korea. Weekly Chosun, 1714 [in
Korean]. Retrieved October 18, 2003, from http://www.weekly.chosun.com/
Mitchell, V., & Greatorex, M. (1989). Risk reducing strategies used in the purchase of wine
in the UK. European Journal of Marketing, 23(9), 31-46.
Oldroyd, A. (2001, April 24). Beverages: Can wine lift the spirits? New York: Morgan
Stanley Dean Witter Equity Research.
Orth, U., & Krska, P. (2002). Quality signals in wine marketing: The role of exhibition
awards. International Food and Agribusiness Management Review, 4, 385-397.
Roberto, M. (2002). Robert Mondavi & the wine industry. (Harvard Business School Case,
9-302-102). Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
Ryu, S. (1994). Korean wine purchasing behaviors between domestic and imported wines.
Unpublished master’s dissertation, Yonsei University, Seoul, Korea.
Schell, B. H., Amero, L., Cameron, S., & Scott, J. (1985). A profile of consumers of fine
wine clubs. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 4(1), 43-44.
Seo, Y. (2002, August 1). Wine changes Korean drinking culture. Weekly Chosun, 1714 [in
Korean]. Retrieved September 19, 2002, from http://www.weeklychosun.com/
Seoul Wine Expo. (2003). South Korean wine market. Retrieved December 21, 2003, from
http://www.seoulwinexpo.co.kr/english/sub1_markets.asp
Seung, K. (2002, December 5). Wine marketing in Korea. Weekly Dong-A, 362, 18.
Sharp, B. (1991). Marketing orientation: More than just a customer focus. International
Journal of Wine Marketing, 3(1), 20-25.
Smith, D. E., & Solgaard, H. S. (2000). The dynamics of shifts in European alcoholic
drinks consumption. Journal of International Consumer Marketing, 12(3), 85-109.
Lee et al. / KOREAN WINE MARKET 41

Solana-Rosillo, J. B. (1997). Firm strategies in international markets: The case of interna-


tional entry into the US wine industry. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Purdue Uni-
versity, West Lafayette.
Spahni, P. (2000). The international wine trade. Cambridge, UK: Woodhead.
Spawton, T. (1990). Developing in the global alcoholic drinks industry and its implications
for the future marketing of wine. European Journal of Marketing, 24(4), 47-54.
Spawton, T. (1991a). Marketing planning for wine. European Journal of Marketing, 25(3),
6-48.
Spawton, T. (1991b). Why winemakers should know who consumes their wine and devise
their marketing accordingly. The Australian Grapegrower & Winemaker, 334, 33-37.
Stephens, B. (2003). Korean wine market is growing. Wines & Vines, 84(1), 30-33.
Thomas, A. (2000). Elements influencing wine purchasing: A New Zealand view. Interna-
tional Journal of Wine Marketing, 12(2), 47-62.
Thompson, K. E., & Vourvachis, A. (1995). Social and attitudinal influences on the inten-
tion to drink wine. International Journal of Wine Marketing, 7(2), 35-45.
Vinexpo avec le Concours de Vertumne International & Associes. (2002a). Le marche des
vins et spirituex en Coree du Sud: Faits marquants [The wine and spirits market of
South Korea]. Bordeaux, France: Author.
Vinexpo avec le Concours de Vertumne International & Associes. (2002b). World wine and
spirit market overview and prospects for 2006. Bordeaux, France: Author.
Walker, L. (2002, July). Export boom. Wines & Vines, 83(7), 16-22.
Williams, J. L., & Pearson, B. (1992). Tackling the challenge of Western markets: The case
of Tokai, Hungary. International Journal of Wine Marketing, 4(2), 38-44.

Submitted March 24, 2003


First Revision Submitted September 16, 2003
Final Revision Submitted April 17, 2004
Accepted May 16, 2004
Refereed Anonymously

Kyuho Lee (e-mail: leekyuho@vt.edu), is a Ph.D. student of Hospitality and Tourism


Management in Pamplin College of Business at Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State
University. Jinlin Zhao, Ph.D. (e-mail: zhaoj@fiu.edu), is an associate professor at the
School of Hospitality Management at Florida International University. Jae-Youn Ko,
Ph.D. (e-mail: jyko@khu.ac.kr), is an assistant professor in the College of Tourism &
Hotel Management at Kyung-Hee University, Seoul, Korea.

View publication stats

You might also like