DH V CHINA

ARBITRATION
jurisdictional
merits
pH claim ruling ruling
① China 's UNCLOS comprehensively
maritime S C Sea
engagements in Granted
'
'

allocates rights
exceed
to maritime areas
may not those established by UNCLOS
.

OH win

There is no legal
② China 's nine line
"
"
dash is invalid the
claim to
Granted basis for China to
-

claim historic rights

extent it exceeds the limits established by UNCLOS '

to in these
watery
.

Sea -

pH win

③
Scarborough Shoal generates no EEZ Granted Scarborough Shoal
is a
rock that
or continental shelf .

generates no EEF .

PH WIN

part of the EEZ

④ Mischief reef and second Thomas Shoal are part Granted a continental shelf .

Of the pH 's EEZ and continental shelf .

PH win .

⑧ Mischief Reef second,

Thomas Shoal ,
and subi Granted
they are LTE 's

Relf are all LTE 's that do not generate territorial

seas or EEZ 's are not subject to appropriation .

Both reefs are above

⑥ fallen Reef and Mckennon Reef C including Hughes water at

high tide ;
Granted they are rocks that

Reef ) are LTE 's that generate no maritime entitlement , generate territorial
seas but no EEZ

but may be used to determine baselines to or continental shelf .

measure territorial sea .

They are rocks that

Johnson Reef Warburton
. Reef, and Fiery cross Net Granted
generate no tot

entitlements EEZ continental shelf continental shelf

generate no or
'

to or
.

Granted
⑧ China has interfered w/ the soil 's exercise of yes ,
on interfered at
pH sovereign rights
sovereign rights over
living a non living resources to
fishing
exploration Min
a
hydrocarbon

its EET and continental its Ett

Min shelf
. .

PH win .

⑨ China has failed to prevent its nationals 2

vessels granted China failed to
prevent Mines -0
from
exploiting the
living resources in the PH 'S
fishermen from
fishing within
EET .

the PH EET
'

PH WIN
④ on has prevented PH fishermen from pursuing their Granted China violated the
PH 's trad
fishing
livelihoods through traditional fishing around 8.
Shoal
rights .

PH WIN

④ China has violated UNCLOS

'
environmental protection
Granted
China engaged in
in
environmentally
Obligation harmful fishing 1
at
Scarborough Shoal and second Thomas
harvesting practices
-

Shoal PH
Nih
'

Environmental protections
④ China 's occupation and construction on Mischief 's Granted were violated at MR .

artificial island
construction violated pH
Reef violate UNCLOS provisions on artificial islands
sovereign rights Min "

in EETs the appropriation

"

and environmental protection , and are unlawful acts claim is moot bc

M R -
is an LTE
not
Of capable of appropriation
attempted appropriation
.

PH Wth

⑧ China has violated UNCLOS by dangerously operating Granted CH violated UNCLOS

e other treaty
enforcement of collision
law vessels
creating serious risk provisions
maritime
on
safety .

Shoal PM Nih
Scarborough
'

near .

④ extended Although there is no

Onna has unlawfully aggravated I the
jurisdiction over
Granted in
disputes involving
dispute by interfering w/ the PM 's
right of navigation part
denied military activities such
as the second Thomas
In Part
near Scarborough Shoal ,
preventing The rotation and resupply Shoal standoff China .

has aggravated , extended

of pH personnel stationed at second Thomas Shoal , the disputes through
recent large
-

scaly

the
and
endangering the health of personnel there land reclamation &
.

artificial island construction

in the Ph EET
'

PH win .

This claim
simply ask

④ Going forward China shall respect the rights and Granted China to do what it
is required to
freedoms of the pH under UNCLOS I
comply w/ its
do under UNCLOS :
duties under uncles
.
Therefore no further
statement is

necessary
.