Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s00170-016-8466-y
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Received: 26 August 2015 / Accepted: 1 February 2016 / Published online: 27 February 2016
# Springer-Verlag London 2016
2.3 Measure methods Fig. 3 CAD models for experiments of residual stress distribution. a
Along height direction. b Along horizontal direction
Table 2 Chemical compositions (wt %) of 316L stainless steel Items Power/W Speed/ Hatch/mm Thickness/ Scanning strategy
(mm/s) mm
Element C Cr Ni Mo Si Mn O Fe
Value 200 400 0.08 0.04 X-Y inter layer
Mass fraction (%) 0.03 17.53 12.06 2.16 0.86 0.38 0.13 Bal stagger
650 Int J Adv Manuf Technol (2016) 87:647–656
the temperature of region І is lower than Tp, the material When a high energy laser irradiates the molten pool, the tem-
changes from the former complete plastic state into an incom- perature gradient between the bottom of the molten pool and
plete plastic state and the volume shrinkage is restricted by the surface provides a driving force for the growth of the grain.
region II. Thus, tensile stress is produced in region І and com- However, the solidification rate can reach values as high as
pressive stress in region II increases, as shown at stage 2 in 108 K/s when the laser beam moves out of the molten pool
Fig. 4b. [24, 25]; thus, the crystal development of austenite is signifi-
As the temperature drops continuously, region І shrinks cantly restricted due to insufficient time for the grain growth
further, but is still restricted by region II. This causes tensile [24, 27].
stress in region І and compressive stress in region II to further In SLM, a subsequent layer is deposited on the underlying
increase, and compressive stress is extended to region III, as layer, the temperature in the underlying layers has already
illustrated at stage 3 in Fig. 4b. decreased to a lower level, which leads to a non-
synchronous heating and cooling process between the ad-
3.2 Effect on the microstructure jacent layers. This so called thermal boundary effect
makes a discrepant of microstructures in the adjacent
Figure 5a shows a macro crack with a maximum length of layers. However, heat in the subsequent layer conducts
about 500 μm on the unpolished side surface, whereas through to the underlying layers, which changes the
Fig. 5b shows a micro crack with a maximum length about cooling and solidification processes as well as the micro-
30 μm on the polished side surface. This is because under the structural evolution, as shown in Fig. 6b–d.
action of a moving high energy laser, the melting and solidi-
fication processes are completed in a considerably short peri-
od of time, which induce a high temperature gradient and a 4 Results and discussion
high stress, as a result of which, cracks tend to be formed in
order to release the thermal stress [22]. 4.1 Residual stress distribution along the height direction
The microstructure of SLM 316L part is shown in Fig. 6.
Figure 6a shows that the sizes of most of the grains are less The residual stress along the height direction is shown in
than 1 μm, which can be attributed to the complete melting Fig. 7. It shows that residual stresses within SLM 316L
and high heating and cooling rates during the SLM process. parts are of lower magnitude and the range is between
−90 and 120 MPa. Stresses in the underlying layers are maximum σy of 73, 61, and 114 MPa. This is because
compressive, the maximum σ x are −41, −54, and the underlying layers near the base plate, the temperatures
−64 MPa, and the maximum σ y are −33, −68, and of which decrease initially and then the shrinkage of the
−88 MPa, respectively, which occur in the centers of newly added layers causes the underlying layers to be
parts. Peak values of tensile stresses are found in the top compressed, thereby producing compressive stresses in
layers with maximum σ x of 44, 31, and 54 MPa and the underlying layers [28]. With the increasing number
4.2.2 Effect of the scanning track length rapidly at the onset of tracks, and subsequently oscillates to a
small degree. This is because the molten pool is surrounded by
Samples 1, 2, and 3 were used to investigate the influence of non-melted powder at the onset of tracks, which possesses
scanning track length. The lengths were 44, 32, and 18 mm, lower thermal conductivity than that of the corresponding sol-
respectively, as shown in Fig. 3b. The laser power was 200 W, id material [30]. Heat in the molten pool is not easily trans-
scanning speed was 400 mm/s, layer thickness was 0.035 mm, mitted to the surrounding materials. Hence, a larger tempera-
hatching space was 0.08 mm, the scanning strategy was Z- ture gradient is produced in scanning tracks, which induces
type X-direction, and the total number of layers was 50. greater residual stress at the onset of tracks. As the laser beam
Curves in Fig. 10 show the distribution of residual moves forwards, the heat in the scanning tracks is diverted,
stress for different scanning track lengths. The longer and then the temperature gradient decreases and tends to grad-
the scanning track, the larger the residual stress. This ually bring about dynamic balance, and consequently the re-
trend is consistent with the finite element analysis (FEA) con- sidual stress decreases.
ducted by Matsumoto et al. [29]. An explanation for this is that
when the laser irradiates the powder bed and forms melting 4.2.3 Effect of sector scanning strategy
tracks, the tracks mainly shrink along the scanning direction.
When the scanning tracks are excessively long, the shrink- The above analysis illustrates that residual stresses mainly
age compensation is insufficient, which induces a larger occur along the scanning direction, and are the main causes
residual stress. In addition, the range of σx is between of warp in SLM parts. Finite element analyses [29, 31]
80 and 200 MPa, and the range of σz is between 30 showed that the degree of warping in SLM parts is propor-
and 90 MPa (except point 1_A). Hence, σx is much larger tional to the scanning tracks, hence implying that the residual
than σz. stresses in SLM parts can be significantly reduced if only the
The peak values of σx and σz occur at the onset of scanning length of the scanning track is shortened. As shown in Fig. 11,
tracks, and then decrease along the scanning direction; how- the length of sample 6 is equal to sample 1, but it was divided
ever, the trends are different. In the first half of the scanning into three segments. Each segment was scanned by scanning
track, the decrease in σx is minimal, and then in the second strategy of Z-type X-direction. The results show that sector
half the decrease is dramatic. On the contrary, σz decreases scanning can reduce residual stresses in SLM parts effectively;
the average decrease of σx reaches 22 %, whereas the average producing elastic compressive strains. When yield strength of
decrease of σz reaches 17 %. However, it is evident that sector the material is reached, the top layers become plastically com-
scanning has a greater impact on σx. At the measuring points pressed. During the cooling and shrinking period, the plasti-
of 1_A, 1_B, 1_C, 1_D, and 1_E, the σx decreases by more cally compressed upper layers become shorter than the bottom
than 50 MPa. This is because a short track length leads to a layers with the development of a bending angle (θ), towards
minimal cooling time between adjacent tracks [19], thereby the laser beam [19], as shown in Fig. 12. In this case, stable
resulting in a smaller temperature gradient, along the X support structures not only prevent the deformation of part
direction. caused by the material’s shrinkage, but also maintain the
manufacturing stability during the SLM process [20, 32]. As
shown in Fig. 13, the main parameters of support structure are
4.3 Measures for preventing warps and cracks tooth base interval, tooth base length, tooth top length, tooth
height, and hatching. The larger the tooth base interval +
Residual stress contributes to the crack formation or discon- length, top length or the smaller the hatching, the larger the
nection of parts from the base plate, therefore taking measures strength between support structure and part, the lesser is the
to reduce the residual stress in SLM part is necessary. probability of warping [33, 34].
Annealing treatment is a conventional and long established Three parts with same high aspect ratio (the length is
method to reduce stress in metallic parts, which are normally 60 mm, the section dimensions are 6 × 6 mm) were presented
used in welding, casting, forging, etc. Zhang et al. [28] used in Table 4. Part І was added uniform support structure, in
annealing treatment to reduce the residual stresses in Ti6Al4V which the hatching was 2 mm, tooth base interval + length
alloys manufactured by laser engineering net shaping (LENS). was 2 mm, and tooth top length was 0.3 mm. In part II, the
The results showed that the average stress could be reduced by hatching was 1 mm at the two ends, and 2 mm in the central
72 %. Although annealing treatment can effectively reduce region, the tooth base interval + length was 2 mm, and tooth
residual stress after manufacturing, it cannot prevent top length was 0.3 mm. Part III was added uniform support
warping and cracking caused by thermal stress during the structure, in which the hatching was 2 mm, tooth base inter-
SLM process. It is therefore necessary to try out other val + length was 2 mm, and tooth top length was 1 mm. The
methods to resolve these issues. processing parameters were laser power of 150 W, scanning
When a new layer is produced, the expansions of the heated speed of 400 mm/s, layer thickness of 35 μm, scanning space
top layers are restricted by the surrounding material, thereby of 80 μm, scanning strategy was X-Y inter-layer stagger. The
results were shown in Fig. 14, the part І warped at two ends,
whereas parts II and III were manufactured successfully. This
is because support structures with smaller hatching and larger
top length not only constrain warping at both ends of the parts,
but can also conduct heat from the top layers to the base plate,
thereby reducing the temperature gradient in the SLM parts.
5 Conclusions
Part
10 2 mm 1 mm
I
Part
10 2 mm 1 mm
II
Part
10 2 mm 1 mm
III
theoretically. Stresses along height and horizontal directions layers on the previously scanned layers, the tensile stress
were measured by X-ray diffraction, the influences of subse- converts into compressive, and the compressive stress is
quent thermal cycling, energy input and scanning track length enhanced due to subsequent thermal cycling.
were investigated, and several conclusions can be drawn, (2) Residual stress parallel to the scanning direction is
which are as follows: much larger than that perpendicular to the scanning
direction. Lower energy input and shorter line length
(1) Compressive stress occurs at the bottom and tensile induce smaller residual stress in SLM parts.
stress at the top of SLM part, but with addition of new Therefore, sector scanning strategy, which reduces
the scanning track length, can reduce residual stress 15. Zhao HH, Zhang GJ, Yin ZQ, Wu L (2012) Three-dimensional
finite element analysis of thermal stress in single-pass multi-layer
efficiently.
weld-based rapid prototyping. J Mater Proc Technol 212:276–285
(3) The peak values of residual stress always occur at the 16. Zhang AF, Qi BL, Shi BF, Li DC (2015) Effect of curvature radius
onset of scanning track, which indicates that the both ends on the residual stress of thin-walled parts in laser direct forming. Int
of part are easy to warp and crack. Therefore, stronger J Adv Manuf Technol 79(1):81–88
17. Zaeh MF, Branner G (2010) Investigation on residual stresses and
support structures are needed at both ends of SLM part,
deformations in selective laser melting. Prod Eng Res Dev 4(1):
to prevent warps and cracks, during the SLM process. 35–45
18. Kruth JP, Deckers J, Yasa E, Wauthle R (2012) Assessing and
Acknowledgments The authors gratefully appreciate the National comparing influencing factors of residual stresses in selective laser
Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC, No. 51275179, 51405160), melting using a novel analysis method. Proc Inst Mech Eng B J Eng
and Special Fund Project for Technology Innovation of Foshan City Manuf 226(6):980–991
(No. 2013AH100042). 19. Kruth JP, Froyen L, Vaerenbergh JV (2004) Selective laser melting
of iron-based powder. J Mater Proc Technol 149(1–3):616–622
20. Wang D, Yang YQ, Ye ZH (2013) Research on the fabricating
quality optimization of the overhanging surface in SLM process.
References Int J Adv Manuf Technol 65(9–12):1471–1484
21. Wang D, Yang YQ, Su XB, Chen YH (2012) Study on energy input
1. Kruth JP, Levy G, Klocke F, Childs THC (2007) Consolidation and its influences on single-track, multi-track, and multi-layer in
phenomena in laser and powder-bed based layered manufacturing. SLM. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 58(9):1189–1199
CIRP Ann Manuf Technol 56(2):730–759 22. Li RD, Shi YS, Wang ZG (2010) Densification behavior of gas and
2. Branner G, Zaeh MF, Groth C (2008) Coupled-field simulation in water atomized 316L stainless steel powder during selective laser
additive layer manufacturing. Proceedings of the 3rd International melting. Appl Surf Sci 256(13):4350–4356
Conference on Polymers and Moulds Innovations, Gent, Belgium, 23. GB/T 7704–2008 (2002) Non-destructive testing-practice for resid-
pp 184–193 ual stress measurement by X-ray. China Standard Press, Beijing
3. Withers PJ, Bhadeshia HK (2001) Residual stress: part 2—nature 24. Zhang BC, Dembinski L, Coddet C (2013) The study of the laser
and origins. Mater Sci Technol 17(4):366–375 parameters and environment variables effect on mechanical proper-
4. Mercelis P, Kruth JP (2006) Residual stresses in selective laser ties of high compact parts elaborated by selective laser melting
sintering and selective laser melting. Rapid Prototyp J 12(5): 316L powder. Mater Sci Eng A 584:21–31
254–265 25. Thijs L, Sistiaga MLM, Wauthle R (2013) Strong morphological
5. Grum J, Sturm R (2004) A new experimental technique for mea- and crystallographic texture and resulting yield strength anisot-
suring strain and stresses during a laser remelting process. J Mater ropy in selective laser melted tantalum. Acta Mater 61(12):
Process Technol 147(3):351–358 4657–4668
6. Lai YB, Liu WJ, Kong Y (2013) Influencing factors of residual 26. Roberts IA, Wang CJ, Esterlein R (2009) A three-dimensional finite
stress of Ti-6.5Al-1V-2Zr alloy by laser rapid forming process. element analysis of the temperature field during laser melting of
Rare Metal Mater Eng 42(7):1526–1530 melting powders in additive layer manufacturing. Int J Mach Tool
7. Casavola C, Campanelli SL, Pappalettere C (2009) Preliminary Manuf 49(12–13):916–923
investigation on distribution of residual stress generated by the se- 27. Ding ZS, Li BZ, Liang SY (2015) Phase transformation and resid-
lective laser melting process. J Strain Anal Eng 44:93–104 ual stress of Maraging C250 steel during grinding. Mater Lett 154:
8. Rangaswamy P, Griffith ML, Prime MB, Holden TM, Rogge RB 37–39
(2005) Residual stresses in LENS components using neutron dif- 28. Zhang SY, Lin X, Chen J (2009) Influence of heat treatment on
fraction and contour method. Mater Sci Eng A 399(1–2):72–83 residual stress of Ti6Al4V alloy by laser solid forming. Rare
9. Vrancken B, Cain V, Knutsen R, Humbeeck JV (2014) Residual Metal Mater Eng 38(5):774–778
stress via the contour method in compact tension specimens pro- 29. Matsumoto M, Shiomi M, Osakada K, Abe F (2002) Finite element
duced via selective laser melting. Scr Mater 87:29–32 analysis of single layer forming on metallic powder bed in rapid
10. Yadroitsev I, Yadroitsava I (2015) Evaluation of residual stress in prototyping by selective laser processing. Int J Mach Tool Manuf
stainless steel 316L and Ti6Al4V samples produced by selective 42(1):61–67
laser melting. Virtual Phys Prototyp 10(2):67–76 30. Rombouts M, Kruth JP, Froyen L (2006) Fundamentals of selective
11. Vrancken B, Wauthlé R, Kruth JP, Van HJ (2013) Study of the laser melting of alloyed steel powders. CIRP Ann Manuf Technol
influence of material properties on residual stress in selective laser 55(1):187–192
melting. Proceedings Solid Freeform Fabrication Symposium, 31. Nickel AH, Barnett DM, Prinz FB (2001) Thermal stresses and
Austin, August 2013, pp 1–15 deposition patterns in layered manufacturing. Mater Sci Eng A
12. Shiomi M, Osakada K, Nakamura K, Yamashita T (2004) Residual 317(1–2):59–64
stress within metallic model made by selective laser melting pro- 32. Hong J, Li DC, Tang YP, Lu BH (2000) Design of RP support
cess. CIRP Ann Manuf Technol 53(1):195–198 structure. J Xi'an Jiaotong Univ 34(9):58–61
13. Wang TM, Xi JT, Jin Y (2006) A model research for prototype warp 33. Calignana F (2014) Design optimization of supports for overhang-
deformation in the FDM process. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 33(11): ing structures in aluminum and titanium alloys by selective laser
1087–1096 melting. Mater Des 64:203–213
14. Hussein A, Hao L, Yan C, Everson R (2013) Finite element simu- 34. Strano G, Hao L, Everson RM, Evans KE (2013) A new approach
lation of the temperature and stress fields in single layers built to the design and optimization of support structures in additive
without-support in selective laser melting. Mater Des 52:638–647 manufacturing. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 66(9–12):1247–1254