Professional Documents
Culture Documents
for
perspective
developing
Examining multiple
03 perspectives
literacy
05 Focussing on sociopolitical issues
Repositioning students as
06 researchers of language
MULTIPLE
TEXTS-
RESISTANCE
PERSPECTIVE
..
Multiple texts improve students’
application of reading–thinking
strategies, build confidence, and develop
the motivation to learn. Through the use
of multiple texts, all students have the
opportunity to learn new information and
make meaningful contributions to
discussions. Moreover, varied texts
provide multiple perspectives that help
students rethink events and issues that
impact everyone and deepen their
knowledge of literary genres.
RESISTANT READING
During resistant reading, students analyze
the dominant reading of a text and “resist” it
by engaging in alternative readings.
Resistant readings scrutinize the beliefs and
attitudes that typically go unexamined in a
text, drawing attention to the gaps, silences
and contradictions.
EXAMPLE
Acquiring a resistant perspective is sometimes stimulated
by asking students to assume new or unfamiliar identities.
For example, in a unit on Wisconsin state history, the
teacher organized students into small groups that took on a
family identity (e.g., Native American, German American,
English American) and then expressed their family’s views
as Wisconsin evolved from part of the Northwest Territory
to a separate territory and then to statehood. Similarly, EG.
another teacher introduced Laura Ingalls Wilder’s Little
House on the Prairie by asking students to consider their
reactions to the white and Native American characters.
Finding their responses Eurocentric, she encouraged
students to reconsider their responses from a Native
American point of view. A resistant perspective can also be
motivated by inviting students to read from an alternative
frame of reference.
MULTIPLE
PERSPECTIVES
Exploring multiple perspectives (which is known as
"multiperspectivity" in parts of Europe) requires
incorporating source materials that reflect
different views of a historical event. In recent
decades scholars and educators have begun to
question the validity of singular (one-sided)
historical narratives. Instead of just focusing on
dominant groups and communities, they recommend
employing multiple perspectives. One reason for
this stems from increasing diversity and cultural
pluralism, since many groups—women, the poor,
ethnic minorities, etc.—have been ignored in
traditional historical narratives.