You are on page 1of 4

CHAPTER 294: 1971

Arrange follow-up appointments according to Centers for Disease SANEs and SAFEs are all trained in the sexual assault forensic examina-
Control and Prevention recommendations. Patients receiving postexpo- tion of males. Resources for counseling may be more difficult to find for
sure prophylaxis should be seen within 1 week following initial assess- the male survivor, especially in small communities. The Rape, Abuse
ment, and all patients should be seen in 1 to 2 weeks.31 This ensures & Incest National Network does have special resources for men. Its
the effectiveness of pregnancy prophylaxis and sexually transmitted victim hotline can be reached at 1-800-656-HOPE, and its website can
infection treatment. be accessed at www.rainn.org.
Male sexual assault survivors should follow up with a urologist or
proctologist. Special populations, such as children, should be referred to REFERENCES
a pediatrician or a pediatric abuse clinic.
The complete reference list is available online at www.TintinalliEM.com.
SPECIAL POPULATIONS
! ADOLESCENTS AND CHILDREN
Consider sexual abuse in children if no definitive explanation for non-
sexual transmission of a sexually transmitted infection can be identified.31
CHAPTER Intimate Partner Violence
For extensive discussion, see Chapter 150, “Child Abuse and Neglect.”
and Abuse
The most experienced examiner available should examine children to
minimize pain or further trauma.
294 Cameron Crandall
Sylvia Gonzalez Alden
! ELDERLY PATIENTS
Most elder assaults take place at the patient’s home, and most assaults
are by an unknown assailant.52 In the case of an elderly assault survivor, INTRODUCTION AND EPIDEMIOLOGY
the forensic interview and examination present unique challenges. The
patient not only may resist the pelvic examination because of injury or Intimate partner violence includes physical violence, sexual violence,
pain, but the pelvic area may be difficult to visualize because of hip con- threats of physical or sexual violence, stalking, progressive social isola-
tractures or vaginal atrophy. It is also difficult to explain the examination tion, and psychological aggression perpetrated by someone who is, was,
to a patient with dementia or cognitive impairment. Further challenges or wishes to be involved in an intimate or dating relationship with an
include obtaining an accurate and reliable history of the details of the adult or adolescent individual. These actions are aimed at establishing
assault, the injuries sustained, and regions of pain or discomfort.52,53 control by one partner over the other.1-3
Special adjustments may be needed for the interview and sexual assault Intimate partner violence and abuse is the preferred alternative for
examination.52,53 previously used terms such as spousal abuse, wife battering, and domestic
violence. This term more accurately reflects the fact that this type of abuse
occurs not only in adult heterosexual married relationships but also in
! TRANSGENDER AND LESBIAN PATIENTS relationships between cohabiting, separated, gay and lesbian, bisexual,
Until recently, information about sexual assault of lesbian and trans- and transgender individuals as well as in adolescent dating relationships.3
gendered women has mostly relied on data from informal surveys54 and Intimate partner violence and abuse occurs in every racial, ethnic,
anecdotal evidence. These data indicate that 47% of transgender women cultural, geographic, and religious group, and it affects individuals of
report being raped at least once in their life.55 The Centers for Disease all socioeconomic and educational backgrounds worldwide. Men are
Control and Prevention’s 2018 report, National Intimate Partner and affected, but the overwhelming burden of victimization from intimate
Sexual Violence Survey,24 used more rigorous research methods and partner violence is borne by women.1,4 Intimate partner violence occurs
presents significant data about the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, in both opposite sex and same sex relationships.3 Risk factors for inti-
and queer community and sexual assault. FORGE (www.forge-forward mate partner violence and abuse include female sex, age between 18 and
.org) is a Wisconsin-based group for the support of the transgender pop- 24 years, low income level of the household, black or multiracial race/
ulation. The group has a website with printable handouts for lesbian and ethnicity, bisexual sexual orientation, and relationship status of sepa-
transgendered patients who are sexual assault survivors, survivor first- rated rather than divorced or married.1 Presence of weapons in the home
person narratives, and resource links for both patients and providers. and threats of murder are associated with increased risk of homicide.
Effects extend to family members, friends, coworkers, other wit-
nesses, and the community at large.1 In families in which either child
! MEN maltreatment or spousal abuse is identified, it is likely that both forms of
Male sexual assault is less common than sexual assault of women.56 abuse exist.5 Children exposed to violence in the home have higher rates
Assaults on males generally result in more severe injuries,57,58 with 40% of behavioral difficulties; mental and health problems including depres-
to 60% of males sustaining anogenital injuries,58,59 and assaults on men sion, anxiety, abusive behaviors, and drug abuse; and eating, sleeping,
are likely to involve multiple assailants.60 At least a third of males who are and pain problems.5 Frequent exposure to violence in the home may
sexually assaulted have a history of psychiatric or cognitive disability.59 normalize violence for children, resulting in higher rates of victimiza-
One major factor that complicates the care of male survivors is the fact tion and perpetration later in life.1,5
that physiologically, the stimulation of anal penetration can lead to Providers should ask about a history of intimate partner violence or
involuntary erection and sometimes to ejaculation. Furthermore, many abuse during healthcare encounters. Failure to recognize and intervene
assailants manually stimulate their victims to cause ejaculation. Numer- in situations of intimate partner violence may have serious conse-
ous cases of male sexual assault have been determined to be consensual quences for the survivor and family. Such consequences may include
by judges and defense attorneys who fail to understand the involuntary continued violence, physical and behavioral health problems, and injury
nature of this physiologic response.60 The survivors themselves can be or even death.1,6,7
confused and distressed by this response and may hesitate to offer this
information. Use a short, simple explanation of the physiology using lay CLINICAL FEATURES
language to assist in history taking.
Hospitals have male rape kits available, and the same guidelines Intimate partner violence is often cyclical in nature. The cycle begins
should be followed for history, physical exam, collection of forensic evi- with a period of tension building, which may include arguing, blam-
dence, and maintaining chain of custody as have already been described. ing, or controlling behaviors or jealousy. The next phase is escalation

FB:Cardiologia Siglo XXI

Tintinalli_Sec25_p1967-1978.indd 1971 8/2/19 1:50 PM


1972 SECTION 25: Abuse and Assault

TABLE 294-1 Health Consequences of Intimate Partner Violence TABLE 294-2 Signs Suggestive of Intimate Partner Violence
Adults Adolescents Children Findings Comments

plus
abuse

Multicultural and multilingual information about intimate partner


and may include verbal threats, physical and sexual abuse, or assault. violence and effects on abused individuals and family members should
Weapons may be used at this point. Sometimes there may be a “honey- be made available to the public and employees. This may consist of
moon” phase in which the perpetrator may apologize or make excuses posters and/or brochures in areas of the hospital such as public areas,
for inappropriate behavior. Over time, the abusive behavior tends examination rooms, and restrooms. Community resources that provide
to increase in severity, and the intervals between abusive episodes services to victims should be a part of the shared information.
become shorter. Screening should be conducted by providers educated about the
There are no “usual” features to help identify a victim of intimate dynamics of intimate partner violence. Provide a safe and private envi-
partner violence. Health-related consequences of violence or abuse often ronment for the interview. Take into account cultural differences and
lead to an ED visit (Table 294-1).2,8,9 Signs suggestive of intimate partner expectations. If language interpreters are required, use individuals who
violence and abuse are summarized in Table 294-2.1,8 have no connection to the patient. Document screening results, safety
Signs of abuse may be suspected by behavior of the partner. The assessment, and any interventions, including referrals and required
abusive partner may be defensive, hostile, and aggressive, and might reporting. Screening guidelines for adolescent and adult patients are
demonstrate controlling or overly solicitous behavior toward the summarized in Table 294-3.9 Sample verbal screening questions are
patient.9 The patient may appear frightened of the partner or refuse listed in Table 294-4.9 The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force has pub-
to answer questions and instead defer all responses to the partner. In lished a review of a variety screening tools.2
situations raising concern, and if the patient agrees, hospital security When conducting screening and assessment, be nonjudgmental, sen-
can prevent the alleged perpetrator from visiting the patient in the ED sitive, and direct. Let the patient know that you take the situation seri-
and hospital. ously. Assure victims of confidentiality. Communicate an understanding
of the complexity of the situation and the difficulties of achieving a
“quick fix.” Reassure the victim that no one deserves abuse and victims
SCREENING AND ASSESSMENT are not at fault. It is the abuser whose behavior is unacceptable. Avoid
pressuring, respect patient decisions, and work together to determine
Many experts, including the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force and an appropriate course of action.12 Ask abused individuals if they have
the American College of Emergency Physicians, recommend routine suicidal or homicidal ideation. Such ideation, particularly if accom-
screening for intimate partner violence for all adolescent and adult panied by a concrete plan of action, should trigger immediate consul-
women who present to the ED and for mothers of children brought tation with a mental health provider.
to the ED. Futures Without Violence has published national screening
consensus guidelines.9 Because of the known adverse long-term impacts
of intimate personal violence on health, when time permits, consider RISK ASSESSMENT AND DISPOSITION
screening for lifetime exposure.
A protocol should be implemented that addresses identification of, Ensuring the safety of the abused individual and children is the
and screening for, intimate partner violence; training of ED personnel; foremost goal. The most dangerous periods for abused individuals are
confidential interviewing; and appropriate interventions, including vali- during the time of abuse disclosure and during attempts to leave the
dation and referral.2,9,11 relationship. Indicators of a high-risk and potentially lethal situation

FB:Cardiologia Siglo XXI

Tintinalli_Sec25_p1967-1978.indd 1972 8/2/19 1:50 PM


CHAPTER 294: 1973

TABLE 294-3 Summary of National Consensus Guidelines for Screening for Intimate Partner Violence and Abuse in the ED9
Screening Assessment Intervention Documentation Referral and Follow-Up

include escalation in the frequency or severity of violence; the threat decide what is best. The patient’s decision making may be very complex,
or actual use of weapons; obsession with the abused individuals; hos- because depression, lack of self-esteem, lack of support, social isolation,
tage taking; stalking; strangulation; and homicide or suicide threats financial dependence on the perpetrator, and fear make it difficult to
or attempts and evidence of violent behavior outside the home. leave the relationship.
Another risk factor for serious injury or death is substance abuse by the Refer individuals to intimate violence experts, such as trained hos-
perpetrator, which can increase violent behaviors.1,8 pital social workers or community-based advocates, who can help the
If lethality risk is high, consult with experts before ED discharge.9 victim assess the situation, understand options, plan for safety, and
Hospital admission of the abused individual or children is an option in arrange safe shelter. Community advocates are typically on call or avail-
high-risk situations in which there is no other way to ensure safety. Use able by telephone. If the patient can be safely discharged from the ED
of a 24-hour safe room, a location established by some hospitals and and personal contact with an advocate cannot be made before discharge,
communities to provide a safe place for the patient to stay while arrange- give the patient up-to-date information about available services in the
ments for safe disposition of the patient and family members are made, community. Intimate personal violence advocates should not be asked
is another option. Use of an alias name on admission and screening of to call the patient directly unless the patient agrees, because calls to
incoming phone calls may also be of benefit. the home could jeopardize the patient’s safety.
Some individuals feel safer remaining in the violent relationship than Resources for healthcare providers to assist in preparing their prac-
leaving without adequate planning for a safe departure.9 Placing the tices for optimal response to victims of intimate personal violence are
patient in a shelter or having the attacker arrested may not be congru- available from a number of organizations (Table 294-5 ). Table 294-6
ent with the individual’s goals. Ultimately, the abused individual must lists hotlines for patients.
decide if it is safe to return home. By providing information about inti-
mate violence, risks, and options, the ED provider can help the patient ! ED RECORD DOCUMENTATION
Voluntary descriptions of intimate personal violence should be quoted
and described in the patient’s own words. Do not use the word alleged
TABLE 294-4 Sample of Intimate Partner Violence Screening Questions* because it implies that the person recording the incident does not believe
the complaint.9 A complaint of “sexual assault” is no more alleged than
is a complaint of “ear pain” or a “sore throat.”
Record past and current abuse, with details of date, time, location,
witnesses, and specific injury. Describe the patient’s health complaints,
injuries, appearance, and demeanor. Annotated body maps and photo-
graphs can supplement written notes.

TABLE 294-5 Resources for Healthcare Providers

FB:Cardiologia Siglo XXI

Tintinalli_Sec25_p1967-1978.indd 1973 8/2/19 1:50 PM


1974 SECTION 25: Abuse and Assault

TABLE 294-6 Hotlines for Patients CHAPTER Abuse of the Elderly and
Impaired
295 Jonathan Glauser
Frederic M. Hustey

INTRODUCTION
Obtain relevant forensic evidence, and follow the appropriate chain Elder abuse is an act or omission resulting in harm to the health or wel-
of custody of evidence. If sexual assault has occurred, document ED fare of an elderly person. Three key groups have published definitions of
testing and treatment; arrange for a sexual assault nurse examiner exam, elder abuse.1-3 Although the incidence of elder neglect and abuse is
if locally available. See Chapter 29 3, “Female and Male Sexual Assault,” unknown and widely felt to be underreported, the rate of different types
for detailed discussion. of abuse among the elderly has been estimated to be in the mid-single
Record safety assessment and planning. A safety assessment form or digits up to 10% of persons age >65 years,4 or between 500,000 and
referral notes from an expert are helpful adjuncts. 1 million U.S. adults.5,6 One meta-analysis identified the pooled preva-
lence of elder abuse overall in geographically diverse countries to be
! LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS 15.7%.7 Alternatively, a clinician seeing between 20 and 40 adults over
age 60 per day could encounter more than one victim of elder mistreat-
Most states in the United States have laws that require healthcare provid- ment on a daily basis.8 Table 295-1 summarizes the categories of elder
ers to report specified injuries, wounds, or crimes. Intimate personal abuse.
violence is a crime in all 50 states.13 Four states have exceptions to manda-
tory reporting for injuries related to domestic violence. The specifics of
the reporting requirements vary from state to state, and the adequacy CLINICAL FEATURES
! PHYSICAL ABUSE
of response by the police to reporting varies by jurisdiction. Inadequate or
inappropriate response to the reports (e.g., informing the perpetrator
of the report without providing for the safety of the abused individual) Physical abuse is the most easily recognized form of elder abuse. It is
can increase the risk of harm to the abused. Inform the victim if there is defined as the use of physical force that might result in bodily injury,
an obligation to make a police report and explain possible ramifications. physical pain, or impairment. Pushing, slapping, burning, striking with
objects, and improper use of restraint are all examples of physical abuse.
Chemical restraint (such as intentional overmedication or administra-
SPECIAL POPULATIONS tion of tranquilizers) is a more subtle form. Regardless of mechanism,
! PREGNANCY
physical abuse is carried out with the intention of causing suffering,
pain, or other physical impairment to the abused person.
Prevalence of intimate partner violence during pregnancy ranges from
6% to 22%.4,8 Women who report intimate partner violence and abuse ! CAREGIVER NEGLECT
during pregnancy are at increased risk of postnatal abuse. Women
assaulted during pregnancy are three times more likely to be admitted Elder neglect is the most common form of elder maltreatment, account-
to the hospital than nonpregnant women.8 ing for more than half of all elder maltreatment cases reported to adult
protective services agencies annually.9 Elder neglect is defined as the
! IMMIGRANT POPULATIONS
failure of a caregiver to meet basic needs for a person or to provide
goods and services necessary to prevent physical harm or emotional
Overall, prevalence of intimate partner violence is lower in people born
outside of the United States. However, certain immigrant populations
have rates far higher than U.S. natives.1,14 Moreover, the burden of TABLE 295-1 Categories of Elder Abuse
intimate partner violence can be much higher in these populations as Categories of Abuse Example
victims may be socially and linguistically isolated and perpetrators can
use threats of deportation to restrain victims from seeking help.14 The
federal Violence Against Women Act establishes protection that may
protect undocumented persons from deportation if they have been a
victim of crime, including intimate partner violence.

! LGBTQ PERSONS
Intimate partner violence occurs in same sex relationships at rates gen-
erally similar to opposite sex relationships. Bisexual women and men,
however, report substantially higher rates of intimate partner physical
violence overall.1 Transgender women and gender nonconforming per-
sons also experience intimate partner violence at higher rates. Lesbian,
gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer persons may not report to police
or seek advocacy services for fear of discrimination.3
Acknowledgment: The authors gratefully acknowledge the contri-
butions of Mary Hancock, the author of this chapter in the previous
edition.

REFERENCES Source:
The National Elder Abuse Incidence Study
The complete reference list is available online at www.TintinalliEM.com.

FB:Cardiologia Siglo XXI

Tintinalli_Sec25_p1967-1978.indd 1974 8/2/19 1:50 PM

You might also like