Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Himanshu Bisaria & Pragya Shandilya (2018): Experimental investigation
on wire electric discharge machining (WEDM) of Nimonic C-263 superalloy, Materials and
Manufacturing Processes, DOI: 10.1080/10426914.2018.1532589
CONTACT Himanshu Bisaria rme1509@mnnit.ac.in Mechanical Engineering Department, MNNIT Allahabad, Allahabad, India
Color versions of one or more of the figures in the article can be found online at www.tandfonline.com/lmmp.
© 2018 Taylor & Francis
2 H. BISARIA AND P. SHANDILYA
machining of Ti50Ni49Co1 shape memory alloy and studied Materials and methods
the influence of input parameters on cutting rate (CR) and SR.
Material
It was noticed that CR and SR were increased with the
increase in pulse on-time, while spark gap voltage showed Nimonic C-263 superalloy, which is extensively used in aero-
the reverse trend and high surface crack density was also space industries for the turbine blade manufacturing, was
observed at higher value of CR and SR. Sharma et al.[17] selected as target material for the experimental studies. For
examined the influence of material of wire electrode on CR the elemental composition of the Nimonic C-263, EDS test
and surface integrity aspects for Inconel 706 superalloy in was used which is shown in Fig. 1. The procurement of
WEDM. It was reported that the improved surface quality in material was in the square-shape plate of dimensions
terms of lower SR, smoother topography, and thin recast layer 155 × 155 × 5 mm3. The mechanical and physical properties
was obtained with the hard brass wire, whereas higher cutting of Nimonic C-263 are given in Table 1.
speed as productivity was obtained with zinc-coated wire.
However, the effect of diffused wire was moderate. The effect
of discharge energy on the machinability of AISI 4340 steel
was also investigated by Giridharan and Samuel.[18] It was Experimental methodology
found that the MRR, SR, and recast layer thickness were The experiments were performed on Nimonic C-263 super-
increased with the increase in discharge energy. alloy by using four-axis, CNC Express cut 7732C wire cut
The conclusions from the comprehensive analysis of machine which is shown in Fig. 2. For this experimental
previous literature can be made that the most of the past study, the most influencing parameters of WEDM such as
research work was focused on the machinability of Ni- spark energy (Es), spark frequency (fs), and peak current (Ip)
based superalloys, but consideration of spark energy and with five levels were selected based on preliminary experi-
spark frequency for the performance characteristics of ments which are tabularized in Table 2, whereas some WEDM
these superalloys in WEDM was rarely reported. Hence, parameters were kept at a fixed level during experimentation
the goal of this investigation is to explore the influence of are listed in Table 3. SR, average CR, and surface character-
WEDM process parameters such as spark energy, spark istics have opted as response parameters. For measuring the
frequency, and peak current on SR, average CR, and sur- surface quality of the machined surface, average SR (Ra) has
face integrity aspects for Nimonic C-263 superalloy using been considered, whereas average CR epitomizes the produc-
one-parameter-at-a-time (OPAT) approach. Under surface tivity. The detail description of response parameters and their
integrity aspects, the surface morphology, surface topogra- measurements are summarized in Table 4.
phy, elemental composition, recast layer thickness, and The energy required for material removal in WEDM is
phase analysis have been studied by using Scanning elec- gained from the conversion of spark energy to thermal energy.
tron microscope (SEM), optical profilometer, energy dis- Thus, the spark energy or discharge energy may be defined as
persive spectroscopy (EDS), and X-ray diffraction (XRD) the average electrical energy per pulse. The spark energy can
technique, respectively. be given as Eq. (1)[11]:
Properties Density (g/cm3) Avg. hardness (Hv) Yield strength (MPa) Elongation (%) Creep stress (MPa) Tensile strength (MPa)
Specification 8.36 300 ≥400 24.1 120 ≥540
Figure 2. Pictorial view during the machining of Nimonic C-263 in WEDM (EX7732).
Table 2. Variable parameters and their levels of WEDM for Nimonic C-263 superalloy.
Table 3. Fixed parameters for WEDM of Nimonic C-263 superalloy. Es ffi Ve Ie tON (2)
Parameters Specification where tON is pulse on-time, the five levels of tON, 40, 50, 60,
Wire electrode Molybdenum (Ø 180 µm) 70, and 80 µs and pulse off-time (tOFF), 5, 10, 15, 20, and 25 µs
Dielectric fluid De-ionized water
were selected during experiments. The discharge voltage and
Dielectric pressure (MPa) 0.98
Dielectric conductivity (µs/m) ±20–23
peak current 28 V and 6 A were, respectively, maintained
Working temperature (°C) 25 constant during the study. Sparks frequency (number of
Polarity Straight polarity sparks per second) is given according to Eq. (3),[11] which
Wire feed rate 7 m/min increases with the decrease in tON.
Sparkfrequency ðkHzÞ ¼ 103 =ðTON þ TOFF Þ (3)
te
Spark energy ðJ Þ ¼ ò Ve ðtÞ ie ðtÞ dt ffi Ve Ie te
0 Results and discussion
(1) Surface roughness and average cutting rate
where Es is the spark energy (J), Ve is discharge voltage (V), te The effect of separate WEDM process parameters on SR and
is discharge duration (µs), and Ie is discharge current (A). For CR is shown in Figs. 3–5, while other WEDM process para-
ideal discharge condition i.e. zero delay in ignition, the dis- meters are kept at the middle level. Figure 3 displays the
charge duration becomes equal to pulse duration and spark influence of spark energy on SR and CR. CR and SR are
energy can be written as Eq. (2)[11]: significantly increased with an increase in ES, whereas the
4 H. BISARIA AND P. SHANDILYA
Figure 3. Effect of spark energy on average cutting rate and surface roughness.
other WEDM process parameters were kept at a fixed level. of ES on SR can also be explained with the help of the
The spark energy directly affects the amount of thermal mathematical relationship between crater depth and spark
energy required for material removal. With the increase in energy as given in Eq. (4).[21] As spark energy is increased,
Es, more thermal heat transferred to material causes high the deeper craters are formed because of high crater depth.
temperature which assists in the removal of material and
hence CR is increased.[20] It can be observed from Fig. 3 hc ðmmÞ K Es 0:33 (4)
that the SR also exhibited the similar trend with ES i.e. it where hc is crater depth (mm), Es is spark energy (J), K is
increases with the increase in ES. This is because at the higher constant whose value depends on the material.
value of Es, deeper and wider craters are formed on the The variation of CR and SR with spark frequency, keeping
machined surface, and as a result, SR is increased. This effect other WEDM process parameters at the middle level, is shown
MATERIALS AND MANUFACTURING PROCESSES 5
Figure 4. Effect of spark frequency on average cutting rate and surface roughness.
in Fig. 4. The CR was found to decrease with the increase in fs. higher Es, more material is melted which led to the for-
This is because of shorter pulse duration at higher fs. At mation of surface irregularities.
shorter pulse duration i.e. pulse on-time, the spark energy
and spark’s intensity are decreased which causes low MRR
and thus CR is decreased. The similar trend is shown by SR, it Surface topography
decreased with the increase in fs. As fs increases, sparking The machined surface’s 3D surface topography generated
ampere output i.e. sparking current decreases. So, lower fs is at lower and higher ES are shown in Fig. 7(a–b), respec-
generally used for rough cutting operation, whereas higher fs tively. From 3D surface topography, it can be concluded
is preferred for the finishing operation.[11] that at lower ES, fine surface with higher smoothness was
Figure 5 depicts the effect of peak current on CR and SR obtained compared to higher Es. At higher ES, deeper
keeping other WEDM process parameters at the middle level. craters (average depth 42 µm shown in Fig. 7(b)) are
Similar to spark energy, the CR and SR are increased with an formed compared to the shallow crater (average depth
increase in IP. At the higher value of IP, the amount of spark 18.443 µm) formed at lower Es which also experimentally
energy is increased which led to increasing MRR and crater rectifies the Eq. (4) i.e. the mathematical relationship
size. Therefore, the CR and SR are found to be increased at between crater depth and spark energy. At higher Es,
higher IP compared to lower IP. more thermal heat is transferred to workpiece surface
which led to more melting of material and hence the
formation of wider and deeper craters is increased.
Surface morphology
For microstructural analysis of machined surface, SEM
Recast layer thickness and EDS analysis
images were captured at 500 × magnification. Fig. 6(a–b)
shows the morphology of the machined surface generated Figure 8 illustrates the thickness of the recast layer depos-
at lower and higher spark energy, respectively. SEM ited with the elemental composition of constituent ele-
micrograph of machined surface illustrates the formation ments present on outer machining surface at higher Es.
of discharge craters, micro-voids, droplets of molten mate- It can be observed that a thick recast layer of thickness
rials, and micro-globules. It was also detected that there 32 µm is deposited on the outer machining surface with
was no formation of micro-cracks on the machined sur- high deposition of foreign atoms, for example Mo, C, and
face due to the high toughness of Nimonic C-263 super- O form the dielectric fluid and the wire electrode. At
alloy. The similar findings were also observed by Sharma higher Es, the amount of thermal energy transferred to
et al.[17] during machining of Inconel 706 in WEDM. It workpiece material is enhanced which causes the more
can be also noticed that at higher Es, the surface has more melted material to re-solidify on the outer machining sur-
distorted morphology compared to lower Es because at face which led to the deposition of thick recast layer. The
6 H. BISARIA AND P. SHANDILYA
Figure 5. Effect of peak current on average cutting rate and surface roughness.
Figure 6. SEM micrograph of machined surface at (a) lower Es (6.72 mJ) and (b) higher Es (13.44 mJ).
elemental composition of Mo-wire is shown in Fig. 9. with high percentage of foreign elements (Cu, Zn, C, and
Since the Mo-wire was used for machining, Mo atoms O) was deposited on the machined surface at higher pulse
on the machined surface were recorded approximately on-time as compared to lower pulse on-time. Similar find-
2.80 times more compared to the base material composi- ings were also supported by Sharma et al.[17] for Inconel
tion. Oxygen and the high carbon content from ionization 706 superalloy in WEDM. A thick recast layer was depos-
of dielectric besides base material were also observed on ited on the machined surface at higher discharge energy
the outer machining surface in EDS analysis. The deposi- compared to lower discharge energy.
tion of recast layer on the outer machining surface is
unfavorable to applications related to aerospace industries.
XRD phase analysis
So, this recast layer was significantly reduced at lower Es.
As can be seen in Fig. 10, a recast layer of lower thickness The XRD pattern of the outer machining surface at lower and
with less transfer of foreign atoms was formed on the higher Es is illustrated in Fig. 11(a-b), respectively. The surface
outer machining surface compared to higher Es. Similar after WEDM comprises the various compounds such as
observations were recorded by Bisaria and Shandilya[7] for Fe1.2Ni0.8, Fe1.5Ni0.5, Co0.06Fe0.94, and Alo.29Ni0.27Ti0.44 identi-
electrical discharge wire cutting of Ni-rich NiTi-shape fied through analysis of XRD peaks. The high reactivity of
memory alloy. It was noticed that a thick recast layer titanium and nickel are mainly accountable for the various
MATERIALS AND MANUFACTURING PROCESSES 7
Figure 7. 3D surface topography of machined surface at (a) lower Es (6.72 mJ) (b) higher Es (13.44 mJ).
Figure 8. Recast layer and elemental composition of machined surface at higher Es (13.44 mJ).
compounds formation. XRD pattern of machined surface noticed toward right side which shows the existence of resi-
divulges that the peak intensity has been decreased with the dual stress of tensile in nature within the surface after WEDM
increase in Es. This is due to fact that the crystal size of the of Nimonic C-263 superalloy. Similar observations are also
surface after WEDM has been reduced at higher Es; however, observed by Sharma et al.[17] for Inconel 706 in WEDM. The
crystal structure remains unchanged only orientation of pre- detail information of identified peaks in XRD pattern is given
ferred is changed. The shifting of peaks in XRD pattern is also in Table 5.
8 H. BISARIA AND P. SHANDILYA
Figure 10. Recast layer and elemental composition of machined surface at lower Es (6.72 mJ).
Figure 11. XRD peaks of machined surface at (a) lower Es and (b) higher Es.
Compound Ref Code Density (g/cm3) Crystal Structure Space group Lattice parameters
a/b/c (Å) α/β/ϒ (°)
Fe1.2Ni0.8 98–008-8175 8.02 Cubic Im-3m a = b = c = 2.869 α = β = ϒ = 90
Fe1.5Ni0.5 98–008-8167 7.69 Cubic Im-3m a = b = c = 2.868 α = β = ϒ = 90
Co0.06Fe0.94 98–009-9003 7.46 Cubic Fm-3m a = b = c = 3.618 α = β = ϒ = 90
Alo.29Ni0.27Ti0.44 98–011-7656 5.08 Hexagonal P63/mmc a = b = 5.013, α = β = 90
c = 8.073 ϒ = 120
Co0.06Fe0.94, and Alo.29Ni0.27Ti0.44 and also the existence [6] Sreenivasa, R. M.; Venkaiah, N. Parametric Optimization in
of tensile residual stress. Machining of Nimonic-263 Alloy using RSM and Particle
Swarm Optimization. Procedia Mater. Sci. 2015, 10, 70–79.
[7] Bisaria, H.; Shandilya, P. Experimental Studies on Electrical
Discharge Wire Cutting of Ni-rich NiTi Shape Memory Alloy.
Mater. Manuf. Processes 2017, 33(9), 977–985.
References [8] Pramanik, A.; Basak, A. K.; Dixit, A. R.; Chattopadhyaya, S. Processing
[1] Ezugwu, E. O.; Bonney, J.; Yamane, Y. An Overview of the of Duplex Stainless Steel by WEDM. Mater. Manuf. Processes 2018.
Machinability of Aeroengine Alloys. J. Mater. Process. Technol. doi:10.1080/10426914.2018.1453165
2003, 134, 233–253. [9] Naina, S. S.; Dixit, G.; Sanjeev, K. Performance Evaluation of the
[2] Ezilarasan, C.; Senthil, V. S. K.; Velayudham, A. An Experimental WEDM Process of Aeronautics Super Alloy. Mater. Manuf.
Analysis and Measurement of Process Performances in Machining Processes 2018. doi:10.1080/10426914.2018.1476761
of Nimonic C-263 Super Alloy. Measurement 2013, 46, 185–199. [10] Mussada, E. K.; Hua, C. C.; Rao, A. K. P. Surface Hardenability
[3] Mandal, A.; Dixit, A. R.; Das, A. K.; Mandal, N. Modeling and Studies of the Die Steel Machined by WEDM. Mater. Manuf.
Optimization of Machining Nimonic C-263 Super Alloy Using Processes 2018. doi:10.1080/10426914.2018.1476695
Multi-cut Strategy in WEDM. Mater. Manuf. Processes 2015, 31, [11] Bisaria, H.; Shandilya, P. The Machining Characteristics and
860–868. Surface Integrity of Ni-rich NiTi Shape Memory Alloy using
[4] Mandal, A.; Dixit, A. R.; Chattopadhaya, S.; Paramanik, A.; Hloch, Wire Electric Discharge Machining. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. C: J
S.; Krolczyk, G. Improvement of Surface Integrity of Nimonic Mechanical Engineering Science 2018. doi:10.1177/
C-263 Super Alloy Produced by WEDM Through Various Post- 0954406218763447
Processing Techniques. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 2017, 93, [12] Chaubey, S. K.; Jain, N. K. Investigations on Surface Quality of
433–443. WEDM-Manufactured Meso Bevel and Helical Gears. Mater.
[5] Ezugwu, E. O.; Okeke, C. I. Performance of PVD Coated Carbide Manuf. Processes 2017. doi:10.1080/10426914.2017.1415440
Inserts When Machining a Nimonic C-263 Alloy at High Speed [13] Shandilya, P.; Bisaria, H.; Jain, P. K. Parametric Study on Recast
Condition. Tribol. Trans. 2000, 43, 332–336. Layer During Electric Discharge Wire Cutting (EDWC) of Ni-rich
10 H. BISARIA AND P. SHANDILYA
NiTi shape memory alloy. J. Micro Manuf. 2018. doi:10.1177/ Processed Inconel 706 for Aircraft Application. J. Mater. Eng.
2516598418766934 Perform. 2013, 25, 3672–3681.
[14] Gostimirovic, M.; Kovac, P.; Sekulic, M.; Skoric, B. Influence of [18] Giridharan, A.; Samuel, G. L. Analysis on the effect of discharge
discharge energy on machining characteristics in EDM. J. Mech. Energy on Machining Characteristic of Wire Electrical Discharge
Sci. Technol. 2012, 26, 173–179. turning process. Proc. Inst. Mech. Eng. B 2015, 230, 2064–2081.
[15] Punturat, J.; Tangwarodomnukun, V.; Dumkum, C. Surface [19] Groover, M. P. Fundamentals of Modern Manufacturing:
Characteristics and Damage of Monoceystalline Silicon Induced Materials, Processes, and Systems, John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken,
by Wire-EDM. Appl. Surf. Sci. 2014, 320, 83–92. New Jersey, Unite State. 2007. 90–95. ISBN0-471-74485-9.
[16] Soni, H.; Narendranath, S.; Ramesh, M. R. Experimental [20] Sharma, P.; Chakradhar, D.; Narendranath, S. Analysis and
Investigation on Effect of Wire Electro Discharge Machining of Optimization of WEDM Performance Characteristic of Inconel
Ti50Ni45Co5 Shape Memory Alloys. Silicon 2018. doi:10.1007/ 706 for Aerospace Application. Silicon 2017, 10, 921–930.
s12633-018-9780-9 doi:10.1007/s12633-017-9549-6
[17] Sharma, P.; Chakradhar, D.; Narendranath, S. Effect of Wire [21] Ghosh, A.; Mallik, A. K.; Science, Manufacturing East-West, Press Pvt.
Material on Productivity and Surface Integrity of WEDM Ltd., New Delhi, India, 2010. 380–382. ISBN: 978-81-7671-063-3