Available online at www.sciencedirect.

com

ScienceDirect
Procedia Technology 19 (2015) 438 – 443

8G; "AG8EA4G<BA4? CBA98E8A68 "AG8E7<F6<C?<A4E<GL <A EA:<A88E<A:, "',E*-E' 2014, 9-10 (6GB58E
2014, ,<E:H-&HE8F, *B@4A<4

A ?BB> <AGB 8?86GE<6/;L5E<7 64EF 9EB@ 4A 86B?B:<64?

C8EFC86G<I8
AA7E84 AHEBE4 *46M4, "BAHR &HAG84A5◆, +8E:<H-D4A +G4A4
#
F#%5-48 0( M'%*#/+%#- E/)+/''2+/), !'%*/+%#- "/+6'23+48 0( C-5,.N#10%#, 103-105 M5/%++ B-6&, C-5,-N#10%#,400641, R0.#/+#
$
D'1#24.'/4 0( A540.#4+0/, !'%*/+%#- "/+6'23+48 0( C-5,.N#10%#, 26-28 G*. B#2+4+5 42., C-5,-N#10%#, 400027, R0.#/+#

Abstract

A JBE?7J<78 CEB5?8@ GB74L <F 8AI<EBA@8AG4? CB??HG<BA, E8FH?G<A: <A G;8 :E88A;BHF8 89986G, G;8E89BE8 G;8 4CC84E4A68 B9 86B-
9E<8A7?L 64EF <F 4 :E84G 58A89<G GB G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG. ,86;AB?B:L ;4F A88787 GB 8IB?I8 :E84G?L GB 58 45?8 GB CBJ8E
G;8F8
4HGB@B5<?8F BI8E ?BA: 7<FG4A68F 4A7 G;8 CEB68FF ;4F ABG 8A787 L8G. "A G;<F EHA 9BE 8IB?HG<BA 4A7 899<6<8A6L, G;8E8 4E8 4 ?BG B9
DH8FG<BAF G;4G FG<?? E8@4<A BC8A 4A7 BA8 B9 G;8@ <F J;4G ;4CC8AF 4G G;8 8A7 B9 G;8 ?<986L6?8 B9 4 54GG8EL 4A7 4A 8?86GE<6 @BGBE.
AF G;8 AH@58E B9 FB?7 8?86GE<6 64EF J<?? <A6E84F8, G;8 4@BHAG B9 8?86GE<6 @BGBEF 4A7 54GG8EL J4FG8 J<?? <A6E84F8 GBB G;HF ?847<A:
GB 4
:E84G8E <@C46G BA G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG. FBE G;<F E84FBA, <A G;<F C4C8E, J8 CE8F8AG 4?FB G;8 A8:4G<I8 <@C46G G;4G G;8 @8AG<BA87 J4FG8
J<?? ;4I8 BA G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG GB 46G 4F 4 @BG<I4G<BA 9BE @BE8 E8F84E6; <A G;<F 9<8?7.

©
N 2015
2014 The
,;8Authors.
AHG;BEF.Published
)H5?<F;87by5LElsevier
E?F8I<8ELtd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
%G7.
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
+8?86G<BA 4A7/BE C88E-E8I<8J HA78E E8FCBAF<5<?<GL B9 V)8GEH &4<BEW -A<I8EF<GL B9 ,<E:H-&HE8F, F46H?GL B9
Peer-review under responsibility of “Petru Maior” University of Tirgu Mures, Faculty of Engineering
K'8702&3 :E86L6?<A:, E8@4AH946GHE<A:, J4FG8 8?86GE<64? 4A7 8?86GEBA<6 8DH<C@8AG

1. Introd ction

!L5E<7 8?86GE<6 I8;<6?8F (!E.), <A<G<4??L FB?7 BA?L <AGEB7H687 <A 'BEG; A@8E<64A, EHEBC84A 4A7 #4C4A8F8
@4E>8GF <A G;8 F86BA7 ;4?9 B9 G;8 90UF, 4E8 ABJ FG4EG<A: GB :4<A @4E>8GF <A 78I8?BC<A: 4A7 GE47<G<BA4? 6BHAGE<8F,
<A6?H7<A: C;<A4 4A7 BE4M<? 213. AG G;<F @B@8AG, G;8 G86;AB?B:L G;4G <F <@C?8@8AG87 <A ;L5E<7 8?86GE<6 I8;<6?8
@4AH946GHE<A: <F FH99<6<8AG?L 78I8?BC87 9BE 4 JBE?7J<78 8KC4AF<BA.

◆CBEE8FCBA7<A: 4HG;BE. ,8?.: +40-264-202-437

E-.#+- #&&2'33:<BAHG.@HAG84A@4HG.HG6?H=.EB

2212-0173 © 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of “Petru Maior” University of Tirgu Mures, Faculty of Engineering
doi:10.1016/j.protcy.2015.02.062
 Andrea Aurora Racz et al. / Procedia Technology 19 (2015) 438 – 43
443

A ;L5E<7 8?86GE<6 I8;<6?8 64A 58 4?FB A4@87 86B-9E<8A7?L 64E 213. E6B-9E<8A7?L 6BA68CG 64EF EHA BA 8?86GE<6<GL BE
BA 4 6B@5<A4G<BA B9 8?86GE<6<GL 4A7 ;L7EB:8A 9H8?. BBG; GLC8F ?847 GB 4 E87H6G<BA <A GE4AFCBEG4G<BA 6BFGF J;<?8 4G
G;8 F4@8 G<@8 E87H6<A: G;8 C(2 8@<FF<BAF. /;<?8 E87H6<A: G;8 4@BHAG B9 9H8? 6BAFH@CG<BA 784?F 7<E86G?L J<G;
G;8 I8;<6?8UF 899<6<8A6L, G;8E8 4E8 BG;8E 6B@CBA8AGF G;4G @4L 64HF8 78?8G8E<BHF 89986GF <A G;8 ?BA:-G8E@. ,;8
54GG8EL 6B@CBA8AG <A G;8 GBC ;L5E<7 I8;<6?8F 4E8 GLC<64??L 6BI8E87 5L 4A 8<:;G L84E J4EE4AGL 4A7 6BAFH@8E J<?? ;
4I8 GB 784? J<G; G;8 E8C?468@8AG 4A7 7<FCBF4?. B864HF8 <G <F 4 LBHA: <A7HFGEL, G;<F FH5=86G ;4F ABG 6B@8 HC 4F 4A
<FFH8, 5HG 4F
;L5E<7F C8EI478 G;8 I8;<6H?4E <A7HFGEL 9HEG;8E 4A7 4:8, G;8F8 <FFH8F J<?? 58:<A GB 8@8E:8 4G G;8 9BE89EBAG 223.
(HE C4C8E J<?? 9B6HF BA 8?86GE<6/;L5E<7 64EF 9EB@ 4A 86B?B:<64? C8EFC86G<I8 J;8E8 ABG BA?L G;8 CBF<G<I8F J<?? 58
CE8F8AG87, 5HG 4?FB G;8 CEB5?8@F G;4G 4CC84E 4G G;8 8A7 B9 G;8 ?<98 B9 54GG8E<8F 4A7 8?86GE<6 @BGBEF 4A7 G;8 8K<FG8AG
FB?HG<BAF 4I4<?45?8.
,;8 C4C8E CE8F8AGF <A +86G<BA 2 4 78G4<?87 78F6E<CG<BA B9 8?86GE<6 4A7 ;L5E<7 4HGB@B5<?8F. "A +86G<BA 3 G;8 8?
86GE<6 @BGBEF GB:8G;8E J<G; G;8 @4<A 54GG8EL GLC8F HF87 GB74L <A <A7HFGEL 4E8 CE8F8AG87. +86G<BA 4 CE8F8AGF G;8 86B?
B:<64? C8EFC86G<I8 BA 8?86GE<6/;L5E<7 64EF 4A7 <A +86G<BA 5 G;8 6BA6?HF<BAF 4E8 7E4JA.

2. Electric/H"brid a tomobiles

2.1. E-'%42+% #540.0$+-'3

CHEE8AG?L, 8?86GE<6 4HGB@B5<?8F 4E8 6E84G87 5L HF<A: G;8 F4@8 6;4FF<F 4F :4FB?<A8 64EF, FB 9EB@ G;8 BHGF<78 <G <F
I8EL 7<99<6H?G GB 7<FG<A:H<F; 4A 8?86GE<6 64E 9EB@ 4 :4FB?<A8 64E. ,;8 BA?L G;<A: G;4G 6BH?7 <A7<64G8 G;4G G;8 I8;<6?8 <F
4A 8?86GE<6 64E <F G;8 ?BJ AB<F8 ?8I8? G;4G <G CEB7H68F. A F<@C?8 789<A<G<BA B9 4A 8?86GE<6 64E JBH?7 58: 4A 4HGB@B5<?8
J;BF8 :4FB?<A8 8A:<A8 J4F E8C?4687 5L 4A 8?86GE<6 @BGBE 223.
,;8 CBJ8E GE4AF@<GG87 GB G;8 @BGBE 6B@8F 9EB@ 4A 4EE4L B9 E86;4E:845?8 54GG8E<8F 4A7 <F E8:H?4G87
5L 4 6BAGEB??8E. ,;8 BC8E4G<A: CE<A6<C?8 B9 4A 8?86GE<6 64E <F 54F87 BA DC 6BAGEB??8EF G;4G G4>8 CBJ8E 9EB@ G;8
54GG8EL 4A7 @B7H?4G8 <G <A FH6; 4 @4AA8E G;4G G;8 @BGBE E868<I8F BA?L G;8 4@BHAG B9 CBJ8E G;4G <G E8DH<E8F. ,;8
G;EBGG?8 F<:A4? <F FHCC?<87 GB G;8 DC 6BAGEB??8E GB <A7<64G8 G;8 CBJ8E ?8I8? GB 58 F8AG GB G;8 @BGBE.
E?86GE<6 I8;<6?8F (E.F) 4E8 BA8 B9 G;8 @BFG CEB@<F<A: J4LF GB <A6E84F8 8A8E:L 899<6<8A6L 4A7 GB E87H68
:E88A;BHF8 :4F8F 4A7 <A 2012, 9EB@ 74G4 54F8F 6B??86G87 JBE?7J<78, G;8 C8E68AG4:8 B9 8?86GE<6 64EF C8E 6BHAGEL,
BHG B9 G;8 GBG4? AH@58E B9 4HGB@B5<?8F, <F G;8 9B??BJ<A::
• FE4A68 T 11%
• C;<A4 - 6,2%
• -$ T 4,4%
• D8A@4E> T 3,6%
• 8E@4AL T 3%
• #4C4A -2,4%
• )BEGH:4? T 1%
• "G4?L -0,9%
• "A7<4 T 0,8%
• '8G;8E?4A7F -0,7%
• +J878A -0,7%
• +C4<A -0,4%
• F<A?4A7 -0,1% 233.

2.2. H8$2+& #540.0$+-'3

AAL I8;<6?8 J<G; GJB FBHE68F B9 CBJ8E 64A 58 64??87 4 ;L5E<7 I8;<6?8 243.
!L5E<7 64EF :8G G;8<E CBJ8E 9EB@ GJB FBHE68F, 4 :4FB?<A8 8A:<A8 4A7 4A 8?86GE<6 @BGBE. !L5E<7 64EF 4E8 78F<:A87
G;4G <A FB@8 64F8F 5BG; CBJ8E FBHE68F 4E8 HF87 F<@H?G4A8BHF?L 4A7 <A BG;8EF G;8 FBHE68F 4E8 HF87 4?G8EA4G<I8?L. FBE
8K4@C?8, J;8A 4 ;L5E<7 64E EHAF 4G FC887F 58?BJ 5-10 >@/;, 8.:. J;8A 4CCEB46;<A: BE ?84I<A: 4 GE499<6 =HA6G<BA, <G
EHAF BA?L BA G;8 8?86GE<6 @BGBE, J;<6; E87H68F G;8 9H8? 6BAFH@CG<BA.
 "A ;L5E<7 64EF, G;8 8?86GE<6 @BGBE :8GF <GF CBJ8E 8<G;8E 9EB@ 54GG8E<8F, 54GG8E<8F G;4A 64A 58 E86;4E:87 J;<?8 G;8 64E
<F 5E4><A: (E8:8A8E4G<I8 5E4><A:), BE J;8A <7?<A:, 9EB@ 4A 8KG8EA4? CBJ8E FBHE68. AABG;8E E86;4E:<A: G86;A<DH8 <F
J;8A G;8 <AG8EA4? 6B@5HFG<BA 8A:<A8 <F 6BAA86G87 GB 4 :8A8E4GBE G;4G 7<E86G?L E86;4E:8F G;8 54GG8E<8F.
FBE ;L5E<7 64EF G;8E8 8K<FG GJB 7<998E8AG 78F<:A F6;8@8F BA ;BJ G;8 <AG8EA4? 6B@5HFG<BA 8A:<A8 4A7 G;8 8?86GE<6
@BGBE 4E8 6BAA86G87 253. ,;8 9<EFG F6;8@8 <F G;8 F8E<8F 6BAA86G<BA J;8E8 G;8 6B@5HFG<BA 8A:<A8 <F HF87 GB E86;4E:8
G;8 54GG8E<8F, G;8 8?86GE<6 @BGBE 58<A: <A 6;4E:8 B9 G;8 GE46G<BA. AABG;8E 6BAA86G<BA F6;8@8 <F G;8 C4E4??8?
6BAA86G<BA J;8E8 5BG; 8A:<A8F 4E8 HF87 GB CBJ8E G;8 64E, G;8 GBEDH8 B9 G;8 GJB 8A:<A8F 58<A: E8:H?4G87 5L 4
6BAGEB??8E.
!L5E<7 64EF 64A 58 64??87 @<?7 BE 9H?? ;L5E<7, G;8 7<998E8A68 58GJ88A G;8 GJB 6BAF<FGF <A ;BJ G;8 8?86GE<6 @BGBE
7E<I8F G;8 64E. "9 G;8 @BGBE 64A 7E<I8 G;8 64E J<G;BHG G;8 :4FB?<A8 8A:<A8, G;8A G;8 4HGB@B5<?8 <F 64??87 9H?? ;L5E<7,
4A7 <9 ABG G;8A G;8 4HGB@B5<?8 <F 64??87 @<?7 ;L5E<7 263.

2.3. C0.1#2+30/ $'47''/ '-'%42+% #/& *8$2+& %#23

BBG; 8?86GE<6 4A7 ;L5E<7 64EF 4E8 6BAF<78E87 GB 58 86B-9E<8A7?L, 5HG 4G G;8 F4@8 G<@8 G;8 9B??BJ<A: 7<998E8A68F
8K<FG:
"A ;L5E<7 64EF, G;8 64E5BA 7<BK<78 4A7 BG;8E ;4E@9H? 8@<FF<BAF 4E8 E87H687, E846;<A: M8EB <A 8?86GE<6 64EF 273.
,;8 ;L5E<7 64E <F DH<8G8E G;4A BA8 J<G; 4A <AG8EA4? 6B@5HFG<BA 8A:<A8, 8?86GE<6 64EF 58<A: 8I8A DH<8G8E 283.
,;8 54GG8EL G;4G CBJ8EF G;8 8?86GE<6 @BGBE 9EB@ 8?86GE<6 64EF A887 GB 58 E86;4E:87. ,;8 54GG8EL 9EB@ ;L5E<7 64EF
7B8F ABG A887 GB 58 E86;4E:87 5864HF8, <A @BFG 64F8F, <G E86;4E:8F 4HGB@4G<64??L J;8A G;8 64E <F <A HF8 293.

3. Electric motors and batteries sed in electric and h"brid cars

,;8 @4<A 6B@CBA8AGF <A 8?86GE<6 4A7 ;L5E<7 64EF G;4G ;4I8 588A @B7<9<87 <A 6B@C4E<FBA GB 4A <AG8EA4?
6B@5HFG<BA 8A:<A8 4E8 G;8 @BGBE 4A7 G;8 54GG8E<8F. '8KG, J8 J<?? 9B6HF A8KG BA G;8F8 GJB 8?8@8AGF 4A7 BA G;8<E
6;4E46G8E<FG<6F.

3.1. E-'%42+% .04023

,;8 8?86GE<6 @BGBEF 4E8 78I<68F G;4G 6BAI8EG 8?86GE<64? 8A8E:L <AGB @86;4A<64? 8A8E:L 4A7 4E8 C4EG B9 G;8 8?
86GE<64? FLFG8@ B9 4 64E, GJB GLC8F 58<A: 6HEE8AG?L <@C?8@8AG87 <A 4HGB@B5<?8F: 7<E86G 6HEE8AG (DC) @BGBEF BE 4?
G8EA4G<A: 6HEE8AG (AC) @BGBEF 2103.
,;8 8?86GE<6 @BGBE <A 6B@C4E<FBA J<G; <AG8EA4? 6B@5HFG<BA 8A:<A8F ;4F @BE8 47I4AG4:8F:
• %BJ <A<G<4? 6BFG TG;8 <A<G<4? 6BFG B9 4A 8?86GE<6 @BGBE <F 6BAF<78E45?L ?BJ8E G;4A 4 9BFF<?-9H8? 8A:<A8;
• %BA: ?<98 4A7 ?<GG?8 @4<AG8A4A68 E8DH<E87 T8?86GE<6 @BGBEF B998E BI8E 30.000 ;BHEF B9 BC8E4G<A: G<@8
J<G;BHG E8DH<E<A: @4=BE E8C4<EF;
• !<:; 899<6<8A6L T8?86GE<6 @BGBEF 4E8 ;<:;?L 899<6<8AG, J<G; 4 E4G<A: E4A:<A: 9EB@ 50% GB 95% ( 78C8A7<A: BA
G;8 F<M8 B9 G;8 @BGBE 4A7 G;8 BC8E4G<A: 6BA7<G<BAF);
• EAI<EBA@8AG4? F498GL T8?86GE<6 @BGBEF 8@<G ?<GG?8 GB AB AB<F8, E87H68 G;8 8@<FF<BAF B9 64E5BA 7<BK<78 4A7 BG;8E
;4E@9H? :4F8F G;HF, 7HE<A: G;8<E ?<98G<@8, ;4I<A: I8EL ?<GG?8 A8:4G<I8 89986G BA G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG;
• %45BHE 6BFG F4I<A:F T8?86GE<6 @BGBEF 4E8 F@4??8E 4A7 84F<8E GB 6BAGEB?, G;8 @4<AG8A4A68 58<A: 7BA8 DH<6>8E
4A7 84F<8E E8FH?G<A: <A ?BJ8E 6BFGF 223.
E?86GE<6 @BGBEF ;4I8 G;BH:; BA8 @4=BE 7<F47I4AG4:8: 78@4A7 6;4E:8F T HF<A: ;<:;-;BEF8CBJ8E @BGBEF
<A 4CC?<64G<BA 64A E8FH?GF <A 4 ;<:; 6BFG C8E ;BHE B9 BC8E4G<BA 223.
CHEE8AG?L, E8F84E6;8EF 4E8 78I8?BC<A: FB?HG<BAF 9BE E86L6?<A: 8?86GE<6 @BGBEF, 4A7 G;8L 4E8 9B6HF<A: BA
C8E@4A8AG @4:A8GF, J;<6; 6BAG4<A @4AL E4E8 84EG; 8?8@8AGF FH6; 4F '7, DL, ,5 4A7 )E. BH<?7<A: 4 6B@C46G 4A7 ?
<:;GJ8<:;G 8?86GE<6 @BGBE E8DH<E8F 4CCEBK<@4G8?L 30% B9 G;8 E4A:8 B9 E4E8 @8G4?F. "A G;8 6B@<A: L84EF, G;8
CEB7H6G<BA B9
8?86GE<6 4A7 ;L5E<7 64EF J<?? <A6E84F8, E8DH<E<A: G;8 78I8?BC@8AG, 9BE G;<F GLC8 B9 @BGBEF J<G; C8E@4A8AG @4:A8GF,
B9 A8J G86;AB?B:<8F <A BE78E GB E87H68 G;8 HF8 B9 E4J E4E8 84EG;F @8G4?F.
,;8 8?86GE<6 @BGBEF, 9BE 8?86GE<6 4A7 ;L5E<7 I8;<6?8F, 7B8F ABG A868FF4E<?L 6BAG4<A E4E8 84EG; @8G4?F, F8I8E4? GLC8F
B9 8?86GE<6 @BGBEF 5H<?G J<G;BHG C8E@4A8AGF @4:A8GF 58<A: <A HF8. ,;<F GLC8F B9 8?86GE<6 @BGBEF J<G;BHG @4:A8GF
4E8
6;84C8E, 4A7 4E8 :8A8E4??L AC @BGBEF, 9BE 8K4@C?8 G;8 ,8F?4 *B47FG8E <F 8DH<CC87 J<G; 4A 8?86GE<6 @BGBE J<G;BHG
E4E8 84EG; @8G4?F 2113.
A?G8EA4G<I8F, CEBCBF87 5L E8F84E6;8EF 9EB@ G;8 9<8?7 B9 8?86GE<6 @BGBEF E86L6?<A:, <A6?H78 G;8 E8@BI4? B9
@4:A8GF 9EB@ F6E4C @BGBEF, E8C4<E 4A7 FH5F8DH8AG E8HF8 B9 G;8 8?86GE<6 @BGBE BE <GF 6B@CBA8AGF 2143.
FBE G;8 @B@8AG, J;8A 4A 8?86GE<6 @BGBEF E846;8F G;8 8A7 B9 <GF ?<98 6L6?8, 49G8E 7<F@4AG?<A: 4A7 4A4?LM<A:, BA8
64A F4L <9 G;8 8?86GE<6 @BGBE 64A 58 E8C4<E87, FG4EG 4 A8J ?<98 6L6?8, BE E86L6?87 5L 6B@CBA8AGF.

3.2. B#44'2+'3

,;8 54GG8EL <F 4 78I<68 9BE FGBE<A: 6;8@<64? 8A8E:L 4A7 6BAI8EG<A: <G <AGB 8?86GE<6<GL. A?? 54GG8EL G86;AB?B:<8F
;4I8 GJB 9HA74@8AG4? 6;4E46G8E<FG<6F G;4G 49986G 54GG8EL, 78F<:A, CEB7H6G<BA, 6BFG B9 BC8E4G<A:, C8E9BE@4A68 4A7
7HE45<?<GL:
• )BJ8E 78AF<GL TG;8 4@BHAG B9 8A8E:L BI8E G;8 C8E<B7 B9 G<@8 <A J;<6; G;8 8A8E:L 64A 58 78?<I8E87 4A7
• EA8E:L 78AF<GL TG;8 4@BHAG B9 8A8E:L FGBE87 <A G;8 54GG8EL 2153.
B8GJ88A G;8F8 GJB 984GHE8F, G;8E8 <F HFH4??L 4 6B@CEB@<F8 GB 58 @478, FB@8 54GG8E<8F ;4I<A: ;<:;8E CBJ8E
78AF<GL 4A7 4 ?BJ8E 8A8E:L 78AF<GL 4A7 I<68 I8EF4.
EI8E F<A68 G;8 4CC84E4A68 B9 G;8 8?86GE<6 4A7 ;L5<E7 I8;<6?8F E8F84E6;8F ;4I8 588A @478 BA ;BJ GB <@CEBI8 G;8
E86;4E:8 6L6?8F, 7HE45<?<GL B9 G;8 54GG8E<8F 8G6. FBE 8K4@C?8, G;8 7HE45<?<GL <F BA8 B9 G;8 @BFG <@CBEG4AG
6;4E46G8E<FG<6F 4A7 <GUF E8CE8F8AG87 5L G;8 ?<98 6L6?8 B9 4 54GG8EL. ,;8 ?<98 6L6?8 B9 4 54GG8EL <F :<I8A 5L G;8 AH@58E
B9 6;4E:<A:T 7<F6;4E:<A: 6L6?8F. AABG;8E 946GBE G;4G 49986GF G;8 7HE45<?<GL B9 G;8 54GG8EL <F G;8 G8@C8E4GHE8, ?BJ BE
;<:; G8@C8E4GHE8F 49986G<A: FGEBA:?L G;8 ?<98 B9 4 54GG8EL.
AABG;8E 7E4J546> 9BE 54GG8E<8F <F G;8 A868FF4EL G<@8 GB E86;4E:8, 6HEE8AG?L 8K<FG<A: G;E88 6B@@BA E86;4E:<A:
@8G;B7F:
• CBA7H6G<I8 6;4E:<A: T G;8 6;4E:<A: CEB68FF <F F<@C?8, G;8 8?86GE<6 I8;<6?8 A887F GB 58 C?H::87 <AGB 4
FG4A74E7 13A FB6>8G J<G; 4 787<64G87 6<E6H<G 4A7 CEBG86G<I8 78I<68. "G <F 84FL 4A7 6BAI8A<8AG, 5HG <G G4>8F 4 ?
BA: G<@8, E4A:<A: 9EB@ 8 GB 10 ;BHEF 9BE 4 6B@C?8G8 6;4E:8;
• "A7H6G<I8 6;4E:<A: T 4 6;4E:<A: CEB68FF J<G;BHG G;8 A887 B9 4 645?8 6BAA86G<BA. ,;8 8A8E:L 9EB@ G;8 6;4E:8E 4A7
<F GE4AF@<GG87 GB G;8 I8;<6?8 G;EBH:; 4 @4:A8G<6 9<8?7 HF<A: ;<:; AC 6HEE8AG. ,;8 CEB68FF <F 6B@C?8K 4A7
8KC8AF<I8 5864HF8 B9 G;8 E8H<E87 8DH<C@8AG;
• B4GG8EL FJ4CC<A: T 4ABG;8E 6;4E:<A: CEB68FF G;4G 7B8FAUG E8DH<E8 645?8 6BAA86G<BA. !8E8, G;8 7<F6;4E:87
54GG8E<8F 4E8 E8C?4687 J<G; 9H??L 6;4E:87 BA8F, ;BJ8I8E G;8 HF8E 7B8F ABG BJA G;8 54GG8E<8F, 5HG C4LF 4 E8AG4?
988 2163.
• *8:4E7<A: G;8 54GG8EL GLC8F, G;8 @BFG 6B@@BA BA8F 4E8:
• %847-46<7 54GG8E<8F;
• '<6>8? @8G4? ;L5E<7 54GG8E<8F ( '<&! );
• %<G;<H@-<BA 54GG8E<8F ( %<-<BA ).
,;8 9<EFG E86;4E:845?8 54GG8E<8F J8E8 ?847-46<7 BA8F 4A7 J8E8 <AI8AG87 <A 1859 <A FE4A68. ,;8 ?847 46<7
54GG8E<8F 4E8 4 @4GHE8 <A7HFGE<4? CEB7H6G, J;<6; 4E8 CEB7H687 <A ?4E:8 IB?H@8F.
A 6B@@BA ?847 46<7 54GG8EL <F 4 @BAB-5?B6> 6BAFGEH6G<BA J<G; F<K 68??F, 846; 68?? 6BAG4<A<A: 19 8?86GEB78F G;4G
78?<I8E 4 AB@<A4? IB?G4:8 B9 12 IB?GF. ,;8 68?? 64C46<GL <F 75 A 4A7 846; 12 IB?G 54GG8EL @B7H?8 ;4F 4 AB@<A4?
8A8E:L B9 900 /; 2173.
DE..4F4AG $H@4E 9EB@ G;8 -A<I8EF<GL B9 C4@5E<7:8 ;4F 78I8?BC87 4 A8J CEB68FF GB E86L6?8 ?847-46<7 54GG8E<8F.
,;8 @8G;B7 6B@CE<F8F B9 7<FFB?I<A:, <A 4 ?846;<A:-CE86<C<G4G<BA CEB68FF, G;8 ?847-584E<A: 46G<I8 6B@CBA8AGF B9
54GG8EL C4FG8 <A 4A 4DH8BHF FB?HG<BA B9 64E5BKL?<6 46<7 4A7 CE86<C<G4G<A: 4 ?847 584E<A: BE:4A<6 CE86HEFBE. ,;8 ?847
BE:4A<6 CE86HEFBE <F 6BAI8EG87 5L 6B@5HFG<BA-64?6<A4G<BA GB ?847 @BABK<78 6BAG4<A<A: 4A 4@BHAG B9 @8G4??<6 ?847
4F 78F<E87 9BE 7<E86G 54GG8EL C4FG8 CE8C4E4G<BA. ,;8 BE:4A<6F 8@5B7<87 <A G;8 CE86HEFBE F8EI8 4F 9H8? 5L 6B@5HFG<BA
GB
4<7 64?6<A4G<BA. AAL E8F<7H4? ?847 FH?C;4G8 G;4G 8F64C8F 9<K<A: <A G;8 FB?HG<BA 7HE<A: ?846;<A: <F 4?FB HF87, 4F <G 64A
58 E86BI8E87 <A G;8 64?6<A87 ?847 CEB7H6G <A G;8 9BE@ B9 5<A78E 9BE G;8 CE8C4E4G<BA B9 G;8 CE86HEFBE 9BE @4><A: A8J
?847 46<7 54GG8E<8F 2183.
A GLC<64? '<6>8?-&8G4? 54GG8EL ;4F 4 90 GB 100 A; 68?? 64C46<GL J<G; 4 CE<F@4G<6 68?? 6BA9<:HE4G<BA.,;8 4I8E4:8
?<98G<@8 I4E<8F 9EB@ 2 HC GB 5T7 L84EF. A5BHG 65% B9 G;8 HF87 54GG8E<8F 4E8 ABG 7<FCBF87 B9 5HG >8CG 5L G;8 HF8E
(FB- 64??87 ;B4E7<A:) 2193. ,;<F <F 4 7<E86G 6BAF8DH8A68 B9 G;8 946G G;4G HF8EF 7B ABG E8:4E7 HF87 54GG8E<8F 4F
7<FCBF45?8.
 B864HF8 G;8 '<&! 54GG8E<8F 4E8 4 E8?4G<I8?L A8J CEB7H6G, E86L6?<A: G86;AB?B:<8F 4E8 FG<?? HA78E 78I8?BC@8AG.
,;8 @BFG 6B@@BA CEBCBF4? <F @478 9BE G;8 CLEB@8G4??HE:<64? E86L6?<A: B9 '<&!, @H6; E8F84E6; ;4I<A: 9B6HF87
BA G;8
;L7EB@8G4??HE:<64? GE84G@8AG 2193. ,;8 ;L7EB@8G4??HE:<64? CEB68FF8F 4E8 G;BH:; 7<99<6H?G GB CHG <AGB CE46G<68 7H8 GB
G;8<E ;<:; 6B@C?8K<GL.
-A9BEGHA4G8?L, ABA8 B9 G;8 CEBCBF87 E86L6?<A: CEB68FF8F 4E8 HF87 4G 4A <A7HFGE<4? F64?8, G;8 @BFG 6B@@BA
G86;AB?B:L GB E86L6?8 '<&! 54GG8E<8F <F GB HF8 G;8@ 4F 4 6;84C FBHE68 <A FG4<A?8FF FG88? CEB7H6G<BA 2193.
&BFG 64E @4AH946GHE8EF 4E8 FG<?? HF<A: A<6>8? @8G4? ;L7E<78 ('<&!) 54GG8E<8F, 5HG 5864HF8 G;8 ?<G;<H@-<BA
54GG8E<8F B998E 4 58GG8E C8E9BE@4A68, F@4??8E J8<:;G 4A7 ;<:;8E 68?? CBG8AG<4?, G;8 A<6>8? @8G4? ;L5E<7 54GG8E<8F 4E8
8KC86G87, <A G;8 A84E 9HGHE8, GB 58 E8C?4687 J<G; G;8 ?<G;<H@-<BA 54GG8E<8F 2203.
,;8 ?<G;<H@-<BA 54GG8E<8F J8E8 9<EFG 78I8?BC87 <A G;8 -A<G87 +G4G8F 4A7 EHEBC8, ;BJ8I8E #4C4A8F8 6B@C4A<8F
J8E8 G;8 9<EFG GB 6B@@8E6<4?<F8 G;8 54GG8E<8F <A G;8 84E?L 1990F. &4AH946GHE<A: @BI87 G;8A GB C;<A4 4A7 $BE84 <A
G;8 84E?L 2000F 4A7 4G G;8 8A7 B9 G;8 9<EFG 786478 B9 G;<F 68AGHEL FBHG;-84FG AF<4 J4F 7B@<A4G<A: G;8 @4AH946GHE<A:
B9 ?<G;<H@-<BA 54GG8E<8F, J<G; 98% B9 G;8 :?B54? CEB7H6G<BA. ,B74L, G;8 -A<G87 +G4G8F 4E8 <AI8FG<A: <A 6E84G<A: ?B64?
CEB7H6G<BA F<G8F 9BE ?<G;<H@-<BA 54GG8E<8F, J;<?8 AF<4A 6B@C4A<8F FGE<I8 GB 64CGHE8 G;8 @4E>8G 9BE 8?86GE<6 I8;<6?8F
2213.
,;8 E86L6?<A: CEB68FF <A G;8 ?<G;<H@-<BA 54GG8E<8F 6BAF<FG <A 4 @86;4A<64? CEB68FF<A: J;8E8 G;8 54GG8E<8F 4E8
6EHF;87 <A 4 C(2 8AI<EBA@8AG, FB G;8 IB?4G<?8 BE:4A<6 8?86GEB?LG8 8I4CBE4G8F 4A7 <F 6B??86G87 4F ABA-HF45?8
6BA78AF4G8. A FH5F8DH8AG @4G8E<4? F8C4E4G<BA <F 7BA8 J<G; G;8 7<998E8AG @4G8E<4? 9E46G<BAF 58<A: FB?7 4F 9887FGB6>
9BE BG;8E CEB68FF8F.
(E<:<A4??L, G;8 ;L7EB@8G4??HE:<64? ,BK6B (E86L6?<A: @8G;B7) CEB68FF J4F 78I8?BC87 9BE G;8 F498 E86L6?<A: B9
HF87 ?<G;<H@-<BA CE<@4EL 54GG8E<8F. ,B74LUF 946<?<GL CEB68FF8F HF87 ?<G;<H@-<BA F86BA74EL 54GG8E<8F 4F J8??.
"9 A868FF4EL, G;8 54GG8E<8F 4E8 GE84G87 5L ,BK6BUF (E86L6?<A: @8G;B7) C4G8AG87 6ELB:8A<6 CEB68FF, <.8. G;8L 4E8 6BB?
87 GB 45BHG Y200 OC. %<G;<H@, 4?G;BH:; ABE@4??L 8KC?BF<I8?L E846G<I8 4G EBB@ G8@C8E4GHE8, 58;4I8F 4?@BFG <A8EG
4G I8EL ?BJ G8@C8E4GHE8F. ,;8 54GG8E<8F 4E8 G;8A F498?L F;E87787 4A7 G;8 @4G8E<4?F F8C4E4G87. ,;8 ?<G;<H@
6B@CBA8AGF 4E8 F8C4E4G87 4A7 6BAI8EG87 GB ?<G;<H@ 64E5BA4G8 9BE E8F4?8. "9 G;8 54GG8E<8F 6BAG4<A 6B54?G, G;8A G;<F
6B@CBA8AG <F 4?FB E86BI8E87 9BE CEB7H6G<BA B9 %<CB(2 4F A8J 54GG8EL 8?86GEB78 @4G8E<4? 2223.

4. Ecological perspecti!e

,;8 5<::8FG 6;4A:8 G;4G ;4F 588A 5EBH:;G 5L G;8F8 86B-9E<8A7?L 64EF J4F G;8 AB<F8 E87H6G<BA 4A7 4 ?8FF8A<A: B9
G;8 4<E CB??HG<BA 5L E87H6<A: G;8 64E5BA 7<BK<78 4A7 BG;8E ;4E@9H? 8@<FF<BAF 2233. ,;8 A8J 6BA68CG B9 86B-9E<8A7?L
64E <F 4 :BB7 FG4EG 9BE 4 ;84?G;<8E 8AI<EBA@8AG, 5HG 4G G;8 F4@8 G<@8 @BE8 4GG8AG<BA A887F GB 58 C4<7 GB G;8 E86L6?
<A: CEB68FF 5864HF8 G;8 58A89<GF B9 8?86GE<64? 54GG8E<8F 4E8 4?J4LF @8AG<BA87, ;BJ8I8E G;8 A8:4G<I8 89986G
B9 G;8 E86L6?<A: CEB68FF <F B9G8A F><CC87.
FEB@ @4AL FGH7<8F, <G E8FH?GF G;4G HAG<? 2020, <A -+ 4?BA8, 4EBHA7 6 @<??<BA 8?86GE<6 I8;<6?8F 6BH?7 58 FB?7, G;8
AH@58E E4<F<A: GB 11 @<??<BA JBE?7J<78 2243. "9 G;8 AH@58EF B9 8?86GE<6 I8;<6?8F J<?? 9B??BJ G;8 8FG<@4G87 9<:HE8F,
G;8A 4 J8??-789<A87 8A7 B9 ?<98 FGE4G8:L 9BE G;8 8?86GE<6 8A:<A8 4A7 54GG8E<8F E8@BI87 9EB@ 8?86GE<6 I8;<6?8F <F
E8DH<E87. (A?L 49G8EJ4E7F 64A G;8 4HGB <A7HFGEL 58 64??87 4A 8AI<EBA@8AG4? 9E<8A7?L <A7HFGEL 2243.
,;8 9<EFG FG8C <A 78I8?BC<A: J8??-789<A87 8A7 B9 ?<98 FGE4G8:<8F 9BE 54GG8E<8F <F G;8 A868FF<GL GB >ABJ
G;8<E 6B@CBF<G<BA <A BE78E GB 6;BBF8 G;8 6BEE86G E86L6?<A: CEB68FF. BL E86L6?<A: G;8@, 30 % B9 G;8 8A8E:L
64A 58 E86BI8E87. A :8A8E4?<M87 E86L6?<A: CEB68FF 9BE 54GG8E<8F HF8F J4G8E 4A7 8A8E:L GB F8C4E4G8 G;8 J4FG8F 9EB@
I<45?8 FH5FG4A68F.
A9G8E G;8 E86L6?<A: B9 1 >: 8?86GE<6 54GG8EL, G;8 FH5FG4A68F G;4G 4E8 E8?84F87 <A FB?<7F, J4G8E 4A7 4<E
4E8 4CCEB46;<A::
• 0,24 >: F?4: 4A7 30 : GBK<6F GB FB?<7;
• < 0,1 >: +5, !:, '<, )5, C7 GB J4G8E;
• < 5 : )5, C7, CH, 1H, AF, '< GB 4<E 2253.
,;8 E86L6?<A: CEB68FF <F G;HF ;4E@9H? 8FC86<4??L 9BE G;8 C8BC?8 J;B 4E8 JBE><A: <A G;8 E86L6?<A: CEB68FF
?45BE4GBEL 5864HF8, 9BE 8K4@C?8, @8E6HEL 64A 58 45FBE587 G;EBH:; G;8 F><A BG;8E ;4E@9H? GBK<AF 64A 58 <A;4?87 BE
<A:8FG87.
 (A8 64A F4L G;4G G;8 E86L6?<A: CEB68FF 64A 58 4 74A:8EBHF CEB68FF 9BE ;H@4AF 4A7 G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG <9 G;8 6BEE86G
FGE4G8:<8F 4E8 ABG CEBC8E?L 4CC?<87 2263.

5. Concl sions

CBA68EAF 45BHG G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG 4A7 E<F<A: 6BFGF B9 9BFF<? 9H8?F 4E8 7E<I<A: 4HGB@4>8EF GB 78F<:A 4A7 5H<?7 6?
84A8E, @BE8 8A8E:L 899<6<8AG I8;<6?8F, E8CE8F8AG87 8FC86<4??L 5L ;L5E<7 4A7 8?86GE<6 I8;<6?8F. ,;<F E87H68F G;8 C(2
8@<FF<BAF 4A7 BG;8E ;4E@9H? 8@<FF<BAF G;HF ;4I<A: 4 ?BJ8E <@C46G BA G;8 8AI<EBA@8AG.
,;8 @4<A 7E4J546> <F G;8 8A8E:L FBHE68: G;8 54GG8E<8F. *4E8 84EG; 8?8@8AGF 4E8 4I4<?45?8 <A ?<@<G87 DH4AG<G<8F 4A7
8KC8AF<I8, G;8E89BE8 E8F84E6;8EF 4E8 78I8?BC<A: FB?HG<BAF 9BE 8KGE46G<A: 4F @H6; 4F CBFF<5?8 9EB@ 7<F64E787
54GG8E<8F. -A9BEGHA4G8?L, ABA8 B9 G;8 CEBCBF87 FB?HG<BAF <F HF87 4G 4A 8KG8AF<I8 ?8I8?. B4F87 BA G;8<E CBG8AG<4?,
G;BH:;, G;8 G<@8 HAG<? G;8L E846; <A7HFGEL F64?8 <F ABG 94E 4J4L.

References

213 *B5 78 #BA:, &4K P;@4A, *B:<8E =46B5F, E?<F4 DH@<GE8F6H. !L5E<7 E?86GE<6 .8;<6?8F. '4<EB5<, $8AL4. -A<G87 '4G<BAF EAI<EBA@8AG
)EB:E4@@8. 2009
223 !88=4L $<A:. AA 4A4?LF<F B9 ;L5E<78-8?86GE<6 I8;<6?8F 4F G;8 64E B9 G;8 9HGHE8. &4FF46;HF8GGF "AFG<GHG8 B9 ,86;AB?B:L. &4FF46;HF8GGF. 2007.
233 ,4?< ,E<::, )4H? ,8??8A. ?B54? EI (HG?BB> "A<G<4G<I8. ,;8 E?86GE<6 .8;<6?8F. +<@<?4E B?H8. 2013
243 !4AGH?4, *<6;4E7. !BJ 7B ;L5E<7F 64E JBE>. '8J 0BE>. C;8?F84 !BHF8 )H5?<F;8EF. 2010.
253 *HCE8>;4 BE4;@46;4E<. !L5E<7 64EF. "AFG<GHG8 B9 ,86;AB?B:L. *BBE>88, "A7<4. 2010.
263 DBH54, &<>8, &47<FBA. EA:<A8, 78F<:A, F<M<A: 4A7 BC8E4G<BA <A ;L5E<7. &47<FBA, /<F6BAF<A, +-A. 2011.
273 EBHC AEA EA8E:L&EAI<EBA@8AG. !L5E<7 8?86GE<6 4A7 54GG8EL 8?86GE<6 I8;<6?8F. ,86;AB?B:<8F, 6BFGF 4A7 58A89<GF. DH5?<A, "E8?4A7. 2007.
283 E7J<A .8E;8H=8A, #4A #4558A. E9986G B9 8?86GE<6 64EF BA GE499<6 AB<F8 4A7 F498GL. '4G<BA4? "AFG<GHG8 9BE )H5?<6 !84?G; 4A7 G;8 EAI<EBA@8AG.
B<?G;BI8A, '8G;8E?4A7F. 2010.
293 '4G<BA4? "AFG<GHG8 B9 +HFG4<A45?8 EA8E:L. !L5E<7 E?86GE<6 4A7 B4GG8EL E?86GE<6 .8;<6?8F. DH5?<A, "E8?4A7. 2007.
2103 -A<I8EF<GL B9 &BE4GHJ4. E?86GE<6 7E<I8EF. &BE4GHJ4. 2008
2113 ,;8 E?86GE<6 CB@C4AL. E? )4FB E?86GE<6. 2(A?<A83 ;GGC://603.4CB:88.A8G.
2123 E6>4E7 !8?@8EF, )4GE<6> &4EK. E?86GE<6 64EF G86;A<64? 6;4E46G8E<FG<6F 4A7 8AI<EBA@8AG4? <@C46GF. EAI<EBA@8AG4? +6<8A68 EHEBC8. 2012.
2133 +<8@8AF. *86L6?<A: 8?86GE<6 @BGBEF 4F FBHE68 B9 E4J @4G8E<4?F. 2011.
2143 C4A<F, B<??. B4GG8EL @4AH946GHE<A: 9BE ;L5E<7 4A7 8?86GE<6 I8;<6?8F: )B?<6L <FFH8F. CBA:E8FF<BA4? E8F84E6; F8EI<68. 2013.
2153 C%) (A?<A8. /85 F<G8. 2(A?<A83 !BA: $BA: %<@<G87, 2013. ;GGCF://JJJ.6?CBA?<A8.6B@.
2163 %<C@4A, ,<@BG;L,. ,;8 6BFG B9 @4AH946GHE<A: 8?86GE<6 I8;<6?8 54GG8E<8F. "AFG<GHG8 B9 ,E4AFCBEG4G<BA FGH7<8F CH5?<64G<BAF. C4?<9BEA<4. 1999.
2173 .4F4AG $H@4E, #<>4H4A 04A:, +8E89 +BA@8M. *8?8I4A68 B9 E846G<BA B9 ?847 6B@CBHA7F J<G; 64E5BKL?<6 46<7 <A ?847 E86BI8EL 9EB@ F86BA74EL
7BHE68F. C4@5E<7:8, -$. 2013
2183 ,B5<4F &H??8E, BE8A7 FE<87E<6;. D8I8?BC@8AG B9 4 E86L6?<A: CEB68FF 9BE A<6>8?-@8G4? ;L7E<78 54GG8E<8F. A46;8A, 8E@4AL. 2005.
2193 E>8E@B .<>GBE. *86L6?<A: BCCBEGHA<G<8F 9BE %<-BA 54GG8E<8F 9EB@ ;L5E<78 I8;<6?8F. C;4?@8EF -A<I8EF<GL B9 ,86;AB?B:L. BG85BE:, +J878A.
2005.
2203 $4F4G?L, +;8E<9. ,;8 %<G;<H@ "BA 54GG8EL 9BE 8?86GE<6 I8;<6?8F. "AFG<GHG8 B9 ,86;AB?B:L 9EB@ &4FF46;HF8GGF. &4FF46;HF8GGF. 2010.
2213 ,. 8BE:<0&4F6;?8E4, B. FE<87E<6;4. *. /8L;85. D8I8?BC@8AG B9 4 E86L6?<A: CEB68FF 9BE %<-<BA 54GG8E<8F. A46;8A. 8E@4AL. 2012.
2223 *4@BA<, &BAFHEH (?4?8>4A. EA7 B9 ?<98 <FFH8F 4A7 BCG<BAF 9BE I8;<6?8 54GG8E<8F. C?84A ,86;AB?B:L EAI<EBA@8AG. B8E?<A, 8E@4AL. 2013.
2233 #.%. +H??<I4A, %. 4<A8F. A E8I<8J B9 54GG8EL ?<98 6L6?8 4A4?LF<F. EE:BAA8 '4G<BA4? %45BE4GBEL. C;<64:B. 2010.
2243 &4?4I<>4, C. *.)4?B A?GB. EAI<EBA@8AG4? E9986GF 4FFB6<4G87 J<G; 54GG8EL 7<FCBF4?. C;<64:B. 2004.
2253 "AFG<GHG8 B9 E?86GE<6 )BJ8E *8F84E6;. EAI<EBA@8AG4? AFF8FF@8AG B9 C?H:-<A. C4?<9BEA<4. 2007.