Professional Documents
Culture Documents
[Research project]
[Student Name]
[University Name]
[Date]
Research project i
a) Research Proposal
Title
The quality of services delivered holds substantial importance in the health care sector as these
services can directly influence the physical and psychological health of the patients as well as
their family members. But when it comes to delivering the health care services to those with the
disabilities, there are many barriers and inevitable challenges. Giving the quality treatment to
those living with communication disabilities has gained substantial global attention of the
practitioners and the researchers over the last decade because the patients suffering with such
disabilities are more vulnerable to the poor quality of care. These patients cannot effectively
communicate their condition nor they can effectively take the instructions by the health care
service providers such as doctors, nurses etc. Another reason why this area of study has been
given substantial attention is that in year 2013, a report revealed that about thousand and two
hundred patients who had the communication disabilities died due to the causes which could
have been prevented. It has been shared that such incidents were the result of the negligence and
There are many reasons why the communication problems between the health care service
providers and the patients of communication disabilities are occurring and the major problems
include the lack of argumentative and alternative communication skills, ineffective education of
the nurses, lack of post graduate education and ineffectiveness in training system (Hemsley,
Balandin, and Worrall, 2012; Nouwens, van Lieshout, Bouma, Braspenning, and Wensing,
2014; Tay, Ang, and Hegney, 2012). Health care service providers are having adverse attitude
towards the patients having communication disabilities resulting from the lack of additional
incentives offered to them. The health care service providers are not motivated enough to deliver
the care required by the patients with such sensitivities and disabilities. It is important to take
under consideration that, health care organizations’ decisions and HR initiatives tend to have
direct and significantly impact on motivating the medical and caregiver staff to serve the patients
with disabilities with additional care and attention (de Bruin, Baan, and Struijs, 2011).
The underlying study is based on a problem that whether the organizational initiatives to use the
incentive or pay of performance can have any positive influence on the quality of care delivered
Research question
Research hypothesis
Research project iv
Use of Pay for performance strategy can improve the motivation of health care service providers
and can improve the quality of care provided to patients with communication disabilities.
Aim
To reveal the relationship between the health care organizations’ Pay for performance initiative
Objectives
To discuss the role of health care organizations’ HR strategies in the quality of care
To reveal the relationship between Pay for performance initiative and improved
To examine how pay for performance strategy can improve the motivation of health
Research methodology
Research design
The research deigns is the collection of strategies and methodologies which are collectively
applied for attaining the research aim and to answer the research questions. The three main types
of research deigns includes descriptive, casual and exploratory research designs. Based on the
Research project v
nature of the research topic under discussion, the underling study plans to use the descriptive
Research approach
There are two research approaches including the inductive and deductive research approaches.
The inductive research is used when the underlying study aims to prove the new theories and
new ideas and is conducted at a very large scale (Denscombe, 2009). On the other hand, the
deductive research is conducted when the study plans to prove the existing ideas, concepts and
theories. As the underlying study plans to critically examine the existing literature, compare and
contrast the ideas and prove the existing studies, this study will incorporate the deductive
Research choice
The three research choices include the qualitative, quantitative and mixed research choices. The
qualitative research allows the detailed and comprehensive analysis, whereas the quantitative
research allows the decision making on the basis of factual information and statistical evidences
(Jankowicz, 2005; Maylor, and Blackman, 2005). On the other hand, the mixed approach is
based on the combine use of qualitative and quantitative data. The mixed approach is most useful
as it can deliver the benefits of both qualitative and quantitative studies and can prevent many
discrepancies. The underlying study will incorporate the mixed approach where both qualitative
and quantitative data will be incorporated to examine the phenomenon in detail, but the
qualitative and quantitative data will be gathered from only the secondary sources (Ketchen and
Bergh, 2006).
Research project vi
The research data will be collected only from the secondary sources and no primary data will be
collected due to the nature of the study. This research requires the detailed examination and
analysis due to which the secondary sources will be used and contradictory and critical analysis
will be done (Scruggs, and Mastropieri, 2006; Saunders, Saunders, Lewis, and Thornhill, 2011).
This secondary data will be collected from the authentic sources such as the Books Published
journal articles, and authentic web sources (Ketchen and Bergh, 2006).
Data analysis
A critical and comprehensive literature review will be conducted, which will be based on
comparative analysis of the some contradictory and some similar perspectives and ideas shared
by the other studies that have examined the similar research topics. After the detailed analysis a
Ethical considerations
The study is based on collecting and analysing the secondary data, so in order to prevent
the intellectual property theft, the study will incorporate the proper in-text citations and a
detailed bibliography will be given at the end of the report (Beri, 2013).
The study will critically discuss the ideas shared by the alternative studies but during the
The personal bias will be avoided during the comparative analysis of the ideas.
It will be ensured that the data collected for the underlying research will be used only for
b) Literature Review
The underlying research aims to reveal relationship between health care organizations’ Pay-for-
performance strategy and quality of the health care services delivered to patients with
communication disabilities. In this regard, various qualitative and quantitative studies are to be
A relevant study can be incorporated which has revealed that the incentives for the better
performance can boost the quality of health care and it can be done by the use of various
methods and modes. It has been explained that incentives are designed for the purpose of
motivating and encouraging the health care staff to perform well and to improve their medical
outcomes. These incentives could be both non-monetary and monetary incentives and a proper
Pay for Performance system can be applied to gain the desired results. It has been further
elaborated that when health care service providers’ performances are compared against the
performed indicators, their high performance outcomes are rewarded. The goal behind this
practice is to encourage the medical staff to live up to the expectations and the predetermined
standards. The monetary and non-monetary rewards boost the willingness of the medical staff to
deliver the excellent quality services which can prevent the mistakes and can make patients of
communication disabilities and their families satisfied (Abduljawad, and Al-Assaf, 2011).
A study conducted in 2005 has proposed that 75% of the American companies are using the Pay-
for-Performance technique to boost the performance and when it comes to the health care sector
the same payment system is used but it is having some drawbacks. It has been elaborated that
despite the use of Pay for Performance, the medical outcomes are not improving because the care
Research project viii
providers are rewarded for the quantity of services instead of the quality of services. Due to
increased workloads the medical service providers lack the time and that lack of time
compromises the quality of service delivered to the disabled patients as they require additional
time for better care. The study has not only criticized the current problems in the American
health care sector and poor quality of care due to the ineffective use of Pay for Performance
system but has also proposed some suggestions. It has been added that a system based on proper
measures, guidelines and quality focused Key performance indicators (KPI) must be used
Another broader study can be incorporated which has not focused on both normal or disabled
patients but has provided an overall aspects regarding the impact of incentive pay system on the
quality of medical care delivered by medical service providers such as nurses etc. This study
holds substantial importance as it has based the argument on the primary data. The research has
examined the data shared by 613 hospitals and has revealed that those hospitals which used the
Pay for Performance system significantly improved the quality of health care in chronic, acute
and primary care. This study has examined the performance of hospitals over the period of 2
years and has revealed that hospitals which were engaged in utilizing the pay for performance
attained greater improvements into the quality of care and incentives stimulated the
improvements and the programs used by the hospitals out weighted their costs. The findings of
this study can support the research hypothesis as it has clearly revealed the importance of using
pay for perfromnce for improving the quality of care (Lindenauer, Remus , Roman, Rothberg ,
To analyze and anticipate the impact of Pay for performance strategy on the communication and
interaction between health care service providers and patients with communication disabilities,
Research project ix
some more relevant studies can be incorporated which have focused on analyzing the impact of
Aghabarari, Shiri, Karimi, and Samami, 2016). One of the relevant studies was conducted in
2011 which has proposed some very interesting and important ideas. It has been claimed that
Pay for Performance helps in improving the disease management system and improves entire
health care system. It can motivate the medical service provider to serve patients in most
effective manner as it offers incentives and payments. This relevant study has argued that
payment model holds substantial importance in improvement of health care because the financial
incentives leave direct and significant impact on the performance outcomes of nurses as well as
other medical staff members. It has been further explained that additional or in some cases
reduced payments are paid to nurses based on their performance outcomes that plays a central
role improving communication and it reflects that it can facilitate those with communication
disabilities to gain the best care (de Bruin, Baan, and Struijs, 2011).
The underlying literature review has adopted a critical and comprehensive approach of exploring
the phenomenon under discussion. Various studies based on both qualitative and quantitative
data have been incorporated and multiple aspects have been studied that have helped in
examining the influence of the health care organizations’ pay for performance initiative on the
quality of care delivered to the patients having communication disabilities. After the detailed
analysis, several implications have been revealed but there are still some gaps into the literature
which can be addressed by conducting primary research and its analysis in the future studies.
a) A record
Research project x
The following Gantt chart is representing a record of the tasks preformed in the 6 weeks in which the
Background
information
research
Identification of
research problem
Writing Research
questions
Writing research
hypothesis
Writing research
aim and
objectives
Literature review
Literature review
Application of
research
methodology
Complete
compliance with
Research project xi
Ethical
considerations
Data Analysis
Conclusion and
recommendations
Week 1 and 2:
In the first week of the project the background information was researched, research problem
statement was written and the research questions were formed. The main theme which was
selected to be analysed was the health care for those living with disability and long term
influence on the health care quality in association with which, the topic for the underlying
research was selected. This research has focused on analysing the influence of the health care
organizations’ pay for performance strategy on the quality of care delivered to those with the
communication disabilities. The area of disability and long term condition is quite broad and to
narrow down the research area, only those with communication disabilities have been selected
for the analysis as the communication disability directly influence the ability to receive the
quality care as the patients lacks the ability to share what they feel, and face difficulties in
understanding the communication by the health care service providers due to which the risk of
the ineffective care increases. After spending lot of time on selecting the most suitable and more
Research project xii
interesting area of study, a research problem was identified and relevant research questions were
In the second week the clear hypothesis was identified which is based on an idea that when pay
for performance initiatives are used, they motivate the health care providers to serve well and
enable them to deliver the quality care to those who need additional care and attention. After
setting a hypothesis the next initiative was the research aim and objectives. In this week, many
problems were encountered because it was difficult to breakdown the core research area into
different parts and to set some specific, measurable, attainable, realistic and timely objectives.
Week 3 and 4:
In week 3 and 4 comprehensive literature review was conducted and no other parts of the
research were covered. The literature review was given substantial importance because the study
was entirely based on the secondary data analysis, and critically and comprehensively analysing
the ideas and most relevant information held substantial importance to reach a conclusion. In the
beginning, the literature review was quite challenging as it was hard to identify only authentic
sources of information. The topic of the impact on pay for performance on health care was easy
to research as there were many studies available on it, but when it came to analyze the impact on
the health care of patients with communication disabilities, it was challenging to find out the
relevant studies. There were very few studies that particularly focused on impact of Pay for
Performance on improving the quality of care delivered to patients suffering with the
communication disabilities. After a few days, a systematic approach was adopted and the
literature review was completed. In middle of the week 4, I started working on the research
methodology and decided the suitable research deigns, research approach and research choice.
Research project xiii
When deciding the suitable methodology, I faced some confusions due tow which I consulted the
instructor and also discussed with fellows because any mistake in selecting the methodology
Week 5 and 6:
After identifying the research design of descriptive research, a deductive approach and mixed
research choice, in week 5 the data collection and analysis were made. In the beginning I decided
to use the primary and secondary data together to gain detailed understanding into the
phenomenon. But it was challenging and almost impossible to get the first hand data from the
nurses or health care service providers or the patients with the communication defects in the
given time period. In addition to this, the topic under discussion was a significantly broad topic,
and the primary outcomes gathered from few research respondents were not likely to represent
such a large population. So I decided to use only secondary data and to adopt a comparative
analysis and discussion method to compare and contrast the alternative ideas and perspectives.
After analysing the data in the 6th week, I started working on forming a conclusion by
considering answers for predetermined research question and the attainment of research
objectives. And by the end of the 6th week, a dependable conclusion was formed and the future
Chapter 3: Analysis
In the proposal the comprehensive and comparative literature review, analysis and discussion of
findings have been proposed as the evaluation techniques. These evaluation techniques are
Research project xiv
significantly relevant and useful because no primary data has been collected and the study was
based on only the secondary data. When it comes to the secondary data analysis, the best
technique is the comparative and critical review of the literature to reveal the useful information
and gather the dependable findings. The study aimed to analyse and reveal the impact of the
health care organizations’ pay of performance initiative on the quality of care delivered to the
patients with communication disabilities. The hypothesis was set that using the Pay for
Performance by health care organizations positively influence the quality of care for those with
communication disabilities. Based on the nature of the hypothesis that is to be provided true or
false, the secondary data analysis with the comparative evaluation of the findings with discussion
and analysis was the most suitable method. This was a very broad topic and required
comprehensive analysis and discussion before proposing any conclusion, so collection of data
from a small sample could have comprised the dependable conclusion, so the selected approach
The discussion and analysis techniques can be applied to interpret and to analyse the data and
result collected during the literature review to form a dependable conclusion. Lindenauer, Remus
, Roman, Rothberg , Benjamin, Ma, and Bratzler’s study holds more importance into the study as
this study has incorporated the primary data directly collected from the hospitals. After the
detailed analysis the study has revealed that those hospitals which were using the Pay for
Performance had more accurate medical results as compared to those which were not using it.
This idea is somewhat similar to the study shared by O'Halloran, Grohn, and Worrall but the key
differentiation is that it has provided a broader perspective and has focused on chronic, acute as
well as primary care. The type of plans which are referred by this study are very relevant to pay
Research project xv
for performance plans and according to which, it can directly improve quality of the health care
delivered for those who are having some sort of disability in their communication. De Bruin,
Baan, and Struijs also suggested similar idea but their study has made a different claim as well as
it has proposed that payments are determined based on the performance of health care service
providers and the financial motivator helps in shaping the service providers’ behaviour and
attitude towards the disabled patients. On the whole, it has shared that Pay for Performance
improves disease management system and holds the ability to encourage improvements so that
patients could be effectively and efficiently served in the highly effective and efficient manner
due to the incentives and payments offered to them. It is a Pay for Performance system that is
based on proper measures and software and sets the clear goals due to which nurses could be
bund to live up to standards so that they could be remunerated accordingly. It helps in analyzing
the medical staff’s performance in a timely manner and its quantifiable measures can
substantially improve quality of care and in quantifying performance outcomes through the use
of Key performance indicators (KPIs). The payments are to be determined on the basis of
performance and financial motivator shapes the service providers’ attitude. In addition to this,
examination of many other studies in the literature review has revealed that pay for performance
and incentive systems can also play part in improving disease management system and can
encourage improvements to attain high effectiveness and efficiency which can lead to
disabilities.
The study has analysed how pay for performance initiative used by health are organizations can
improve health care service delivered to patients with communication disabilities. This study has
Research project xvi
revealed some useful implications which can help the academic researchers and analysts to gain
substantial information from various perspectives and help the health care institutions in
adopting the pay for performance system as a solution for such communication problems.
Massive number of patients having communication disability have died all across the globe in
the last decade and by identifying the technique to responds to that health care policies can be
improves. On the whole, the findings of the research holds significant importance for the
academic researchers, analysts as well as the practitioners but there are still gaps into the
literature which must be filled by the future research studies based on the recommendations
blow:
In order to add authenticity into the argument, the future researchers should focus on
basing the opinions on the actual medical outcomes of hospitals that have adopted the
Pay for performance initiative, so that it can be evaluated that how this Human resource
strategy can contribute in improving the communication between the health care
The future studies must place more focus on evaluating the importance of pay for
performance in improving the communication in the acute hospital settings because the
acute hospitals tend to have more challenging environmental barriers and it can be more
disability.
The topic must also be analyzed by collecting the primary data so that primary and
secondary data could be synthesized and more dependable conclusion could be formed.
Transcript
Due to the rising concerns and extensive attention given to the importance of improving health
care services for patients with disabilities, I have selected this area of research to fill the gap into
the literature. It has been revealed by the studies that in the recent years, many patients with the
communication disabilities died due to some reasons which were curable and it has been
revealed that by focussing on improving the quality of are delivered to the patients with
communication disabilities, their fatalities can be prevented. Due to the significant importance of
the improvement in the health care services delivered to such disabled patients, I have focused on
revealing how the health care organizations’ Pay for Preference initiative can lead to any
possible improvements. And I have focused on the research hypothesis that “Use of Pay for
performance strategy can improve motivation of health care service providers and can improve
the quality of care provided to patients with communication disabilities”. After the detailed
examination of the literature this hypothesis has been proved true as most of the qualitative and
quantitative studies have valued the use of Pay for performance system for improving the health
care service providers’ level motivation and dedication to give more time to those who need
Peer 1: Why have you avoided using the firsthand data, don’t you think that could have provided
No, I believe the primary data can surely provide more accurate information, but only when it is
used in accordance with the nature of the topic under discussion. The time frame for completing
the research was not enough to conduct primary research, and secondly it was not feasible to
gather the information from the patients of communication disabilities regarding how better they
Research project xviii
felt, and what was their level of satisfaction towards the service delivered by health care service
providers. So in the available resources, the secondary data analysis was the most suitable
research method.
Peer 2: Communication disabilities are usually a problem when treating the children, but you
The communication disabilities are not limited to children because speech sound disorder,
stuttering, social communication disorder and many other communication disabilities are also
common in Adults. So I have tried to analyse the phenomenon from broader perspective instead
Peer 3: Can you give example of any hospital or medical institute that has actually implemented
Pay for performance and has attained any visible improvement in the quality of care?
Here, I can explain you the study I have incorporated in literature by Lindenauer, Remus ,
Roman, Rothberg , Benjamin, Ma, and Bratzler, 2007. This research has revealed the outcomes
of 613 hospitals and those which have used Pay for performance system and have stimulated
quality of care for patients with communication disabilities and have recovered their costs.
I hope you all are satisfied with my answers and this study has made contribution to your
Harvard Formatted
Reference List
1. Abduljawad, A. and Al-Assaf, A.F., (2011). Incentives for better performance in health
2. Barleon, B. (2013). More than 1,200 people with a learning disability die of avoidable
network/2013/apr/18/learning-disability-healthcare-avoidable-deaths-mencap [Assessed 8
Oct 2018]
4. de Bruin, S.R., Baan, C.A. and Struijs, J.N., (2011). Pay-for-performance in disease
5. Denscombe, M. (2009). Ground rules for social research: Guidelines for good practice.
6. Hemsley, B., Balandin, S. and Worrall, L., (2012). Nursing the patient with complex
10. Kothari, C. R. (2004). Research methodology: Methods & techniques. New Delhi: New
SAGE.
12. Lindenauer, P.K., Remus, D., Roman, S., Rothberg, M.B., Benjamin, E.M., Ma, A. and
Bratzler, D.W., (2007). Public reporting and pay for performance in hospital quality
Palgrave Macmillan.
14. Needleman, J. and Hassmiller, S., (2009). The role of nurses in improving hospital
quality and efficiency: real-world results. Health Affairs , vol.24 , no.8,pp. 625-633.
15. Norouzinia, R., Aghabarari, M., Shiri, M., Karimi, M. and Samami, E., (2016).
16. Nouwens, E., van Lieshout, J., Bouma, M., Braspenning, J. and Wensing, M., (2014).
17. Rosenthal, M.B., Frank, R.G., Li, Z. and Epstein, A.M., (2005). Early experience with
18. Saunders, M. N., Saunders, M., Lewis, P., & Thornhill, A. (2011). Research methods for
20. Tay, L.H., Ang, E. and Hegney, D. (2012). Nurses’ perceptions of the barriers in