REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE/SYNTHESIS

PAPER/POLICY REVIEW

Name: John Carlo O. Vertudazo

Section Code: B 292

Reference:

Based on study of Biclar, Lachica , Virtudazo, & Latoza ( 2018) Indigenous

Knowledge Systems and Practices (IKSP) are critical to the physical,
socioeconomic, and cultural ecosystem's equilibrium. Frameworks in the
operation of human interaction and adaptability to the environment will be
affected if it is not provided.

RUBRICS FOR REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE/SYNTHESIS PAPER/POLICY

REVIEW
Excellent (20 Very Satisfactory Satisfactory (10 Needs Points
points) (15 points) points) Improvement
(5 Points)
 The appropriate All major sections All major sections Major sections
content is of the content are of the content are of pertinent
covered in depth included, but not included, but content have
Content
without covered in as not covered in been
being much as much depth, omitted or
redundant. depth, or as or as explicit, greatly run-on;
Sources are cited explicit, as as expected; not not all
when specific all sources are
expected.
statements are cited when
Sources are sources are cited
made. when specific specific
cited when
statements are statements are
specific
made. made.
statements are
made.

Clear sense of May lack a Logic of

Organizati order. Begins thesis sentence, argument is Lacks clear
with a thesis or but points are minimally
on organizational
topic sentence. presented in a perceivable. Points
presented in a plan. Reader
Supporting logical is confused.
points are seemingly random
progression.
presented in a fashion, but all
logical support argument.
progression.

There is one There is one

Relevance clear, well clear, well There is one The topic and
focused focused topic.
to the topic. main ideas are
topic. Main Main ideas are
Title clear but are not Main ideas are not clear.
ideas are clear somewhat clear.
and are well well
supported supported by
by detailed detailed
and accurate information.
information.

All citations The majority of Citations and Citations

Reference and citations and references are not and references
references are references are presented in are not
s
presented in presented in proper format, and presented in
proper format proper are in need of proper format
and do not need format, and are in moderate revision. and need
revision. need of minor significant
revision. revision.

Total Points