Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Mangosteen peels have antibacterial activity. SNEDDS has many advantages in developing a drug
delivery system to increase the penetration of active compounds. The purpose of this study was to compare
the effectiveness of the antibacterial SNEDDS of ethyl acetate fraction from mangosteen peels and ethyl
acetate fraction of mangosteen peels without SNEDDS preparation as an antibacterial against Eschericia coli,
Pseudomonas aeroginosa, and Proteus mirabilis, that cause diabetic ulcers. This research began with
maceration. The thick ethanol extracts were continued and fractionation was carried out with ethyl acetate
solvents then was formulated into SNEDDS. The measurement of the antibacterial activity with the bacterial
growth inhibition parameters of SNEDDS preparations extracted from ethyl acetate fraction of mangosteen
peels was compared with ethyl acetate fraction of mangosteen peels without SNEDDS preparation. Data
were analyzed using independent sample T-Test. The results showed the SNEDDS preparation of ethyl
acetate fraction from mangosteen peel had activity against both types of bacteria causing diabetic ulcers,
but it had no activity against Proteus mirabilis. The results of statistical analysis showed that there were
significant differences in the activity of SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction of mangosteen peels and ethyl acetate
fraction of mangosteen peels without SNEDDS in Eschericia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa.
Keywords: antibacterial; ethyl acetate fraction; mangosteen peels; SNEDDS
α-mangostin (Parveen et al., 1988); using ethyl 70%. Extracted samples were evaporated using
acetate fraction solvents is expected to be able to waterbath until become thick extracts (Pratiwi et
attract α-mangostin compounds. In an effort to al., 2017).
maintain the stability of α-mangostin and to
increase comfort for patient, it needs to be made Preparation of Plant Fraction
with pharmaceutical preparations. One of the Some condensed ethanol extract was
pharmaceutical preparations is the self- partitioned with n-hexane to obtain n-hexane
nanoemulsifiying drug delivery system (SNEDDS). soluble fractions and residues. Then, the residue
The advantages of conventional emulsions or lipids was added with ethyl acetate to obtain the
carriers were significantly reduced for their ethyl acetate fraction and residue. Furthermore,
preparation and physical stability upon storage extracted soluble fraction of ethyl acetate
(Constantinides et al., 1996). SNEDDS have been fraction were collected and concentrated by
described in the literatures as homogenous rotary evaporator and a waterbath at
complex systems consisting of oils, surfactants, co- 40±0,5 °C to obtain a thick fraction (Pratiwi et al.,
solvents and water, which are thermodynamically 2017).
stable (Wang et al., 2009). When it is introduced
into the body, it is rapidly dispersed to form Preparation of SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction
droplets of approximately nano-size range (<200 Optimum SNEDDS formulated with a
nm) (Gursoy et al., 2004). It can reduce the combination of surfactant, co-surfactant and oil,
limitation of slow and incomplete dissolution of namely Tween 80, PEG 400 and VCO with a ratio of
water-soluble drugs and facilitate the formation of 4,98: 1,02: 1. Furthermore, ethyl acetate fraction
isolated phases from which absorption might take 150 mg / 5 mL SNEDDS was added. The mixture is
place (Chakraborty et al., 2009). An effort in the conditioned in a waterbath at 40 ° C for 10 minutes.
prevention and control of resistance is the use of The process of dissolving the fraction in the
natural compounds that have the potential as carrier is maximized with a sonicator for 15
antibacterial in applicative pharmaceutical minutes.
preparations and proven effective in DFU wounds
with bacterial infections. The aim of this study was Antibacterial Effectiveness Test
to determine the antibacterial effectiveness of Sterilization of tools and materials was by
SNEDDS preparation ethyl acetate fraction from covering the tools aluminum foil and cotton. They
mangosteen peels compared with ethyl acetate were put in an autoclave, and it was set at 121°C
fraction without SNEDDS, against diabetic foot with a pressure of 15 psi (per square inch) (Radji,
ulcers. This research needs to be developed 2010).
continuously to obtain effective mangosteen peels
SNEDDS against E. coli, P. aeroginosa, and Nutrient Agar (NA) Media
P.mirabilis bacteria in vitro. The success of the As much as 23 grams of nutrient was
study has an impact on further development of the dissolved in 1000 mL of sterile aquadest and was
potential of the development of a pharmaceutical then heated until all dissolved. In the heat state the
preparation. solution was then put into erlenmeyer, followed by
checking the pH of the media ranging from 6,8 ±
METHODOLOGY 0,2. The media is then sterilized at 121 °C autoclave
Materials for 15 minutes (Difco, 1977).
The dark purple peels were selected for the
study were freshly from Central Java, Indonesia. Mueller-Hinton Agar (MHA) Media
The other materials are ethanol 70% (Dwicentra), MHA media was made by dissolving media
n-hexane (Merck), ethyl acetate (Merck), methanol (38 grams) in 1 L of distilled water while being
(Merck), aquades (Dwicentra), VCO (Bagoes), PEG heated. It was then sterilized by autoclaving at 121
400 (Bratachem), Tween 80 (Bratachem), °C for 15 minutes (Difco, 1977).
Nutrient Agar (NA), Mueller-Hinton Agar (MHA),
NaCl 0,9% sterile were used. Bacterial Rejuvenation
The pure culture of the test bacteria from
Methods the NA media was etched aseptically with ose
Preparation of Plant Extract needle on the sloping NA media. Scratching is done
One kg of powdered mangosteen peels was by zigzagging on the surface of the media. Then it
extracted via maceration for 72 hrs using ethanol was incubated at 37 °C for 24 hours.
(1) (2)
Figure 1. (1) Ethanol extract 70% of mangosteen peels, (2) Ethyl acetate fraction of mangosteen peels
cause larger active compounds to dissolve solutions showing that there was no bacterial
(Synco, 2006). growth. Based on Figure 3, it can be seen that
VCO is a high lauric oil containing saturated SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction has a greater
fatty acids, with glycerol to form a medium chain of inhibition zone than ethyl acetate fraction without
triglycerides. Oils that have short and medium preparation does. The results of the antibacterial
chain triglyceride chains are easier to form activity test of SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction
nanoemulsions compared to those have long produced inhibition zone diameters of 18,33 mm ±
chains (Date et al., 2010). Medium chain lipids can 3,05. Whereas, ethyl acetate fraction without
be more easily mixed with the water phase preparations produced inhibition zone diameters
compared to long chain lipids, but they are also of 13,22 mm ± 3,65. Data analysis with statistic
used in emulsions to facilitate the dissolution and using the independent sample T-Test test revealed
encapsulation of hydrophilic drugs (Griffin et al., the obtained p-value 0.024 <0.05 so that there is a
2011). In a study with emulsions containing difference between SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction
medium chain triglycerides namely soybean and ethyl acetate fraction without SNEDDS.
oil, Tween 80 surfactant, and PEG, the effects The results of the antibacterial activity of
of osmotic swelling were found which SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction and ethyl acetate
led to increased drug release ability fraction of mangosteen peels without SNEDDS
(Cunha et al., 1997). have been carried out showed that there was a
growth inhibition of Pseudomonas aeroginosa
The effectiveness of SNEDDS of mangosteen which was characterized by the formation of
peels against Eschericia coli, Pseudomonas inhibition zones around wells which had been
aeroginosa, and Proteus mirabilis filled with test solutions showing that there was no
The data were obtained in the form of bacterial growth. The results of the antibacterial
quantitative and qualitative data. Qualitative data activity test of SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction
was in the form of presence or absence of against Pseudomonas aeroginosa produced
observable inhibition zones from ethyl acetate inhibition zone diameters of 12 mm ± 1. While
fraction with SNEDDS and ethyl acetate fraction ethyl acetate fraction without preparations
without SNEDDS; quantitative data consisted of the produced inhibitory zone diameters of 11,83 mm ±
amount of inhibition zones from ethyl acetate 4,64. The Proteus mirabilis inhibition zone around
fraction with SNEDDS and ethyl acetate fraction the well was not formed, it was filled with a test
without SNEDDS. solution which indicated that SNEDDS growth of
The results of the antibacterial activity of SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction bacteria and ethyl
SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction and non SNEDDS acetate fraction mangosteen peels has no
ethyl acetate fraction of mangosteen peels that antibacterial activity. Data analysis with statistic
have been carried out showed that there was using the independent sample T-Test test revealed
inhibition of Eschericia coli growth which was obtained p-value 0,048 <0,05 so that there is a
characterized by the formation of inhibition zones difference between SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction
around the wells which had been filled with test and ethyl acetate fraction without SNEDDS.
25
Inhibition Zone (mm)
20
15
10
0
E.Coli (1) E.Coli (2) E.Coli (3)
Test Sample
Figure 3. Inhibition zone SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction and ethyl acetate fraction without SNEDDS to
Eschericia coli
20
Inhibition Zone (mm)
15
10
0
P.aeroginosa (1) P.aeroginosa (2) P.aeroginosa (3)
Test Sample
Figure 4. Inhibition zone SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction and ethyl acetate fraction without SNEDDS to
Pseudomonas aeroginosa
The antibacterial activity of SNEDDS ethyl to stop (Trease et al., 1978). In addition, the
acetate fraction and ethyl acetate fraction mechanism of xanthone antimicrobial activity is
inhibiting the growth of Eschericia coli and thought to be due to the reaction of carbonyl
Pseudomonas aeroginosa is thought to be the effect groups in xanton with amino acid residues in cell
of the content of several secondary metabolites membrane proteins, extracellular enzymes and cell
contained in the fraction. Antibacterial active wall proteins, which causes protein to lose its
ingredients can interfere with physiological function (Nengah and Putera, 2010). Saponins,
processes and prevent the formation of bacterial tannins, and flavonoids are compounds in plants
cell components such as cell wall synthesis, that have antibacterial activity (Poeloengan and
cytoplasmic membrane protein synthesis and Praptiwi, 2010). Tannins are thought to be able to
nucleic acid synthesis (Subandrio, 1995). Active shrink bacterial cell walls so that they can interfere
ingredients that have high solubility in polar with cell permeability. Disruption of bacterial cell
solvents will more easily penetrate the cell permeability causes the cell to be unable to carry
membrane phospholipid so that it disrupts the out living activities so that its growth is inhibited
physiological functions of the bacteria more or dies (Ajizah, 2004).
quickly and eventually the cells will die (Kneblock In this study, SNEDDS was formulated from
et al., 1989). Xanton is one form of flavonoids Tween 80 as surfactant, PEG 400 as co-surfactant,
contained in the mangosteen peels which can and VCO as an oil phase. Tween 80 can be used as a
denaturate proteins causing cell metabolic activity penetration enhancer because Tween 80 is
Note:
a. SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction
b. Ethyl acetate fraction without SNEDDS
Figure 5. Effectivity SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction and ethyl acetate fraction without SNEDDS to: (1) E.coli,
(2) P.aeroginosa, dan (3) P.mirabilis
a surfactant that works by dissolving lipophilic The antibacterial activity of SNEDDS ethyl acetate
compounds and dissolving the lipid layer in the fraction and ethyl acetate fraction to Pseudomonas
stratum corneum. Ionic surfactants tend to cause aeroginosa has moderate antibacterial activity.
damage to human skin and increase water loss in
the skin because it can be held in the horn layer. CONCLUSION
Non ionic surfactants are safer to use because they SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction has
do not cause skin damage, are more stable, and are antibacterial activity against Eschericia coli with an
practically not absorbed in the horn layer (Aiache, inhibition zone of 18,33 mm ± 3,05 which is a
1993). In fatty acids, the longer the chain of fatty strong antibacterial activity. Ethyl acetate fraction
acids will increase penetration. The fatty acids without SNEDDS has antibacterial activity against
found in VCO are lauric acid. This can increase the Eschericia coli with an inhibition zone of 13,22 mm
penetration of compounds that are both ± 3,65 which is of moderate antibacterial activity
hydrophilic and lipophilic. The mechanism is category. SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction has
through interaction with lipids in the stratum antibacterial activity against Pseudomonas
corneum (Swarbrick and Boylan, 1995; Williams aeroginosa with inhibition zone of 12 mm ± 1. Ethyl
and Barry, 2004). acetate fraction without SNEDDS has antibacterial
The strength of the extract in inhibiting the activity against Pseudomonas aeroginosa with
growth of test bacteria was classified according to inhibitory zones of 11,83 mm ± 4,64, which are
inhibition zone diameter according to Monks et al. both categorized as medium antibacterial activity.
(2002) with the following criteria: inhibition zone
diameters less than 7 mm were categorized as not ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
having antibacterial activity; inhibition zone The authors would like to thank Pharmacy
diameters 7–11,99 mm categorized as weak Departement, Faculty of Medicine Tanjungpura
antibacterial activity. The inhibition zone 12-16,99 University.
mm is categorized as medium antibacterial
activity. Inhibition zone more than equal to 17 mm REFERENCES
is categorized as strong antibacterial activity. Abidin, K.R., Suriadi & Adiningsih, B.S., 2013,
Based on these criteria, the antibacterial activity of ‘Inhibiting Factors for Diabetic Foot Ulcer
SNEDDS ethyl acetate fraction to Eschericia coli has Wound Proliferation in Type II Diabetes
very strong antibacterial activity while the Mellitus Patients in Pontianak Kitamura
antibacterial activity of ethyl acetate fraction to Clinic’, Skripsi, Pontianak, Tanjungpura
Eschericia coli has moderate antibacterial activity. University.
Aiache, J.M., 1982, ‘Pharmacetics 2: Monks, R., Clea Lerner, N., & Amelia, H., 2001,
Biopharmaceuticals’, Airlangga University ‘Anticancer, antichemotatic and
Press, Surabaya. antimicrobial activities of marine sponges
Ajizah, A., 2004, ‘Sensitivity of Salmonella collected off the coast of Santa Catarina,
thypimurium to Psidium guajava L’, Journal southern Brazil’, Journal of Experimental
of Bioscientiae. 1, 31-38. Marine and Ecology. 281, 1-12.
Cunha, A.S., Grossior, J.L., Puisieux, F. & Seiller, M., Nengah, K.P., 2010, ‘Antibacterial Activity of
1997, ‘Insulin in w/o/w multiple emulsions: Mangosteen (Garcinia Mangostana L.) Skin
preparation, characterization and Extract and Its Active Compound Content’,
determination of stability towards Jurnal Teknologi dan Industri Pangan. 21, 1-
proteases in vitro’, Journal of 5.
Microencapsulation. 14, 311–319. Parveen, N. & Khan, N.U., 1988, ‘Two xanthones
Date, A.A., Desai, N., Dixit, R. & Nagarsenker, M., from Garcinia mangostana’, Phytochemistry.
2010, ‘Self-nanoemulsifying drug delivery 27, 3694-3696.
systems: formulation insights, applications Pedraza-Chaverri, J., Cárdenas-Rodríguez, N.,
and advances’, Nanomedicine. 5, 1595– Orozco-Ibarra, M. & Pérez-Rojas, J.M., 2008,
1616. ‘Medicinal properties of mangosteen
Difco, 1977. Manual of dehydrated culture media (Garcinia mangostana)’, Food and Chemical
and reagents for microbiology and clinical Toxicology, 46, 3227–3239.
laboratory procedures (9th ed.), Detroit Phitaktim, S., Chomnawang, M.,
Michigan, Difco Laboratories. Sirichaiwetchakoon, K., Dunkhunthod, B.,
Griffin, B. & O'Driscoll, C., 2011, ‘Opportunities and Hobbs, G, & Eumkeb, G., 2016, ‘Synergism
challenges for oral delivery of hydrophobic and the mechanism of action of the
versus hydrophilic peptide and protein-like combination of α-mangostin isolated from
drugs using lipid-based technologies’, Garcinia mangostana L. and oxacillin against
Therapeutic Delivery. 2, 1633–1653. an oxacillin-resistant Staphylococcus
Kapoor, V.K., Dureja, J. & Chadha, R., 2009, ‘Herbals saprophyticus’, BMC Microbiology. 16,195.
in the control of ageing’, Drug Discovery Poeloengan, M. & Praptiwi., 2010, ‘Antibacterial
Today. 14, 992–998. Activity Test for Mangosteen (Garcinia
Lina, E. P. & Sholihatul, M., 2016, ‘Risk factors for mangostana Linn) Peels Extract’, Media
chronic complications (diabetic legs) in Litbang Kesehatan. 10, 65-69.
Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus’, The Indonesian Priya, V., Jainu, M., Mohan, S.K., Saraswati, P., &
Journal of Health Science. 7, 26-39. Gopan, C.S., 2010, ‘Antimicrobial activity of
Kneblock, K.A., Pauli, A., Iberl, B.,Weigland, H. & pericarp extract of garcinia mangostana
Weis, N., 1989, ‘Antibacterial and Antifungal linn’, International Journal of
Properties of Essential Oil Components’, Pharmaceutical Sciences and Research. 1,
Journal of Essensial Oil Research. 1, 119-128. 278-281.
Manisha, J., Mitesh, P.H., Nidhi, S.K., Modi, D.J. & Radji, M., 2010, ‘Microbiology Textbook: Pharmacy
Vegad, M.M., 2012, ‘Spectrum of microbial and Medical Student Guides’, Jakarta:
flora in diabetic foot ulcer and antibiotic Medical Book Publishers, EGC.
sensitivity pattern in tertiary care hospital Sari, R. & Apridamayanti, P., 2015, ‘Identification
in Ahmedabad’, National Journal of Medical of ESBL-producing bacteria in patients with
Research. 3, 354-357. III and IV Wagner diabetic ulcer. DIPA
Mohamad, N.A., Jusoh, N.A., Htike, Z.Z. & Win, S.L., Research Report. Pontianak: Tanjungpura
2014, ‘Bacteria identificaton from University.
microscopic morphology: A review’, Shafiq-un-Nabi, S., Shakeel, F., Talegaonkar, S., Ali,
International Journal on Soft Computing, J., Baboota, S., Ahuja, A., et al., 2007,
Artificial Intelligence and Applications. 3, 1- ‘Formulation development and
12. optimization using nanoemulsion
Moongkarndi, P., Kosem, N., Kaslungka, S., technique: a technical note’, American
Luanratana, O., Pongpan, N. & Neungton, N., Association of Pharmaceutical Scientists. 8,
2004, ‘Antiproliferation, antioxidation and 12–17.
induction of apoptosis by Garcinia Sinko, J.P., 2006, ‘Martin's Physical Pharmacy and
mangostana (mangosteen) on SKBR3 Pharmaceutical Sciences’, 5th edition.
human breast cancer cell line’, Journal of Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, United
Ethnopharmacology. 90, 161–166. State of America.
Subandrio, W.K., 1995, Antimicrobial Tjahjani, S., Widowati, W., Khiong, K., Suhendra, A.
Chemotherapy, Antibiotics. MIPA Faculty, & Tjokropranoto, R., 2014, 'Antioxidant
Indonesia University. Properties of Garcinia Mangostana L
Swarbrick, J., & Boylan, J.C., 1995, ‘Encyclopedia of (Mangosteen) Rind', Procedia Chemistry. 13,
Pharmaceutical Technology’, Marcel Dekker, 198–203.
New York. Weecharangsan, W., Opanasopit, P., Sukma, M.,
Taher, M., Zakaria,T., Susanti, D. & Zakaria, Z., 2016, Ngawhirunpat, T., Sotanaphun, U. &
‘Hypoglycaemic activity of ethanolic extract Siripong, P., 2006, ‘Antioxidative and neuro
of Garcinia mangostana Linn in protective activities of extracts from the
nomoglycaemic and streptozotocin-induced fruit hull of mangosteen (Garcinia
diabetic rats’, Complementary and mangostana Linn.)’, Journal Medical
Alternative Medicine. 16, 135. Principles and Practice. 15, 281-287.
Trease, G.E. & Evans, W.C., 1978, ‘A Textbook of Williams, A.C., & Barry, B,W., 2004, ‘Penetration
Pharmacognosy’, 11th Edition, London: enhancers’, Advanced Drug Delivery Reviews.
Bailleire Tindal. 56, 603–618.