You are on page 1of 5

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/350121550

Review of Superelastic Archwires in Orthodontics

Article  in  Trends in Biomaterials and Artificial Organs · March 2021

CITATIONS READS

0 530

4 authors, including:

Neetha Pious
MGM Dental college and Hospital, Mumbai
5 PUBLICATIONS   4 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

COVID-19 View project

Archwires View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Neetha Pious on 17 March 2021.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


N. Pious, R.V. Krishnan, V. Patni, A. Mhatre / Trends Biomater. Artif. Organs, 35(1), 91-94 (2021)

Review Article www.sbaoi.org/tibao

Review of Superelastic Archwires in Orthodontics


Neetha Pious, Ravindranath V. Krishnan, Vivek Patni, Amol Mhatre
Department of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, MGM Dental College and Hospital, Kamothe, Navi Mumbai, India

Received: 20 May 2020 Over the last century a plethora of archwires have been introduced into the field of orthodontics. With changing
Accepted: 3 September 2020 treatment philosophies and advancement in dental materials, treatment has now become simpler. Nickel titanium
Published online: 10 March 2021 wires has revolutionized the field of orthodontics with its superelasticity and shape memory properties. They have
proved superior compared to other traditional wires. Further improvements have been incorporated into these
Key words: superelastic; nickel wires by modifying the composition and advancement in their manufacturing technology. With the availability of
titanium; archwires thermodynamic, superelastic and aesthetic archwires, several options are being presented to clinicians for treatment
of malocclusion. Literature search was performed on electronic databases—PUBMED, ScienceOpen, Lilacs, Google
Scholar, SciELO and Cochrane. This article can shed knowledge on the available improved wires and guide
orthodontist to choose the ideal wire according to the clinical situation.

© (2021) Society for Biomaterials & Artificial Organs #20040920

Introduction levelling and alignment stage of orthodontic treatment. This article


can shed knowledge on the available improved wires and guide
Over the last century, material science has made rapid progress. In orthodontists to choose the ideal wire according to the clinical
the branch of orthodontics, not only have materials improved situation.
but also the philosophies have changed. Orthodontic wires, which
generate the biomechanical forces through brackets for tooth Material and Methods
movement, are central to the practice of the profession. The
advancement of wire manufacturing technology and the A literature review was performed in PUBMED, ScienceDirect,
development of new orthodontic techniques has led to the search Lilacs, Google Scholar and Cochrane. Additional studies were
for better quality alloys [1]. Up until the 1930s the only orthodontic hand-searched and retrieved from the reference lists of relevant
wires available were made of gold and precious metal alloys. Later articles. Data was gathered using the keywords “Superelastic”,
austenitic stainless steel, cobalt-chromium and titanium wires “Nickel Titanium”, “Archwires”. The title and abstract of acquired
gained popularity and were widely used [2]. The Nitinol alloy was articles were analysed and data was extracted by the authors such
developed by William F Buehler, a research metallurgist at Naval that the topic can be adequately summarized in a narrative manner.
Ordinance Laboratory in the year 1960 after which Dr. George The search was limited to articles in English. The reference list of
Andreason introduced it in orthodontics where it brought about selected papers was hand searched for further relevant articles. Only
a revolutionary change [3]. The initially discovered nitinol was a those articles were included which studied various aspects of
martensitic stabilized alloy which showed no superelasticity. Nickel superelastic archwires in the field of orthodontics. Articles with
titanium (NiTi) archwires have been evolving since their initial reviews, abstracts, letters to editorials, clinical and in vitro studies
development with shape memory and superelastic properties [4]. studying properties of superelastic archwires were included, while
Superelasticity is a phenomenon wherein the stress remained nearly articles studying applications of superelastic archwires other than
constant despite the strain change within a specific range and is in the field of orthodontics were excluded. Articles researching on
achieved through stress-related martensite-austenite superelastic materials other than archwires were not considered. A
transformation. This allows a constant force to be delivered over total of 4354 articles were acquired from the literature search, out
an extended portion of the deactivation range and is therefore of which 34 articles were selected from which data was extracted,
more likely to generate physiologic tooth movement and greater reviewed and compiled in a correct manner.
patient comfort [5,6]. Thus they can be utilized in the initial
Composition and Manufacturing Process
*Coresponding author
E-mail address: neethaortho@gmail.com (Dr. Neetha Pious, MGM Dental College and Nickel and titanium are most commonly manufactured into nickel
Hospital, Kamothe, Navi Mumbai, India) titanium alloy by the process of vacuum induction melting,
91
N. Pious, R.V. Krishnan, V. Patni, A. Mhatre / Trends Biomater. Artif. Organs, 35(1), 91-94 (2021)
electron beam melting, plasma arc melting or vacuum arc melting generated by copper NiTi is less than that of NiTi alloys. This
process [7]. Several re-melts are often needed to improve the explains the clinical efficiency of copper NiTi to continue working
homogeneity of nickel titanium alloy. Alloy is converted into a as teeth near their intended positions. The additional copper
powdered form. The process of hot isostatic processing is used by element in the composition made it is possible to build in, precise
the manufacturer to form the powders into wires. The present transformation temperature characteristics during the
invention provides a nickel-titanium-palladium superelastic alloy manufacturing process. This built-in precision is designed to put
material of a composition consisting of, by atomic percent, 34 to the clinician in control especially during the early stages of treatment,
49% nickel, 48 to 52% titanium, and 3 to 14% palladium. Optionally, like no other force delivery system currently available. These wires
a part of nickel and/or titanium of this alloy is replaced with one are set at four transformation temperatures for four distinct force
or more elements selected from a group of chromium, iron, cobalt, levels, enabling clinicians to deal with specific clinical situations and
vanadium, manganese, boron, copper, aluminium, niobium, are classified as follows.
tungsten and zirconium, such that these elements to be replaced
amount to 2% or less in total (by atomic percent) [8]. The alloy is Type I: (150C)
hot worked followed by a final heat-treatment after which wires It has not been used frequently in clinical situations because it
obtain their final shape by the process of drawing or rolling. generates very heavy forces and clinical indications are few.
Types of superelastic archwires Type II: (270C)
Chinese NiTi archwires This wire generates higher forces compared to type III and IV. It is
They were developed by originally by Dr. Hua Cheng Tien and best used in patients who have an average or higher pain threshold,
colleagues at research institute for non-ferrous metal in Beijing normal periodontal health.
(China) in 1978. Chinese NiTi wires possess superelasticity and
and where rapid tooth movement is required and the force system
shape memory. At mouth temperature, this wire is work hardened
generated by the orthodontic archwire is constant.
martensite and hence does not rely on shape memory characteristics
in clinical applications. It’s very high springback and low stiffness Type III: (350C)
characteristics have won wide clinical acceptance for initial tooth
alignment. The stiffness of this wire is 73% that of stainless steel This wire generates forces in mid-range and is useful in patients
wires and 36% that of conventional nitinol. It can be deflected 1.6 who have low to normal pain threshold, where periodontium is
times as far as nitinol wire or 4.4 times as far as stainless steel wire normal to slightly compromised and when relatively low forces are
without appreciable permanent deformation [9,10]. It has a high desired.
range of action and spring back properties. Chinese NiTi is
applicable clinically where large defection for uprighting, labial and Type IV: (400C)
lingual tooth movements is needed. These wires generated tooth driving forces only when the mouth
temperature exceeds 400C. These forces are intermittent in nature.
Japanese NiTi archwires The indication for use of this alloy includes patients who are
In 1978 Furukawa Electric Co. Ltd. of Japan discovered a new type sensitive to pain, with compromised periodontal conditions or
of NiTi alloy which was reported by Miura et al in 1986 [5]. They where tooth movement is deliberately slowed down (e.g. when the
are austenitic active NiTi alloys. It displays superelasticity which is patient may not be able to visit the orthodontist regularly, or the
achieved by stress-induced martensitic transformation (SIM) [11]. co-operation is very poor).
Clinically they provide light continuous force for physiologic tooth
movement and greater patient comfort. Japanese NiTi is marketed Supercable archwires
as Sentalloy [12]. It was discovered by Hanson in 1993. It is a seven stranded round
coaxial superelastic NiTi which increases the flexibility and minimizes
NeoSentalloy archwires the force delivery of the wire [14]. These wires can be engaged in
They are new superelastic NiTi and rectangular wires. They can be extremely crowded teeth with ease. Its advantages include improved
used with extremely light force in the initial phase of treatment anchorage control, less patient discomfort and use of fewer wires
rather than using round wires in the initial treatment. Three-point for treatment. Its disadvantages include the tendency of wire ends
bending and torque tests have shown the wire to exert light, to fray, break and unravel in extraction spaces and the inability to
continuous force regardless of deflection or wire size [13]. Its accommodate bends, steps, or helices in the wires.
advantages include good three-dimensional tooth control which
can be effected at the same time as horizontal, vertical leveling and Biotwist NiTi archwires
root torquing. They also provide greater archwire flexibility and less They are 0.021"x 0.025" pre-form rectangular archwires They are
patient discomfort than conventional NiTi wires. formed with multiple strands of titanium superelastic wires. They
display low force and low stiffness along with excellent flexibility
Copper NiTi archwires [15]. The rectangular shape allows significant engagement of the
Copper NiTi was developed by Rohit Sachdeva and Suchio Miyasaki slot. Bio twist wires have been indicated for use at the beginning of
in 1994. They represent the next generation of both superelastic treatment during the leveling and aligning while also controlling
and shape memory wires by reducing hysteresis and by providing torque.
precise transformation temperature. When compared to BioForce archwires
conventional nickel titanium wires copper NiTi develops
approximately 20% less loading force [12]. This permits easier They were introduced by GAC International (New York, United
engagement in the bracket slot since the wire can be manipulated States). They are aesthetic and belong to the first and only family
with less difficultly and it creates less trauma and discomfort to the of biologically correct archwires. They are graded thermodynamic
patient. Around the rest position, however, the decrease of force nickel titanium archwires. These wires can produce variation in
92
N. Pious, R.V. Krishnan, V. Patni, A. Mhatre / Trends Biomater. Artif. Organs, 35(1), 91-94 (2021)
archwire force by variable transition temperatures along the length Nitinol total control: A new orthodontic alloy
of the wire [16]. Variable heat treatment of the wire allowed a
single wire size to have three different force levels. The optimal Nitinol Total Control (NTC) is a new pseudo-superelastic nickel
super elastic wire now offered light forces in the anterior section, titanium alloy. They accept specific first, second, and third order
medium force in the bicuspid area and a heavier force in the molar bends while maintaining its desirable superelastic properties. NTC
region. combines the ability of superelastic NiTi to deliver light, continuous
forces over the desired range with the flexibility required to account
BioForce with ionguard archwires for variations in the arch form [21]. It reduces the archwire inventory
without compromising treatment mechanics. These wires apply
For reducing the frictional resistance, GAC International (New York, lower forces that are generally associated with less patient discomfort.
United States) created a Nickel-Titanium wire which underwent an The number of archwire changes required is less, thus NTC allows
Ion implantation process but did not affect the unique superelastic the clinician to treat more patients effectively and efficiently. They
properties of BioForce. At low temperature, a high energy beam display low stiffness and its properties are not temperature-
of ions is used to modify the surface structure and chemistry. Ion dependent.
implantation is not a layer on the surface therefore, it does not alter
the dimensions or properties of the archwire. Ion implantation Alignment efficiency of superelastic archwires
improves wear resistance, surface hardness, resistance to chemical
attack, and most importantly reduces friction. BioForce with Multistranded stainless steel, Nitinol, thermal and superelastic
Ionguard showed a smoother surface and generated less frictional archwires can be used for levelling and alignment of teeth. The
force compared to untreated NiTi [17]. superelastic archwires exhibit superelasticity and has better mechanical
properties like good springback, low stiffness, high resilience, which
SmartArch® multi-force super-elastic archwires is also present in multistranded stainless steel wires [3]. The load
deflection rate of superelastic archwires is also less than conventional
SmartArch® (S-A) is a new generation of multi-force laser- NiTi and multistranded stainless steel wires [22]. Superelastic NiTi
conditioned Copper NiTi wires. Its properties are based on the was found to be superior to multistranded stainless steel and
optimal compressive stress in the periodontal ligament (PDL) to conventional NiTi in laboratory studies [23]. It has to be noted
achieve rapid tooth movement with minimal necrosis and patient that multi-stranded wires be it braided, twisted or coaxial have
discomfort. These latest wires were discovered by Dr. W. Eugene similar properties and great potential for use in the early stages of
Roberts, Dr. Jeffery A. Roberts, Dr. Stephen Tracey and Dr. David orthodontic treatment. However, their low elastic limit makes them
M. Sarver. They were manufactured by Allesee Orthodontic susceptible to plastic deformation because of external forces, such
Appliances (Sturtevant, Wisconsin, United States) using multiple as chewing. Superelastic NiTi is an archwire that produces a similar
memory material technologies [18], which precisely program level of force at any range of deflection and hence biologically more
transition zones as narrow as 0.001” in a cross-section of shape- acceptable. In few studies [24,25], there was no statistically significant
memory alloy wire. Wires are programmed to deliver an ideal difference in the tooth alignment and the time taken for alignment
physiologic load on each tooth based on each tooth’s PDL between the superelastic and conventional NiTi wires. Some studies
compressive stress value. They are unique archwires that are available [26,27] have reported statistically significant differences in the time
in a 0.016-inch round and 0.018 x 0.025 inch rectangular taken for alignment between superelastic NiTi and multistranded
configurations. stainless steel wires. Other studies [28-30] concluded that there was
no statistically significant difference between superelastic NiTi and
Orthocosmetic elastinol archwires
multistranded stainless steel wires in their efficiency in preadjusted
These were manufactured by Masel Orthodontics (Carlsbad, United edgewise appliance brackets. A study [31] showed that the degree
States). They are epoxy coated, esthetic high performance NiTi of alignment with coaxial superelastic NiTi was greater than with
superelastic archwires that blend exceptionally well with ceramic or single-stranded superelastic NiTi.
plastic brackets. They don’t stain, discolour, and also resist cracking
or chipping [19]. Recycling of Superelastic archwires
Marsenol archwires The relatively high cost of these wires has prompted some of the
clinicians to reuse them after sterilization. Many of the clinicians
Marsenol is a tooth coloured nickel titanium wire and was who recycled these wires indicated that a deterioration in the
manufactured by Glenroe technologies (Florida, United States). mechanical properties of the wires was their major concern. Recycling
They are elastomeric poly tetra fluroethyl emulsion (PTFE) coated involves repeated exposure of the wire for several weeks or months
nickel titanium archwires. It exhibits all the same working to mechanical stresses and elements of the oral environment, as
characteristics of an uncoated superelastic nickel titanium archwires well as sterilization between uses. The combined effects of repeated
[20]. The coating adheres to the wire and remains flexible. They clinical use and sterilization may subject, the wire to corrosion and
deliver constant force over long periods of activation and is fracture cold working, with a resultant alternation in its properties. Clinical
resistant. recycling increases the loading and unloading forces associated with
these wires and also reduces the superelasticity of these wires. A
Nitanium tooth toned archwire study was designed [32] to examine the effects of currently used
They are superelastic NiTi wires marketed by Ortho Organizers infection control procedures on the mechanical properties of
Organizers (Carlsbad, United States). They have special plastic and superelastic nickel titanium alloy archwires. No statistically significant
friction-reducing tooth coloured coatings that blend with natural differences were found between the groups (recycled group) or
dentition, ceramic, plastic, and composite brackets, and maintain against an untreated control. One study [33] evaluated the load-
their original colour. These wires deliver gentle force but the coated deflection characteristics of three types of superelastic wires and
white coloured wires have shown to succumb to forces of investigated the effects of recycling on their superelastic properties.
mastication and enzyme activity of the oral cavity. They are available A significant increase in load deflection rate was seen and autoclave
in round 0.014”, 0.016”, 0.018” and rectangular 0.016” x 0.022” sterilization was recommended for clinicians who tend to reuse
sizes [19]. superelastic wires. According to the findings of another study [34],
93
N. Pious, R.V. Krishnan, V. Patni, A. Mhatre / Trends Biomater. Artif. Organs, 35(1), 91-94 (2021)
it is not possible to recycle and autoclave superelastic NiTi wires 11. T.G. Bradley, W. A. Brantley, B. M. Culbertson, Differential scanning
without a significant reduction in their tensile properties and calorimetry (DSC) analyses of superelastic and nonsuperelastic nickel-
titanium orthodontic wires, Am. J. Orthod. Dentofacial Orthop., 109(6),
degradation of surface properties. Clinically, the results of most 589-597(1996).
studies suggest that orthodontists should avoid recycling and reuse 12. W.A. Brantley, T. Eliades, “Orthodontic wires” in Orthodontic materials:
of the archwires as the efficiency is decreased. scientific and clinical aspects, Stuttgart, Thieme(2001).
13. F. Miura, M. Mogi, Y. Okamoto, New application of superelastic NiTi
Conclusion rectangular wire, J. Clin. Orthod, 24(9), 544-8(1990).
14. J. Berger, F. K Byloff, T. Waram, Supercable and the SPEED system, J.
In the last few decades, a plethora of new wires and alloys have Clin. Orthod., 32(4), 246-253(1998).
been introduced into orthodontics. These wires demonstrate a 15. N. Malik, R. Dubey, A. Kallury, A. Chauksye, T. Shrivastav, B. R. Kapse, A
wide spectrum of mechanical properties and have added to the review of orthodontic archwires. Int. J. Orofac. Res., 5(1), 6-11(2015).
versatility of orthodontic treatment. Superelastic archwires are a 16. D. M. Ibe, D. Segner, Superelastic materials displaying different force
levels within one archwire, J. Orofac. Orthop., 59(1), 29-38(1998).
great asset in the field of orthodontics. The use of superelastic 17. K. Mendes, P. E. Rossouw, Friction: validation of manufacturer’s claim,
archwires can enhance patient comfort, reduce chairside time and Semin. Orthod., 9(4), 236-250(2003).
the duration of treatment. This will help the clinician in restoring 18. W.E. Roberts, J.A. Roberts, S. Tracey, D.M. Sarver, SmartArch multi-
the smiles of millions faster. Superelasticity and shape memory force, super-elastic archwires: A new paradigm in orthodontics, J. Digit.
wires can help the orthodontist to bring about more efficient tooth Orthod., 55, 66-79(2019).
movement. They are capable of producing excellent treatment 19. D.P. Singh, Esthetic archwires in orthodontics-A review, J. Oral Hyg.
Health, 4(194), 2332-0702(2016).
results because they deliver a light and constant force for a long 20. R. Nathani, P. Daigavane, S. Shrivastav, R. Kamble, D. Gupta, Esthetic
period; which is considered physiologically desirable for tooth arch wires-A review, Int. J. Adv. Res., 3(12), 743-51(2015).
movement. Recycling of superelastic wires should be avoided to 21. T.A. Thayer, K. Fox, E. Meyer, Nitinol total control: a new orthodontic
get optimum performance. Even among superelastic archwires, alloy, J. Clin. Orthod, 33(10), 563(1999).
further improvements have been incorporated to develop superior 22. C.C.A. Quintão, L.M. Menezes, C.N. Elias, Force-deflection properties
wires. In the present day commercialization, SmartArch multi-force of initial orthodontic archwires, World J. Orthod., 10(1), 29-32(2009).
23. R.I.M. Tonner, N.E. Waters, The characteristics of super-elastic Ni-Ti
archwire is a new technology that can both accelerate treatment and, wires in three-point bending. Part l: The effect of temperature, Eur. J.
more important, improve clinical efficiency in treating malocclusions. Orthod, 16(5), 409-419(1994).
Treatment will become simpler with customized superelastic 24. K. O’Brien, D. Lewis, W. Shaw, E. Combe, A clinical trial of aligning
archwires. Many clinicians may be unaware the of several new wires archwires, Eur. J. Orthod, 12(4), 380-384(1990).
available in the market. This article gives an overview of several 25. R.S. Abdelrahman, K.S. Al-Nimri, E.F. Al Maaitah, A clinical comparison
superior superelastic wires and their properties. It will encourage of three aligning archwires in terms of alignment efficiency: a
prospective clinical trial, Angle Orthod., 85(3), 434-9(2015)
clinicians to use the newer superior wires instead of the conventional 26. D.R. Vimalathithan, Is nickel titanium superior to multistranded stainless
wires. The clinician must weigh the requirements of the individual steel wire in aligning crowded lower anteriors? A comparative in-vivo
case at each point in time and make the selection of the archwire study, IOSR-JDMS, 9(3),47-51(2013).
based on the property of wires and clinical needs. 27. A.E. West, M.L. Jones, R.G. Newcombe, Multiflex versus superelastic: a
randomized clinical trial of the tooth alignment ability of initial arch
wires, Am. J. Orthod. Dentofacial Orthop., 108(5), 464-71(1995).
References 28. C.C.A. Quintao, M.L. Jones, L.M. Menezes, D., Koo, C.N. Elias, A
1. C.C.A Quintão, I. Brunharo, Orthodontic wires: knowledge ensures prospective clinical trial to compare the performance of four initial
clinical optimization, Dental Press J. Orthod., 14(6), 144-57(2009). orthodontic archwires, Korean J. Orthod., 35(5), 381-387(2005).
2. R.P. Kusy, Orthodontic biomaterials: from the past to the 29. T.J.W Evans, M.L. Jones, R.G. Newcombe, Clinical comparison and
present, Angle Orthod., 72(6), 501-512(2002). perfor mance perspective of three aligning arch wires, Am. J.
3. S. Kapila, R. Sachdeva, Mechanical properties and clinical applications of Orthod. Dentofacial Orthop., 114(1), 32-39(1998).
orthodontic wires, Am. J. Orthod. Dentofacial Orthop., 96(2), 100-109, 30. S.S. Sandhu, V.S. Shetty, S. Mogra, J. Varghese, J. Sandhu, J.S. Sandhu,
(1989). Efficiency, behavior, and clinical properties of superelastic NiTi versus
4. N.E. Waters, Superelastic nickel-titanium wires, Br. J. Orthod.,19(4), 319- multistranded stainless steel wires: a prospective clinical trial, Angle
322(1992). Orthod., 82(5), 915-921(2012).
5. F. Miura, M. Mogi, Y. Ohura, H. Hamanaka, The super-elastic property of 31. B. Sebastian, Alignment efficiency of superelastic coaxial nickel-titanium
the Japanese NiTi alloy wire for use in or thodontics, Am. J. vs superelastic single-stranded nickel-titanium in relieving mandibular
Orthod. Dentofacial Orthop., 90(1), 1-10(1986). anterior crowding: a randomized controlled prospective study, Angle
6. R.P. Kusy, A review of contemporary archwires: their properties and Orthod., 82(4), 703-708(2012).
characteristics, Angle Orthod., 67(3), 197-207(1997). 32. O.P. Crotty, E.H. Davies, S.P. Jones, The Effects of Cross-infection
7. L.M. Wang, L.H. Liu, H. Yang, L.Y. Wang, G.Q. Xiu, Melting and fabrication Control Procedures on the Tensile and Flextural Properties of
of NiTi shape-memory alloy wires, Mater. Sci. Forum, 394, 297-300 Superelastic Nickel-titanium Wires, Br. J. Orthod., 23(1), 37-41(1996).
(2002). 33. B.A. Ramazanzadeh, F. Ahrari, B. Sabzevari, S.M. Zebarjad, A. Ahrari,
8. K. Mitose, T. Ueki, Ni-Ti-Pd superelastic alloy material, its manufacturing Effects of a Simulated Oral Environment and Sterilization on Load-
method, and orthodontic archwire made of this alloy material, U.S. deflection Properties of Superelastic Nickel Titanium–based
Patent No. 5,885,381 (1999). Orthodontic Wires, Int. J. Orthod., 22(1), 13-21(2011).
9. C.J. Burstone, B. Qin, J.Y. Morton, Chinese NiTi wire-a new orthodontic 34. V.N. Bavikati, G. S. Singaraju, P. Mandava, S.S. Killamsetty, V. Nettam,
alloy, Am. J. Orthod., 87(6), 445-452 (1985). P.K.R. Karnati, Evaluation of Mechanical and Physical Properties of
10. R. Chen, Y.F. Zhi, M.G. Arvystas, Advanced Chinese NiTi alloy wire and Clinically Used and Recycled Superelastic NiTi Wires, J. Clin. Diagn.
clinical observations, Angle Orthod., 62(1), 59-66(1992). Res., 10(7), ZC35–ZC40(2016).

94

View publication stats

You might also like