Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Katharine Arntz
Institut fur Geographische Wissenschaften, Freie Universitat Berlin .
Lebuser StraGe 11, 10243 Berlin , Germany .
E- mail: arntz @ zedat .fu -berlin .de
A key to understanding historic townscapes is built fabric of many European towns. The
an appreciation of their genius loci . Each nature of this process of change has been
townscape reveals something of the power, explored in a number of case studies which
wealth , ideals or even misery of its vary from an assessment of the relationship
inhabitants, past and present . 1 Every new between building activity and commercial
generation lives to a certain extent within the function,3 to examination of the influence of
framework provided by its predecessors, but town hierarchy and population size on
adapts and modifies the built environment to townscape change,4 to accounts of the
suit changing needs and aims. In this way evolution of building types, to descriptions
'
priately explored in Potsdam, where the I succeeded to the throne in 1713, the town
townscape formed during the eighteenth had only c. 1500 inhabitants, was
century , a time of absolute monarchical economically unimportant, and had no
power, was later extensively modified by independent authority to represent its
individual owner-occupiers. residents. Friedrich Wilhelm took advantage
The years between the end of the of this weak political and economic position
Franco-Prussian War in' 1871 and the and began to develop Potsdam as a royal
beginning of the Great World War in 1914 garrison . Regiments were transferred to the
have been chosen for detailed analysis. This town and soldiers were quartered in the
is a period when alterations to Potsdam’s homes of Potsdam ’s residents. This method
;
baroque town centre reached their peak as the of providing accommodation for the military
built environment was modified to meet the made it necessary to attract civilians to
demands and expectations of a new Potsdam, so manufacturing firms were
generation . Residents enjoyed unprecedented encouraged to locate there. The construction
freedom of development. The variation in of new houses for their employees increased
the amount of total change over time is the quarters available for the soldiers and , in
examined and different types of change their turn , the soldiers provided the demand
discussed in the context of the society of to drive the economy . By 1740, at the end
Potsdam at the turn of the century . This of Friedrich Wilhelm’ s reign , Potsdam
involves considering not only the effects of consisted of over a thousand houses and had
rising living standards, technological advance II 708 civilian and 4294 military residents.8
and fashion , but also the attitude of Friedrich Wilhelm provided for the
inhabitants towards their townscape as accommodation of the enlarged population
revealed in contemporary accounts and the with two planned extensions to the town .
planning system . Town walls were erected around the newly-
The discussion is limited to the area within built areas and , with the surrounding
the town walls: the old town , and the first waterways and marshes, deterred the
and second planned extensions as shown in press-ganged soldiers from deserting . The
Figure 1 . This entire area is henceforth street plan was influenced by existing
termed the town centre. north -south roads (such as LindenstraBe and
Nauener StraBe ), which were incorporated ,
and the presence of marshy areas, such as
The building of Potsdam
Bassin Platz, which could not be built upon
( Figure 1 ). Initially the king provided
Although records show that Potsdam already
subsidies for the building work and free
existed in 993, the town’s precarious
building materials. Later, buildings were
livelihood was based on its situation at a
given to those willing to move to the town .
major crossing point of the River Havel and
In both cases the residents were expected to
it did not achieve stability of wealth ,
construct the necessary rear buildings, such
structure or population until the eighteenth
as washrooms and stables, from their own
century . In 1660, as a result of war and
resources. Within the first planned extension
fires, only 50 of the 198 houses grouped
simple timber- framed buildings were cheaply
around the castle were in good condition , 20
and quickly built . The houses of the second
were damaged and the remainder abandoned .
extension were also timber framed but their
The fortunes of Potsdam started to
improve when the town was chosen as the facades were planned so as to form rhythmic
second seat of the Kurfiirst ( Prince) of the interchanges of particular forms so that the
Mark Brandenburg in 1660. This rise in streets and squares presented a strictly
status brought with it renovation of the castle uniform appearance ( Figure 2 ). This
and the construction of homes for courtiers. streetscape was said to be a reflection of
Nevertheless, when King Friedrich Wilhelm Friedrich Wilhelm ’s delight in rows of
.
Figure 1. The town centre of Potsdam, 1845
i 5T
i I Ml
* *
!
i
3,
: ::
:
l
-
i l l ill m
LU m i
I
:
.
Figure 2 Example of a streetscape of the second planned extension , as constructed
1733 40.'° -
96 Authoritarian townscapes
As has been noted in other towns, these local The general trend of intensification of use
figures do not accord perfectly with national within the town centre as a whole was
trends;16 they do not , however, differ by more reflected in the study block . Between 1871
than the 5- year mean deviation found to be and 1914 the number of businesses in the
typical by Gottlieb. 17 block rose from 67 to 85, and the space
The mixed nature of development is occupied by retailing in part of
obvious and a number of explanations for the Brandenburger StraBe more than doubled.
changes may be inferred . The extensions to Despite rising living standards, the number of
living space ( namely , attic conversions, households in the block also increased from
additional storeys and building within the 167 to 191, and building extensions were
block interior ) should be seen in relation to numerous ( Figure 4 A ). The mean number of
the fast growth in population : from 43 834 in alterations per house over the study period
98 A uthoritarian townscapes
30
20
Facade alterations
Addition of
storeys and
attic conversions
Additions and
changes to
30 T
20 4
30
: all
20 4-
-
. i luliiiulL
buildings in the
block interiors
0 J
30 T
20
Internal
alteration 10 -
0
Partial
20 -
rebuilding 10 -
o - ilalalallll milili 1 1 l I
X X
20
Total
rebuilding 10 4-
o i
n
CO CO 00 S
Figure 3. Number of changes of different types to houses in the town centre of
Potsdam , 1871 - 1914.21
was 3.6, with a range of 0-8, although this Production (for instance a carpenter’s, a
varied between the streets: Brandenburger brewery , and a pottery' ) comprised 6 per cent
StraBe showed the highest development of implemented applications and was
pressure, measured both in total applications concentrated in the interior of the block .
and implemented applications, Branden - Retailing ( 44 per cent) was found primarily
burger StraBe was the main shopping street, on the ground floors of the buildings, with
so this larger amount of change corresponds shops facing the street and storage of goods
with the finding in Utrecht , the Netherlands, on the ground floors of extensions in the
that hard core shopping streets undergo more back yards, Change associated with
change than secondary ones. "
residential use was mostly in the upper
Examination of the functions with which storeys and also made up 44 per cent of
changes within the study block were implemented applications.
associated reveals their spatial segregation . Figure 4B shows the extent of fa?ade
A uthoritarian townscapes 99
(A ) ( B)
CharlottenstraSe Charlottenstrafte
D no change D no change
Figure 4. Changes to the study street - block ( shown diagramatically ), 1871 - 1914.
( A ) Rebuilding, extension and other changes . ( B ) Alterations to facades.
modification in the study block , including the decoration and the middle building
construction of shop windows, the emphasized , so the whole appears to be a
introduction of new windows for the attics, palatial villa. Figure 5 B show's the condition
the addition of storeys, and changes in the of the building in 1914, as reconstructed from
decorative elements of the facades. Although the planning records. Not apparent in this
a limited number of alterations had already drawing is another common source of
taken place before 1871 , the volume of disunity , namely the painting of different
change over the study period was such that sections of such facades in different colours.
the appearance of very few houses remained Such types of adaptive change have been
unaffected . The impact on the townscape of shown to be quite characteristic of European
Potsdam was correspondingly great . By 1914 towns at this time . 2 ' The distinctiveness of
there were large display windows in the townscapes became blurred as they
ground floors, storeys and balconies had been underwent similar processes of adaptation for
added , and there were other changes to the more intensive residential and commercial
fa?ades: the uniformity had all but use: the break -up of ground - floor fa?ades for
disappeared . shop windows was particularly
The townscape created by Friedrich II had characteristic.24 In eastern and middle
been dominated by the impression made by Prussia, many of the adaptations led to an
individual fa < jades. This was very vulnerable increasing similarity between different
to change . Because several houses, and thus building ' types as part of a progression
several owners, were hidden behind each towards the multiple-dwelling form , with
fa?ade the unity of the facade could be easily several storeys, extensions in the form of
disturbed by piecemeal change. Figure 5 A wings, and buildings in the backyards . 2' The
shows a reconstruction of the original fa$ade contrast , however, between the harmonious
of CharlottenstraBe 96 to 98, where the two townscape of Potsdam created by the
outside buildings were given the same monarchy in the eighteenth century , and that
100 A uthoritarian townscapes
(A)
3 3 5 § I
-—
» i
HU
iMI
c
mm m m mm
~ L ?q rr»i inr
$
=4 :
fi
:
I '
r -!
f c^
i
t
sr
i
1
. i
I :
I r a I =
-=-=
'T
rjJ ,
^ k
-
f
b=:
U
— a
-
Hi I -
J
( B)
. - .
Figure 5 Charlottenstrafte 96 98 ( A ) Reconstruction of the original facade 26 .
.
( B ) Reconstruction of the facade in 1914 after alterations.27
created by the actions of many individuals, is certain fire and safety regulations and thus
extreme. Developments occurred within the required a permit from the police
existing morphological frame , which commissioner. These regulations stipulated
constrained and shaped their form , but they the building materials to be used , the density
modified the townscape to reflect new of development , the maximum height in
realities. relation to the width of the street or yard , and
so on . They thus had an obvious effect on
Planning the nature of townscape change, but were not
intended to control design or to address the
At the beginning of the study period, all aesthetic value of proposed change. There
proposed building work was subject to also existed a declaration , made by Friedrich
Authoritarian townscapes 101
the necessary repairs themselves. Haberlin passed in 1923, by which time practically all
reports that they believed it to be the king’s houses in the town centre had been modified
duty to build , and they were determined that and the townscape of Potsdam contained
he should continue to be offended by the clear signs of the change from a society
state of the houses until he repaired them . dependent on , and strictly controlled by , the
Indeed , when one resident began building monarchy , to one of loosely - regulated
work himself, neighbours smeared his house profit-seeking individuals.
with dirt.35
By about 1850, it had reached the point Conclusion
that houses would collapse if they were not
repaired . The residents started to repair them By the onset of the First World War the
and , in so doing, to adapt their property to townscape of Potsdam , created by the
suit their needs rather than the visions of the authoritarian power of the Prussian monarchs,
king. Yet the evidence suggests that the had been transformed to reflect fundamental
inhabitants still did not regard their changes in society . The harmonious facades
townscape as valuable. Friedel reports on of the mid-eighteenth century had revealed
interviews he conducted with owners of the dominance of royal control , not only over
houses with ornate fagades in which he was the built fabric, but also over the people .
told that the facades were no cause of pride ‘No town in Prussia was so privileged and
but regarded only as a burden .36 Unlike the pampered by the Hohenzollem , but nor was
monarchs, the residents of Potsdam were not any town so severely dominated by them, as
interested in creating a great artwork , but Potsdam’.38 As the grip of monarchical
individually adapted the built fabric to suit power slackened , so residents began to invest
themselves and reflect their commercial in their own property, leaving barely a house
standing. The result was extensive changes in the town centre that did not display signs
to the townscape, as a laissez - faire townscape of quite considerable alteration by 1914.
emerged out of an authoritarian one. Although the process of categorizing such
In the second half of the study period , the alterations can invest them with a certain
consequences of this scarcely-controlled sense of uniformity , it should be emphasized
development began to be recognized and that they are unplanned variations on a
regretted. Complaints, particularly about the number of themes. The growth in height and
style of adaptations designed to suit the depth of building cover on each plot , the
fashions and demands of the modem world , grouping of buildings around backyards, and
began to be heard from about 1910, and the break - up of ground -floor fa?ades for shop
various organizations concerned themselves windows, are general tendencies of
with the question . The conclusions were that development , but their physical manifestation
the residents of Potsdam needed to be can vary considerably . A street of houses
educated about the value of their townscape, that all have their ground floors given over to
that architects should replace the builders retailing rarely forms a harmonious unit . The
who commonly designed the alterations, and contrast between the planned regularity of the
that legislation (an Ortsstatut ) controlling authoritarian townscape and the diversity
development should be passed . ' resulting from a period of laissez - faire
The debate continued in and out of the change is thus considerable.
local newspapers for over 10 years. One While each physical alteration in central
party outlined the benefits of an Ortsstatut Potsdam was the result of an individual
while attempting to play down the limitations decision to initiate change, a number of
it would put on the freedom of the residents, factors can be seen to have encouraged
and the other party argued vehemently for the adaptation and to have influenced its form .
right of the property owner to develop his The continuing urbanization of Prussia was
house as he desired . Legislation was finally accompanied by rising land values and rents,
Authoritarian townscapes 103