Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Development Report
2012
Human Development
and the Shift to Better
Citizen Security
Caribbean Human Development Report 2012
Human Development and the Shift to Better Citizen Security
Copyright © 2012
by the United Nations Development Programme
1 UN Plaza, New York, NY 10017, USA
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted, in any
form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without prior permission.
ISBN: 9789962688082
Website: http://www.regionalcentrelac-undp.org/en/hdr-caribbean
For a list of any errors or omissions found subsequent to printing please visit our website.
Helen Clark
Administrator
United Nations Development Programme
Rebeca Grynspan
Associate Administrator
United Nations Development Programme
Anthony Harriott
Lead Author Caribbean HDR
Executive Board
Marcia De Castro Luis Felipe Lopez Calva
UNDP Resident Representative Former Chief Economist and Practice Leader
Trinidad and Tobago and Suriname Poverty, MDGs and Human Development
Regional Bureau for LAC
Thomas Gittens
UNDP Country Director Alvaro Pinto
Suriname Former Practice Leader
Democratic Governance
Michelle Gyles-McDonnough Regional Bureau for LAC
UNDP Resident Representative
Barbados and OECS Pablo Ruiz
Practice Leader
Arun Kashyap Crisis Prevention and Recovery
UNDP Resident Representative Regional Centre for LAC
Jamaica
Khadja Musa
UNDP Resident Representative
Guyana
Consultants
Edward Maguire
Consultant on Criminal Justice Systems
National Consultants
Peer Reviewers
The increase in violence and crime in Latin America and the Caribbean is an undeniable fact
that erodes the very foundation of the democratic processes in the region and imposes high so-
cial, economic and cultural costs. Our region is home to 8.5 percent of the world’s population,
yet it concentrates some 27 percent of the world’s homicides. Violence and crime are therefore
perceived by a majority of Latin American and Caribbean citizens as a top pressing challenge.
The resulting alarm has often led to short-sighted, mano dura (iron fist) policies, which have
proven ineffective and, at times, detrimental to the rule of law.
The situation varies much among and within countries. Broadly speaking, there are high- and
low-crime countries in the region, and differences exist even within each of the sub-regions
(i.e., South America, Central America, and the Caribbean). However perceived insecurity and
citizens´ concern are independent of actual crime rates, so that mano dura policies are not
exclusive of high-crime countries.
In this context, we are confronted by a paradox: Why is it that, despite the democratization
process experienced in the region in the last 20 years, citizen security levels, as well as the justice
and security institutions in the region, are in crisis? Why is it that, despite the structural and
institutional reforms promoted by countries in the region in order to construct governance
mechanisms which are more transparent, horizontal and democratic, the justice and security
institutions are overwhelmed and confidence in them is shattered?
To begin to resolve this paradox and deal effectively with crime and violence, we need accurate
assessments that provide evidence for action. To this end, the United Nations Development
Programme, in association with governments, civil societies and international agencies, is lead-
ing numerous initiatives aimed at improving citizen security in Latin America and the Carib-
bean. This report is a one of these efforts. Drafted by a team of outstanding scholars building
upon previous research and practical experience, this report also reflects findings from the
analysis of extensive new survey data and sustained consultations involving over 450 experts,
practitioners and stakeholders in seven Dutch- and English-speaking Caribbean countries.
Of primary concern with citizen security is the issue of public confidence in state capacity to
protect citizens and ensure justice. If citizens lack confidence in the police, the judiciary and
other public authorities, no amount of repression will restore security. The success of any law
enforcement system depends on the willingness of the people to participate and contribute.
For the state to enjoy the trust and commitment of the people, it must strive to eradicate exclu-
sion, improve transparency and create opportunities that encourage a sense of belonging
for all.
A key message of the report is that Caribbean countries need to focus on a model of security
based on the human development approach, whereby citizen security is paramount, rather
than on the traditional state security model, whereby the protection of the state is the chief
aim. Indeed, the contrast between prevention on the one hand and repression and coercion
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 V
on the other is ill conceived. Social inclusion to help prevent crime and violence and efficient
and effective law enforcement are by no means incompatible or mutually exclusive. In a truly
democratic society, broad based social inclusion and swift criminal justice–or “prevention” and
“coercion”—serve to reinforce and complement each other. This is one of the most important
lessons to be taken from this report – and not only for the Caribbean but for all of Latin
America as well.
An issue of common interest to Latin America and the Caribbean is security. Organized trans-
national crime, mainly that which involves drug trafficking, looms large in the security crisis
currently affecting an increasing number of countries in both sub-regions. Although this re-
port concentrates on implications for the domestic dimensions of the problem in the Carib-
bean, especially among youth, it is also important to note that the Caribbean is a critical transit
route between drug producers and large-scale consumers. As a result of this geographical po-
sitioning, it is necessary for the Caribbean to strengthen cooperation with its Latin American
neighbours and project a larger voice in the global dialogue on existing policies and possible
alternatives.
An improved worldwide policy addressing the problem of addictive drugs could contribute
considerably to reducing levels of violence and social disruption in the Caribbean. This belief
is substantiated by an encouraging finding presented in the report: despite exceptionally high
homicide rates, the overall incidence of crime in the Caribbean as measured by the victimiza-
tion survey data “compares favourably at the lower end with countries such as Japan,” referring
to nations that participated in the 2004-2005 International Crime Victimization
Survey This suggests that the spiral of violence generally associated with drug trafficking exists
within the context of an otherwise durable social fabric that makes for lesser ordinary “street”
crime.
This is but one of the constructive insights readers of the Caribbean Human Development
Report 2012 will find. With its fresh prospective, solid data and rigorous analysis, this publica-
tion offers people from the Caribbean, along with those from Latin America and every other
region, many valuable lessons to apply in the ongoing effort of confronting crime and fostering
human development.
Heraldo Muñoz
Assistant Secretary-General of the United Nations,
Assistant Administrator of the United Nations Development Programme
and Regional Director for Latin America and the Caribbean
This groundbreaking report, the first regional Caribbean Human Development Report, rep-
resents an incredible collaboration across sectors of UNDP and non-UNDP experts, practi-
tioners, academics and policy-makers whose combined insight and dedication have made this
publication possible. Thus, the list of credits and thanks extends far beyond these pages, but
first and foremost goes to the UNDP Country Offices in the Caribbean and the UNDP Re-
gional Bureau for Latin America and the Caribbean for both financial and technical support
of this process since its inception.
Likewise, the UNDP Bureau for Development Policy contributed funding and expertise, and
the Human Development Report Office provided critical guidance and commentary. A spe-
cial appreciation is also in order for the UNDP Bureau for Crisis Prevention and Recovery for
its extensive and invaluable expert participation along with its financial backing.
Several teams and individuals were essential to the success of this production as well. Among
them are the technical committee that included Trevor Benn, Sandra Baptiste Caruth, Akiko
Fuji, Pablo Gago, Sonia Gill, Stein Hansen, Daniel Luz, Chisa Mikami, Paula Mohamed, Edo
Stork, and Alana Wheeler; the communications team comprised of Pablo Basz, Maria Blanco
Lora, Janine Chase, Franciois Coutu, Luke Paddington and Laura Raccio; the internal and exter-
nal readers Carmen de la Cruz, Alfredo Gonzalez, George Ronald, Natasha Leite, Jairo Matalla-
na, Gerardo Noto, Stefano Pettinato, Maria Tallarico, Hernando Gómez, Mitchell Seligson and
Oscar Yunowsky; the research and finance component with Danielle Brown, Estefania Grijalva,
Norma Peña, Querube Mora, Raj Ramnath and Cheryle Tewarie. A special appreciation is also
due to Minh Pham (Former UNDP Resident Representative Jamaica), Paula Hidalgo, and Pedro
Moreno who provided valuable inputs at onset of the preparation process.
The statistical team from the University of the West Indies was indispensible for the design
and implementation of the UNDP Citizen Security Survey 2010. Another important institu-
tional contributor was the Vanderbilt University Latin American Public Opinion Project (LA-
POP) that facilitated access to Caribbean LAPOP survey data and commented instructively
on methodology and results.
With the support of UNDP Country Offices and the UNDP Democratic Dialogue Regional
Project, a widespread series of consultations was conducted that involved over 450 government
officials, policy-makers, opposition members, academic researchers, civil society representatives,
and national and international development practitioners. A special effort was also made dur-
ing these consultations to include representatives of typically underrepresented groups such as
youth, women, Maroon communities and other populations facing potential discrimination. All
of the participants in these consultations provided vital qualitative data as well as insightful refer-
ences that were important for consolidating the findings and recommendations of the report. We
thank those who acted as chairs and repertoires of the working groups, Mobola Aguda-F, Charles
Clayton, Beverly Chase, Gianluca Giuman, Itziar Gonzalez, Lebrechtta Oye Hesse-Bayne, Meri-
am Hubard, Gaston Ian, Anna West, Rosemary Lall, Ruben Martoredjo Carol Narcisse, Rachida
Norden, Howie Prince, Philip Thomas, Joan Seymour and Stacey Syne.
A more detailed presentation of the background research, which was commissioned across
a broad range of topics and the complete list of participants attending the consultations, are
available online in the Caribbean HDR website http://www.regionalcentrelac-undp.org/en/
hdr-caribbean. Finally, we, the regional Caribbean HDR Team, would like to sincerely thank all
of those who were involved directly or indirectly in the research and compilation of this report.
We particularly want to express our gratitude to the survey respondents whose number reached
more than 11,000 and who generously supplied the responses that serve as the basis for the prepara-
tion of this report. The new regional insights provided in this publication are a reflection of the col-
lective investigative effort, while any errors of commission or omission are the sole responsibility of
the Report Team. We are all proud to have been instrumental in this pioneering endeavor and hope
it will pave the way for many Caribbean Human Development Reports to follow.
VIII C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Contents
Overview 1
Chapter 1 Crime Trends since Independence and the Impact on Vulnerable Groups 13
Introduction 15
The Caribbean Context 15
Human Development in the Caribbean Community 16
Trends in the Three Basic Dimensions of Human Development 17
The Inequality-Adjusted HDI 17
The Gender Inequality Index 17
Crime Trends since Independence 20
Crime Victimization 27
Determinants of Victimization 27
Domestic Violence and the Victimization of Women 29
Trafficking in Persons 31
Identification of Groups Vulnerable to Victimization 33
Fear of Crime 36
Perceptions of Security and Insecurity 36
Women’s Fear of Crime 39
Conclusion 41
Introduction 45
Youth Violence and Caribbean Human Development 45
Youth Involvement in Violent Crime 46
The Impact of Youth Violence on Caribbean Human Development 49
Risk and Vulnerability: Explaining the Patterns of Youth Violence 50
Societal Risks 52
Community and Interpersonal Risks 54
Individual Risks 56
Reducing Risk and Enhancing Resilience 57
Reducing Risk and Vulnerability 57
Enhancing Youth Resilience 58
Factors Supporting Risk Reduction and Resilience-Building 59
Conclusion 63
Chapter 3 Reducing the Contribution of Street Gangs
and Organized Crime to Violence 65
Introduction 67
Scope and Nature of the Problem 68
Prevalence of the Problem 68
The Sex and Age Composition of Caribbean Street Gangs 71
The Organizational Characteristics of Street Gangs 72
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 IX
The Consequences of Street Gangs and Organized Crime 73
The Causes of Street Gangs and Organized Crime 79
Community-Level Explanations 79
Individual-Level Explanations 82
Responding to Street Gangs and Organized Crime 83
Suppression 84
The Consequences and Limitations of Suppression 85
The Need for Intervention and Prevention 87
Conclusion 88
Introduction 93
Policing under Colonial Rule: State-Oriented Security 93
Modern-Day Policing: The Citizen Security Approach 94
The Police in the Caribbean 95
The Capability Challenges 95
The Integrity Imperative 96
The Rights-Respecting Imperative 96
Accountability 97
Changing the Relationship with Citizens: Community-Based Police 97
Developing Capacity: Advancing Police Training and Education 99
Regional Cooperation 100
Perceptions on the Police in the Caribbean Region 101
Perceived Police Legitimacy 103
Perceived Police Competence and Performance 105
Willingness of Citizens to Participate and Cooperate with the Police 108
Conclusion 114
Introduction 117
Criminal Justice Systems 117
Legal Systems 117
Prosecution and Defence 119
Correctional Systems 119
Statistical Infrastructure 122
Indicators of the Effectiveness of Criminal Justice Systems 122
Case Processing Delays and Backlogs 123
Low Conviction Rates 124
Prison Overcrowding 125
Insufficient Alternatives to Incarceration 126
Opinions on the Effectiveness of Justice Systems 129
Confidence in the Justice Systems 130
Mechanisms to Prevent and Control Crime 131
Accountability 133
Regulating Police Misconduct 133
Regulating Official Corruption 135
Regional Links 136
CARICOM 136
The Caribbean Court of Justice and the Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court 137
Regional Bodies Focused on Police, Prosecution, and Corrections 137
Additional Regional Efforts 138
Conclusion 138
Introduction 143
The Policy Environment 144
Crime and Insecurity in the Caribbean: The Policy Factor 144
The Evolution of Policy, Deterring Social Violence, and the War on Narco-Trafficking 145
The Shift in Policy Reflected in Budgetary Allocations 146
Explaining the Policy Shift 148
The Policy Orientation of the Population 152
The Policy Environment 152
Public Attitudes towards Crime and Punishment 153
The Salience of Crime in Public Opinion 153
Measure of Punitiveness 154
Social Tolerance and Ideals of Justice 155
Public Opinion on Mechanisms for Preventing and Controlling Crime 157
Balancing Crime Prevention and Crime Control 159
The Implications of Policy Responses 160
State Capacity and Citizen Security 163
Institutional Capacity 163
Building the Human Capacity for Development 164
Youth Unemployment and Social Prevention 167
Conclusion 170
Introduction 173
Conclusions 173
Existing Efforts 173
The Demand for Change 174
Directions for Future Efforts 175
Recommendations 175
Reducing Victimization 176
Reducing Risk and Building Youth Resilience 178
Reducing Gang Violence 181
Transforming the Police 182
Reforming the Justice System 184
Building the Capacity for Evidence-Based Policy 185
Notes 187
References 201
Boxes
Tables
“The advantage of economic growth is not access to tertiary education. There have been
that wealth increases happiness, but that it tremendous advances in reducing the levels of
increases the range of human choice.”1 These poverty and improving the standard of living
words were written in 1955 by Arthur Lewis, of the majority. These advances are reflected
a Caribbean scholar and Nobel laureate in eco- in the Human Development Index (HDI)
nomics who made an important contribution scores and rankings for these countries.
to the development debate and development There have also been advances in politi-
policy in the Caribbean and elsewhere. It is a cal development and democratic governance.
profoundly people-centred approach to eco- Car-ibbean countries are, with some excep-
nomic growth that prefigured the later debates tions, stable democracies with high levels of
on human development. If people are generally political participation and low and declining
regarded as the centre of the development pro- levels of political violence, which is, in the
cess in that their freedom of choice, standard main, associated with electoral cycles. Demo-
of living and general welfare are the purpose of cratic stability is evidenced by the repeated
development and their participation, creativ- uneventful changes in the political adminis-
ity and power in society, the economy and pol- trations in the countries of the region since
ity are the primary drivers of these outcomes, independence (with interruptions in Grenada
then these truths are important in Caribbean and Suriname).3 This stability in the electoral
countries, which are generally characterized system has been accompanied by the progres-
by small size and limited natural resources.2 sive consolidation of the rule of law. The re-
This meaning of human development, which duction of undue and unlawful political influ-
emphasizes freedoms and human choice, ences on law enforcement and the protection
is found in the work of the Indian develop- of the independence of the courts have been
ment economist Amartya Sen. Human devel- major achievements in political development
opment means the enlargement of people’s since the end of the colonial era.
freedom to lead lives they value. This revolves Despite these advances, several countries
around expanding choices and capabilities. in the region are beset by high rates of violent
The history and developmental aspirations of crime and troubling levels of non-criminalized
the Caribbean are truly connected with this forms of social violence that are typically di-
approach. rected at the members of vulnerable groups
Caribbean people now have a vastly wider that historically have been disfavoured and
range of choices than they had in the colonial discriminated against.4 If the purpose of devel-
era when Arthur Lewis wrote the words quot- opment is to widen human choice, the elevated
ed above. There have been significant advanc- rates of violent crime in the Caribbean may be
es in human development especially in health taken as evidence of problematic development
care and education. Since the 1960s, there paths that leave far too many behind because of
have been marked increases in life expectancy rather limited choices and limited life chances.
across most of the countries of the Caribbean Much of the crime that is evident in the region
and a similarly marked decline in infant mor- is, after all, the outcome of a limited range of
tality. There has been a virtual revolution in human choice, that is, the inequalities of op-
access to education. Secondary education is portunity that restrict these choices among
nearly universal, and there is much greater large sections of the populations of the region.
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 1
Within the region, crime may thus rightly be fice on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) and
regarded as a problem that is profoundly de- World Bank (2007), have made invaluable
velopmental. contributions to the better understanding of
Consistent with this understanding of the the problem, improving policy-making and
relationship between crime and development, potentially enhancing the effectiveness of
Amartya Sen, in the introduction to the glob- planning and programming in crime preven-
al Human Development Report of 2010, The tion and control at the national and regional
Real Wealth of Nations: Pathways to Human levels. This HDR attempts to build on these
Development, makes the point that, while efforts and to promote an explicitly develop-
much has been accomplished on a global scale mental approach to the security of people.
since the first Human Development Report This HDR does not aim to replicate or
in 1990, “the human development approach to improve on these efforts, but, rather, to
is motivationally committed to concentrat- extend them. There are unavoidable overlaps
ing on what remains undone—what demands between the HDR and these earlier reports,
most attention in the contemporary world— but this HDR reflects a deliberate attempt
from poverty and deprivation to inequality to minimize these overlaps. Therefore, this
and insecurity.”5 Insecurity is one of the issues HDR does not attempt to explore every as-
that demand greater attention in the human pect of the security situation in the region.
development process. Insecurity restricts the Thus, for example, the discussion of drug
capacity of people to exercise their freedom use and drug-trafficking is somewhat lim-
of choice and their autonomy. It reinforces ited, and, related to this, the discussion of
inequalities because it mainly affects vul- the transnational activity of organized crime
nerable people. It has a negative impact on networks is also limited. Indeed, the discus-
economic growth. If insecurity is related to sion of organized crime is largely restricted to
elevated rates of violent crime, as it is in the national dimensions and activities and, par-
case of the Caribbean, it reflects the limited ticularly, the violence that is generated. This
range of choices open to significant sections approach calls greater attention to the inter-
of society and the inequalities of opportunity nal roots of the problem and does so without
that prevail. Given the strong relationship minimizing the importance of international
among crime, insecurity and human develop- cooperation in tackling transnational organ-
ment in this region of highly vulnerable small ized crime networks and drug-trafficking.
and island micro-states and the importance Similarly, while the UNODC and World
of this issue to the people of the region, it is Bank report (2007) focuses on organized
most appropriate that the problems of crime crime, the HDR places greater emphasis on
and insecurity should demand the attention street gangs and their role in generating vio-
of the first Human Development Report on lence. Consistent with the intent to avoid re-
the Caribbean. tracing the paths followed by earlier reports,
A Time for Action, the report of the West the important issues of white-collar and cor-
Indian Commission (1993), was an attempt porate crime, as well as deportee or involun-
to address the challenges of Caribbean de- tarily returned migrants, are also excluded.6
velopment in a comprehensive way. Written The focus on violence and the responses or
in 1993, the report only briefly discussed the incapacity to respond effectively to violence
problem of insecurity, through a focus on ille- is a central concern of the report.
gal drugs. The decade of the 1990s was, how-
ever, a period in which the issue of insecu- The Caribbean
rity became more problematic in the region.
Subsequent regional reports, including the This is the first HDR on the Caribbean re-
reports of the Task Force on Crime and Se- gion. The Caribbean is diverse. It consists of
curity of the Caribbean Community (CARI- several subgroupings that may be categorized
COM 2002) and of the United Nations Of- in different ways. It may be subdivided by
1
CHAPTER
since Independence
and the Impact on
Vulnerable Groups
Proactive, pre-emptive
policies need to target at-risk
groups, eradicating violence
before it starts
of high rates of violence. Persistently high countries among the Dutch-speaking and
rates of violence in a single country or group English-speaking countries in the Caribbean,
of countries have the potential to damage the while, for many others, especially small island
reputations of all the countries of a region. developing states (SIDSs), the HDI was esti-
This is truly a regional issue and a regional mated for the first time only in 2010–2011.3
vulnerability. This represents a challenge in looking at HDI
Politically, the region underwent dra- trends in the region.
matic changes in response to powerful shifts The HDIs for the seven Caribbean coun-
in global and local values that began in the tries selected as the research sites for this re-
1960s with the Black Power Movement and port (the Caribbean-7) are presented in chart
continued into the 1970s with other social 1.1. The HDI for Barbados for 2011 is 0.793,
movements that were inspired by grass-roots positioning the country in the very high hu-
advocacy for social justice and social change. man development category and a rank of 47
The outcome was a shift to the left by some among 187 countries and territories. For the
states, such as Guyana, which adopted co- rest of the countries, with the exception of
operative socialism under Forbes Burnham, Suriname and Guyana, the HDI ranges be-
and Jamaica, which turned to democratic tween 0.764 and 0.723, positioning these in
socialism under Michael Manley. During the the high human development category. Suri-
1970s, the ideas associated with these social name and Guyana, with HDIs of 0.680 and
movements became, for a time, part of the 0.633, respectively, are in the medium human
political mainstream and profoundly influ- development category. Among the Carib-
enced the development policies of govern- bean-7, only Barbados, Antigua and Barbuda,
ments in the region. and Trinidad and Tobago have HDIs higher
In one of the outcomes, social sensibili- than the HDI for the Latin America and Car-
ties and public attitudes towards restraining ibbean (LAC) region (0.731).
moral values underwent dramatic changes To reflect more closely the specific charac-
beginning in the early 1970s. As the growing teristics of the Dutch-speaking and English-
population of young people became more as- speaking countries, we have estimated a 2011
sertive, claims for individual empowerment aggregated HDI that covers all CARICOM
and more open opportunity structures, espe- countries for which data are available.4 This
cially wider access to education, created great- represents the first attempt to estimate such
er pressure for social reform. This is reflected an HDI. The 2011 CARICOM estimated
in the comparatively better performance of HDI is 0.564, which is considerably lower
the countries of the Caribbean Community than the 2011 LAC HDI. Since the HDI is
(CARICOM) on international indicators a population-weighted index, the low value
such as the Human Development Index of the CARICOM HDI may be explained by
(HDI) and their ranking as middle-income the impact of Haiti, given the proportion of
countries.2 the CARICOM population accounted for by
Haiti (nearly 60 percent) in 2011. If the CAR-
Human Development in ICOM HDI is estimated without including
the Caribbean Community Haiti, the value shifts upwards (0.724), which
Human development measures rely on the better approximates the reality of the Dutch-
HDI, which is a summary measure for as- speaking and English-speaking countries and
sessing long-term progress in three basic is closer to the LAC HDI (0.731).
dimensions of human development: a long
and healthy life, access to knowledge and a
decent standard of living. The HDI has been
16 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Chart 1.1 Human Development Index, Caribbean-7, 2011 1
0.600
0.564
0.550 CARICOM
HDI
0.500
0.450
0.400
Barbados Antigua & Trinidad & Jamaica Saint Lucia Suriname Guyana
(47) Barbuda Tobago (79) (82) (104) (117)
(60) (62)
Source: Calculations of the UNDP Regional Centre for Latin America and the Caribbean based on International Human
Development Indicators (database), UNDP, New York, http://hdrstats.undp.org/en/tables/.
Antigua & Barbados Guyana Jamaica Saint Lucia Suriname Trinidad &
Barbuda (47) (117) (79) (82) (104) Tobago
(60) (62)
Source: Calculations of the UNDP Regional Centre for Latin America and the Caribbean based on International Human Development Indicators (database),
UNDP, New York, http://hdrstats.undp.org/en/tables/.
of reasonable quality allow.6 The GII shows some exceptions, countries in the region cur-
the loss in human development caused by in- rently have high debt ratios, high unemploy-
equality between the respective achievements ment rates and significant poverty rates. Gir-
of men and women in the three GII dimen- van (2011, citing CARICOM 2010a) reports
sions. The 2011 score on the GII has been that national poverty rates are 14.5 percent in
estimated for Trinidad and Tobago (0.331), Jamaica, 15.9 percent in Nevis, 16.7 percent
Barbados (0.364), Jamaica (0.450), and Guy- in Trinidad and Tobago, 18.4 percent in Anti-
ana (0.551). The scores reflect a percentage gua and Barbuda, 27.0 percent in Saint Kitts,
loss in achievement across the three dimen- 28.8 percent in Saint Lucia and 37.7 percent
sions that arises because of gender inequality in Grenada.7 The majority of the region’s poor
of 33.1, 36.4, 45.0 and 55.1 percent, respec- live in rural areas.8 UNDP (2004) finds that
tively. Trinidad and Tobago, as well as Barba- there is considerable variation and uneven-
dos, experienced the least loss, while Guyana ness in the poverty profile of countries in
experienced the greatest loss. In the case of the region, as well as significant disparities in
Jamaica and Guyana, the loss is higher than wealth distribution.
the LAC average (44.5 percent). Women have made important advances in
Advances in social policy that are rep- education, labour force participation, political
resented in the HDI measurements noted participation and equality before the law, but
above may be compromised by poor econom- gender inequalities persist.9 The economic sec-
ic performance and high debt burden. With tors that have traditionally provided employ-
18 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
ment and contributed to the livelihoods of poor As the discussion above illustrates, the
women and their families, such as agriculture growth of violent crime in the Caribbean 1
and light industries, have experienced signifi- region is one manifestation of declines on
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
have been subjected to globalization and fairly and gang conflicts. The third stage also evi-
rapid modernization. These forces have also fos- dences an increase in violent crimes such as
tered social instability and rising rates of violent homicide, more firearm-related offences and
crime. As the literature on modernization and violence against women. This is not the inevi-
development confirms, modernization has con- table trajectory of other Caribbean countries.
tradictory effects. On the one hand, it enhances Indeed, several other Caribbean countries
economic growth and living standards. On the have not followed this path, but they have
other, it fosters social mobility that may widen been variously affected by the drug trade
the gulf between rich and poor, thereby height- and gang violence, and, in several countries,
ening the sense of relative deprivation among there was a clearly discernable turn towards
marginalized groups. Indeed, a deep sense of higher rates of homicide and other categories
relative deprivation may well have an impact of violent crime during the first decade of the
on the crime rate precisely because it fosters, 2000s. During the consultations that were
among marginalized groups, outrage and the part of the process of producing this report,
search for remedies to injustice by any means.12 participants repeatedly expressed concern re-
The increase in criminal violence across the re- garding the elevated levels of violence in their
gion threatens the post-independence develop- countries and in the region.
ment trajectory of most nations and will have In some Caribbean countries, aggregate
consequences in the attainment of or the poor crime rates are falling. Prior to 1990, with
performance in global indicators such as the some exceptions, the Caribbean was charac-
Millennium Development Goals, as well as in terized by low rates of violent crime, and the
national development plans. ratio of property crimes to violent crimes ap-
The changes in post-independence environ- proximated the rates in developed countries.
ments have coincided to impact the region’s For more than a decade, violent crimes have
security landscape. This includes the economic been on a downward trend in most parts
consequences of structural adjustment pro- of the world. Harrendorf, Heiskanen, and
grammes in several countries. In addition, the Malby (2010) report that, in countries where
region has been affected by the violence associ- trend data are available, the majority show de-
ated with and emerging from political competi- creasing or stable homicide rates. In the Car-
tion, growth in the drug trade and, more recent- ibbean, however, the trend in violent crime
ly, gang-related violence. High levels of violence has been moving in the opposite direction; it
represent a break from the colonial pattern of has been increasing.
criminal offending, which was characterized Despite the rising rates of violent crime,
by high rates of property crime and low rates of there are variations in the structure of crime
violent crime. Jamaica was the first country to and the complexity of crime problems across
break with this pattern and consistently exhibit the Caribbean countries. In some countries,
high rates of violent crime. property crime rates continue to outstrip vio-
In a discussion of crime trends in Jamaica, lent crime rates. A review of the current struc-
Harriott (1996), identifies three discernable ture of crime throughout the region shows
stages in the development of criminality in countries such as Barbados, Saint Lucia, and
independent Jamaica. The first was a continu- Antigua and Barbuda with low violent crime
ity with the colonial era in terms of the struc- rates, but high rates of property crime.13 Prop-
ture of crime, that is, a continuation of a pat- erty crimes such as burglaries are often asso-
tern that was dominated by property crime ciated with inequalities, especially relative
rather than violent crime. The second stage poverty.
was associated with a clear turn towards vio- Homicides: Homicide is one of the most
lence (largely due to the growth in drug-traf- reliably and consistently recorded crimes.14
20 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Chart 1.4 Homicide Rates Per 100,000 Population, Caribbean-7, 1990–2010 1
60
50
40
Rate
30
20
10
0
1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010
Sources: Royal Antigua and Barbuda Police Force; Royal Barbados Police Force; Guyana Police Force; Jamaica Constabulary Force, Statistics Division; Royal
Saint Lucia Police Force, Crime and Problem Analysis Branch; Trinidad and Tobago Police Service.
The patterns exhibited in the associated crime rates were relatively low and stable in the
rates may therefore be discussed with consider- other five across the 1990–2000 period. Since
able confidence. During the pre-independence then, the homicide rate has risen substantially
period, Caribbean homicide rates were com- in Trinidad and Tobago and fluctuated, but
parable with and, in some instances, lower trended mostly upward in Antigua and Bar-
than the rates in other developing countries. buda, Guyana, and Saint Lucia. Barbados has
After independence and prior to the 1990s, experienced some fluctuation, but tended to
homicide rates within the region were below have a low and stable rate across the 20-year
the global average.15 By 1990, however, Latin period of 1990–2010.
America and the Caribbean had an average Some of the conditions that influence
homicide rate of 22.9 per 100,000 citizens, and homicide rates across the Caribbean region
the region was ranked first in the homicide rate include, but are not limited to crime clearance
among regions of the world.16 rates, levels of development, low rates of eco-
As depicted in chart 1.4, there has been nomic growth, and the proportion of young
considerable variation in the homicide rates men in the population.17 Drug-trafficking (in
across time in the countries of the Carib- some concrete contexts) and weapons avail-
bean-7 on which trend data are available. ability are also associated with high homicide
Jamaica has had particularly high per capita rates.
homicide rates and is ranked among the most The RTFCS report identifies increased ac-
violent countries worldwide. The homicide cess to firearms and the greater involvement of
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 21
youth in crimes as conditions influencing the as Barbados, there has been a rise in firearm-
1 commission of crimes in the region. Increased related offences. Between 1975 and 2010, the
insecurity can be related to gun ownership. use of firearms increased in Barbados, and,
Crime Trends since Independence and the Impact on Vulnerable Groups
On the one hand, it can lead to a rise in the despite a decline in firearm-related offence
number of legal registration applications for rates between 2000 and 2009, the rates have
firearms. On the other hand, insecurity also remained above the levels of the 1990s. Since
arises from the spread of legal and illegal fire- 1997, Trinidad and Tobago has seen a steady
arms, a condition that is now manifest in the increase, which peaked in 2005 at 66 offences
rise in firearm-related offences. per 100,000 population. All three jurisdic-
Firearm-related offences: Across the Car- tions showed a reduction in rates in the last
ibbean, deaths and injuries because of gun three years of the data period, but the rates in
violence have been exacerbated by the ready all remain significantly above the 1990 rates.
availability and misuse of firearms. The im- The LAC region is disproportionately af-
pact is being witnessed predominantly in fected by small arms violence. This type of vio-
nations such as Guyana, Haiti, Jamaica, and lence accounted for 42 percent of all firearm-
Trinidad and Tobago, but, regionwide, fire- related deaths worldwide. The Caribbean is,
arms are being used more often in the com- however, not a major producer, exporter, or
mission of crimes. consumer of legal firearms. Indeed, between
Chart 1.5 shows the rate of firearm-relat- 2004 and 2006, only 3 percent of global arms
ed offences in Barbados, Jamaica, and Trini- trade transfers involved the Caribbean.18 Gun
dad and Tobago, the only nations on which violence is related to the ease of access to US
data are available. The rates have consistently markets for firearms and to narcotics traffick-
been highest in Jamaica. However, even in ing, as well as governmental inability to se-
jurisdictions with low rates of violence, such cure the borders, which are issues intricately
80
70
60
50
Rate
40
30
20
10
0
1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010
Sources: Royal Antigua and Barbuda Police Force; Royal Barbados Police Force; Jamaica Constabulary Force, Statistics Division; Trinidad and Tobago Police
Service.
600
500
400
Rate
300
200
100
0
1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010
Sources: Royal Antigua and Barbuda Police Force; Royal Barbados Police Force; Guyana Police Force; Jamaica Constabulary Force, Statistics Division; Royal
Saint Lucia Police Force, Crime and Problem Analysis Branch; Trinidad and Tobago Police Service.
4500
4000
3500
3000
Rate
2500
2000
1500
500
0
1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010
Antigua & Barbuda Barbados Jamaica Trinidad & Tobago Saint Lucia
Sources: Royal Antigua and Barbuda Police Force; Royal Barbados Police Force; Jamaica Constabulary Force, Statistics Division; Royal Saint Lucia Police Force,
Crime and Problem Analysis Branch; Trinidad and Tobago Police Service.
burglaries and robberies, crimes that involve groups. This is a general trend that does not
high social, economic and personal costs apply to every country. Prenzler and Towns-
among victims. As chart 1.7 shows, there has ley (1996) have reviewed the literature and
been a long downward trend in burglaries. suggest that affluent homes often attract
While Trinidad and Tobago saw low and sta- skilled professional burglars, while homes
ble burglary rates, Barbados and Saint Lucia and businesses in poorer areas are vulnerable
saw somewhat higher, but stable rates over to burglaries committed by individuals who
1990–2010. The burglary rate in Jamaica fell live nearby. Demographically, households
significantly from a higher level, and the rate in lower socio-economic areas are the most
in Antigua and Barbuda mirrored this behav- vulnerable, but burglary rates are also high in
iour, but from an even higher initial rate. The communities that lack social cohesion. The
low recent rates for Jamaica may be attributed number of people in a household, marital sta-
to underreporting. tus, housing type, and time of day also impact
Economists and criminologists have long the likelihood of a burglary.25
discussed the impact of economic condi- Another set of insecurity-generating
tions on crime. Development affects crime, crimes worth examining is gender-based vio-
but crimes of violence and theft are affected lence. Across the Caribbean, three specific
differentially. Specifically, as development in- practices have become a significant concern
creases, violent crimes decrease, while crimes primarily regarding women and the girl-child,
of theft increase across all socio-economic although data generated by the Citizen Secu-
24 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
rity Survey 2010 suggest that smaller shares of Not every violent act that a woman may
men also fear becoming the victims of these experience encompasses gender-based vio- 1
practices. These are sexual violence, domestic lence.28 Instead, the term ‘gender-based’ ac-
120
100
80
Rate
60
40
20
0
1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009
Sources: Royal Antigua and Barbuda Police Force; Royal Barbados Police Force; Jamaica Constabulary Force, Statis-
tics Division; Royal Saint Lucia Police Force, Crime and Problem Analysis Branch; Trinidad and Tobago Police Service.
rapes and indecent assaults accounted for as UNODC and World Bank (2007), drawing
much as 20 percent of the country’s violent on United Nations crime trend data for various
crime rate. 33 years, state that 3 of the top 10 recorded rape
Rape is one of the most underreported rates occur in the Caribbean. Among Caribbean
crimes worldwide. The underreporting tran- countries on which there are available and com-
scends age, race, class and geography. Accord- parable data, each showed a rape rate that was
ing to worldwide estimates, 60 percent of all higher than the unweighted average of the full
sexual crimes go unreported, and one in three set of 102 countries in the study. A comparison
women will be raped, beaten, forced into sex, shows significant differences in incidence rates
or otherwise assaulted in her lifetime.34 In across rape statistics as measured by reports to
countries such as Guyana, Jamaica, and Trini- police, hospital records and surveys. In general,
dad and Tobago, the risk of sexual victimiza- the number of self-reported rapes in victimiza-
tion increases in specific geographical areas tion surveys is approximately 25 percent greater
and among specific subpopulations.35 than the number known by or reported to the
Across the Caribbean, rape rates are rela- police.37 It is even more difficult to estimate rates
tively high, and clearance rates on cases are for some of the other sexual offences.
low; so, by extension, conviction rates are also Regionwide, violence against women is
low.36 For example, during the period 1970 to disproportionately borne by youth and sig-
2009, the average clearance rate for cases of nificantly impacts the girl-child. Amnesty In-
rape and carnal abuse in Jamaica was 48 per- ternational (2008) finds that, in 2004, seventy
cent. It declined from 62 percent in 1970, was percent of all reported sexual assaults in Ja-
lowest, at 35 percent, in 1995, and then rose maica were committed against girls rather than
to 50 percent in 2009. women. LAC is the region with the highest
26 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
proportion of adolescent females who claim spondents are important for understanding
to have had their sexual debut before age 15, the risk of victimization. As chart 1.10 shows, 1
at 22 percent; there are no equivalent figures three groups were significantly more likely to
Suriname
Jamaica
Guyana
Caribbean-7
Females 9.3
Males 12.0
Employed 10.4
Unemployed/ 12.5
Seasonally Employed
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
Percent
Robbery at 2.2
gunpoint 3.4
1.6
Assault with a
weapon 3.8
Female Male
20
17.3
15.7
15
10
8.3
5.9
5
0
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
22.7
14.3
Female
13.2
10.7
19.0
8.8
Male
9.7
6.7
20.9
11.6
Caribbean-7
11.4
8.6
0 5 10 15 20 25
Percent
physical injury (reported by 9 percent). Do- ical violence and psychological aggression. The
mestic violence is experienced by both males Multiple Indicator Cluster Surveys for Guyana
and females, but, as chart 1.13 shows, females (2006-2007) and Suriname (2006), as well as
experience all forms of violence at higher McDonald (2008), who presents findings of
rates than males. the 2008 Reproductive Health Survey in Ja-
Psychological abuse is often downplayed maica, indicate that there are entrenched at-
by victims, policy makers and the media. How- titudes held by men and women according to
ever, evidence exists that psychological abuse is which it is justified to use violence in response
often a precursor to physical abuse and, in its to violations of expectations about gender
myriad manifestations, can be as devastating roles.45 Thus, the progression from aggressive
as physical abuse.44 Le Franc et al. (2008), in a abuses such as pushing and insults to more
three-country Caribbean study, find high lev- serious physical violence is cause for concern,
els of interpersonal violence, which they sug- and efforts need to be undertaken to disrupt
gest may be indicative of an entrenched culture this progression.
of violence and adversarial intimate relation- In response to this problem, CARICOM
ships. They also report significant between- has developed model legislation on issues af-
country differences in the overall level of phys- fecting women; three of these initiatives spe-
America and Europe, and as destination areas world, including poverty, lack of economic
for both internal and intraregional flows.53 opportunities, marginalization, violence, il-
The scale of the problem in the Caribbean literacy, gender discrimination, homeless-
region has not been properly estimated, but ness, some distinctive vulnerability factors
trafficking in persons appears to have become have been identified in Latin America and
a particular problem in some countries in the the Caribbean. These include gang affiliation,
region. While trafficking occurs in a variety persistent substance abuse and births among
of exploitative forms, forced labour, domestic girls under the age of 18 years.59 With regard
servitude and sex exploitation are believed to to children, who are often sexually exploited
be the most common manifestations in the for the financial benefit of their families, lack
Caribbean. Sex exploitation seems to be the of awareness of the risks, a history of sexual
most predominant form. abuse of children and parental migration
Most victims trafficked for the purposes of resulting in child abandonment have been
sexual exploitation are women and girls, who found to be additional push-pull factors in
are usually found eventually to be involved in some Caribbean countries.60
prostitution, exotic dancing, massages, por- In the Caribbean, the organization of the
nography and other related activities. Evidence trafficking of persons and the main actors in-
suggests that, while boys and young men are volved are not well understood, but, in the
more at risk of becoming victims of traffick- larger Latin American and Caribbean region,
ing for labour exploitation, especially in the organized crime groups have become signifi-
agricultural, construction and mining sectors, cant actors. They use trafficking in persons to
some are also trafficked for sexual exploita- fund other illicit activities. Increasingly, traf-
tion and domestic servitude.54 Across the re- ficked victims are at risk of contracting HIV/
gion, the number of children that are sexually AIDS and other diseases. Migrant communi-
exploited may be increasing, and the average ties are especially vulnerable to trafficking.61 It
age may be decreasing. Women are typically has also been found that minority and indig-
trafficked internationally, while children are enous populations face specific vulnerabilities
most often trafficked within their own coun- to trafficking.
tries. The trafficking of children and children UNODC and UN.GIFT (2008) have iden-
vulnerable to commercial sexual exploitation tified lack of knowledge, an inadequate national
are most common in popular tourist desti- legal framework, ineffective policy and capacity
nations and centres of sex tourism.55 Indeed, to respond, limited protection of and assistance
the growing demand for sex tourism is largely for victims, and poor international cooperation
considered the primary factor contributing to as the primary challenges to efforts to eradicate
sex trafficking in Latin America and the Carib- trafficking in persons. A number of Dutch-
bean, particularly in relation to minors.56 With speaking and English-speaking Caribbean
regard to the Caribbean countries, for most of countries have ratified the Protocol to Prevent,
which tourism constitutes a major industry, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Es-
research suggests that trafficking cases exist pecially Women and Children (2000), which
within the sex tourism industry.57 is attached to the United Nations Convention
In 2005, the International Organization on Transnational Organized Crime, includ-
for Migration identified unsecured borders, ing Jamaica (2003), Guyana (2004), Suriname
lax enforcement of rules on entertainment (2007), and Trinidad and Tobago (2007).62 All
visas and work permits, legalized prostitution countries are also signatories of various anti-traf-
and the tourism industry as contributors to ficking and forced labour–related conventions,
the problem.58 While most of the push-pull such as the Convention on the Elimination of
risk factors for trafficking in persons primar- all Forms of Discrimination against Women
32 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
and the CARICOM Declaration on the Vulnerable groups face threats arising from
Rights of the Child 2008. However, the Le- discrimination, exploitation, or displacement. 1
gal Review on Trafficking in Persons in the They are stigmatized relative to others mainly
perpetrator and the type of victimization. Regionwide, children face increased vul-
The United Nations Population Fund lists 16 nerability to sexual crimes, domestic violence,
forms of gender-based violence. Worldwide, trafficking, child labour, commercial sexual
patterns of violence indicate that women’s exploitation, sexually transmitted infections
vulnerability to these forms of gender-based and early sexual initiation. Groups of children
violence, especially intimate partner violence identified as especially vulnerable are abused
and sexual violence by other perpetrators, children, children of absent parents, children
is greater. Women and men are thus also af- in minority groups such as Guyana’s Amerin-
fected differentially by crime. Women are dians and Suriname’s Maroon communities,
more likely to be killed or sexually assaulted children in poor households, children living
by someone they know. In addition, because in inner-city communities, disabled children,
fear of victimization can be disempowering, and children of parents who are disabled,
it has the potential to constrain the ability have mental health problems, or suffer from
to participate fully in society. This is partly drug or alcohol abuse.
why gendered vulnerabilities must be taken Across the region, there is concern for
seriously by the state and why gender-based the safety of children in institutional care, in
violence must be reduced. children’s homes and other custodial settings
Approximately half of all households in the and in correctional institutions. In many of
Caribbean are headed by women, who must these institutions, children are often placed
therefore shoulder the responsibility for both alongside adult residents, which is a violation
productive and reproductive work. Women of the Convention on the Rights of the Child
also have longer life expectancies than men. because this exposes the child to physical and
Together, these factors contribute to the femi- sexual violence.70
nization of poverty.67 Women who live in pov- Youth: Across the Caribbean, youth are
erty experience additional vulnerabilities, such the primary victims and perpetrators of
as higher infant mortality rates, higher likeli- crime. According to CARICOM (2010b),
hood of early pregnancy, lower school enrol- crime and violence associated with poverty,
ment, lower employment rates, and increased unemployment, and other political and social
likelihood of experiencing violence. Poverty is inequities remain the number one concerns
the typical condition of single mothers, elderly among adolescents and youth in the Carib-
women and disabled women.68 bean Community. Levels of youth unemploy-
Children: Within the Caribbean, chil- ment in the region are among the highest in
dren are disproportionately affected by the world, and the education system does not
crime and violence.69 Published by UNICEF prepare youth adequately for the regional and
(2006), the United Nations Secretary-Gen- global labour market. Youth violence affects
eral’s Study on Violence against Children victims, families, friends and communities.
highlights a range of physical, emotional and In addition to death or injury, there are nega-
social abuse children experience in homes tive psychological outcomes such as a poorer
and families, communities, schools, institu- quality of life, reduced productivity and gen-
tions, and work situations. They are witnesses erally disrupted lives.
to and victims of violence across all the major Youth-related vulnerabilities and insecuri-
social institutions and in the media: domestic ties have also emerged because of an upward
violence, child abuse and neglect, and cor- trend in drug-trafficking, the spread of HIV/
poral punishment at home and in school. In AIDS, adolescent pregnancies, gang involve-
some jurisdictions, there has been an increase ment, and access to and use of firearms. While
in the number of children killed and a rise in crime is typically male-on-male and youth-
the number of children who are victims and on-youth, young girls face the added burden
on Human Rights, and the Citizen Security Tobago are high, and respondents in these
and Justice Programme of the Inter-American countries expressed more negative feelings
Development Bank. Their work can strength- about security.
en the knowledge base on citizen security and Caribbean citizens are sensitive to is-
aid creative policy-making. sues of safety and security. The insecurity
can be measured by the fear of crime, that
Fear of Crime is, the feelings and subsequent behaviours
of citizens in response to perceived criminal
Citizen security refers to the freedom from threats. Chadee, Austen, and Ditton (2007)
physical violence and to the freedom from characterize this as differential sensitivity
fear of violence.75 It encompasses security at to risk. Insecurity is manifest in a feeling of
home, in the workplace and in political, so- safety only in specific places, a willingness to
cial, and economic interactions with the state engage in only specific activities and the tak-
and other members of society. ing of protective actions based upon the fears
generated.
Perceptions of Security and Insecurity The affective aspects of fear are assessed
Public opinion polls and surveys have gen- by asking people about the level of worry or
erally provided means to assess the public’s fear they feel about the possibility they will
perception of crime and insecurity. However, become victims of crime. Across all countries,
while there are some national and regional 48 percent of respondents to the Citizen Se-
surveys, there is no consistent regional assess- curity Survey 2010 had worried at some time
ment in the Caribbean, nor is there system- about becoming victims of crime. House-
atic participation throughout the Caribbean breaking (41.3 percent) and robbery (33.7
in international standardized surveys such percent) were the most frequent among eight
as the International Crime Victims Survey. crimes possibly facing communities; so, it is
Harrendorf, Heiskanen, and Malby (2010) not surprising that these two crimes created
rank the Caribbean as the second most vio- the greatest level of insecurity. Chart 1.14
lent region of the world. Central America is shows the percentages of respondents in each
the first. Violent crimes increase insecurity country who said they worried about each
and create challenges for regional develop- crime all or most of the time. The data indi-
ment. How secure do Caribbean citizens feel cate that the fear of victimization associated
in the face of the crime profile documented with the two crimes was highest in Guyana
in police records and the victimization data (47 percent) and lowest in Barbados (14 per-
presented in this chapter? cent).
The Citizen Security Survey 2010 con- Primary insecurities emerge from the
ducted for this report asked respondents perception that burglary is highly likely to
about their perception of security. As shown occur and, more importantly, that the crime
in chart 1.3 nearly 46 percent of all respond- constitutes a violation of the home, a space
ents reported that they felt secure or very se- considered private. In addition, there are
cure. The sense of security ranged from a low psychological consequences of burglary that
of 25 percent in Trinidad and Tobago to a relate to the fear that one will be victimized
high of 79 percent in Barbados. The feelings again. Robbery at gunpoint is more terrifying
of security were negatively correlated with to the victim because of the arbitrariness and
the level of violent crime, especially homicide unpredictability of the situation.
rates, in a country. For example, Barbados Across the surveyed countries, 73 per-
and Suriname record low levels of officially cent of respondents felt safe walking in their
reported violent crime, and high percentages neighbourhoods during the day; 65 percent
36 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Chart 1.14 Fear of Burglary and Robbery, Caribbean-7, 2010 1
24.5 25.0
25
22.4 22.6 22.8
20.9 20.5
20 19.3 19.1
17.9 18.2
16.6
15 14.2
Percent
11.2
10 8.4
5.2
5
0
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
House Broken into at Night Robbed at Gunpoint
felt safe at home after dark; 61 percent felt Carrying a weapon is an extreme response
safe at work; and 50 percent felt safe walking that could escalate the potential of victimiza-
in their neighbourhoods at night. tion, that is, concern for safety may encour-
Behavioural aspects of fear relate to the age weapon-carrying behaviour; however,
extent to which people modify their behav- weapon-carrying may also reduce the concern
iour in response to their level of fear. This for safety and thus increase both vulnerability
includes protective strategies such as changes and the likelihood of victimization. Weap-
in routine to avoid activities and locations ons, especially gun ownership, may also be
that are perceived to increase the risk of being part of a self-help tradition that has devel-
victimized or such as ‘target hardening’ (for oped because of a lack of access to the legal
example, carrying pepper spray or installing system.76 Thus, building institutional capacity
security devices in the home). The Citizen Se- to enhance the public’s sense of security may
curity Survey 2010 reveals that the major be- significantly reduce the fear of crime and, by
havioural changes included keeping a weapon extension, the reliance of citizens on weapon-
at home (23 percent of all respondents) and carrying for protection.
carrying a weapon at night (9 percent) (chart Jackson and Gray (2010) point out that
1.15). insecurity need not be debilitating. Instead,
35
31.4
30
26.8
25
23.0
22.3
21.1 21.1
20 19.6
16.0 8.4
Percent
15
12.5
0
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
Keep a Weapon at Home Travel with a Weapon at Night
it can motivate vigilance and routine pre- community decreases trust among peers and
caution or problem-solving to increase per- neighbours. Distrust hinders social capital
sonal and collective safety. For example, the and possible civic participation. Citizen per-
results of the Citizen Security Survey 2010 ceptions of the government’s ability to ensure
show that, across the region, 5 percent of re- freedom from crime are also an integral part
spondents moved to a more secure location in of feeling secure. Across the Caribbean-7,
2009; 11 percent put in a security device; and there was general optimism on this point: 41
72 percent indicated that their communities percent of the respondents to the Citizen Se-
had taken steps to address the crime problem. curity Survey 2010 expressed the belief that
However, the extent to which they mobilize their country had sufficient capacity to solve
to solve problems within their communities or manage the problem of insecurity.
is affected by their perception of social sta- The levels and patterns of fear of crime
bility, moral consensus and informal control documented through the survey indicate that
processes. only a small percentage of the respondents
Citizens are concerned about trouble were fearful of being killed, and fewer than
in the neighbourhood and the physical en- one-fifth were seriously worried about hav-
vironment. Perception of crime within the ing their homes broken into or being robbed
38 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
at gunpoint. Overwhelmingly, the survey of crime in the Caribbean. These findings
participants expressed feelings of safety at should, however, not be understood to indi- 1
home, at work and in their neighbourhoods cate an essential or naturally occurring fearful-
Female Male
25
20 19.1
15
Percent
12.2
6.7 7.4
5.0 5.7
5 4.5 3.5
3.0 3.8 2.5 2.8
1.6
0
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
Beaten-up by Spouse /Partner Sexually Assaulted
being sexually assaulted in some fashion; one- is matched by outrage about the victimization
third of this subgroup also fear being beaten of women and girls. This paradox may partial-
by a spouse or partner (chart 1.17). ly be explained by the highly individualistic
The Citizen Security Survey 2010 asked and deeply religious cultures in the region.
about the likelihood that members of one’s Concern for individual rights, a political
community would intervene in a suspected culture of democracy, and widespread piety
case of domestic violence. Of the respond- often lead to protection for victims and vul-
ents, 45 percent said an intervention would nerable populations. This concern for rights
be made. Implied in the question was that an is most notable among sections of the Carib-
intervention would stop or prevent violence bean population, both working class and the
against women. This finding highlights a wealthier class, that are law-abiding, church-
contradictory aspect of Caribbean popular going and justice-seeking. In such cases, as the
culture on matters pertaining to the status of data show, sizeable minorities can be counted
women. Despite the general indifference to on not only to condemn, but also to inter-
the plight of women in the region and broad vene against the victimization and demeaning
complicity in what might be deemed a rape treatment of women, girls and other vulner-
culture, the prevailing attitudes on the status able groups.
of women, recognition of their victimization, Community activism is important in a
and concern regarding their fears are far more context where the general perception of per-
complicated. Hence, indifference to women formance and the confidence in the police’s
40 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
ability to control domestic violence and rape the capacity of their institutions to respond
are not high. Among women who were physi- effectively to these problems. 1
cally or sexually abused in 2009 and reported The increase in violent crimes has been
Antigua & 0.9 0.5 2.3 2.3 0.0 4.6 6.5 82.9
Barbuda
non-violent offences. Meanwhile, young men been accused or arrested for violent crimes was
are more likely than young women to be in low (0 percent with weapons, and 1.9 percent
conflict with the law for violent offences. without). It should be noted, though, that, in
In the context of the survey, only 1.6 per- absolute terms, the actual number of cases in all
cent of youth between 18 and 24 years of age countries was small.
had been accused or arrested for violent crimes Six key patterns associated with the in-
involving the use of weapons, and only 2.5 per- cidence of youth violence were observed
cent for violent crimes without weapons. The through the UNDP Citizen Security Survey
variations across countries are highlighted in 2010. We now list these.
table 2.2. The variations across countries are First, youth violence has a gender dimen-
highlighted in table 2.2. The highest propor- sion. Across the region, the majority of ag-
tions of reported youth violence occurred in gressors and victims are young men who use
Saint Lucia (2.7 percent with weapons and 4.3 violence for protection against threats—real
without), followed by Guyana (1.4 percent with or perceived—or who have been socialized
weapons and 4.2 percent without), Trinidad into a male-dominated tradition of conflict
and Tobago (3 percent with weapons, and 2.6 resolution through violence. At the same time,
percent without) and Barbados (4 percent with young women are victims of verbal and physi-
weapons, and 1.3 percent without), despite the cal violence, particularly in the interpersonal
country´s reputation for low levels of violent and domestic spheres. Relative to men, almost
crime. Notwithstanding Jamaica’s regional and twice the proportion of women reported being
international reputation for relatively high levels threatened by spouses, partners, or ex-partners
of violence, the proportion of Jamaican youth (14 percent of young women compared with
survey respondents who reported they had 7.5 percent of young men). This reinforces the
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 47
“We feel more secure point that young men are predominantly the of victimization has contributed to the for-
2 when we form gangs in violent aggressors among Caribbean youth. In mation of delinquent groups and gangs in
addition, the majority of youth reporting fear schools, as students seek to defend themselves
Youth Violence: Reducing Risk and Enhancing Resilience
Country Year Youth Direct Forgone Forgone Opportunity Total cost, Total
15–24 costs, earnings, tourism costs, US$ US$ cost, %
convicted, US$ US$ revenue, GDP
total US$
Trinidad and Tobago, decreasing youth crimes recognized internationally by the United Na-
by 1% could increase tourism revenues by tions in the context of monitoring the imple-
nearly 35 million USD yearly.” mentation of the World Programme of Ac-
Linked with estimates of the costs of tion for Youth.16 In other areas of the world,
low educational achievement and poor progress has been made towards analysing
health status among youth, these fig- these relationships through the correlation of
ures represent a good contribution to our a youth development index and the Human
understanding of the youth crime and vio- Development Index.17 However, to date, no
lence–human development nexus. However, Caribbean country has formulated a youth de-
the estimates do not account for the non- velopment index. Such an instrument would
monetary costs of youth violence. Thus, there certainly enhance the regional capacity to
are certainly social costs of youth violence, in- measure the contribution of advances in youth
cluding physical and psychological pain, suf- development to national and regional develop-
fering and trauma, the erosion of social capital, ment, including reductions in youth crime and
the intergenerational transmission of vio- violence. The lack of national and regional data
lence, and lower quality of life.15 There are also management frameworks to support evidence-
political costs associated with the labelling, based planning and programmes for youth is
marginalization and exclusion of at-risk or addressed elsewhere below in our discussion
problem youth from participation in govern- on approaches to building resilience. We turn
ance, the economy and society. The general attention at this point to an examination of the
labelling of youth holds potential for encour- contextual factors that have contributed to the
aging negative stereotyping, which can be patterns of youth violence and victimization
internalized by youth, causing frustration and outlined above.
fuelling aggressive behaviour.
There is still a lack of appropriate data in the Risk and Vulnerability:
“Youth are assets in the Caribbean to permit rigorous analysis of the Explaining the Patterns of Youth Violence
relationships among youth development, hu-
development process but man development, and youth violence and An explanation of the patterns of youth vio-
remain vulnerable to risk.” delinquency. The need for these data has been lence and its impact on human development
50 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
requires a discussion of the factors that give development context to predispose youth to
rise to the violence in light of the considera- violent behaviour and expose youth to victimi- 2
tion that youth are inherently vulnerable as- zation.
13.5
13.2
Cost of food
Unemployment
er levels. However, concerns remain about the cent for English). These outcomes are wor-
increasing rates of school drop-outs and de- risome given the acknowledged correlation
clining levels of educational attainment, par- between declining educational achievement
ticularly among boys. Data of the Caribbean and increasing levels of violence in society.27
Examinations Council show that overall pass Departure from school without the requisite
rates in the basic subjects of mathematics and skills and abilities increases the likelihood of
English at the secondary school level have de- youth exposure to and experience of other
clined and declined more significantly among risk factors, including higher levels of unem-
boys.25 On average between 1997 and 2009, ployment, teen pregnancy, risky sexual activ-
the pass rate in mathematics fell by over 8.0 ity and substance abuse, which contribute
percent among boys and by about 2.5 percent to other problem behaviours among youth.
among girls, even though boys had higher The early departure of boys from school cer-
pass rates.26 Over the same period, in English, tainly contributes to the male-on-male char-
the pass rates declined by over 13.0 percent acter of violence in the Caribbean. On the
among boys and by 12.5 percent among girls one hand, school drop-out rates suggest that
(girls had the higher pass rates). Overall, the educational institutions do not meet student
average pass rates among boys and girls in expectations. On the other hand, it is impor-
2009 were low in both subjects (around 35 tant to acknowledge other factors that may
percent for mathematics and around 55 per- impinge on the capacity of students to con-
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 53
tinue schooling. The lack of financial support munity environment include exposure to com-
2 for studies, school closures due to violence, munity and gang volatility, exploitation and
and inability to concentrate because of envi- abuse by adults, and loss of social cohesion.
Youth Violence: Reducing Risk and Enhancing Resilience
Isolate oneself and stay Form gangs to protect Report violence to the police
indoors each other (notwithstanding some distrust
Try to stay neutral and do Face risk directly and of police in Jamaica and in Trin-
not take sides in any conflict defend oneself using vio- idad and Tobago)
Be polite to everyone lence Go to church and pray
Focus on productive work, a
job, or other activity
Go to parties to relieve stress
The Parental Education Programme has been offered for education, scarce family resources, abuse and violence,
more than seven years by the Bureau for the Development impaired parental mental health and the presence of non-
of Children, an NGO in Suriname. The programme of- biological parents. Parents and professional educators have
fers combined socialization and educational services to collaborated on strategies to address risk factors, while also
a low-income community in Sophia’s Lust, a slum in the acknowledging the context of discrimination against Ma-
urban periphery of Paramaribo, where the majority of the roons. Healthy social networks, positive role models, the
population is of Maroon descent. The risk factors that have existence of friends who are at low risk, and fair treatment
been identified in the family setting include low parental have been indicated as positive protective factors.
Source: Parental Education, Suriname. Bureau for the Development of Children, Suriname.
The Peace Ambassadors Programme was established in nities. The programme currently involves over 150 Peace
2006 to confront the rise of violence and conflict in sec- Ambassadors at seven secondary schools in Barbados. It
ondary schools in Barbados and to influence positive encourages the establishment of zones of peace at each
choices and decision-making among boys and girls. The school, supported by events and activities that promote an
programme targets young people interested in living in atmosphere of harmony within the school environment.
peace by promoting respect for themselves and others. It The Peace Ambassadors are easily identified by other stu-
brings girls and boys together to speak out and take action dents through the pins that the ambassadors wear that are
against violence by encouraging them to become involved inscribed with the word ‘Peace’.
with others to solve problems in their schools and commu-
Source: Peace Ambassadors, Barbados. Personal communication, Adisa (AJA) Andwele, Program Director.
from violence as negative influences have been to their peers. A revival of structures for youth
effective in pushing youth towards violence. participation is critical to building resilience.
Several programmes have been developed The community: Schools, community
across the region that seek to link youth perpe- groups and faith-based organizations also
trators to their victims and to other youth who play a role in the protection of youth and in
have been rehabilitated and reintegrated into building their resilience. Several successful
society (box 2.2). These types of interventions violence prevention programmes have been
are considered most effective in resilience- located across the region within such social
building. The decline of youth movements institutions and are implemented by civil so-
and capacity issues among youth organizations ciety groups, including NGOs, faith-based
have affected the ability of youth to reach out organizations, universities and coalitions of
Box 2.3. A Promising State-Community Programme: The Peace Management Initiative, Jamaica
A programme of early intervention, the Peace Manage- contributed significantly in lowering the homicide rate;
ment Initiative (PMI) seeks to stop conflict from escalat- during the first two years of its operations, the homicide
ing into violence and strengthens civic organizations that rate dropped by 15 percent. Although Jamaica’s crime rate
offer stability, sustainable development, security and self- escalated again thereafter, PMI is still seen as a worthwhile
respect in inner-city communities. These objectives are initiative. There is a prevailing perception that, in the ab-
achieved through a number of short- and long-term strat- sence of the programme, the homicide rate would have
egies such as deploying mediators, providing support to been even higher.
community organizations and developing economic liveli- Among the lessons learned through PMI, programme
hoods. PMI has worked to control gang violence, negoti- members have highlighted the following: capacity build-
ate peace agreements, provide counselling and treatment ing reduces the incidence of violence; there is a need to
to individuals affected by violence, and cultivate relations distinguish between community and criminal violence in
with community leaders. planning and programmes; understanding the role played
Led by the Ministry of National Security, PMI involves by civil society is fundamental in supporting governmental
several interest groups, such as churches, academia, politi- initiatives; and employable skills and training are crucial to
cal parties, government agencies, and NGOs at the local preventing and reducing crime.
and national levels. Established in January 2002, PMI has
Source: The Peace Management Initiative, Jamaica. Personal communication, Rohan Perry.
tionalization of youth in need of care and collaboration with other government depart-
protection also harbour a gender bias. Data ments and civil society organizations in form-
on Barbados reveal that the majority of youth ing an inter-agency management committee
institutionalized for wandering are girls. It is for the programme.
likely that the pattern is similar in other coun- While in contact with the criminal justice
tries. system, youth have become victims of abuse
Meanwhile, the majority of youth living or fail to receive adequate rehabilitative or re-
on the streets are boys or young men. For ex- integration services. Over 50 percent of the
ample, Cooke (2002, 6) notes that, among youth respondents to our survey believe that
street children in Jamaica, “boys outnumber the justice systems in their countries are cor-
girls by a proportion of 70:30.” These boys, rupt, and 47 percent believe that the police
averaging about 13 years of age, become in- are incompetent. Of the youth who reported
volved in various forms of child labour and that they had been victims of violent crimes,
other forms of exploitation. That boys out- 64.1 percent had reported the crimes to the
number girls on the streets is likely to be a police, while 34.5 percent had not. The rea-
regional trend. These findings suggest that sons for non-reporting have not been deter-
young men who leave their homes for various mined, but, of those youth who reported,
reasons, including child abuse, are allowed to 18.6 percent were ‘dissatisfied’ with the police
live on the streets, while young women who investigative processes, and 18.8 percent were
leave their homes for similar reasons are more ‘very dissatisfied’. Nonetheless, the majority
likely to be institutionalized. This distinction of the youth respondents felt that the police
is in itself a sign of inequality; however, we deserved their support, and they indicated a
argue that neither approach is appropriate. willingness to work towards violence preven-
Both reflect neglect: a neglect of the responsi- tion. The strengthening of police-youth rela-
bility to provide care and protection to youth. tions can become the foundation of strategies
Neither young males living on the street, nor to reduce youth violence by adopting social
young females in institutions receive the kind measures in policing and by preventing the
of support, counselling, or encouragement immediate institutionalization of youth. This
required to address the issues that lead them issue is discussed in more detail in chapter 5.
to abandon their homes and families. The third weakness apparent in state re-
There should be a shift away from insti- sponses is the failure to create effective links
tutionalization as a first response for youth to build communities and strengthen social
in conflict with the law. The focus of state capital and social cohesion while in pursuit of
approaches should be on working with civil violence reduction.
society to provide a protective environment The fourth weakness of the state frame-
to prevent youth from coming into conflict work is the lack of the pursuit of youth-adult
with the law. However, where conflict with partnerships by which youth and civil society
the law has not been avoided, governments become acknowledged as joint stakeholders
should encourage the use of alternative ap- in the process of violence prevention. Youth
proaches to incarceration, including diver- have a role to play in violence reduction and
sion and restorative justice. An example of a prevention. The majority of youth surveyed
good practice originates in Barbados. The Ju- indicated that they currently contribute or
venile Liaison Scheme, which was launched are willing to contribute to violence reduc-
by the Royal Barbados Police Force in 1983, tion programmes and human development
has helped over 3,000 young people and their programmes. They express hope that they
families by diverting offenders away from the will be able to contribute. “We have the
criminal justice system. Police officers pro- skills to make a contribution but have no
62 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
tools,” Joseph, Holder, and Alexis (2009) problem, particularly through anecdotes re-
quote a youth from Belize saying during the ported in the media, may serve to stereotype 2
consultations conducted by the CARICOM youth, particularly young males. Stereotyping
Strengths Weaknesses
a. The majority of youth are not violent a. Youth are stigmatized as violent
b. Some youth are already contributing to violence reduction b. Youth offenders do not receive adequate rehabilitation
and human development and reintegration support
c. Several promising programmes have been implemented to c. Lack of appropriate data to support planning and pro-
reduce risk and build youth resilience; these now require grammes
evaluation, assessment and replication as appropriate
Opportunities Threats
a. Youth are open to new experiences and pursuits, and, so, a. High levels of youth unemployment and inadequate edu-
change is not as threatening to them cational opportunities
b. Youth generally feel respected in their communities, b. Parents neglect and abuse their children
which provides a foundation for building youth-adult c. Societal tolerance of violence threatens to erode progress
partnerships in non-violent socialization among youth at home and
c. Youth have strong feelings about participation and are school and in communities
willing to contribute to violence prevention
d. Most youth believe that the police deserve their support
3 Contribution of Street
Gangs and Organized
Crime to Violence
More social cohesion, less
crime
in neighbourhood-level drug sales, organized of studies on this topic reveals the dangers of
crime groups are involved in the wider distri- oversimplifications, especially the ones that
bution and trafficking of drugs. picture gangs as out-and-out criminal groups
or as innocent youth clubs. The lack of research
Scope and Nature of the Problem in the Caribbean should not come as a surprise
given that, as Caribbean scholars report, little
Research on street gangs and organized crime attention has been given to citizen insecurity
has a long and extensive history in the United until recently and even less attention has been
States; in Europe, the topic has also received dedicated to gangs and problems related to or-
increasing attention, but these phenomena ganized crime. Most of what is known comes
have not been as systematically examined from the two largest Caribbean nations: Ja-
in the Caribbean. According to the Central maica and Trinidad and Tobago.
American Human Development Report 2009–
Prevalence of the Problem
Multiple data sources show that street gangs are
Chart 3.1 Perceptions of the Street Gang active in much of the Caribbean region, albeit
Problem, Caribbean-7, 2010 the magnitude of the problem in each nation
varies substantially. Popular tools in the research
45 on the issues are resident perception data, offi-
40.7 cial police data and self-reporting data.7
39.7 38.0
40 Of the respondents to the UNDP Citizen
Security Survey 2010 across the Caribbean-7,
35 32.4 12.5 percent believe that gangs are in their
30.8
30
29.6 neighbourhoods (chart 3.1). However, per-
25.8 ceptions vary by nation. Almost 18 percent of
25 residents surveyed in Saint Lucia report the
presence of gangs in their neighbourhoods,
Percent
20 17.9
followed by Trinidad and Tobago (13.9 per-
13.9 cent), Guyana (13.2 percent) and Antigua
15 12.7 13.2
12.4 10.8 12.5 and Barbuda (12.4 percent). About 9 to 18
10.3
10 9.2 percent of the residents claim there are gangs
in their neighbourhoods. Chart 3.1 also
5 shows that, among those who report a gang
presence in their neighbourhoods, about 32.4
0
percent state that the problem is a big one.
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
19.1 17.4
23.1 19.1 27.6 20.6
42.6 20.3
29.4 31.3
18.7 26.4 16.2
20.5 25.9
22.3 18.7
15.9 11.8 14.7 15.3 12.9 16.3
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
Within the last year More than 1, but less than 3 years ago
More than 3, but less than 5 years ago More than 5 years ago
Guyana — —
Saint Lucia — —
Suriname — —
represents a challenge to policy makers in might have a relatively significant gang prob-
these nations to have an accurate understand- lem. Similarly, Katz, Choate, and Fox (2010)
ing of the problem. Some Caribbean police have examined a sample of 2,292 youth at-
agencies do not have the capacity to diagnose tending schools in urban areas in Trinidad and
the scope of local gang activities. Tobago. Their analysis indicates that 12.5 per-
Possibly the most common strategy adopt- cent of school-aged youth self-report they have
ed in examining the prevalence of gang-related been in gangs. In contrast, self-reported data
phenomenon is the use of self-reporting. Self- obtained from school-aged youth in Jamaica
reported data have proven to be a robust, valid indicate substantially lower rates of gang mem-
and reliable method for collecting informa- bership. Wilks et al. (2007), utilizing a com-
tion from gang members.9 Ohene, Ireland, munity-based sample of 1,185 youth, find that
and Blum (2005) have conducted one of the only 6.4 percent self-report ever being in gangs;
few studies that examine the prevalence of using a school-based methodology, Fox and
gang membership across the Caribbean. They Gordon-Strachan (2007) find a like propor-
have collected self-reported data from 15,695 tion (6 percent). Data collected through focus
school-aged youth in Antigua and Barbuda, groups and survey-based convenience samples
the Bahamas, Barbados, British Virgin Islands, of school-aged youth in Antigua and Barbuda
Dominica, Grenada, Guyana, Jamaica and have confirmed the presence of gangs in neigh-
Saint Lucia. They find that 17–24 percent of bourhoods and schools, although quantitative
males and 11–16 percent of females (vary- estimates are unavailable.10 Self-reported data
ing by age) report they have been involved in collected from adults on their participation
gangs. Their research suggests that, compared in street gangs in the Caribbean are rarer. As
with more developed nations, the Caribbean part of the 2009 Jamaican National Crime Vic-
70 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
timization Survey, over 3,100 residents were females in Jamaican street gangs. Police data
surveyed, of which fewer than 0.51 percent of suggest, however, that gang membership is 3
those aged 16 years or older self-reported ever predominately male. A survey of experts with
30 29.4
formation required to understand the problem
are lacking in the Caribbean basin. 25
ity and the role females fulfil in gangs. symbols and initiation rituals.17 Street gangs
This same body of research suggests in Jamaica, however, appear to be more well
that individuals join street gangs at a young organized. According to Leslie (2010), gangs
age (see box 3.1). In Trinidad and Tobago, there are characterized by an organizational
school-aged youth who self-reported gang hierarchy and a division of labour, typically
membership stated that, on average, they had including an all-powerful leader, an upper
first become involved with their gangs when echelon, a middle echelon and bottom-level
they were 12 years old.14 Surveys of school of- ‘workers’. Gangs in Jamaica exhibit several ty-
ficials in Antigua and Barbuda have indicated pologies that range from small, loosely organ-
that most gang members are between the ages ized gangs to large highly organized gangs.
of 12 and 15 years.15 These preliminary find- Leslie (2010) also notes that these gangs lack
ings together imply that the street gang prob- defined territories and do not use identifying
lem is largely confined to young marginalized signs such as tattoos or gang colours.
males. School-based gang prevention efforts Much less is known about organized crime
should therefore begin early in life to inocu- groups in the region. In Jamaica, organized
late youth from gang membership. crime groups are hierarchical and are led by
‘dons’. Dons typically have several ‘soldiers’ who
The Organizational perform many functions. While some may be
Characteristics of Street Gangs involved in a gang or criminal lifestyle; others
Available research finds that the organiza- may be more involved in local politics. Soldiers
tional characteristics of Caribbean street have access to the resources that are derived
gangs vary by nation. Studies based on data from their activities.18 Dons play a leadership
collected from law enforcement experts in role in politics, community affairs and the un-
Antigua and Barbuda and in Trinidad and To- derground economy. For example, they have
bago indicate that street gangs typically have veto power over political party decisions and
an accepted name and that gang members regularly provide essential public services that
refer to themselves as a gang or crew, spend the government cannot provide such as food,
a lot of time in public places and claim turf. jobs and community safety.19 These organized
While, in Trinidad and Tobago, according to crime groups have identifiable territories, re-
police experts, most street gangs do not have ferred to as ‘garrisons’, that are considered safe
symbols such as recognizable styles of cloth- havens from law enforcement. Harriott (2008b,
ing, ways of speaking, or signs, police experts 24) notes that “entry into these areas by the po-
in Antigua and Barbuda say that most street lice may precipitate armed battles that are costly
gangs do make use of such symbols.16 Rely- in lives lost and may be politically costly for the
ing on self-reported data from self-identified police and the political administration.”
school-aged gang members in Trinidad and In Trinidad and Tobago, there have been
Tobago, Pyrooz et al. (2012) indicate that, several drug-trafficking networks, some of
while most gang members state that their which have evolved into organized crime
gangs hold regular meetings (56 percent) groups. There are, however, alternate trajec-
and have rules (52 percent), fewer than half tories to organized crime. Members and ex-
state that their gangs have a leader (45 per- members of the Jamaat al Muslimeen consti-
cent) or insignia (45 percent). While these tute a network that is involved in organized
gangs exhibit relatively low levels of organiza- crime activities. The network is reportedly
tion, Pyrooz et al. (2012) find that gang or- highly organized and prolific.20 International
ganizational structure is positively related to attention turned to the group in 1990 when
delinquency. In other words, the more struc- members attempted to overthrow the govern-
turally organized a gang, the more the gang ment of Trinidad and Tobago.21 The structure
72 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
of organized crime groups in Guyana and to which countries are affected by gang-related
Suriname is less well known, but is believed to crime and violence. For example, in Antigua 3
be comprised of loosely organized networks and Barbuda, homicide data for 2006–2007
After controlling for social-structural factors, the authors of a recent study have found that there is a strong relationship
between the presence of gangs and gang members and the incidence of homicide in communities. Thus, for every addi-
tional gang member in a community, the number of homicides increased by 0.4 percent, and, for every additional gang in
a community, the number of homicides increased by about 10 percent (table a).
Increase in gangs, number Increase in homicides, % Increase in gang members, number Increase in homicides, %
1 9.1 1 0.4
2 19.0 5 2.0
3 29.9 10 4.1
4 41.7 50 22.1
400 393.7
506 homicides, of which 34.8 percent (n = 176) Perhaps our greatest understanding of the
were gang related. Accordingly, not only did the threat posed by Caribbean street gangs was
proportion of gang-related homicides increase provided by research conducted in Trinidad
in both countries, but the number of gang-relat- and Tobago. A national study diagnosing the
ed homicides almost doubled in both countries issue of street gangs was funded by the Min-
over the same period. istry of National Security. It examined several
Research suggests that these figures may data sources, including official data, self-report-
underreport the extent of the problem. Over ed data of school-aged youth, and self-reported
the last several decades, a number of research- data of arrestees. All three data sources yielded
ers have described the limitations of gang similar outcomes. The official data showed that
homicide data and the under classification of gang members, relative to non–gang members,
homicides as gang related.24 One such study were two times more likely to have been arrest-
was conducted in Trinidad and Tobago. Katz ed for property crimes, three times more likely
and Maguire (2006) examined the nature of to have been arrested for violent, gun, or drug
the homicides in the Besson Street Station offenses, and five times more likely to have
District, a station district with one of the worst been arrested for drug sales.25 Self-reported
homicide rates in the nation. They determined data of school-aged youth showed that, com-
that, while the police classified about 25 per- pared with non–gang members, gang members
cent of the district’s homicides as gang related, were about 11 times more likely to be involved
interviews and document reviews revealed that in drug sales, 7 times more likely to be involved
at least 62.5 percent of the homicides were ac- in violence, 5 times more likely to be involved
tually gang related. This suggests that, through- in property crimes, and three times more likely
25
20.2
20
15 14.5
Percent
0
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
Antigua & 9.3 23.3 3.1 12.7 4.8 12.7 0.1 0.0
Barbuda
Saint Lucia 9.1 19.7 3.2 11.4 4.9 9.3 0.1 0.4
Trinidad & 9.6 16.0 3.7 10.1 4.2 5.3 0.2 0.0
Tobago
property crime victimization. With respect presence of street gangs made their neigh-
to victimization through violence, the rela- bourhoods safer or less safe. While most re-
tionship was particularly strong in the Car- spondents stated that gangs made their com-
ibbean-7: almost 10 percent of the residents munities less safe, a surprisingly large share of
of neighbourhoods with gangs had been vic- the respondents in Barbados (14.3 percent)
tims of violent crimes, compared with about and Jamaica (14.9 percent) stated that gangs
3 percent of the residents of neighbourhoods made their neighbourhoods safer (chart 3.4).
with no gang problems. The highest rates of This might reflect the concern of Barbadians
victimization by violence in neighbourhoods about the high risk of victimization and their
with gangs were found in Barbados, a coun- perception that gangs might provide citizen
try in which the gang problem appears to be safety. In Jamaica, these findings may reflect
fairly modest relative to the other countries; the view of resident that the state has failed in
the lowest rates were in Jamaica, a country in its responsibilities to ensure citizen security,
which the gang problem is fairly substantial and gangs have filled the void.
relative to the other countries. These findings Organized crime groups are engaged in ac-
may arise from the fact that neighbourhoods tivity that is often less visible to the public, but
with emerging gang problems experience that can nonetheless have an equally or more
greater conflict than neighbourhoods with damaging effect than the activity of street gangs.
long-standing and chronic gang problems. Data are sparse; for most nations, we must rely
We sought to understand these same issues on learning about the consequences of organ-
by examining the perceptions of residents in ized crime through anecdotal evidence. For ex-
ample, such evidence indicates that, in Guyana
and Suriname, both South American nations
Chart 3.4 Respondents Who Believe Gangs Make geographically, but Caribbean in culture, the
Neighbourhoods Safer, Caribbean-7, 2010 consequences of organized crime are varied,
but are often related to drug-trafficking. Local
16 officials note that “the people who are involved
14.3 14.9
in moving drugs are often the same people who
14 will use the same operation for many other il-
12 legal activities” such as money laundering and
terrorism.28 Drug-trafficking perpetuated by
10 9.4 organized crime groups also often leads to lo-
Percent
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
those who support them (their soldiers), but avenues. The UNDP Citizen Security Survey
also to community residents in need, such as 2010 suggested that judicial corruption is per-
the elderly, children, or pregnant women, and vasive. For example, 53 percent of residents in
this garners good will for the benefit of the the Caribbean-7 believe that politically con-
criminal groups. Because URP contracts are nected criminals go free; about 50 percent
administered through local community lead- believe that the justice system is corrupt; 47.3
ers, organized crime groups seek to increase percent believe powerful criminals go free; and
their territory by pressuring community lead- 37.2 percent believe judges are corrupt (table
ers to cooperate so that the groups may obtain 3.3). While organized crime appears to have
more URP contracts. Disputes over territory undermined the faith of the public in the rule
frequently arise. There are no official statistics, of law across the Caribbean, the problem ap-
but one report indicates that, since 2002, over pears particularly acute in Trinidad and To-
100 URP supervisors, foremen, contractors, bago. Almost 70 percent of the residents there
and workers have been killed because of the believe the judicial system is corrupt and po-
schemes.36 litically connected criminals go free, and about
Organized crime can also have a substantial 62 percent of respondents believe powerful
impact on the rule of law through the corrup- criminals go free and 59 percent believe judges
gest that community cohesion and informal a sense of belonging to their nation. Feelings of
social control might be important factors in societal inclusion were also significantly associ-
understanding the causes of street gang for- ated with the presence of gangs in the neigh-
mation in the Caribbean. bourhoods of respondents. Inclusion is the
We also examined various dimensions of extent to which respondents believe they are
social cohesion and their relationship to the similar to others in the country.43 In Antigua
presence of gangs in the neighbourhoods of and Barbuda, Barbados, Guyana, and Trinidad
respondents. Our results indicate that some and Tobago, respondents who lived in neigh-
dimensions of social cohesion are specific to bourhoods with gangs were significantly less
nations and that policy makers cannot neces- likely to feel a sense of inclusion. Participation
sarily generalize across the Caribbean (table was also significantly related to the presence of
3.5). Across the Caribbean-7, respondents re- gangs in the neighbourhoods of respondents.
siding in neighbourhoods with gangs were sig- Participation was measured by the willingness
nificantly less likely to feel a sense of belonging of respondents to work with others to reduce
than respondents residing in neighbourhoods violence and improve the country.44 In Barba-
without gangs. Belongingness is the sense of dos, Guyana, and Trinidad and Tobago, resi-
pride and loyalty that respondents feel towards dents of neighbourhoods with gangs were less
their countries.42 In Antigua and Barbuda, likely to state that they were willing to partici-
Barbados, Guyana, Saint Lucia, and Trinidad pate with others to reduce violence or improve
and Tobago, respondents who lived in an area the country. We also examined the relationship
with gangs were significantly less likely to feel between neighbourhood gang presence and
80 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Table 3.5. Mean Levels of Social Cohesion in Communities with and without Gangs,
Caribbean-7, 2010 3
Antigua & −0.25 −0.82 −0.11 −0.56 −0.06 −0.56 −0.04 −0.53 −0.18 −0.50
Barbuda
Barbados 0.17 −0.14 −0.06 −0.32 −0.39 −0.60 0.23 −0.02 −0.04 −0.31
Guyana −0.25 −0.56 −0.04 −0.49 −0.06 −0.28 −0.23 −0.64 −0.15 −0.47
Jamaica 0.22 0.17 0.19 0.06 0.32 0.20 0.21 0.04 0.21 0.01
Saint Lucia 0.00 −0.19 0.01 −0.05 0.23 −0.05 0.20 −0.02 0.28 0.04
Suriname 0.07 0.05 0.03 −0.07 −0.04 0.05 −0.09 −0.14 −0.08 −0.11
Trinidad & 0.20 −0.08 0.20 −0.22 0.11 −0.17 0.02 −0.47 0.18 −0.22
Tobago
Caribbean-7 0.03 −0.23 0.03 −0.23 0.01 −0.11 0.04 −0.26 0.03 −0.21
the perceptions of respondents about the le- As a consequence of the lack of social co-
gitimacy of the criminal justice system and the hesion, community cohesion and informal
perceptions of respondents about the respect social control, as well as the lack of effective
granted to them within society. Legitimacy formal social control to respond to gangs
was measured by the willingness of respond- and organized crime, criminal groups have
ents to support institutions such as the police filled the void, empowering them and help-
and the courts and the views of respondents ing them become engrained into the fabric of
on judicial fairness.45 Respect was measured by local communities (see below and chapters 5
the perceptions of respondents about whether and 6). In Jamaica, formal and informal social
they were respected by their fellow citizens, control and social and community cohesion
people earning more than them, and people of have deteriorated to such an extent that some
different ethnic origins.46 With the exception communities have turned to dons and street
of Suriname, the respondents in all the Car- gangs for help. Mogensen (2005) reports that,
ibbean-7 who were living in neighbourhoods in Jamaica, citizens do not believe that the
with gangs scored lower on the legitimacy and police can effectively address crime, and they
respect scales than the respondents who were seek justice from local dons through kangaroo
living in neighbourhoods without gangs. To- courts. “When crimes are carried out within
gether, these findings suggest that people living the community, dons enforce discipline, in-
in neighbourhoods with gangs feel isolated, cluding beatings or executions, to an extent
disenfranchised and apathetic and are less sup- considered commensurate with the level of
portive of formal mechanisms of social control. the crime.”47 Dons also provide housing, food,
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 81
medical assistance, policing services, early through the risk factor prevention paradigm.
3 childhood education and other assistance to Risk factors are those characteristics or symp-
citizens who are loyal, as well as greater oppor- toms that, if present, increase the odds that an
Street Gangs and Organized Crime
tunities for political advancement to people individual will be involved in problem behav-
with political aspirations.48 Research in Trini- iour. Conversely, protective factors are those
dad and Tobago yielded similar findings. One characteristics or symptoms that, if present,
community leader, when asked about this is- decrease the odds that an individual will be
sue, stated, “Gangs bring down crime. They in- involved in problem behaviour.50 The risk and
stituted a community court that meets weekly protective model has been used extensively in
where young males are punished and given public health since researchers first learned
strokes. . . . One to two local councillors have that heart disease was associated with risk
gone to the courts to observe their practice.” factors such as tobacco use, lack of exercise,
Another stated, “Gangs are the first ones to and family history of heart disease and that
respond to crime; the police are incompetent, individuals were less likely to experience heart
they take too long and never finish the work. disease if protective factors such as exercise
If you go to the gang leader you know they will and low-fat diets were present in the individu-
take care of you.” Still another explained, “If als’ lives.51 Since then, the risk and protective
you live in a community where there is gang factor approach has been used extensively to
cohesion you are more safe because they [pro- understand and develop public health policy
tect you]. . . . Gangs provide safety, create jobs surrounding cancer, mental health, and dis-
. . . , give people food, give mother’s milk for ease. Most recently, it has been applied to
their babies.”49 Harriott (2008b) notes that, as achieve greater understanding of the reasons
a consequence, leaders of street gangs and or- people join gangs.
ganized crime groups have served as role mod- There is almost no research on the risk and
els and mentors in some communities, which protective factors associated with street gang
necessarily perpetuates a culture that places membership. Anecdotal evidence hints that
additional value on these criminal organiza- membership is related to risk factors such as
tions and their positive role in communities. neighbourhood social disorganization, neigh-
bourhood levels of crime and drug use, lack
Individual-Level Explanations of attachment to school, poor school perfor-
Another approach to explaining and under- mance, unemployment, poor family manage-
standing delinquent and criminal groups is ment, attachment to antisocial peers, and an
Box 3.3. Deportees, Street Gangs and Organized Crime in the Caribbean
In the Caribbean, public policy makers and residents have and 15 percent of deportees to Trinidad and Tobago were
made claims that deportees from Canada, the United King- later charged with a crime. There have been similar findings
dom and the United States have contributed to the prob- in Jamaica. However, the UNODC and World Bank report
lems of gangs and organized crime in the region. The claims noted that, while most deportees are not involved in crime,
have largely focused on the belief that individuals learn a small number might be responsible for much violence. For
about criminal behaviour in developed nations and, after instance, the report states that, between 2001 and 2004,
they have been deported home, are responsible for much of 224 individuals were deported to Jamaica who had previ-
the crime. While there has been little research on this issue, ously been convicted of murder. The report concludes that,
preliminary evidence indicates that deportees are not a ma- given the relatively small population of Jamaica, such a large
jor contributor to crime and violence in the Caribbean. number of deportees can have a significant impact on local
A joint report by UNODC and the World Bank (2010), for crime rates.
example, shows that 13 percent of deportees to Barbados
Malcolm Klein (1995), an eminent gang scholar, notes that, strategies finds that they are ineffective in reducing gang
in Los Angeles, gang sweeps by the police are not an effec- membership or gang crime.b Indeed, some of the research
tive means of generating gang arrests and do not appear to indicates that these programmes lead to an increase in gang
justify the US$150,000 a day that they cost the local police membership and gang delinquency. Klein (1971) reports
department. Klein claims that such tactics may actually have a that the assignment of caseworkers increases the local repu-
negative impact on the community’s gang problem. He argues tation of particular gangs, which helps attract new members
that, because the majority of the people arrested were imme- and leads to more gang activity in the areas employing de-
diately released without having been charged, gang cohesive- tached caseworkers. Spergel (1995) reports similar findings
ness may have been strengthened, and the deterrent impact on in his examination of a programme that was designed to pro-
gang members may have been reduced. vide job training and job opportunities for gang members in
Suppression efforts in Central America have yielded simi- Chicago. Project staff were primarily comprised of gang lead-
lar results. Mano Dura, the gang-reform programme in El ers from two of the largest gangs in Chicago. The analyses
Salvador, criminalized gang membership, and, as a conse- indicate that the project was a failure by almost all accounts.
quence, youth, even if they were only remotely associated Job training and placement efforts were unsuccessful; gang
with gangs, were arrested, incarcerated and then discrimi- structures became more sophisticated; and the number of
nated against upon their return to their communities from gang-motivated homicides rose. As a consequence, many
prison. The policy had the unintended impact of increasing policy makers no longer believe that prevention and social
gang cohesion and the proliferation of gangs.a intervention approaches represent a successful method to
A number of researchers have evaluated the impact of other deal with gangs. This has led to a general decrease in in-
prevention and social intervention approaches on gang tervention efforts conducted by youth-oriented agencies,
membership and gang crime. While a few studies report which have since undertaken more general prevention ini-
some positive impacts, most of the research examining these tiatives aimed at younger at-risk youth.c
a. USAID (2006).
b. Short (1963); Spergel (1995).
c. Spergel (1986).
gangs and organized crime. The suppression related crime.55 Security officials report that
strategies are typically reactive in nature and this crime-fighting strategy has resulted in a
make use of criminal law to control behaviour. 44 percent reduction in killings in the first
The objective of the strategies is not only to quarter of 2011 compared with the same pe-
address immediate issues (to arrest individuals riod in 2010.56 Trinidad and Tobago was one
for criminal activity, for example), but also to of the first nations in the Caribbean to estab-
deter youth and adults from joining gangs and lish a specialized unit with trained personnel
organized crime groups and discourage gang to respond to gangs. Trinidad and Tobago’s
members from engaging in future crime. Typi- Gang/Repeat Offender Task Force—since
cal tactics involve arrest, prosecution, interme- disbanded (see below)—was established in
diate sanctions, and imprisonment by criminal May 2006 and staffed with approximately 40
justice officials. sworn officers.57 The unit was trained by gang
While general law enforcement strate- specialists (sworn officers) from the United
gies have been used to respond reactively to States, and the staff included a coach (a for-
crimes perpetrated by gangs, no nation, with mer sworn officer from the United States)
the exception of Jamaica and of Trinidad and who was responsible for mentoring the unit’s
Tobago, have focused efforts on the gang leadership. The unit was responsible for ap-
members or gangs that are disproportionately prehending wanted persons, collecting gang
involved in gang crime. Most of these nations intelligence, disseminating information to
lack sufficient intelligence services to iden- units across the police service, and conduct-
tify accurately the members of gangs or the ing random patrols in areas with gang prob-
main groups involved in violence. The police lems.
response has generally lacked the adequate Much of the response to organized crime
focus on persons and places that can lead to in the Caribbean has come through the enact-
good results. ment of legislation and drug-related interna-
Operation Kingfish was launched in Ja- tional treaties. These treaties support the op-
maica in 2004 to restore community confi- erational work of the United Nations Office
dence and reduce the fear of crime by target- on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) and help
ing dons and leaders of gangs and by breaking secure membership in regional and interna-
up organized crime groups. The operation tional organizations that foster collaboration
task force reportedly made a major dent in or- and cooperation to suppress drug-trafficking.
ganized crime, effected the arrest of some of However, in many ways, the legislation and
Jamaica’s most wanted men, smashed at least treaties have served more as symbolic re-
two gangs, and disrupted six others.53 Jamai- sponses to the problem rather than as effec-
can police stepped up their efforts in 2011, tive means to combat organized crime. Carib-
targeting 47 groups, particularly those with bean nations have not had the law enforcement
more sophisticated ties to local political par- capacity to implement many of the laws they
ties. The new strategy appears to be focused have passed, and the result has been suppres-
on local police commanders, who identify the sion strategies targeting end-users and street-
three worst criminal groups in their jurisdic- level drug traffickers, rather than apprehending
tions and undertake suppression efforts.54 Ad- those who profit most from drug-trafficking.
ditionally, the Jamaica Constabulary Force, Some effort has been made to address other
through an enhanced anti-gang strategy, has types of activity associated with organized
recently identified the dismantling of gang ac- crime such as money laundering, bribery and
tivities as a priority. It requires officers to (1) fraud; however, these efforts have been ham-
focus on streets and public spaces; (2) iden- pered by lack of financial resources and person-
tify, profile and act to disrupt or completely nel with the relevant investigative skills.
84 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Recently, the Global Commission on Drug the past few years, the Jamaican Constabulary
Policy, a group comprised of current and past Force has been accused of killing civilians in 3
influential statesman from Brazil, Columbia, pursuit of gang members. One report indicat-
19.1
individuals. Instead, they document individu- 20
als according to the ideas, beliefs and biases 15
of the police. Second, specialized police units 9.9
10
dedicated to responding to gangs are them-
selves frequently the target of suspicions 5
about serious misconduct and human rights 0
violations. For example, in Trinidad and To-
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
Barbados 45.3 37.7 45.6 43.3 41.4 43.7 11.7 3.8 17.6 14.0
Guyana 23.9 17.8 17.9 9.6 17.8 10.1 5.8 3.4 6.9 3.4
Jamaica 22.7 21.4 22.8 22.0 20.5 17.9 9.1 5.8 11.7 6.9
Saint Lucia 20.2 21.1 19.8 23.3 18.5 19.9 6.2 9.1 7.2 6.6
Suriname 34.6 36.0 30.4 28.5 27.7 24.8 9.5 12.2 12.4 15.3
Trinidad & 9.5 4.1 11.4 4.5 10.6 4.5 3.5 1.8 3.7 0.9
Tobago
Caribbean-7 26.7 21.3 25.4 20.5 23.0 19.2 7.9 5.7 10.2 6.8
According to analysis of the UNDP Citi- with gangs. Second, Barbados and Trinidad
zen Security Survey 2010, only 24 percent of and Tobago were outliers in our measures.
respondents in the Caribbean-7 had confidence Specifically, resident confidence in the po-
in the police to control gang violence (chart lice to control crime was relatively high in
3.5). In Trinidad and Tobago, fewer than 10 Barbados, but, in Trinidad and Tobago, few
percent of respondents were confident that the residents stated they had high confidence in
police could perform this task. Respondents the police. Third, residents in all Caribbean-7
in Barbados showed the highest level of confi- nations had little confidence in the ability of
dence, at only 39 percent. the police to control crime in general or the
In the Caribbean-7, survey respondents criminal activity of powerful criminals. The
in neighbourhoods with gangs have even less public appears to believe that the police and,
confidence in the ability of the police to con- potentially, the judicial system are heavily in-
trol gang crime (table 3.6). Relative to crimes fluenced by organized crime and that the re-
in general, respondents expressed more con- sponse of the police to crimes of a less serious
fidence in the ability of the police to solve nature, but experienced more frequently by
crimes involving homicide, gang violence residents is rarely effective.
and drug-trafficking. A few other findings are The problem, however, is more compli-
also of particular interest. First, in Jamaica, cated than residents simply having little con-
Saint Lucia and Suriname, confidence in the fidence in the police and believing that judges
crime-fighting ability of the police did not and the justice system are corrupt. Because
significantly vary even in neighbourhoods they believe criminals are too powerful, sur-
86 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Table 3.7. Residents Who Do Nothing about Crime Because Criminals Are Too
Powerful, Caribbean-7, 2010 3
vey respondents also do nothing about crime The Need for Intervention and Prevention
(table 3.7). This finding was particularly If implemented properly, suppression can be
pronounced in neighbourhoods with gangs. an important strategy in addressing street
About 4.5 percent of respondents in Barba- gangs and organized crime, but it is only part
dos, 12.0 percent in Saint Lucia and in Trini- of the solution. Suppression strategies typi-
dad and Tobago, and 22.0 percent in Jamaica cally address problems that already exist; they
reported that they did not respond to crime do little to prevent individuals from joining
because criminals were too powerful. gangs or organized crime groups, and they do
While it is difficult to assess what re- not address the social conditions that give rise
spondents mean by ‘too powerful’, prior re- to these gangs and groups. Caribbean govern-
search in Trinidad and Tobago suggests that ments have been slow to adopt such interven-
this answer may be related to the perceived tion and prevention strategies (box 3.5).
inability of the police to do something about It is necessary for Caribbean nations to
the problem and the perceived belief that implement mobilization tactics that focus on
gang members will seek retribution. For ex- the development of community coalitions in-
ample, through a community survey in the volving schools, churches and public health
neighbourhood of Gonzales in Trinidad and and criminal justice agencies for the purpose of
Tobago, Johnson (2006a, 2006b) found that coordinating services and developing collabo-
more than 85 percent of residents had heard rative responses to gangs and organized crime.
gun-shots in the previous 30 days, but only 7 Collaborative efforts that have been undertak-
percent had reported the gun-shots to police. en are often not focused solely on gang issues.
At the same time, 86 percent of the respond- Likewise, Caribbean nations should imple-
ents stated they believed gangs would retali- ment opportunity provision strategies aimed
ate against people who reported gang-related at addressing the root causes of gangs and
crimes to police. organized crime. This approach assumes that
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 87
3 Box 3.5. On the Horizon: Caribbean Anti-Gang Legislation
Street Gangs and Organized Crime
As of late 2011, no Caribbean nation had enacted legisla- a second conviction. Likewise, individuals who aid gang
tion that defines gangs, gang membership, or gang crime. members may be imprisoned for up to 25 years.
Gang legislation can supply an opportunity for public dis- There are a number of troublesome aspects to these legis-
course on the scope and nature of the problem and can of- lative initiatives. First, they do not define a gang or gang
fer policy makers an opportunity to define concepts. Well- membership, nor do they place a check—a quality-control
developed legislation provides guidelines and supports the review, for example—on the discretion of the police or the
police in documenting gangs and gang membership. It can courts in labelling a group as a gang or a person as a gang
also represent an opportunity for citizens to review gang- member. Second, the proposed legislation would have only
related police records, the success or failure of anti-gang limited impact in suppressing gang membership, gangs, or
initiatives, and decisions related to the identification of gang activity. Both Jamaica and Trinidad and Tobago have
gang status. low clearance and detection rates in gang-related crime.
Two nations have begun the process of enacting gang leg- For example, Katz and Maguire (2006) report that, in 53
islation: Jamaica and Trinidad and Tobago. Both nations homicide investigations associated with gang activity in
are seeking to criminalize gang membership and individu- one Trinidadian community, there were only three arrests
als who assist gang members. The legislation provides the and no convictions. While the legislation may have a mod-
police in both nations with greater authority to search and est effect on arrest rates, it would likely have no impact on
seize individuals involved in gangs. Thus, the proposed leg- the conversion of arrests to convictions. Instead, the leg-
islation in Trinidad and Tobago—Act No. 10 of 2011— islation may have the undesirable effect of increasing the
would allow the police, without a warrant, to enter and probability that gang members will threaten witnesses be-
search any location where they believe gang members may cause of the severity of the potential sentences if they are
be found. Furthermore, gang members would be sentenced convicted
to 10 years in prison for a first conviction and 20 years for
many individuals become involved in criminal and involvement with criminal groups. The
groups to obtain goals and resources because programmes focus on the supply of services
they do not have access to legitimate opportu- to an entire population or to populations in
nities. These strategies focus on improving the high-risk communities. Primary prevention
academic, economic and social opportunities services can be provided to youth, families, or
of disadvantaged youth. They often rely on job communities by schools, NGOs, government
training and job placement, educational initia- agencies and faith-based groups. Examples
tives and the development of problem-solving of such programmes include school-based
skills. The use of social intervention strategies instruction, individual- and family-based life
is also lacking. Social intervention strategies skills training and public service opportuni-
often rely on outreach workers to supply im- ties.63 There are few formal prevention efforts
mediate services to gang members in moments aimed at dissuading youth in the Caribbean
of need. For example, following a violent inci- from becoming involved in street gangs or or-
dent, an outreach worker may provide counsel- ganized crime groups.
ling, crisis intervention, or temporary shelter.
Outreach workers also undertake inter-gang Conclusion
mediation, group counselling and conflict res-
olution among gangs.62 This chapter argues that street gangs and or-
Primary prevention programmes are also ganized crime contribute significantly to the
needed for youth in the Caribbean. The goal levels of criminal violence and other forms
of such programmes is to change life trajec- of crime and undermine the rule of law in
tories among youth by offering encourage- the region. Street gangs and organized crime
ments for them to avoid gang membership should therefore be among the most impor-
88 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
tant concerns for Caribbean policy makers in trafficking and fraud. While less visible than
their goal of improving human development street gangs, but perhaps more consequen- 3
in the region. A key first step is to understand tial, organized crime has infiltrated state in-
established in 1822.7 This constabulary was citizens. The constables prided themselves on
designed to quell governmental disruption in responding to citizen reports of victimization,
Ireland and control political and social dissent. investigating reported crimes and capturing
It was a well-armed paramilitary force that was and charging perpetrators. To accomplish
primarily concerned with the protection of the this, they were assigned to geographical dis-
state and not with the quality of life or human tricts with the mandate to get to know local
rights among the citizenry. The model was im- families and community organizations for the
plemented in the English-speaking Caribbean purpose of intervening early with individuals
and other British colonies; the role of the po- or groups that might commit criminal acts
lice as protector of the state was most poign- and building trust and respect so that com-
antly exhibited during the labour unrest in the munity members would alert them whenever
Caribbean in the late 1930s.8 interventions were needed.11
The independence gained by the British This focus on police-citizen relations and
colonies in the Caribbean in the second half citizen cooperation with the police relies on
of the 20th century did little to change the three principles, as follows: (1) citizens co-pro-
role of the police. Rather than protecting the duce security in cooperation with the police,
old colonial government, the police protect- (2) police function as problem solvers, and (3)
ed the newly independent governments.9 The the police and the populace jointly seek organ-
same was true in the nations of the Nether- izational changes in the police and in neigh-
land Caribbean in which the police served to bourhoods that will improve crime prevention
protect Netherland colonial interests to the and control. Community policing is a philoso-
detriment of citizens. phy rather than a rigid set of requirements, and
police agencies are expected and encouraged
Modern-Day Policing: to apply the philosophy in ways that meet the
The Citizen Security Approach specific, self-defined needs of the public.12 The
underlying philosophy also implies a commit-
One of the first steps in the modernization and ment on the part of the police to serve as a
democratization of a police force was taken in catalyst for local change through outreach, or-
London in 1829. The Peelian reforms, institut- ganizational initiatives and educational efforts
ed by Sir Robert Peel, were based on the simple that reflect citizen input and concerns.13 Com-
principle that police should be citizens pro- munity policing entails a commitment on the
tecting citizens from crime and social disorder. part of the police to greater responsiveness and
As a symbol of their citizen status, the police accessibility to citizens (see box 4.1).
were dressed like the gentlemen of the time With the move towards community polic-
and were not allowed to carry military-type ing, police officials began to realize that positive
weapons. According to the premise underly- citizen perceptions of the legitimacy and com-
ing the reform experiment, effective policing petence of the police were critical.14 Legitimacy
required the confidence and the cooperation and competency are directly related to a police
of the citizens of London. As Peel wrote in a force’s ability to control and prevent crime, as
letter to the Duke of Wellington on 5 Novem- well as ensure citizen security from disorder,
ber 1829: “I want to teach people that liberty victimization and insecurity.15 The role of the
does not consist in having your house robbed populace is essential for excellent and effective
by organised gangs of thieves, and in leaving policing because if citizens do not report crimes
the principal streets of London in nightly pos- to the police, cooperate in police investigations
session of drunken women and vagabonds.”10 and alert the police to potential crimes and
The Peelian reforms required constables criminals, crimes are not solved and criminals
of the London Metropolitan Police and their are not removed from the streets. Thus, citizen
94 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Box 4.1. The Example of the Royal Grenada Police Force 4
Source: Personal communication, James Clarkson, Commissioner, Royal Grenada Police Force, April 2010.
participation and cooperation promote partner- integrity because corruption invariably com-
ships with the police and the co-production of promises performance and weakens public
crime prevention and control. Neighbourhoods confidence. This issue bridges both perfor-
engaged in effective community policing yield mance and what may be called the problem
nations in which citizens feel unthreatened by of values, authority and legitimacy. The third
crime and sufficiently secure to lead productive challenge is to reduce abuses of power and to
and creative lives. become more rights-regarding.
of a population between rural and urban set- major reason behind the selection of individu-
tings and the geography of the territory. als from outside the force as members of top
The fairly high police densities across the management. For example, Trevor MacMillan,
region suggest that, with the possible excep- a former military officer, was selected as com-
tion of Guyana and Jamaica, coverage is not a missioner of police in 1993. In the following
particularly acute problem. Perhaps the more two years, 572 allegations of misconduct were
challenging issue is the effective use of these investigated. This represented approximately
human resources. Adequate police strength 10 percent of the JCF at the time.17 After Mac-
and density are conditions for effective ser- Millan’s tenure ended, the force sank back into
vice delivery and the protection of the popu- a pattern of corruption. Currently, the JCF
lation, but they are not sufficient conditions. is again making serious strides in combating
The effectiveness and efficiency of even the internal corruption, and it is achieving fairly
largest police services enjoying the best re- good results. Commissioner Ellington and the
sources may be compromised by corruption. Ethics Committee have aggressively identified
corrupt police officers and have terminated the
The Integrity Imperative employment of these officers: 20 since the be-
The performance and values dimensions of ginning of 2011, with 137 officers denied reen-
legitimacy can be insidiously undermined by listment in 2010 because of allegations of cor-
corruption. One of the major barriers to the ruption.18 The JCF is attempting to reform the
adoption of more effective and efficient crime police culture from the acceptance of corrup-
control methods and the meaningful inclu- tion to zero tolerance. The Jamaican example
sion of citizens in police operations is corrup- demonstrates that the police can do something
tion. Corruption is particularly devastating to to control corruption and thereby increase
crime prevention and control efforts because their legitimacy in the eyes of the citizenry.
of the detrimental effect that it has on citizen
perceptions and subsequent actions.16 Tankebe The Rights-Respecting Imperative
(2009) notes that, in developing nations, the If corruption has the effect of weakening the
relationships between the public and the po- values-based moral authority of the police,
lice are fraught with distrust and alienation. abuses of power that take the form of a disre-
In Suriname and in Trinidad and Tobago, 89 gard for the rights of citizens tend to have an
percent of the respondents to the UNDP Citi- equal or even greater negative effect on this
zen Security Survey 2010 believed that gov- dimension of the legitimacy of the police. In
ernments should invest more in reducing cor- this area, there is considerable variation in the
ruption so as to lower the incidence of crime. performance of Caribbean police forces. In the
The respondents in Barbados were not as con- countries with high rates of violent crime, the
cerned about corruption as those in the other abuses of citizen rights and, particularly, extra-
six nations: only 71 percent agreed or strongly judicial killings tend to be more frequent than
agreed that the government should invest in countries with lower homicide rates. This is
more in reducing corruption. The Jamaican re- supported by data of the UNDP Citizen Se-
spondents were the most concerned about this curity Survey 2010. Situational factors seem
issue: 94 percent believed that corruption and to play an important role in determining these
crime are linked and that government should outcomes. The governments and police ser-
invest more in reducing corruption. Accord- vices of the region have tried to respond to the
ingly, it is difficult to speak of the success of challenges by improving accountability and
modern police reforms without simultane- capability and by introducing new methods of
ously acknowledging the destabilizing role of policing that aim at greater responsiveness to
corruption. needs and better relationships with citizens.
96 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Accountability Based on the performance of these police ser-
One of the challenges facing police forces in vices, these systems have not, however, proved 4
the Caribbean, as elsewhere, is the necessity effective in ensuring a desirable level of crime
Suriname _ _ _ _
Throughout the 1990s, the police of Rio de Janeiro faced were problems. The small units had to confront powerful
serious credibility issues because of severe human rights drug-trafficking networks, and many of the police volunteers
abuses and the poor relations of the police with urban poor were not accustomed to these sorts of operations. Moreover,
communities. In response to these problems, the police es- the resources were insufficient to realize an integrated, effec-
tablished a unit, Grupamento de Aplicação Prático Escolar (lit- tive approach.
erally, the group for Applied Practice), that was responsible Unidades de Policia Pacificadora (Police Pacification Units),
for ensuring public security within communities. At the end the initiative currently being tried, represents quite a differ-
of the 1990s, another initiative, Mutirão pela Paz (or Collec- ent approach. First, the units begin patrolling into the favelas,
tive Effort for Peace), was undertaken by the police to deliver the poor shantytowns of Rio de Janeiro, where they confront
social services to communities in an effort coordinated with and attempt to neutralize drug networks and suppress other
labour, welfare and other governmental departments. criminal activities. Next, fresh graduates of the police academy
In the 2000s, Grupamento de Policiamento em Áreas Especiais who have received special training in community policing are
(Police Unit for Special Areas) was created to patrol high-risk stationed in the favelas. However, they are not deployed in
areas. Participating police officers had to be volunteers. The isolation. They are assisted through social services and other
areas in which the units were active all had high homicide support programmes. This permits effective engagement with
rates. Small police stations were opened in these areas. The community members and promotes a less repressive image of
results were revealing; the units had an impressive effect in the police. These new units are larger and have more resources
bringing together police and communities. However, there than the Grupamento de Policiamento em Áreas Especiais.
police forces. Many of these efforts have cen- mise with a change in administration and a
tred on the adoption of community-oriented rapidly rising rate of violent crime. (See box
policing. For example, Barbados made the 4.2 for an example of a similar context.) To-
shift to a community-oriented approach be- day, Jamaica is trying again to reform the po-
ginning in the 1970s. The establishment of lice. The Trinidad and Tobago Police Service
the Office of Public Relations in the early has also adopted a community-oriented ap-
1980s was a crucial part of this transforma- proach, but, because of the high levels of vio-
tion. The Community Policing Unit has been lent victimization among citizens that strain
credited with reaching out to neighbour- police and the shortage of public resources,
hoods through education and programmes these reforms have not been achieving pro-
to help citizens protect themselves and their gress as quickly as desired.
neighbours. The results of the UNDP Citi- The other Caribbean-7 nations have not
zen Security Survey 2010 indicate that sup- achieved the same level of reform as Barba-
port for police is greater in Barbados than in dos, but are not struggling as much as Jamaica
the other Caribbean-7 nations; Barbadians or Trinidad and Tobago. For example, Suri-
believe the police to be a legitimate force. name has also adopted a community policing
Given these findings, it is not surprising that approach. Citizen involvement in crime pre-
Barbados has been the most successful nation vention grew organically during the 1990s,
in the region in instituting reforms that tran- when an increase in crime was coupled with
sition the police force beyond older models of an economic downturn. Citizens formed
policing. Jamaica made great strides towards their own neighbourhood watch groups be-
reform beginning in the 1990s with the in- cause they were displeased with the effective-
tent of increasing the transparency, effective- ness of the police. Such groups usually do not
ness and legitimacy of the police. Communi- build a sense of general security because they
ty policing was implemented along with these do not involve two-way communication and
changes. However, the reform movement and coordination with the police. The formation
community policing came to an untimely de- of these groups represented, however, an ef-
fort by the citizenry to begin to take responsi- tween the 1950s and the 1980s.19 Chart 4.1
bility for public safety. The police found ways summarizes the training programmes offered.
of positively responding to this problem by It is based on information provided by the
establishing community police managers who security agencies of the respective countries.
engaged with residents in problem-solving Investigative competence, use of force, human
(box 4.3). rights, women’s rights, appropriate responses
In 2009, Antigua and Barbuda imple- to gender-based violence and community
mented community policing based on the policing are curriculum topics in most of the
principle of the co-production of security. training programmes.
Police salaries were also increased. A formal
complaint procedure for citizens was estab-
lished, and other reforms were undertaken. Box 4.4. The Co-Production of Security in Nicaragua
Despite the major changes, community-ori-
ented policing has not been fully realized, In 2001, the national government established the Comprehensive Policy on
and the police continue to behave in a largely the Police and the Community, which defined the concepts and strategies of
reactive manner by focusing on response a community policing model. Since 2004, the Proactive Community Polic-
times. A recent initiative is intended to equip ing Model has brought together the government, NGOs and communities
law enforcement with the latest in computer to address the issues of violence and crime by sharing information and to
and telecommunications technology, an ef- build trust, interaction and partnerships. The programme helps identify the
fort that modernizes rather than reforms the security needs of citizens and address them through comprehensive initia-
police and their relationship to the public. tives and planning.
Although the modernization of equipment The Proactive Community Policing Model has four main components. The
is important in the Caribbean, it will not first is the operation of a police ‘total school’ that was established by the po-
enhance feelings of security among citizens. lice academy and is used to train and develop officers throughout their ca-
There must be reform aimed at improving reers. Police training and related programmes were also inaugurated in each
the relationship between the police and the local police station. The second component involves fostering police-citizen
public so that effective co-production of secu- partnerships to address local crime issues. The third is the commissioner for
rity can occur. The Nicaraguan experience is women and children, a position created to address the prevention of domes-
a good example of citizen-police partnership tic and sexual violence. The fourth component is the Adolescents and Youth
for the co-production of security (box 4.4). Affairs Department, which was created to address youth violence and rein-
tegrate youth into their communities. The programme is being supported by
Developing Capacity: the Youth Affairs Division of the National Police.
Advancing Police Training and Education
Another aspect that is important for the fu- Sources: UNDP (2009).
ture of policing in the Caribbean is the model
of police training. All the Caribbean-7 coun-
tries have police training academies. These
institutions or units were all established be-
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 99
4 Chart 4.1 Incidence of Key Topics in Police Training Curricula
percent
The Police: Transitioning to Citizen Security
Women’s Rights 33
International Humanitarian Law 50
Gun Control 58
Intelligence 75
Fraud 83
Drug Control 83
Management 83
Gender Violence 83
Crowd Control 92
Community Policing 92
Use of Non-lethal Weapons 92
Suspect Interrogation Techniques 100
Traffic Control and Management 100
Investigation 100
Human Rights 100
Use of Lethal Weapons 100
Criminal Law 100
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Source: Data of CARICOM Implementation Agency for Crime and Security, Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago,
http://caricomimpacs.org/impacs.
Note: Special thanks is owed to IMPACS for granting UNDP access to the report led by IMPACS and funded by
the European Commission.
Source: Data of CARICOM Implementation Agency for Crime and Security, Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago, http://caricomimpacs.org/impacs.
Note: Special thanks is owed to IMPACS for granting UNDP access to the report led by IMPACS and funded by the European Commission.
approach to common regional challenges and ceptions of respondents about the police
to establish a regional network of security op- in terms of the protection of the rights of
eratives and officials. individuals and equitable treatment of all
These various initiatives and programmes people
have advanced the process of change within • The performance and competence dimen-
the police services of the region. This process sion of the legitimacy of the police, that is,
should be intensified. The perceptions of the the perceptions of respondents about the
populations of the region who are served by effectiveness of police in controlling spe-
the police reveal the extent of concern about cific types of crimes in the community and
these issues and the extent of the demand for at the national level
change. • The willingness of citizens to cooperate
with the police in crime prevention and to
Perceptions on the Police in the Carib- work with others in the community to re-
bean Region duce violence.
The public’s perceptions of the police are
This section presents analysis primarily of re- crucial in the transition to citizen security.
sponses to questions on the UNDP Citizen The police must be viewed as possessing the
Security Survey 2010 regarding experiences, legitimate authority to uphold and enforce
opinions and perceptions about the police. the laws and the rights of citizens, as well
Four main topics are explored, as follows: as the competence to fulfil these duties in a
• The effects of crime on the general sense of way that is fair, appropriate and respectful. If
insecurity among citizens citizens view police in this light, they will be
• Indicators of the values dimension of the more likely to cooperate with the police and
legitimacy of the police, that is, the per- participate in crime prevention and control
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 101
4 Chart 4.2 The Role of Perceptions of the Police in Achieving Citizen Security
The Police: Transitioning to Citizen Security
Perceive
Police
Legitimacy
Perceive
Police
Competence
efforts. As the role of citizens in crime preven- Violent crime was considered a more se-
tion and control grows, citizens will begin to rious problem than property crime by the
co-produce the positive outcomes along with respondents in almost all the Caribbean-7
the police, ultimately increasing the public’s countries. The fact that violent crime is per-
sense of security from crime (chart 4.2). As ceived as more threatening is typical of most
fear of crime lessens and the sense of security developed nations in the world, even though
increases, citizens will become more able psy- the incidence of property crime is gener-
chologically to pursue human development ally many times greater than the incidence of
activities that enhance the quality of their violent crime.20 At the neighbourhood level,
lives. robbery and day-time break-ins were rated as
Crime is salient to citizens in the Carib- the first or second greatest crime problems in
bean region. Less than half of the survey all the Caribbean-7 countries except Guyana
respondents felt secure from crime (see and Jamaica. In Guyana, citizens worried the
chapters 1 and 6). Given the high rates of most about robbery and night-time break-ins
homicide, robbery, burglary, rape and domes- in their neighbourhoods; in Jamaica, murder
tic violence documented in chapter 1, it is not was feared the most.
surprising that insecurity is widespread. The In the rest of this section, we discuss the
region is also facing economic challenges that two factors—shown in chart 4.2—that are
are sometimes more immediate and threaten- predictive of a sense among citizens that they
ing than the fear of becoming the victim of a are secure from crime: perceived police legiti-
crime. It is therefore revealing that the survey macy and perceived police competence. If cit-
found that nearly one fifth of the respondents izens see the police as credible agents of social
said crime is the number one problem in their control operating under the rule of law and
nations; a smaller percentage said crime was as competent in that role and worthy of assis-
the first or second greatest problem in their tance and cooperation, then citizens are likely
neighbourhoods. to feel secure from crime. Perceived legiti-
102 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
macy and perceived competence may both be
eroded by the use by police of excessive force
Chart 4.3 People Who Believe Police Treat Citizens 4
with Courtesy, Equality, Fairness and
or by police corruption; so, it is important for
60
51.8
50 48.8
39.7
40 37.7 37.9
36.3
33.0
Percent
30.2
30
25.7
23.9 23.3
19.3 20.7
20 17.2
15.0
11.1
10
0
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
Respect for All Citizens’ Rights Respect for Your Rights
supported by a study that examined calls for po- lied on different five-point rating scales; the
lice service assistance by citizens in three of the answers are thus not strictly comparable. The
Caribbean-7.23 Using the proportion of calls results suggest, however, that the respondents
related to non-criminal matters as an indicator tended to feel their own rights are respected
of legitimacy, the study found that Barbadian more than those of their fellow citizens. Thus,
citizens regard their police as more legitimate almost 49 percent of the respondents in Saint
than the citizens in either Trinidad and To- Lucia felt that the police respected their
bago or Jamaica. The police in Barbados have rights, but fewer than half of this 49 percent
also achieved the greatest amount of reform, believed that their fellow citizens were treated
while the police in Trinidad and Tobago are in a respectful manner. Agreement that the
struggling to keep pace with the high levels of police showed respect for the rights of other
criminal activity there. The other four coun- citizens averaged only 21 percent across the
tries fall somewhere in between. Caribbean-7, while respect for the respond-
Respondent perceptions of the respect ents’ own rights averaged 39 percent. Except
shown by the police for citizen rights gener- in Barbados, neither set of answers seemed
ally and for civil rights in particular are out- to indicate that the police in the region are
lined in chart 4.4. The two relevant survey regarded as legitimate. This finding is likely
questions probed police legitimacy through related to the perception that the police are
the perceptions of respondents on the re- corrupt. In any case, it appears these countries
spect displayed by police for the rights of face a significant challenge in seeking citizen
the respondents, but also the rights of other cooperation with the police or citizen co-pro-
citizens. The questions were asked at differ- duction in crime prevention and control.
ent points in the survey interviews and re-
104 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Chart 4.5 Victims of Domestic Violence Who Believe Police 4
Treated Them with Respect, Caribbean-7, 2010
40 38.9
34.5
32.2 31.0 30.0 32.9
30 29.9 29.9 27.5
24.3 25.3 24.1
22.5
20
16.0
10
0
Antigua & Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Caribbean-7
Female Male
The pattern is different among victims of the percentage of respondents in the Carib-
domestic violence (chart 4.5). The level of bean-7 who chose the last two answers. Re-
satisfaction of these people, both men and spondents in Barbados showed the greatest
women, regarding their treatment by police is amount of confidence in the competence of
low. the police in this area: 16.7 percent respond-
ed “a great deal”, and 65.4 percent responded
Perceived Police Competence and “some confidence”. As above, this is not sur-
Performance prising given the transformation of the police
The perception that police officers and police in Barbados. For example, the Royal Barbados
agencies are competent rests on the belief that Police Force has recently improved its already
the police can control crime through preven- well-regarded services by expanding outreach
tion activities and by solving criminal cases, to rural areas. If we sum the two response op-
as well as the perception that the police are tions within each country, the data show that
effective in carrying out their myriad other more than 55 percent of the respondents in
responsibilities.24 The UNDP Citizen Secu- each country felt some confidence or a great
rity Survey 2010 included three questions deal of confidence in the ability of the police
that measured perceived competence. The to control crime.
first question asked respondents to gauge The survey findings show that the confi-
how much confidence they had in the ability dence of respondents in the police also mir-
of the police to control crime effectively: no rors the assessment by respondents of the
confidence, some amount of confidence, or performance of the police in controlling two
a great deal of confidence. Chart 4.6 displays major crimes: robbery and burglary (com-
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 105
4 Chart 4.6 Perceived Confidence in the Police to Control
Crime, Caribbean-7, 2010
The Police: Transitioning to Citizen Security
70
65.4
62.5 62.1
60 59.4 59.1
57.3
53.9 52.7
50
Percent
40
30
20 16.7
14.3 14.3 15.5
11.6 11.9
10 6.7 4.6
0
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
Some Amount of Confidence A Great Deal of Confidence
pare charts 4.6 and 4.7). The respondents in the measures so far discussed, and this trend
Barbados had the greatest confidence in the continued with regard to performance. In
police: around 82 percent had a great deal contrast, the respondents in Trinidad and To-
of confidence or some confidence in the po- bago had little confidence in the police and
lice (chart 4.6). Their rating of police perfor- also rated the performance of the police the
mance in controlling robbery and burglary lowest in controlling robbery and burglary.
was also the highest relative to respondents Suriname was second to Barbados: 77.6 per-
in the rest of the Caribbean-7: 40 percent of cent of the respondents there indicated they
the respondents in Barbados rated the police had confidence in the police to address the
good or very good in controlling both rob- crime problem, while 29.1 and 27.7 percent,
bery and burglary (chart 4.7). Respondents in respectively, rated the police as good or very
Trinidad and Tobago showed the least con- good in controlling robbery and burglary.
fidence in the police: 58 percent had a great It is also evident in chart 4.7 that the per-
deal of confidence or some confidence in the ceptions of the police control of robbery (that
police (chart 4.6). They also rated police per- is, theft from a person) tracks closely with
formance the poorest in controlling robbery perceptions of the police control of burglary
and burglary: only 10 percent rated the po- (theft from a building, car, home, and so on),
lice good or very good in these areas (chart even though the latter is a much more frequent
4.7). As seen in charts 4.3, 4.4 and 4.6, the crime in the Caribbean. Another conclusion
respondents in Barbados rated the police as is that, although the respondents have more
the most legitimate and most competent on or less confidence in the police to control the
106 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Chart 4.7 Perceived Performance of the Police in Controlling 4
Robbery and Burglary, Caribbean-7, 2010
40 39.4 40.1
30 29.1
Percent
27.1 27.7
25.4 23.5 24.123.7
20.6 20.5
20 19.8 20.8 19.8
10.5 10.8
10
0
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
Burglary Robbery
40
31.9
30 28.9
27.4 27.1
22.9 23.3 23.9 25.6 23.0
22.9 21.7
20 19.6 20.7
Percent
18.0
10.8
10
8.9
0
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
mance of the police in controlling domestic the fact that the respondents rate the perfor-
violence in the communities and the coun- mance of police in their communities more
tries of the respondents. The findings show favourably than the performance of police in
that the rating by respondents of the ability their countries. This parallels research show-
of the police to control domestic violence ing there is greater support for the police in
mirrors the assessment by respondents of one’s own community than for police else-
the performance of the police in controlling where, suggesting that familiarity has a some-
robbery and burglary. Thus, Barbados ranks what positive effect on assessment.
the highest, and Trinidad and Tobago ranks
the lowest. However, even in Barbados, only Willingness of Citizens to Participate
29 percent of the respondents thought the and Cooperate with the Police
performance of the police in the community
was either good or very good; the majority If citizens perceive the police to be both legiti-
perceived the performance of the police as mate in the use of social control mechanisms
less effective. This indicates that police de- and competent in doing so, citizens are more
partments in the Caribbean need to focus likely to participate in crime control activities
with the police and to be generally supportive
Chart 4.9 Reporting Crimes to the Police, of police efforts.25 The crime control activities
Caribbean-7, 2010 include reporting crimes to the police, coop-
erating in investigations, coming forward with
information about future or past criminal inci-
80 dents, and donating time and money to police
73.4 programmes. The only relevant question on
70.8
70 67.1 65.3 65.9 participation in the UNDP Citizen Security
62.4 63.1
62.0 60.9 Survey 2010 came at the end of a question se-
60
quence: “In the last year, were you the victim
48.2
51.1 of any of the following 18 violent crimes, and,
50 46.8 47.6
43.9 if yes, did you report the violent incident to the
40 39.2 police?” A similar sequence of questions dealt
Percent
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
percent
trol. This informal mechanism may explain tigua and Jamaica. As measured by the survey,
the low satisfaction of some citizens with the the lack of gender differences across the region
police response to crime reports. In Guyana, indicates that the police do not systematically
citizens say they do not believe the police will respond differently to crime reports filed by
follow up on reports regarding non-violent women or men. This suggests that inputs by
crimes and, so, often do not file such reports. women into discussions on the best way for
Nonetheless, relative to respondents elsewhere, police forces to transition to a citizen security
when citizens in Guyana do report property focus or inputs by women serving on police
crimes, they are the most satisfied with the po- oversight bodies are not being discounted by
lice reaction. police services.
Charts 4.10 and 4.11 show that, across the Attitudes that support the police can be as
Caribbean-7, there was no particular general important as participation with the police in
gender pattern in the satisfaction of respond- crime prevention and control activities. The
ents with the police reaction to reports of UNDP Citizen Security Survey 2010 included
violent crimes or property crimes. There were, five items measuring supportive attitudes. Two
however, marked differences across the seven items focused on the personal attitudes of re-
nations. For example, significantly higher per- spondents about the competence of the police
centages of women in Barbados, Saint Lucia, and whether the police deserve support (chart
and Trinidad and Tobago were satisfied with 4.12). The first question allowed a simple yes
the police response to their reports of violent or no. On average, 57 percent of the survey re-
or property crimes. In contrast, significantly spondents said “yes” in answer to this question
higher percentages of men were satisfied with about police competence. The share varied
the police response to violent crime reports in widely across the Caribbean-7, from a low of
Guyana and to property crime reports in An- 42 percent in Guyana to a high of 72 percent
110 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Chart 4.12 Respondents Who Believe the Police Are Competent 4
and Deserve Support, Caribbean-7, 2010
40
30
20
10
0
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
Police are Competent Police Deserve my Support
in Barbados. Agreement with the statement have rated the effectiveness at a higher level.
“The police force deserves my support” was Second, the respondents might not think the
measured on a five-point scale ranging from police are currently effective, but, because there
“the weakest feeling” to “the strongest feel- is only one police force, they feel the police
ing”. For this question, the two most positive deserve citizen support to help them become
responses were combined. The overall rate of more effective. Third, support is a fuzzy term,
agreement with the statement was 54 percent, and some citizens may base their support on
and the positive responses ranged from a low confidence in the ability of the police to pre-
of 40 percent in Guyana to highs of 65 percent vent and solve crimes, while others base their
in Jamaica and 67 percent in Saint Lucia. Both support on the friendliness and fairness of the
measures showed considerable attitudinal sup- officers with whom they come into contact.29
port for the police. Thus, these questions may be measuring quite
It may not be inconsistent for citizens to be different aspects of the willingness to partici-
dissatisfied with the police and unsure about pate and cooperate with the police. Fourth, the
the effectiveness of the police in respond- belief that police deserve support may reflect
ing to major crimes and, yet, also believe that the optimism and hope of respondents that the
the police deserve their support. First, the police will continue to reform and meet the de-
respondents were only asked about effective- mands of modern policing.
ness regarding specific major crimes and not Three other attitudinal measures in the
a fuller range of crimes for which they might UNDP Citizen Security Survey 2010 gauged
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 111
4 Chart 4.13 Respondents Who Believe the Police Need More Personnel and More
Resources, Caribbean-7, 2010
The Police: Transitioning to Citizen Security
90
82.6
82.0
80 76.4 76.7 77.0
71.9 72.1 74.8
69.2 70.7 68.5 72.5
70 67.3 66.3 68.8
65.0 64.9
60.1
60 57.9
54.4
52.7 51.0 52.6 53.1
50
Percent
40
30
20
10
0
Antigua & Barbados Guyana Jamaica Saint Lucia Suriname Trinidad & Caribbean-7
Barbuda Tobago
Increase Size of Police Invest More in Police More Police on the Street for Security
the support of respondents for governmental the rule of law and service of the citizenry. The
action that would enhance police services by government and the police should not take ad-
putting more police on the streets, investing vantage of this support only to modernize the
more in the police force and increasing the force (for example, by obtaining better weap-
size of the force. Together, all three actions ons, communications systems and transporta-
garnered more than 55 percent agreement tion), but also genuinely to reform the force
(chart 4.13). Across the Caribbean-7, an aver- by enhancing the organizational structure of
age of 75 percent of the respondents supported the police, the incentive and reward structure
investing more in the police; 69 percent fa- within the service and the relationship be-
voured putting more police on the streets; and tween the police and the public.
58 percent favoured increasing the size of the The final measure of the likelihood of citi-
police force. Together, the findings outlined in zen participation was the response to a survey
charts 4.12 and 4.13 demonstrate considerable question on working together with others
attitudinal support for the police in terms of to reduce violence. At least 45 percent of re-
competence, reputation and the need for more spondents across the Caribbean-7 expressed
resources from the government. These results their willingness to do this (chart 4.14). Ja-
indicate that citizens are interested in support- maica showed the highest positive response
ing the police. This support can be leveraged rate (65 percent), and Barbados the lowest
to aid the police in realizing the transition to (46 percent). The latter finding is not surpris-
an organization that is more well oriented to ing because the respondents in Barbados do
112 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Chart 4.14 Respondents Chart 4.15 Respondents 4
Willing to Work Willing to Work
70 70
65.5
60 59.3 60 58.9 58.3 59.2 57.4
56.8 56.8
54.0 54.6 56.6
50 50 51.6
46.2 45.7
40 40
Percent
Percent
30 30
20 20
10 10
0 0
Antigua & Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Caribbean-7
Willingness to
Work Together
Police Force
Deserves my
Support
Source: UNDP Citizen Security Survey 2010. Source: UNDP Citizen Security Survey 2010.
Note: Base: all respondents (N = 11,155). Question: Note: Base: all respondents (N = 11,155). Questions:
“Using a scale from 1 to 5 (1 weakest, 5 strongest), indi- “How do you rate the cohesiveness of your commu-
cate how you rate the cohesiveness of your community nity on the following: ‘To what extent would you be
on the following: ‘To what extent would you be willing willing to work together with others to reduce violence
to work together with others to reduce violence in this in this country?’ ‘The police force deserves my sup-
country.’” The chart shows the percentage of respon- port.’?” The chart shows the percentage of respon-
dents who answered “A great extent”, “A good extent” dents who answered “Strongly agree” and “Agree”.
or “A fair extent”.
not believe that the country has a major crime may not have the means, knowledge, or lead-
problem warranting more widespread col- ership to do so effectively. For example, even
laborative action. The Jamaican respondents though neighbourhood watch programmes
realized, in contrast, that they have a serious are common in Suriname, they do not nec-
crime problem. essarily make citizens feel safer. Nonetheless,
These data indicate that a crucial element the data indicate there is an untapped pool
in citizen participation and cooperation in of respect for the police and a sense of social
solving the crime problem exists across the connectedness that, if properly mobilized by
Caribbean: the willingness of citizens to work an innovative police agency, could lead to the
collectively to reduce crime. However, the co-production of citizen security.
willingness to work collectively is not identi- To assess the distribution of this willingness
cal with engaging in partnerships with the po- across populations, the answers of respondents
lice.30 Although citizens may express a desire were broken down by demographic character-
to engage in the co-production of safety, they istics. Charts 4.15, 4.16 and 4.17 show that the
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 113
willingness is exhibited in all age categories, crease security. These findings differ from find-
4 both genders and all but the lowest socio-eco- ings in the United States, where older citizens
nomic category. Thus, the distribution is broad and women are more likely to participate and
The Police: Transitioning to Citizen Security
United Provinces (the Netherlands) defeated of Justice and the Court of Appeal.9 Both
England in battle during the Second Anglo- are based in Saint Lucia. It acts as an itiner-
Dutch War.2 ant court, travelling to member states at fixed
In addition to the similarities in the foun- periods throughout the year to “hear appeals
dations of their legal systems, the criminal from the decisions of the High Court and
justice systems in the Caribbean-7 also share Magistrates Courts in Member States in both
structural similarities. Each nation has a simi- civil and criminal matters”.10 Whereas other
lar hierarchy of courts that handle both civil countries may operate their own independent
and criminal matters, as well as appeals. With high court and court of appeals, the ECSC
the exception of courts in Suriname, the offers these functions regionally for member
courts in each country have a three-tier struc- states. However, the ECSC does not serve as a
ture that includes magistrates courts, a high final appellate court. For Antigua and Barbu-
court and a court of appeal.3 The terminology da and for Saint Lucia, final appellate jurisdic-
used for these three entities is fairly consist- tion rests with the Judicial Committee of the
ent, though there are variations.4 The magis- Privy Council, an entity located in London
trates courts serve as the lowest level of the and formally tied to the United Kingdom and
court system, hearing lesser judicial matters, to judicial systems in many Commonwealth
including small claims civil actions and less countries.
severe criminal matters.5 Typically non-jury The majority of the countries of the Carib-
cases are handled in the magistrates courts, bean Community (CARICOM) use the Judi-
while more serious civil and criminal matters cial Committee of the Privy Council as a last
are handled through the high courts. Con- venue for appeals.11 As the only country of the
sistent caseload statistics are not available for Caribbean-7 that does not have a predomi-
each country, though it has been estimated nantly British legal foundation, Suriname uses
that approximately 90 percent of the legal its own High Court of Justice as a final court
proceedings in the judicial system in Guyana of appeals.12 Only Barbados and Guyana rely on
emanate from the magistrates courts.6 the regional Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ)
The court structure in Suriname, the only na- as final appellate court.13
tion in the Caribbean-7 with a legal system The CCJ was established by a treaty that
based on laws of the Netherlands, is some- was ratified in 2003. However, “although the
what different. Suriname’s legal system is Agreement was signed by nearly all of the
grounded on three cantonal or district courts, Member States of the Community, only three
each of which is presided over by a single of those States (Barbados, Belize and Guyana)
judge, whose decisions can be appealed to have enacted the required domestic legislation
the Court of Justice. The First District Court to accord access to the Court by their nation-
tries civil cases in specific regions of the coun- als.”14 The CCJ is modelled after the British
try. The Second District Court tries criminal appellate system and replaces the Privy Coun-
cases in specific regions of the country. The cil for those countries that choose to enact
Third District Court hears civil and criminal the appellate jurisdiction of the agreement.
cases in those regions not covered by the two The CCJ was established to “provide for the
other courts. There is also a lower court, the Caribbean Community an accessible, fair,
Martial Court, which has jurisdiction over efficient, innovative and impartial justice sys-
cases involving military personnel.7 tem built on a jurisprudence reflective of Car-
The Eastern Caribbean Supreme Court ibbean history, values and traditions, while
(ECSC) has jurisdiction in the member maintaining an inspirational, independent in-
countries of the Organization of Eastern Car- stitution worthy of emulation by the courts of
ibbean States, including Antigua and Barbu- the region and the trust and confidence of its
Source: World Prison Brief (database), International Centre for Prison Studies, London, http://www.prisonstudies.org/info/
worldbrief/.
Note: The data year is in parentheses.
a. The total includes pre-trial detainees and remand prisoners. The rate is per 100,000 national population. The population
of pre-trial detainees and remand prisoners and the population of juveniles are shown in percentages of the total prison
population. Juveniles = under-18-year-olds.
b. Prison population as a percentage of official prison capacity.
c. US State Department (2010c).
d. Based on an estimated national population of 89,500 in December 2010 (United Nations data).
e. Data of the national prison administration.
f. Based on an estimated national population of 257,200 in October 2010 (United Nations data).
g. Based on an estimated national population of 761,000 in October 2010 (United Nations data).
h. Eight prisons are for adults; four are for juveniles.
i. Based on an estimated national population of 2.7 million in October 2007 (United Nations data).
j. Based on an estimated national population of 176,000 in December 2010 (United Nations Data).
k. Three adult prisons, one pre-trial detention centre, one juvenile detention centre, and 19 temporary detention centres in
police stations.
l. US State Department (2010e).
m. Based on an estimated national population of 522,000 at the end of 2009 (United Nations data).
n. Based on an estimated national population of 1.3 million in January 2010 (United Nations data).
processing by the crime laboratory.31 The re- was proposed in the Guyana Justice Sector Re-
searchers concluded that the backlogs at the form Strategy of 2006–2010.35 However, even
laboratory were partially responsible for the with this programme in place, the shortages of
nation’s massive increase in homicides and judges make it virtually impossible to reduce
shootings because violent repeat offenders the civil litigation backlog. Estimates suggest
who might have been incarcerated based on that, even if two judges were assigned and even
the evidence were free to continue offending. if each one concluded one civil matter every
Trinidad and Tobago’s solution to the prob- working day of the year (249 days), this would
lem was to hire foreign firearms examiners only lead to the completion of 498 cases out
from the United Kingdom and the United of an average of 5,600 cases filed, thus leaving
States. Such short-term measures may be use- a backlog of 5,102 cases.36
ful, but they suggest a failure to recognize the No silver-bullet solutions have emerged in
systemic nature of this problem and associ- the Caribbean for case processing delays and
ated problems. No long-term solutions were backlogs. As more of these nations begin us-
put in place to prevent the backlog from re- ing sophisticated forensic evidence process-
turning. ing techniques (such as ballistics imaging and
The issue of evidence processing backlogs DNA profiling), it is likely that the delays will
will become even more resonant as Caribbean actually worsen. Finding a way to address this
nations grow increasingly reliant on foren- problem is crucial.
sic evidence to close cases. For instance, the
United States is currently dealing with massive Low Conviction Rates
backlogs in DNA evidence.32 While DNA is Although systematic data are not available,
a wonderful tool for identifying and convict- scattered evidence suggests that conviction
ing offenders, processing DNA evidence is ex- rates in the Caribbean are alarmingly low.
pensive and resource-intensive and is likely to For instance, Guyana’s Justice Sector Re-
worsen case processing delays and backlogs. form Strategy 2006–2010 reports that an
Backlogs are, however, not merely a matter estimated “90% of criminal prosecutions in
of efficiency; they go directly to the ques- the Magistrates Courts are unsuccessful.”37
tion of whether defendants are being treated Brathwaite (1996) reports that, in Barbados,
justly. Consider Guyana, which reports that, the number of convictions fell from 1,729 in
in 2010, nearly 41 percent of its prisoners had 1960 to only 775 in 1990.
not yet been tried or convicted on the current Part of the challenge in studying the prob-
charges for which they were being detained.33 lem is that case processing delays make it dif-
For defendants who are not guilty, backlogs ficult to measure conviction rates: the two is-
might mean spending a lot of time in jail for sues are hopelessly intertwined. For instance,
offences they did not commit. Consider Suri- a study conducted in Trinidad and Tobago
name, where many prisoners awaiting appeal found that, of the 123 cases involving defend-
end up serving their full original sentence ants committed to stand trial in the High
before their appeal is heard because there are Court in 2003–2006, only 30.1 percent had
not enough judges to adjudicate these cases.34 been concluded as of July 2008. Only seven
The general consensus within the region is (5.7 percent) of the 123 cases had produced
that backlogs are exacerbated by inadequate a conviction either by trial or by plea.38 Simi-
staffing. However, even attempts to address larly, a report on human rights practices in
these concerns highlight the crippling extent Guyana notes that “Prisoner Justin John was
of the problem. For example, Guyana reduced taken into custody in 2003 and charged with
to some extent its backlog in the civil court murder; his trial was scheduled to begin in
under a special project whereby part-time 2008, but, in May 2010, he was among 23
124 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
prisoners who requested an early trial; he was only approximately 20 to 25 percent are pros-
freed on June 16 after the state was unable to ecuted. The remaining cases are dismissed or 5
produce witnesses in support of its case.”39 left in limbo. The prosecution office simply
percent in 2010, while, in 2005, Suriname likelihood of recidivism and to develop alter-
reported that more than 50 percent of the natives to incarceration for nonviolent offend-
prison population was being held for pre-trial ers and those whose likelihood of repeat of-
or remand. fending is minimal. This idea of a correctional
While overcrowding is problematic on its triage strategy applies most directly to three
face, it has also generated residual issues as- types of offenders: juvenile offenders, older
sociated with the conditions of confinement. offenders and people convicted of drug pos-
Some reports document widespread deterio- session. Juvenile offenders, particularly those
ration in prison conditions in the Caribbean new to crime and those who commit nonvio-
because of overcrowding, poor sanitation and lent offenses, will often either be victimized or
resource constraints. According to the US will go on to commit more crime as a result of
State Department (2010b, 2010e), among spending time in a criminogenic environment
the Caribbean-7, only the prison facilities in such as a prison. Imprisoning older offenders,
Barbados and Saint Lucia meet international who are often long past the peak of the age-
standards. crime curve, is not always the most efficient use
The large number of people held in pre-trial of prison space. Finally, imprisoning offenders
detention is a major contributor to backlogs and convicted of drug possession is also often not
overcrowding, but other factors also contribute. wise because many such offenders need treat-
For instance, many nations faced with increases ment for addiction. In all three cases, offenders
in crime, particularly violent crime, have passed and society may be best served through alter-
laws containing provisions for harsher sanc- native punitive sanctions, coupled with reha-
tions and longer prison terms for certain types bilitation.
of offenders, particularly those convicted of
gang-related crimes. Harsher prison sentences Insufficient Alternatives to Incarceration
for certain types of offenders are likely to pro- Policy makers facing increases in crime and
duce public safety benefits, but such sentences high levels of violence often focus so intent-
for other types of offenders—particularly non- ly on being tough on crime that they forget
violent drug offenders and older offenders who about the importance of rehabilitation and
have aged out of crime—contribute to prison alternative sanctions. The Caribbean region’s
overcrowding. Brathwaite (1996) finds that, in nascent criminological infrastructure is not
Barbados, the share of offenders sentenced to yet supported by a well-developed knowledge
prison for three or more years rose from 6.9 to base on effective sanctions and rehabilitation
38.5 percent between 1960 and 1990. Brath- strategies. This is so despite the experiences of
waite also notes that patterns in crime changed other nations, which provide evidence on the
across this time period so that there was an in- effectiveness and promise of a range of strate-
crease in drug-related offences, robbery and gies, as well as approaches that may actually
theft. Caribbean nations can learn from the increase crime. For instance, Scared Straight!,
experiences of California. Decades of tough- a popular programme that has evolved from a
on-crime rhetoric by politicians led to runaway ground-breaking film, involves exposing juve-
spending on prisons and contributed to a finan- nile offenders to the reality of life in prison.
cial meltdown that resulted in major cuts to Critics assert that such programmes not only
public services, especially education. Moreover, fail to deter crime, but increase offending
the financial crisis caused California to release among young participants.44 Lacking a com-
tens of thousands of prisoners under less than prehensive local knowledge base on effective
ideal circumstances. strategies, Caribbean policy makers run the
Correctional policy must balance the require- risk of excessive reliance on the knowledge
ment to protect the public and the need for ef- base of more developed countries. A regional
126 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
investment in an institute to study the effec- policy makers.
tiveness of strategies in reducing crime and Of course, any wise correctional strategy 5
recidivism would be a positive step towards will account for the fact that offenders pre-
and Tobago is experimenting with restorative detainees” and that “the danger to juveniles of
justice strategies. In 2002, the Government of ‘criminal contamination’ while in detention
Trinidad and Tobago appointed a task force pending trial must not be underestimated. It
to review the penal reform system. One of the is therefore important to stress the need for
key recommendations advanced by the task alternative measures. . . . to avoid such deten-
force was the implementation of a restorative tion in the interest of the well-being of the
justice philosophy throughout the criminal juvenile.”51
justice system in Trinidad and Tobago. The The degree to which countries in the region
Prison Service is facing a familiar set of chal- observe the set of principles outlined in the
lenges in its efforts to shift from retributive Beijing Rules varies. In Guyana, provisions for
justice to restorative justice. juveniles are deficient in that there are no al-
The issue of alternatives to incarceration ternatives to detention prior to trial, nor have
is particularly salient for juvenile offenders. adequate facilities been established to support
Each of the Caribbean-7 has indicated that juveniles while they are kept in detention. A
juveniles detained for non-criminal matters detention centre has been constructed, but it
such as truancy, lack of appropriate guardian- has not been functional, and juveniles, both
ship and victimization through abuse are of- males and females, have been housed with
ten housed together with juveniles who have adults in detention facilities. This increases
committed criminal, often violent offences.49 the risk of sexual abuse. Indeed, it has led to
Because it is a long-standing truism of crimi- news reports of the sexual and physical abuse
nology that one of the most potent causes of of juveniles by law enforcement operatives
delinquency is exposure to delinquent peers, and adult inmates.52
any strategy that houses minor offenders to- Concerns about proper supervision and
gether with serious offenders is likely to in- staffing at some juvenile facilities or, in some
crease crime. Furthermore, these approaches instances, a complete lack of a juvenile correc-
are also likely to expose the less serious of- tional facility may result in the detention of
fenders to further victimization. juvenile offenders in adult facilities, as in An-
Researchers find that “for the entire popu- tigua and Barbuda and in Guyana. In Antigua
lation of three juvenile institutions in Trini- and Barbuda, the Boys Training School is crit-
dad and Tobago, 58.5 percent of youth in an icized for inadvertently preparing abandoned
institution for young boys and 92.8 percent and abused boys for lives of crime by housing
of youth in an institution for young girls were offenders and non-offenders together in the
institutionalized for non-illegal acts.”50 Suri- same facility. Many magistrates try to avoid
name, on the other hand, has a pre-detention remanding juvenile offenders to the facility.
juvenile facility specifically for youth awaiting One magistrate revealed that she is extremely
trial. The facility, which is called Opa Doeli, upset with the system’s failure to address ad-
was founded in 2007 and houses young per- equately the problem of young boys who con-
sons aged 10 to 18 years. It can accommodate stantly get into trouble. This particular magis-
54 boys and 14 girls, and these are able to at- trate has joined the chorus of complaints with
tend school normally within the centre. The respect to poor management, untrained staff,
purpose of the facility is to provide the youth ineffective rehabilitation and little oversight
with the skills to defend themselves against of the boys. Because of these inadequacies,
criminal influences. boys who commit serious offences are com-
The Beijing Rules, adopted by the United mitted to Her Majesty’s Prison, the country’s
Nations in 1985 to define a set of principles adult prison. Furthermore, in Antigua and
for the proper administration of juvenile jus- Barbuda, aside from probation, there are no
tice, speak directly to these concerns. These alternatives to sentencing and no restorative
128 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
justice options, and juveniles are tried in the justice planning agencies in Caribbean na-
same courts as adults. tions. Putting in place agencies capable of 5
There are a number of reasons to support this kind of systems thinking to monitor the
80
70.3
70
60
Percent
51.7
50
40 40.0 40.9
37.8
32.3 30.6
30
27.2
20
10
0
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
curity Survey 2010 asked respondents in the Trinidad and Tobago is the wealthiest of these
Caribbean-7 to assess the capacity of their nations, yet is perceived by its citizens to have
countries “to solve and better manage the the lowest capacity to address citizen security
problem of insecurity.” The share of respond- concerns. Similarly, Suriname and Guyana are
ents rating the capacity of their nations as among the poorest nations in this group, yet
‘sufficient’ or ‘very sufficient’ varied widely by they rank second and third, respectively, in
nation, from a low of 27 percent in Trinidad perceived level of capacity to address citizen
and Tobago to a high of 70 percent in Bar- security.53 National wealth alone is insuffi-
bados (with an average of 41 percent) (chart cient to guarantee citizen security and safety.
5.1). Three patterns are striking in the find-
ings. First, the wide variation across nations Confidence in the Justice System
suggests that some governments have done a One of the principal goals of government gen-
substantially better job in the eyes of citizens erally and criminal justice systems specifically
in building capacity to address security issues. is to provide for the security of the popula-
Second, although perceived capacity varies by tion. This security has an objective component
nation, it is quite low overall. Less than half of that is reflected in official statistics on crime,
the respondents across the Caribbean-7 per- violence and other threats to human security.
ceive their nations to have sufficient capacity It has a subjective component as well. For in-
45
41.1
40
35
31.6 30.3
30 28.9
26.8 26.8
25 24.6
Percent
22.9
20 18.4 17.8
15.9 15.8 15.7 15.5
15 14.5
10.4
10
0
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
of variation in their support, from 61.5 to make it unlikely that capital punishment will
75.5 percent. Similarly, a 2001 study of the be administered with sufficient swiftness or
opinions of college students on capital pun- likelihood to produce a deterrent benefit.
ishment found that 86.7 percent of males The research evidence on capital punishment
and 78.4 percent of females in Saint Augus- is mixed, but generally tends to indicate that
tine, Trinidad favoured capital punishment capital punishment is a weak deterrent.61 In-
in cases of first degree murder.55 The study deed, there is evidence suggesting that it may
noted that “not one of the respondents in even backfire by legitimating the use of deadly
Saint Augustine checked the ‘No Opinion’ force.62 Moreover, regardless of its actual or
category, suggesting that capital punishment potential instrumental benefit, the death pen-
is a particularly salient topic there.”56 Mean- alty is incompatible with the values that are
while, in Suriname, the only recent former associated with the human development ap-
colony of the Netherlands examined here, proach.
only 35.7 percent of respondents supported Human rights: The UNDP Citizen Se-
the death penalty.57 What accounts for this curity Survey 2010 asked respondents about
puzzling disparity? It is often said that colo- their agreement that human rights are obsta-
nies, even after independence, continue to cles to more effective crime control. Across
take on the characteristics of their colonizers. the Caribbean-7, only about 43.2 percent of
The Netherlands abolished capital punish- the respondents agreed, ranging from a low of
ment more than a century ago (in civil law, 34.2 percent in Guyana to a high of 62.8 per-
not in military law) and remains steadfast in cent in Saint Lucia. The nation with the sec-
its rejection of capital punishment. To this ond highest share of respondents who agreed
day, the Netherlands will not honour extra- was Suriname, at 48.2 percent. Thus, with the
dition requests in which the death penalty is exception of Saint Lucia, the extent of varia-
a possible sanction.58 In contrast, the United tion in the responses was fairly narrow. What
Kingdom abolished capital punishment only accounts for the relatively high proportion of
a little more than a decade ago. A 2009 poll respondents in Saint Lucia who view human
on attitudes towards the death penalty in rights as an impediment to crime control? The
the United Kingdom found that “70 percent most likely explanation is a recent outbreak of
think the U.K. should still have the death violent crime in Saint Lucia. Another potential
penalty as the maximum possible penalty for explanation is a Privy Council ruling prohib-
at least one of the twelve different types of iting Saint Lucia from enforcing a mandatory
crime surveyed.”59 Thus, the variations in the death penalty for all capital offenses and the
support for capital punishment in the Carib- Privy Council’s general unwillingness to up-
bean seems to be directly linked with the cul- hold death sentences during appeal phases.63
ture of support for the death penalty among Building more prisons: The survey asked re-
the former colonizers. spondents to rate their level of agreement that
The overwhelming level of support for government should build more prisons to re-
capital punishment in six of the Caribbean-7 duce crime. Across the Caribbean-7, only about
appears to be out of proportion with the 26.0 percent agreed, ranging from a low of 11.7
likely deterrent value of the punishment. A percent in Barbados to a high of 41.3 percent
long-standing axiom of criminology holds in Guyana. Excluding these two outliers, one
that deterrence has three components: cer- sees that the extent of variation in support for
tainty, severity and celerity (or swiftness).60 building more prisons is minimal (from 21.7
This means that the sanctions with the great- percent in Jamaica to 33.8 percent in Trinidad
est deterrent value are sufficiently severe and and Tobago). Moreover, these findings point
are administered swiftly and with a strong to a curious pattern. Across the Caribbean-7,
132 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
83.1 percent of respondents believe criminals the policy options that come to mind most
should be punished more harshly, and 62.6 quickly. The data here suggest that the public 5
percent support the death penalty; yet, only is looking at other options as well.
persons died as a result of the use of force by justice system. For instance, the Guyana Hu-
police. Of these, 1,748 died between 2000 man Rights Association (GHRA 2002, 37)
and 2009. Many of these killings have been concluded that the relative regularity of exe-
justified by statements that they occurred cution type killings by the police implies that
during shoot-outs with gunmen. However, there are elements in the Guyana Police Force
the high number of killings, eye-witness testi- who attempt “to ensure that persons they be-
mony, and other evidence such as the virtual lieve to be guilty of crimes do not escape the
absence of injuries or fatalities among police consequences”. The courts are therefore impli-
have raised concerns about the possibility of cated in the police use of excessive force in at
summary executions by police. least two ways. First, by failing to hold police
In Trinidad and Tobago, excessive use of officers accountable for the excessive use of
force by police is reportedly widespread, and force, courts may be implicitly supporting it.
“mechanisms to hold members of the police Second, by failing to hold offenders account-
service accountable for alleged abuses are able for their crimes, they may be implicitly
weak”.67 Trinidad and Tobago’s Police Com- (and unintentionally) promoting the exces-
plaints Authority, which reviews allegations sive use of force by police. Research in other
of police misconduct, reported that the sys- countries shows that courts can play a crucial
tem to investigate killings by police “contin- role in controlling the police use of deadly
ues to be unsatisfactory and unacceptable”.68 force, but only if this is matched by internal
These patterns are suggestive of a more wide- controls within police departments.70
spread trend in developing nations with a The Caribbean-7 countries all face con-
potent combination of weak judiciaries and cerns about police misconduct to varying de-
high crime rates. Police in these nations may grees. However, each has undertaken efforts
hold the view that their job is to sanitize be- to curb misconduct and create a system of
cause the court systems fail to hold offenders checks and balances to strengthen oversight.
accountable for their crimes.69 Thus, when Gomes (2007) highlights some of the police
Antigua and Barbuda, the issue of anti-cor- ing on some of the issues raised in this report.
ruption was identified as an important area of Regional professional bodies can serve as
concern, as were issues of youth violence and an outstanding venue for professional devel-
the enhancement of forensic and ballistics ex- opment by offering an arena for contact with
aminations. peers from other parts of the world who can
The Caribbean Association of Judicial share their ideas and help ensure a more vi-
Officers is a relatively new regional organiza- brant dialogue about regional criminal justice
tion: it held its inaugural conference in 2009. practices. To support this goal, regional pro-
Membership consists mostly of current or fessional bodies (such as the Association of
retired judicial officers from throughout the Caribbean Commissioners of Police) might
Caribbean. The association aims to enhance seek affiliation with larger bodies (such as the
the administration of justice, promote judi- International Association of Chiefs of Po-
cial independence and standards of integrity lice).
and accountability, foster professional de- Regional cooperation and communi-
velopment among judicial officers, support cation are vital in any plan to improve the
research on the administration of justice and practice of criminal justice in the Caribbean.
improve the public image of the judiciary, However, there are at least two main caveats.
among other goals. The topics featured at its First, the benefits of regional cooperation are
annual conferences echo many of the themes often overstated. Professional meetings can
raised in this report, including trial manage- serve as a forum for spreading effective prac-
ment; expanding access to justice, especially tices, but they can as easily serve as a forum for
among vulnerable populations; and protect- reinforcing shared assumptions and spreading
ing victims from reprisal. However, other bad ideas. Second, while globalization has
important themes have not been taken up, had a fundamental impact on criminal jus-
especially case processing backlogs and over- tice systems throughout the world, including
crowding in prisons. the Caribbean, not all the crime and criminal
justice problems faced within Caribbean na-
Additional Regional Efforts tions are regional or global. Some are local
The organizations outlined above represent phenomena, and local solutions are needed
some of the more well known and well estab- to address these problems. While regional
lished forums for regional cooperation and problems deserve regional solutions, local
collaboration, but other ongoing efforts not problems deserve local solutions. Making the
described here might also play a role in im- distinction is vital.
proving the practice of criminal justice in the
region. Conclusion
Regional initiatives are a good way to en-
hance the level of professionalism, coordina- This chapter outlines important issues facing
tion and cooperation in dealing with issues Caribbean criminal justice systems. Research
of vital importance to Caribbean nations. has demonstrated that the structure and be-
Such initiatives enable nations to work to- haviour of criminal justice institutions can
gether to solve common problems, providing have a critical impact on citizen security. At
economies of scale often not possible in some the same time, they can undermine public
of the Caribbean microstates that lack suffi- faith in the criminal justice system and gov-
cient resources to address some problems on ernment authority more generally. A long tra-
their own. Regional professional bodies also dition of research in criminology has shown
provide an opportunity for nations to share that criminal justice systems can generate un-
ideas, borrow effective programmes and prac- intended increases in crime and decreases in
138 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
human security if they do not adopt fair, ef- system. Medium-term gains can be realized
fective, transparent and accountable practic- by establishing a credible, secure and well-de- 5
es. Although the region’s criminal justice sys- signed witness protection programme at the
6
CHAPTER
An investment in sustainable
development is an investment
in sustainable security
6
CHAPTER
State Policies and the Policy
Orientation of Populations 6
the media in several countries, and this devel- ion on a variety of issues, including crime.
opment has deepened citizens’ awareness of In this way, the media shape agendas, act as
public issues and enhanced an already well- a watchdog for the public interest and play a
developed democratic culture. By the same role in the governance process. They facilitate
token, the media amplify the population’s accountability, help reduce the policy imple-
concerns, influence the perceptions of citizens mentation gap and bring the people into the
regarding the acuteness and character of prob- process of governance.
lems, help to set the agenda of concerns, and,
in so doing, help to frame policy discussions. The Policy Environment
Across the region, the media in their vari-
ous expressions exist as a form of open par- Crime and Insecurity in the Caribbean:
ticipation for the public. This ranges from The Policy Factor
radio talk shows and television programmes Crime control involves social, economic and
that allow call-in participation to lively print political dimensions that require the imple-
publications that invite letters to the editor. mentation of strategies to reduce and prevent
Despite the prevalence of television, radio criminality. Crime policies should actually
remains a primary source of information for prevent rather than seek to manage the relat-
Caribbean residents. Across the region, espe- ed problems. They must prevent and control
cially in Jamaica, weekday radio programmes crime by targeting its most violent and de-
are dominated by call-in sessions. These help structive expressions, while also being acutely
hold the government and governmental sensitive to the protection of citizen rights
agents accountable. The ability to rebroadcast and contributing to meeting social and eco-
via YouTube and the use of other social media nomic needs. An optimal response includes
aid the process of accountability. For exam- crime prevention strategies that address the
ple, during the May 2010 operation to arrest root and proximate causes of crime, as well as
and extradite Christopher Coke, a Jamaican crime reduction initiatives such as the remov-
drug lord, social media were used to follow al of criminals from society. Achieving this
and report on the activities and, particularly, balance is integral to citizen security. There-
the alleged human rights abuses of Jamaica’s fore, how crime policy is developed and ex-
security forces. Likewise, news reports of po- ecuted and the level of effectiveness of crime
lice-civilian confrontations in Jamaica and in policy are at the core of the achievement of a
Trinidad and Tobago have been rebroadcast safe society.
via YouTube.2 Establishing a safe society, however, does
The first stage in a policy process might not mean the absence of crime and violence.
involve the framing of an issue by the media. Rather, it means the calibration of policy so
Across the region, this is evidenced in edi- that policy can help lead to desired outcomes
torials and commentaries on the role of the such as lower crime rates, increasingly effec-
Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) in its juris- tive public institutions, growing conformity
diction as a court of last resort. Regionwide, with laws and citizen support for crime policy
the media are a strong institution operating and the agencies and actors responsible for
to strengthen governance. They facilitate par- enforcement of the policy. The ultimate aim
ticipation and transparency by giving citizens is a more well integrated society.
a voice and permitting the free flow of infor- However, while effective crime control
mation, while helping hold governments ac- policies can never be a panacea for all the ills
countable through reporting, investigative of unsafe societies in the region, the policy
journalism and a whistle-blowing role. The response to the challenge of crime in these
media and the public work symbiotically: the democracies and the effect of the response on
144 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
citizen perceptions of government efforts in a reduction in the incidence of crime and ad-
crime reduction and in the respect for rights dress the social roots of crime, while securing 6
uniquely determine whether these societies citizen support for state policy. It also invites
traditionally disadvantaged groups and meet control model. However, such initiatives have
the demands of these groups for social justice. not become priorities in policy-making nor
Components of this approach have been pre- do they reflect a “comprehensive integrative
sent in the policies and programmes of various vision of crime control and citizen security.”
countries, but were most evident in Guyana Rather, the initiatives have taken the form of
and Jamaica in the 1970s.5 Yet, this empha- ad hoc measures, pilot programmes and ex-
sis on social policy and on remedial measures periments in bridging the gap between citi-
to assist the poor had uneven effects. While zens and the state.
crime rates in Guyana remained low, Jamaica The crime control approach and the social
experienced violent political conflict, high crime prevention–social justice approach are
levels of crime and near economic collapse. often viewed as polar opposites: one is tough
Unlike the due process model, the social on crime, and the other is soft on crime. Yet,
justice model is a powerful critique of exist- both are more nuanced than the either-or de-
ing social arrangements as they affect crime scription suggests. The integrated model that
and punishment. The social justice approach combines the best of both approaches bridges
assumes that crime is caused, in large part, by the dichotomy between the two. Despite ges-
unjust social arrangements and unequal power tures in this direction, nowhere in the Carib-
relations.6 It demands more than the equal- bean has any country moved fully towards
ity and fairness required under a due process an integrative model linking crime control
framework. It is a rights-seeking model that and social justice. The model has yet to find a
favours socially excluded and disadvantaged champion among the ranks of the incumbent
groups through state intervention. It encapsu- Caribbean political elite.
lates civil and criminal justice, deals with the Nevertheless, at the turn of the millenni-
overall fairness of a society and society’s rela- um, governments in the region were spurred
tionships and seeks to advance human well- to adopt tighter preventive measures. This
being, including by addressing the needs of the shift saw initiatives ranging from constitu-
most disadvantaged through the redistribu- tional reforms, implementation of citizen
tion of resources.7 security and justice projects, to gun buy-back
Central to this approach is the notion that schemes in Jamaica and in Trinidad and Toba-
government has a responsibility to ensure a go. In a similar vein, several countries adopted
basic quality of life for all citizens. The focus complementary initiatives aimed at restrain-
of the approach is crime prevention and the ing delinquency among the young, encourag-
reduction of criminality. The crime prevention ing community development and facilitating
methods seek to improve life chances through citizen empowerment. This was buttressed
greater social integration, cohesion and respect with the installation of independent commis-
for human rights and by confronting the pow- sions in Guyana, Jamaica, and Trinidad and
er relations in society. It is valuable for dealing Tobago that were created to achieve equal
with problems of social marginalization and opportunity for ethnic groups, secure respect
the lack of legitimate opportunities. for human rights and protect women and
Across the region, most states exhibit a children from abuse. Box 6.1 offers an exam-
preference for the crime control model and, ple of an integrated programme.8
specifically, an excessive reliance on law en-
forcement. As described by Packer (2004), The Shift in Policy Reflected in
the “Crime Control Model is based on the Budgetary Allocations
proposition that repression of criminal con- There has been a shift at the level of ideas
duct is by far the most important function to about crime prevention and control. In some
be performed by the criminal process.” countries, this shift has been accompanied by
146 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Box 6.1. The Citizen Security Programme, Trinidad and Tobago 6
Source: ‘Citizen Security Programme: Promoting a Culture of Peace and Lawfulness’, Government of Trinidad and Tobago, Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago,
http://csp.gov.tt/.
social crime prevention programmes, such as budgets to security, Barbados and Antigua
citizen security programmes in Jamaica and in and Barbuda, where the problem is not as se-
Trinidad and Tobago targeting youth at risk vere, both allocate 7.1 percent to security. It
and communities of urban poor. It is worth- may be that budgetary allocations are also a
while to probe the extent of this shift in actual function of economic and fiscal constraints
policy through an analysis of public security and political pressures on governments to ap-
budgets. pear to be responsive to the security needs of
Budgets reflect the actual policy priori- the populations. Debt burdens are certainly
ties of governments. They may reveal a gap countervailing constraints.
between declared and actual priorities. An ex- Likewise, the outcomes in terms of crime
amination of public expenditures on security reduction have no apparent association with
in six of the Caribbean-7 reveals that between expenditure. The expenditure of Trinidad and
5.9 percent (in the case of Guyana) and 13.9 Tobago on security is relatively high, but the
percent (Trinidad and Tobago) of the 2010 country’s serious crime rate remains high. Fi-
budgets were spent on security (see chart 6.1).9 nancial investment is not a sufficient condi-
These are fairly large proportions of the budg- tion for crime reduction. Much depends on
ets of these countries. As a proportion of GDP, the mix of policies, the public support for the
the figures are also significant. The average policies and the capacity to implement the
public expenditure on security in other regions policies effectively.
such as Central America is around 2.5 percent The right mix of policies means rebalanc-
of regional GDP, which is lower in comparison ing policy to give appropriate emphasis to
with the expenditure in the Caribbean coun- social crime prevention. The distributions of
tries.10 These levels of expenditure reflect the the security budgets in six of the Caribbean-7
increasing security problem and increasing risk (less Suriname) suggest that, despite new pro-
in the Caribbean, but also highlight the risk of grammes that have been introduced in some
diverting resources from other areas that are countries, crime prevention is relatively ne-
similarly vital to achieving the developmental glected (table 6.1).
goals of these countries. The crime prevention figures in table 6.1
The budgetary allocations that are shown are rough estimates based on aggregating ex-
in chart 6.1 do not fully represent the level, penditure on youth development, commu-
intensity and complexity of the problem. nity development and other such blunt pro-
Thus, while Jamaica and Trinidad and To- grammes and thus may tend to overestimate
bago, which have the highest rates of serious the actual expenditure. However, some social
crime among the Caribbean-7, respectively al- crime prevention projects and programmes
locate 6.2 and 13.9 percent of their national are funded through loans and grants that may
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 147
6 Chart 6.1 Estimates of Government Expenditure on
Security, Caribbean-7
State Policies and the Policy Orientation of Populations
16.0
13.9
14.0
12.0
12.0 11.0
10.0
8.0 7.1
Percent
7.1
6.2
5.9
6.0
3.3 3.8
4.0 2.9
2.1 2.1
2.0
0.0
Antigua & Barbados Guyana Jamaica Saint Lucia Trinidad &
Barbuda Tobago
not all be included in the estimates. These dif- grammes are required. Accountability, evalu-
ficulties aside, the data in the table reveal the ation and innovation are also required.
reality that, while a shift towards greater so- If the shift towards social crime preven-
cial crime prevention may be occurring, this tion is to be realized more fully, greater advo-
is still in the early stages and is insufficiently cacy will be needed. Old and new advocates
reflected in the budgetary allocations of Car- will have to exert greater influence on policy.
ibbean governments. Further consolidation
of this shift will mean rebalancing security Explaining the Policy Shift
budgets in favour of crime prevention. Crime control has consistently been on gov-
Meanwhile law enforcement, the courts ernment agendas in the Caribbean for more
and corrections rely on elaborate structures than three decades. Deep concerns about po-
that require large payments for salaries and litical violence and regime protection against
the maintenance of buildings and equip- subversion influenced policy from the 1960s
ment, which are not necessarily a measure through the mid-1980s. From the late 1960s
of responsiveness to the security demands of to the early 1980s, Caribbean leaders expend-
citizens. Social crime prevention has no such ed the effort in managing rising street crime
structures. Higher proportions of the preven- and the mounting criticism of racial and
tion dollar are therefore more likely to go di- class bias in policing and in the dispensing of
rectly to programmes. criminal justice. For example, both Jamaica
As in the case of law enforcement and and Trinidad and Tobago declared states of
the other areas of the criminal justice system, emergency: Jamaica in 1966 and 1976, and
there is no guarantee that the expenditure on Trinidad and Tobago in 1970.
prevention will have a commensurate return By the mid-1990s, as governments came
in terms of crime reduction. Effective pro- to see narco-trafficking as the main threat to
148 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Table 6.1. The Distribution of Government Budgetary Expenditures on Security
percent
6
national and hemispheric security, crime con- velopment of strategic intelligence on crime.13
trol came to be directed primarily at deterring Strategic intelligence refers to the capacity to
violent criminal behaviour and stemming the discern optimal approaches to the solution
increasing trade in guns and drugs. Trafficking of crimes and to calibrate policy in ways that
in drugs and the associated ills created such a produce effective results. Thus, targeting and
sense of exposure and heightened vulnerabil- a tight focus on drug-running were matched
ity among the region’s leaders, that they imag- by meaningful cooperation and coordination
ined the danger as an existential threat to the among the members of the Caribbean Com-
entire region.11 munity (CARICOM).
The perception of an existential threat was This regional focus on crime control with
not unfounded.12 However, political leaders its emphasis on law enforcement, deterrence
and law enforcement agencies in the region and interdiction constituted a major policy
had to be sensitive to the already inadequate departure: the initiatives displayed a grasp of
capacity of Caribbean states to secure their the fact that narco-trafficking was susceptible
borders, conduct sophisticated surveillance to a regional and coordinated strategy. This
of traffickers and devise new legislative and shift to a more nuanced policy orientation was
other enforcement measures to bring traffick- encouraged by several developments. They
ers to justice. included the recognition that addressing the
Between the mid-1990s and the present, crime problem required crime reduction, but
Caribbean leaders, local law enforcement also crime prevention. In addition, the loss of
agencies and allied international organiza- citizen confidence in the ability of Caribbean
tions have responded to the crime threat. states to provide public safety encouraged the
Recognizing that they could not work alone, states to seek alternative solutions.
heads of government in the region readily In general, factors influencing policy shifts
adopted a regional approach to the problem. include ideas, institutions and actors.14 Across
In policy terms, the regional response to the Caribbean, the most influential of the
the crime threat in recent years seems to con- three may be official and unofficial policy ac-
firm the growth in policy-learning and the de- tors. The Caribbean crime policy arena con-
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 149
sists of several main policy actors, often known ber states are parties to several regional and
6 to each other, who, singly or in tandem, seek international conventions that are comple-
to effect change in the crime landscape. These mented by bilateral and multilateral coop-
State Policies and the Policy Orientation of Populations
actors include CARICOM, police and other eration initiatives such as the Barbados Plan
law enforcement organizations, international of Action of May 1996, the Action Plan of
development partners, and the United States. October 1996 for the implementation of
Civil society groups, particularly the private an anti-drug strategy in the hemisphere, the
sector, the media, regional organs such as the Bridgetown Plan of Action, and the Europe-
Association of Caribbean Commissioners of an Union–Latin America Action Plan.17 The
Police and the Regional Security System, and, Barbados Plan of Action sets out specific ac-
to a lesser extent, engaged citizens have also tivities to be undertaken by states in the area
influenced crime policy in the direction of of drug control and coordination. The Car-
social crime prevention. ibbean has also partnered with international
The shift across the region has involved initiatives such as the Drug Prevention Net-
a change in ideas, as well as policies. For ex- work of the Americas.
ample, there are currently more social pre- CARICOM leaders moved to deepen
vention programmes within the region than their knowledge of crime in the region and
there were five years ago. This includes the sought expertise by appointing a Regional
citizen security programmes sponsored in Task Force on Crime and Security in 2001.
Guyana, Jamaica, and Trinidad and Tobago They received the report and recommenda-
by the Inter-American Development Bank. tions of the task force the following year.18
Success in swaying policy depends on the In 2007, as a demonstration of its commit-
ability to influence policy makers. However, ment to regional security and in response to
across the Caribbean, this sort of influence the scope of the regionwide crime problem,
has not occurred through lobbying or the for- CARICOM adopted security as the fourth
mation of coalitions of civic groups. Instead, pillar of the community. In 2008, the CARI-
the ability to influence changes in policy is re- COM Secretariat, in tandem with the United
lated to but not restricted to party member- Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, pro-
ship, funding status, knowledge of the system duced the draft Caribbean Community Ac-
and group interest and power. tion Plan for Social Development and Crime
Through organs such as the Implemen- Prevention. The action plan seeks to prevent
tation Agency for Crime and Security (IM- and reduce levels of violence and crime in
PACS), the Council for Human and Social member states. It has five specific goals: re-
Development and the Council of National duce violence, foster social inclusion, promote
Security and Law Enforcement, CARICOM integration, empower victims and protect the
has had the most influence on crime policy environment and economic resources.19
from within the region. One avenue has been CARICOM crime control initiatives
the formalization of IMPACS, an outgrowth also include regional gun-marking and gun-
of the CARICOM task force report on crime tracing programmes, as well as regional ini-
and security. IMPACS provides, among other tiatives to promote firearms marking in Latin
assistance, “mobilization of resources to sup- America and the Caribbean.20 (See box 6.2 for
port the collective fight against serious crime a sample regional firearms trafficking control
and to counter security threats in the re- initiative.) In collaboration with international
gion”.15 These CARICOM entities have been and regional NGOs and civil society groups
able to influence a shift towards advocacy for and the Institute of International Relations
and the adoption of prevention programmes at the University of the West Indies campus
such as the Social and Development Crime in Saint Augustine, Trinidad and Tobago,
Prevention Plan. CARICOM IMPACS launched a regional
For more than two decades, CARICOM initiative aimed at reducing the use of guns in
has had regional drug control plans.16 Mem- the commission of violent crimes.21
150 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Box 6.2. The Control of Firearms Trafficking in Central America and Neighbouring Countries 6
the Organization of American States, pos- community policing initiatives and support
sess mechanisms to allow civil society par- for the rule of law through the United States
ticipation in their activities. CARICOM, for Agency for International Development, and
example, has adopted the Charter of Civil the support offered by the UK Department
Society for the Caribbean Community. At for International Development for police
the national level, however, acceptance of forces.26
civil society’s role in influencing national This emergent orientation, with its em-
policy-making and debate is still feeble. In phasis on crime prevention, poses a challenge
most countries, the architecture for regular to competing ideas about law enforcement in
engagement between governments and civil the region. For example, debates about en-
society is still being developed. Strengthen- forcing the law generated advocacy within the
ing civil society participation was among the law enforcement community for increased re-
recommendations of the Caribbean Sub Re- sources to heighten police visibility and deter
gional Civil Society Forum held in Prepara- crime. Consequently, across the region, the
tion for the Fifth Summit of the Americas, in implementation of this approach has seen an
2009.23 Government–civil society collabora- increase in the number of police officers on
tion requires a climate of cooperation, the the streets. Law enforcement influence on the
institutionalization of civil society partici- policy landscape occurs through interest and
pation and a framework of supportive legal membership. Law enforcement community
and regulatory structures. Many civil society influence on the implementation of policy is
organizations are struggling for legitimacy. exemplified by the role of the Jamaica Con-
Mutual respect and trust are still being devel- stabulary Force in the realization of Jamaica’s
oped between governments and civil society ‘six anti-crime bills’ in 2010 (see the section
organizations. on implications below).27
The United States is also a major actor The portfolio of CARICOM initiatives
in crime control policy, influencing policy on drug-trafficking and criminal activities is
through initiatives such as the Caribbean Ba- an example of how to address the crime chal-
sin Security Initiative, through capacity de- lenge effectively. Moreover, it evidences an es-
velopment programmes and through annual tablished framework for pursuing social and
reporting protocols such as the annual Nar- development crime prevention initiatives to
cotics Control Strategy Report, the Traffick- facilitate the transition to citizen security.
ing in Persons Report and the State Depart-
ment Country Reports on Human Rights.24 The Policy Orientation
The United Kingdom has also sought to of the Population
influence the region with respect to human
rights practices.25
Among the more powerful policy actors The Policy Environment
in the region are bilateral and multilateral Public opinion has become an integral part
agencies and international development part- of the public policy process. This means that
ners, such as the Canadian International De- attention to the orientation of the public
velopment Agency, the European Union, the and to the level of support of the public for
Inter-American Development Bank, the Or- policies is an essential element in the shift to-
ganization of American States, the UK De- wards greater citizen security. Across the re-
partment for International Development and gion, data on public attitudes are increasingly
the United States Agency for International being assessed. Simultaneously, research on
Development. These actors do not remain public attitudes towards the insecurity arising
isolated, but seek allies, support and leverage because of crime and related issues has grown
152 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
substantially. Much of this research has taken results of the UNDP Citizen Security Survey
the form of opinion surveys assessing the pub- 2010, the value orientation of the popula- 6
lic’s attitudes about a range of crime-related tion reflects inconsistencies and ambiguities.
percent Caribbean-7,
2010
Social
Development Institutional Issues
Issues (housing, (corruption, voice)
schooling, 5.9 50
47.6 47.2
poverty, migration,
sanitation, health)
45
13.9
40
35
Percent
30 29.9
Crime Issues 27.4
(property
crime, 25
Economy/Prices violent crime,
insecurity) 21.7
Issue 20
(unemplyment, 27.4
17.4
cost of food, 16.1
cost of living) 15
52.9
10 8.9
Jamaica
Barbados
Guyana
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Caribbean-7
Antigua & Barbuda
portunities for intervention. They indicate a the respondents to the UNDP Citizen Secu-
high level of punitiveness, as well as a lack of rity Survey 2010 supported the use of dons
support for the rule of law, but they also indi- as agents of crime control.38 That more than
cate that sections of the population are con- 1 person in 10 support a phenomenon that
temptuous of criminals and criminal behav- is confined to socially excluded communities
iour. This opposition to criminality should indicates the extent to which some citizens
be channelled into more law-regarding and have lost confidence in the government. En-
socially constructive directions. dorsement of informal social control mecha-
There is a disconnection in the support nisms, including vigilante justice, is also an
for human rights practice and the principle indicator of the erosion of the rule of law and
of the rule of law. Thus, there is advocacy for the perception of the state’s weak capacity to
the harsher treatment of criminals, but citi- provide protection.
zens are less inclined to allow the police to The survey contained one question about
break the law to control crime or kill gunmen. the level of agreement of respondents with a
This finding mirrors the findings of Powell policy that would allow citizens easier access to
and Lewis (2011) in Jamaica, where there is firearms to reduce crime. Across the Caribbe-
strong support for the rule of law, but failings an-7, only about 17.9 percent of the respond-
in the observance of civil and human rights in ents agreed. (The range was from 6.6 percent
areas such as law enforcement and prison sys- in Barbados to 25.9 percent in Suriname.) Al-
tems, in the increasing incidence of vigilante lowing people to arm themselves in the name
attacks, and in the excessive and sometimes of crime prevention does not appear to be a
deadly use of force by the police in their treat- favoured policy option in the Caribbean.
ment of offenders. The extent to which a society is viewed as
In general, Caribbean societies have been just is integral to perceptions of security. Jus-
judged to possess a strong belief in basic rules tice encompasses economic practices, cultural
and values of democracy, especially the right to attitudes, and social and personal relation-
due process, respect for the rule of law, the de- ships, privileges and networks.39 Across the
fence of civil liberties and the political freedom Caribbean-7, 40.0 percent of the respondents
of citizens. Nonetheless, as the dissatisfaction felt their societies are fundamentally unjust.40
of citizens with escalating crime rates grows, Also, 52.5 percent of the respondents indi-
more people are registering support for un- cated that politically connected criminals are
democratic alternatives such as a willingness to likely to go free; 47 percent felt that powerful
support the police in the violation of rights. criminals are likely to go free; and 41.8 per-
Support for the rule of law is a crucial cent reported that suspects who are poor are
component of democracy. Where the securi- not likely to be treated fairly. This captures the
ty situation has deteriorated, support for the sense of unfairness people are perceiving. Re-
rule of law has also declined. Crime victimi- gionwide, only 34.2 percent of the respond-
zation and the perception of insecurity both ents rated the courts fair, although one person
negatively impact the level of support for the in four believes the courts are more fair today
rule of law.37 Indeed, as more citizens experi- than they were five years ago.
ence crime and the level of insecurity and fear Meanwhile, 43 percent of the respondents
increases, citizen attitudes towards the rule of perceived society as fundamentally law-abid-
law has become cavalier, thus increasing the ing. A law-abiding society is one in which citi-
willingness to accommodate violations. Con- zens voluntarily defer to legal authority and
sequently, high crime rates have the potential adherence to laws regardless of a police pres-
of jeopardizing democracy directly and indi- ence or absence or a threat or lack of sanctions
rectly, and support for the rule of law can be by the courts. It reflects a general belief in the
156 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
legitimacy of the law; rule breakers are in the justice institutions, particularly in the police,
minority. The view that a society is just is an is an important precursor of citizen security. 6
expression of an attitude towards and confi-
70
65.0
60
53.0
50
44.4 44.8
43.6 43.5
Percent
40
30
25.3 23.4
20.8
20 17.0
14.8 14.9 15.3
13.3
11.8
10 9.7
0
Antigua &
Barbuda
Barbados
Guyana
Jamaica
Saint Lucia
Suriname
Trinidad &
Tobago
Caribbean-7
the Caribbean-7, about 43.5 percent of the the attorney general, fifth; the justice system,
respondents agreed that government should ninth; and the police force, fourteenth. Final-
rely more on the military to reduce crime. ly, a 2010 opinion survey in Suriname asked
The range was from a low of 25.5 percent in respondents to indicate the extent to which
Barbados to a high of 65.1 percent in Jamaica. they trusted 16 institutions.44 Among these,
Overall, only about two citizens in five in the the armed forces ranked fifth; the Court of
Caribbean-7 appear to view the military as an Justice, sixth; the attorney general, seventh;
option for crime control. and the police, ninth. In every case in which
Here, the pattern of outliers at the upper we were able to find opinion data ranking the
end of the distribution is a little clearer. The degree of trust in institutions, the military
two nations with the highest homicide rates, ranked higher than the components of the
Jamaica and Trinidad and Tobago, also show justice system (excluding the police), which
the highest level of citizen support for mili- outranked the police.
tary involvement in reducing crime. We envi- A loss of confidence in criminal justice in-
sion several explanations for this finding. stitutions may lead to greater support for mil-
First, in both nations, there appears to be a itary involvement in crime control. However,
common sentiment that the police and other the militarization of policing raises concerns
criminal justice agencies are unable to keep up about the suspension of personal rights in
with the challenges of fighting crime, particu- support of crime control, fears about due pro-
larly violent crime carried out by street gangs cess guarantees and questions about the ero-
and organized crime groups. Second, since sion of democratic values. Citizen support for
none of these nations are currently at war, the military involvement in crime control signals
military is likely perceived as a slack resource a weakness in criminal justice institutions that
that is on the payroll, armed and ready to de- ought therefore to be remedied by consistent
ploy at a moment’s notice. Third, in nations reform efforts.
in which the armed forces are viewed with Despite a general lack of confidence in and
significantly more confidence than the police, criticism of the criminal justice system across
the military may be viewed as a more viable the Caribbean-7, respondents were in support
option for containing crime and violence. of building capacity in the police: 74.8 percent
The last explanation above is supported by agreed that the government should invest more
scattered evidence from public opinion polls in the police force (chart 6.5). However, there
conducted in four nations: Guyana, Jamaica, was a 25 percentage point difference between
Suriname, and Trinidad and Tobago. Thus, a the regional average and the share in Suriname,
2005 opinion survey in Trinidad and Tobago where there is a perception that the police have
found that 26 percent of respondents had “a been more effective at the community and
lot of faith” in the armed forces, a figure sec- country levels in the last few years.
ond only to the church among the 14 institu- Except for Barbados and Saint Lucia, which
tions listed. By comparison, only 13 percent have new correctional facilities, overcrowding
of the respondents had a lot of faith in police and the condition of prisons remain a regional
or judges.41 A 2010 opinion survey carried problem. Nonetheless, in the Caribbean-7, in-
out in Jamaica examined public trust in 11 in- vestment in prisons is among the crime control
stitutions. On a scale with a potential range of options that is less well supported: only 26.7
0 to 100, the army came in first, with a score percent of the survey respondents agreed that
of 65.9. The Supreme Court ranked fourth, this option was a priority (chart 6.5). The outli-
with a score of 51.3; and the police ranked ers are Barbados, at 11.7 percent, and Guyana,
last, with a score of 32.6.42 A 2010 opinion at 40.9 percent. Built in 2007, Dodds prison
survey in Guyana asked respondents to indi- in Barbados has a capacity of 1,250 and was
158 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Chart 6.5 Citizen Support for Institution Building in Crime Control, Caribbean-7, 2010 6
50 49.0
40.9
40
33.7
30 28.5
26.1 24.3 26.7
21.7
20
11.7
10
0
Antigua & Barbados Guyana Jamaica Saint Lucia Suriname Trinidad & Caribbean-7
Barbuda Tobago
Build More Prisons Build Police Capacity Reduce Corruption
designed to meet modern international stand- the problem of crime can be contained. Less
ards. The 2010 Human Rights Report on Guy- than 30 percent of the respondents felt that
ana identifies deteriorating prison conditions nothing could be done about crime.
and overcrowding as major issues.45
According to Transparency International’s Balancing Crime Prevention and
Corruption Perceptions Index, public sector Crime Control
corruption is at a high level across the region. Commensurate with the optimism about the
Although the ranking of each country sur- possibility of turning around the crime envi-
veyed in the Corruption Perceptions Index ronment was general support for social inter-
in 2009 and 2010 improved, Barbados is the vention through education initiatives, youth
only CARICOM country ranking above 5 on programmes, job creation, poverty reduction,
a scale from 1 (‘highly corrupt’) to 10 [‘very and programmes for the urban poor (chart
clean’).46 6.6; see also chart 5.2).
Among the crime control responses advo- The UNDP Citizen Security Survey 2010
cated by survey respondents, there was over- demonstrates that, despite the ambiguities in
whelming support for reduction in corruption: public opinion, support for crime prevention
86.1 percent across the Caribbean-7. Jamaica, policies such as increased investment in edu-
which registered the highest support for cor- cation, youth development, job creation and
ruption reduction, was also the only country poverty reduction is fairly universal across
in which respondents said that corruption was the Caribbean-7. Although there are minor
among the top three national problems.47 fluctuations among respondents across na-
Despite increasing levels of insecurity, the tions, the level of support for these initiatives
response was unambiguous regionwide that is strong in every country: an average of 89.9
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 159
punished more harshly. Thus, citizens do not
6 Chart 6.6 Support for Investment in Social
appear to view crime prevention and crime
Interventions as a Means of Crime Control,
control as an either-or proposition. They
State Policies and the Policy Orientation of Populations
Caribbean-7, 2010
want governments to do both.
example, conforms to this practice. Thus, not- form is on the agenda and where complimen-
withstanding concerns about their constitu- tary initiatives, including social interventions,
tionality, the bills were passed on the premise are increasingly regarded as part of the policy
that there was a need to “get on top of this mix, appealing to the emotions of the public
crime problem” and that desperate times call may prove counter-productive.
for desperate measures.50 However, less than Second, because of continuing pressures
a year later, the constitutional court entirely to respond to public anxieties about crime,
struck down one bill and revised most of the the policy process tends to produce ‘feel
provisions of a second, while a third, the Con- good’ anti-crime initiatives. Such measures
stabulary Force (Interim Provisions for Arrest offer little substantive hope of addressing the
and Detention) Act of 2010, expired, thus re- root causes of crime and thus permanently re-
quiring an extension.51 ducing crime.
While not every policy initiative met this An unfortunate outcome of excessive re-
fate, the emphasis on crime control indirect- liance on symbolic reassurances is a growing
ly reinforced the primary causes of crime in disconnect between the expressed policies
certain instances. Indeed, research on the ef- and actual programme implementation. This
fectiveness of crime control measures across implementation gap can cause the public to
the region discloses worrisome aspects of the lose faith in the effectiveness of crime policy.
policy process that has led to a number of un- Bold declarations such as ones on the
helpful policy outcomes. death penalty imply that perpetrators will be
First, the policy process often caters to the apprehended swiftly and promptly adjudicat-
public attentiveness and understanding of ed and sentenced. However, because of con-
punishment. Within the Caribbean context, straints and shortcomings in judicial systems,
crime is increasingly used to mobilize the the clearance rate for serious crimes is gener-
populace to support state programmes. How- ally low and alarmingly low for homicide. Be-
ever, the public is not always fully informed cause these constraints are hardly ever men-
about the issues. In a region where policy re- tioned in the cut and thrust of public debate
ity to deliver the promised results. porteur, who recommends that police be more
Third, within the democratic countries of well trained so as to reduce extrajudicial kill-
the Caribbean, police personnel have been ings.54
identified as major violators of human rights. Fifth, because of activism on behalf of hu-
Despite such vulnerabilities regarding the man rights in the region, there is a perception
lack of respect for rights, legislation and anti- among the public that the criminal justice sys-
crime policies still depend on a heavy police tem is skewed in favour of protecting suspects
presence in the streets matched by tough and defendants rather than the victims of
anti-crime rhetoric. This has increased con- crime. This weak public support for the rights
cerns about the violation of rights and poses a of defendants also creates an environment in
significant challenge to the struggle for social which the police may feel that they have pub-
justice. lic support for violating the rights of criminal
Fourth, the police disregard of the rights of suspects.
suspects highlights a related problem: the in- Sixth, because of the region’s overempha-
sufficiently robust protection of human rights sis on law enforcement, social interventions
by governments. Despite an admirable record have been given minimal attention in the
of political democracy, the region has been fight against crime. However, this imbalance
faulted by international human rights agencies in policy-making in favour of the law enforce-
for neglecting these rights. Indeed, for the Car- ment approach has not reduced violent crime
ibbean as a whole, the annual Country Reports to a level that might be considered a normal
on Human Rights Practices have called atten- range or closer to the world average. This
tion to the arbitrary or unlawful deprivation of shortcoming suggests the need not only for
life, as well as police killings, as the primary vi- more social interventions, but also for a care-
olation of human rights within the region.52 In ful assessment that looks at the policy mix in
the Jamaican case, the United Nations special terms of effectiveness in reducing crime.
rapporteur on extrajudicial, arbitrary and sum- Seventh, crime control initiatives are usu-
mary executions noted an apparent “section of ally tailored to suppressing violent crime, and
influential public opinion that sanctified every this bias has sometimes compromised the
action by the police, regardless of its violent di- physical safety of citizens and the region’s
mensions, on the grounds that the first prior- democratic ideals. Coupled with the tough
ity is to wipe out crime.”53 In this regard, Belur stance on crime and the zero tolerance ap-
(2010) points out that police officers are more proaches, this bias poses significant challeng-
likely to use force if they perceive a social con- es to the struggle for social justice, as well as
sensus supporting police use of deadly force to human rights. Thus, not addressing the ten-
eliminate ‘criminals’. sion between the norms of social justice and
The high incidence of extrajudicial killings the dictates of law enforcement efficiency ap-
in the region emphasize the risks associated propriately generates problems in protecting
with simultaneously trying to control crime, physical safety and democratic ideals.
while assuring social justice. Crime fighting Eighth, crime and criminal victimization
in the Caribbean has involved securing the are social ills that also threaten the basic hu-
former at the expense of the latter. Achieving man rights of citizens. This is particularly so
justice for the population at large is difficult in among socially excluded communities across
such circumstances, but social justice remains the region where citizens are criminally vic-
even more elusive for vulnerable persons who timized by groups that act with impunity be-
experience discrimination and socio-econom- cause of weak criminal justice institutions.
ic inequities. This lack of respect for rights These citizens are doubly victimized: first,
has raised concerns across the region and in by the neglect of the state, which results in
162 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
social exclusion and marginalization, and, meanwhile, integral to citizen security. Citi-
then, by confinement in environments that zens are likely to feel not only secure, but also 6
are significantly underdeveloped. The social to have confidence in a state that includes the
ban neighbourhoods and to males has done Over the past two decades, socio-eco-
little to reduce the sense of insecurity that nomic constraints, including mounting do-
pervades the entire society. The regional mestic debt, have contributed to the growth
problem of crime and violence requires a of inequality across the region. Wage con-
range of responses, including socio-econom- trols, price increases, layoffs, cutbacks in gov-
ic measures. ernment spending, and unemployment and
Such measures include enabling the sus- underemployment have all contributed to so-
tained economic participation of youth. They cial inequality in the region. The brunt of this
must be able to obtain meaningful work at economic hardship has been borne by vulner-
liveable wages. If this economic participation able and disadvantaged groups, especially job-
is to be sustained over the long run, a stable less youth who often experience higher rela-
formal economy that facilitates job creation tive rates of poverty.
and increased employment opportunities Relative deprivation and the inequality it
will have to be established. However, recent represents may increase the risk of criminality
developments in the global economy have among jobless youth, particularly in contexts
weakened Caribbean economies and, thus, in which the dignity of the youth is impugned.
the prospects for jobless youth. However, the relationship between inequal-
166 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
ity and crime is often indirect. The propen- velopment might have components addressing
sity to commit crimes may be enhanced if it sub-standard housing and low levels of fam- 6
is accompanied by poverty, social isolation ily income and education. They might involve
Table 6.2. Youth Labour Force Participation Rates, by Gender, Latin America
and the Caribbean, 2000–2015: History, Estimates and Projections
Aim: To train and employ 10,000 unskilled youth over the course of four
ing programmes, supports youth and acts as a
years
repository for information on youth.
Target: Young people 18 to 25 years old
The strategic importance of youth to the
Implementing partners: The HEART Trust/National Training Agency
development of the Caribbean is also evident
screens and assesses candidates. The Jamaica Foundation for Lifelong
in a number of recent reports, including ‘Eye
Learning provides training in basic numeracy and literacy skills. Around
on the Future: Investing in Youth Now for
25 private sector companies have committed to the programme so far.
Tomorrow’s Community’, a 2010 report by
the CARICOM Commission on Youth De-
Source: Extracted from ‘Law and Order’, DLP (2008, 49).
velopment; the UNICEF 2006 regional as-
sessment, ‘Violence against Children in the
Caribbean’; and the 2003 World Bank report,
‘Caribbean Youth Development: Issues and
The Barbados Youth Business Trust Policy Directions’.60
has continued to grow, and the net- As the foregoing account of state inter-
work was able to support over 8,500 ventions in the area of youth programming
new entrepreneurs during 2009 attest, Caribbean states share a growing con-
through our proven model of ac- cern about the importance of youth to the
cess to credit, volunteer mentors and region’s future. In addition to being signato-
business start-up services. ries to international conventions on youth,
—Andrew Devenport, Chief Execu- all countries have established ministries or
tive Officer, Youth Business Interna- departments with responsibility for youth.
tional (BYBT 2011) Similarly, a range of governmental, non-gov-
ernmental and civil society organizations also
provide programmes for youth. Still, because
among youth who are underemployed or em- many youth-related programmes have not
ployed in low-skilled jobs and youth who have been evaluated, the extent of their effective-
never worked. They have also recognized the ness cannot be verified. Nonetheless, pro-
challenge of restructuring the education sys- grammes exist in various thematic areas such
tem to take into account people who have left as education, training and skill development,
school, but are in need of numeracy and lit- community sports and leisure, national youth
eracy skills. The Special Youth Employment services, national youth councils, and micro-
and Training Project in Jamaica is an example enterprise development. Trinidad and To-
of a programme that seeks to address crime bago’s prime minister, Kamla Persad-Bissesar,
and education together (box 6.5). Employ- has recently announced a special commission
ment programmes also exist that are geared to to examine youth issues. In Jamaica, the prob-
youth who are neither in school nor working. lem has been more acute and prolonged and,
The Youth Business Trust operates in Bar- hence, has benefited from more plans and
bados, Jamaica, and Trinidad and Tobago. As programmes.
a youth development agency, it focuses on As the World Development Report 2011
helping unemployed youth start new busi- highlights, significant social stresses and weak
nesses. It has been in existence in Barbados institutions increase the risk of violence.61
since 1996. In Barbados, it is an extension States with weak institutions run the greatest
of the focus of the government and other risk of extreme levels of criminal violence.
stakeholders on entrepreneurship as a growth Governmental capacity to implement so-
strategy for the country. cial and development policies is affected by
There are also regional programmes, such a range of issues. Capacity is limited in some
as the Commonwealth Youth Programme, instances, and, in others, there are blockages.
168 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Across the Caribbean, obstacles to capac- corruption legislation and, in Jamaica, the ap-
ity development and, thus, to a transition to- pointment of a contractor general to look into 6
wards citizen security are governance related. the awarding of contracts (box. 6.6).
Character, Objective, Achievements The National Integrity Action Forum has also commis-
The National Integrity Action Forum was launched in sioned and produced training manuals, including ‘Best
January 2009 to promote more effective outcomes in com- Practices in Prosecuting Anti-Corruption Cases’ and
bating corruption in Jamaica. Towards this end, it seeks to ‘Strengthening Jamaica’s Conflict of Interest Regime’.
provide a mutually reinforcing network of public sector The organization’s lobbying and advocacy have contributed
anti-corruption champions and to associate these cham- to legislative initiatives such as the passage of the Whistle
pions with leaders of the private sector and civil society Blower Protection Act.
through forums on anti-corruption issues. The forums have The Future
achieved an initial purpose by clarifying the impediments To sustain its network within the highly competitive politi-
to a more effective engagement with corruption and, on cal environment in Jamaica, the forum has established and
this basis, developing an agenda of urgently needed leg- maintained its non-partisanship in all areas of its activity.
islative and administrative measures. Several outreach fo- For this reason, because of its ties to the public sector, the
rums have been held to open a dialogue between the anti- forum decided to create a companion non-profit NGO, Na-
corruption champions and opinion shapers in the media, tional Integrity Action Limited. The purpose of this NGO
religious leaders, researchers in various anti-corruption is to build public awareness of the need to combat corrup-
agencies, and international experts at the World Bank In- tion in Jamaica. National Integrity Action Limited does
stitute and Transparency International. The advocacy and this by enhancing the advocacy for effective anti-corruption
communication activity that has emerged from this effort legislation, by facilitating capacity-building through train-
has significantly influenced the governance reform agenda ing aimed primarily at key anti-corruption officials, and by
of the government, helped sustain the attention of the me- building relationships with civil society.
dia on corruption issues and contributed to reductions in Together, the National Integrity Action Forum and National
victimization through corruption in Jamaica. Integrity Action Limited are challenging political corrup-
tion and its impunity in Jamaica’s governance arrangements.
Source: Information from the National Integrity Action Forum, University of the West Indies, Kingston, Jamaica.
istries and other ministries that have portfo- change in thinking about the security issues
lios involving youth and, by extension, crime in the region. Innovation and change typi-
and crime control. cally occur in times of crisis or after a long
Capacity development is the engine of hu- period of difficulties. In the absence of such
man development and necessary for sustain- conditions, innovative proposals often do not
able (long-term) change. UNDP (2009b, 5) gain serious consideration or may be vigor-
defines capacity development as “the process ously opposed. Thus, the transition to citizen
through which individuals, organizations and security, though necessary, will need policy
societies obtain, strengthen and maintain the entrepreneurs who are interested in seeking
capabilities to set and achieve their own de- to achieve long-term outcomes rather than
velopment objectives over time.” short-term gains.
The goal of governance initiatives should A shift to social prevention has occurred
be to encourage the capacities that are needed at the level of ideas, but this is not sufficient-
to realize development.63 Hence, it is impor- ly reflected in planning, programmes and
tant to promote state and societal capacities budget support. There must be more mean-
to implement strategies that minimize the ingful engagement and prioritization. The
impact of impediments to development, in- network of policy actors must be strength-
cluding crime and violence. ened to reflect more meaningfully the sup-
While crime prevention as a distinct pol- port for social and developmental crime pre-
icy focus has been part of the region’s policy vention.
landscape for more than a decade, there has As the evidence in this report indicates,
been an evident implementation deficit. citizens are optimistic and hold positive views
Thus, advocacy for prevention as a core com- about the transition to greater citizen security.
ponent of a policy framework for transition- They have identified social interventions that
ing to citizen security should call for funding can significantly propel the shift to citizen
for the design, implementation and evalua- security, and they are willing to be engaged.
tion of relevant policies and initiatives. There is considerable optimism that social in-
Central to successful transformation are tervention can make significant inroads into
consensus-building, financial support, public the incidence of crime and violence. There is
support and coordination mechanisms. Be- a sense that change is possible and that there
cause of the impact of violence on develop- is a capacity for change. In policy parlance, a
ment, the reestablishment of security can lead policy window has been opened. It is time to
to significant development progress. The time undertake the transition to a safer, more just
to start is now. Caribbean society.
The evidence presented in this report problem-solving capacity of the people and
demonstrates the imperative that the police the potential of citizen security. Additional
and other institutions of criminal justice sys- channels of participation need to be opened
tems must serve the public and promote non- so that citizens may become more actively in-
violence and justice. This is a condition for volved as co-producers of security.
their success in dealing with crime. The need The shift in ideas must find representa-
for a comprehensive reform of police services tion in sound policies, and, even more impor-
is recognized in several countries. There is a tant, it must become associated with more
similar recognition concerning justice sector effective programme designs and changes in
reform, although the recognition in this case resource allocations that reflect the new pri-
is driven by administrative problems rather orities. With few exceptions, the countries
than by an understanding that the relation- of the region have only limited resources.
ship of these institutions with the people Nonetheless, through innovation, it is possi-
must be reviewed, that is, there must be a ble to achieve progress even with limited re-
change in the way people are treated by jus- sources. This is being demonstrated by poor
tice systems, especially people who have been countries elsewhere in the greater region and
victimized by criminals or otherwise brought in other parts of the world. The successes of
into contact with these institutions without the Nicaraguan police in establishing a close
having committed crimes. Re-engineering partnership with communities to lower crime
this relationship means making the system rates have been documented, for example.
more open. It also means that these institu- Countries can solve critical problems and
tions must offer a wider range of services and make good progress by encouraging human
decriminalize some behaviours, particularly creativity. This applies to people working in
the problematic behaviour of young people. It institutions such as the police, the courts and
means improving the access to justice. Some corrections facilities, as well as people in com-
countries are attempting to undertake these munities who may be suffering relatively more
steps. Their attempts should be encouraged from crime and the abuse of rights.
and reinforced.
There is also a recognition that security The Demand for Change
cannot reliably rest only on the capabilities Despite the efforts of governments to bring
and the performance of law enforcement the crime problem under control, the inse-
agencies. The Caribbean Community (CAR- curity levels remain high. The insecurity has
ICOM) has, for example, elaborated a social roots partly in a lack of confidence that the
crime prevention plan that represents a shift institutions of the state, especially the police,
in the way security problems are addressed. can protect citizens and treat them fairly. The
Indeed, some countries are seeking to ensure lack of trust is contributing to the demand for
that national security policies conform with change being expressed by the populations of
and are informed by long-term development the region. The demand is for a reform that is
policies. not narrowly administrative or technical. It is
Governments have led in establishing causing these institutions to become more re-
crime and violence prevention plans and sponsive and fair in their treatment of people.
programmes, but NGOs and community It is a demand for greater attention to crime
groups have also contributed. The region is as a social problem and for programmes that
not barren of innovation. There are promis- promote greater social justice by targeting the
ing practices. However, they have not been roots of crime in social inequalities and the
carefully tested and evaluated; many are not inequitable distribution of opportunities in
even documented. This shortcoming should society.
174 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
This demand for change is supported by This report is intended to reinvigorate the
a willingness to participate with the state in discussion on citizen security among policy 7
activities that are designed to bring about the makers and citizens across the region. The
proving the capabilities of the actors involved families and the public.
in the co-production of security. The recom- • Regarding illegal firearms, in addition
mendations are also divided into subgroups to the usual border control and tracing
according to whether they are short term or measures, attention should be paid to
long term. Short-term recommendations may measures that are simple, but of con-
be implemented fairly quickly and are likely siderable symbolic value in mobilizing
to show results in the short to medium term. the populations of the region against
Long-term recommendations may require gun violence (see box 7.1). An example
more time to implement, and their effects might be the periodic public destruc-
may not be observed for years. The justifica- tion of illegal weapons.
tions and supporting evidence for each of the 3. Government protection should be en-
recommendations and the relationship of the hanced for those most at risk and least able
recommendations to the main messages of to protect themselves, especially from vio-
this report may be examined within the re- lence by fellow citizens and representatives
spective chapters. of the state. Accomplishing this would in-
volve the following:
Reducing Victimization • Establishing better monitoring systems
The following are general recommendations to prevent child sexual abuse generally,
aimed at reducing crime victimization, espe- but also among children in the care of
cially among the groups that are most at risk, the state.
least adequately protected by the state and • Providing better legal protection for in-
least likely to be able to protect themselves digenous persons and sexual minorities.
through the justice system. This would include the following:
1. Citizen security, human rights and human ■■ Appropriate national legislation to
development are interdependent. The cre- protect human rights.
ation of a more secure environment neces- ■■ Support to strengthen advocacy
sitates the social, economic and political groups.
empowerment of women and other vul- ■■ Reviews of current legislation to
nerable groups to counter the decades of eliminate legal provisions that tend
deprivation among these groups caused by to discriminate against indigenous
poverty and social, cultural, political and persons and sexual minorities or
institutional practices. There is also a more facilitate intolerance and violence
general need to undertake initiatives to against these groups.
promote awareness of and respect for hu- • Establishing or developing capacity of
man rights especially within law enforce- gender-based anti-violence units in the
ment. police services of the region.
2. Short-term efforts are rightly focused on These ideas were repeated frequently by
mitigating and more effectively managing participants in the multicountry consul-
those problems that are the most proxi- tations that were held as a part of the re-
mate facilitators of violence of all types. search for this report.
Managing the access to legal firearms 4. Long-term efforts to promote awareness
and reducing the access to illegal firearms of and respect for human rights should
should be important elements in such ef- be undertaken. Appropriate measures
forts. could be carried out in partnership with
• Regarding legal weapons, firearms ac- ministries of justice, the media and ad-
quisition processes should be made vocacy groups. They should include the
more transparent, robust and free of following:
176 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Box 7.1. Developing Capacity to Combat Illicit Trafficking in Firearms in the Caribbean 7
Objectives
• Promote the effective implementation of national, regional and international firearms instruments by strengthening
national firearms control measures
• Reduce the availability and number of firearms in circulation by facilitating the destruction of surplus, obsolete and
confiscated weapons and ammunition
• Enhance the security and management of national stockpile facilities, thus reducing the risk of diversion to criminal
networks
• Develop the capacity of law enforcement officials to combat the illicit trafficking in firearms, ammunition and explosives
Activities in 2010–2011
• The assistance project was officially launched in Kingston, Jamaica in March 2010 through an awareness-raising
workshop. At the workshop, participating member states were informed of the International Ammunition Technical
Guidelines developed by the United Nations Office for Disarmament Affairs and the International Small Arms Con-
trol Standards being developed by the same office and UNDP.
• In December 2010, UNLIREC convened a meeting of participating Caribbean states to review national action plans
and outline the implementation process for 2011–2012. During this meeting, Caribbean member states agreed that
dumping confiscated, surplus and obsolete firearms into the Caribbean was no longer an acceptable practice. The
United Nations offers alternative means of disposal.
• During 2010 and 2011, the UNLIREC legal unit undertook detailed studies of national firearms legislation in Belize,
Jamaica, and Trinidad and Tobago and examined key recommendations for reform to reinforce the ability of countries
to combat illicit trafficking and comply with international obligations.
• In October 2011, UNLIREC provided training to officials in the Trinidad and Tobago Defence Force, Coast Guard,
Police Service and Prisons Service in the destruction of nearly 1,200 confiscated firearms that had been tagged for
elimination by the courts and 5 metric tons of confiscated and obsolete ammunition using a small arms ammunition
burning tank designed by UNLIREC for small-scale ammunition disposal operations based on International Ammu-
nition Technical Guidelines.
Next Steps
UNLIREC will continue working with the governments in the region in the following areas:
• In Jamaica, 30,000 firearms and several tons of ammunition will be destroyed in February 2012.
• A UNLIREC flagship inter-institutional training course on combating illicit firearms trafficking will be conducted in
Jamaica in February 2012 and in the Bahamas in April 2012.
• Technical teams will be deployed throughout the Caribbean to provide training in firearms and ammunition destruc-
tion and stockpile management according to established international standards.
• Legal advise will be offered to assist governments in producing appropriate national firearms legislation, to promote
the harmonization of laws across the region and to foster international legal cooperation in combating illicit firearms.
to police services in implementing these but many are also considered detached and at
practices. risk. The risks can be mitigated by supportive
• Strengthening support for victims, in- programmes that strengthen the resilience
cluding through the training of staff in of young people. The report of CARICOM
dealing with various victim situations; (2010f ) contained within the Declaration
increasing the relevant budget alloca- of Paramaribo on the Future of Youth in the
tions. Caribbean Community is supportive of pro-
5. The knowledge base on social crime pre- grammes that are aimed at mitigating the
vention should be expanded. Appropriate risks among youth and empowering youth to
initiatives should also be launched. These play a role in national and regional develop-
steps would include the following: ment processes. The declaration represents a
• The assessment and evaluation of job useful guide for prevention programmes and
training and employment creation pro- policy development at the national level. The
grammes in the Caribbean should be following recommendations are intended to
systematic. reduce risk and build youth resilience.
• More support should be supplied to 1. Develop programmes to promote ‘pro-so-
families, especially families living in cial’ behaviour. The main target groups are
areas characterized by high levels of in-school youth and out-of-school, out-
violence. This might include the de- of-work youth, particularly new school
velopment of nationally and culturally leavers. The targeting of these groups and
appropriate parenting manuals and sup- the design of these programmes should be
port for children who are at risk so that carried out in a gender-differentiated man-
they may remain in school and in stable ner. For the in-school group, comprehen-
and supportive home environments. sive after-school programmes should be
Such programmes, if they are effec- developed. Some NGOs in some countries
tive, are likely to reduce the number of already offer such programmes. For the
children admitted to state institutions out-of-school, out-of-work group, some
because of neglect or sexual abuse at countries offer national youth service.
home. The support should also focus on These national youth service programmes
reducing delinquency. should be reviewed to make them more
• Social workers should be trained in comprehensive and more effective.
the delivery of specialized services for • Structured voluntary community ser-
families. The training should involve vice is a good way to promote pro-social
instruction in the recognition of the behaviour among young people. Volun-
warning signs of child sexual abuse and teerism among youth should be recog-
in support services for the families of nized and encouraged. This might take
child victims of sexual abuse and other the form of accreditation, which would
forms of violence. facilitate the access of youth to other
• The budgetary allocation for social educational and training opportunities.
crime prevention programmes should • Designing and implementing pro-
be increased, and the capacity of states grammes that support family stability
to design and implement these pro- and prevent ‘child-shifting’ are also use-
grammes should be improved. Capac- ful investments in promoting pro-social
ity can be improved by monitoring and behaviour and reducing delinquency.
learning from crime prevention experi- Such programmes should assist needy
ences elsewhere in the Caribbean and parents so that they are able to keep
abroad (box 7.2). their children in the parental household
178 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Box 7.2. Citizenship Culture in Bogota 7
Programmes to protect Valuing norms Disseminate norms and facilitate voluntary compliance; demon-
life and ensure strate the democratic basis and the benefits of the fulfilment of norms
compliance with norms Through public awareness campaigns, emphasize standards of secu-
rity and coexistence and their significance in public transportation,
taxation, urban life, and the environment
Sanctity of life Discourage gun ownership and promote actions aimed at reducing
violent deaths
Build trust and security so that rights and freedoms may be exercised
Programmes to pro- Decision-making Promote the use of democratic procedures to change laws
mote a procedures Broaden public discussion by emphasizing the usefulness of discus-
democratic culture sion in clarifying differences, resolving conflicts and reaching agree-
ments
Programmes to Communicate Promote art, culture and recreation in public spaces to enhance the
encourage life and fair play creative and communicative capacities of cultural actors and citizens
communication and and increase the collective enjoyment of the city
solidarity through the Expand the social appropriation of the city through research projects
use of public spaces and means of mass dissemination
Mimes in the streets reminded drivers (silently) about proper traffic etiquette. This illustrates that a local government can
carry out a teaching function.
Citizens were encouraged to ration their use of water. These voluntary water savings avoided months of water shortages,
and citizens learned to economize on water. Between 1996 and 2003, household water consumption dropped from 28
to 18 cubic meters per month.
Through the 110 percent with Bogota tax programme, 63,000 households or entities agreed to pay an additional 10 per-
cent in property taxes. In exchange, they were given the opportunity to assign the extra 10 percent tax contribution to 1
of 15 public projects.
Several studies documented the progress of this citizenship culture in Bogota. Particularly useful were surveys on citizen-
ship culture and Bogotá Cómo Vamos (Bogota How are We Doing), a programme that monitors more than 200 indicators
quarterly and conducts an extensive annual survey.
Among the most dramatic results of these initiatives in Bogota were a reduction in the homicide rate from 80 to 23 per
100,000 inhabitants per year and a reduction in traffic fatalities from almost 1,400 at the beginning of the 1990s to fewer
than 600 in 2003. The restriction of alcohol consumption during certain hours at night (the ‘Carrot Law’) was also a key
step.
rather than shifting them to relatives for wrongdoing, restorative justice, and
and family friends. alternative means for providing care and
• Another means of promoting pro-social protection. Existing programmes that
conduct is the development of youth- offer offenders viable alternatives to vio-
friendly spaces to facilitate the access lent and criminal behaviour should be
of youth to services, strengthen their strengthened and provided with more
ties to their communities, build their resources. For, example, youth might be
relationships with and access to criti- placed in community corrections and
cal state institutions, including law en- community service programmes while
forcement, and empower them to make in the custody of their parents. Youth
contributions to violence prevention in who display violent behaviour deserve a
their communities. Youth are willing to second chance.
participate in enhancing citizen secu- • Review legislative provisions and repeal
rity. They require spaces that build their those that treat running away as an of-
resilience to act as agents of change and fence. Youth require support in address-
play a role in violence prevention and ing the issues that lead them premature-
human development. ly to leave their homes; this support may
2. The institutionalization of youth in con- best be provided by the state.
flict with the law should be a last resort. • Systems should be established for the
• Greater attention should be paid to the systematic evaluation of the mental
development of youth diversion pro- health status of children and youth
grammes and non-custodial sentences who are in jails and prisons and who are
180 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
generally in the care of the state. They terrence, it is important to arrest and convict
should be provided with any necessary individuals who engage in serious illegal ac- 7
medical treatments and counselling. tivities related to street gangs and organized
Through its Prevention of Juvenile Vio- ties, vocational training and job placement.
lence Programme, the National Police of The police unit receives specific training on
Nicaragua is working with state institu- human rights and community mediation
tions, local crime prevention committees, and is involved in the social reinsertion of
the media, the private sector, and gang ex–gang members. For Independence Day,
members to rehabilitate those who leave the police trained and used 800 youths for-
gangs. The programme provides psycho- merly belonging to gangs to maintain or-
social counselling, educational opportuni- der during the festivities.
dation, or corruption. Box 7.3 offers an in- viduals from a relatively early point in their
novative example within the police. lives through their 20s, regardless of where
5. Develop plans and programmes to assist they might be. It should collect information
gang members to exit from gangs success- on a variety of topics related to human devel-
fully and to assist the victims of gang activ- opment, including, but not limited to educa-
ity. Research has shown that many of the tion, delinquency and crime, health, work,
victims of gang violence are gang members social development, and involvement with
and that the act of leaving a gang is often criminal organizations. Official data sources
preceded by an incident involving violent are somewhat limiting, and a longitudinal
victimization. However, currently, there study of youth would help Caribbean nations
are few programmes to assist gang mem- plan and implement effective prevention, in-
bers who are interested in leaving gangs or tervention and suppression strategies.
the victims of gang-related activity. Pro-
grammes that focus on these individuals Transforming the Police
might help reduce the amount of time in- The Caribbean police, in general, must do
dividuals are associated with gangs. more to facilitate the transition from the state
6. Establish a rigorous research agenda on the security model to the citizen-oriented model
causes of street gangs and organized crime of policing. This will require a shift in focus
in the Caribbean. Such a research agenda at the highest levels of police administration.
is essential for the development of efficient First, there must be dramatic changes in the
and effective public policy in the region. leadership styles of top administrators. The
Investment in basic research examining traditional leadership styles of ‘steward’ and
the impact of social structural factors, the ‘commander’ must be replaced by the ‘execu-
community, the family, the school, peers tive’ style.1 The executive style incorporates a
and individuals are necessary, along with deep commitment to strategic planning and
basic research that examines the unique creative thinking to enhance the organization’s
role of gender, age and citizenship in crim- value to the community it serves. For example,
inal organizations. The research agenda both strategic planning and creative thinking
would include assessments and documen- are needed to determine how best to mould
tation on good practices and strategies and the willingness of citizens to help reduce vio-
policies in various aspects of gang control, lence into a viable and sustainable police-com-
reduction and prevention. munity partnership. In addition, the executive
Perhaps most needed, however, is a lon- style views changes in organizational structure,
gitudinal study on youth. The longitudi- cultural changes and programmatic changes as
nal study should be conducted in nations part of an evolutionary process that is to be em-
throughout the Caribbean and track indi- braced rather than avoided, as is traditionally
182 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
done in the Caribbean. Finally, the executive strengthen the quality of their service de-
style highly values input not only from sub- livery to enhance the trust and confidence 7
ordinates, but also from external groups and among the citizenry for the police.
The Juvenile Liaison Scheme was estab- titioners, entrepreneurs, or victims who
lished in 1983 by the Royal Barbados Po- have been affected by the youth. The pro-
lice Force with the goal of diverting juve- gramme is staffed by police officers espe-
niles aged 7 to 16 years from the criminal cially trained in social work, mental health
justice system. The programme is located and issues related to adolescent and family
at the Central Police Station in Bridge- functioning, as well as community devel-
town. Youth enter the programme through opment. Since its creation, the programme
referrals that originate with parents, police has supported over 3,000 youth and their
officers, school officials, social service prac- parents or guardians.
systems must include elements that are inter- Reforming the Justice System
nal to the police forces and elements that are The recommendations in support of the re-
external, as well as formal and informal ele- form of the justice system include manage-
ments. The internal systems should include ment and capacity development, issues of
the following: access, measures indicating how people are
• Capable and credible departments of pro- treated by the system and methods to make
fessional responsibility that possess the the system more fair and equitable.
authority and the capability to investigate 1. Develop rational court scheduling strate-
corruption effectively and to prevent it in gies that minimize delays and backlogs and
all its forms. do not place undue strain on criminal jus-
• External units charged with investigating tice personnel. The strategy would include
use-of-force violations by the police, espe- minimizing delays that originate outside
cially those violations that have resulted the criminal justice system. Delays im-
in death. An example in Jamaica is the re- posed by witnesses could be corrected by
cently created Independent Commission better witness management systems that
of Investigations, which should serve as a are able to provide needed supports to wit-
model for police services in other Carib- nesses such as cost of travel. The strategy
bean nations. would also aim at reducing delays caused
• External informal systems of police ac- by incompetence, such as poor case prepa-
countability include an alert press and ac- ration by criminal justice practitioners.
tive, credible and organized human rights Finally, the strategy would reduce delays
groups that are focused on the issue of po- caused by the corrupt practices of court ad-
lice misconduct. Efforts should be made to ministrative personal, lawyers who double-
improve the capacity of the media to play book cases and other institutional actors.
its role as a vital element in the system of 2. Introduce criminal justice planning coun-
accountability. cils that would coordinate the work of
• The public is also an important element in the various institutions within the system
the process of informal accountability. The and ensure proper staffing to accommo-
small police forces of the region tend to be date changes in workloads. These councils
responsive to public pressures. Measures should accept inputs from representatives
should therefore be adopted to change the of the people.
strongly held belief in some nations that 3. Establish a well-run, well-protected re-
extrajudicial killings of offenders are useful gional witness protection programme to
in reducing crime. This could be done by improve the level of witness cooperation
enhancing the capabilities of human rights with police and prosecutors. The small
and police-affiliated citizens’ groups to size of most Caribbean countries presents
conduct appropriate awareness campaigns. many difficulties for such programmes. A
5. Reform may also be encouraged through renewed effort should be undertaken to
incentives. An innovative programme in explore the possibilities for such a project
Brazil offers a rare example of an external at the regional level. There are two groups
motivating force for good police behaviour.3 that should be considered: the protection
The Citizen Police prize was created by an of witnesses who are criminal informants
NGO dedicated to public security, disar- and the protection of witnesses who are
mament and human rights. The prize, con- victims of serious crimes. The second group
sisting of cash or a university scholarship, is should be treated not merely as witnesses,
awarded to police officers who have solved but also as victims. They should therefore
public security problems in a creative, effi- also have access to victim support services.
184 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
4. Review sentencing policies to remove in- victories. Every justice agency should es-
consistencies in punishments. Alternative tablish a sound public relations and com- 7
punishments should be devised especially munications strategy that seeks to instil
ness of strategies in reducing crime, disor- government. Policy design, research and
der and fear and to establish a culture of evaluation within the region calls for re-
experimentation and constant improve- search capacity that does not presently ex-
ment. A starting point could be the assess- ist within the region.
ment and documentation of promising The above recommendations can be real-
crime prevention and control practices ized only if there is increased budgetary sup-
in the Caribbean. These practices should port for these measures. Many Caribbean
include, for example, mentorship pro- governments are restricted by budgetary con-
grammes, after-school programmes, entre- straints. Nonetheless, new priorities mean
preneurship and job creation programmes shifts in allocations.
for youth at risk, the use of music culture These recommendations will have a better
among youth at risk, reentry programmes chance of being implemented properly if there
for prisoners and deportees, exit strategies is more sustained advocacy on the part of civil
for gangs, community violence reduction society groups and a greater commitment to
programmes and proper case management citizen involvement by the governments of
to avoid court delays. the region. Participation is a principle of citi-
• Strengthen the capability of regional insti- zen security. It is also of great instrumental
tutions to measure crime and other threats value. It facilitates successful outcomes.
to human security and to study the capac- People are resources, and they are the crea-
ity of governments to prevent and alleviate tors of change. Effective implementation of
these threats. the many recommendations in this report
• Establish a regional crime observatory will require the participation of youth organi-
that would provide crime mapping and zations, women’s rights groups, victims’ rights
other evidential, monitoring and evalua- groups, and human rights groups. It will re-
tion support for promising practices and quire action and commitment by officials in
policies. The observatory would seek to fill the state systems of the region, as well as those
existing data gaps in areas such as gender- in the regional civil service or CARICOM
based violence. It would design and imple- structures, and it will require the support of
ment frameworks for analysis that would regional organizations such as the Associa-
be comparable across territories. It would tion of Caribbean Commissioners of Police
monitor vulnerable populations and pro- and CARICOM Youth Ambassadors. Edu-
vide data that can be used to directly in- cational institutions that are involved in the
form policy. training of social workers and other service
The definitions of rape, domestic vio- professionals must ensure that the competen-
lence and other gender-based violence cies and skills that will be needed are instilled
need to be regularized across the legal through the schools and through the educa-
systems of the Caribbean so that data col- tion and training of professionals.
lection systems parallel each other more Urgent, but well-considered, well-planned
closely. This would require coordinated ac- and sustainable action is required. It is not
tion by several governments over the long beyond the inventiveness and innovation
term. characteristic of the Caribbean people to deal
• Connect regional professional bodies with with the problem of insecurity more effec-
their international counterparts to ensure tively and to meet the requirements of citizen
a continuous flow of fresh ideas from in- security so that the region will become a safer
side and outside the region. and more just place to live and work.
• Strengthen policy-design and policy-eval-
uation units within government. Strength-
186 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Notes
Overview 10. This has its origins in the 1968 27. For a full description of the
Caribbean Free Trade Association sample design and discussion of
1. See Lewis (1955), page 420.
negotiations. The use of the term other technical issues, see the
2. Guyana and Suriname may be
LDC in this contest should not be methodological note on the
regarded as exceptions because of
confused with its use in the United report website, http://www.
their larger territories and relative
Nations system, where it means regionalcentrelac-undp.org/en/
abundance of natural resources.
least (not less) developed countries. hdr-caribbean.
3. Grenada (1978) and Suriname
11. Some of these recommendations are
(1980) have experienced regime
revisited in chapter 7.
changes by force of arms.
12. In 2002 the OECS sub-regional Chapter 1
4. Here, there is a distinction
HDR on ‘Building Competitiveness
between violent behaviour that is 1. WTTC (2011). http://www.
in the face of Vulnerability’ was
criminalized and punishable by wttc.org/research/e conomic-
the state, such as murder and rape, produced
13. See UNODC and World Bank impact-research/regional-reports/
and violent behaviour that is not caribbean/
so criminalized and that may even (2007).
14. See Ayres (1998); Francis et al. 2. CARICOM is composed of 15
enjoy the approval of large sections
(2009). member states: Antigua and
of the population. Examples of the
15. Crime control refers to the use of Barbuda, the Bahamas, Barbados,
latter include child-beating in some
political, legislative and (reactive) Belize, Dominica, Grenada,
settings, intimate partner violence,
law enforcement methods to reduce Guyana, Haiti, Jamaica, Saint
and fighting. Although, in some
crime in a society. According Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Saint
jurisdictions, these forms of violence
to Schmallager (2011), crime Vincent and the Grenadines,
are not explicitly criminalized, there
prevention is the anticipation, Montserrat, Trinidad and Tobago,
are usually laws that allow the police
to charge offenders who engage recognition, and appraisal of a crime and Suriname.
in them. However, such laws may risk and the initiation of action to 3. See appendix 1 on the website
not be applied because these types eliminate or reduce this risk. of this report, http://www.
of violence are not socially defined 16. See UNODC and World Bank regionalcentrelac-undp.org/en/
or regarded as crimes and the laws (2007). hdr-caribbean.
do not draw direct attention to 17. See Powell and Lewis (2011). 4. See appendix 1 on the report website,
them as specific problems of great 18. Powell and Lewis (2011). http ://www.regionalcentrelac-
seriousness. 19. Speech before the Second Ministerial undp.org/en/hdr-caribbean.
5. UNDP (2010a, vi). Conference on the Geneva 5. UNDP (2010a).
6. For a comprehensive discussion of Declaration, Geneva, 31 October 6. Reproductive health is measured by
deportees in the region, see Barnes 2011. maternal mortality and adolescent
and Seepersad (2008). 20. United Nations (2010a), page 1. fertility rates. Empowerment
7. 1821 is the year of the independence 21. See UNDP (2006). is measured by the share of
of the Dominican Republic from 22. IACHR (2009). parliamentary seats held by
Spain. The country also uses 1844 23. IACHR (2009). each gender and attainment in
to mark its independence from 24. IACHR (2009). secondary and higher education
Haiti. 25. World Bank (2011a). by each gender. Economic activity
8. These statistics have been computed 26. For details on the report methodology, is measured by the labour force
using data from the most recent the results of the consultations, and the participation rate for each gender.
national censuses. participants, see the report website, 7. Antigua and Barbuda (2007)
9. See the most recent national censuses http://www.regionalcentrelac-undp. and Saint Lucia ( June 2005)
for the respective countries. org/en/hdr-caribbean. have recently been the subject of
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R EP
EPORT 2012 187
Country Poverty Assessments; 14. Homicide is used to describe all cases of mass destruction. There is also
however, CARICOM (2010a) is of suspected murder. Suspected the gun-marking and gun tracing
more recent. murders are classified as killings prior programme under the auspices of
8. See IFAD (2002). to the discovery of proof or disproof the Committee of the Organization
9. In 2010, the share of women aged of murder. Murder is defined as the of American States on the Inter-
25 or older who had attained at unlawful killing of a person with American Convention against Illicit
least secondary education reached intent. This definition applies in all Manufacturing of and Trafficking in
89.5 percent in Barbados, 42.6 the English-speaking countries in Firearms, Ammunition, Explosives
percent in Guyana, 74.0 percent our study. Among all crimes rates, and Related Materials.
in Jamaica, and 67.6 percent in the homicide rate most closely 21. Guyana aggregates robberies and
Trinidad and Tobago. With the approximates the true rate. Police extortion. However, the incidence
exception of Guyana, these values reports may be compared with data of extortion is not statistically
are above the LAC average of 50.5 from ministries of health on the significant.
percent. (No data are available on discovery of bodies associated with 22. UNODC and World Bank (2007).
the other Caribbean-7 countries.) suspected murder. In Caribbean 23. Burglary usually has a time
In 2009, female labour force countries, the discrepancies are requirement that includes night
participation rates in Barbados typically insignificant. hours. Jamaica specifies that night
(65.8 percent), Jamaica (56.1 15. De Albuquerque and McElroy begins at 7 pm; in Trinidad and
percent) and Trinidad and Tobago (1999); Harriott (2002). Tobago, night begins at 8 pm. In
(55.1 percent) were higher than the 16. See Buvinic, Morrison, and Shifter both countries, it ends at 5 am. The
LAC average (51.7 percent), while (1999); UNODC and World Bank exception to the night requirement
they were lower than the average in (2007). is Barbados, where burglary may
Saint Lucia (51.7 percent), Guyana 17. See Francis et al. (2009); Bennett, occur at any time of day or night.
(44.7 percent), and Suriname (38.5 Shields, and Daniels (2007); This means that the burglary rates
percent). (No data are available on UNODC and World Bank (2007). for Barbados are less comparable
Antigua and Barbuda.) In 2011, 18. See ‘The Balance in Balance: with rates in the other jurisdictions.
women’s political participation Exports and Imports of Small Arms Consequently, for comparability,
as measured by the share of seats and Light Weapons (SALW), break-ins and burglaries are
in national parliaments held by Parts and Ammunition in Latin combined in the chart and in the
women was higher than in the LAC America and the Caribbean 2000– discussion.
region (18.7 percent) in all the 2006’, En La Mira: The Latin 24. Acquisitive crime covers crimes
Caribbean-7, with the exception of American Small Arms Watch, involving items that are stolen or
Suriname (9.8 percent). See Human 3 (23) (August), 2008, http:// acquired fraudulently. This includes
Development Reports (database), w w w. huma n s e c uri t y g at e way. theft, burglary, vehicle crime, and
UNDP, New York, http://hdr. c o m / d o c u m e n t s / L A S AW _ fraud; see ‘Tackling Acquisitive
undp.org/en/statistics/data/; also BalanceOf Balance_SmallArms. Crime’, Local Government
see ECLAC (2010); Robinson pdf. Improvement and Development,
(2005); World Bank (2011b). 19. UNODC and World Bank (2007). London, http://www.idea.gov.uk/
10. The relationship between poverty 20. These include the regional Citizen idk/core/page.do?pageId=8790065.
rates (absolute and relative) and Security Programme of the Inter- 25. With the exception of Jamaica,
crime rates is a complex one. It is not American Development Bank, the there have been no studies on the
suggested that poverty universally World Bank–funded Programme relationship between economic
and always directly accounts for all for Violence Prevention, conditions and crime in individual
types of crime. The effects of poverty CARICOM initiatives, and countries in the Caribbean since
are often indirect and vary with the collaboration and partnerships 1996.
different categories of crime. to build capacity and greater 26. See United Nations (1993).
11. See CARICOM (2002). compliance with the reporting Subsequent reiterations are
12. See Deosaran (2000). requirements under United Nations contained in the Convention on
13. Both Barbados and Saint Lucia Security Council Resolution 1540 the Elimination of All Forms of
categorize robberies as property crimes. on the non-proliferation of weapons Discrimination against Women
188 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
and the Beijing Declaration and www.icpsr.umich.edu/icpsrweb/ 37. Discussions of the measurement
Platform of Action (see below). NACJD/NCVS/), data from problems as evident in the
27. ‘Convention on the Elimination the Rape and Sexual Assault: differences between official rates
of All Forms of Discrimination Reporting to Police and Medical and the results of surveys are long
against Women’, Division for Attention 1992–2000 database standing and widely accepted. For
the Advancement of Women, (see http://www.bjs.gov/index. example, see Skogan (1975).
Department of Economic and cfm?ty=pbdetail&iid=1133), and 38. UNICEF (2011).
Social Affairs, United Nations, data of the National Center for 39. CARICOM (2010b); World Bank
New York, http://www.un.org/ Policy Analysis (see Reynolds 1999), (2003).
womenwatch/daw/cedaw/text/ estimate that 15 of 16 rapists walk 40. Baumgartner et al. (2009).
econvention.htm. free. Based on these sources, RAINN 41. This applies to differences in the
28. See Russo and Pirlott (2006). estimates that, if a rape is reported, victimization rates for people of
29. Paragraph 118, Beijing Plan of there is a 50.8 percent chance of an East-Indian and African descent
Action, ‘Beijing Declaration and arrest. If an arrest is made, there is a in Guyana and in Trinidad and
Plan of Action’, Fourth World 80 percent chance of prosecution. Tobago. Based on data of the
Conference on Women, Beijing, If there is prosecution, there is a 58 UNDP Citizen Security Survey
4–15 September 1995, http:// percent chance of conviction. If 2010, t-tests suggested there were
www.un.org/womenwatch/daw/ there is a felony conviction, there is no significant differences in the
beijing/pdf/BDPfA%20E.pdf. a 69 percent chance the convict will rates of victimization among these
30. See Robinson (2005). spend time in jail. So, of 39 percent groups.
31. This definition is common in most of attacks reported to the police, 42. van Dijk, van Kesteren, and Smit
jurisdictions. There are, however, there is only a 16.3 percent chance (2007).
differences in age requirements. In that the rapist will go to prison. 43. Lee, Kotch, and Cox (2004).
Guyana, the victim must be 13 years Factoring in unreported rapes, 44. O’Leary (1999); Sims (2008).
of age or older; in Barbados and in RAINN concludes that only about 45. See Multiple Indicator Cluster
Trinidad and Tobago, 14 or older; 6 percent of rapists will ever spend Surveys–MICS3, Childinfo
in Jamaica, 16 or older. In Saint a day in jail. See ‘Statistics’, RAINN, (database), United Nations
Lucia, there is no age stipulation. All Washington, DC, http://rainn.org/ Children’s Fund, New York, http://
intercourse (consensual and non- statistics. See also ‘Violence against www.childinfo.org/mics3_surveys.
consensual) with a female under the Women’, UN Women, Bangkok, html.
ages stated above is defined as rape http ://unifem-eseasia .org/ 46. ‘Model Legislation on Issues Affecting
or carnal abuse. These differences are Violence_Against_Women/index. Women’, CARICOM, Georgetown,
within the limits of comparability. html. Guyana, http://www.caricom.org/
32. For example, in Guyana, the 35. Of reported rapes and sexual jsp/secretariat/legal_instruments/
category ‘sex crimes’ includes assaults in Trinidad and Tobago, model_legislation_women_issues.
attempted rape, carnal knowledge 18.4 percent occurred in the jsp.
of girls between 12 and 13 years of northern police district. Amnesty 47. ‘CARICOM Model Legislation on
age, rape, indecent assault, buggery, International (2008), Ustanny Domestic Violence’, CARICOM,
abduction, incest, attempted incest, (2006), and Country Reports on Georgetown, Guyana, http://www.
acts of gross indecency, and bigamy. Human Rights Practices (see http:// caricom.org/jsp/secretariat/legal_
33. Prior to 1991, the enumerated www.state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/) instruments/model_legislation_
female population was not identify vulnerabilities to sexual domestic_violence.jsp.
available; as a result, rape rates prior violence among women residents of 48. Trinidad and Tobago Domestic
to that time were calculated on the Jamaica’s inner-city communities. Violence Act, 1999, http://www.
entire population rather than on the 36. Concerns have been raised in the ttparliament.org/publications.
population of females. United Kingdom by the Stern php?mid=28&id=461.
34. The Rape, Abuse & Incest National Review that the conviction rate 49. Le Franc et al. (2008); Pottie Bunge
Network (RAINN), using 2005 has taken over the debate and that and Locke (2000).
data from the US National Crime a primary outcome is the impact on 50. See Le Franc et al. (2008); Inter-
Victimization Survey (see http:// reporting rates. See Stern (2010). Agency Campaign on Violence
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R EP
EPORT 2012 189
against Women and Girls (1999). set forth in subparagraph (a) of this 66. Jackson and Gray (2010).
Among the organizations and article; (d) ‘Child’ shall mean any 67. CARICOM (2007a) data show that
initiatives are the following: person under eighteen years of age” women comprise half the region’s
Antigua and Barbuda Directorate (UNODC 2004, 42–43). population; however, poverty is high
of Gender Affairs; Saint Lucia 52. SAP-FL and ITUC (2007). within this group. The feminization
Department of Gender Relations; 53. IOM (2010a). of poverty refers to the fact that
Centre for Investigation of Sexual 54. IOM (2010b). women, who represent half the
Offences, the division of the Jamaica 55. Ribando (2005). global population, receive only a
Constabulary Force responsible 56. Ribando (2005). 10th of the world’s income, own less
for sexual offences against women 57. IOM (2010b). than a 10th of the world’s property,
and children; Trinidad Rape Crisis 58. IOM (2005). and, increasingly, are living below
Society; Help and Shelter Guyana; 59. Coffey (2004). the poverty line. Despite a rise in
Women Crisis Centre, Jamaica; 60. IOM (2005). women’s labour force participation,
Crisis Centre of Barbados; and 61. Thomas-Hope (2002). the poverty rate among women
Caribbean Association for Feminist 62. Ratification status as of October continues to increase. Woman-
Research and Action, Suriname. 2011; see United Nations Treaty headed families and women living
51. Article 3 of the Protocol to Prevent, Collection (database), United alone comprise a disproportionate
Suppress and Punish Trafficking Nations, New York, http://treaties. share of the individuals living in
in Persons, Especially Women and un.org/Pages/ViewDetails.aspx?src poverty. Women who must support
Children (2000) defines trafficking =UNTSONLINE&tabid=2&mtd themselves and their families are
in persons as “(a) . . . the recruitment, sg_no=XVIII-12-a&chapter=18& becoming the majority of the poor.
transportation, transfer, harbouring lang=en#Participants. Women are often unable to escape
or receipt of persons, by means of the 63. As of October 2010, only the poverty after the loss of a husband.
threat or use of force or other forms Bahamas (2008), Guyana (2005), Moreover, women who have been
of coercion, of abduction, of fraud, Jamaica (2007), Saint Lucia (2010) largely confined to the domestic
of deception, of the abuse of power and Suriname (2006), among sphere would be poor if they had to
or of a position of vulnerability or of the eight countries reviewed, had support themselves.
the giving or receiving of payments passed an anti-trafficking law (IOM 68. ECLAC (2010).
or benefits to achieve the consent 2010a). 69. This section relies extensively on
of a person having control over 64. IOM (2008). UNICEF (2006). See also World
another person, for the purpose 65. It is often assumed that gender refers Bank (2003); CARICOM (2010b).
of exploitation. Exploitation specifically to women. However, Additional resources on violence
shall include, at a minimum, the gender, as defined in The World’s against children include Global
exploitation of the prostitution Women: Trends and Statistics Initiative to End All Corporal
of others or other forms of sexual (United Nations 2010b), refers to Punishment of Children (2005);
exploitation, forced labour or the socially constructed differences O’Donnell (2004); UNICEF
services, slavery or practices similar and attributes and opportunities (2000, 2002, 2004).
to slavery, servitude or the removal in being female or male and to the 70. See ‘Georgetown Declaration on
of organs; (b) The consent of a social interactions and relationships Building a Region Fit for Children
victim of trafficking in persons to between women and men. As Ellis for the Survival, Development, Pro-
the intended exploitation set forth (2003) puts it, gender is more than tection, Dignity, and Participation
in subparagraph (a) of this article understanding masculinity and of Children within the Caribbean
shall be irrelevant where any of the femininity: it is about recognizing Community’, CARICOM, George-
means set forth in subparagraph (a) the importance of human town, Guyana, 19 March 2008,
have been used; (c) The recruitment, relationships; it is about examining http://www.caricom.org/jsp/com-
transportation, transfer, harbouring how history has shaped and defined munications/meetings_statements/
or receipt of a child for the purpose both women and men; and it is georgetown_declaration_children.
of exploitation shall be considered about how men, as well as women, jsp. See also UNICEF (2011).
‘trafficking in persons’ even if this have assisted in defining male and 71. Maroon are descendants of runaway
does not involve any of the means female behaviour. slaves who formed communities.
190 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
An official definition of indigenous according to the socio-psychological as part of the national research for
has not been adopted by any function they serve, as follows: (a) this report.
United Nations agency. Indigenous experiential: categorizes the reality 7. Deosaran (2007a); De Lisle et al.
typically involves self-identification of past interactions; (b) defensive: (2007).
by individuals that is accepted by relates to coping with one’s inner 8. Chevannes (2004); De Lisle et
the community. It also refers to conflicts and anxieties by projecting al. (2007); Deosaran (2007b);
people’s historical continuity with them onto the homosexual persona; Deosaran and Crawford (1996);
pre-colonial or pre-settler societies and (c) symbolic: expresses a more Queeley-Roberts (2007).
and is associated with strong links to abstract concept of self and one’s 9. Samms-Vaughan, Jackson, and
territories and surrounding natural social network and reference group. Ashley (2004); Meeks Gardner et
resources. Indigenous groups often 75. World Bank (2011a). al. (2003).
rely on distinct social, economic, 76. Felson and Pare (2010). 10. For example, see Madden (2011).
or political systems and have 11. Deosaran (2007a); Queeley-Roberts
language, culture and belief systems (2007).
that are distinct from dominant Chapter 2 12. CARICOM (2010b).
social groups. Often, they resolve 13. Carter, R. (2008); Carter, S. (2008).
to maintain and reproduce their 1. See UNODC and World Bank 14. Moser and van Bronkhorst (1999);
ancestral environments and systems as (2007); ICPC (2010). The term Cunningham et al. (2008).
distinctive peoples and communities. youth is reserved for boys, girls, 15. Madden (2011); Levy (2009);
See Copabianco, Shaw, and Sagant young men, or young women Chaaban (2009); UNODC and
(2009). between the ages of 15 and 24 World Bank (2007).
72. A hydroelectric power plant was built years. In the Caribbean, definitions 16. United Nations (2005a).
in Suriname in the 1960s to generate differ according to political, legal 17. See Jacobo (2007); United Nations
cheap electricity for the foreign- and sociocultural traditions and (2005a). Youth development
controlled bauxite industry (the according to data collection and indices have been constructed in
pillar of the Surinamese economy), research needs. Some research on countries such as Cyprus, Brazil,
but it did not generate sustainable youth development and youth India, Malaysia, and Nigeria.
development for the benefit of the violence may address young people 18. See CARICOM (2010b); Carter, R.
local Maroon population. Despite up to 30 years of age (Moser and (2008); Carter, S. (2008).
increased economic activity since van Bronkhorst 1999; CARICOM 19. Moser and van Bronkhorst (1999,
the 1980s among foreign companies 2010b). However, the United 2).
and small local entrepreneurs in gold Nations standard is employed here 20. Constantine, Benard, and Diaz
mining, the lumber industry and in an attempt to apply a common (1999); Cunningham et al. (2008);
tourism, the Brokopondo district definition across countries. Ungar et al. (2008); UNODC and
is characterized by inequalities and 2. CARICOM (2010b). World Bank (2007).
widespread poverty, particularly 3. United Nations (1995). 21. In conditions of rapid negative
among the local Maroon population. 4. Deosaran (2007a); De Lisle et al. change, they may condition or
73. See ‘Video: An Interview with (2007). even trigger rioting and political
Julia Greenberg on HIV in the 5. For Antigua and Barbuda, violence, however. Unemployment
Caribbean’, AIDS-Free World, information was provided by the should not be confused with youth
Brooklyn, 30 September 2009, Royal Police Force and the National unemployment. The latter is more
http://www.aidsfreeworld.org/ Youth Intervention Unit. For directly associated with violent
Our-Issues/Homophobia/Video- Jamaica, see ‘Gangs in Schools’, crime.
An-Interview-with-Julia-Greenberg- Go-Jamaica, 22 July 2008, http:// 22. UNODC and World Bank (2007).
on-HIV-in-the-Caribbean.aspx. go-jamaica.com/news/read_article. 23. Harriott (2008a); UNODC and
Greenberg is associate director of php?id=2832. For Trinidad and World Bank (2007).
AIDS-Free World, a global advocacy Tobago, see Lall (2007). See also 24. CARICOM (2010b); ICPC
group tackling HIV/AIDS. Deosaran (2007b). (2010); Cunningham et al. (2008).
74. Herek proposes a model that 6. Focus group session conducted in 25. The reports are cited in CARICOM
distinguishes three types of attitudes Suriname with youth representatives (2010b, 37–39).
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R EP
EPORT 2012 191
26. The average of the Caribbean 51. CARICOM (2010c). 16. Katz and Choate (2006); OAS
Examinations Council pass rates 52. Wandering is a legal category in (2008a).
across six countries: Antigua and Barbados that applies to minors 17. Allan Goodridge, ‘Gangs in
Barbuda, Barbados, Guyana, only. It involves being absent from Barbados’, presentation at a Parent-
Jamaica, Saint Lucia, and Trinidad home without the consent of Teacher Association Meeting,
and Tobago. parents or guardians. Elsewhere Bridgetown, Barbados, 24 March
27. ICPC (2010). in the Caribbean, the category is 2010, cited in ‘Parents in Barbados
28. CARICOM 2010b; Carter, R. simply running away from home. Placed on Gang Alert’, Daily Herald
2008; Carter, S. 2008; Joseph, (Bridgetown), 26 April 2010.
Holder, and Alexis (2009). 18. Mogensen (2005).
29. For example, note the difference Chapter 3 19. Harriott (2008b).
between Moser and van Bronkhorst 20. Townsend (2009).
(1999) and HHS (2001). 1. UNODC and World Bank (2007); 21. Walker, R. ‘Profile: Jamaat al
30. Blum et al. (2003). Harrendorf, Heiskanen, and Malby Muslimeen’, BBC News, 3 June
31. Hernandez-Ramdwar (2008). (2010). 2007, http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/
32. De Lisle et al. (2007); Deosaran 2. van Gemert (2005, 148). americas/6716765.stm.
(2007b); Deosaran and Chadee 3. van Gemert (2005). 22. Katz (2008).
(2007); Queeley-Roberts (2007). 4. Harriott (2011, 6). 23. OAS (2008a); Wilkinson, B. ‘11
33. Levy (2009). 5. Harriott (2008b). Slain in Guyana Coastal Village:
34. Evans, quoted in Chevannes (2004, 6. UNDP (2009). Gang Leader Blamed’, Associated
9). 7. All three data source have their Press (27 January, 2008).
35. Moser and van Bronkhorst (1999). respective problems and sources 24. Maxson and Klein (1990); Katz
36. Moser and van Bronkhorst (1999); of error. Citizen perception (2003).
Cunningham et al. (2008). data may not be reliable because 25. Katz and Choate (2006).
37. Brathwaite (2008). various self-definitions of gangs 26. Katz, Choate, and Fox (2010).
38. CARICOM (2010b). may be operative and may inflate 27. Katz, Choate, and Fox (2010);
39. Blum et al. (2003). the problem. Self-report surveys Wells, Katz, and Kim (2010).
40. UNODC and World Bank (2007). may understate the problem 28. ‘Guyana Ups Drugs Trafficking Fight’,
41. Madden (2011); Crawford-Brown because of poor sample frames Weekend Mirror (Georgetown,
(2010). and the reluctance to reveal gang Guyana), 3 December 2010.
42. “In many Caribbean countries the membership. Police statistics are 29. Granger (2010).
onset of sexual activity is occurring often rough estimates because 30. Granger (2010).
at young ages and early sexual various definitions of gangs and 31. Granger (2010).
initiation has been positively gang-related violence may be 32. United States of America vs. Samuel
correlated with child abuse” operative, at times even within Knowles (2010) D. C. Docket
(Ruland and Finger 2004, cited in the same police force. However, 00–00425-CR-JIC; also see Paulin
Jones and Trotman Jemmot 2009, researchers have to make the (2010).
18). best of the sources that exist and 33. US State Department (2011a).
43. Queeley-Roberts (2007). try to minimize errors through 34. Data of the Immigration
44. UNODC and World Bank (2007). triangulation of the available data. Enforcement Department, Antigua
45. Deosaran (2007b). 8. Katz, Webb, and Schaefer (2001); and Barbuda.
46. Ungar et al. (2008, 168). Katz (2003). 35. ‘ Woman Falls Victim to Jamaican
47. See Joseph, Holder, and Alexis 9. Webb, Katz, and Decker (2006). Sweepstakes Scam’, Jamaica
(2009). 10. Meeks Gardner, Katz, and Observer (Kingston, Jamaica), 8
48. Blum et al. (2003). Rosenblatt (2008). May 2010.
49. Moser and van Bronkhorst (1999). 11. Wortley (2009). 36. Townsend (2009).
50. Cunningham et al. (2008); 12. Katz and Choate (2006). 37. UNODC and World Bank (2007);
Constantine, Benard, and Diaz 13. OAS (2008a). Solis and Aravena (2009).
(1999); Ungar et al. (2008); Madden 14. Katz and Choate (2006). 38. UNODC and World Bank (2007).
(2011); Levy (2009). 15. Katz (2008). 39. Katz and Schnebly (2011).
192 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
40. The community cohesion scale was people in this community generally the people in this country mean a lot
constructed by applying principal very trustworthy?’ to me’, (b) ‘I like to think of myself
components analysis using 14 41. The informal social control scale was as similar to the people who live in
variables. The component used had constructed by applying principal this country’, (c) ‘to what extent do
an eigenvalue of 5.7 and accounted components analysis using three people in your country have similar
for 40.7 percent of the variance variables. The component used had values as yourself ?’
in the original 14 variables. A an eigenvalue of 2.2 and accounted 44. The societal cohesion–participation
standardized variable was used to for 74.3 percent of the variance scale was constructed by applying
represent this component. The in the original three variables. A principal components analysis using
variables included in the component standardized variable was used to two variables. The component
were as follows: (a) ‘living here gives represent this component. The used had an eigenvalue of 1.8 and
me a sense of community’ (reverse variables included in the component accounted for 89.8 percent of the
coded); (b) ‘the associations/ were as follows: ‘What is the variance in the original two variables.
relationships that I have with the likelihood that people from your A standardized variable was used
people in this neighbourhood/ community would intervene in a (a) to represent this component. The
community mean a lot to me’ suspected case of domestic violence, variables included in the component
(reverse coded); (c) ‘I like to think (b) fight breaking out in front of were as follows: ‘to what extent
of myself as being in many ways your house with someone being would you be willing to work
similar to the people who live in beaten, (c) stranger is suspected of together with others (a) to reduce
this neighbourhood/community’ stealing from someone?’ violence in the country?, (b) on
(reverse coded); (d) ‘I like to think 42. The societal cohesion–belonging something to improve this country?’
of myself as being in many ways scale was constructed by applying 45. The societal cohesion–legitimacy
similar to people of other ethnic principal components analysis using scale was constructed by applying
groups who live in this country’ four variables. The component principal components analysis using
(reverse coded); (e) ‘to what extent used had an eigenvalue of 2.5 four variables. The component
do you feel like you belong in this and accounted for 62.6 percent used had an eigenvalue of 2.6
neighbourhood/community?’; (f ) of the variance in the original and accounted for 65.5 percent
‘to what extent do you feel loyal to four variables. A standardized of the variance in the original
the people of this neighbourhood/ variable was used to represent four variables. A standardized
community?’; (g) ‘to what extent this component. The variables variable was used to represent this
would you prefer to live somewhere included in the component were component. The variables included
else rather than continue to live in as follows: (a) ‘I feel like I belong in the component were as follows:
this neighbourhood/community?’ in this country’, (b) ‘I feel loyal to (a) ‘the police force deserves my
(reverse coded); (h) ‘to what extent the people of this country’, (c) ‘to support’, (b) ‘the court system
are you proud of being in your what extent are you proud of your deserves my support’, (c) ‘to what
neighbourhood/community ?’; nationality?’, (d) ‘I would prefer to extent do you think that the courts
(i) ‘to what extent do you work live in another country’ (reverse of this country guarantee a fair
together with others to reduce coded). trial?’, (d) ‘to what extent are your
violence in your community?’; 43. The societal cohesion–inclusion rights protected regardless of which
(j) ‘to what extent do you work scale was constructed by applying party is in power?’
together with others to improve principal components analysis using 46. The societal cohesion–respect scale
your community?’; (k) ‘to what three variables. The component was constructed by applying principal
extent do you participate in used had an eigenvalue of 2.2 components analysis using three
community activities?’; (l) ‘how and accounted for 71.9 percent variables. The component used had
involved are you in community of the variance in the original an eigenvalue of 2.2 and accounted
organizations and activities such three variables. A standardized for 72.6 percent of the variance
as the church, sports, community variable was used to represent this in the original three variables. A
centres, cultural activities?’; (m) ‘I component. The variables included standardized variable was used to
feel respected by the people who in the component were as follows: represent this component. The
live in this community’; (n) ‘are (a) ‘the associations that I have with variables included in the component
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R EP
EPORT 2012 193
were as follows: (a) ‘I feel respected 56. For example, see Matthews (2011); 14. Skogan and Hartnett (1997); Strobl
by (most of ) my fellow citizens’, (b) see also ‘More on the Decline (2011).
‘I am respected by most citizens of in Jamaica’s Crime’, Go-Jamaica 15. Tyler (2004, 2011); Skogan and
another race/ethnicity’, (c) ‘I am (Kingston, Jamaica), 7 April 2011, Frydl (2004).
respected by persons who earn a http ://g o -jamaica .com/news/ 16. Herrmann, MacDonald, and
higher income than me’. read_article.php?id=27841. Tauscher (2011).
47. Leslie (2010, 22). 57. Spohn and Katz (2008). 17. Harriott (2000).
48. Harriott (2008b, 2009); Leslie 58. Katz and Webb (2006). 18. Hall (2011).
(2010). 59. Simon (2010a, 2010b). 19. See CARICOM Implementation
49. Katz (2007). 60. Fahim (2010); see also ‘Examining Agency for Crime and Security,
50. Blum et al. (2003). the Tivoli Gardens Gang Bust in Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago,
51. Hawkins et al. (1999). Jamaica’, PRI’s The World (Boston), http://caricomimpacs.org/impacs.
52. Human beings constantly interact 21 December 2011, http://www. 20. Bennett (1991a, 1991b).
with each other. They must therefore theworld.org/2011/12/gang-tivoli- 21. Tyler (2004, 2011); Sunshine
master rules of interaction if they gardens-jamaica/. and Tyler (2003); Bayley (2006);
are to live peacefully together and 61. Spohn and Katz (2008). Skogan and Frydl (2004).
accomplish worthwhile aspirations. 62. Burch and Chemers (1997). 22. Factor analysis is a statistical
Observance of these rules of 63. Wyrick (2006). technique that identifies common
interaction may be broadly regarded features or similar underlying
as pro-social behaviour. Antisocial concepts in a group of items or
behaviour stands in contrast to pro- Chapter 4 variables by analysing the extent to
social behaviour. Broadly, antisocial which items cluster around a central
behavior is behavior that is harmful 1. Bayley (2006) identifies four essential concept and can be treated as a
to others. Such behaviour patterns characteristics of a democratic, conceptual unit.
are usually carried out in violation of citizen-oriented law enforcement 23. Bennett (2004).
social norms or the law. Individuals agency, as follows: (a) police must 24. Skogan (2006).
are socialized, consciously or be accountable to the rule of law 25. Peak, Bradshaw, and Glensor
subconsciously, about societal values and not the government; (b) (1992).
as reflected in customs, norms and police must protect human rights; 26. Bennett and Wiegand (1994).
mores. Individuals learn or are (c) police must be accountable to 27. Van Dijk, van Kesteren, and Smit
socialized through official or formal people outside their organization; (2007).
control exercised through the state and (d) top priority must be given 28. Van Dijk, van Kesteren, and Smit
or informal control mechanisms to servicing the needs of individual (2007).
exercised by non-state agents such as citizens and private groups. 29. Worrall (1999).
families or other persons on whom 2. Tyler (2004); Skogan and Frydl 30. Terpstra (2008).
power has been conferred or who (2004). 31. Ren et al. (2006).
are able to exercise control or impose 3. Sunshine and Tyler (2003); Tyler
sanctions. The internalization (2011); Engel (2005).
of social norms serves to ensure 4. Trojanowicz and Bucqueroux (1990). Chapter 5
conformity and can become 5. Cordner (2001).
oppressive to minorities that engage 6. Collier (2005); Harriott (2000); 1. Rowat, Malik, and Dakolias (1995).
in norm-violating behaviour that Palmer (1988). 2. Antoine (2008).
may not be harmful to others. When 7. Palmer (1988). 3. Antoine (2008).
such tensions rise, they typically lead 8. Harriott (2000); Dookhan (1975). 4. Antigua and Barbuda, Barbados,
to conflict and change. 9. Collier (2005); Harriott (2000). Guyana, Saint Lucia, and Trinidad
53. Sinclair (2004a, 2004b). 10. Quoted by Critchley (1967, 54). and Tobago use the term supreme
54. For example, see Barrett (2011). 11. Miller (1973); Critchley (1972). court to describe the entity that
55. For instance, see Sinclair (2011). The 12. Fridell and Wycoff (2004); Skogan comprises both the high court and
Proceeds of Crime Act makes it a (2004). the court of appeal. The Supreme
crime to profit from criminal activity. 13. Greene (2000); Skogan (1990). Court of Jamaica is the official term
194 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
used to describe the high court 1st Session of the 9th Parliament, 43. Webster’s New World Law
in that nation, while the court of Parliament of the Republic, Dictionary (Wild 2006) defines
appeals acts as the highest local Port of Spain, http://www. pre-trial detention as “the detaining
appeals court. ttparliament.org/publications. of an accused person in a criminal
5. Antoine (2008). php?mid=28&id=355. case before the trial has taken
6. See Guyana, Supreme Court of 22. For more information on the place, either because of a failure
Judicature (2009). issues outlined in this section, see to post bail or due to denial of
7. United Nations (2004a). 2010 Country Reports on Human release under a pre-trial detention
8. In addition to Antigua and Barbuda Rights Practices (database), Bureau statute.” Black’s Law Dictionary
and to Saint Lucia, the ECSC of Democracy, Human Rights, (Black 1910) defines remand as
member states are Anguilla, British and Labor, US State Department, follows: “to remand a prisoner, after
Virgin Islands, Dominica, Grenada, Washington, DC, http://www. a preliminary or partial hearing
Montserrat, Saint Kitts and state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/2010/. before a court or magistrate, is to
Nevis, and Saint Vincent and the 23. The absence of bail in Suriname, send him back to custody, to be kept
Grenadines. as well as the possibility of lengthy until the hearing is resumed or the
9. Antoine (2008). pre-trial detention, can be traced to trial comes on.”
10. See the ECSC website, http:// the Netherlands. The Netherlanders 44. Petrosino, Turpin-Petrosino, and
www.oecs.org/. have been criticized for their pre- Finckenauer (2000).
11. Of the Caribbean-7, Antigua and trial detention practices in the 45. Maguire and Bennett (2008).
Barbuda, Jamaica, Saint Lucia, and Netherlands and in the Netherland 46. The Prisons After Care Programme
Trinidad and Tobago continue to territories in the West Indies. was introduced in Barbados in 1977,
use the Judicial Committee of the 24. Jamaica, Ministry of Youth and but has since undergone scrutiny
Privy Council as a final appellate Community Development (1969, because of its limited effectiveness.
court ( JCPC 2009). 1). 47. ‘Case Study: Resolving Disputes
12. United Nations (2003a). 25. Lum and Yang (2005); Sherman through Alternative Means; Court
13. Saunders (2010). (2003); Weisburd, Lum, and Yang Mediation Process in Guyana Helps
14. Bernard (2009, 223). (2003). in Reducing Case Backlogs’, United
15. ‘Our Mission, Our Vision’, 26. See Maguire and Bennett (2008); States Agency for International
Caribbean Court of Justice, Port of Maguire et al. (2008). Development, Washington, DC,
Spain, Trinidad and Tobago, http:// 27. See Holdip (2010). http ://www.usaid.gov/stories/
www.caribbeancourtofjustice.org/. 28. Maguire and King (2011). guyana/cs_guyana_law.html.
16. Bernard (2009, 220). 29. Spohn and Denholm (2008, 9). 48. ‘21,366 Civil Matters Pending
17. Antoine (2008). 30. King and Maguire (2006). at the End of 2007’, Kaieteur
18. US State Department (2010b, 4). 31. See Maguire et al. (2010). News (Georgetown, Guyana),
19. For more information on the issues 32. Nelson (2011). 14 March 2009, http://
outlined in this paragraph, see 33. World Prison Brief (database), w w w. k a i e t e u r n e w s o n l i n e .
2010 Country Reports on Human International Centre for Prison com/2009/03/14/21366-civil-
Rights Practices (database), Bureau Studies, London, http://www. matter s -p en d ing - at-th e - en d-
of Democracy, Human Rights, prisonstudies.org/info/worldbrief/. of-2007/.
and Labor, US State Department, 34. US State Department (2010e). 49. Guyana provides the following
Washington, DC, http://www. 35. GINA (2006). example: “Section 17 of the
state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/2010/. 36. Guyana, Supreme Court of Juvenile Offenders Act identifies 7
20. DFC (2004). Judicature (2009). instances whereby a juvenile can be
21. The homicide rates are based on data 37. GINA (2006, 7). brought before the Courts: begging
presented in chart 1.4, chapter 1. 38. Spohn and Denholm (2008). or receiving alms; wandering;
For background on the bail reform, 39. US State Department (2010f, 6). destitute; under the care of a parent
see Trinidad and Tobago, Office of 40. Spohn and Denholm (2008). or guardian who by reason of
the Parliament (2008), ‘The Bail 41. Spohn and Denholm (2008, 4). criminal or drunken habits, is unfit
(Amendment) Bill, 2008: An Act 42. National Task Force on Crime to care for the child; is the daughter
to Amend the Bail Act, Chap. 4:60’, Prevention (2005). of a father who had been convicted
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R EP
EPORT 2012 195
of incest; or frequents the company 2009), http://www.ipsos-mori.com/ 82. ‘Caribbean Prisons Urged to Be Part
of any reputed thief, or common or researchpublications/researcharchive/ of Crime Solution’, Bahama Islands
reputed prostitute. These instances poll.aspx?oItemId=2504. Info (Freeport, Grand Bahama), 22
are not seen as criminal conduct 60. See Blumstein, Cohen, and Nagin June 2010.
by a juvenile but rather as the State (1978).
acting in the best interest of the 61. See Cohen-Cole et al. (2009).
child by removing that child from 62. See Cochrane, Chamlin, and Seth Chapter 6
a vulnerable situation and placing (1994).
him/her in the care of a relative or 63. Gifford (2009). 1. Brown (2010).
institution.” (Guyana, Office of the 64. US State Department (2010b, 2). 2. For example, see ‘Clash between
President 2008, 1–2) 65. US State Department (2010f, 3). Police and Residents, Laventille,
50. Deosaran and Chadee (1997). 66. Amnesty International (2009). Trinidad and Tobago’, CNC3News
51. United Nations (1985, 8). 67. See Amnesty International (2011). video, 4:10, 16 May 2009, uploaded
52. For example, see Jordan (2009). 68. Amnesty International (2011). to YouTube, 18 March 2011, http://
Also see ‘Police Probing 69. Maguire (2010). vodpod.com/watch/5788670-
Allegations of Ranks Having 70. Fyfe (1988). trinidad-war-in-laventille ;
Sex with Female Prisoners’, 71. Guyana, Ministry of Home Affairs ‘Jamaican Police Kills Man’, TVJ
Kaieteur News (Georgetown, (2011, 22). News video, 2:24, 31 July 2010,
Guyana), 18 November 2011, 72. Guyana, Ministry of Home Affairs uploaded to YouTube, 10 August
http://www.kaieteurnewsonline. (2011, 28) 2010, http://www.youtube.com/
com/2011/11/18/police-probing- 73. Transparency International (2010, 4). watch?v=eWHSOdVN97Q.
allegations-of-ranks-having-sex- 74. Heritage Foundation and Wall 3. An example is the Governance
with-female-prisoners. Street Journal (2011). and Accountability Framework
53. Guyana is the poorest of the seven 75. Chabrol (2010). established as part of Jamaica’s
nations, with a 2010 annual GDP 76. Integrity in Public Life Act, Public Sector Modernization
per capita of about US$6,800. Government of Antigua and Programme. The framework
Suriname ranks fifth out of the Barbuda, No. 23 of 2004, Official allows for public involvement in
seven nations, with a 2010 GDP per Gazette 44 (95), 30 December, the government decision-making
capita of about US$9,900. h t t p : / / w w w. l a w s . g o v. a g / process. A Consultation Code of
54. See Rountree and Land (1995); acts/2004/a2004-23.pdf. Practice for the Public Service is
Warr (1987). 77. ‘History of the Caribbean among the initiatives introduced
55. Norris and Chadee (2001), Community (CARICOM)’, through the framework. The code
56. Norris and Chadee (2001, 69). CARICOM, Georgetown, Guyana, establishes guidelines that require
57. Guyana was once a colony of the http ://www.caricom.org/jsp/ public consultation on all policies
Netherlands, but it then became a community/history.jsp. Current that affect the population. This
British colony for 151 years before member states are Antigua and requirement of accountability and
achieving independence in 1966. Barbuda, the Bahamas, Barbados, citizen participation facilitates
58. For example, see article 7, Belize, Dominica, Grenada, debates on new laws, for example.
‘Extradition Treaty between the Guyana, Haiti, Jamaica, Montserrat, Thus, through open debates or
United States of America and the Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, legislative submissions, civil society
Kingdom of the Netherlands’, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, has participated in the drafting of
signed at The Hague on 24 June Suriname, and Trinidad and anti-gang legislation, the Terrorism
1980 and entered into force 15 Tobago. Associate members are Prevention Act (2005) and the
September 1983, https://www. Anguilla, Bermuda, British Virgin Sexual Offences Act (2009).
unodc.org/tldb/showDocument. Islands, the Cayman Islands, and 4. Private sector initiatives included the
do?documentUid=6086&country Turks and Caicos. creation of a 12-point declaration
=NET&language=ENG. 78. CARICOM (2007b). and establishment of an anti-crime
59. ‘Survey for Channel 4 on Attitudes 79. Coward (2011). fund. For example, see ‘PSOJ
towards the Death Penalty’ (database), 80. Antoine (2008). Turns Up “Dudus” Heat’, Jamaica
Ipsos Mori, London (28 October 81. Byron and Dakolias (2008, 93). Observer (Kingston, Jamaica),
196 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
11 March 2010, http://www. public services. Nonetheless, we Timely and Reliable Manner, Illicit
jamaicaobserver.com/PSOJ-turns- maintained our focus on analysis Small Arms and Light Weapons,
up--Dudus--heat-3-11-2010#. of direct public expenditure in adopted by the United Nations
5. Harriott (2009). matters regarding security. This General Assembly on 8 December
6. Harriott (2009). has included prevention of armed 2005 (United Nations 2005b). The
7. Schmallager (2011). violence, community-based instrument commits states to mark
8. For Trinidad, see Equal Opportunity solutions, initiatives to limit drug existing stocks of weapons held by
Commission, http://www. and alcohol consumption, witness governments, armed individuals
equalopportunity.gov.tt/. For and victim protection programmes and security forces. This surveillance
Guyana, see ‘Guyana: The Main focused on women and youth, local seeks to reduce the chances of the
Human Rights Institutions’, United security management programmes, flow of these weapons to the illicit
Nations Population Fund, New and the prevention of human market. By 26 September 2011,
York, http://www.unfpa.org/ trafficking. Thus, we did not analyse 14 governments in the greater
derechos/guyana_eng.htm. fully even the budgets of ministries region had signed agreements
9. The estimates were calculated of security, government, interior to execute a related Project to
based on public information in and justice. Much of the work of Promote Firearms Marking in
expenditure reports delivered these ministries also involves other Latin America and the Caribbean:
by the treasury departments or matters, including issuance of Barbados, the Bahamas, Belize,
ministries of finance of each passports, registries on individuals Costa Rica, El Salvador, Grenada,
country. However, these figures are and documentation services. For Guatemala, Guyana, Paraguay,
approximations. Despite a rigorous defense expenditures, for example, Saint Lucia, Saint Kitts and Nevis,
effort to select the budget lines only budgetary activities directly Saint Vicente and the Grenadines,
that reflected the real expenditure related to citizen security such as Trinidad and Tobago, and Uruguay
on security, the real total is not arms collection and destruction, (OAS 2011a). Firearms marking
fully captured for several reasons. border control, and maritime is also a mandate within the
Without deeper involvement in the surveillance were examined. framework of the Inter-American
budgetary process, one faces great 10. UNDP (2011b). Convention against the Illicit
difficulty in attempting to capture 11. See Christie (2002); Patterson Manufacturing and Trafficking in
the values that match some lines, (2004); ‘US Pledges Help to Fight Firearms, Ammunition, Explosives
especially in areas such as violence Caribbean Drug Trafficking’, BBC and Related Materials (US State
prevention and institutional News, 17 April 2010, http://news. Department 1997).
strengthening. Thus, although most bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/8626674. 21. See OAS (2010b, 2011b);
of the budgetary weight in crime stm. ‘CARICOM Tracking Illegal
prevention, for example, falls on the 12. US State Department (2000). Guns in Region’, Jamaica
ministries of security, government, 13. Sabatier (1988). Observer (Kingston, Jamaica),
or interior, there are also relevant 14. Howlett, Ramesh, and Perl (2009). 11 February 2011, http://www.
initiatives in ministries of foreign 15. See the CARICOM IMPACS j a m a i c a o b s e r v e r. c o m / n e w s /
affairs, education, welfare, health, website, at http://www. Caricom-tracking-illegal-guns-in-
and so on. Our analysis has caricomimpacs.org. See also region#ixzz1ZEeHRKje.
consisted in the identification, CARICOM (2002). 22. ICNL (2001).
down to the budget line, of 16. Gordon (1997); Seelke et al. (2011). 23. OAS (2008c).
programmes and initiatives directly 17. See CARICOM (2000, 2010d); 24. See US State Department (2011b);
related to matters of security. There OAS (2010a); United Nations Narcotics Control Reports
is a consensus that well-groomed (1994); Iglesias (2002). (database), US State Department,
public spaces, universal education 18. CARICOM (2002). Washington, DC, http://www.
and anti-corruption initiatives 19. CARICOM (2010c, 2010e). state.gov/g/inl/rls/nrcrpt/index.
influence, in a clear manner, 20. Gun marking and tracing htm; Trafficking in Persons Report
success in preventing violence, programmes are in line with the (database), US State Department,
building citizenship and promoting International Instrument to Enable Washington, DC, http://www.
coexistence, besides improving States to Identify and Trace, in a state.gov/j/tip/rls/tiprpt/index.
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R EP
EPORT 2012 197
htm; Human Rights Reports gleaner.com/gleaner/20110117/ and independently adjudicated,
(database), US State Department, lead/lead5.html. and which are consistent with
Washington, DC, http://www. 32. Angus Reid Public Opinion (2010). international human rights norms
state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/. 33. Sourcebook of Criminal Justice and standards. It requires, as well,
25. ‘Caribbean Could See Reduced UK Statistics (database), Section 2 measures to ensure adherence
Aid over Anti-gay Laws’, Stabroek ‘Public Opinion’, US Bureau to the principles of supremacy
News (Georgetown, Guyana), of Justice Statistics, Hindelang of law, equality before the law,
30 October 2011, http://www. Criminal Justice Research Center, accountability to the law, fairness in
stabroeknews.com/2011/news/ University at Albany, Albany, the application of the law, separation
breaking-news/10/30/caribbean- NY, http://www.albany.edu/ of powers, participation in decision-
could-see-reduced-uk-aid-over- sourcebook/. making, legal certainty, avoidance
anti-gay-laws/. 34. The commission reported on of arbitrariness and procedural and
26. See DFAIT (2011); GINA (2006); death penalty–related cases in the legal transparency.”
USAID (2004); Rodgers (2011); Bahamas, Belize, Grenada and 38. This use of ‘don’ is derived from a
Virtue (2011). Jamaica, where the Commission term of respect in Italian that has
27. See ‘Police Present Seven found government violations been adopted outside Italy to refer to
Reasons for 60 Days’, Jamaica and recommended remedies for a high-ranking or powerful member
Gleaner (Kingston, Jamaica), 1 violations of inmate rights with of the Mafia. In the Caribbean
October 2008, http://jamaica- respect to issues of and treatment context, the term has come to
gleaner.com/gleaner/20081001/ with respect to the imposition of prominence as a euphemistic
lead/lead2.html; ‘Know Your the death penalty (IACHR 2011). label for a ‘community leader’ in a
Crime Bills’, Jamaica Gleaner 35. Some consequences of this socially excluded or marginalized
(Kingston, Jamaica), 12 July 2010, backlash include withdrawal of community.
http : / / j ama i ca - g l e an er.c om / ratification of the Inter-American 39. Robotham (2003).
gleaner/20100712/news/news3. Convention of Human Rights, 40. Alves and Correia (2010); Lench
html. the First Optional Protocol to the (2007); Hellman, Muilenburg-
28. This includes the Latin American International Covenant on Civil Trevino, and Worley (2008).
Public Opinion Project’s and Political Rights, and creation 41. Worcester and Gill (2005).
AmericasBarometer, Multiple of the Caribbean Court of Justice 42. Powell and Lewis (2011).
Indicator Cluster Surveys in Guyana as a court of final jurisdiction. More 43. Latin American Public Opinion
and Suriname and National Crime recently, 12 Caribbean countries Project, ‘Guyana’, Vanderbilt
Victimization Surveys in Barbados voted against United Nations University, Nashville, http://www.
and Jamaica. General Assembly Resolution vanderbilt.edu/lapop/guyana.php.
29. G arland (1990); Costelloe, 63/168 calling for a moratorium on 44. Latin American Public Opinion
Chiricos, and Gertz (2009); Baker executions. See Helfer (2002). Project, ‘Suriname’, Vanderbilt
and Roberts (2005). 36. ‘Govt. to Get Tough on Crime’, University, Nashville, http://www.
30. ‘St. Lucia’s Crime Plan’, nationnews. Jamaica Gleaner (Kingston, vanderbilt.edu/lapop/suriname.
com (Fontabelle, Barbados), 1 Jamaica), 16 February 2011, php.
Februar y 2011, http ://www. http ://Jama ica - g leaner.c om/ 45. US State Department (2010f ).
nationnews.com/articles/view/st- gleaner/20110216/carib/carib1. 46. Transparency International (2009,
lucias-crime-plan/; ‘Govt. to Get html. 2010).
Tough on Crime’, Jamaica Gleaner 37. The following definition of the rule 47. Transparency International has
(Kingston, Jamaica), 16 February of law has been proffered within the also warned about state capture in
2011, http://Jamaica-gleaner.com/ United Nations (2004b, 4): Jamaica (Salas and Reiter 2009).
gleaner/20110216/carib/carib1. “It refers to a principle of governance 48. Edelman (1967, 1971, 1988)
html. in which all persons, institutions categorizes policies as instrumental
31. ‘ Trinidad and Tobago Bringing and entities public and private, (tangible) or expressive (symbolic).
Back Death Penalty’, Jamaica including the State itself, are While instrumental policies actually
Gleaner (Kingston, Jamaica), 17 accountable to laws that are publicly address a problem, symbolic policies
January 2011, http://www.jamaica- promulgated, equally enforced are adopted by governments to
198 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
appease public concerns; they 54. United Nations (2003b).
typically do not create long-term 55. World Bank (2011a).
changes or may be enacted, but not 56. Jones (2007).
enforced. 57. United Nations (2005c); UNDP
49. See Marion and Oliver (2006, (2010b).
2010), including the references. 58. Thomas and Wint (2002).
50. ‘Support Us to Fight Crime: PM 59. UNODC and World Bank (2007);
Golding’, Office of the Prime WHO (2010).
Minister, Government of Jamaica, 60. See CARICOM (2010b);
Kingston, Jamaica, 18 June 2010, UNICEF 2006; World Bank
http://www.opm.gov.jm/news_ (2003).
and_public_affairs/support_us_ 61. World Bank (2011a).
to_fight_crime_pm_golding. 62. UNDP (1997).
51. Golding (2011); JIS (2011). 63. UNDP (1994).
52. For example, see the report on
Barbados, which identifies the
occasional use of excessive force as Chapter 7
a human rights problem (US State
Department 2010b). 1. Moore and Stephens (1991).
53. United Nations (2003b), paragraph 2. Wycoff and Skogan (1994).
81. 3. Cano (2008).
Alves, H., and I. Correia. (2010). ‘Personal ibbean Studies: Viewpoints, World
and General Belief in a Just World as Bank, Washington, DC.
Judgement Norms’. International Jour-
nal of Psychology 45 (3): 221–231. Baker, E., and J. V. Roberts. (2005). ‘Glo-
balization and the New Punitiveness’.
Amnesty International. (2008). ‘Jamaica, “Let In The New Punitiveness: Trends,
Them Kill Each Other”: Public Securi- Theories, Perspectives, ed. J. Pratt, D.
ty in Jamaica’s Inner Cities’. Report (1 Brown, M. Brown, S. Hallsworth, and
April), Amnesty International, Lon- W. Morrison, 121–138. Portland,
don. http://www.amnesty.org/en/ OR: Willan Publishing.
library/info/AMR38/001/2008/en.
Barnes, A., and R. Seepersad. (2008). Beyond
Amnesty International. (2009). Amnesty In- Boundaries: A Comparative Study on
ternational Report 2009: The State Deportation in Antigua and Barbuda,
of the World’s Human Rights. Lon- Guyana, Jamaica and Trinidad and
don: Amnesty International. http:// Tobago. Port of Spain, Trinidad and
report2009.amnesty.org/sites/re- Tobago: CARICOM Implementation
port2009.amnesty.org/files/docu- Agency for Crime and Security.
ments/air09-en.pdf.
Barrett, L. (2011). ‘Cops Winning the
Amnesty International. (2011). ‘Trinidad Fight against Gangs’. Jamaica Glean-
and Tobago: Amnesty International er (Kingston, Jamaica), 31 March.
Submission to the UN Universal Peri- http://jamaica-gleaner.com/glean-
odic Review, 12th session of the UPR er/20110331/lead/lead5.html.
Working Group, October 2011’. Doc-
ument AMR 49/005/2011 (March). Baumgartner, J. N., C. Waszak Geary, H.
Amnesty International, London. Tucker, and M. Wedderburn. (2009)
http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/ ‘The Influence of Early Sexual Debut
info/AMR49/005/2011/en. and Sexual Violence on Adolescent
Pregnancy: A Matched Case-Control
Angus Reid Public Opinion. (2010). ‘U.S., Brit- Study in Jamaica’. International Per-
ain and Canada Endorse Death Pen- spectives on Sexual and Reproductive
alty’. Angus Reid Global Monitor (25 Health 35 (1): 21–28.
January), Angus Reid Public Opinion,
Vancouver. http://www.angus-reid. Bayley, D. H. (2006). Changing the Guard:
com/polls/38156/us_britain_and_ Developing Democratic Police Abroad.
canada_endorse_death_penalty/. New York: Oxford University Press.
———. (2007a). ‘Women and Men in ———. (2010e). ‘Welcome Remarks by His
the Caribbean Community: Facts Excellency Edwin W. Carrington,
and Figures, 1998–2005’. February, Secretary General, Caribbean Com-
CARICOM, Georgetown, Guyana. munity (CARICOM), on the Occa-
http://www.criti.info/sharing_the_ sion of the First Meeting of the Re-
vision/CARICOM%20Documents/ constituted Inter-Governmental Task
CHAP1-POPFAM.pdf. Force (IGTF), 29 September 2010,
Georgetown, Guyana’. Press Release
———. (2007b). ‘One Team, One Space, 380/2010 (29 September), CARI-
One Caribbean’. Implementation COM, Georgetown, Guyana. http://
Agency for Crime and Security, CAR- www.caricom.org/jsp/pressreleases/
ICOM, Port of Spain, Trinidad and press_releases_2010/pres380_10.jsp.
Tobago. http://caricomimpacs.org/
impacs/pdf/07.pdf. ———. (2010f ). ‘Declaration of Para-
maribo on the Future of Youth in the
———. (2009). ‘Youth Risk Composite Caribbean Community’. Press Re-
by Country’. Commission on Youth lease 47/2010 (30 January), CARI-
Development, CARICOM, George- COM, Georgetown, Guyana. http://
town, Guyana. www.caricom.org/jsp/pressreleases/
pres47_10.jsp.
———. (2010a). Caribbean Trade and In-
vestment Report 2010: Strategies Carter, R. (2008). ‘Caribbean Youth: An In-
for Recovery, Renewal and Reform. tegrated Literature Review’. Commis-
Georgetown, Guyana: CARICOM; sion on Youth Development, CARI-
Kingston, Jamaica: Ian Randle Publi- COM, Georgetown, Guyana.
cations.
Carter, S. (2008). ‘Youth Visions, Aspirations,
———. (2010b). ‘Eye on the Future: Invest- Concerns and CSME Perspectives’.
ing in Youth Now for Tomorrow’s Commission on Youth Development,
Community’. Draft report ( January), CARICOM, Georgetown, Guyana.
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 203
Chaaban, J. (2009). ‘The Cost of Negative Coffey, P. S. (2004). ‘Literature Review of
Youth Behaviours in the CARICOM Trafficking in Persons in Latin Amer-
Member States’. Report, Commission ica and the Caribbean’. August, United
on Youth Development, CARICOM, States Agency for International De-
Georgetown, Guyana. velopment, Washington, DC. http://
www.oas.org/atip/regional%20re-
Chabrol, D. S. (2010). ‘Local Chapter of ports/usaid%20lac%20tip%20litera-
Transparency International in the ture%20review.pdf.
Making: Expects Hurdles’. Demerara
Waves 1497 (11 November), Deme- Cohen-Cole, E., S. Durlauf, J. Fagan, and D.
rara Waves Media, Georgetown, Guy- S. Nagin. (2009). ‘Model Uncertainty
ana. and the Deterrent Effect of Capital
Punishment’. American Law and Eco-
Chadee, D. (2003). ‘Fear of Crime and Risk nomics Review 11 (2): 335–369.
Victimization’. Social and Economic
Studies 52 (1): 70–97. Collier, M. W. (2005). Political Corruption
in the Caribbean Basin. New York:
Chadee, D., L. Austen, and J. Ditton. (2007). Routledge.
‘The Relationship between Likeli-
hood and Fear of Criminal Victimiza- Constantine, N. A., B. Benard, and M. Diaz.
tion: Evaluating Risk Sensitivity as a (1999). ‘Measuring Protective Factors
Mediating Concept’. British Journal of and Resilience Traits in Youth: The
Criminology 47 (1): 133–153. Healthy Kids Resilience Assessment’.
Paper presented at the Seventh Annual
Chevannes, P. (2004). ‘Preliminary Study Meeting of the Society for Prevention
on Violence in Caribbean Schools’. Research, ‘Toward a Synthesis of Pre-
Paper prepared for the Change from vention Science Paradigms over the Life
Within Project, Cluster Office, Unit- Course’, New Orleans, 24–26 June.
ed Nations Educational, Scientific and
Cultural Organization, Kingston, Ja- Cooke, R. (2002). ‘Report of the National
maica. Survey of Street and Working Chil-
dren’. Child Support Unit, Ministry of
Christie, N. (1986). ‘The Ideal Victim’. In Health, Kingston, Jamaica.
From Crime Policy to Victim Policy:
Reorienting the Justice System, ed. E. Copabianco, L., M. Shaw, and V. Sagant.
A. Fattah, 17–30. Basingstoke, United (2009). ‘Community Safety and In-
Kingdom: Palgrave Macmillan. digenous Peoples: Sharing Knowledge,
Insights and Action’. Background pa-
Christie, P. (2002), ‘Speech by Hon. Perry per for the International Centre for
Christie, Prime Minister of the Baha- the Prevention of Crime’s Workshops,
mas’. Speech presented at the Twenty- Aboriginal Policy Research Confer-
Third Meeting of the Conference of ence, Ottawa, 9–12 March.
Heads of Government of the Carib-
bean Community, Georgetown, Guy- Cordner, G. (2001). ‘Community-Based Po-
ana, 3 July. http://www.caricom.org/ licing’. In Critical Issues in Policing:
jsp/speeches/23hgc_christie.jsp. Contemporary Readings, ed. R. G.
Dunham and G. P. Alpert, 493–510.
Cochrane, J. K., M. B. Chamlin, and M. Seth. Long Grove, IL: Waveland Press Inc.
(1994). ‘Deterrence or Brutalization?
An Impact Assessment of Oklahoma’s Costelloe, M., T. Chiricos, and M. Gertz. (2009).
Return to Capital Punishment’. Crim- ‘Punitive Attitudes toward Criminals’.
inology 32 (1): 107–134. Punishment and Society 11 (1): 25–49.
204 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Coward, S. L. (2011). ‘CONSLE to Au- licing’. In Crime, Delinquency and
dit IMPACS’. Press release (2 June), Justice: A Caribbean Reader, ed. R.
Caribbean Press Releases. http:// Deosaran, part 4. Kingston, Jamaica:
www.caribbeanpressreleases.com/ar- Ian Randle Publishers.
ticles/8376/1/CONSOLE-to-Audit-
IMPACS/Page1.html. ———. (2007b). ‘School Violence and De-
linquency: The Dynamics of Race,
Crawford-Brown, C. (2010). Children in the Gender, Class, Age and Parenting in
Line of Fire: The Impact of Violence the Caribbean’. In Crime, Delinquen-
and Trauma on Families in Jamaica cy and Justice: A Caribbean Reader,
and Trinidad and Tobago. Kingston, ed. R. Deosaran, 89–132. Kingston,
Jamaica: Arawak Publications. Jamaica: Ian Randle Publishers.
Critchley, T. A. (1967). A History of Police in ———. (2009). ‘Keynote Address; Crimi-
England and Wales, 900–1966. Lon- nology: Challenges and Public Policy’.
don: Constable. Caribbean Journal of Criminology
and Public Safety 14 (1–2), iv–xvi.
———. (1972). A History of Police in Eng-
land and Wales. Montclair, NJ: Patter- Deosaran, R., and D. Chadee. (1997). ‘Juve-
son Smith. nile Delinquency in Trinidad and To-
Cunningham, W., L. McGinnis, R. García bago: Challenges for Social Policy and
Verdú, C. Tesliuc, and D. Verner. (2008). Caribbean Criminology’. Caribbean
Youth at Risk in Latin America and the Journal of Criminology and Social
Caribbean: Understanding the Causes, Psychology 2 (2): 36–83.
Realizing the Potential. Directions in ———. (2007). ‘Juvenile Delinquency in
Development: Human Development. Trinidad and Tobago: Challenges for
Washington, DC: World Bank. Social Policy and Caribbean Crimi-
De Albuquerque, K., and J. L. McElroy. nology’. In Crime, Delinquency and
(1999). ‘A Longitudinal Study of Seri- Justice: A Caribbean Reader, ed. R.
ous Crime in the Caribbean’. Caribbe- Deosaran, 159–195. Kingston, Jamai-
an Journal of Criminology and Social ca: Ian Randle Publishers.
Psychology 4 (1–2): 32–70.
Deosaran, R., and C. Crawford. (1996).
De Lisle, J., N. Ramkhelawan, C. Joseph, S. ‘Crime (and Delinquency) and Vio-
Annisette, I. Maraj, A. Singh, K. Ali, T. lence in Schools: Analysis, Interven-
Thomas, L. Murray, and J.-A. Walcott. tion and Prevention; Project Proposal’.
(2007). ‘Thinking Violent Thoughts: University of the West Indies, St. Au-
Students’ Attitudes to Violence within gustine, Trinidad and Tobago.
Secondary Schools in Trinidad and
DFAIT (Foreign Affairs and International
Tobago’. In Crime, Delinquency and
Trade Canada). (2011). ‘Canada-
Justice: A Caribbean Reader, ed. R.
CARICOM Relations’. 26 July,
Deosaran, 133–148. Kingston, Jamai-
DFAIT, Ottawa. http://www.inter-
ca: Ian Randle Publishers.
national.gc.ca/americas-ameriques/
Deosaran, R. 2000. Psychonomics and Pov- canada_caricom/canada_caricom.
erty: Toward Governance and a Civil aspx?lang=eng&view=d.
Society. Kingston, Jamaica: University
of the West Indies Press. DFC (Disciplined Forces Commission).
(2004). ‘Report of the Disciplined
———. (2007a). ‘A Caribbean Portrait of Forces Commission’. May, DFC,
Crime, Justice and Community Po- Georgetown, Guyana. http://www.
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 205
scribd.com/doc/56146823/Report- Engel, R. S. (2005). ‘Citizens’ Perceptions of
of-the-Disciplined-Forces-Commis- Distributive and Procedural Injustice
sion-Unofficial-Copy. during Traffic Stops with Police’. Jour-
nal of Research in Crime and Delin-
Ditton, J., and S. Farrall. (2000). Fear of Crime. quency 42 (4): 445–481.
Aldershot, United Kingdom: Ashgate.
Fahim, K. (2010). ‘Jamaican Forces Ac-
DLP (Democratic Labour Party). 2008. cused of Killing Unarmed Men’. New
‘Pathways to Progress: Manifesto of York Times, 2 June. http://www.
the Democratic Labour Party, 2008’. nytimes.com/2010/06/03/world/
31 August, DLP, Bridgetown, Barba- americas/03jamaica.html.
dos. http://www.dlpbarbados.org/
cms/images/stories/policy/2008_ Favaro, E. M. and D. Peretz. (2008). ‘Intro-
dlp_manifesto.pdf. duction’. In Small States, Smart Solu-
tions: Improving Connectivity and
Dookhan, I. (1975). A Post-Emancipation Increasing the Effectiveness of Pub-
History of the West Indies. London: lic Services, ed. E. M. Favaro, 1–24.
Collins. Washington, DC: World Bank.
Douglas, L. (2008). ‘Jobs for Gangs: 10,000 Felson, R. B., and P.-P. Pare. (2010). ‘Gun
Unskilled Youths to Be Trained over Cultures or Honor Cultures? Explain-
Next Four Years’. 23 October, Jamai- ing Regional and Race Differences in
ca Labour Party, Kingston, Jamaica. Weapon Carrying’. Social Forces 88
http://www.jamaicalabourparty.com/ (3): 1357–1378.
base/content/jobs-gangs.
Fox, K., and G. Gordon-Strachan. (2007).
ECLAC (United Nations Economic Commis- ‘Jamaican Youth Risk and Resiliency
sion for Latin America and the Carib- Behaviour Survey 2005: School-Based
bean). (2010a). ‘Caribbean Synthesis Survey on Risk and Resiliency Be-
Review and Appraisal Report in the haviours of 10–15 Year Olds’. Report
Context of the 15th Anniversary of TR-07–58 (March), University of the
the Adoption of the Beijing Declara- West Indies, Kingston, Jamaica.
tion and Platform for Action’. Docu-
ment LC/CAR/L.259 (14 May), Francis, A., G. Gibbison, A. D. Harriott, and
ECLAC, Santiago, Chile. C. Kirton. (2009). Crime and Devel-
opment: the Jamaican Experience.
———. (2010b). ‘What Kind of State? Kingston, Jamaica: Sir Arthur Lewis
What Kind of Equality: 11th Region- Institute of Social and Economic
al Conference on Women in Latin Studies.
America and the Caribbean’. (Decem-
ber), ECLAC, Santiago, Chile. Fridell, L., and M. A. Wycoff, eds. (2004).
Community Policing: The Past, Pre-
Edelman, M. J. (1967). The Symbolic Uses sent, and Future. Washington, DC:
of Politics. Chicago: University of Il- Annie E. Casey Foundation, Police
linois Press. Executive Research Forum.
———. (1971). Politics as Symbolic Action: Fyfe, J. J. (1988). ‘Police Use of Deadly Force:
Mass Arousal and Quiescence. New Research and Reform’. Justice Quar-
York: Academic Press. terly 5 (2): 165–201.
———. (1988). Constructing the Political Garland, D. (1990). Punishment and Mod-
Spectacle. Chicago: University Of ern Society: A Study in Social Theory.
Chicago Press. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
206 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
GHRA (Guyana Human Rights Association). Golding, M. (2011). ‘The Judicial Disman-
(2002). ‘Ambivalent about Violence: tling of the Crime Bills’. Jamaica
A Report on Fatal Shootings by the Gleaner (Kingston, Jamaica), 17 July.
Police in Guyana, 1980–2001’. Re- http://jamaica-gleaner.com/glean-
port, GHRA, Georgetown, Guyana. er/20110717/cleisure/cleisure2.
http://www2.ohchr.org/english/bod- html.
ies/cat/docs/ngos/GHRA-reporton-
Gomes, C. (2007). ‘Police Accountability in
FatalShootings.pdf.
the Caribbean: Where are the Peo-
Gifford, A. (2009). ‘The Death Penalty: De- ple?’ Paper presented at the Civicus
velopments in Caribbean Jurispru- World Assembly’s Workshop on Po-
dence’. International Journal of Legal lice Accountability, Glasgow, 23–27
Information 37 (2): 196–203. May.
McDonald, O. P. (2008). ‘Gender Attitudes Moncrieffe, D. (1998). ‘Gang Study: The Ja-
and Violence vs. Women: Findings maican Crime Scene’. Report, Crimi-
from the Reproductive Health Survey, nal Justice Research Unit, Ministry of
2008’. PowerPoint presentation. Na- National Security and Justice, King-
tional Family Planning Board, King- ston, Jamaica.
ston, Jamaica.
Moore, M. H., and D. W. Stephens. (1991).
Meeks, J. (2009). ‘Caribbean Children’s In- Beyond Command and Control: The
volvement in Gangs’. Paper presented Strategic Management of Police De-
at the Consortium for Social Develop- partments. Washington, DC: Police
ment and Research ‘Teleconference on Executive Research Forum.
Research Activities’, University of West
Moser, C., and B. van Bronkhorst. (1999).
Indies, Kingston, Jamaica, 30 June.
‘Youth Violence in Latin America
Meeks Gardner, J., C. M. Katz, and J. Rosen- and the Caribbean: Costs, Causes
blatt. (2008). ‘Reports of Gangs in and Interventions’. LCR Sustainable
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 213
Development Working Paper 3 (Au- Caribbean Forum, of the Recommen-
gust), Urban Peace Program Series, dations on the Draft Declaration of
Latin America and Caribbean Region, Commitment of Port of Spain: Fifth
World Bank, Washington, DC. Summit of the Americas (Forum Held
in Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago
National Task Force on Crime Prevention.
on October 30–31, 2008)’. Document
(2005). ‘Study on Court Delays in Re-
OEA/Ser.E GRIC/O.6/doc.10/08
lation to Criminal Cases in Barbados’.
(11 December), Summit Implementa-
Crime & Justice 5, Office of the Attor-
tion Review Group, OAS, Washing-
ney General, Bridgetown, Barbados.
ton, DC.
Nelson, M. (2011). ‘Making Sense of DNA
———. (2010a). ‘Hemispheric Drug Strat-
Backlogs, 2010: Myth vs. Reality’. NIJ
egy and Preparation of Its Plan of Ac-
Special Report NCJ 232197 (Feb-
tion’. Resolution of the General As-
ruary), National Institute of Justice,
sembly (8 June), Inter-American Drug
Office of Justice Programs, US De-
Abuse Control Commission, OAS,
partment of Justice, Washington,
Washington, DC. http://www.cicad.
DC. http://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/
oas.org/Main/Template.asp?File=/
nij/232197.pdf.
main/aboutcicad/basicdocuments/
Norman, Lisa R., Robert Carr, and Julio resolution_strategy_plan_eng.asp.
Jimenez. (2006). ‘‘Sexual Stigma and
———. (2010b). ‘Report on Measures and
Sympathy: Attitudes toward Persons
Actions Related to the Implementa-
Living with HIV in Jamaica.’’ Culture,
tion of the Declaration on Security
Health & Sexuality 8(5):423-33.
in the Americas (Submitted by the
Norris, M., and D. Chadee. (2001). ‘Capi- CARICOM Implementation Agency
tal Ideas: A Cross-Cultural Study on for Crime and Security: IMPACS)’.
Death Penalty Attitudes in and around Document OEA/Ser.G CP/CSH-
the Caribbean’. Caribbean Journal of 1169/10 (21 January), Committee
Criminology and Social Psychology 6 on Hemispheric Security, Permanent
(1–2): 62–81. Council, OAS, Washington, DC.
Ren, L., J. Zhao, N. P. Lovrich, and M. J. Rountree, P. W., and K. C. Land. (1995). ‘Per-
Gaffney (2006). ‘Participation in ceived Risk Versus Fear of Crime: Em-
Community Crime Prevention: Who pirical Evidence of Conceptually Dis-
Volunteers for Police Work?’ Polic- tinct Reactions in Survey Data’. Social
ing: An International Journal of Police Forces 74 (4): 1353–1376.
Strategies and Management 29 (3):
Rowat, M., W.H. Malik, and M. Dakolias,
464–481.
eds. (1995). Judicial Reform in Latin
Reynolds, M. O. (1999). ‘Crime and Punish- America and the Caribbean: Proceed-
ment in America: 1999’. NCPA Pol- ings of a World Bank Conference.
icy Report 229 (October), National World Bank Technical Paper 280.
Center for Policy Analysis, Dallas. Washington, DC: World Bank.
http://www.ncpa.org/pdfs/st229.pdf.
Russo, N. F., and A, Pirlott. (2006). ‘Gender-
Ribando, C. (2005). ‘Trafficking in Persons Based Violence: Concepts, Methods,
in Latin America and the Caribbean’. and Findings’. Annals of the New York
CRS Report for Congress RL33200 Academy of Sciences 1087 (Novem-
(15 December), Congressional Re- ber): 178–205.
search Service, Library of Congress,
Sabatier, P. A. (1988). ‘An Advocacy Coali-
Washington, DC.
tion Framework of Policy Change and
Robinson, T. (2005). ‘Access to Justice for the Role of Policy-Oriented Learning
Women Who Are Victims of Violence Therein’. Policy Sciences 21 (2–3):
in the Caribbean’. Paper presented at 129–168.
the Organization of American States
Salas, A., and Z. Reiter. (2009). ‘Report on
and Inter-American Commission on
Visit to Jamaica, September 15 to
Human Rights work meeting, ‘The
September 20, 2009’. Report (18 No-
Protection of Women’s Rights in the
vember), Department of the Americas,
Inter-American System of Justice: An
Transparency International, Berlin.
Analysis of Access to Justice’, Washing-
http://www.normangirvan.info/wp-
ton, DC, 19–20 April. http://www.
content/uploads/2009/12/ti_report_
sdnp.org.gy/16days/files/Access%20
to_usaid_on_visit_to_jamaica_fi-
to%20Justice%20for%20Women%20
nal11.pdf.
who%20are%20Victims%20of%20
Violence%20in%20the%20Carib- Samms-Vaughan, M. E, M. A. Jackson, and
bean.pdf. D. E. Ashley. (2005). ‘Urban Jamaican
Children’s Exposure to Community
Robotham, D. (2003). ‘Crime and Public
Violence’. West Indian Medical Jour-
Policy in Jamaica’. In Understanding
nal 54 (1): 14–21.
Crime in Jamaica: New Challenges for
Public Policy, ed. A. D. Harriott, 197– Sampson, R. J., S. W. Raudenbush, and F.
238. Kingston, Jamaica: University of Earls. (1997). ‘Neighborhoods and
the West Indies Press. Violent Crime: A Multilevel Study
of Collective Efficacy’. Science 277
Rodgers, P. (2011). ‘Britain Commits to (5328): 918–924.
US$40-Million Compete Carib-
bean. Jamaica Observer (Kingston, SAP-FL (Special Action Programme against
Jamaica), 12 October. http://www. Forced Labour) and ITUC (Internation-
216 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
al Trade Union Confederation). (2007). www.trinidadexpress.com/news/Po-
‘A Workers’ Alliance against Forced lice__criminals__working_arm-in-
Labour and Trafficking’. Brochure (20 arm_-102713764.html.
August), International Labour Organi-
———. (2010b). ‘The “Killing Squad”’.
zation, Geneva. http://www.ilo.org/
Trinidad Express Newspaper (Port
sapfl/Informationresources/Factsheet-
of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago), 12
sandbrochures/WCMS_083841/lang-
September. http://www.trinidad-
-en/index.htm.
express.com/news/The__killing_
Saunders, A. D. (2010). ‘A Commentary on squad_-102713759.html.
the Early Decisions of the Caribbean
Sims, C.-D. L. (2008). ‘Invisible Wounds, In-
Court of Justice in Its Original Juris-
visible Abuse: The Exclusion of Emo-
diction’. International and Compara-
tional Abuse in Newspaper Articles’.
tive Law Quarterly 59 (3): 761–778.
Journal of Emotional Abuse 8 (4):
Schmallager, F. (2011). Criminal Justice To- 375–402.
day: An Introductory Text for the
Sinclair, G. (2004a). ‘All Out Assault: “Op-
21st Century. Upper Saddle River, NJ:
eration Kingfish” to Target Dons,
Prentice Hall. Gangs’. Jamaica Gleaner (Kingston,
Seelke, C. R., L. S. Wyler, J. S. Beittel, and M. Jamaica), 20 October. http://jamaica-
P. Sullivan. (2011). ‘Latin America and gleaner.com/gleaner/20041020/lead/
the Caribbean: Illicit Drug Trafficking lead1.html.
and U.S. Counterdrug Programs’. CRS ———. (2004b). ‘“Kingfish” Targets a Doz-
Report for Congress 7–5700 R41215 en Major Gangs’. Jamaica Gleaner
(12 May), Congressional Research (Kingston, Jamaica), 26 October.
Service, Washington, DC. http:// http://jamaica-gleaner.com/glean-
www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/R41215. er/20041026/lead/lead1.html.
pdf.
———. (2011). ‘Ealan Vows to Destroy
Sheffield, C. J. (1989). ‘Sexual Terrorism’. In Gangs’. Jamaica Gleaner (Kingston,
Women: A Feminist Perspective, 4th Jamaica), 25 January. http://jamaica-
ed., ed. J. Freeman, 3–19. Mountain gleaner.com/gleaner/20110125/lead/
View: CA: Mayfield Publishing Com- lead2.html.
pany.
Skogan, W. G. (1975). ‘Measurement Prob-
Sherman, L. W. (2003). ‘Experimental Evi- lems in Official and Survey Crime
dence and Governmental Administra- Rates’. Journal of Criminal Justice 3
tion’. Annals of the American Acade- (1): 17–31.
my of Political and Social Science 589
(1): 226–233. ———. (1990). Disorder and Decline:
Crime and the Spiral of Decay in
Short, J. F., Jr. (1963). ‘Introduction’. In The American Neighborhoods. Berkeley,
Gang: A Study of 1,313 Gangs in Chi- CA: University of California Press.
cago, Frederic M. Thrasher. Abridged
ed. Chicago: University of Chicago ———. (2004). ‘Community Policing:
Press. Common Impediments to Success’. In
Community Policing: The Past, Pre-
Simon, A. (2010a). ‘Police, Criminals “Work- sent, and Future, L. Fridell and M. A.
ing Arm-in-Arm”’. Trinidad Express Wycoff, 159–167. Washington, DC:
Newspaper (Port of Spain, Trinidad Annie E. Casey Foundation, Police
and Tobago), 12 September. http:// Executive Research Forum.
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 217
———. (2006). ‘Asymmetry in the Impact Sunshine, J., and Tyler, T. R. (2003). ‘The
of Encounters with the Police’. Polic- Role of Procedural Justice and Legiti-
ing and Society 16 (2): 99–126. macy in Shaping Public Support for
Policing’. Law & Society Review 37
Skogan, W. G., and K. Frydl, eds. (2004). Fair-
(3): 513–548.
ness and Effectiveness in Policing: The
Evidence. Washington, DC: National Tankebe, J. (2009). ‘Public Cooperation with
Academies Press. the Police in Ghana: Does Procedural
Fairness Matter?’ Criminology 47 (4):
Skogan, W. G., and S. M. Hartnett. (1997).
1265–1293.
Community Policing, Chicago Style.
New York: Oxford University Press. Terpstra, J. (2008). ‘Police, Local Govern-
ment, and Citizens as Participants in
Solís, L. G., and F. R. Aravena, eds. (2009).
Local Security Networks’. Police Prac-
Organized Crime in Latin America
tice and Research 9 (3): 213–225.
and the Caribbean: Summary of Arti-
cles. San José, Costa Rica: Latin Amer- Thomas, M., and E. Wint. (2002). ‘Inequality
ican Faculty of Social Sciences. and Poverty in the Eastern Caribbean’.
Paper presented at Eastern Caribbean
Spergel, I. A. (1986). ‘The Violent Gang Prob-
Central Bank’s ‘Seventh Annual Devel-
lem in Chicago: A Local Community
opment Conference’, Basseterre, Saint
Approach’. Social Service Review 60
Kitts and Nevis, 21–22 November.
(1): 94–131.
Thomas-Hope, E. (2002). ‘Human Traffick-
———. (1995). The Youth Gang Problem:
ing in the Caribbean and the Human
A Community Approach. New York:
Rights of Migrants’. Paper persented
Oxford University Press.
at Conferencia Hemisférica sobre
Spohn, C., and K. Denholm. (2008). ‘Case Migración Internacional: Derechos
Processing Outcomes in Homicide Humanos y Trata de Personas en las
Cases’. Report (11 September), Minis- Américas, Santiago, Chile, 20–22 No-
try of National Security, Port of Spain, vember. http://www.eclac.org/celade/
Trinidad and Tobago. noticias/paginas/2/11302/Thomas-
Hope.pdf.
Spohn, C., and C. M. Katz. (2008). ‘Update
on GANG/ROP Task Force Arrest Townsend, D. (2009). ‘No Other Life: Gangs,
Activity’. Report, Arizona State Uni- Guns, and Governance in Trinidad
versity, Phoenix. and Tobago’. Small Arms Survey
Working Paper 8, Graduate Institute
Stern, Baroness V. (2010). The Stern Review: of International and Development
A Report by Baroness Vivien Stern Studies, Geneva.
CBE of an Independent Review into
How Rape Complaints Are Handled Transparency International. (2009). ‘Corrup-
by Public Authorities in England and tion Perceptions Index 2009’. Trans-
Wales. London: Government Equali- parency International, Berlin. http://
ties Office, Home Office. www.transparency.org/policy_re-
search/surveys_indices/cpi/2009/
Strobl, S. (2011). ‘From Colonial Policing to cpi_2009_table.
Community Policing in Bahrain: The
Historical Persistence of Sectarianism’. ———. (2010). ‘Corruption Perceptions In-
International Journal of Comparative dex 2010’. Transparency International,
and Applied Criminal Justice 35 (1): Berlin. http://www.transparency.org/
19–37. content/download/55725/890310.
218 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
Trojanowicz, R. C., and B. Bucqueroux. http://www.beta.undp.org/content/
(1990). Community Policing: A Con- undp/en/home/librarypage/capacity-
temporary Perspective. Cincinnati: building/capacity-development-a-un-
Anderson Publishing Company. dp-primer.html.
Tyler, T. R. (2004). ‘Enhancing Police Legiti- ———. (2010a). Human Development Re-
macy’. In To Better Serve and Protect: port 2010: The Real Wealth of Na-
Improving Police Practices, ed. W. G. tions: Pathways to Development. New
Skogan, 84–99. Annals of the Ameri- York: UNDP; New York: Palgrave
can Academy of Political and Social Macmillan. http://hdr.undp.org/en/
Science 593. Thousand Oaks, CA: reports/global/hdr2010/.
Sage.
———. (2010b). Beyond the Midpoint:
———. (2011). ‘Trust and Legitimacy: Po- Achieving the Millennium Devel-
licing in the USA and Europe’. Euro- opment Goals. January. New York:
pean Journal of Criminology 8 (4): UNDP. http://www.sl.undp.org/1_
254–266. doc/MDG_mid_point.pdf.
UNDP (United Nations Development Pro- ———. (2011a). Human Development Re-
gramme). (1994). ‘Initiatives for port 2011 – Sustainability and Equity:
Change’. UNDP, New York. A Better Future for All. New York:
———. (1997). ‘Governance for Sustain- UNDP; New York; Palgrave Macmil-
able Human Development’. A UNDP lan. http://hdr.undp.org/en/reports/
Policy Document ( January), UNDP, global/hdr2011/.
New York. http://mirror.undp.org/ ———. (2011b). ‘Información sobre el gasto
magnet/policy/. público de seguridad y justicia en Cen-
———. (2004). ‘Regional Report on the troamérica, 2006–2010’. UNDP Re-
Achievement of the Millennium De- gional Centre for Latin America and
velopment Goals in the Caribbean the Caribbean, Panama City.
Community’. September, UNDP, Ungar, M., L. Liebenberg, R. Boothroyd, W.
New York. http://www.undp.org/lati- M. Kwong, T. Y. Lee, J. Leblanc, and
namerica/docs/RegionalMDGCarib- A. Makhnach. (2008). ‘The Study of
bean.pdf.
Youth Resilience across Cultures: Les-
———. (2006). ‘Guía de Evaluación de la Se- sons from a Pilot Study of Measure-
guridad Ciudadana en América Latina ment Development’. Research in Hu-
y El Caribe’. UNDP Regional Centre man Development 5 (3): 166–180.
for Latin America and the Caribbean,
UNICEF (United Nations Children’s Fund).
Panama City.
(2000). An Assessment of the Status of
———. (2009a). Abrir espacios para la Children and Adolescents with Disa-
seguridad ciudadana y el desarrollo bilities in the Caribbean. Bridgetown,
humano: Informe sobre Desarrollo Barbados: UNICEF Office for Barba-
Humano para América Central, dos and the Eastern Caribbean.
2009–2010. Panama City: UNDP
———. (2002) ‘The OECS Family Law and
Regional Centre for Latin America
Domestic Violence Legal and Judicial
and the Caribbean; Bogotá: D’Vinni
Reform Project’. Children in Focus 15
S.A.
(2), UNICEF Office for Barbados and
———. (2009b). ‘Capacity Development: the Eastern Caribbean, Bridgetown,
A UNDP Primer’. UNDP, New York. Barbados.
C ARIBBEAN H UMAN DE VELOPMENT R E P O R T 2 0 1 2 219
———. (2004). The State of the World’s Article 40 of the Covenant; Second
Children 2005: Childhood under Periodic Report: Suriname’. Inter-
Threat. New York: UNICEF. national Covenant on Civil and Po-
litical Rights, document CCPR/C/
———. (2006). ‘Violence against Children
SUR/2003/2 (4 July), Human Rights
in the Caribbean Region: Regional
Committee, Office of the High Com-
Assessment; UN Secretary-General’s
missioner for Human Rights, United
Study on Violence against Children’.
Nations, Geneva. http://www.un-
Child Protection Section, UNICEF
hchr.ch/tbs/doc.nsf/0/ed050cc5c9
Regional Office for Latin America and
1e7b91c1256dbf002d2b25/$FILE/
the Caribbean, Panama City.
G0342817.pdf.
———. (2011). The State of the World’s
———. (2003b). ‘Report of the Special Rap-
Children 2011; Adolescence: An Age
porteur, Asma Jahangir, Submitted
of Opportunity. New York: UNICEF.
Pursuant to Commission on Human
United Nations. (1985). ‘United Nations Rights Resolution 2003/53, Adden-
Standard Minimum Rules for the dum: Mission to Jamaica’. Document E/
Administration of Juvenile Justice CN.4/2004/7/Add.2 (26 September).
(“The Beijing Rules”)’. Document United Nations, New York. http://
A/RES/40/33 (29 November), www.unhchr.ch/Huridocda/Huridoca.
United Nations, New York. http:// nsf/0/a7af3c2c5ba84be7c1256ddb00
www.un.org/documents/ga/res/40/ 39c202/$FILE/G0316217.pdf.
a40r033.htm.
———. (2004a). ‘Republic of Suriname:
———. (1993). ‘Declaration on the Elimi- Public Administration Country Pro-
nation of Violence against Women’, file’. Country Profile (December), Di-
Document A/RES/48/104 (20 vision for Public Administration and
December), United Nations Gen- Development Management, Depart-
eral Assembly, New York. http:// ment of Economic and Social Affairs,
www.un.org/documents/ga/res/48/ United Nations, New York. http://
a48r104.htm. unpan1.un.org/intradoc/groups/pub-
lic/documents/un/unpan023204.pdf.
———. (1994). ‘Report of the Global
Conference on the Sustainable De- ———. (2004b). ‘The Rule of Law and Tran-
velopment of Small Island Develop- sitional Justice in Conflict and Post-
ing States, Bridgetown, Barbados, 25 conflict Societies: Report of the Secre-
April–6 May 1994’. Document A/ tary-General’. Document S/2004/616
CONF.167/9 (October), United Na- (23 August), United Nations, New
tions, New York. http://www.un.org/ York. http://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/
esa/dsd/dsd_aofw_sids/sids_pdfs/ doc/UNDOC/GEN/N04/395/29/
BPOA.pdf. PDF/N0439529.pdf ?OpenElement.
———. (1995). ‘World Programme of Ac- ———. (2005a). ‘Report of the Expert
tion for Youth to the Year 2000 and Group Meeting on Youth Develop-
Beyond’. Document A/RES/50/81 ment Indicators’. United Nations,
(14 December), United Nations, New York. http://www.un.org/esa/
New York. http://www.un.org/docu- socdev/unyin/documents/youthindi-
ments/ga/res/50/a50r081.htm. catorsreport.pdf.
In preparing the first Caribbean Human Development Re- sites for this report1, a purposive sample for both national
port (Caribbean HDR) for the English- and Dutch-speaking and regional consultations was developed with input from
Caribbean countries, a critical data collection methodology the UNDP Country Office focal points. Sample selection
employed—and one which embodies the HDR Corporate for both national and regional consultations was carried
Principles of national ownership and participatory and inclu- out in line with the principles of the Framework for Actor
sive preparation—was that of a series of national and regional Mapping/Stakeholder Analysis presented in Democratic Di-
consultations, the details of which are described in this tech- alogue: A Handbook for Practitioners, which facilitates the
nical note. The purpose of these consultations was twofold: analysis of potential actors, their interrelationships and dis-
to obtain qualitative data on the views, experiences and pri- tinct perspectives on the issue at hand.2
orities of stakeholders across the region regarding the issue of The key actors for a potential dialogue include a variety
citizen security, and to promote Caribbean ownership of and of individuals, institutions and interest groups. A thorough
buy-in for the report as a means to strengthening its advocacy analysis for determining a valid sample takes into considera-
potential. tion not only the identification of major relevant groups and
The consultation processes involved extensive and inten- institutions but also the diversity existing within each of these
sive one-on-one interviews and focus group dialogues with organizations. The figure below presents the matrix frame-
experts, practitioners and institutional actors from across work through which such an analysis was configured.
the region. In six of the seven countries selected as research
A total of 194 actors participated in the national consul- to bilateral meetings and no national consultations were con-
tations; 62 percent represented governmental agencies and ducted in Saint Lucia. In total, 92 national consultations were
38 percent represented non-governmental bodies. A total held, 69 (75 percent) of which were bilateral meetings and 23
of 256 actors participated in the regional consultations; 49 (25 percent) of which were group meetings.
percent represented governmental agencies and 51 percent
represented non-governmental bodies. Table 1 below shows Regional Consultations
the breakdown by number and representative percentage of Five group dialogue regional consultations also took place
participants by country. in September 2010 in Paramaribo, Suriname; Port of Spain,
Trinidad and Tobago; Bridgetown, Barbados; Castries, Saint
National Consultations Lucia; and Kingstown, Jamaica. These meetings involved a
For the national consultations, three or more rounds of fo-
cus group dialogue sessions were held in Barbados, Jamaica,
NOTES:
Suriname and Trinidad and Tobago. Additionally, national
researchers held a series of bilateral meetings with key local 1 No consultation has been carried out in Guyana. The data on Guyana have been obtained
through public sources and the UNDP Citizen Security Survey 2010.
actors who were unable to participate in the group consulta-
tions. In Antigua and Barbuda, the consultations were limited 2 IDEA, CIDA, OAS, and UNDP. 2007. Democratic Dialogue –A Handbook for Practitioners.
total of 256 participants from regional organizations such the official crime statistics reported and the representativeness
as the Regional Security System (RSS), the Organization of of the findings of the surveyed data, particularly with regard
Eastern Caribbean States (OECS) and the CARICOM Sec- to urban and rural populations and different demographic
retariat, among others. The regional consultations provided groups. A call for reformation of the criminal justice system
an opportunity to triangulate the quantitative data findings was endorsed in all consultations and proposals were offered
from the survey with the experiences of the participants in- for alternative penal solutions, different policing models and
volved in the consultative process and to solicit feedback on methods, means for reducing youth violence, and strategies to
the report presentation. promote wider involvement of the local community.
Recommendations offered in the course of these consul- It is important to note that the recommendations present-
tations ranged from suggestions for supplementing missing ed during the consultations were either accepted as offered
data, revising chapter titles and changing terminology defini- or further researched and developed; a concerted effort was
tions to the identification of successful crime prevention pro- made in the report preparation to incorporate all substanti-
grammes. Questions were also posed by the participants, spe- ated feedback from consultation participants.
cifically on methodology employed as well as the accuracy of
The most important methodological tool utilized in the prep- • Policy orientations of the population
aration of the first Caribbean Human Development Report • Evaluation of and confidence in police and justice systems
was the Citizen Security Survey, which involved over 11,000 • Community and societal cohesion
respondents from across the region and contributed the pri- • Informal control of crime and violence
mary data for much of the subsequent analysis presented in • Self-reported interaction with the criminal justice system
the report. The objective of the survey was to provide empiri- • Demographics
cal evidence for the analysis of how, in the context of the Eng- The survey was conducted in the seven selected territories
lish- and Dutch-speaking Caribbean countries and within the that served as sites for the report research--Guyana, Trinidad
development context of Caribbean Small Island Developing & Tobago, Suriname, Antigua & Barbuda, Saint Lucia, Bar-
States (SIDS), insecurity and violence have negatively impact- bados and Jamaica. The target population of the survey was
ed human development. Guided by this central objective, the households with at least one permanent resident 18 years of
survey collected data on the following: age or older. In total, 11,155 persons were interviewed.1
• Satisfaction with standard of living/level of human devel- The sample for the survey was designed to reflect key de-
opment mographic characteristics of the adult populations in the par-
• Actual victimization/Crime at the community level ticipating countries based on the most recent census data. The
• Domestic Violence sample was self-weighted by region and gender distributions.
• Fear of crime Even though probabilistic procedures were followed to select
226 C A R I B B E A N H U MA N D E VELOPM ENT REPORT 2 0 1 2
households, it was expected that at least some of the sample justice system, etc.); and regime commitment (or attitude
would present moderate biases in variables not controlled by to regime change or military government).
quota. In order to detect and analyze underlying attitudinal ori-
Post-fieldwork processing of the data implied control of entations in the population, a cluster analysis was performed
all relevant demographic variables for each country against based on a series of 22 items included in the questionnaire.
the last available census data to evaluate possible biases and to These measured degrees of support or rejection for different
elaborate and apply weighting factors where needed. The vari- statements related to social prevention policies, punitive poli-
able distributions controlled for were age, gender, ethnicity, cies, and attitudes of optimism (or pessimism) about whether
education level and population by county/area. the crime problem can effectively be solved by the state and
The report also utilizes a series of surveys conducted by the the society.2 Cluster analysis is a segmentation method that
Vanderbilt University Latin American Public Opinion Pro- identifies groups of entities or statistical samples (in this case,
ject (LAPOP). These datasets were used primarily for their the citizens), intended to identify homogeneous subgroups of
data on the justice systems in the countries surveyed. cases in a population. This technique is used to first, estab-
lish groups not previously defined but relevant to the study
Analysis of policy attitudes in question, and second, analyze the group’s membership and
The issues that guided the analysis on attitudes of the popula- characteristics. The specific technique used in chapter 6 of this
tion towards policy were based on the following: report was hierarchical clustering. This statistical method al-
• The extent to which crime and insecurity is defined by the lows the researcher to select a definition of distance, a linking
various populations as a serious social problem in need of methodology for forming clusters, and the number of clusters
policy attention. Section 1 of the Citizen Security Survey best suited to the data.
questionnaire measures this as the relative seriousness of Lastly, the analysis of confidence in police and justice sys-
the problem. tems is based on the construction of simple additive scales.
• The specification of policy orientation dimensions and de- Cronbach Alpha coefficients were analyzed in order to test
termination of the extent and intensity of support for each. the scales’ reliability.
• The patterns of support towards different policy orienta-
tions by country, victimization experience, confidence in Use of official crime statistics
the criminal justice system, age, gender, income, education The report also relied on secondary data taken from official
and area. state sources in the seven countries included in the HDR. Of-
• Intensity and coherence of the different tendencies or ori- ficial crime statistics were used for the trend analyses reported.
entations. An important condition for comparing crime indicators is
• Correlates with perceptions of societal features (for exam- that the compatability of definitions across the range being ex-
ple, how just a society is seen to be); law-abiding inclina- amined. For this reason, the categories of crime used in these
tion among the populations; perceptions of good govern- analyses were restricted to homicide, rape, and the aggregate
ance (control of corruption, confidence in the criminal categories of violent crimes and property crimes.
NOTES:
1 For more details on all technical aspects of the survey described in this note, please refer to the
following website: http://www.regionalcentrelac-undp.org/en/hdr-caribbean.