Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dierk Schroder
qq-4 Ft”F,-
r - - 4 Cell Boost
is difficult. One difficulty are the parasitic elements Burk
if high switching frequencies are desired. This paper
shows a general procedure for the design and optimi-
zation of these circuits with CAEtools. These tools
L-
are physical models for the power-semiconductors
which are implemented in programs for electronic cir-
FTHj,
cuit analysis. But the physical models of the power-
Buck-8oosf Cuk
semiconductors are optimized to achieve on the one
FT-!k+
hand very short calculation times compared to device
models and on the other hand very good accuracy of
1% = A‘
the switching transients compared to SPICEmodels.
So this CAE-tool is an intermediate tool in between
the device-modeling for the semiconductor on the one
hand and the system-modeling on the other hand.
Zeta Sepic
I. INTRODUCTION
626
I
I I I
nant.
The results of the simulation in fig. 4 show clearly that
Fig. 3. PhasoShift-Bridge-DC-DC-
Converter, topology
627
la i
5A /E
"01
lCQV/E
UDGI
200V/E
"7
I,,,.
- u2.- -- - --
'p-
T T-
I A A A 1 I
8 current with a n approximately constant negative d i l d t at
the beginning due to the charging of the capacitors when a
transient with an inductive load is considered. After Cj is
Ob G mi" charged to the supply voltage a damped resonant process
will occur due to the capacitor Cj and the RL of the load.
But the simulated transients of the diode-current and the
diode-voltage and the real reverse recovery will vary very
much. The main explanations are the high injection of
the v-zone and the specific boundary conditions when a
power-diode is used. This stored charge will be removed
during the reverse recovery. Fig.7 shows the transient re-
moval of this charge during a reverse recovery and the
current and voltage of the diode.
Fig.7 shows clearly the differences to fig. 6 during the
reverse recovery. Thus the modeling of the charging of
the v-zone is important to describe the inductive beha-
viour of the power-diode during a switching-on transient.
But most important is the modeling of the removal of the
charge during reverse recovery (switching off),
Fig. 6. pn-junction, SPICE model and reverse Due to this lack of the original SPICE model other models
recovery exist, which describe the reverse recovery effects by adding
additional elements to the model, most of them are fitted
to a limited range of operating points or they are fitted to
a specific operating point. Therefore these models imitate
the reverse recoverey effect for a specific set of parameters
628
Symbol
G+qq Drain
G
strUtture
model
Drain D
Model1
model
Fig. 8 . Vertical MOSFET, type SIPMOS
Fig. 9. Structure of an IGBT
of the diode and the topology. These models must fail, if
the parameters of the diode used and/or the parameters power-semiconductors. Thus we must consider the most
of the topology differ. This was the situation in the exam- important effects of power-semiconductors physics, to de-
ple in fig, 3 and the results in fig. 4 and fig. 5 . This is an scribe the characteristics of these semiconductors.
essential result and leads to the starting point of our re- The same considerations are necessary for all power-
search; CAE-models for power-semiconductor should be semiconductors. We have to start from the structure of the
based on physical approach. This holds for all power- device and develop a basic model. The components and
semiconductors, because all power-semiconductors have their parameters of this model must be derived, starting
an intrinsic or low doped zone. from semiconductor physics, reducing the partial differen-
Fig.8 shows the symbol, the structure and an implified tial equations to ordinary differential equations by specific
model of a vertical MOSFET. approximations. Thus the physical background is still va-
Considering the structure of such a vertical MOSFET, lid and the range of validity is ensured. If this approach
it is a well-known fact, that power-MOSFETs possess is accepted, we have to derive first models for the power-
an inherent antiparallel n+n-p+-diode, this diode is a diode, the P B J T and in a third step a full model for the
typical power-diode. Furthermore we can define a para- vertical MOSFET. When these basic models are available,
sitic n+ptn- n+-transistor (power-BJT or PBJT) which more complex models for recent power-semiconductors
is built by the source-gate-drift-zone. The base-collector- can be derived.
diode of this parasitic transistor is the antiparallel power- The most recent power-semiconductors are combinations
diode. Additionally there are capacitors and resistors. of unipolar and bipolar devices to gain a combination of
This most basic model of a vertical FET is shown in fig. the advantages of both: simple gate circuit, high blocking
6, too. As soon as such a very basic model is defined in voltage, low on-resistance, high collector currents and
the first step to derive a model, it is necessary to consider good dynamic behaviour. From fig. 9 it can be derived ea-
with great care how the components must be modeled. sily, that for example the IGBT (Insulated Gate Bipolar
This is very important for the range of validity. Even if Transistor) is such a hybrid power switch. The structure
we use such a basic model, we can define critical operating of the IGBT is at the upperside in fig. 9 similar to a verti-
conditions. When we use - for example - the antiparallel cal F E T in fig. 8. Additionally a p+-layer is added at the
diode as a freewheeling diode, the reverse recovery current drain side of the FET.
of this diode can trigger a switching transient of the pa- If we summarize the aspects in this chapter, we must
rasitic PBJT. This transient will occur, when the voltage state:
drop at the resistor between base and emitter is great 0 The modern power semiconductors have complicatcd
enough, An additional switching transient of the PBJT structures which result in very complex models to
can occur, when a transient with a high positive du/dt describe the static and dynamic behaviour.
is applied to the blocked MOSFET. This high du/dt will
produce a charging current for the capacitor between the 0 There is a wide variety of combinations of semicon-
collector and the base of the parasitic PBJT. This cur- ductors as active switch and there is a very wide va-
rent can produce a voltage drop at the resistor between riety of topologies for dc-dc; dc-ac; ac-dc and ac-ac
base and emitter of the transistor again. Even avalanche converters. Furthermore hard switched semiconduc-
effects can be considered, if the components in the mo- tors, special snubber circuits, ZVS or ZCS switch con-
del are starting from semiconductor physics. As the first figurations can be used.
result of the discussion in t h e chapter it must be stated,
Thus the optimization process
that even a unipolar power switch as the vertical MOS-
FET contains parasitic elements, which are real bipolar 0 which topology for the desired application,
629
0 which switch configuration, b = -Pn : mobility ratio
PP
which active switch,
D= ILn .p p : ambipolar diffusivity
0 which interactions and which parasitic effects can oc- + PP
Pn
cur, P + CA .p3
R=- : composite recombination rate
Th
0 are these effects acceptable or not,
Since D,b, TSRH are functions of the local carrier den-
e which are the stresses for the components and the sity, the local dopant density and other local parameters,
ratings of these components, these quantities are also functions of space.
This set of nonlinear partial differential equations has no
is difficult and costly. If models of these power- closed mathematical solution. Thus in device simulation
semiconductors can be derived, these models could be programs like PISCES this set of equations is is solved nu-
implemented in network simulator programs. Such a tool merically by inserting a geometric mesh and solving the
would be very helpful to reduce practical experiments and equations step by step. Due to this mathematical pro-
provide a path for CAE for power converter topologies, cedure the calculation of one switching transient is very
too. time-consuming and the complexity of the topology of the
circuit in which the power semiconductor is inserted must
11. BASICSTEPSFORTHEDERIVATION OF POWER be very simple.
SEMICONDUCTOR MODELS Due to this situation it is absolutely unefficient to try to si-
mulate the topologies shown in the first chapter with these
If the simulation of power-semiconductors or systems with programs. Another approach is the system simulation of
power-semiconductors are considered we must distinguish a system as in fig. 3 (third level). Due to the high order of
between three different simulation levels. The first level is this system and to the fact that the time-constants in such
the device simulation of the static and dynamic beha- a system vary very much (on the one hand lOns - 2011s
viour of the power-semiconductor itself. This simulation for the switching of the power-semiconductors and on the
uses the partial differential equations set of the semicon- other hand seconds in electrical machines) the integration
ductor physics as Poisson’s (or the Maxwell-), the current steps must be chosen or adapted automatically to this si-
density- and the continuity-equations. tuation to guarantee stability of the simulation. To avoid
Poisson’s equation : to small steps for the integration and to limit the compu-
ting time the semiconductors are approximated only by
ideal switches with a fixed time-constant normally. There-
fore both levels of simulation cannot be used to simulate
Current density equations: the switching behaviour of power semiconductors with-
in converter- or inverter-topologies and thus getting the
desired informations to replace breadboard experiments.
The objective of the approach discussed in this paper is a
circuit-analysis program to simulate the switching behavi-
Continuity equations: our of power-semiconductors. Such a simulation program
is classified in between the two levels discussed just before.
The general idea is:
? - --. 8D
- + D a. p- + - . - 0. 2- p- J 1 ab develop for all passive and active components of the
at ax ax at2 q ( b + 1)2 ax basic model adequate descriptions,
630
A more accurate approach to solve the ADE was presented
in [21], [23] and [22] which uses a time dependent discreti-
zation scheme for the high injected part of the drift zone.
diil(grYrtlp) = 1 (- P
- + aP
%) This will be outlined briefly now.
DA TH As the borders of the high injected region xi and t r are
moving during switching transients, any spatial discreti-
zation introduced in order to solve the ambipolar diffusion
equation has to adapt to these moving boundaries. As the
boundary conditions (current density equations) have to
be fulfilled at changing positions, any discretization fixed
with respect to time and locus inherits either unphysical
results or severe numerical problems. Hence the most ade-
quate discretization is related directly to the positions of
xi(t) and tr(t)
631
drift zone
1 :..............i.....,
;f(pl@
....i.............:
$!(p,li I -180
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
Fig. 11. The drift zone module as a central time (ns)
part of the diode model
Fig. 12. Current during reverse recovery, model
111. CAE-RESULTS
A = 0.3cm3 0
= 100pm
Wepi
-50
N+ = 2 . 1014cm-1
wa = w, = 2 0 p m --> -100
N , = N , = 5 . 1018cm-'
~ " 0= rPo = 6ps
4
-% -150
-200
632
time (ns) Fig. 17. Snapoff
Fig. 16. Carrier densities in the drift-zone Fig. 18. IGBT,turn-off at 300K for different
load currents (20A,40A,60A), emit-
ter current
633
Fig. 19. IGBT, turn-off at 400K for different Fig. 21. GTO, snubberless turn-off of clam-
load currents (20A, 40A,60A), emit- ped inductive load at 40A/80V
ter current
634
V. CONCLUSION
I I I
In this paper CAE for power electronics is discussed. On
the one hand the latest power semiconductors can be des-
_ - cribed only by models which contain different basic struc-
I
tures. These basic structures describe the basic effects
starting from semiconductor physics. On the other hand
modern power electronics do not only use "hard switched"
switches only, but also switches with special circuits to
reduce the switching losses or quasi-, multi-, or transient
switches. The analysis of such topologies is very difficult,
thus the determination of the ratings and therefore the
optimization of the elements is troublesome. An analysis
with CAE tools as described in this paper is a much favo-
rable solution than breadboard experiments. Furthermore
with this CAEtool the mutual interdepencies of different
parameters can be determined selectively. This gives an
opportunity to optimize the parameters of the different
elements or for the power semiconductors depending on
Fig. 23. GTO, iduence of different gate pul- the specific topology. Another important objective is the
ses on turn-on time
opportunity to study the influence of parasitic elements or
effects, which are very difficult to determine in a bread-
board experiment. Additionally internal signals can be
analyzed which cannot be measured or external signals
the model made several approximations which had to be which are difficult to measure or which cannot be measu-
discussed in respect to its application. The first approxi- red at all because parasitic components are inserted which
mation is that the device is one-dimensional. This can be change the topology. So the switching transients can be
assumed if the devices are fine structured, which is the simulated during the normal operation or with extended
tendency for the development of the power devices now. models which describe critical operations.
For devices with large structures the two-dimensional ef- This is an important step ahead to find the adequate to-
fects such as current crowding, current pinching etc. are pology with the adequate power semiconductor for a spe-
important. These two dimensional effects are not included cific application. Furthermore, the best suited data of the
in the models. One possible solution is to fit the parame- power semiconductor in a specific application can be de-
ters and average the effects. A more physical approxima- termined. So this CAE-tool is the missing link between
tion is to parallel several models [6],[19]. the specialists on the one hand which design the topolo-
gies - but are no specialists in the field of semiconductors
A model for the avalanche breakdown, which describes the physics - and the power semiconductor specialists on the
field dependence of the ionization rate and the influence other hand which design the power semiconductors - but
of the mobile charges is added to each terminal current are no specialists in the field of topologies.
boundary condition in the drift-zone model [22]. Thus,
also the important dynamic avalanche effect is accounted
for. Generally the range of validity for unipolar devices is REFERENCES
much higher as for bipolar devices. F. C. Lee, et. al., "Resonant switches - topologies and
characleristics", PESC 1985, pp. 106-116.
In [20] an overview is given for different types of models:
generic, subcircuit, mathematical. One result of this in- F. C. Lee, et al., "State-plane analysis of quasi-
vestigation is: generic models are not very accurate and resonant conuerters", seventh IEEE INTELEC
very restricted in the range of validity. The subcircuit mo- Conf., Munich, October 1985.
dels are generally better but nevertheless restricted in the
range of validity and in the accuracy, too. The mathemati- F. Franck, D. Schroder, "A contribution for the de-
cal models - starting from semiconductor physics are best sign specification of quasi- and muliiresonant conver-
suited for general application, because the range of vali- ters", PESC 1990, San Antonio, pp. 552-559.
dity is high. But the more precise, the more complex are U. Kirchenberger, D. Schroder, " A multiresonant
the models. The author of the above mentioned paper con-
half-bridge converter for high output voltage", IPEC
sidered these mathematical models best suited for device 1990, Tokio, pp. 169-176.
designers, but much to complex for circuit design. The
reality shows contradictory results. So the efforts should R. A. Fisher, K. D.T. Ngo, M. 11. Kuo, " A 500 kHz
be concentrated on mathematical models. 250 W dc-dc-converter with multiple outpuls control-
635
led b y phase-shifted pwm and magnetic amplifiers", [21] T. Vogler, D. Schroder: "A new a n d accuraie circuii-
HFPC-Conference May 1988 modeling approach for the power diode", P E S C 1992,
Toledo, pp. 870-876.
[6] E. Stein, "Elektn'sche Modelle von Leistungs-
halbleitem f i r den Entwurf von Stromrichter- [22] D. Metzner, T. Vogler and D. Schroder: "A modular
Stellgliedem". Ph.D. thesis, Universiat Kaiserslau- concept for the circuit simulation of bipolar power
tern, 1984. semiconductors", EPE 1993, Brighton.
[7] D. Schroder, E. Stein, "Computing the switching be- [23] D. Metzner, D. Schroder, "A physical GTO-model
haviour of power MOSFETs to optimize the circuit for circuit simulation", IAS 1992, Houston, pp. 1066-
design", IPEC 1983, Tokio, pp. 778-789. 1073.