Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Female Feminists Versus Male Feminists
Female Feminists Versus Male Feminists
Volume: 1st & Issue:4th (October - December 2013’) PP: 374-386 Date: 29-12-2013
E-Mail: gbishunkumar@yahoo.co.in
Mobile: 0091 9454970144
Author’s Introduction:
Issues which are in press. He has been supervising two Ph. D. scholars enrolled in the
department of English Babu Banarsi Das University, Lucknow. His areas of research interest
Page
T
he idea of viewing feminism in within the four walls, their dependency on
two everlasting contradictory
streams created by male and men, exploitation of their virginity and
female feminists is rather
absurd and may appear to be patriarchal dominance on them. It also
prima facie illogical. It is a
motivates, excels and empowers women to
fault line that seems making a crack in the crystal
clear concept of feminism. But I apologize for some resist and revolt against their exploitation,
exceptions, as my observations are basically
inspired by Mary Wollstonecraft’s A Vindication to fight for their rights rather beg, to
of the Rights of Woman, a foundational text
marked by a female’s observations on women and receive education, to understand to break
men. She finds differences in perceptions of women
of male and female feminists, be they education, the cob-web and nexus and to break
rights, freedom from patriarchal dominance or
economic independence. A comparative study of
through the cultural stereo-types, the roles
the works of Tennyson, Rousseau, Hardy, Pope, assigned to them by men and to become a
Aristotle, Mulk Raj Anand, R.K. Narayan, Raja
Rao and Manohar Malgonkar so called the male ‘New Woman’ or ‘Newly Born Woman’
feminists and the works of Mary Wollstonecraft,
Simone de Beauvoir, Helene Cixous, Elaine and attain a personality to sustain in this
Showalter, Virginia Woolf, Attia Husain, Shashi
Deshpande, Mamta Kalia, Toni Morrison, Tahmina world independent of men. Both men and
Durrani, Begum Rukaiyat Sakhwat Husain and
Kate Millet produces an evidence of the difference
women have made effort to emancipate
in perceptions of women by male and female women from patriarchal clutches, to
feminists. The present paper aims at finding out
men’s motive, their politics of subordination and educate them to groom their own
imperialization, and the megalomaniac nature of
passion. Though the work requires an entire personality and career and to enlighten
thesis, this paper limits me to present my views
briefly. them to understand the politics of stereo-
B
ut no one can ignore the
T
he idea of dividing
gap between male’s and
feminism into male and
female’s perceptions of
female seems absurd.
women. Both male and
One may think it an
female feminists seem to be bound to run
attempt at dissociating the associating
375
and suppression while female feminists them while female feminists want to create
want to emancipate themselves from the their own world. Both male and female
clutches of patriarchy also. Male feminists feminists make every effort to educate
do not condemn men as an entire race but women but male feminists educate them to
the demon in man while female feminists train her to be a pleasant companion for
condemn men as an entire race. Male her husband and to be an intelligent
feminists patronize and glorify women to mother of his children while female
condition them according to false myths-- feminists educate women to enlighten
myths exercising man as savior of woman them to understand the politics of man, to
while female feminists are growing fight for their rights which are their dues
blasphemous about all myths whether and to become economically independent
social or religious. Male feminists believe person. The male feminists are worried
that the development of women could be about how to subordinate and manipulate
possible only when man transformed women while female feminists leave no
himself into a Prospero while female ground untouched to escape each and
feminists believe that it is mere a every tactics of men. The gap in their
coincidence and women's development is a perceptions becomes much more obvious
matter of Caliban Complex. Male when female feminists challenge the fact
feminists believe in dependence syndrome how men can write about women; how
and think that women always need support they can experience women's desires,
of a man since they are born with inbuilt feelings, emotions, menstruation, itching,
feminine weakness while female feminists pregnancy, labour pain, etc which women
challenge that they do not need any help want to write about. Professor S. Z. H.
from men and their weakness is not inborn Abidi too, in his keynote address, agrees
but because of process of the ‘girling’, that, ‘man can not truly pen down the
‘gender stereo-typing’ and ‘male experiences of women’ (on 14th of
constructed myths’. Male feminists appear February, 2009).
to be beauty-addict--tempted towards
Evidences of These Gaps:
376
T
Page
in the same direction with fluctuating but Wollstonecraft is even dissatisfied with
permanent gap. I apologize to those of Hester Piozzi and Madame de Stael as
sentimental writers. Mary Wollstonecraft unthinking supporters of Samuel Johnson
is the first woman to closely observe this and Rousseau- clear victims of the
gap. The universally acknowledged fact is conditioning of women by patriarchy and
that Rousseau (the male) first of all set out finds that she has few role models left to
the plan for the education of women which recommend. According to her, only two
is an indication of their position in the women, Catherine Macaulay and Mrs.
society. But Wollstonecraft senses Chapone, are the precursors on the theme
Rousseau's motive in educating women. of women’s education whom she can
She, to express his motive, cites the feature with dignity. The depressed
following extract: condition of women then was marked by
an enfeebling education, no career, no
For my part, I would have a
economic independence and no sense of a
young English woman
support-network with women achievers.
cultivate her agreeable talents
in order to lease her future
Unlike Rousseau's views on
husband with as much care
education, Wollstonecraft suggests women
and assiduity as a young
to get education which must include their
Circassian cultivates hers, to
rights too. The following extract expresses
fit her for the harem of a
her desire:
Circassian bashaw.
I earnestly wish to point out
(Wollstonecraft, 95) in what true dignity and
happiness consists, I wish to
In other words, middle and upper-
persuade women to
middle class women aspire at the most for
endeavour to acquire
an education that would prepare them for a
strength, both of mind and
companionate marriage. This was a
body......(and ) to show that
marriage in which the wife, as Rousseau
377
oriented society while women deny all faulty cultural conditioning and deluding
these set social norms which degrade them education and male’s betrayal of her
and struggle to create their own world, emotions dooms the life of female
their own religion which could consider Shakespeare. Simone de Beauvoir too in
their happiness and their character as well. her the monumental book The Second Sex
Tennyson (the male) in “The Princess” attacks on gender stereo-typing and
talks of the ‘higher education and rights of advocates that ‘Sex is natural while gender
women’ but at the same time he is a construct’.
marginalizes them and assigns stereotyped
roles to them with a view to confining Almost all men deal with women
them within the four walls. The following more or less in the Tennysonian style and
lines of the poem are an evidence of then assess them as feeble and inferior
women’s degradation by him; beings. R. K Narayan’s Savitri in The
Dark Room, a character created by a male,
Man for the field and woman
leaves her husband’s house for having
for the hearth,
been fed up with the patriarchal
Man for the sword and for the
dominance but she remains economically
needle she;
dependent on him only. It is her
Man with the head and
dependence syndrome that pulls her back
woman with the heart,
and makes her surrender before her
Man to command and woman
husband while Shashi Deshpande (a
to obey,
female writer) does not give this weakness
All else confusion.
to her women (characters). Sarita, a
(“The Princes”)
woman character, in her novel, The Dark
Holds No Terrors, leaves her husband’s
The story of enfeebling women
(Manohar’s) house for his intolerable
begins with the gender stereotyping.
tortures but she doesn’t come back and
Virginia Woolf attacks all Tennysonian
surrender to her husband, for Deshpande
gender stereo-typing in her episode
379
Women characters in men’s (the male) also. In the novel The Big
writing, though, deny the traditional norms Heart, Anand's woman character, Janki,
of the society, adopt modernity and breaks through all the traditional norms of
liberate themselves from patriarchal society, and comes to Ananta to live with
clutches , this could only be possible with him as his mistress. She successfully
the help and support of other men defends herself from the vicious circle of
however, modernized and humane in the wantons who wish to turn her into a
thought and attitude while women whore and to become a commodity of
characters of women's writing does not physical pleasure for them. In this novel
seek support or help of men. They look Anand goes one step ahead that Janki does
male-phobic. For instance, Mulk Raj not demand marital status from Ananta
Anand's character, Maya, in the novel, The like Maya but she is nothing without
Village denies the ancient culture, revolts Ananta, the male. She learns everything
against the norms of her Kshatriya family from Ananta and after his death, spiritual
and resists mother's process of ‘girling’. guide and mentor Puran Singh (the male)
Maya's love for Lal Singh (Lalu) attacks fuses enthusiam in her. Even the novel The
the stereotype roles assigned to women Old Woman and the Cow which is written
through wrong acculturation. Anand from the gynocentric angle bears the stamp
emboldens Maya enough to stand against of the male treatment of feminism. Gauri,
the terror of her father but he retains her the heroine of the novel, is hit back by her
feminine weakness by making her husband Panchi. However, she learns
economically and socially dependent on nursing and becomes economically
her lover Lal Singh. She demands marital independent, not by her own but with the
status from Lalu, for she thinks without help of colonel Mahindra again the male.
social sanction of her relation with her Mulk Raj Anand conditions Gauri in such
lover she cannot live the life of dignity. a way that even after becoming
Maya's runaway marriage though earns her economically self dependent, she longs for
modernity by transforming herself into a the same male (her husband) who had
380
‘new woman’ but female feminst feel it tortured her and made her condition
revolt against ancient norms for social life pathetic and miserable; she ultimately
Page
and accept modernity rather than act as a returns to him yet the novelist praises her
feminist activist and modernity is and rewards her of the dignity of ‘a chaste
embraced not only by Maya but Lal Singh Indian woman’. It seems that male
W
ollstonecraft observes
life depend on males only—however, the
that the education
males of humane nature and not the
provided by men to
wanton rogues.
women is faulty. That is
But, for the female feminists, the why women, instead of thinking and
prize ‘chastity’ is a process of women’s fighting for their rights and economic
imprisonment and curtailing their freedom independence, have a desire for a naughty,
that brings them within the range of handsome-looking, loving and
patriarchal clutches. They treat women economically rich husband. She says;
characters adversely to that of males’.
Men look for beauty and the
Shashi Deshpande's woman character
simper of good humored
Sarita in her novel The Dark Holds No
docility; women are
Terrors raises herself as a promising
captivated by easy manners; a
doctor without help or support of any
gentleman like man seldom
male. She does not suffer from androgyny
fails to please, and their
and therefore, doesn't hit back her husband
thirsty ears eagerly drink the
but she does not long for her husband like
insinuating nothings of
male writers’ women characters. Attia
politeness, whilst, they turn
Husain entirely ignores man’s intervention
from the unintelligible
in pleasures of woman. Her character,
sounds of the charmer reason,
Laila, in Sunlight on a Broken Column,
charm he never so wisely
marries Ameer whom she loved and defies
the wishes of her family about her (Wollstonecraft, 12).
marriage. Like Laila, her character,r
Afro-American female feminist,
Nandi, a servant gir,l too is a projection of
Toni Morrison, does not accept the male’s
Attia’s own ideology. Nandi says, “A
perception of woman as ‘a home maker’
man’s love is not different from an
381
critic of the males. Love also has been towards their beauty and therefore,
treated differently by both the male and the unconsciously become a textual seducer of
female writers. Men love women for their the women (characters) created by them.
physical satiety and her beauty while No female writer has described the beauty
women get emotionally attached with men of the female body as Mulk Raj Anand
for their decency and robust nature. In does in his novel Untouchable, in his
short, man is megalomaniac in nature. This description of the beauty of the
is evidenced in Anand's novel Confession untouchable girl, Sohini.The following
of a Lover. Krishna, the hero of the novel passage is an indication of his temptation
(the autobiographical self of Anand for Sohini;
himself), loves Yasmin intensely and plans
She had a sylph like form,
to elope with her but when Noor's wife
not thin but full bodied
congratulates him on 'becoming a potential
within the limits of graceful
father', his courage fails him. On
frame, well rounded on the
revelation of Yasmin's pregnancy he
hips, , with an arched narrow
himself reveals his megalomaniac nature.
waist from which descended
I had the corroding doubt that the folds of her trousers and
I really wanted the pleasure above which were her full
of physical love. Perhaps round, globular breasts,
awful thought, I still loved jerking slightly, for lack of a
myself and my pleasures bodice, under her transparent
more than I love Yasmin. I muslin shirt.
was a megalomaniac. I
(Untouchable. p -22)
wanted the experience of
making love but did not want Thomas Hardy has also
the burden of her theoretically criticized women's
suppression and oppression by men but he
(Confession of a Lover. p-
too is actually a textual seducer. The way
383
344)
he treats Tess in the novel Tess of the
In the treatment of the beauty of D'Urbervilles, indicates that he sided with
Page
women both male and female writers Angel Clare and Alec without actually
attain polarity. Male feminists are sick of knowing it. No woman writer can treat
beauty of women. They are tempted women characters in this way. Emma
Shakespeare to compare with the like Dopadi Majhen bears the stamp of
female writing. Devi’s Dopadi too is a
Page
F
inally, one can reach to
Reprinted as Gauri. New Delhi:
the conclusion that unless
Arnold Heinemann, 1984.
and until human society
Arney, Smita. Sita’s Ramayana.
will attain a gendered
Dainik Jagran. Dated.
identity, both men and women will stand
Cixous, Helene. The Newly Born
in binaries. The prominence should be
Woman. London.I B Tauris
given to one’s identity as a person than as
Publishers, 1985.
a man or a woman. To overcome this gap,
Cowasjee, Saros. So Many
opportunities should be availed equally to
Freedoms: A Study of Mulk Raj
the both as person than as gender. The
Anand. Delhi: OUP, 1947.
division of labour should be on the basis of
one’s interest and innate talents rather than de Beauvoir, Simone, The Second
on the basis of gender. The education Sex (1949). London: Four Squire
thinking than to internalize the age old Deshpande, Shashi. The Dark Holds
---- The Big Heart (1945). New Woman and ‘The Subjection of
Revised ed. New Delhi: Arnold Women”. London: J. M. Den and
Heinemann, 1980. Sons, 1985.